News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by thenewwazoo on Thursday March 10, 2016 @03:56PM (#11262229)
IBM has literally no disincentive to do this, either de jure or de facto. The threat of H1-B applications being denied is either laughable or [there aren't enough of them anyway] depending on who you ask. And IBM employees, like most tech workers, don't think they need to act (read: bargain) collectively and thus have no recourse. Until the tech industry wakes up to the reality that they _are_ labor, companies will continue to treat their employees as fungible, on an increasingly global scale.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:11PM (#11262357)
The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

I have worked for a few companies that have gone out of business. Looking for work afterwards is mostly a screening job, picking the work I want to do out of the various offers. Every time, I have been hired for more money than I was making before (it is common knowledge that changing jobs is the best way to get raises)

It isn't like I am some hotshot developer, either. I am not a networking type person, so all of my contacts are just people I have worked with at previous shops. The reason it is so easy to find work is because there are simply more jobs available than qualified workers.

I know this because I have been on the other side, too (trying to hire people). It is really hard to find quality developers, because they always have multiple offers.

Why would workers in this situation want or need to collectively bargain? Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by ryandrake on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:55PM (#11262735)
> The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

Having been through two tech downturns, and unemployed at points in both of them, I can guarantee you the job environment you describe is temporary.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:37PM (#11263449)
I went through the same downturns as you, and while the companies I worked for went out of business, I was still able to find new work easily - and STILL had trouble finding qualified people when I was hiring.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Apocryphon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:18PM (#11262930)
Why would workers in this situation want or need to collectively bargain? Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

Every skilled craftsman in every generation in the history of civilization has made this claim. Why do you think your position of privilege is any more lasting than that of weavers or threshers?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by smm2000 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @08:11PM (#11263942)
Most skilled trades lasted as skilled for thousands of years - way more than average working life. I do not need programming to last that long - just my working careers (35 years). Right now it looks like I will be fine.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by vacri on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:33PM (#11263426)
Threshing is about as far from a skilled craft as you can get whilst still having a name for the activity. You can describe how to thresh in less than a minute, and it's pure labouring drudge work.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Apocryphon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:49PM (#11263520)
I was referencing the Swing Riots.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:46PM (#11263503)
It may not be lasting. I long for the day that computers and software are advanced enough that software developers are no longer needed.

At that point, I will need to learn a new skill (and/or retire).

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:42PM (#11262629)
It depends a lot where you live in this little planet of ours.

I know quite a few countries where being a IT person won't matter one tiny thing.

It is job hunting and begging like everyone else.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by smm2000 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @08:13PM (#11263950)
What country is it? Shortage is global and exist in most countries. Unless you talk about Syria, Somalia or some other shithole.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:46AM (#11264865)
Almost all of them in tier 2 and 3, specially if living outside the capital.

There is no shortage as such, what there is, are the conditions that many companies offer, where sometimes is better to not even have a job than working endless hours almost for free.

And if you want names for countries, in Portugal unless you are living in Porto or Lisbon there is a very thin possibility to land a developer job. And there aren't enough companies in those cities to employ everyone.

A large majority has been forced to go away to other countries.

Edit: And those that are above 40 have even a harder time finding something as a developer, because you are supposed to just be a manager.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:57PM (#11263549)
As long as you have an internet connection and developer skills, you won't have to be begging.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:40AM (#11264846)
If you live in countries with higher life cost than traditional offshoring one, yes you will, unless you try to survive by the same amount of money.

When the location doesn't matter, it is all about the price.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by mooreds on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:58PM (#11262767)
> The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

For now. We've had a good few years.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tryitnow on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:29PM (#11263401)
I honestly don't think collective bargaining is the right approach. But professionalization of software engineering could lead to more long term stability. This is what doctors, lawyers, accountants, and actuaries do.

Professionalization also helps in screening potential employees. Right now it's kind of a crapshoot unless you have some firm informal signal that the potential hire is quality. Usually that signal is past employment at well-known firm with high standards.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:40PM (#11263464)
I don't know... as a self-taught developer who has built a successful career with no formal training or certification, I would really hate having any sort of formal licensing or certification system.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by zanny on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:28PM (#11262516)
> Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

If this is actually true, in any situation where this happens, you are being underpaid, because it implies the employer is getting more out of your employment arrangement than you are.

