News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:28PM (#15118385)
I don't know by what metrics you're making these comparisons. Audio recognition and self-driving vehicles are apples and oranges.

Autonomous driving is difficult primarily because of a changing world and low tolerance for mistakes. The state space of situations you're trying to map is just large. It will take time. But it's not even close to impossible.

Audio recognition is difficult for a different reason: language is difficult to disambiguate without context. So today the limits of our audio recognition bump up against knowing the context of words you're saying. It used to be the case that audio recognition had fundamental difficulties e.g at word boundaries but those challenges are mostly solved. Some of these challenges might not be solved without improvements in areas outside of the raw listening part of ASR.

> That being said, Toyota's (and Subaru's) approach is the smart way forward - add sensors and capabilities that augment the human, but leave the human always responsible and in control. In order for a crash to happen, the human AND the machine BOTH have to miss it.

This is your opinion. Folks at some other companies (e.g waymo) don't think this makes you safer. Human attention might not work the way you think it does.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kpil on Monday August 28, 2017 @01:58PM (#15118668)
I think that audio recognition is an order of magnitude less complicated than fully autonomous driving. The world is fully contextless outside the road to an not-even-at-insect-level brain driving two tons of metal, and anything can happen.

Voice recognition is getting just barely tolerable. If you have tried to do something important using voice recognition you'd probably go bat shit crazy after a while. If it had the potential to kill people no sane human would allow it.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by sol_remmy on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:44PM (#15119458)
Voice recognition also has a lot less market demand than self driving cars. Technology can be invented that is decades ahead of other fields if enough money is invested.

That is why I think self-driving cars and voice recognition are not comparable problems.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by LrnByTeach on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:24PM (#15120204)
Totally agree ..

> Voice recognition also has a lot less market demand than self driving cars.

Just to expand on your point, today's 'self driving car' technology we may equal to where 'voice recognition technology' was 20 years ago. But 20 years ago, there is no incentive for industry to invest say $100 Billion in 'voice recognition technology', the benefits did not warrant such a huge investment. Where as'self driving car' technology there is potential to reap benefits that is why industry today investing $100 Billion ( all combined investments from all players )

> Technology can be invented that is decades ahead of other fields if enough money is invested.

> That is why I think self-driving cars and voice recognition are not comparable problems.

The huge economic value the can be created with perfected 'self driving car' is in the order of hundreds of Billions of dollars per year world wide combined . Here is an example scenario

In 2025 'self driving Electric Autonomous fleet' vehicles by Uber, Googles of the world offer 'miles plan' ( like our 2005 mobile monthly plan N minutes/month ) that is like 1000 miles per month you can hail any time for a monthly price of $300/month . This is huge economic value for at least 50% of USA drivers and people will embrace it.

Typical USA drivers total cost of ownership of CAR today is in the range of $400 to $600 per month ( CAR price + Repairs costs + car Insurance + gasoline cost) . This is with out counting 1.5 hours/day you have pay attention to drive, the time that can be used for other thing with autonomous fleet

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by fastball on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:51PM (#15121105)

  I think
Wonderful.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by dang on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:18PM (#15121661)
Would you please not do this here? We're trying for at least a slightly higher quality level on HN. One thing that helps is not to assume stupidity in the other; we even added a new guideline recently to say that. More diplomatically though.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:42PM (#15119893)
> The world is fully contextless outside the road to an not-even-at-insect-level brain driving two tons of metal, and anything can happen.

See that's where you're wrong. An autonomous vehicle doesn't have to have a human brain. It has to have very accurate sensors and classifiers tuned with generous safety params.

Like any vehicle it also needs redundancies for safety and sane default behavior (mostly "slam on the breaks").

Also, not "anything can happen." There are rules that govern the road that make this problem tractable. There are rules that govern physics that mean if you have adequate sensors + compute you can avoid hitting any objects at all, whether it's a person or otherwise. "Object x is 30 ft away with trajectory y, we're going 15mph, slam on the brakes."

