News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by ohitsdom on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:51AM (#9652489)
TPP details definitely need to be in the public, but I'm surprised WikiLeaks is offering a bounty. Have they done this before? Not that I can recall. And I would think offering money would change the tone of prosecuting the "whistle-blower". It'd be hard to claim that you are a whistle-blower when you are receiving money- that seems a lot more like standard espionage to me.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by kauffj on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:15AM (#9652674)
An individual holds information that is in the public good to be released.

Said individual is threatened with significant harm by states if the information is released.

Only those with tremendous conscious, like Snowden or Manning, step up in the face of odds like that.

Financial compensation shifts the balance to make dangerous humanitarian disclosures more self-interested. It means that more information that should be public becomes public.

What's wrong with that?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jpwagner on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:24AM (#9652759)
What's wrong with that?

In the past, Wikileaks has not been the moral arbiter. If a whistleblower decides that exposing information is in the public interest, that is on them, Wikileaks provides a medium.

Here, whether or not information should remain secret, there is an incentive to expose it. Wikileaks has decided what deserves to be public -- it's irrelevant if I, personally, agree with that judgment when I say: this makes me question Wikileaks as a trusted medium.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DSMan195276 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:53AM (#9652985)
I agree with you on pretty much everything. However, I think it's worth noting that Wikileaks isn't actually the one paying $100,000, in that way the title is misleading IMO. What Wikileaks is doing is holding a funding goal of $100,000, with the funding currently around $35,000. So, while it was Wikileaks' idea, ultimately it's the general public (Or, at-least, a few people who would like this to be leaked) who are offering this money as a bounty. So I wouldn't consider it exactly the same as Wikileaks just flat-out offering $100,000 - This bounty won't happen unless there are a decent amount of people which support this decision and fund it. It still does change the dynamic like you've said though.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by vinceguidry on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:17AM (#9653180)
Organizing and coordinating a fundraising goal isn't all that different than giving it yourself. Wikileaks already subsists substantially off of donations.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by alokdhari on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:39AM (#9652866)
I very much agree with you. It should be up to the person who has the information to decide whether it should be made public or not. Morally speaking, it could cause outage and even war, who knows.. but it should be up to that person to decide. Monetary incentives dilute the idea of moral responsibility and also gives some people an opportunity to shout : "Oh! They did it for the money". What next .. will the information be put on auction !!
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by vasilipupkin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:52AM (#9652973)
it's still up to the person though. It's an incentive not an imperative.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by richmarr on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:39PM (#9653854)
I wouldn't even call it an incentive, it's more the balancing out of a strong negative incentive that already exists.

Considering that Wikileaks exists to make conspiracies harder/smaller I think this totally fits with their purpose. The only question being why it applies to this, but not to other leaks.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jarradhope on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:43AM (#9652906)
Well, isn't the bounty is crowdfunded? So it's the public asking for this, via WikiLeaks. The press value of this move puts the issue in the media spotlight which also good for the issue in public favour, WikiLeaks using it's name makes more sense from a media perspective as opposed to "some random assortment of people".

Really, the TPP should be public, shouldn't we be questioning the trust of the Governments?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by evgen on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:27AM (#9652785)
If this is the first thing that has made you question Wikileaks as a trusted medium then you have not been paying attention.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by StavrosK on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:42AM (#9652897)
I have not been paying attention, would you care to enlighten me?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:15PM (#9654661)
After months of talking up the BofA files, "oops, they're all gone."
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by misterbishop on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:26PM (#9655625)
It's open to interpretation whether you want to blame this on "Wikileaks" or question their integrity over it.

But it should be acknowledged that Daniel Domscheit-Berg 'stole' 5GB of Bank of America documents from Wikileaks servers as well as their submission system, which he used to launch openleaks.

So you can definitely question their internal security, but it should not be presented as an affirmative decision on the part of the organization.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by StavrosK on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:22PM (#9654722)
Oh wow. What do people supposed happened?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:37AM (#9653347)
Please give sources for this statement.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by liquidise on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:40AM (#9652878)
While i agree that this is unusually activist of wikileaks, i have a hard time arguing this move as worse than the status quo. I would rather see governments be actively transparent than actively secretive.

Thought experiment: if governments knew that any decision made had a chance of becoming public, would their behavior shift for the better?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DominikR on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:55PM (#9654539)
> this makes me question Wikileaks as a trusted medium.

Aren't you overreacting? There are many possibilities why Wikileaks needs the money.

For one it might be that they had to pay the informant to get the information. Also they probably don't get their infrastructure (including legal) for free.

Last but not least I have to ask you this: Do you equally question every medium that charges for its services? I mean sure, the New York Times and Washington Post uses a different business model, but they charge nonetheless.