I know what you meant, it is just the semantics of economics are precarious and a lot of people would fight tooth and nail to be in a position to bargain for more because of a situation where an employer values the worker much more than the worker values the employer. You want equilibrium where the worker gets as much from the employer as they can, which is when employer and work both get as much out as one another.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:45PM (#11262652)
No employer could ever stay in business if they paid employees as much value as the employee brings in. A $100K engineer may work on features worth a million dollars a year, but that doesn't mean that an employer could pay that employee a million dollars because the employer has many overhead expenses -- office rent, paying for servers, marketing expenses, paying the sales guys that bring in the million dollars a year, paying other support employees, putting money in the bank to ride through lean times, investing in new products/features that may never make money, etc.

The only way an employee can be paid as much money as he brings in for the company is if he is self employed.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by geofft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:06PM (#11262835)
That doesn't seem implausible, but I generally prefer lower pay for stability (or other soft benefits like more political capital). There is an equilibrium salary at which it is just barely worth it for my employer to keep me; there is another lower salary where it it is obviously worth it for my employer to keep me, and therefore still worth it for them to keep me despite me being burned out for a week, or having a bad day and having yelled at someone important, or having just broken something in production, or whatever. Or despite them having a tight budget and a soft or hard requirement to cut payroll by some fixed amount, as seems to be the case here.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:40PM (#11262612)
Well, it usually starts out being more equal when the job first starts. Over time, however, your value goes up faster than you get raises (which is why you get the largest raise when you change jobs).
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:04PM (#11262288)
But unlike with service jobs that need to be done locally like a garbageman or electrician, what good does a union do against outsourcing jobs that can literally be done anywhere in the world?

Demanding to the employer: "Either keep our jobs in this country or we're going to stop working!", seems like it would just accelerate the offshoring.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by guelo on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:11PM (#11262360)
One leverage workers have is refusing to train their replacements. That's just cruel. IBM probably forces them to do it by threatening their severance package. But if there was collective refusal that power balance could be tipped.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gaius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:17PM (#11262413)
Or refuse to work there in the first place.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:32PM (#11262553)
That seems like pretty weak leverage, since refusing to transition the work won't stop the outsourcing. Even if a worker refuses to tell anyone how the Widget Orders get entered into the computer that orders them, someone can reverse engineer the process and figure it out.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by guard-of-terra on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:54PM (#11262721)
"Even if a worker refuses to tell anyone how the Widget Orders get entered into the computer that orders them, someone can reverse engineer the process and figure it out"

Someone could reverse engineer this, but they fired him too.

The process might be disrupted seriously. But - who would care?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:56PM (#11262746)
Someone could reverse engineer this, but they fired him too.

Or they fly him in from overseas and say "Hey, see that stack of forms? You are your team have to figure out how they get entered into the computer so we can make more Widgets"

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:44PM (#11262645)
It depends how protective the country laws are.

Here in Germany, Nokia was forced to either find alternative jobs for the employees of a plant they were closing down or to return to the local government all the subsidies that had gotten to built the plant.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tw04 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:21PM (#11263338)
That's because the German government apparently isn't bought and paid for by private corporations. Or at the very least not foreign ones.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by hockley on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:15PM (#11262402)
It would work if you organized globally. Masonry guilds did it 700 years ago.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pigpaws on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:06PM (#11262304)
the companies can be taxed to the point that it would cost the same to have an American employee or one in a foreign country. Companies want "globalism" but they don't want to pay for it.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:30PM (#11262532)
I don't see how that could work since companies would either contract out overseas work, or hire overseas workers through a subsidiary, so instead of IBM hiring 1,000 foreign call center workers, they'll pay "Joe's Call Center" a negotiated fee to run a call center, without IBM writing a single foreign paycheck.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Karunamon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:54PM (#11262720)
This sounds like a corner case in the hypothetical law, which is addressed by wording the law more carefully, not jettisoning the idea.

