News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jtchang on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:09PM (#9875599)
It is always amazing for me to read about Nintendo's history, especially during the 80s and when they released the NES. It is even more amazing when you think about everything that has changed about gaming since then.

It is kind of sad to me that the newer generation does not get to grow up playing old school games like Final Fantasy and Zelda. Some of the games these days really focus too much on graphics and not gameplay. I felt a lot of games back then were much harder and more unforgiving than games today.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by zobzu on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:12PM (#9875605)
i find graphics and environment are actually much nicer in games with "no 3d engine".

they're not nearly as detailed, but they're just more artistic/pleasant, as if more time was spent in that direction to "compensate" for the lack of detail

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by TeMPOraL on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:05AM (#9877344)
2D games are usually more detailed than their 3D counterpart.

I was thinking a long time about why I prefer 2D games to 3D ones, at least in terms of visuals. The conclusion I reached is that it's because technological limitations you get to see in graphics. Models are made from low-poly meshes, and you can (still) see the straight edges where you know they should be curved. Textures are too low-detail; stand next to a wall or close to any entity in a 3D game and you'll always see the texture upscaling, lack of detail.

Most of 3D games try to go for "realistic" visuals, but they never cross the uncanny valley. 2D games seem to look prettier to me because they don't set up expectations - so as long as they have consistent art style, the brain doesn't complain much. Moreover, in 2D productions artists usually have full control of every pixel displayed on screen, so the art can be (and usually is) very detailed. The limits that 2D environment places are more strict than limits of available technology, so your experience doesn't get ruined by jagged edges and texture upscaling.

That's why I still like the original StarCraft more than StarCraft 2 and think that introducing 3D graphics was a bad decision - the original art style looked serious, dark, had an atmosphere. SC2's style is dominated by clunky 3D models which look more like child's toys than serious hardware. But then again maybe this was made on purpose - the plot of SC2 seems about as serious as the graphics, which is not at all.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by chopman on Monday July 13, 2015 @08:08AM (#9877577)
On the other hand, 3d games that don't try to go for the realistic visuals like Okami or Mario 64 itself look gorgeous.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by digi_owl on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:11PM (#9875808)
the whole 3D thing also seems to complicate controls to all hell.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:43PM (#9875912)
Part of the reason Nintendo was not hungry to jump on the 3D bandwagon. Most of the 3D games on PS1 launch were very hazardous, messy and bland. If it wasn't for the technology prowess of the day nobody would have bought them.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eatfish on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:30AM (#9876584)
Actually, Nintendo were releasing 3D games even before the PS1. Starfox was the first poly 3D game from Nintendo and was released in 1992, at least a year, maybe more, before the PS1.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by digi_owl on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:08AM (#9878553)
Lets not confuse a 2D game using 3D models with one that allow free(-ish) movement in 3D space.

Starfox was a rail shooter that used 3D models rather than scaled sprites.

the more complicated stuff came with third person shooters and similar. Where you either had fixed cameras, thus having the controls shift between "cuts", or the camera on its own control (tap your head and rub your tummy style).

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by mreiland on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:02AM (#9876675)
I also recall a 3D pacman game on the SNES that was hella fun.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by hartator on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:32AM (#9876409)
Mario Kart N64, Super Mario N64 and Goldeneye N64? All 3D game not made by sony at the time of the PS1? Maybe the best in the world? 3D is awesome when made correctly and not trying to reproduce a movie.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by serf on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:35AM (#9876595)
It's somewhat amusing to think of the N64 being cited when the parents replied to are about 3D environments complicating the control schemes.

Most of the people who encountered the N64 did not know how to hold the controller at first glance. This was made worse by the fact that practically every game has a different idea about how the controller was to be used. Nintendo had to settle a court-case by distributing gloves to players complaining of friction injuries.[0] .

This was mostly because developers didn't know how to deal with the control schemes of 3D environments very well, and Nintendo was planning for what they considered to be needed in the future : more controls.

There's very likely a reason that the M shape was never used for controllers again, however it did leave a lasting legacy in the form of trigger buttons (not shoulder buttons), which are now practically a universal controller feature.

[0] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nintendo_64_controller

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by david-given on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:16AM (#9877877)
I really liked the N64 controller --- I still think it's one of the most comfortable ever. The asymmetrical shape when using it analogue mode felt really nice in the hands. I've never felt happy with the dual-stick PS ones.