Edit: I also have to say that I doubt, Wikileaks wouldn't leak the data in any case.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:13PM (#9654651)
Do the Times and Post pay their government sources?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DominikR on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:25PM (#9654739)
What makes you think they never did? Maybe its are rare thing to do in the US, but with foreign governments, especially those where corruption is rampant I'd imagine this is nothing unheard of.

By the way, TPP is circulating within many governments. For example it could have been leaked by a Vietnamese government official.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by yAnonymous on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:02PM (#9653519)
Not true. They usually redact information they find unsuited for public release.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by karmacondon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:51AM (#9652967)
The problem is that there is no clear definition of "the public good".

The current system isn't perfect, but it's more empowering to the common person than incentivizing anyone who has access to any information to sell it to the highest bidder, or to make unilateral decisions that affect everyone in society. At least I get to vote for someone I trust to make the right decisions.

There are plenty of people, especially in red states, who have complete faith in elected and appointed officials to decide what information should be public and what should be private. The personal beliefs of any given government employee aren't any more valid than anyone else's. I don't want to live in a society where any one person gets to decide what's in the public good and what isn't.

If you think the system should be changed so that anyone who has access to classified information can make it public on a whim, then vote for people who will implement that as policy. I don't agree with that idea, but it's a valid political belief and it's at least worthy of debate. But it isn't up to me, you or any other individual to make the final decision. Everyone should get a vote.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by resu_nimda on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:33AM (#9653313)
That's lovely and all, but the game is rigged. Vote? lol.

Do you want to live in a society where business interests collude with governments behind closed doors to decide what's in the "public" good? Because that's the one we live in.

The balance of power is just amazingly asymmetrical. The status quo is a machine that exists only to preserve itself, not for the public good. How can you honestly believe that it's in our best interests for this deal to remain private? Anyone who would leak it isn't "decid[ing] what's in the public good" at least in terms of actual policy, they're literally just letting the public be aware of what's going on with new policies that affect them (and this is not sensitive military information that might "threaten our national security" if released, so that argument is out).

From the article: "Proponents argue its a debate so fragile that airing the specifics publicly would thwart progress. They say the chapters already published by WikiLeaks, ones on the environment and intellectual property, strained talks by inflaming interest groups."

What the fuck? This is not democracy. "Well you know a bunch of people would probably be unhappy about this massive global policy we're enacting so let's just not tell them about it."

I'm sorry for the rhetoric but this kind of stuff...that society you don't want to live in - I feel like we're already there. It's not one person deciding but it's a group of people and they are continually fucking over everyone else for their own interests. We could do so much better.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JadeNB on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:23PM (#9654726)
> What the fuck? This is not democracy. "Well you know a bunch of people would probably be unhappy about this massive global policy we're enacting so let's just not tell them about it."

That reminds me of this quote found on a Metafilter discussion (http://www.metafilter.com/150141/Its-not-paranoia-if-they-ar...) about the FBI's use of fake companies to hide its operation of a 'civilian air force':

> The FBI asked the AP not to disclose the names of the fake companies it uncovered, saying that would saddle taxpayers with the expense of creating new cover companies to shield the government's involvement ….

EDIT: To be clear, the quote comes not from Metafilter itself, but from the article being discussed on Metafilter. However, I think that the discussion itself is worth reading, particularly for comments by jjwiseman, who was involved in related research (http://www.metafilter.com/150141/Its-not-paranoia-if-they-ar...).

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pyre on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:07AM (#9653093)
How can we vote on something that the government says we aren't allowed to see?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:16PM (#9654676)
The vote happens after you're allowed to see it.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by zo1 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:10PM (#9655504)
No, they have to pass it so that you can find out what's in it! </sarcasm>
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pyre on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:46PM (#9655733)
You're allowed to see it only after the President has agreed to the terms, and works are greasing the wheels of Congress to update the laws.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by davorb on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:35AM (#9653330)
One of the problems with this trade deal is that most of our representatives -- the people who are supposed to write legislation -- aren't even allowed to know any more about it than we are. Not only that, the text will stay secret for two years after it has been ratified.

> the decision to keep the text of TPP secret was itself classified as secret

http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2013/06/first-congress-member...

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by btilly on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:06PM (#9655009)
Your information is out of date.

According to http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/17/business/obama-trade-legis... an agreement has been reached between the administration and Congress which requires, among other things, that,

The bill would make any final trade agreement open to public comment for 60 days before the president signs it, and up to four months before Congress votes. If the agreement, negotiated by the United States trade representative, fails to meet the objectives laid out by Congress — on labor, environmental and human rights standards — a 60-vote majority in the Senate could shut off “fast-track” trade rules and open the deal to amendment.

Of course Congress and the administration do not have a history of being particularly responsive to the public. But it does seem that everyone will be able to know what was agreed on before it is signed into law.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:18PM (#9654697)
There's nothing in your link to suggest the treaty will remain secret even after ratification.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by worklogin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:33AM (#9652818)
> Only those with tremendous conscientious, like Snowden or Manning, step up in the face of odds like that.