If every company is taxed heavily for outshoring work, it would be impossible for Joe's Call Center to employ 1,000 people and make enough profit for them to be competitive vs just hiring the workers directly.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:03PM (#11262805)
Joe's Call Center is incorporated in India and run by Indian management. IBM just hired them for Call Center services.

Unless you forsee taxing all companies for all oversees work, I don't see how that can work.

And I'm not sure how you can effectively tax a company for all overseas labor, for example, a computer is made up of thousands of components with thousands of suppliers, how can you tax IBM for the low-paid subcontracted labor that mines the minerals that are sold to a manufacturer that makes the plastic that's sold to another manufacturer to create the dielectric for capacitors that's sold to another subcontractor that makes the capacitors that are sold to another subcontrator that glues them on the big tape reels that are sold to another subcontractor that loads them into the pick and place machines that are used by another contractor to build a board that's used by another subcontractor to build a computer for IBM.

How far down the chain do you plan on going with taxation? It's easy to look at the simple case and say "Tax overseas workers!" but it's actually quite complicated to come up with rules do actually do so since there's no clear line that divides employees and non-employees. And if you draw that line, the company will move its workers to the otherside of the line.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Karunamon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @09:25PM (#11264235)
How far down the chain do you plan on going with taxation?

Start with the low-hanging fruit and target specific industries. Call center, direct marketing, etc. Perhaps a tax break for not tasking, directly or indirectly, an offshore company for any primary business need. (The law has the benefit of not being code - a judge can see through most avoidance schemes)

There's probably a nontrivial healthcare cost benefit in reducing the collective country's blood pressure from being able to talk to someone they can understand when they need help..

(Only sort of kidding about that last bit...)

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by IncRnd on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:37PM (#11262584)
All that would do is move more work overseas.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by hiram112 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @10:15PM (#11264432)
I hear this all the time. If it could have been sent overseas, it would have been already.

The reason H1Bs are popular is it allows cheap workers whom can be managed in the US onsite. The management that uses H1Bs doesn't want to move the whole department overseas; if they did, they themselves wouldn't be needed. Executives grow their departments as big as possible as a political goal.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by parfe on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:00PM (#11262256)
>Until the tech industry wakes up to the reality that they _are_ labor

Never going to happen. The great conceit of the tech world peons is believing they're above the simple garbage man or postal worker. After all they create such value. Admitting a union would help acknowledges they're not special.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by oldmanjay on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:02PM (#11262272)
When you feel like you can sum up a few million opinions as the result of a stupidity that you personally do not suffer, the odds that you are correct in your assessment approach zero.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by parfe on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:11PM (#11262359)
Programmers eagerly work in EA style sweatshops producing games and other software with massive unpaid overtime, or count themselves lucky that IBM kept them for just a few extra months to train their replacements.

IT workers could demand protection from the same abuses that custodians and delivery drivers fought for and earned decades ago. But then the industry might need to admit their collars aren't as white as they pretend.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Chlorus on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:26PM (#11262493)
> But then the industry might need to admit their collars aren't as white as they pretend.

You're fucking insane if you think the plight of the average programmer is anywhere near what custodians go through. I used to work for one of these IBM-like offshoring firms before I knew better and the quality of their work is simply garbage(there's some good people in there of course). For example, I was called in to troubleshoot a faulty URL - I asked them for it; they linked me to a localhost page. Other joys included network engineers who didn't know what port SSH runs on and Java programmers who literally copy-pasted straight from the web.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by untog on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:18PM (#11262430)
Some programmers do that, most don't.

But more to the point, if you desire a work/life balance you absolutely can find a programming job that will allow it. It'll pay less than the unpaid overtime job, but it exists, and will still pay more than most occupations.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pattisapu on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:58PM (#11263202)
In the US most such programmers are likely exempt from the overtime requirements of the FLSA [1].

