News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dperfect on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:22AM (#15117130)
I've been saying this for a while. The problem is that people are mostly familiar with the rate of overcoming traditional technical challenges (e.g., making your current computer/phone more compact, improving graphics quality, making cameras and screens with more pixels, etc.). What people don't realize is that full autonomous driving will require more than just faster/smaller/cheaper technical innovation - it will require the refinement of innovations that probably haven't even been invented/researched yet.

I can't help but think about speech recognition 20 years ago. Many of the hot software packages claimed something like 96% accuracy, and that sounded great on paper. People thought intelligent voice-computer interfaces were just around the corner, yet here we are in 2017, and Siri/Alexa/Cortana are barely becoming usable (but still frustratingly lacking in many situations).

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by strebler on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:30AM (#15117186)
You've hit the nail on the head - audio recognition is quite poor after (a lot of) concerted effort over decades. Driving a car safely is significantly more difficult (and dangerous).

That being said, Toyota's (and Subaru's) approach is the smart way forward - add sensors and capabilities that augment the human, but leave the human always responsible and in control. In order for a crash to happen, the human AND the machine BOTH have to miss it.

Once the machine is good enough (and we figure out what "good enough" means), then it can take over driving. But not before.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Animats on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:39PM (#15119416)
That being said, Toyota's (and Subaru's) approach is the smart way forward - add sensors and capabilities that augment the human, but leave the human always responsible and in control. In order for a crash to happen, the human AND the machine BOTH have to miss it.

That's the approach we know won't work. That was Tesla's first-round autopilot, the self-crashing car. The one that would happily run into obstacles protruding into a lane.[1][2][3] There are two big flaws with that approach. First, if it's good enough that people can tune out, they will tune out. Second, if the driver waits until the self-driving system has clearly made a mistake before taking over, they will be slower at reacting than if they were driving, and may be too late. See especially [3].

Volvo's CEO takes the position that if one of their cars crashes in self-driving mode, it's Volvo's fault. Urmson, while at Google, pointed out the first problem coming up even with their test drivers.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc0yYJ8-Dyo [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvRkSMCDX3o [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2ml6sjk_8c

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by strebler on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:36PM (#15120281)
Tesla took the opposite approach of what I described (the Subaru approach).

Tesla took the approach that the machine is in control and the human has to detect and take over when the machine makes a mistake. That is known to be a very problematic strategy, it's easy for the human to get distracted.

What Subaru has done is to leave the human in control, the machine only steps in when it sees a problem.

It's totally different safety outcomes. In fact, not even the same problem - one is "self driving", the other is "crash prevention".

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by eof on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:45PM (#15121753)
Yes they are different. They are also WILDLY different value propositions. Crash prevention is nice, just getting safer and safer is nice--though I personally wouldn't stop driving ~$5k cars for even "really good" crash protection.

But a car that can drive me while I sleep and become a Taxi while I work is something I would go into debt for.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Joeri on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:48AM (#15122571)
But a car that can drive me while I sleep and become a Taxi while I work is something I would go into debt for.

I don't think most regular people will actually own fully autonomous cars to rent them out. Big players will do the capital expenditure to buy a fleet, and rent out transportation service. Renting in uber style will be basically the price of owning, but without the up-front capital expenditure, and it will provide the convenience of choosing the type of car for the specific transport needs of the moment. The margins of these rent-a-fleet services will be low, so you won't have a hope as individual car owner of actually buying a car and renting it out without turning it into a loss compared to just renting.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by eof on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:31AM (#15124520)
Certainly if most people owned them, there wouldn't be a market to rent them out.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by adventist on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:43PM (#15126616)
I would go into debt for that also!
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by unityByFreedom on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:43AM (#15122123)
> Tesla took the approach that the machine is in control

That's not really accurate. Tesla says the driver is ultimately responsible. That holds unless a court determines otherwise. The same is true for Toyota/Subaru. They're all SAE level 2 systems.

The opposite approach from this would be Waymo/Volvo who intend to take responsibility for decisions made by their vehicles. Those are SAE level 4 or 5 systems.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Skunkleton on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:51PM (#15119519)
Perhaps a portion of Tesla's problem was with marketing? Autopilot gives very different cues than something like LKAS (lane keep assist).
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by memnips on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:31PM (#15121013)
And it's also called "Autopilot" which sets an extremely different tone and expectation than other driver-assistance/safety technologies.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by will_hughes on Monday August 28, 2017 @08:48PM (#15121358)
> And it's also called "Autopilot" which sets an extremely different tone and expectation than other driver-assistance/safety technologies.

Only to those not familiar with autopilot systems in aircraft.

It's like the use of "hacker" - here on this site it still (probably) has most of it's original meaning. To the rest of the world it means a guy in a ski-mask with a russian/chinese accent who's after your bank account.

Unfortunately most of the world thinks pilots in commercial aircraft turn on the autopilot and can then go for a sleep, so when they see "Autopilot" on a Tesla, they think they can do the same.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by mchahn on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:15PM (#15121849)
> most of the world thinks pilots in commercial aircraft turn on the autopilot and can then go for a sleep

They can go to sleep and the plane will continue to fly itself. However, if anyone found out they were sleeping heads would roll.

Autopilot electronics on a plane is trivial. Autopilot for a car is damn hard.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by lttlrck on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:16AM (#15124015)
> Only to those not familiar with autopilot systems in aircraft.

Isn’t that most people?

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Trundle on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:12AM (#15122024)
>Unfortunately most of the world thinks pilots in commercial aircraft turn on the autopilot and can then go for a sleep

They can go for a sleep though.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by will_hughes on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:30AM (#15122724)
Only if you're happy waking up to find you're about to plow into another large object at a high rate of speed.

The Pilot in Command is expected to sit in their seat and monitor the aircraft, surrounding airspace and the radios, and be ready to take control at a moments notice.

They can't go for a snooze without handing that over to another pilot first.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vsl on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:07PM (#15127208)
The same expectation applies to drivers of Tessa's Autopilot.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:34PM (#15120268)
> That's the approach we know won't work. That was Tesla's first-round autopilot, the self-crashing car.

I think OP was talking about "crash avoidance" systems. Not systems that claim to drive the car but not really.

You're always driving, the car is just silently observing. If the car sees you're about to crash, it steps in and takes over. The opposite of Tesla's approach where you play the role of observer taking over when things go wrong.

The first approach is safe. The second approach isn't safe until full autonomy due to cognitive load and task switching delays.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Animats on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:29PM (#15120676)
There are many automotive "auto-brake" systems, usually controlled by a radar. Those are useful. They're usually programmed to act only when a collision is inevitable. They prevent some slow-speed collisions, and reduce the damage in some faster ones.