I'm pretty sure I saw someone being vapourised by one in an episode of Lexx, too.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by nsxwolf on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:21AM (#9878199)
I've always felt like I need 3 hands to use it. It is like 2 controllers welded together. In more complex games I have to constantly change my grip from the outside left to the middle position and I've just never gotten used to it.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by david-given on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:24PM (#9879107)
...there are games which use the analogue stick and the D-pad? They shouldn't do that --- you're supposed to hold it either by the two outside wings, with d-pad and buttons; or by the middle and the right-hand wing, with analogue stick and buttons. Using the analogue stick and the d-pad makes no sense, for exactly the reasons you say.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:09PM (#9879412)
I kinda recall FPS using the paddle that way. d-pad for position, analog for aiming.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by david-given on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:07PM (#9880286)
Okay, let me rephrase: the N64 controller has designed for people with at most two hands. Use the d-pad with the left hand and the analogue stick and trigger with the right hand is fine. Requiring the use of the buttons as well is not.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:45PM (#9881913)
Oh right, constant switching must be pretty bad.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by david-given on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:15PM (#9880348)
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:16PM (#9879049)
I couldn't use the right hand buttons to save my life. Big low, tiny high, counter intuitive to my fingers.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by mcphage on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:48AM (#9877491)
> it did leave a lasting legacy in the form of trigger buttons

Also analog sticks, which are even more important.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by BFay on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:40AM (#9877980)
There were occasionally minigames in Mario Party or similar games that required you to rotate the control stick as quickly as you could - the stick was not padded, so you could really hurt your thumb (or the palm of your hand, if you chose to use that).

I'd imagine the friction lawsuit had something to do with that.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:11AM (#9876535)
Come on the N64 came far later, and that was my point. And it was all over the place how Mario 64 gameplay was tailored, camera viewpoint and everything. Many games at the PS1 launch had the cam lost in translation somewhere between polygons, or just point at a weird angle.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jonkratz on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:20PM (#9875836)
What are some good examples of games without a 3d engine? Your comment makes me feel like I'd like to check them out.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by greyskull on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:46PM (#9875922)
Usually smaller scale indie games are the ones doing it, big shot studios feel the need to go ham on graphics. Here's a handful I managed to scrape together from memory and quick searches, but it's easy to find more.

  - Shovel Knight
  - Dust: An Elysian Tail
  - Hotline Miami
  - Don't Starve
  - Spelunky
  - Braid
  - Papers, Please
  - Sunless Sea
There _has_ been quite a few retro-style, pixelated graphics style games to come out of that sector for one reason or another, but ignoring that, the games tend to have a more stylized feel to them. Limited fidelity means the games need to more creative, but I think that tends to just come with works of passion from smaller studios.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by DiabloD3 on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:26PM (#9876033)
Let's throw in everything Way Forward is doing as well, such as the Shantae series of games.

It's been awhile since I've played a sidescroller that warranted multiple playthroughs, but I picked up Shantae: Risky's Revenge up in one of the HumbleBundles, and I loved the hell out of it.

One part Castlevania, one part Megaman, one part Metroid.

It was so good I went out and bought an XBox One controller to play it further, even though I don't own an XBox One. Side note: apparently its the best PC gamepad you can find that has a good D-Pad; the D-Pad is probably the best one I've used since my childhood.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by TJSomething on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:06PM (#9876148)
Oh wow. It's actually plus-shaped. I've been looking for a PC controller with a plus-shaped D-pad for a while. They've been rare for a few years, due to Nintendo's patent on plus-shaped D-pads, but that expired in 2005.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by DiabloD3 on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:13AM (#9876696)
Yup, and I actually had bought a XB360 gamepad... the D-Pad was mushy and horrid, returned it immediately for the XBOne one and it's a well built solid controller.

Also, I don't need to put batteries in if I run it off wired USB, so theres also that.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by ekianjo on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:40PM (#9876251)
You forgot Limbo. Yeah, not pure 2D per se, but it's a clear 2D game at heart (just like Another World).
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by nightpool on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:48AM (#9876475)
Been enjoying the hell out of Nidhogg recently. Some other notable ones are Mark of the Ninja and Bastion (maybe? I don't know if you're counting 2.5d games. included it because its absolutely, stunningly, beautiful. seriously worth looking in to)
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by kriro on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:36AM (#9876862)
Nidhogg is amazing :) My goto answer for addicting 2d game is Binding of Isaac.