[1] http://www.dol.gov/whd/overtime/fs17e_computer.pdf

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by draw_down on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:20PM (#11262443)
On the other hand, anti-vaxxers exist. Many of them.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by levemi on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:19PM (#11262437)
I've never met anyone nor worked with anyone who thought they were better than someone else because of their job. Maybe that's something you want to believe, but it isn't true. A great deal of the engineers I work with in the bay area are socially conscious to the tech sector's impact on the community. And really they're harmed by it too, a software engineer can't afford to buy a house either.

If what you really believed was true there's no way that someone like Barbara Lee could be in office with such huge wins every two years when so many of her constituents are the same people that work in the area you think is so terrible. Why are you even posting on HN? This is a technical news site.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gist on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:36PM (#11262577)
I am not a programmer (although I can program) but I do a fairly important job at the company (that I own) that takes a great deal of thought, training and experience. So yes I do feel that I am "better" than a postal worker or a garbage man a job that doesn't take a great deal of thought, training, intelligence or experience or quite frankly in most (but not all cases) motivation. Of course there are people who are garbage men or postal workers that are there because of luck not intelligence or effort, but there are also people who grew up middle class like I did that aren't doing anything significant in their career either.

This idea that all of us are equal (we are not even factoring in luck) is really just a modern day PC version of the way the world is not.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by fluxquanta on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:56PM (#11262747)
I mean no offense by this, but how old are you? I ask because I used to believe the same thing, but as time passed I realized that being special and having specialized knowledge are not one and the same. Very few of us are truly special.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gist on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:01PM (#11262785)
Well I'd rather not say how old I am but I will say that I am not young by HN standards.

The issue is not whether one is special but special relative to someone who does that type of menial repetitive job.

And just that I think I have more capabilities than the average garbage man or postal worker. And I grew up in a time when it was ok to say something like that by the way.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Retra on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:02AM (#11264745)
Well, you can always move your goal posts...
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by AnimalMuppet on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:21PM (#11262958)
There's "better", and there's better.

Are you better in terms of intrinsic worth as a human being? No, they're just as human as you are.

Are you better in terms of physical strength or stamina, as mattwood asked? No.

Are you better morally than them? (Remember that "morally" includes not just overt acts like theft or murder. It also includes things like pride.)

Or is it merely, as you said in your reply to mattwood, that you think you're better mentally? (And perhaps in terms of achieving financial results.) But of all the possible axes of measurement, why did you pick that one to be the definition of "better"? (Cynically, I wonder if you didn't pick it because it's the one you win on...)

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Retra on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:07AM (#11264761)
"Are you better morally than them?"

Yes. And I really don't see why you'd bring up pride, since if that's something that comes to your mind when you think about moral superiority, then you're barking up the wrong tree with the rest of 'em.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by vchynarov on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:48PM (#11263150)
This is such a nice explanation I've never heard before and I too have been guilty of thinking like this.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by matwood on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:55PM (#11262741)
You're better in what way? Thinking? Are you physically better than the garbage man that is outside in 100 degree heat all day picking up your trash?

As an aside, I always leave the garbage man Gatorades because frankly the job looks like it sucks.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by yardie on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:43PM (#11263120)
LOL. I'm friends with sons of a garbage man. They are highly unionised with a bulletproof health plan, pension plan, college savings plan, etc. And if the city tries to take away even one of those things... ever see trash spontaneously combust when its been left to sit in its own juices for weeks.

The guys that haul trash have got it exactly right. It's a hard job that no one wants to do so they know their worth and when they demand they get it. If I lose Facebook for an hour its a bummer. If the trash isn't hauled away its a health hazard.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gist on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:52PM (#11263167)
> so they know their worth and when they demand they get it

> It's a hard job that no one wants to do so they know their worth

Well not exactly. They have a union in most cities and some of those jobs the pay is so good there is a waiting line to get the job actually. And since they can strike in many contracts they have quite a bit of leverage (what you are saying).

Link below is without overtime pay. In some cases with overtime the pay can easily be 6 figure. I can assure you that there are many takers for this job, although perhaps where you live that might not be the case of course.

Examples:

New York:

http://salarygenius.com/ny/new-york/salary/garbage-man-salar...

Cincinnati:

http://salarygenius.com/oh/cincinnati/salary/garbage-man-sal...