What they don't do is take over steering. A last-second takeover of steering would make things worse some of the time.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by nradov on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:22PM (#15120982)
The next Volvo model will take over steering for collision avoidance.

http://www.leftlanenews.com/volvo-xc60s-collision-avoidance-...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Chaebixi on Monday August 28, 2017 @08:04PM (#15121164)
> What they don't do is take over steering. A last-second takeover of steering would make things worse some of the time.

I have a Honda. While its lane-keeping system won't steer during a crash, it definitely does steer to keep you centered in the lane (when it's able). That could help avoid all kinds of crashes due to inattentive lane-drifting.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by atomical on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:45PM (#15121754)
Is it less fatiguing?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Chaebixi on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:29AM (#15132948)
Yes. You still have to pay attention, but there's not as much pressure and fewer startling surprises.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by mjevans on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:55AM (#15122164)
I really don't want those on in stop and go rush-hour traffic. They're very likely to cause someone /behind/ the automated car to have an accident. (Yeah yeah, following distances; trying building enough capacity for everyone to do the proper following speed and keep distance.)
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ingenieroariel on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:51PM (#15120806)
Can you elaborate?

Assuming for example the car is fitted with solid state lidar on the four corners and ESR on the four sides or even LIDAR.

What are your thoughts on crash prevention if the car has the same hardware as a a Waymo car?

(edit: to clarify, would you consider autosteering at the last minute safer than a human driver in that scenario?)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:43PM (#15120750)
Don’t Volvo and Mercedes do obstacle avoidance? Or is that still in research? I think I remember seeing videos.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kuschku on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:05PM (#15120889)
Yes they do. They take over steering, automatically drive around obstacles, etc. And this is already deployed in production vehicles today.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by csomar on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:44AM (#15123606)
Interesting. The three of them show the car being hit from the left side when driving on a high-way. It seems that the autopilot is bad at recognizing objects that suddenly appear on that side.

More like, if you are not a car on the left lane, then you are not. Bam, you got an accident.

Edit: Is the last video in the US? Is it normal for other drivers not to stop when they see an accident?

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Animats on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:21PM (#15127699)
Right. Tesla's round 1 "autopilot" used Mobileye's car recognizer for obstacle detection. If it didn't look like a car, it didn't get recognized as an obstacle.

I wrote a previous YC posting on this, on why you need to use geometry first, then object recognition.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:46PM (#15120768)
Whether or not it "works" it has the overwhelming benefit of being an incremental approach. Incremental (evolutionary) change tends to work while revolutionary is more tricky. e.g. video phones were demonstrated in the 1960s but are still not really widely used. Also no need for Star Trek - level AI, which is a significant advantage.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by virgilp on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:16AM (#15123065)
> but are still not really widely used

Seriously? All smartphones are video phones. I fail to see how they could be more widely used.

You may mean that people choose to make audio-only calls... but just because people choose to do that, it doesn't mean the technology isn't here & fully available in affordable, commercial, "good enough" form.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:28PM (#15118385)
I don't know by what metrics you're making these comparisons. Audio recognition and self-driving vehicles are apples and oranges.

Autonomous driving is difficult primarily because of a changing world and low tolerance for mistakes. The state space of situations you're trying to map is just large. It will take time. But it's not even close to impossible.

Audio recognition is difficult for a different reason: language is difficult to disambiguate without context. So today the limits of our audio recognition bump up against knowing the context of words you're saying. It used to be the case that audio recognition had fundamental difficulties e.g at word boundaries but those challenges are mostly solved. Some of these challenges might not be solved without improvements in areas outside of the raw listening part of ASR.

> That being said, Toyota's (and Subaru's) approach is the smart way forward - add sensors and capabilities that augment the human, but leave the human always responsible and in control. In order for a crash to happen, the human AND the machine BOTH have to miss it.

This is your opinion. Folks at some other companies (e.g waymo) don't think this makes you safer. Human attention might not work the way you think it does.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kpil on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:58PM (#15118668)
I think that audio recognition is an order of magnitude less complicated than fully autonomous driving. The world is fully contextless outside the road to an not-even-at-insect-level brain driving two tons of metal, and anything can happen.

Voice recognition is getting just barely tolerable. If you have tried to do something important using voice recognition you'd probably go bat shit crazy after a while. If it had the potential to kill people no sane human would allow it.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by sol_remmy on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:44PM (#15119458)
Voice recognition also has a lot less market demand than self driving cars. Technology can be invented that is decades ahead of other fields if enough money is invested.

That is why I think self-driving cars and voice recognition are not comparable problems.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by LrnByTeach on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:24PM (#15120204)
Totally agree ..

> Voice recognition also has a lot less market demand than self driving cars.

Just to expand on your point, today's 'self driving car' technology we may equal to where 'voice recognition technology' was 20 years ago. But 20 years ago, there is no incentive for industry to invest say $100 Billion in 'voice recognition technology', the benefits did not warrant such a huge investment. Where as'self driving car' technology there is potential to reap benefits that is why industry today investing $100 Billion ( all combined investments from all players )

> Technology can be invented that is decades ahead of other fields if enough money is invested.

> That is why I think self-driving cars and voice recognition are not comparable problems.

The huge economic value the can be created with perfected 'self driving car' is in the order of hundreds of Billions of dollars per year world wide combined . Here is an example scenario

In 2025 'self driving Electric Autonomous fleet' vehicles by Uber, Googles of the world offer 'miles plan' ( like our 2005 mobile monthly plan N minutes/month ) that is like 1000 miles per month you can hail any time for a monthly price of $300/month . This is huge economic value for at least 50% of USA drivers and people will embrace it.

Typical USA drivers total cost of ownership of CAR today is in the range of $400 to $600 per month ( CAR price + Repairs costs + car Insurance + gasoline cost) . This is with out counting 1.5 hours/day you have pay attention to drive, the time that can be used for other thing with autonomous fleet

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by fastball on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:51PM (#15121105)

  I think
Wonderful.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dang on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:18PM (#15121661)
Would you please not do this here? We're trying for at least a slightly higher quality level on HN. One thing that helps is not to assume stupidity in the other; we even added a new guideline recently to say that. More diplomatically though.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:42PM (#15119893)
> The world is fully contextless outside the road to an not-even-at-insect-level brain driving two tons of metal, and anything can happen.

See that's where you're wrong. An autonomous vehicle doesn't have to have a human brain. It has to have very accurate sensors and classifiers tuned with generous safety params.

Like any vehicle it also needs redundancies for safety and sane default behavior (mostly "slam on the breaks").

Also, not "anything can happen." There are rules that govern the road that make this problem tractable. There are rules that govern physics that mean if you have adequate sensors + compute you can avoid hitting any objects at all, whether it's a person or otherwise. "Object x is 30 ft away with trajectory y, we're going 15mph, slam on the brakes."