Good. Look how beneficial Snowden's leaks have been to the cause of civil liberties in the past two years, and because he went Hong Kong and Moscow, many think he MUST be a traitor.

Now imagine if Snowden said "Eh, I wouldn't have done it, but $100,000 was nice."

> Financial compensation shifts the balance to make conscientious disclosure more self-interested.

That's bad; now you've eroded the moral grounds. Even offering legal funds up to $100k would be more ethical than cash payouts.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by teekert on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:45AM (#9653398)
God damn it I just want to see that document, I want to know whether I have to watch my food for 31 oestrogenic insecticides that decrease my kid's fertility(1). Why do I have to f-ing pay some outlaw(!) to get information that concerns me! It pisses me off to no end. If raising this 100.000 is the only way, then so be it! (1 http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/may/22/eu-droppe...)
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by noelsusman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:15PM (#9655921)
It will be fully public for 60 days before Congress votes on it.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:29PM (#9655999)
"Fully public", for 60 whole days! I can't wait, also, "Beware of the Leopard."
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by bad_user on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:17PM (#9653655)
There isn't a (proven) financial incentive for Snowden, yet he's classified as a traitor anyway. Even here on Hacker News, a community of people with an intelligence over average, I've seen opinions that Snowden seeking asylum in Russia is fishy, in spite of the fact that he had no other option. Here we have Snowden living the life of a refugee and being hunted by the most competent intelligence agencies on earth, probably for the rest of his life and we are still discussing ulterior motives, even here on HN.

So what difference would a $100,000 incentive would make in the public opinion? Mostly none. But to the whistleblower, it doesn't make one rich, but it can be enough to escape a country and seek asylum somewhere.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by qwerty-- on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:51PM (#9653960)
"Even here on Hacker News, a community of people with an intelligence over average..." Really? intelligent in which topic? You are really demeaning others. Just because you are super techie/coder doesn't make you intelligent in other issues.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by bad_user on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:33PM (#9654371)
I was referring to IQ and while I personally never agreed to its validity, I use it anyway because a lot of people do, but let me change that statement ... it's undeniable that here on HN we've got a large concentration of people very familiar with mathematical logic, relational algebra, discrete maths, the good stuff, so we should be able to detect the truthiness of certain statements when facts are involved, since that's what most of us do in our daily jobs, whereas other people rely more on instinct and feelings which can cloud their judgement. Therefore I found it odd to see people on HN classifying the acts of Snowden to be of a bad nature, without hearing arguments more solid than his asylum in Russia. Of course, everybody is entitled to their own opinion.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DennisP on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:00PM (#9653505)
The content of the leak is the important bit. The whole idea that we should care about the moral standing of the leaker is a distraction created by personality-obsessed media and agenda-driven government PR.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by mordae on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:15AM (#9653160)
On the other hand, it's in my personal interest for to have someone supply my favorite activists with details of that agreement, which is why I pledged. We are talking about a possibility of giving immense control over governments to for-profit corporations that don't lose time pondering morality. And paying out? Someone who leaks TPP will need some protection and 100k is barely enough to move somewhere safe.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:20AM (#9653202)
>Only those with tremendous conscious, like Snowden or Manning, step up in the face of odds like that.

It's unfair to group Snowden and Manning together. Snowden made a very serious, calculated ethical decision to release specific documentation that he felt needed to be in the public forum as reliable, confirmed information of governmental surveillance activity (not speculation or navel-gazing). Manning dumped as much confidential data as he could download because he didn't like the Army anymore.

Snowden was motivated by "tremendous conscience" and Manning was motivated by petty revenge.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:35AM (#9653328)
> Snowden was motivated by "tremendous conscience" and Manning was motivated by petty revenge.

I put it to you that Snowden remained a free(ish) man who was able to communicate his story with the world whilst Manning was locked in isolation and was unable to make public appearances or give interviews. Therefore the 'message' (as the PR people think of it) during the critical time period following leaks and naming of the whistle-blower was controlled by the US government.

I put it to you that this may have influenced your and my and others opinions of them both.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:46AM (#9653402)
That's definitely a valid point.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by calgoo on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:48PM (#9653927)
From someone in Europe who don't follow mainline news, there was never any issues with what Manning did, at least not from me and the people i talked to. The amount of war crimes that were and are committed by individuals in the military and are covered up and almost encouraged are worse then a few undercover personnel in danger and some failed missions. I actually see that as a good outcome, if that actually happened.

That this trade agreement is classified as secret, is just a huge joke. I understand why they are trying to do so... The idea that Corp. Lawyer A is in a lawsuit today against Corp. Lawyer B, and with Corp. Lawyer C acting as judge (who yesterday was in a suit against Corp. Lawyer A).

