Alas, I always struggle to explain it to people from primitive banking cultures.
That destroys the human element, which is a big part of the restaurant/hospitality experience.
There are products out there that let you order through a tablet at your table, and also apps that let staff use an iphone instead of a notepad, but it takes away a large part of the experience.
It's fine for places like McDonald's (who now have touch screen ordering in some countries, like New Zealand and Australia), but if I went to Bouchon Bistro, I wouldn't want to be ordering through a tablet.
I know I enjoy arguing about whether the cash I have is too large for the other party to conveniently make change for. I especially enjoy my wallet bulging with coins and wads of paper. I love the thought of having the week's grocery money ready to be lost and stolen - or even better, carrying my whole pay packet about until I can put it somewhere safe.
Also, WADS of paper? Jeez, get a moneyclip...
I routinely dip into the spouse's in-vehicle change-hoard tray to refill it, because apparently some people can't be arsed to fish a penny out of a giant pile of coins when their drive-through total is $X.01, and would rather dump $0.99 in coins into it--never to be spent--instead.
In theory, you should never need more than four $0.01 coins, never more than one $0.05 coin, no more than two $0.10 coins, and not more than three $0.25 coins, per cash transaction. If you have those 10 coins, you can always provide exact change. If you do not have those exact ten, you can always spend some of your coins, such that you get fewer than nine coins in your change. In practice, I need more coin slots, because I am spending coins that do not originate from my own transactions, and need to spend as many small coins as is possible, rather than maintaining an efficient working set of coins in my wallet.
If no one else is filling up a change jar at home, your coin holder only needs to hold ten coins (in the US). It will fit in the same space as a paper note folded in half.
What's interesting to me is how far ahead some poorer societies are than us in the cash department. Such as in Africa. They have gone all mobile payments and eschew the local currencies.
Or claim to.
I take your point though. The inconvenience to the mugger to force you to travel to an ATM may be much greater than making you send a larger amount with your phone. After all, with physical cash it was very believable you didn't have more money that can be extracted. Now that you can move more, the mugger can force you to move more.
BUT then you can reverse it later. Unless you can argue that the mugger would be more likely to kill you afterwards than before, as a result of the sum. But then you could have the reversals happen anyway, and the muggers would know that's the default. All that remains is proving it was a mugging... all the transactions could be reversed based on that (we are not talking about bitcoins here, but systems of credit so the mugger might go into debt if they spent the money already). The idea of banks etc. instead of bitcoin actually helps in a libertarian type system because the money can be yanked back and the mugger doesn't want the inconvenience of never having a bank account. Plus if his other property is all interconnected, then crime really won't pay, and there would be less need for incarceration. We just have to somehow have fair systems of proving it was really a mugging. Maybe along the lines of the DMCA... someone could claim a mugging and then you'd have some time to respond, both sides would present evidence, and there would be a global reputation for both true and false claims of mugging.
Anyway I think in practice there have been less muggings now that cash is digital in Africa.
All of those options work across the world.
Sarcasm aside, I think the entire debate is just blogspam, both have benefits and both will probably remain for a long time.
First off, Walmart will wire up to $50 for $5 domestic, not $25.
Second, what's the point of sending $1 to much of the world, where it isn't legal tender?
Third, "cashless" in this context means domestic use. Even if we were all cashless tomorrow, you'll still have to pay transfer fees to put $1 into an overseas account. Plus, the bank on the other side may charge to accept that transfer - mine does.
Fourth, the failure rate for sending $1 through the postal system has to be pretty low, because it's hard to detect a single bill in an envelope. A high failure rate would mean that every letter would be opened up, just in case there's cash. That level of tampering is easily detected. (Of course, sending cash overseas is different, as international letters stand out, and perhaps might more often contain cash. But I have send cash to South Africa and it got there just fine.)
If we instead talk about sending $1 inside the US then it's $0.49 for the stamp and $0.07 for the envelope ... for what may be door-to-door delivery.
What other system can beat that price? (I think Bitcoin's transaction fee is slightly less, but not significantly so.)
I've never paid for a bank transfer within Europe, even when the transfer crosses national borders. I've always just assumed that to be one of the basic ideas of a banking system.
This might differ for commercial accounts though.
:)
I can even pay the kids selling strawberries by the roadside via Swish.
Then again, Sweden is in the forefront of the cashless society at the moment, for better or worse.