The difficulties mostly lie in how we can "not slam on the brakes all the time and never make progress." e.g if you enter a construction zone you better know what to do and not just sit still, otherwise you'll never get anywhere.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jotjotzzz on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:27PM (#15120221)
Agreed. I would think audio recognition is not comparable to driving, since the scope of recognizing all voices, accents, languages is vastly different than the set of rules for driving and the complexity of the road.

Realistically speaking, even if Tesla or any other manufacturing company do get to that level of a "super advance Einstein-genius" self-driving car it will still be: "not even close" if it's riding alongside the highway with 18-year old Billy-bob speedster with a penchant for cutting lanes and living dangerously. Most car accidents are due to human error.

If all cars on the highway are self-driving cars, with the ability to learn and communicate with each other through mesh-network or what-not, with predictive capacity -- it will be a lot better than any driving human that can only see what's in front of them. We just need to get to that level where most cars on the highway are smart self-driving capable cars and we can build on top of that. No one should be relying on self-driving cars to do everything at this point in the game because we're not there yet.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by speby on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:08PM (#15118742)
Audio recognition may be apples and oranges to self-driving vehicles. But as it relates to autonomous driving, audio recognition (and I don't mean speech but general sounds) is something nobody has been talking about (at least publicly) as a sensor input for self-driving cars. Think about how much you rely on your hearing to drive safely and well. Sure, we use sight/depth and so forth substantially but we also rely on our ears listening for different kinds of sounds that can occur from any direction to warn us of changing conditions, unsafe circumstances, and so forth.

We can't even get speech recognition right and meanwhile audio (sounds in general) aren't even being seriously considered for self-driving purposes, AFAICT.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:41PM (#15118982)
Curious, isn't it? Humans rely on auditory information to enhance situational awareness so you'd think that would factor into the design of a machine that needs as much situational awareness as possible.

For example, emergency response vehicles announce their arrival and direction often long before any visual contact is made. How will deaf autonomous cars recognize incoming emergency responders if the view is obstructed? Will they pull into the intersection just as a Fire Engine is running the red light?

Auditory input was deemed important enough that California even made it illegal to "wear a headset covering, earplugs in, or earphones covering, resting on, or inserted in, both ears" while driving just last year. [0] I suspect other jurisdictions have/will follow(ed) suit.

[0]http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection....

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jdietrich on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#15120180)
Telling which direction a siren is coming from is really, really easy. You can do it with three electret microphones and a $1 ARM chip. A simple TDOA multilateration algorithm will do a far better job of it than a human, even in complex reverberant environments.

Reliably understanding speech is effectively strong AI. Humans don't speak very clearly, but we're spectacularly good at inferring meaning from context. Accurate transcripts of colloquial speech are often completely incomprehensible, because a vast amount of information is conveyed through context. When we're listening to someone speak, we're decoding the phonemes into symbols, but we're also constructing a model of the speaker's mind and predicting what they mean to say.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by pg314 on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:32PM (#15119364)
Are deaf people allowed to drive? How do you think they handle these situations?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#15119717)
There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals, akin to doorbell or telephone strobes. But the more interesting adaptive technology seems to be a re-wiring of the brain. [0] Deprived of auditory input and with a heightened reliance on visual cues, the autonomous driving version might be something like Lidar + other driver facial recognition.

[0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/superpowers-for-t...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jstanley on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:01PM (#15120034)
> There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals

Yes, I've noticed this too. Sometimes you can almost see blue and red flashing lights on top of a police car.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:14PM (#15120128)
I applaud your synesthesia! Those of us with more common auditory processing are unable to see sound. :(

si·ren (sīrən)noun 1.a device that makes a loud prolonged sound as a signal or warning.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:08PM (#15119663)
According to a quick google, noticing that other cars are pulling in/slowing down usually works if they can't see the emergency vehicle. Still, it's not "perfect", but then Hearing drivers are far from perfect either, and there's plenty of failsafes before an accident happens.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by stevenwoo on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:25PM (#15119777)
Fire trucks and ambulances I've seen when driving against traffic lights/flow of traffic always slow and stop to make sure that there will not be an accident even if they have the right of way - they don't drive like police in pursuit on TV. I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by mindcrime on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:12PM (#15120115)
I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.

Yes, if the driver is well trained. When I was firefighting and instructing drivers, we always emphasized that while the red light and siren gave you the right of way:

a. they don't absolve you of liability for a crash (at least under NC law)

and

b. if you get in a crash on the way to the scene, you're not doing anybody any good, PLUS you've now created another incident requiring another emergency response, PLUS another company (probably coming from further away) has to respond to the original call.

I can't speak for police, but firefighters are actually, in my experience, taught to be pretty conservative when it comes to running red lights, proceeding against traffic on one way streets, and other similar scenarios.

We also always used to emphasize "it does no good to get halfway there, real fast".

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by upvotinglurker on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:45PM (#15135307)
Per [0] they are allowed to drive in the US, and do not have higher accident rates than hearing drivers[1]. Also, "There are now devices available that can be used in r cars that react to the frequency of sirens and which emit visual warnings of approaching emergency vehicles to assist deaf drivers and those with hearing loss" (which could presumably also "assist" self-driving cars).

[0] https://www.enddd.org/end-distracted-driving/enddd-presentat...

[1] This web site's bona fides aren't clear, but its mission does not seem to specifically include advocating for the deaf, so there's no obvious reason for the information presented to be biased in favor of the deaf.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by xapata on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:34PM (#15119378)
Microphones cost much h less than LIDAR.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:44PM (#15119910)
"Nobody talking about it" doesn't mean nobody is working on it ;)
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:37PM (#15120291)
> language is difficult to disambiguate without context.

So why don't Siri/Alexa/etc developers give them context? I would LOVE to be able to say "Alexa, play playlist on shuffle mode" or even simple "Alexa, turn on shuffle and go to next song"

But no, the word "and" is completely off limits. Saying "shuffle playlist" instead of "play playlist" also doesn't work. I have to literally use 3 commands to do what I want:

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift" ... "Alexa, shuffle" ... "Alexa, next song"

With context, I could say "Alexa, play Taylor Swift on shuffle"

Apparently Siri is gaining the ability to deal with follow up questions in iOS11. Excited to try it out.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by balls187 on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:52PM (#15120383)
How would you differentiate:

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift on shuffle"

vs

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift on Spotify" (real command)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:26PM (#15120647)
Spotify is default. She also knows how to do noun recognition. If she can tell the difference between “play” and “stop”, she can differentiate shuffle and Spotify.

I’m also ok sayin “Alexa, shuffle Taylor Swift” if that’s easier for their grammar.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by balls187 on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:03PM (#15120873)
I think "shuffle" is the obvious choice to be used as a verb.