Who even thinks of this?????? Was this a bet by a few drunk 0.1% guys to see if we are stupid enough to let it pass? Im amazed at the audacity of even trying to claim that this is even reasonable or needed. And that is just the process... With these rules, you could basically eliminate ANY worker rights, ANY nature protection law, and ANY laws that are created to keep corporations in check.

Its scary thinking of what legal BS could be added to these laws that we are not even allowed to see until 2 years after it has been completed.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jklinger410 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:46PM (#9654876)
also *she
[deleted]
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:06PM (#9655852)
> I'm not that familiar with the details, but at the time of the leaks, Manning identified as a "he", no?

Manning was certainly publicly identified that way at the time; as I understand Manning's gender identity disorder was diagnosed by a military psychologist either prior to or during the same time the leaks were occurring, and Manning also declared to a supervisor the fact that she self-identified as female during the same period in which the leaks were occurring, so, I don't think one can say that Manning identified as male at the time without substantial qualification.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by digler999 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:24PM (#9655970)
he leaked Collateral Murder because he didn't like the Army ?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:14PM (#9654656)
Why are you a liar? Ignorance or malevolence? Or are you willingly a propaganda sock-puppet?

Because if you aren't, you have a duty to educate yourself before you speak about things of this importance.

[Re: Downvotes] - Is being called out upsetting? Imagine someone being put in jail by your lies. That's a lot more upsetting.

[Re: Re: Downvotes] - Seriously. This isn't Uber vs Lyft, this is knowingly repeating false information to justify keeping someone in jail for treason. That's just steps under lying about someone to drum up support to get them killed. Does asking if a sock-puppet is a sock-puppet hurt HN more than allowing sock-puppets like that to use HN as a platform for hate? If it was Russia's propaganda machine, or a beloved hero like Nelson Mandela, we'd react strongly, but when it's our propaganda machine we give it a pass.

  > http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/feb/01/bradley-manning-wikileaks
  ...
  A dispute had arisen concerning 15 Iraqi detainees held by the national
  Iraqi police force on the grounds that they had been printing "anti-Iraqi
  literature".
  
  The police were refusing to work with the US forces over the matter,
  and Manning's job was to investigate and find out who the "bad guys"
  were. He got hold of the leaflet that the detained men were distributing
  and had it translated into English. He was astonished to find that it
  was in fact a scholarly critique against the Iraqi prime minister,
  Nouri al-Maliki, that tracked the corruption rife within his cabinet.
  
  "I immediately took that information and ran to the officer to explain
  what was going on," Manning later explained. "He didn't want to hear
  any of it … he told me to shut up and explain how we could assist
  the [Iraqi] police in finding MORE detainees."
  ...
The USA was cooperating in arresting innocent Iraqi civilians (and subjecting them to brutal torture when arrested). This is illegal. Under civilian and military law, illegal orders must be refused and reported. Manning had a legal duty to report the illegal orders. If Manning had not reported this, it would be a crime. Being told to ignore it doesn't change that.

If you're pissed off about criminals ruining the reputation and effectiveness of the USA Armed Forces, and you should be, you need to be mad at the officers and soldiers and leaders who committed the crimes not the messenger who told you about it.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:43PM (#9654850)
That doesn't seem to contradict anything I said. He was mad at the Army, so leaked a bunch of classified documents. To any extent which his leaks treat Iraqi police and/or U.S. forces detaining political prisoners, it is incidental -- the document dump was not discriminatory. Manning is not a whistleblower over events of illegal detention.

We already know that this wasn't Manning's motive for leaking docs anyway; he was mad that the Army did not respect his desires to live as a transsexual and that it disciplined him for tardiness and other job failures.

[0] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/12/bradley-manning...

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:12PM (#9655058)
> That doesn't seem to contradict anything I said.

It literally contradicts everything you said. Manning would be a criminal, by our existing laws, for not reporting the abuses.

The attempt to report war crimes was ignored before the leaks. He tried, and was rebuffed, but his responsibility didn't end there.

> He was mad at the Army.

Irrelevant. Manning had a legal duty to - more than just refuse the orders - make sure the illegal actions stopped.

Besides, can you imagine a mobster using this defense? "Sure, I kill people, but Bugsy only told you because he was angry I cut him out of some of the payment. If Bugsy wasn't a little bitch you never would have caught me." We'd laugh because it's irrelevant; a crime is a crime and an illegal order is an illegal order.

  > [link]
  "... Manning flipped a table during counseling ..."
Oh my god! Small emotional outburst cancels importance of illegal conspiracy.

I'm so sorry for the counsellor who had to witness that. It must be almost as traumatic as having your parents taken away and tortured or killed because of politically motivated false arrest. /s

You're only talking about the messenger to distract from the message. What are you afraid of? What are you covering up for?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:34PM (#9655237)
I'm objecting only to the assertion that Manning acted out of "tremendous conscience". The evidence clearly shows that this is false. I didn't say anything about the content he leaked (other than it doesn't pertain to the "crime" you're claiming he was "attempting to report"), whether he deserved his sentence, whether this is a valid legal defense, or anything else you're talking about here. Manning dumped docs not out of "tremendous conscience", but immature rage. That's a settled fact of record, and that's all my comment was meant to point out.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:14PM (#9655534)
> The evidence clearly shows [...]

