News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:11PM (#11262357)
The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

I have worked for a few companies that have gone out of business. Looking for work afterwards is mostly a screening job, picking the work I want to do out of the various offers. Every time, I have been hired for more money than I was making before (it is common knowledge that changing jobs is the best way to get raises)

It isn't like I am some hotshot developer, either. I am not a networking type person, so all of my contacts are just people I have worked with at previous shops. The reason it is so easy to find work is because there are simply more jobs available than qualified workers.

I know this because I have been on the other side, too (trying to hire people). It is really hard to find quality developers, because they always have multiple offers.

Why would workers in this situation want or need to collectively bargain? Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by ryandrake on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:55PM (#11262735)
> The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

Having been through two tech downturns, and unemployed at points in both of them, I can guarantee you the job environment you describe is temporary.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:37PM (#11263449)
I went through the same downturns as you, and while the companies I worked for went out of business, I was still able to find new work easily - and STILL had trouble finding qualified people when I was hiring.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Apocryphon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:18PM (#11262930)
Why would workers in this situation want or need to collectively bargain? Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

Every skilled craftsman in every generation in the history of civilization has made this claim. Why do you think your position of privilege is any more lasting than that of weavers or threshers?

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by smm2000 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @08:11PM (#11263942)
Most skilled trades lasted as skilled for thousands of years - way more than average working life. I do not need programming to last that long - just my working careers (35 years). Right now it looks like I will be fine.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by vacri on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:33PM (#11263426)
Threshing is about as far from a skilled craft as you can get whilst still having a name for the activity. You can describe how to thresh in less than a minute, and it's pure labouring drudge work.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Apocryphon on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:49PM (#11263520)
I was referencing the Swing Riots.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:46PM (#11263503)
It may not be lasting. I long for the day that computers and software are advanced enough that software developers are no longer needed.

At that point, I will need to learn a new skill (and/or retire).

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:42PM (#11262629)
It depends a lot where you live in this little planet of ours.

I know quite a few countries where being a IT person won't matter one tiny thing.

It is job hunting and begging like everyone else.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by smm2000 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @08:13PM (#11263950)
What country is it? Shortage is global and exist in most countries. Unless you talk about Syria, Somalia or some other shithole.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:46AM (#11264865)
Almost all of them in tier 2 and 3, specially if living outside the capital.

There is no shortage as such, what there is, are the conditions that many companies offer, where sometimes is better to not even have a job than working endless hours almost for free.

And if you want names for countries, in Portugal unless you are living in Porto or Lisbon there is a very thin possibility to land a developer job. And there aren't enough companies in those cities to employ everyone.

A large majority has been forced to go away to other countries.

Edit: And those that are above 40 have even a harder time finding something as a developer, because you are supposed to just be a manager.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:57PM (#11263549)
As long as you have an internet connection and developer skills, you won't have to be begging.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by pjmlp on Friday March 11, 2016 @12:40AM (#11264846)
If you live in countries with higher life cost than traditional offshoring one, yes you will, unless you try to survive by the same amount of money.

When the location doesn't matter, it is all about the price.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by mooreds on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:58PM (#11262767)
> The difference is that as skilled tech workers, when we are laid off we can find new work as fast as we want to.

For now. We've had a good few years.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by tryitnow on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:29PM (#11263401)
I honestly don't think collective bargaining is the right approach. But professionalization of software engineering could lead to more long term stability. This is what doctors, lawyers, accountants, and actuaries do.

Professionalization also helps in screening potential employees. Right now it's kind of a crapshoot unless you have some firm informal signal that the potential hire is quality. Usually that signal is past employment at well-known firm with high standards.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @06:40PM (#11263464)
I don't know... as a self-taught developer who has built a successful career with no formal training or certification, I would really hate having any sort of formal licensing or certification system.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by zanny on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:28PM (#11262516)
> Every place I have worked needs me more than I need them.

If this is actually true, in any situation where this happens, you are being underpaid, because it implies the employer is getting more out of your employment arrangement than you are.

I know what you meant, it is just the semantics of economics are precarious and a lot of people would fight tooth and nail to be in a position to bargain for more because of a situation where an employer values the worker much more than the worker values the employer. You want equilibrium where the worker gets as much from the employer as they can, which is when employer and work both get as much out as one another.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by Johnny555 on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:45PM (#11262652)
No employer could ever stay in business if they paid employees as much value as the employee brings in. A $100K engineer may work on features worth a million dollars a year, but that doesn't mean that an employer could pay that employee a million dollars because the employer has many overhead expenses -- office rent, paying for servers, marketing expenses, paying the sales guys that bring in the million dollars a year, paying other support employees, putting money in the bank to ride through lean times, investing in new products/features that may never make money, etc.

The only way an employee can be paid as much money as he brings in for the company is if he is self employed.

Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by geofft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @05:06PM (#11262835)
That doesn't seem implausible, but I generally prefer lower pay for stability (or other soft benefits like more political capital). There is an equilibrium salary at which it is just barely worth it for my employer to keep me; there is another lower salary where it it is obviously worth it for my employer to keep me, and therefore still worth it for them to keep me despite me being burned out for a week, or having a bad day and having yelled at someone important, or having just broken something in production, or whatever. Or despite them having a tight budget and a soft or hard requirement to cut payroll by some fixed amount, as seems to be the case here.
Re:What the IBM Layoffs Look Like by cortesoft on Thursday March 10, 2016 @04:40PM (#11262612)
Well, it usually starts out being more equal when the job first starts. Over time, however, your value goes up faster than you get raises (which is why you get the largest raise when you change jobs).