I own a bunch of retro consoles and games, pretty much all by Nintendo and have always wondered if there's an interest in "let's play" of an original Legend of Zelda and so forth (I'd guess most are done via emulator but that just doesn't feel right to me :P). Would require buying a hardware capture device that's Linux compatible but those are 1in the 50-200 Euro range. I'm feeling like it would be something I'd have a blast with but not sure.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eru on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:50PM (#9876097)
Also, all kinds of strategy games. Eg Europa Universalis 4, any Civilization game (even though they may look 3d these days, it's not why you play them).
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Tomte on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:34AM (#9876420)
Re: EU IV, I'd really like to get into it, but the in-game tutorial is very, very bad. I've had several tries over the last year, but always gave up way to soon.

Is there a practical intro somewhere? One that allows me to actually play a game, even losing it badly, but not encounter half a dozen "huh, I have no idea what that means and what I should do now" situations every turn.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eru on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:38AM (#9877132)
You could try some videos as bookwormAT suggested, alternatively (or in parallel) you can just play as one of the easy nations (Ottomans, Spain, Portugal, France, etc) and blunder about. The Ottomans are nicknamed Easymans by the fans.

That's how people learn Dwarfortress, which is even less penetrable. Remember, losing is fun.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Tomte on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:12AM (#9878583)
I have nothing against losing, but the UI has dozens, if not hundreds of buttons at any time, most very inconspicuous (oh, that's a button?!), and no way to guess what they are for. It's... frustrating.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eru on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:05AM (#9883136)
Oh, that's true. Though they do show you a bunch of the basic features in the official tutorial, don't they?
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bookwormAT on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:03AM (#9877058)
There is no actual tutorial, sorry. The best way to learn how to play EU is to watch a tutorial on youtube.

It's worth it, though...

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by ekianjo on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:39PM (#9876246)
> any Civilization game

Exactly, it's a good example of a game that uses 3D only for effect, without incorporating it at all in the gameplay.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eropple on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:22AM (#9876566)
I'm pretty sure every one of those games except Papers, Please and Hotline Miami, and maybe even those because I don't know much about HaXe or Game Maker, is made with a 3D engine (Unity, XNA/MonoGame, whatever). I mean, you namedrop Sunless Sea, but they do an absolute ton with 3D effects to create the desired look of the game.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by mutagen on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:50AM (#9876641)
Yes, they're made with a 3D engine because the platforms and the widely available frameworks are all 3D. However, the games themselves, the gameplay, and the primary aesthetics of the games are not 3D and would be just as home in a 2D or 2.5D engine and hardware with at most minor changes to the visual look and feel of the game.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by debaserab2 on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:27AM (#9876723)
These games are fully 3d modeled and in no way a 2d game. Their gameplay may be portable to a 2d platform, but they are not 2d. The is a significant difference in terms of development.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by drrotmos on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:03AM (#9877057)
When talking about controls though, how different it is to develop is not a factor. These games are controlled as 2d games.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by cosarara97 on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:24AM (#9877409)
3d modeled? Shovel Knight, Dust: An Elysian Tail and Braid all use 2d sprites, not models.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by balls187 on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:09AM (#9876328)
Terraria.

The new content update 1.3 is boss.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Rooster61 on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:44AM (#9878371)
You left out Axiom Verge. Fantastic game in my opinion with really nice looking environments, and all the more impressive considering one guy coded EVERYTHING in the game, including the graphics. The tileset is a pretty accurate tribute to Metroid/Super Metroid
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by juandopazo on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:29AM (#9876401)
Also, Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet. Not 100% 2D, but close in that spirit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9r6J0b-2BI
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by gambiting on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:26AM (#9877104)
Literally every single game you named was made using a 3D engine. They just went for a 2D top-down view and pixelated graphics,but internally they are all rendered using OpenGL/DX and orthographic cameras.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by toxicFork on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:37AM (#9877127)
OpenGL/DX are not engines, they are graphics APIs.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by gambiting on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:44AM (#9877145)
Well of course, but like I said - the games are made using 3D engines,which use OpenGL/DX to render the scenes. The reason why I point it out is that in both of these APIs if you want to make a 2D game you still operate within 3D space - you just use orthographic cameras and have your Z coordinate set to 0.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by TeMPOraL on Monday July 13, 2015 @06:54AM (#9877318)
This is getting a bit pedantic. Yes, even in DirectX the 2D API was deprecated in favour of 3D one. But the source of a difference isn't the flavour of API you use, it's whether you go full 3D, with polygon meshes, (usually) trying to be "realistic" vs. going with a single perspective and animated sprites.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by kgabis on Monday July 13, 2015 @06:44AM (#9877292)
It's irrelevant, some of those games were ported to other systems where they don't use OpenGL/DX. It's an implementation detail.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by gambiting on Monday July 13, 2015 @06:51AM (#9877312)
You seem to be very keen on holding to that OpenGL/DX reference, and I am not fully sure why, it's not relevant to the point I was making. Maybe I should have just said "these games are rendered in 3D space, using 3D engines, and APIs which are used for 3D work normally, so they are not 2D games in the same way SNES games were 2D". Would that be better?
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by kgabis on Monday July 13, 2015 @08:14AM (#9877612)
Yes, we get it, but it's still wrong and irrelevant. Not all of those games use 3D engines (Shovel Knight?) and I'm pretty sure not all of them even use a 3D API. But even when they do, they're still 2D games with 2D based gameplay, 2D collision detection etc.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eru on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:44AM (#9877144)
Spelunky was made in GameMaker, no 3d there.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by csense on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:03PM (#9876140)
- Factorio (a great game for the HN audience): http://www.factorio.com/