No, your source shows nothing of the sort. It doesn't even purport to address the issue of causality. There's nothing more than conjecture (anywhere) as to what the straw that broke Manning's conscience was, and it's irrelevant because it's just the straw. It's focusing on the messenger not the criminal.

What we do know is that Manning tried to report war crimes, first to a commander and then to the media, and was unable to be heard and stop the crimes. This didn't end the duty to report them, it just exhausted the "proper" channels.

> That's a settled fact of record, and that's all my comment was meant to point out.

Your comment was meant to be the same baseless slander that all other baseless, factless, slander-filled posts are. There are sources that directly contradict you and yet you choose to continue. Your posts are part of a campaign of lies to destroy the life of an innocent - if not a hero.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pc86 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:24PM (#9655163)
Your tone is overly personal and counter-productive.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:53PM (#9655382)
The other poster's words contribute to putting a hero in jail for treason. Mine might not be productive because they're accusatory. I'll take that chance considering the stakes.

How counter-productive would you feel this was if it was your family unlawfully detained?

And, if you'll note, their words are personal. They attack and denigrate Manning specifically and by name, despite evidence. I only refer to them in the abstract because I'm referring to anyone who feels or says what they do. This is important - their words follow Manning forever, mine are only here in this thread, only attached to their hate speech. If they walk away from the lies, they walk away from my judgements.

We shouldn't pretend that willful ignorance is a justifiable opinion that deserves respect - lies are lies, and these ones specifically are calculated to put an innocent in prison.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pc86 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:54AM (#9659665)
> I'll take that chance considering the stakes.

Seriously? You're commenting on an internet forum. There are no "stakes." There is no reason not to be civil.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:25PM (#9663522)
> You're commenting on an internet forum. There are no "stakes."

Whoosh. At risk is ... some incivility. Maybe. And we're already there because of the slanderer.

Attacking someone like that is cyber-bullying. To keep wrongly harassing someone with lasting, hurtful, and harmful messages.

The reason not to be civil and/or ignore the troll is precisely that it doesn't work. Calling them on it builds a culture of challenging lies - making it safer (and more polite) for everyone in the future.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by belorn on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:55AM (#9652518)
I remember when the music/movie industry argued that it was perfectly legal to pay informers, who then just happen to gain access to private servers owned by release groups. Several complains was sent in to the police and nothing came out of it, so I would assume, being that the law treats everyone equal, that this is equally legal.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:05AM (#9653070)
Paying people to divulge information about illegal activities is perfectly legal, yes - leaking classified government information, however, is not. One thing is not like the other. It's not about paying people to share information, it's what kind of information, and which laws protect said information.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:36AM (#9653341)
Is it strictly legal (visa-vi US constitution) for the US government to operate in secret as they are doing with TPP?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:22PM (#9654721)
Nothing in Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 seems to require the discussions take place in public.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:16PM (#9655078)
Fair enough. I was genuinely curious. I'm jealous of countries with constitutions to protect them from particularly egregious laws. But I guess no constitution is perfect.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by xorcist on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:52PM (#9654913)
While I appreciate your knowledge of the Swedish juridical system, the point of the infiltration belorn mentions above was that it was in fact the paid infiltrators who had uploaded the illegal content the server owners was busted over. That is something of a moral gray area, if not a legal one.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by istvan__ on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:08AM (#9653104)
What is the classified information a crime committed by the government? :)
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by draugadrotten on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:03AM (#9652582)
Strange move. It also changes WikiLeaks from observer and passive receiver of information to actor, instigator. That can't be good.

Will WikiLeaks still pay 100K for the information if it was obtained by killing someone?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jberryman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:51AM (#9652968)
> It also changes WikiLeaks from observer and passive receiver of information to actor, instigator.

I think WikiLeaks has only ever seemed passive and neutral to people who agree with its agenda

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:42AM (#9653379)
> I think WikiLeaks has only ever seemed passive and neutral to people who agree with its agenda

No the idea has previously been that any information gets dumped onto wikileaks rather than wikileaks seeking specific pieces of information. This makes them passive.

You can dislike the idea of information being dumped and this would make you disagree with its agenda but it does not mean that wikileaks has (previously) been active rather than passive.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jberryman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:01PM (#9654984)
> No the idea has previously been that any information gets dumped onto wikileaks rather than wikileaks seeking specific pieces of information.