Accepting Swish-payments for merchants, companies, organizations and associations is not free however. The last time I checked (a couple of months back) - Swish was more expensive than handling credit cards in general.
https://www.bankgirot.se/en/about-bankgirot/participant-requ...
There are plenty of legal regulations to wade through to join, but it's not impossible and the requirements are publicly available.
The application is however a gratis download from the AppStore / Google Play store.
In this thread I have seen dozens of comments about muggers and knife wielding assailants at ATM machines. In my 40+ years on the planet, including living in NYC and DC and traveling to dozens of third world countries, I have been mugged exactly once, in 1989. I was able to get away without giving up any money.
Meanwhile, the number of times that an electronic account that I hold funds in has been unexpectedly lower than expected due to error, misunderstanding, or fraud, is at least 100 or more.
On the other hand, "convenience" is a contrived reason to favor cashless transactions. As if the whole purpose in life is to reduce friction from our lives. It's not. Oh, it frees your time up to do other things. As if people didn't have enough time. The main thing lacking for most people when it comes to time is time management and allocation. That is, people who might save an hour's time by automating activities don't go out and spend that hour productively. Likely they'll find something else that'll use up their time.
So, we have people who work in industries which are automating jobs away [say Uber, or even supermarket automation, HFT, etc.] but who on the other hand want authentic hand made or bespoke items. Why not go for the mass produced item from Walmart they helped get produced and are more "convenient"?
> As if the whole purpose in life is to reduce friction from our lives. It's not.
Purpose? No. But it does feel really good not to have friction with silly things in your everyday life.
> That is, people who might save an hour's time by automating activities don't go out and spend that hour productively. Likely they'll find something else that'll use up their time.
Why do you say so? What's objectively productive? Doing nothing with the extra time may be actually a productive / useful solution. If your day is full, just removing stress from life is great.
> we have people who work in industries which are automating jobs away [say Uber, or even supermarket automation, HFT, etc.] but who on the other hand want authentic hand made or bespoke items
Do they? Some probably. But generalising like that over whole industry's lifestyle is silly. Even if you do see those items, maybe they just buy something cool they like, which is simply not what's mass produced and stocked at Walmart.
I feel like you're trying to criticise lifestyles of other people, but don't see a real reason for it.
I feel like you are reading way too much into it. You say less friction "feels really good", but don't address his point that maybe less friction is not actually good. There are many areas of life where this is demonstrably true. Take road widths, for example. If we "reduce friction", we end up with wider and straighter roads which have shown to cause people to drive faster and results in more fatalities (i read this on the internet somewhere). Sometimes friction keeps us grounded.
I found nothing offensive about the parent comment, and have noticed similar things.
For example, human inter-relationships are full of "friction". For some people not having friction would be ideal, for others a relationship without friction is no relationship at all.
And I think that can extend into the physical world. Maybe I'd like to remove the friction of having to wipe after going to the toilet --but it's also a good reminder we're still part animal. So it is when we actually have to drive or cook for ourselves. We're not just commanding people or things to do the bidding for us -we have to face the "dirty work" whether it's having another human do it for us or ourselves. But automation removes this mirror.
The "reason" for it is that we could lose touch with our own humanity. It all becomes abstracted --it's a transaction, the human labor (or lack of it) are not even considered any more. I know this might sound like it's coming from a luddite, but it's not. It's just observation and it may or may not have import in the future, if we keep going this route.
Btw, a bidet is pretty good.
Fine. Prove it. Collect your pay in cash. Pay your rent in cash. Do all your shopping with cash.
Otherwise, lay off the fairy stories and moralising.
There are many, many apps out there to facilitate many things, to reduce friction. You know the two that matter most to me [other than telephony]? Navigation (maps) and Yelp (or similar) [finding food, entertainment]. Most other things can wait till I get to the office or get back home. I detest the idea of being electronically "tethered" into always on attention.
Honestly, I consider that easier than cash.
I'm also waiting for panhandlers to figure out Square is free, assuming they have a smartphone. "Sorry, no cash" stops being the end of the interaction if they start taking credit.
Do you like taking chances like that? Cash saves you here.
Edit: You likely meant to pay for things while you're visiting there? Yeah, I would probably use cash for that too.
Cash has other inconveniences cards dont have , and viceversa.
Until very recently, as a visitor you will be losing 30% of value if you withdraw funds from ATM or pay with card, as opposed to bringing USD cash and exchanging it on street.
I use contactless card payments for pretty much everything except coffee these days.
Considering the second point, would you consider using cash more? To get a better feel at how much/little you're spending each time.