As you mentioned, Alexa already understands shuffle (though I don't think it does for Spotify's integration).

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jstanley on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:00PM (#15120020)
> Audio recognition is difficult for a different reason: language is difficult to disambiguate without context.

That's not the only reason audio recognition is hard. If it were, audio recognition would be exactly as hard as interpreting written text.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by cerved on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:29PM (#15120235)
I get your point but to nitpick, written and spoken language are not equivalent. We don't say things like "quote", "comma" and "question mark". We use things like intonation, gestures etc.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jason_pomerleau on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:06PM (#15117554)
Once the machines are better than humans at a macro level, insurance companies will notice, and I think this will cause widespread adoption pretty quickly.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by tspike on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:31PM (#15118414)
Folks are glossing over this quote too easily:

> “Historically human beings have shown zero tolerance for injury or death caused by flaws in a machine,”

It doesn't matter if it's objectively safer; people have no issue doing dangerous things so long as they can maintain the illusion of control.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Retric on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:46PM (#15119482)
I don' think that's true in terms of transportation systems.

In terms of cars: Streets where built for people or animals walking on them and cars quickly started killing large numbers of people. The response was not to make cars safer by say physically limiting them to 10 MPH, but to remove people from streets.

A fairly high fraction of early aviators where killed, that did little to slow adoption of aircraft.

Astronaut deaths where sadly common, but also expected and did little to slow progress.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:19PM (#15119728)
> The response was not to make cars safer by say physically limiting them to 10 MPH

Umm, reasonably sure that implementing a legal speed limit was an initial response, in the UK at least. It took a number of years (and likely a lot of propaganda, though I haven't looked that closely into it and history is, of course, written by the victors) to allow motorcars to use roads at anything close to a reasonable speed.

Check wikipedia out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limit#History

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Retric on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:29PM (#15120673)
I am referring to a governor which would prevent cars from being capable of 10MPH even on empty roads. Actual in town speed limits would presumably be lower. Now, with our infrastructure that seems like a huge issue, but cites used to be built for walking and even small towns simply had vastly higher density.

Watch this and suddenly those mentioned speed limits are completely reasonable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=954L9MpfCEo

Note, 10MPH would allow for 2-3x the speed of a horse over long distances. So, in this alternate history cars would still have been very useful.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:10AM (#15122645)
Indeed, the speed limits are completely reasonable if you don't want to remove people from the streets - but your suggestion seemed to be that people were near-immediately removed from the streets instead of limiting what cars can do at first. There were 30 years when cars were lawfully limited to 4mph in rural areas, so your "even on empty roads" point is moot.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Retric on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:23AM (#15123517)
There where not exactly a lot of cars over most of that 30 years. However, my point was more cars had strong advocates pushing adoption where pedestrians where simply used to how things where and never really organized to protect how things where.

Thus you get jaywalking as a crime, and justified many deaths as people breaking the law instead of the naritive that cars are insanely dangerous and should be banned. In theory cars could have been banned, but in practice their advocates had little trouble changing perceptions.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:38PM (#15128211)
Note that jaywalking is very much not a crime in the UK. Off of a motorway (which is a relatively recent invention), roads are still for people to some extent. Hopping off the pavement for a couple of seconds to bypass someone who's decided to stop right in front of you is semi-normal, much of rural UK doesn't even have pavements, and we get taught how to Stop, Look, Listen, Live in order to cross a road without a traffic light as kids.

If a pedestrian starts to cross the road, they have right of way. I've been on roads in some city centres where vehicles have to be very, very careful as there's a road through a pedestrianised area and people are rather bold crossing the road. If the vehicle was to cause injury, the driver would likely be liable.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by zip1234 on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:13PM (#15119696)
Cost/benefit--if the rewards are judged to outweigh the risks and there is a clear benefit, people will adopt it. If money/time can be saved, it will be very popular.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dsfyu404ed on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:50PM (#15119512)
>the illusion of control.

No, it's literal control. They'd rather operate a vehicle in a way that's statistically less effective (where effective is defined by a collection of algorithms, we all know how perfect algorithmic generated routes are) than lose that control for a small benefit. Control itself is worth something to people.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jacquesm on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:22PM (#15119756)
A very large factor in this reasoning is that people look at the statistics and then intuitively decide the statistics will not apply to them because they are much better than the average driver.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by strebler on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:43PM (#15117960)
This has already started - look up the discount some insurers give to owners of Subarus that are equipped with EyeSight. The numbers show their collision avoidance is making roads safer.

Also, interesting fact: Subaru is achieving these impressive stats using stereo vision, not lidar.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:48PM (#15120784)
I recently bought a Subaru, and I agree. However, this is in no way at all related to "self driving cars" (which don't actually exist and therefore nobody knows how the insurance companies and general public will react to the liability/safety/skin-in-the-game issues).
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by brudgers on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:07PM (#15120081)
The scenario in which insurance companies drive adoption of self driving cars depends upon insurance companies accepting the risk of system failure due to manufacturing defects or limitations that generate the wrong response in particular conditions.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by gaius on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:30AM (#15122720)
Indeed. You aren't insuring one driver anymore, you're insuring a million instances of the same algo.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by lern_too_spel on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:29PM (#15117806)
California allows drivers to self-insure. The existing auto insurers are going to lose that business to automated taxi fleets.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dperfect on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:35PM (#15117875)
A little more context on the speech recognition part: I remember going to a trade show (many years ago) where a representative from one of the major speech recognition companies was showing off the technology. He wasn't just dictating text, but was also using the software to control the computer. I was floored by it. I was 100% convinced we had arrived at that dream of intelligent voice-computer interaction.

I've felt the same way after watching various autonomous driving demos (like Tesla's[1]). But then I remember my experience of actually trying the same speech recognition software myself; under unrehearsed real-world conditions with edge cases and human mistakes, the technology performed terribly. Any "intelligence" I'd seen in the demo was essentially smoke and mirrors.

Granted, current autonomous vehicle technology incorporates a lot more artificial intelligence than those speech recognition demos ever did, but the challenge is also significantly greater (and more life-critical). Sure, your sensors and cameras might be able to read signage correctly in 99% of conditions, but when there's graffiti on the sign at night during heavy rain, all bets are off. The human driver may have difficulty also, but the human driver has real intelligence and life experience in a variety of domains, enabling them to make inferences based on more than just statistical probabilities.

In my opinion, prior to solving all the edge cases at an acceptable level using AI, we'll solve a different problem allowing us to sidestep many of those challenges; we'll incrementally start building (and converting to) smart roads where only smart vehicles are allowed. Obviously it won't be everywhere, but the most important routes will be covered, and your safety on those routes will be much higher than it would be on traditional roads with AI or human drivers.