- A Valley Without Wind (I like Valley 2): https://arcengames.com/a-valley-without-wind-1-2/

- Rimworld: http://rimworldgame.com/

- Starbound: http://playstarbound.com/

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by squidbidness on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:30PM (#9876047)
Yep, Indie games are a gold mine for great/unconventional art and design, as well as original gameplay mechanics. Some ones I've enjoyed: Limbo, Thomas Was Alone, Cave Story, Braid, FEZ.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Bahamut on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:43AM (#9878360)
One game that came out recently to a lot of acclaim is Ori and the Blind Forest.

There are also games like Super Meat Boy and Binding of Isaac.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by icebraining on Monday July 13, 2015 @04:16AM (#9876949)
Not exactly recent, but the 2D Oddworld games (Abe's Oddysee and Exoddus) were some of the best games I've played.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by sneak on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:12PM (#9875606)
> It is kind of sad to me that the newer generation does not get to grow up playing old school games like Final Fantasy and Zelda.

What makes you think they don't?

http://www.amazon.com/Classic-USB-Super-Nintendo-Controller-...

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eswat on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:32PM (#9875675)
They have access to the games we played but that doesn’t mean they actually will. Many of these have “not aged well” and it’s really hard for the newer generation to look past the graphics, sound and gameplay and have fun with them compared to what you can play today.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by lfowles on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:51PM (#9876101)
> it’s really hard for the newer generation to look past the graphics, sound and gameplay and have fun with them compared to what you can play today.

Heh, so basically "look past everything and you'll have fun!"

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by joshschreuder on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:05PM (#9875788)
I do somewhat agree, and the trends in modern gaming (generally speaking, making games easier or hold the player's hand more) make older games a tough ask for today's generation.

I'm susceptible to this myself, I played through the Resident Evil 1 remake on the Gamecube when I was probably 12-13 and managed to beat it a couple of times. I tried to pick it up again recently with the newest remaster and found it brutally difficult (as I suspect it always was, but I feel sensitive to it in an age where CoD regenerating heath and cover systems make games very easy)

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bphogan on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:25PM (#9875859)
When the Ducktales Remaster came out there were so many younger reviewers that were giving the game low scores because it was hard. And it is hard.

But then, let's see these kids play the NES version of the Ninja Turtles game. You know, the one with the dam level where you have to diffuse the bombs.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Bahamut on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:59PM (#9875952)
Or the original Ninja Gaidens, Silver Surfer, Battletoads...gamers have it easier these days.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by pcunite on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:33PM (#9876053)
Ahhh Ninja Gaiden ... very cruel to my three day rental. I think I beat one of them.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by gknoy on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:33AM (#9876849)
Oh god. I bought an NES to play Final Fantasy, and it came with Ninja Gaiden. I never managed to beat it, and always got stuck on something like the third-to-last level. Rarely have I played so frustrating a game.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by tragic on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:44AM (#9877476)
I remember playing the Terminator game on the Master System when I was about 8, getting so frustrated by it that I rolled off the couch and put my back out for several weeks.

I got hold of it recently to see if it was really as hard as I remembered.

It was harder.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Bahamut on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:55PM (#9879322)
You probably got stuck on 6-2, the stage with the damned bird from hell that would spawn even if you killed it one pixel away.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by 2muchcoffeeman on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:23AM (#9876821)
I was a champion at the dam level. I don't recall ever completing the game though.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Apocryphon on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:21AM (#9876368)
The biggest game with the younger generation this days is Minecraft, which is hardly well known for its graphics.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by byuu on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:05AM (#9876312)
This may just be me, but I feel like 2D ages so much more gracefully than 3D. Especially the PS1 era.