I'm not sure the distinction between "dumped onto" vs "seeking out" is a real one, but my main objection is that I don't see any evidence that wikileaks has been a passive conduit for leaks that come their way; they do curation of "leaks" that arrive in their inbox, they choose to promote certain leaks in certain ways, etc.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:20PM (#9655115)
> I'm not sure the distinction between "dumped onto" vs "seeking out" is a real one

It is huge. It is also recognised as such by laws in many countries. E.g. UK libel act 2013 and US DMCA act (safe harbour provisions). In both cases publishers are protected from legal trouble if they act as an intermediary rather than as a publisher.

> but my main objection is that I don't see any evidence that wikileaks has been a passive conduit for leaks that come their way; they do curation of "leaks" that arrive in their inbox, they choose to promote certain leaks in certain ways, etc.

This is a valid point. But offering money for leaks is a whole different thing.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by codingdave on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:16AM (#9652681)
I'm more concerned about the crowdsourcing of it. How would that work if "they" decide to come after anyone who leaks it. Does putting in a few bucks mean you can be criminally charged if that cash leads to a bounty that leads to a leak?

I'm all for government transparency. But this seems like an unwise mechanism to achieve it.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by sliverstorm on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:52PM (#9655370)
To me "crowdsourcing" it sounds like a convenient way of intelligence-for-hire PLUS the ability for the buyers to remain hidden among the crowd.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by josu on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:00AM (#9653035)
I guess that's the reason why they are accepting bitcoin.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by LyndsySimon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:31AM (#9653294)
If they were also offering Bitcoin to the person who discloses the information, that person could remain anonymous while still benefiting from the bounty.

This is an "assassination market", but for information. I'm very intrigued by this concept.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by ohitsdom on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:51AM (#9653426)
I would guess it would be very difficult for the leaker to remain anonymous to the government. I'm sure they have careful revisioning and at least some compartmentalization, so I think whoever blows the whistle has to do it with the assumption of it becoming public (and it may be in the interest of their safety to follow the Snowden route).
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by josu on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:16PM (#9653639)
I'm not sure, there are too many governments and agencies involved in the negotiations. It could even be a computer engineer that has nothing to do with the negotiations.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by mc32 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:07AM (#9653095)
Agree with this. Money taints the appearance of neutrality. They are no longer a neutral medium but rather an information marketplace. It's no longer based on moral guidance but monetary and economic guidance.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by robotkilla on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:08AM (#9652613)
I had the same reaction at first, but are there any laws stating that the details can't be disclosed? Meaning - is this paying someone to breach a contract or something worse?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by amelius on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:16AM (#9652678)
I don't know... $100,000 to change your identity, suddenly it sounds like a small fee.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:08AM (#9653100)
That depends on whether the whistleblower's identity is published. If Snowden hadn't gone missing, enough people had the same access as he did, and there wasn't a log of who accessed what documents in place (or it was removed), he could've remained anonymous too.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:58AM (#9652537)
TPP details definitely need to be in the public...

Details? Why? Obviously agreements will be public before they become law (nobody disputes this), but why force negotiators making difficult tradeoffs to hash them out in the open?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Someone1234 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:01AM (#9652569)
> Obviously agreements will be public before they become law (nobody disputes this)

Obviously? They've already fast tracked it even before it is available to the public. They've made it available to members of congress without it being available to the public. While on paper they might release it just before it became law, they could easily release it a week before giving nobody time to mount a real challenge.

I'd have no issue if I thought it was going to take six months to pass, and members of the public could have a say, but fast tracking makes that highly unlikely.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Shivetya on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:32AM (#9652816)
To be blunt more than most on this very site were just fat dumb and happy when the FCC fast tracked their rules changes without prior publication, in fact some were insisting on it to quell debate.

There is one simple rule, apply the same standards to all or you have no leg to stand on. Far too many people dismiss the rules when they think the outcome is one they may like; even if that decision is one hundred percent ignorant of facts

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by anigbrowl on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:54PM (#9653989)
Fast tracked means it goes through an up-or-down vote instead of the appalling amendment process Congress usually prefers, which makes no sense in an international trade agreement.

They've made it available to members of congress without it being available to the public.

Yes. So they can do the jobs they were elected to do - represent your interest.

I'd have no issue if I thought it was going to take six months to pass, and members of the public could have a say, but fast tracking makes that highly unlikely.

Honestly, I don't think the public is really competent to form opinions on most of this. >>90% of the complaints I see about trade deals are uninformed, counterfactual, and ignorant. This doesn't mean I think all trade deals are necessarily perfect by any means, but the signal:noise ratio is appalling.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by noelsusman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:20PM (#9655951)
It will be fully public for 60 days before Congress gets a chance to vote for it. Fast tracking just means Congress cannot amend the bill, they can only vote up or down. Opposing fast tracking is essentially the same thing as opposing the entire deal. Our negotiators would be in much weaker positions since other countries would have no reason to believe anything they say.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:08AM (#9652609)
Not to put too fine a point on it, but members of the (U.S.) public had their say when they voted for their President, Senators and Congressfolk. Who, not coincidentally, negotiate all sorts of critically important legislation in private.