[1] https://www.tesla.com/videos/autopilot-self-driving-hardware...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Someone on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:44PM (#15119905)
"I was floored by it. I was 100% convinced we had arrived at that dream of intelligent voice-computer interaction."

I remember talking to Apple's Kim Silverman, ¿head? of speech recognition, somewhere in the end of the '90s. He said you had to spend a few hundreds of hours training the recognizer to get at a good level. That's not a lot more than one would spend learning to touch type at speed, but a large fraction of _that_ time is productive; training a speech recognized wasn't.

Also, touch typing, once you can do it, works everywhere; speech recognition didn't work as well when there was background noise or echos. So, few people were willing to invest the time. And they probably were right.

I also agree with your statement that we will solve restricted, but useful domains first, and that a general solution for autonomous driving will be a long way of.

I also agree roads will be adapted to the self-driving cars. It isn't rocket science to embed a steel wire in the center of each car lane that a robot car can detect, for example.

I remember a television program where the engineers of some European car manufacturer thought universally usable self-driving cars would be safer than human driven ones in 10 years or so, but their human factors specialist said it would be something like 40 years before they would hit the road because she knew you can't expect humans to fully attend to driving on very short notice for a few seconds each week.

(that show also said, and showed, that features such as lane assist are more limited than the cars are capable of because of human factors)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ghaff on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:42PM (#15117948)
Possibly. I think it's more likely that systems get good enough that you can turn over control to them on certain limited access roads. Perhaps construction zones are required to transmit some sort of alert signal that requires a driver to take over within 60 seconds or something along those lines.

This could be a big improvement for both safety and driving comfort and seems as if it would be a much more amenable to solving over, say, a 10 year horizon than a cross-town Manhattan taxi ride at rush hour.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by pg314 on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:45PM (#15119465)
> Sure, your sensors and cameras might be able to read signage correctly in 99% of conditions, but when there's graffiti on the sign at night during heavy rain, all bets are off.

In the vast majority of the cases, that sign will have been seen by another autonomous car on a sunny day before it had graffiti, and stored in the map database. You should be comparing a whole fleet of autonomous vehicles learning from each other versus an individual human.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ChrisLTD on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#15119714)
What if the sign actually changes?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by cerved on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:33PM (#15120259)
Have the responsible authority submit the change to db
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Pigo on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:15PM (#15118798)
I agree with you, We all hope we'll have amazing self-driving cars real soon, it's just funny watching the responses here. If you try to say autonomous cars may not be a perfect solution and available in 6 months, or SpaceX may not have a thriving colony on Mars in 6 years, then you will ruffle some feathers. I think guys that have lived through disappointing hype before have some perspective to share.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by manmal on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:34PM (#15117871)
Granted, but there is arguably a lot more money behind autonomous driving than there ever was behind speech recognition and synthesis. It was a different problem space, but the situation is probably comparable to the space race - the winner will dominate a new market of hundreds of billions in size. The motivation is really really strong, and with it comes lots of funding and talent.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vamin on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:59AM (#15117491)
I disagree with the analogy to speech recognition. What makes speech recognition difficult is that it's highly dependent on context (sounds the same, but means something different depending on surrounding words, what the conversation is about, or even who you're speaking with). With driving, you should be able to make a good decision with just the instantaneous state, given enough information about that state (objects, velocities, etc). You can argue about what constitutes "enough information," but it seems plausible to me that given enough sensors we could meet or exceed the amount of information taken in by a pair of human eyes on a swivel.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by rayiner on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:32PM (#15117849)
Im skeptical you can do real autonomous driving without context. In DC, we have roads that flow one direction part of the day and another direction the other part. We've got roads that will be shut down unpredictably when there is a diplomatic event. We've got constant construction, where a two lane road might be reduced to one lane with a human holding a sign or using hand signals to usher cars through on their turns. How does a self-driving car handle that without understanding context?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by semi-extrinsic on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:44PM (#15119904)
For a few more very common examples of humans using context:

A human will spot a person wearing headphones and recognize that person has a low situational awareness. The computer doesn't come close to even having the optical resolution to do that if the AI was perfect - remember human vision is 570+ megapixels, even a 4K video stream is literally two orders of magnitude lower.

[Now think about the fact that if we built a camera capable of recording 400 megapixels, you'd currently need to schlep around a ~750 lbs 25 node cluster, consuming about 50 horsepower to feed it with electricity, just to be able to process the video stream at 25 fps. Moore's law aint' growing that fast these days, so matching the resolution of human vision is not a realistic option.]

Another example is kids. How does the AI recognize that the 5'1" 30-year-old woman has much better awareness and can be treated differently from the 5'2" 12-year-old boy? Humans can spot that difference even from behind.

How about recognizing an adult who is drunk? Or a blind person? Mourners at a funeral, or fans celebrating after a football game? Or a million other conditions that significantly affect pedestrian situational awareness that human drivers will instantly infer from context?

What will happen when kids figure out they can stop a driverless car on its way to collect its owner just by standing in the street in front of it? They'll have a lot of fun, for sure.

How about when carjackers figure out the same? That they can dress up like construction workers, stop the car in the street, tow it onto a flatbed with built-in RF jammer and head straight for their underground chop shop? There goes your cheaper insurance.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by janzer on Monday August 28, 2017 @09:50PM (#15121568)
> remember human vision is 570+ megapixels

This seems to come from http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/eye-resolution.html

But that number is a calculation of the maximum resolving power of the human eye filled across a 120 degree field of view. The fovea is the only portion of the retina that actually attains that acuity and it encompasses roughly 2 degrees in the center of the retina.

There are roughly 120 million rod cells and 6 million cone cells in the retina. The rod cells for color vision and cone cells for low light. As each individual rod cell is primarily sensitive to one of red, green or blue they match fairly well to the rgb channels of a pixel. So the eye could be considered to provide data roughly equivalent to a 40 megapixel color image and grayscale 6 megapixel. So ~5 times a 4k image.

Edit: And even that actually over estimates the amount of data the brain is actually processing. A 4k 60 fps video is handled by 6Gbps and the human optic nerve only has roughly 8.75Mbps of bandwidth.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by arpa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @06:35AM (#15131018)
A lot of processing is done "on the road", starting from ganglia in the retina itself; so a direct comparison with 4k 60fps video is grossly incorrect.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by wstrange on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:35PM (#15120275)
The computer could just assume the worst case:

That all people are classified as drunk children wearing headphones with low situational awareness.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:53PM (#15120820)
If the self-driving proponents were to say that human drivers would be banned, and all vehicles would therefore be self-driving I'd have more respect for their arguments. That said, you still need to account for things like pedestrians and snow. If we're talking about "self-driving on the I-5 when it isn't raining and there are no human drivers permitted" then yes I think we're probably close..
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by PeterisP on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:57PM (#15118652)
For a self driving car, it's sufficient if its understanding of weird situations is limited to detecting "yep, I'm in a weird situation, I'm going to stop now and wait for a remote human to take control".