The difficulties mostly lie in how we can "not slam on the brakes all the time and never make progress." e.g if you enter a construction zone you better know what to do and not just sit still, otherwise you'll never get anywhere.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jotjotzzz on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:27PM (#15120221)
Agreed. I would think audio recognition is not comparable to driving, since the scope of recognizing all voices, accents, languages is vastly different than the set of rules for driving and the complexity of the road.

Realistically speaking, even if Tesla or any other manufacturing company do get to that level of a "super advance Einstein-genius" self-driving car it will still be: "not even close" if it's riding alongside the highway with 18-year old Billy-bob speedster with a penchant for cutting lanes and living dangerously. Most car accidents are due to human error.

If all cars on the highway are self-driving cars, with the ability to learn and communicate with each other through mesh-network or what-not, with predictive capacity -- it will be a lot better than any driving human that can only see what's in front of them. We just need to get to that level where most cars on the highway are smart self-driving capable cars and we can build on top of that. No one should be relying on self-driving cars to do everything at this point in the game because we're not there yet.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by speby on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:08PM (#15118742)
Audio recognition may be apples and oranges to self-driving vehicles. But as it relates to autonomous driving, audio recognition (and I don't mean speech but general sounds) is something nobody has been talking about (at least publicly) as a sensor input for self-driving cars. Think about how much you rely on your hearing to drive safely and well. Sure, we use sight/depth and so forth substantially but we also rely on our ears listening for different kinds of sounds that can occur from any direction to warn us of changing conditions, unsafe circumstances, and so forth.

We can't even get speech recognition right and meanwhile audio (sounds in general) aren't even being seriously considered for self-driving purposes, AFAICT.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:41PM (#15118982)
Curious, isn't it? Humans rely on auditory information to enhance situational awareness so you'd think that would factor into the design of a machine that needs as much situational awareness as possible.

For example, emergency response vehicles announce their arrival and direction often long before any visual contact is made. How will deaf autonomous cars recognize incoming emergency responders if the view is obstructed? Will they pull into the intersection just as a Fire Engine is running the red light?

Auditory input was deemed important enough that California even made it illegal to "wear a headset covering, earplugs in, or earphones covering, resting on, or inserted in, both ears" while driving just last year. [0] I suspect other jurisdictions have/will follow(ed) suit.

[0]http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection....

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jdietrich on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#15120180)
Telling which direction a siren is coming from is really, really easy. You can do it with three electret microphones and a $1 ARM chip. A simple TDOA multilateration algorithm will do a far better job of it than a human, even in complex reverberant environments.

Reliably understanding speech is effectively strong AI. Humans don't speak very clearly, but we're spectacularly good at inferring meaning from context. Accurate transcripts of colloquial speech are often completely incomprehensible, because a vast amount of information is conveyed through context. When we're listening to someone speak, we're decoding the phonemes into symbols, but we're also constructing a model of the speaker's mind and predicting what they mean to say.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by pg314 on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:32PM (#15119364)
Are deaf people allowed to drive? How do you think they handle these situations?
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:17PM (#15119717)
There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals, akin to doorbell or telephone strobes. But the more interesting adaptive technology seems to be a re-wiring of the brain. [0] Deprived of auditory input and with a heightened reliance on visual cues, the autonomous driving version might be something like Lidar + other driver facial recognition.

[0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/superpowers-for-t...