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gist on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:02PM (#11262795)
Yes in a thinking way.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by dredmorbius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:00PM (#11262778)
So, while I find your attitude rather repgnant, the truth is that you just refuted the parent comment's claim. Which, quite frankly, isn't hard to do (I've encountered the attitude frequently myself, and occasionally have to check myself from adopting it).

But the HN Hivemind doesn't want to hear this, apparently.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gist on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:05PM (#11262826)
Well what exactly is "repugnant" about what I said?
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by dredmorbius on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:46AM (#11264864)
It's one thing to recognise abilities and capabilities. Or even to volunteer that somebody else as a greater human, particularly than yourself.

To self-nominate yourself as "more worthy" than others seems a road down a slippery and ugly path.

Then again, my worthy ancestors have fought on both sides of numerous bloody disagreements over this very concept.

More generally, and I mean this quite generally, I tend to find externally imposed tests far preferable to internally imposed ones. Human eugenics is internally imposed. The incestuous processes of party politics and academic mutual admiration societies strike me as similar. Likewise, to venture into more locally fraught, if less literally gut-spilling ground, defenses of Web or application layout and design which concern themselves with everything but what actual users actually need.

There's also the possibility that someday you'll find yourself less able, or perhaps just recognised and rewarded, than you are now. Will a deaf, or blinded, or crippled, or sick, or depressed, or senile you be less worthy than you are now? Be careful how you answer that, because the loads imposed should you find yourself there are all the more crushing.

Go out there. Do your fucking job, and do it well, for as long as you can.

But let others tell you you're a good person.

It's one of the better ways to be one.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by iofj on Thursday March 10, 2016 @10:08PM (#11264406)
You just told a lot of people that there's no difference between them and a garbagemen. I think you're pushing the point that unless you own a company, you're not "equal" to the people that do (and one assumes you don't mean that employees are better than entrepreneurs).

It doesn't even matter whether you're right or not but you can't attack people's self-worth and expect to be rewarded for it.

Sort of like if I were to say that all company owners and management are fraudulent exploitative criminals.

Were you expecting upvotes ?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Retra on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:04AM (#11264751)
That sounds like the opposite of what they were saying.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by thenewwazoo on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:06PM (#11262298)
I disagree - I think that the right-wing opinion machine has been successfully busting unions and scapegoating labor for so long that the tech industry doesn't see the value-add of the union itself. I view it a bit like the anti-vax movement. Nobody today is dying of polio, so the necessity and urgency are lost. (And Americans are spectacularly bad at learning from history because exceptionalism)
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by clarkmoody on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:49PM (#11262686)
> bad at learning from history

I assume you're referring to the current fascination with socialism? You know, that great political innovation that lead to a hundred million murders in the 20th century.

Sorry, couldn't resist.

You should look into the history of unions. You might be surprised at their non-progressive / non-egalitarian origins. You don't need a "right-wing opinion machine" to besmirch the name of unions; you simply have to look at the long history of state-union corruption.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by yardie on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:50PM (#11263155)
Socialism did what? Some despot puts Socialist in the state name and that makes it socialist? So North Korea is a shining example of democracy because it's right there Democratic People's Republic.

Does your 100million lives include the many millions the USA has helped see to their deaths?

I couldn't resist.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by clarkmoody on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:49AM (#11264876)
Don't get the idea that I'm defending the US government's actions in any way, since I disagree with most of its actions, especially in foreign policy.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Chlorus on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:36PM (#11262573)
> (And Americans are spectacularly bad at learning from history because exceptionalism)

Because the union scandals of the 60s and 70s never happened, of course.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by gaius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:15PM (#11262393)
The funny thing is companies are quite honest and open about this; they call you "a resource" for a reason...
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by nosuchthing on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:07PM (#11262319)
Has anyone ever tried an open source guild / jobs / recruiting / organized labor software system?