Besides, the version of TPA under consideration by the House this month requires that any agreement be public for at least 60 days before it can be signed by the President and submitted to Congress for enabling legislation.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by imron on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:13AM (#9652649)
> but members of the (U.S.) public had their say when they voted for their President, Senators and Congressfolk.

That's not how it works. If it was, we'd have SOPA, but we don't.

Citizens telling their representatives what they do and don't want is fundamental aspect of a well-functioning democracy.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by EliRivers on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:26AM (#9652777)
Well then, the only conclusion is that by design you don't have this well-functioning democracy. The people at the top certainly don't think they should listen.

RECENTLY, when Vice-President Cheney was asked by ABC News correspondent Martha Raddatz about polls showing that an overwhelming majority of US citizens oppose the war in Iraq, he replied, "So?"

"So — you don't care what the American people think?" Raddatz asked.

"No," Cheney replied, and explained, "I think you cannot be blown off course by the fluctuations in public opinion polls."

Later, White House spokeswoman Dana Perino, explaining Cheney's comments, was asked whether the public should have "input."

Her reply: "You had your input. The American people have input every four years, and that's the way our system is set up."

That's correct. Every four years the American people can choose between candidates whose views they reject, and then they should shut up.

http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20080403.htm

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by imron on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:35PM (#9656939)
> Well then, the only conclusion is that by design you don't have this well-functioning democracy

Yes. I would agree that the US is not a well-functioning democracy.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:18AM (#9652696)
Agreed, there are few more harmful concepts to a representative democracy, especially one with as poor of an electoral system as the US, but any representative democracy as well, as the idea that citizen input begins and ends with voting. It's like saying a boss's input on an employee's work is limited to hiring and firing.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:19AM (#9652703)
And no trade agreement has ever become law without months of Congressional hearings and debate. The proposed version of TPA would guarantee at least two, and at least four is what's likely. So what's the point again?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by mcv on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:11AM (#9652634)
With the positions of the various parties secret, there's no way for the people to know whether their interests have been taken into account. These are some seriously heavy negotiations for something that can't possibly be considered more than a preliminary proposal.

In particular, there seem to be provisions in it that cannot be remotely considered acceptable to any democratic system. And the way public interest and civil rights groups are explicitly kept out of this, while corporate groups have pretty thorough access, it's pretty clear who's interests are and aren't being represented.

The entire negotiation process seems utterly pointless.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by peeters on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:04AM (#9652587)
Because once the agreement is finalized in negotiations, it's expected to get a "yea" or "nay" vote from participant legislatures. To my knowledge, congress cannot amend the agreement at that point.

So having the negotiations done in secret puts lawmakers and the public in a difficult position. Instead of compromising and tweaking, if they don't like parts of the agreement, they have to decide whether to flat out reject it, or approve it and live with the crappy parts. And those that reject it will be framed as anti-trade, anti-economy, etc. (even if they only vote against the bill because of its draconian copyright rules, e.g.)

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by rlpb on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:15AM (#9652666)
> even if they only vote against the bill because of its draconian copyright rules

I think it's about time that politicians start voting against bills because of the underhanded way they were drafted, and that voters start to support this behaviour.

It doesn't have to be binary, either. "No for now but you can present it again in a year's time so that it can receive proper debate" should be perfectly acceptable. If for a process reason that actually means "No forever" in practice, then it should be made clear that it was the underhanded process that led to "No forever" and not the politician who was forced to vote it that way just because there was no opportunity to fix the process.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:33AM (#9652820)
Congress can amend implementing legislation. A treaty can't be amended, but a treaty is ratified by the Senate, not the House, and requires a supermajority in the Senate.

Personally, if you want a fast track with no amendments to implementing legislation for an international agreement that requires such legislation (is, is not self-executing), then a prerequisite for that is that the underlying agreement itself should be signed and ratified by the Senate as a treaty first.

You can't modify it because it's implementing a treaty only works as an argument if you accept that the treaty needs to be ratified before we talk about the implementing legislation.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:47AM (#9652942)
You can't modify it because it's implementing a treaty only works as an argument if you accept that the treaty needs to be ratified before we talk about the implementing legislation.

Is anyone making this argument? Has the Constitutional treaty process ever been used for modern trade agreements?

The actual argument is that no agreement can be reached unless Congress concedes their authority to amend enabling legislation. It makes perfect sense: Why would our trade partners want to do N rounds with Congress or other nations' legislative bodies after they've already completed difficult negotiations to get to an agreement with the Executive in the first place? This is why we have a President and a USTR confirmed by Congress.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:16AM (#9652680)
Why would our trading partners make any painful concessions at all if they believe any corresponding painful concessions we make will simply be amended out of the enabling legislation by Congress?