I can look at a game like Tales of Phantasia and bask in how beautiful everything looks, even at 256x224 on that limited hardware. I can even go way back to the '80s on PC-88 titles like Undine and have a lot of fun.

But I load up Grandia and ... oh dear. I know it's a great game, everyone says it's wonderful, but it looks absolutely dreadful.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by gambiting on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:35AM (#9877123)
I think the early 3D systems were the worst for holding up. I can load up pretty much anything that was released on NES, SNES, GameBoy, MegaDrive, and still have an absolute blast. I am sure that if you gave Super Mario Bros to an 8 year old now, they would still enjoy it. But any of the early 3D games are just so visually jarring I can't force myself to play more than a short while before I turn them off. Especially with the early, horrible 3D controls. Even the games which I loved when I was young - Metal Gear Solid, Mario64, Wipeout - they are all unplayable for me now.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jimmaswell on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:37PM (#9876064)
>it’s really hard for the newer generation to look past the graphics, sound and gameplay

"Retro" graphics are pretty popular now, though. They're in the mainstream all the time.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bdcravens on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:48PM (#9875739)
The gameplay on mobile games mirrors many of those older games, and I think eventually Nintendo will give in and start publishing their catalog there. I think if Super Mario was released on iOS and Android, it'd blow Angry Birds numbers out of the water. (though maybe I'm just hopeful)
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Mahn on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:59PM (#9875766)
> The gameplay on mobile games mirrors many of those older games

If only. There are exceptions but the vast majority of mobile games that "make it" have very simple and mindless gameplay. Games like Super Mario/Metroid/Zelda do exist on mobile but very rarely do well, and as a result not many people make them. It's nothing at all like the 80s/90s.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bphogan on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:22PM (#9875849)
Exactly. I can't see the enemy because my thumb is covering him with my virtual joystick.

Give me a crosspad and two buttons. And then get off my lawn.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by clw8 on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:44PM (#9875914)
I just wish phone controllers would start selling enough that more developers would design their games to use physical buttons for gameplay and touch for menu selections etc. Are the current options just that shitty?

I considered buying one when I had a 5S, but decided against when it leaked that the 6's would be bigger. Don't know if the situation's changed.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by david-given on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:09AM (#9877847)
Physical buttons are complex to make and expensive. And bulky; when not playing a game you still have to use up space on the phone for them.

Not that I don't agree with you --- I do; gaming on phones is a miserable experience. You do get game controllers for phones, but they're frequently awful and game designers can't assume that people have them so they have to design for playing on the screen anyway.

I'd love to see a proper solution for this.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Bahamut on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:30AM (#9878261)
I'd rather just game on my 3DS or PS Vita instead - phone battery life is still miserable with intense games, and performance is also questionable.

Phones are just not built to be a good gaming platform as is, and I am not convinced they will be comparable in experience for at least another decade, if not longer. The technology isn't optimal yet.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bdcravens on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:37PM (#9876063)
Ability to swipe anywhere on screen and tap could replicate alot of those mechanics.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eropple on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:24AM (#9876573)
So many people have tried that I feel compelled to say, "prove it." SMB1, SMB3, SMW, and even Mario 64 all require remarkably precise controls for movement--and I tend to think that moving away from that sort of precision of play moves away from something intrinsic to Super Mario games.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by anon4 on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:06AM (#9877831)
Maybe we need to look towards the DS for inspiration. At the beginning, the touch aspect was heavily promoted and a lot of games came out with only touch controls, that worked mostly well. On the other hand, the DS has one very important feature - a stylus with a sharp point. Even if you do get a stylus for your phone, most have very wide ends, nothing like the precise pen that came with the DS. I sometimes wonder whether if mobile phones had all come with styluses, we'd have better games.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by amyjess on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:46AM (#9878402)
I've tried playing platformers on a touch screen. I can never get the hang of it, because I have no idea when I'm touching a button.