Maybe a mix of Glass Door with Adhocracy or Liquid Feedback

https://liqd.net/software.html

http://dev.liquidfeedback.org/trac/lf/

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tosseraccount on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:50PM (#11262689)
Doctors have the AMA bargain for rules in statehouses and Congress. Same with lawyers and the American Bar Association. The trial lawyers are particularly adept at lobbying and "campaign contributions". I'm pretty sure people in these professions consider themselves pretty special.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Apocryphon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:22PM (#11262963)
Perhaps if there's so much resistance to the idea to an IT union, we should buff up the IEEE so it can be a "professional association" on the level of the AMA or the ABA, at least.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by obrero on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:09PM (#11262336)
I used to work in IT at an investment bank. We got no overtime, and had to work all hours - 9 hours a day, sometimes starting at 7 AM, weekend work, pages in the middle of the night.

The electricians all left at 5 PM. They belonged to the IBEW and had pension plans, job security with seniority etc. IT used to bitch about how they'd leave at 5 PM when we had to start doing some work. They would have stayed past 5 PM, but the super wealthy bank would have had to pay them (not us) overtime, and they almost never did that.

The other IT people would also moan about how stupid they were compared to us. How stupid are they? They leave at 5 PM, or get overtime if they do, they have job security, they don't have to work all hours or are paid well if they do any how, they had pensions and job security based on seniority. Who were the real fools?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by mason240 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:21PM (#11262457)
To be fair, I would much rather have a 401k than a pension.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by draw_down on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:21PM (#11262456)
Yes, that sounds like tech workers for sure. (Everyone besides me is so stupid, which is why I work twice as hard as them and earn less.)
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by natrius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:40PM (#11262615)
Why shouldn't the global economy seek to make labor fungible? Why shouldn't Indians and Hungarians have the same opportunities to work that I do? I think putting other people who are trying to produce value at a disadvantage for personal gain is a bad thing.

Yes, some people get to buy new yachts when they stop buying labor from American workers. We could prevent them from buying labor from other workers, or we could do something about the yachts.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tosseraccount on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:53PM (#11262713)
Highest paid people in our society are doctors and lawyers. Are there special laws to subsidize importing them or new laws to deregulate these profession?

Let's try these first, see how it works.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by natrius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:00PM (#11262776)
We should not emulate the legal protectionism that those industries have pursued. The legally imposed shortages in these industries raise prices and make everyone else poorer. I want no part in that. The aim of our industry should be to make everyone else wealthier by producing zero marginal cost goods that solve people's problems.

We should celebrate when problems become cheaper to solve.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tosseraccount on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:59PM (#11263560)
Interesting take on it you have. What can American middle class workers do about stagnant real wages? Productivity is up, but it's been a while since we've had a raise.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by natrius on Thursday March 10, 2016 @07:11PM (#11263620)
If you believe that too much of the gains from progress have accrued to capital, you can fight to redistribute those gains. Protectionism is redistribution too, it's just poorly directed.

Personally, I'd rather see the wealthy fund more public goods. Few people are struggling, and we should support them. Other than that, let's pursue abundance together instead of trying to adjust relative wealth.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tosseraccount on Thursday March 10, 2016 @08:12PM (#11263946)
I just don't think this approach has worked very well.

You have an interesting take on it; I'll respect that and leave it at that.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pavanky on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:17PM (#11262919)
This kind of arguments make me a bit apprehensive. People work in the tech industry are mostly OK with globalization and free markets as long as it does not affect their jobs. I wonder how many people wanting collective bargaining for the tech industry would be OK with increased costs that come with collective bargaining in the manufacturing sector.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by at-fates-hands on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:15PM (#11262399)
>> The threat of H1-B applications being denied is either laughable or [there aren't enough of them anyway] depending on who you ask.

The ironic part is we have close to 10 million people out of work (not including those who have permanently fallen out of the workforce) - you think at least some of those people could fill those jobs?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by golergka on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:29PM (#11263018)
Have you tried hiring engineers?

Most of the applicants would provide negative value if hired.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by product50 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:58PM (#11263197)
It is worth noting that the companies IBM is competing for IT Services type work is TCS and Infosys for whom most of the workers are in India. It is difficult to see how IBM will be successful in the IT services industry if they don't adopt a similar low employee cost model.