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jstanley on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:01PM (#15120034)
> There seems to be some limited automotive technology available that would convert sirens to visual signals

Yes, I've noticed this too. Sometimes you can almost see blue and red flashing lights on top of a police car.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by DoubleCribble on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:14PM (#15120128)
I applaud your synesthesia! Those of us with more common auditory processing are unable to see sound. :(

si·ren (sīrən)noun 1.a device that makes a loud prolonged sound as a signal or warning.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by vertex-four on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:08PM (#15119663)
According to a quick google, noticing that other cars are pulling in/slowing down usually works if they can't see the emergency vehicle. Still, it's not "perfect", but then Hearing drivers are far from perfect either, and there's plenty of failsafes before an accident happens.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by stevenwoo on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:25PM (#15119777)
Fire trucks and ambulances I've seen when driving against traffic lights/flow of traffic always slow and stop to make sure that there will not be an accident even if they have the right of way - they don't drive like police in pursuit on TV. I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by mindcrime on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:12PM (#15120115)
I'm sure there are exceptions but the general case is the emergency vehicles are planning for other traffic to not yield until it is clear the other traffic is yielding.

Yes, if the driver is well trained. When I was firefighting and instructing drivers, we always emphasized that while the red light and siren gave you the right of way:

a. they don't absolve you of liability for a crash (at least under NC law)

and

b. if you get in a crash on the way to the scene, you're not doing anybody any good, PLUS you've now created another incident requiring another emergency response, PLUS another company (probably coming from further away) has to respond to the original call.

I can't speak for police, but firefighters are actually, in my experience, taught to be pretty conservative when it comes to running red lights, proceeding against traffic on one way streets, and other similar scenarios.

We also always used to emphasize "it does no good to get halfway there, real fast".

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by upvotinglurker on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:45PM (#15135307)
Per [0] they are allowed to drive in the US, and do not have higher accident rates than hearing drivers[1]. Also, "There are now devices available that can be used in r cars that react to the frequency of sirens and which emit visual warnings of approaching emergency vehicles to assist deaf drivers and those with hearing loss" (which could presumably also "assist" self-driving cars).

[0] https://www.enddd.org/end-distracted-driving/enddd-presentat...

[1] This web site's bona fides aren't clear, but its mission does not seem to specifically include advocating for the deaf, so there's no obvious reason for the information presented to be biased in favor of the deaf.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by xapata on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:34PM (#15119378)
Microphones cost much h less than LIDAR.
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by kajecounterhack on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:44PM (#15119910)
"Nobody talking about it" doesn't mean nobody is working on it ;)
Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:37PM (#15120291)
> language is difficult to disambiguate without context.

So why don't Siri/Alexa/etc developers give them context? I would LOVE to be able to say "Alexa, play playlist on shuffle mode" or even simple "Alexa, turn on shuffle and go to next song"

But no, the word "and" is completely off limits. Saying "shuffle playlist" instead of "play playlist" also doesn't work. I have to literally use 3 commands to do what I want:

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift" ... "Alexa, shuffle" ... "Alexa, next song"

With context, I could say "Alexa, play Taylor Swift on shuffle"

Apparently Siri is gaining the ability to deal with follow up questions in iOS11. Excited to try it out.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by balls187 on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:52PM (#15120383)
How would you differentiate:

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift on shuffle"

vs

"Alexa, play Taylor Swift on Spotify" (real command)

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by Swizec on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:26PM (#15120647)
Spotify is default. She also knows how to do noun recognition. If she can tell the difference between “play” and “stop”, she can differentiate shuffle and Spotify.

I’m also ok sayin “Alexa, shuffle Taylor Swift” if that’s easier for their grammar.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by balls187 on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:03PM (#15120873)
I think "shuffle" is the obvious choice to be used as a verb.

As you mentioned, Alexa already understands shuffle (though I don't think it does for Spotify's integration).

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by jstanley on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:00PM (#15120020)
> Audio recognition is difficult for a different reason: language is difficult to disambiguate without context.

That's not the only reason audio recognition is hard. If it were, audio recognition would be exactly as hard as interpreting written text.

Re:Toyota Research Institute head says full autonomous drivi... by cerved on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:29PM (#15120235)
I get your point but to nitpick, written and spoken language are not equivalent. We don't say things like "quote", "comma" and "question mark". We use things like intonation, gestures etc.