The only Nintendo games I'd be interested in playing on mobile are RPGs like EarthBound or Pokémon.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by qnaal on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:19PM (#9875834)
imo flappy bird was pretty much the pinnacle of what action games are possible on a touch screen
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by eru on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:51PM (#9876102)
Try Badland.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by ekianjo on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:41PM (#9876254)
Kero Blaster is not half bad.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by onedev on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:58PM (#9875763)
If either Mario or Pokemon were released on iOS or Android, they would blow every single mobile game out of the water EASY.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by drrotmos on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:32PM (#9875883)
Perhaps. Would you be willing to pay ~$40 for it though? I don't believe the profit margins are high enough on mobile games to be interesting for productions like Pokémon or Mario. More likely, the mobile games will be free-to-play crapware utilizing existing Nintendo trademarks.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bonaldi on Monday July 13, 2015 @06:35AM (#9877263)
I would pay up to £30 for a Zelda or Mario on my phone. Why not? I've paid that for cart versions for years, and they don't get the attention they should because I don't carry a GameBoy everywhere any longer.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by drrotmos on Monday July 13, 2015 @07:08AM (#9877353)
If enough people reason like this, then yes, there is a possibility that Nintendo will release quality games for phones. I doubt that will prove to be the case though.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by bdcravens on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:35PM (#9876059)
No, but I'd be happy to pay a subscription fee.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by grogenaut on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:00AM (#9876511)
Sure, That'll be $40/month.

Seriously, most games are finished in a month if they're good and maybe 2 if they're not. So lets go with $.99/Month on the mobile model.

Unless it's one of the endless time suck games like current mobile games, eg dudes fighting castles, or some big online multiplayer on PC you're not really getting a multi month subscription out of it.

The poster boy in this thread, any mario game, is maybe 2 months, 3 in spurts. That's 3 @ .99, 6 @ 1.99, or 9 @ 2.99. None of which gets you even close to what they were making.

And none of those games will hit the same scale as the dudes n castles games will because those games are simple time wasters with little barrier to entry, eg no skill required. You have to limit max players BEST CASE for your great yester year at the same for any console game, eg maybe 10M players max. If they all played for 3 months at max price your best case is 100M, but more likely 10-30M best case. And likely lower. Eg console numbers is console numbers.

These games cost 10M + to develop these days even great 2d ones because they're still modelled in 3d for parts of it. This isn't the multiple order of magnitude payback the mobile folks are getting on their hits with their quick iterate and the dogfight for the winner.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jimmaswell on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:24PM (#9876027)
>It is kind of sad to me that the newer generation does not get to grow up playing old school games like Final Fantasy and Zelda

They're on the e-shop on the 3DS and WiiU, as well as sold in game stores, just as game cases that are for download codes. I'm pretty sure the newer generation is exposed to them.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by toyg on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:34PM (#9875684)
"Games back then were much harder and more unforgiving"? Man, most modern blockbuster games require marksmanship skills way beyond what '80s games ever demanded. Open world, nonlinear plots... You just can't compare recent stuff with side-scrolling shoot-em-ups or roguelikes.

Some games might have felt unforgiving because technological limitations (no saves) or commercial considerations (coin-op first, home later) forced players to repeat procedures over and over again. This is not something to celebrate. I hope my kids will never have to spend the same amount of time and money I wasted on the first 8 levels of WonderBoy II.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by striking on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:37PM (#9875704)
> Man, most modern blockbuster games require marksmanship skills way beyond what '80s games ever demanded.

Like, which ones? Triple-A FPS games that actually have players that require marksmanship? I don't know of any.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by qmalxp on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:52AM (#9876489)
Counter-Strike does, and I say this as a Mario fanboy.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by epmatsw on Sunday July 12, 2015 @08:42PM (#9875720)
Battlefield?
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jimmaswell on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:23PM (#9876023)
Any modern FPS played competitively definitely takes a lot of skill for sure
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by Retra on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:44PM (#9876083)
The card game "War" takes skill if you play it competitively. That doesn't mean it's a hard game.

If you play a game competitively, you play against other people. That will always take skill. The conversation going on above is about playing against the game itself, not other people.

Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by jimmaswell on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:32AM (#9878277)
An FPS is certainly more technically demanding than War.
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by agumonkey on Sunday July 12, 2015 @09:45PM (#9875919)
You think the hyperprecision was made on purpose to force players to replay (at cost) ?
Re:Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf] by toyg on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:56AM (#9878059)
Any coin-op was obviously trying to walk a tight rope between maintaining user engagement and making it hard enough that you would have to spend significant sums for training purposes. Otherwise you might as well give players 999 lives.

Proof: there is no technological limitation for modern coin-ops regarding saving state, but games actually implementing some sort of saving mechanism are still few and far between (and even then, saving features are almost invariably another way to force players to buy add-on gizmos...).