Open Venmo or Squarse Cash, type name (gets auto completed), type amount, done. Works regardless of whether your preceding set of transactions has left with exactly the right number of bills of each denomination.
Here in New Zealand, the only places that don't take cards are small stalls at farmers markets (most of them take cards now), and some taxis (which is more to do with them trying to avoid tax and being generally dodgy, any good taxis take card).
I have the bank account details of all my friends saved, and I can just open up my banks app and send them money, and it arrives within an hour into their account for all but 1 bank.
My belief is that the biggest weakness of a solution is generally a side-effect of its greatest strength, in this case the need to carry around cash in different amounts and risk losing it, having it stolen are necessary in order to have something so easy to exchange among people.
I haven't actually had actual cash in my wallet since before Christmas. Every store takes credit or debit. I can email money to people I owe money to. Cash is darn inconvenient.
Giving money to homeless people is just about the only thing in your list I can't do.
We also have contact-less payments with both credit or debit so it's even faster for low cost purchase. Need a coffee from starbucks? Just tap your credit card and go. But the time you put the wallet back in your pocket it's authorized.
Aren't here any equivalents in the US? Any particular reasons why apps like cash.me don't get adopted?
Why do people keep saying talking in person is inconvenient, as if saying it makes it true? It is, in my experience, extremely convenient. It is the most convenient form of communication, person to person. I want to talk to my friend. Do you have a phone? Oh you don't. Let me make sure I got your phone number right. etc.
People are making the argument that because electronic payment is convenient for large transactions, therefore cash is inconvenient in all cases. This is a falsehood. They are both convenient in different cases.
In a way, convenience is in the eye of the bearer.
(Never mind the whole commercial surveillance angle. I've actually made it a point to go back to cash at various places I'd gotten lazy with. Hitting the ATM every week is a small price for participating in society's most popular mix network)
I tend not to give homeless people money in general, I rather do it via an institution or buy them what they need. If they say they need some money for food I'll go shop with them if I have time. But I've indeed also walked to an ATM at various times, which are fortunately all over the place in my city. Even if I had cash I'd always be a bit conflicted to give... On the one hand I've spoken to various (ex) homeless people and they advised me not to give, not be naive for my sake and their sake (read: drug addiction, better dealt with by an institution which are pretty solid in my city). On the other hand, I've loved ones with homelessness in their past who've rebounded by the grace of complete strangers' help, including financial help, and didn't ever use drugs but were really down n out and on the street. You never know which of the two you're dealing with.
But let's be real, helping homeless people isn't exactly a daily use case. If it was something you do frequently enough, there'd be way better ways to do it than giving away random small bits of cash.
Everything else, digital is more convenient. For example if I have dinner with a buddy, on the way back home I'll grab my phone, open my banking app, click his address which is automatically saved from the first time I used it, type in the amount and press send. It's virtually the same as grabbing my wallet, calculating the tokens I owe him and handing it to him. Payments are literally like messaging for me, but you're sending digital value tokens instead of digital speech. Yes it's hella convenient to do digital messaging of money.
The thing about digital payment's that's more convenient is that I don't rely on carrying a specific denomination of cash with me, or rely on being in physical proximity to the payee. Need to send $500? Well I'd never carry that kind of cash, so that's an ATM trip for me, and then a trip to the guy I owe it to. Digital money is more convenient here.
Payments in stores? Both I and the cashier need to do basic calculations with the tokens using cash, and again I have to carry enough on me. Turns out digital cash is easier and faster. I have my card out by the time it's my turn in the queue, I let the cashier scan, then I hold my card next to a little NFC scanner and I start walking away. In some older places I put in a 4 digit pin, even so it's faster than cash. That's convenience for me.
Don't get me started on online payments, which are btw causing physical store bankruptcies left and right. I see it all around me, I've got friends who buy their entire wardrobe online, their phone online, their groceries online etc etc. I'm not much of an online shopper myself, but even so I rarely use cash and the reason is convenience.
What on earth are they talking about? Why do people keep saying cash is inconvenient, as if saying it makes it true? It is, in my experience, extremely convenient. It is the most convenient form of payment, person to person. I owe money to my friend. Do you have a pay-pass terminal? Oh you don't. Let's just log into our bank accounts. Let me make sure I got your BSB number and account number right. etc.
I want to give some money to the homeless beggar. Excuse me, do you have your bank details?
Cash is king for a reason: Convenience.