The result would be a scuttled agreement, and all the political headache of having made those concessions without any of the corresponding gain.

The U.S. hasn't entered into a major trade agreement without "Fast Track" in 40 years. It's fine to be against liberalizing trade agreements, but it's practically impossible to be for them but against some form of TPA.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by peeters on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:32PM (#9655218)
I don't know what you're arguing against, but I never once said that Congress should be able to amend the treaty as they see fit. That doesn't make sense; it's a treaty. All participants need to ratify the same document.

I was arguing for transparency into the process, when the treaty is still being drafted.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by gnud on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:01AM (#9652570)
Because, when the time comes to actually pass/reject the final agreement, the choice is binary. And a _lot_ of work has been put in from all sides, under the assumption that the tradeoffs they make will be accepted.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Zigurd on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:11AM (#9652635)
> negotiators making difficult tradeoffs

Are there any "difficult tradeoffs" that need to be secret? Or is it just the bad copyright provisions and undermining of environmental protections?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by evgen on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:24AM (#9652760)
All of them need to be made in secret. If industry A learns that it is going to lose a domestic subsidy for the sake of letting industry B gain a foothold in some other country then A is going to lean on the legislators it owns to try to have pressure applied to the negotiators to change the calculus involved, then industry B will jump in, etc. Better for everyone to see the final deal and decide of the collection of tradeoffs is worthwhile than to have to deal with pressure politics from every particular interest group that has a dog in the fight while at the same time trying to deal with trade negotiators from a number of other countries.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by mrgoldenbrown on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:53PM (#9653984)
That doesn't seem very fair when industry B has 10 representatives involved in the negotiation, and industry A doesn't have any. Of course industry B is doing to argue that the tradeoff is worthwhile. And in reality, it's the big corps that have the reps involved in the negotiations right now, and the public interest group that do not.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Zigurd on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:56AM (#9653009)
Example? All the examples I can think of work the other way: Horrors that industry lobbyists want that sell out the people.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by wmil on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @08:51PM (#9656829)
Depends on your definitions of 'industry' and 'the people'.

Take for example the Canadian wine industry. There's international pressure for Canada to open up it's domestic wine market. In Ontario, the largest province, foreign wines can only be sold at government run liquor stores.

Opening up the domestic market is problematic, because apart from ice wine Ontario wine is awful. At any given price point Ontario reds are substantially worse than California reds.

Even if nothing happens, once the government starts openly negotiating to open the market the property value of vineyards will plummet. Farmers will be underwater on their mortgages and will have trouble getting insurance.

The government doesn't want to endanger people's livelihoods like that unless it's sure that the rest of the agreement is worth it.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by zeeed on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:01AM (#9652571)
it can very well be disputed whether or not all details of the trade agreement will be made public, I see no reason or evidence to the contrary.

Why force making it public? I guess there have been arguments of mistrust - or am I getting this wrong?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by happyscrappy on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:02AM (#9652578)
>Obviously agreements will be public before they become law (nobody disputes this)

A good number of people don't understand that these have to be debated publicly in order to pass Congress. Wikileaks shamefully plays on this misunderstanding.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by peeters on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:09AM (#9652620)
A good number of people realize that by the time it goes to Congress for its rubber stamp, it's too late to tweak the agreement. It's not like a bill where you can introduce amendments. They have to either throw away years of negotiations, or accept the agreement with its significant warts.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by happyscrappy on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:14AM (#9652659)
If your goal is to prevent a trade deal then forcing them to negotiate the terms publically will accomplish your goal.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by eli on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:59AM (#9652547)
IANAL but I don't think whistleblower protections would ever apply to leaking a confidential document to wikileaks regardless of whether you're paid or not.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by snowwrestler on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:38AM (#9652862)
I highly doubt that whistleblower protections would apply to leaking a draft trade agreement.

Typically those protections are intended to provide protection for people who disclose wrongdoing that would otherwise be unknown. But in the eyes of the law, negotiating a trade deal is not wrongdoing. It is one of the enumerated powers of the executive branch.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by eli on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:39PM (#9653856)
Good point!
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by scrrr on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:53AM (#9652505)
Well I assume the information would be made publicly available to anyone.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by blowski on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:57AM (#9652536)
Sorry, I don't quite understand what you mean here.

I understood the OP as saying that Edward Snowden (and people like him) justify their actions as being altruistic, for the greater good of society. If you give a financial incentive to someone to be a whistleblower, it no longer looks like altruism.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by Zigurd on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:16AM (#9652682)
There is an ocean of money sloshing around buying Congress and buying provisions in treaties like this. Altruism is for suckers.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by LunaSea on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:28AM (#9652790)
*Moral suckers
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by zeeed on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @09:58AM (#9652542)
is that a reasonable assumption?

This is meant as a serious question. Would the details of the agreement be made public, eventually?