Tesla took the approach that the machine is in control and the human has to detect and take over when the machine makes a mistake. That is known to be a very problematic strategy, it's easy for the human to get distracted.
What Subaru has done is to leave the human in control, the machine only steps in when it sees a problem.
It's totally different safety outcomes. In fact, not even the same problem - one is "self driving", the other is "crash prevention".
But a car that can drive me while I sleep and become a Taxi while I work is something I would go into debt for.
I don't think most regular people will actually own fully autonomous cars to rent them out. Big players will do the capital expenditure to buy a fleet, and rent out transportation service. Renting in uber style will be basically the price of owning, but without the up-front capital expenditure, and it will provide the convenience of choosing the type of car for the specific transport needs of the moment. The margins of these rent-a-fleet services will be low, so you won't have a hope as individual car owner of actually buying a car and renting it out without turning it into a loss compared to just renting.
That's not really accurate. Tesla says the driver is ultimately responsible. That holds unless a court determines otherwise. The same is true for Toyota/Subaru. They're all SAE level 2 systems.
The opposite approach from this would be Waymo/Volvo who intend to take responsibility for decisions made by their vehicles. Those are SAE level 4 or 5 systems.
Only to those not familiar with autopilot systems in aircraft.
It's like the use of "hacker" - here on this site it still (probably) has most of it's original meaning. To the rest of the world it means a guy in a ski-mask with a russian/chinese accent who's after your bank account.
Unfortunately most of the world thinks pilots in commercial aircraft turn on the autopilot and can then go for a sleep, so when they see "Autopilot" on a Tesla, they think they can do the same.
They can go to sleep and the plane will continue to fly itself. However, if anyone found out they were sleeping heads would roll.
Autopilot electronics on a plane is trivial. Autopilot for a car is damn hard.
Isn’t that most people?
They can go for a sleep though.
The Pilot in Command is expected to sit in their seat and monitor the aircraft, surrounding airspace and the radios, and be ready to take control at a moments notice.
They can't go for a snooze without handing that over to another pilot first.
I think OP was talking about "crash avoidance" systems. Not systems that claim to drive the car but not really.
You're always driving, the car is just silently observing. If the car sees you're about to crash, it steps in and takes over. The opposite of Tesla's approach where you play the role of observer taking over when things go wrong.
The first approach is safe. The second approach isn't safe until full autonomy due to cognitive load and task switching delays.
What they don't do is take over steering. A last-second takeover of steering would make things worse some of the time.
http://www.leftlanenews.com/volvo-xc60s-collision-avoidance-...
I have a Honda. While its lane-keeping system won't steer during a crash, it definitely does steer to keep you centered in the lane (when it's able). That could help avoid all kinds of crashes due to inattentive lane-drifting.
Assuming for example the car is fitted with solid state lidar on the four corners and ESR on the four sides or even LIDAR.
What are your thoughts on crash prevention if the car has the same hardware as a a Waymo car?
(edit: to clarify, would you consider autosteering at the last minute safer than a human driver in that scenario?)
More like, if you are not a car on the left lane, then you are not. Bam, you got an accident.
Edit: Is the last video in the US? Is it normal for other drivers not to stop when they see an accident?
I wrote a previous YC posting on this, on why you need to use geometry first, then object recognition.
Seriously? All smartphones are video phones. I fail to see how they could be more widely used.
You may mean that people choose to make audio-only calls... but just because people choose to do that, it doesn't mean the technology isn't here & fully available in affordable, commercial, "good enough" form.
That's the approach we know won't work. That was Tesla's first-round autopilot, the self-crashing car. The one that would happily run into obstacles protruding into a lane.[1][2][3] There are two big flaws with that approach. First, if it's good enough that people can tune out, they will tune out. Second, if the driver waits until the self-driving system has clearly made a mistake before taking over, they will be slower at reacting than if they were driving, and may be too late. See especially [3].
Volvo's CEO takes the position that if one of their cars crashes in self-driving mode, it's Volvo's fault. Urmson, while at Google, pointed out the first problem coming up even with their test drivers.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc0yYJ8-Dyo [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvRkSMCDX3o [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2ml6sjk_8c