The situations you describe are rare - I've once had a diplomatic event that required weird rerouting and twice had cases where traffic was regulated by hand signals due to some crash on the road, but that means just a few cases over a whole lifetime. A system that can't solve these cases but recognizes them as unsolvable is a quite acceptable automated system if it can delegate control to a human inside or a remote dispatcher, which isn't that hard to do.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by rayiner on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:09PM (#15118756)
These situations aren't rare at all. Just in the last few months, I've had: change in left-turn traffic pattern leaving my office onto a major road; humans guiding traffic on 2-3 separate occasions (very common around July 4th); cones dramatically changing lane patterns in construction zones; two occasions of cops blocking off a road with their cars to let a motorcade pass.

And this is just me driving (i.e. my car is parked 90% of the day). If you're talking about a self-driving Uber in D.C., one of the above events will happen on a daily basis.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:56PM (#15120833)
Your mention of humans guiding traffic reminds me of advice from my father many years ago: never assume that a human giving you direction when you're driving is giving you good information. Always evaluate whether what they're conveying to you may be either misunderstood (e.g. what does "wave" mean??) or just plain false. Hard for a human to do.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vel0city on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:37PM (#15120295)
I imagine traffic in D.C. is incredibly atypical compared to most US cities. Issues common to drivers in D.C. are probably very rare to most drivers in the US, including those in other major metropolitan areas.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by cmiles74 on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:50PM (#15120798)
I live in New England and the poster's description of DC traffic sounds like what I see all the time, from cities like Boston or even small towns like East Longmeadow.

http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/05/east_longmead...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:30PM (#15119818)
We actually now understand that passing control to a human is seriously dangerous - unless you can do it a minute or so in advance, the human has to switch context from being a passive passenger (or, more likely, actively engrossed in something else) into being an active driver very quickly. Everything up to level 4 automation will cause accidents when the car attempts to hand control to a human.

Of course, there's a very reasonable argument that e.g. level 3 automation might cause fewer accidents overall, even if it kills people when it has no idea what to do, but convincing Joe Public that such a car with such a known flaw is safe is another matter.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dsfyu404ed on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:57PM (#15119563)
>"yep, I'm in a weird situation, I'm going to stop now and wait for a remote human to take control".

Not that's not sufficient.

If ten people did that in a critical area during a high demand hour it would be a news story and there would be criminal charges depending on the details.

If you redefine "sufficient" to include stopping your car on the George Washington bridge because it's confused by a construction zone it still doesn't solve the backup you cause.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by qyv on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:24PM (#15120211)
The exceptional cases can often be the most important, especially when you are talking about moving humans from place to place. I wonder how a self-driving car would react to something like driving in a hurricane?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by euyyn on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:47PM (#15118001)
But you, as a human, don't need to know what happened before, to be able and drive through those conditions. You just need the immediately-available information, which is what OP defined as "no need for context" vs speech recognition.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by qyv on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:32PM (#15120254)
How does a self driving car differentiate between a police officer flagging you down and a carjacker? Humans can make this judgement because we have a context for each of those situations based on our understanding of how the world works outside of just operating a vehicle safely.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by taneq on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:21AM (#15122056)
To be fair, humans can't do this either, or there wouldn't be such a thing as carjackers.

One of the biggest challenges that automated systems face is that the acceptable failure rate for them is far below the acceptable failure rate for humans in the same role. To err is human...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by zzzzzzzza on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:30PM (#15118400)
yes but even humans are much better drivers on roads they are familiar with.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by enugu on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:11PM (#15118231)
It would not be too costly to augment roads with electronic signalling devices which give information to the software in cars. This information can do what signboards or traffic signals do for humans.

The difficult part - when there is an error in these signals, or things shut down, autonomous cars will suffer much bigger problems than human driven cars.

Its these edge cases that are the problem. We already rely on such mechanisms for planes(information comes from both gorund control and on-flight radar). But a lot of care and resources are is required to get to $n 9's level of reliability.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ChrisLTD on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:18PM (#15119725)
> It would not be too costly to augment roads with electronic signalling devices which give information to the software in cars.

Sounds costly to me. There are a lot more roads than airport runways. And then the big question is: Who is going to pay for it?

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by sah2ed on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:25PM (#15118351)
Remote driving assistance by a retired Uber driver on basic income is a possible low-tech solution.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by garrybelka on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:13PM (#15117617)
By context you mean a timeline of events while speech recognition is actually dependent on that timeline. Same applies to situational state recognition in driving. E.g., to derive speed, acceleration and direction of objects.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by PeterisP on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:50PM (#15118591)
No, in this context (pun intended) of speech recognition, the context means external context, i.e., understanding lots of information about the topic of that speech, knowing what would the speaker might plausibly be trying to say, what real world entities might be involved, and how are they called/spelled - all kinds of information that is not included in the original audio data, things that the listener would know based on life experience.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jessriedel on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:46AM (#15117355)
I use Google voice dictation to transcribe emails and text messages on my phone constantly. Not like "I tried it for a week and then went back". I have been using it daily for months. It's now vastly faster than typing it in by hand on a phone, and even the per-word error rate is actually better than mobile typing.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by leereeves on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:56AM (#15117462)
That's not to say that voice dictation is good enough to trust your life to (as in autonomous driving), just that mobile typing is even worse.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jessriedel on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:08PM (#15120089)
The interesting distinction isn't between life-dependent and non-life-dependent, it's between worse-than-human and better-than-human. I wouldn't "trust my life" to never making a typing error, and yet I trust my life to the driving my fingers do...and statistically, I have a small but real chance of death.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by leereeves on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:01PM (#15120868)
Personally, if the car isn't going to drive significantly better than a human, I'd rather drive myself. I prefer to be responsible for my own safety.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Fricken on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:53AM (#15117427)
Google voice isn't perfect, but it hears better than I do.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by com2kid on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:59PM (#15119124)
> I can't help but think about speech recognition 20 years ago. Many of the hot software packages claimed something like 96% accuracy, and that sounded great on paper. People thought intelligent voice-computer interfaces were just around the corner, yet here we are in 2017, and Siri/Alexa/Cortana are barely becoming usable (but still frustratingly lacking in many situations).

Computer speech recognition now has a greater accuracy than human speech recognition, but the types of use cases for talking to a computer are much less sensitive to error. Short snippets and phrases that are designed to get something done right now.

Compare ordering paper towels with Alexa, to asking a friend for a paper towel when your hands are messy. If your friend mishears you, they can just look over, see your dirty hands, and figure out you probably asked for a paper towel. Alexa has no such benefit, computers are held to a much higher bar.

