News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:33AM (#9652820)
Congress can amend implementing legislation. A treaty can't be amended, but a treaty is ratified by the Senate, not the House, and requires a supermajority in the Senate.

Personally, if you want a fast track with no amendments to implementing legislation for an international agreement that requires such legislation (is, is not self-executing), then a prerequisite for that is that the underlying agreement itself should be signed and ratified by the Senate as a treaty first.

You can't modify it because it's implementing a treaty only works as an argument if you accept that the treaty needs to be ratified before we talk about the implementing legislation.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by twoodfin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:47AM (#9652942)
You can't modify it because it's implementing a treaty only works as an argument if you accept that the treaty needs to be ratified before we talk about the implementing legislation.

Is anyone making this argument? Has the Constitutional treaty process ever been used for modern trade agreements?

The actual argument is that no agreement can be reached unless Congress concedes their authority to amend enabling legislation. It makes perfect sense: Why would our trade partners want to do N rounds with Congress or other nations' legislative bodies after they've already completed difficult negotiations to get to an agreement with the Executive in the first place? This is why we have a President and a USTR confirmed by Congress.