> People thought intelligent voice-computer interfaces were just around the corner,

I would argue it isn't recognition accuracy that makes complex scenarios hard. I've seen context aware recognition being rolled out for keyboards recently (Android's keyboard does it now days, it'll correct the past word based on what the next word is), and it seems like Android does the same for speech reco, based at least on observed behavior during use, but I'm just guessing.

The real hard part is making computers smart enough to do useful things.

We are a long way off from

"Book tickets at The Altair for between 6pm and 7:30pm next Friday and add the reservation to my calendar and my wife's calendar"

being possible in all but a few contrived scenarios. (Now that said, the above scenario is getting easier and easier if you ignore voice, ML is good at figuring out emails that have schedules in them, and forwarding them to other people is now simple, everything is much better than 5 years ago!)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:50PM (#15120797)
Seriously?

>Computer speech recognition now has a greater accuracy than human speech recognition, but the types of use cases for talking to a computer are much less sensitive to error. Short snippets and phrases that are designed to get something done right now.

You just said that speech recognition doesn't work in general. In general is exactly where self-driving has to work. If we just needed self-driving trains, we'd have them already*

*We do have them, but strangely there isn't much demand since human train drivers appear to do an ok job most of the time.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by com2kid on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:09PM (#15120908)
> You just said that speech recognition doesn't work in general.

I replied that the accuracy is high. It turns out, in retrospect, that accuracy and usefulness are two different things.

In regards to automated driving, achieving better than human isn't all that hard. Heck backup cameras with little "warning zone" lines on them are better than human for the one particular task of backing up. Cruise control systems that maintain distance are better than humans. We are incrementally getting there. The progress is much different than with voice reco.

The problem with voice reco isn't recognition technology, that works fine, it is with having computers understand what the hell to do with the voice. Contrast that to driving, where the end goal is easy to list - Rule 1: Don't hit anything. Rule 2: Get to the destination. (Rule 1 is the hard part, Rule 2 99.9% solved!)

With Voice Reco, we got the transcription part down, but... now what? In the example I gave up above, knowing how to make a reservation is painful thanks to market fragmentation (not everything is an API), and people generally don't go and tag all of their contacts with their relationship status. I happen to have my wife under "wife" and my mother under "mother", that simple step alone gives me much more natural usage of voice input.

Then when I saw "OK Google, directions to my Mother's house", well, that still doesn't work for a thousand little reasons[1], even though each and every word was correctly transcribed. (I get a nice Google search instead!)

The set of situations that can happen while driving is far smaller than the set of interactions that can happen over voice when users expect a natural interface. Yes driving is really complicated, but it is possible to get a group together and after a day or so, brainstorm everything that could happen on the road out to 2 standard deviations of likelihood.

It might take an hour+ just to list all the ways someone might ask for directions.

[1] Mainly because no one programmed it to understand that particular way of making a request. It is annoying because I can ask it for directions to home, and that works fine, so I just figured directions to "Contact Name's House" would also work. Of course if I lived in NYC I'd expect "Contact Name's Apartment" to work!

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by lkbm on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @09:52PM (#15137564)
> The problem with voice reco isn't recognition technology, that works fine, it is with having computers understand what the hell to do with the voice.

If I type "remind me at 9am to water the plants", it does the right thing 100% of the time.

If I say "OK, Google, remind me at 9am to water the plants"...not so much.

If it just got "remind me at 9am" 100% of the time, I'd be satisfied. The fact that"water the plants" becomes "watering lamps" doesn't matter--I can figure out what I meant.

But it doesn't transcribe "remind me at 9am" correctly. It knows what to do with that text, but it doesn't get that far reliably enough.

Maybe I haven't tried saying this to humans enough for comparison, but right now, I'm not satisfied with the transcription of even the most common phrase. (Well over 90% of what I say to my phone starts with "OK, Google, remind me ..."

---

For fun, I just tried reading this out to my phone, and it got that phrase all three times:

> If I type remind me at 9 a.m. to water the plants it does the right thing 100% of time if I say OK Google remind me at 9 a.m. to water plants not so much if it just got remind me at 9 a.m. 100% of time I'd be satisfied the fact that water the plants becomes watering clamps doesn't matter I can figure out what I meant but it

Not bad. It cut off partway through, and maybe I need to speak my punctuation, but it's less error prone than normal. Helps to speak very clearly, unsurprisingly.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by qyv on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#15120186)
Isn't that kind of the point though? Yes, computers can hear better than humans, but they fail miserably at understanding the meaning of what they are hearing and responding with the appropriate actions. This is exactly the same issue that is/will be faced with self driving/driverless cars.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by oblio on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:36AM (#15117238)
Even better than speech recognition, handwriting recognition.

Hello, Apple Newton, may you rest in peace. I'm not convinced we'll have handwriting recognition within my lifetime, and if we do I imagine that shortly after I'll go looking for Sarah Connor :)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Animats on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:41PM (#15119440)
Automated reading of checks and of envelopes is working very well. Automated envelope reading is now so good that the USPS only has one center in the US where humans look at images of envelopes. They just look at the hard cases, and if they show up there, they're really hard.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:14PM (#15119699)
Unfortunately you can't augment a level 5 self-driving car with human resources in an analogous way.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by unityByFreedom on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:05AM (#15122203)
Well, we use humans to learn from mistakes in both cases and improve the technology.

The big difference is a mistake in a car is more likely to cause injury than a misdelivered letter.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ricardobeat on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:53AM (#15117429)
Go to your closest Apple store, choose an iPad Pro and try an app called 'Nebo'. Let us know when you find Sarah :)
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by oblio on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:25PM (#15117755)
I'd be useless, I'd have to take my mother, the proverbial doctor, to try it out :o)
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by QAPereo on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:25AM (#15117158)
It really makes the insane gamble of the Uber VC's ultimately terminal.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by devmunchies on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:32AM (#15117207)
That's what happens when you invest in hype. There's no way we'll be able to hail an autonomous Uber in the next 5 years, which is an eternity in startup land.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by chapmindustries on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:34AM (#15117223)
I strongly disagree. Uber has markets that make money and they release new services all the time. There are ways for them to stay in the black if they scale things back and fine tune different markets.

Someone is going to be the first in self driving cars. Uber has a tremendous demand for them. It would be stupid to not at least be trying to be the first one on the scene.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by QAPereo on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:59AM (#15117487)
Someone will be first, but the Uber VCs will be an old cautionary tale by then IMO.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by alphonsegaston on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:36AM (#15117236)
Maybe for this particular investment, but I'm pretty sure the wider intention was to legitimize business practices where the poor live tenuous lives as an app-directed servant class. Uber made this kind of neo-feudalism so socially acceptable that we now celebrate "Uber-for-X" as "innovation."
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by rainbowmverse on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:06PM (#15117558)
It already happened before Uber, except now the app is in the hands of the person being exploited, not the managers creating optimized schedules that make it near impossible for individuals to hold enough jobs to pay the bills.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by alphonsegaston on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:18PM (#15118273)
That's nice PR to assuage the guilt of people building this kind of tech, but it's really not working out that way:

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/jun/17/uber-drivers...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by rainbowmverse on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:24PM (#15118343)
You must have replied to the wrong post. This agrees with my point that this kind of tech is abusive, but doesn't address my point that it's a long-standing problem older than Uber. Managers in retail and food service have used scheduling software to screw workers over for years. Uber just shifts the technology into the hands of people it exploits (smartphone app instead of scheduling software in the manager's office + calling in to get hours/find out you aren't getting any).

You seemed to imply that this is a new phenomenon that isn't yet legitimized. It's been around for a long time. It was and continues to be a problem, but Uber is just a microcosm of it.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by QAPereo on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:59AM (#15117492)
To be fair, few outside of SV do celebrate that.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by ageofwant on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:54PM (#15118069)
Intercontinental planes are mostly autonomous. Trains are autonomous. Massive mine dump trucks are fully autonomous. These things are in use today and has been for almost a decade. They need not be perfect to be useful, they only need to be better than the average human driver.

Toyota is way behind in the game. What do you expect them to say about the competition?

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by mandevil on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:58PM (#15119998)
Planes are a good argument for the opposite.

Do you ever wonder why there are two pilots on every commercial airliner? It's not because airlines like paying so many more pilots- notice how fast flight engineer/navigator positions disappeared as flight management technology and GPS made them unnecessary. But still two pilots are there on every commercial flight, why?

Simple answer: the airline industry has learned, through a lot of lessons in blood over decades, that even with automation you really need a pilot who is always ready to intervene right this second, not in three minutes after they've mentally caught up to what the situations is. And in order to provide that sort of guarantee over many hours, you need two pilots, so they can switch off responsibility. That's because commercial airliners on cruise, way above any animals, terrain, etc. still have situations where immediate human intervention is safety critical. (And when pilot minds fall behind the power curve the result is things like AF447, so it seems like the industry is right about the importance of this human monitoring and intervention.)

So if this well studied, easier externals problem requires someone on ready for immediate intervention at all times, how quickly do you think that a much harder problem like driving is going to get solved sufficient to allow human free driving?

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by smileysteve on Monday August 28, 2017 @09:18PM (#15121469)
Because you reference AF447; Autopilot systems also added additional sensors (satellite assisted speed) for the system to have redundancies.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by semi-extrinsic on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:54PM (#15119961)
> intercontinental planes are mostly autonomous

This is a highly disingenious use of the word autonomous. Airplane "autopilots" are given a set of waypoints and will fly a straight line between those. That's been possible with cars since (at least) the 1960s too; today it's easy enough that you could give it as an end-of-term project for a bunch of robotics undergrads. It's also completely useless outside of very specialized situations like the mining dump trucks you mention.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by taneq on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:37PM (#15121913)
All of those things have a team of engineers maintaining the hardware and configuration of each installation, and operate "on rails" (either GPS-defined or literal) in very carefully controlled environments.

It's like saying that we've had factory robotics for decades and so we should soon have useful robotic housekeepers (in the general sense, not the Roomba sense).

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jpindar on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:23PM (#15118326)
Not all trains are autonomous, and they have been known to crash due to operator error.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by lb1lf on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:14PM (#15118790)
Besides, trains run on tracks, each of which accomodates one train at any given time and rarely intersect; additionally, there's all sorts of signalling and safety infrastructure embedded with the track...

In stark contrast with lane-swerving cars, intersections everywhere, temporary rerouting because of roadworks &c.

Running trains must be orders of magnitude simpler than fully autonomous vehicles.

As for planes, they have a massive benefit in being engineered and maintained for levels of reliability no car can ever hope to achieve, having an awful lot of empty air around them (not to mention being able to move in the Z plane, too, to avoid collisions.

I don't doubt there are many lessons to be learned by designers of autonomous vehicles from work already put down in the fields of trains and planes - however, I'd argue they are very different problems.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by rayiner on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:40AM (#15117286)
> and Siri/Alexa/Cortana are barely becoming usabl

And at least Siri is completely useless without a data connection.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by koffiezet on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @11:28AM (#15124907)
I absolutely disagree. Self-driving cars are complex, but not unmanageable.

> What people don't realize is that full autonomous driving will require more than just faster/smaller/cheaper technical innovation - it will require the refinement of innovations that probably haven't even been invented/researched yet.

Like what? Object detection/recognition? Better sensors? Path/trajectory prediction? Vehicle control? Sensors and processing/unifying their data? The hardest part is letting all these building work together, and then produce a mass-production product from it, but we do have the base technologies, companies like Google, Tesla and Volvo have proven already that.

The problem comes down to software, and Toyota has the problem that it's a hardware-focused company. In the car-industry, just like in any industry, software will become more and more important, and Toyota - just like many other car-companies - simply doesn't have an answer here since they don't understand it.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by aedron on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:49AM (#15123181)
I think instrumenting the roads in one way or another will go a long way to enable real autonomous vehicles. Sure it's expensive, but on the upside it might actually work in this century. We just need to define a standard and let the free market go to work.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by snambi on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:11PM (#15118223)
"ok google" is pretty good, in answering.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by 1_2__4 on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:38PM (#15119415)
Every time this gets brought up here people scoff. Nobody seems to be willing to notice that tech companies have for quite a while now been misrepresenting the pace of innovation in areas that not-coincidentally are attempts at diversifying revenue streams by hitting new tech home runs. See also: Glass, any of the other nonsense coming out of Google X (Loon? Cyber contacts?), drone delivery, digital assistants, and so forth. Not to say cool stuff isn't happening in all these fields but we are not just a few short years away from the tech being viable.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kyrra on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:03PM (#15126274)
To Loon's defense, it actually worked well in the recent flooding on Peru[0].

[0] https://blog.x.company/helping-out-in-peru-9e5a84839fd2

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by eighthnate on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:38AM (#15124574)
Until we get a very generalized form of AI, I think cities will have to be remodeled to assist self-driving cars. Places like NYC ( manhattan ) can be easily converted into a self-driving car city given it's grid-like layout and I can easily see china building cities around the idea of self-driving cars.

I don't think the technical aspects are as difficult for the 99.99% of the cases. It is the 0.01% of unknowns that will be difficult to overcome. But we can minimize that by modifying or building cities specifically for self-driving cars.

The most difficult part I think is the legal/regulatory issues.

This is why I see self-driving cars taking off in china/asia first before the US. They'll probably limit it to city limits initially. And when the technology is mature enough, broaden it to the entire country.