News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jpwagner on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:24AM (#9652759)
What's wrong with that?

In the past, Wikileaks has not been the moral arbiter. If a whistleblower decides that exposing information is in the public interest, that is on them, Wikileaks provides a medium.

Here, whether or not information should remain secret, there is an incentive to expose it. Wikileaks has decided what deserves to be public -- it's irrelevant if I, personally, agree with that judgment when I say: this makes me question Wikileaks as a trusted medium.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DSMan195276 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:53AM (#9652985)
I agree with you on pretty much everything. However, I think it's worth noting that Wikileaks isn't actually the one paying $100,000, in that way the title is misleading IMO. What Wikileaks is doing is holding a funding goal of $100,000, with the funding currently around $35,000. So, while it was Wikileaks' idea, ultimately it's the general public (Or, at-least, a few people who would like this to be leaked) who are offering this money as a bounty. So I wouldn't consider it exactly the same as Wikileaks just flat-out offering $100,000 - This bounty won't happen unless there are a decent amount of people which support this decision and fund it. It still does change the dynamic like you've said though.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by vinceguidry on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:17AM (#9653180)
Organizing and coordinating a fundraising goal isn't all that different than giving it yourself. Wikileaks already subsists substantially off of donations.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by alokdhari on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:39AM (#9652866)
I very much agree with you. It should be up to the person who has the information to decide whether it should be made public or not. Morally speaking, it could cause outage and even war, who knows.. but it should be up to that person to decide. Monetary incentives dilute the idea of moral responsibility and also gives some people an opportunity to shout : "Oh! They did it for the money". What next .. will the information be put on auction !!
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by vasilipupkin on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:52AM (#9652973)
it's still up to the person though. It's an incentive not an imperative.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by richmarr on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:39PM (#9653854)
I wouldn't even call it an incentive, it's more the balancing out of a strong negative incentive that already exists.

Considering that Wikileaks exists to make conspiracies harder/smaller I think this totally fits with their purpose. The only question being why it applies to this, but not to other leaks.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by jarradhope on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:43AM (#9652906)
Well, isn't the bounty is crowdfunded? So it's the public asking for this, via WikiLeaks. The press value of this move puts the issue in the media spotlight which also good for the issue in public favour, WikiLeaks using it's name makes more sense from a media perspective as opposed to "some random assortment of people".

Really, the TPP should be public, shouldn't we be questioning the trust of the Governments?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by evgen on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:27AM (#9652785)
If this is the first thing that has made you question Wikileaks as a trusted medium then you have not been paying attention.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by StavrosK on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:42AM (#9652897)
I have not been paying attention, would you care to enlighten me?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:15PM (#9654661)
After months of talking up the BofA files, "oops, they're all gone."
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by misterbishop on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:26PM (#9655625)
It's open to interpretation whether you want to blame this on "Wikileaks" or question their integrity over it.

But it should be acknowledged that Daniel Domscheit-Berg 'stole' 5GB of Bank of America documents from Wikileaks servers as well as their submission system, which he used to launch openleaks.

So you can definitely question their internal security, but it should not be presented as an affirmative decision on the part of the organization.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by StavrosK on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:22PM (#9654722)
Oh wow. What do people supposed happened?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by JupiterMoon on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @11:37AM (#9653347)
Please give sources for this statement.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by liquidise on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @10:40AM (#9652878)
While i agree that this is unusually activist of wikileaks, i have a hard time arguing this move as worse than the status quo. I would rather see governments be actively transparent than actively secretive.

Thought experiment: if governments knew that any decision made had a chance of becoming public, would their behavior shift for the better?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DominikR on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:55PM (#9654539)
> this makes me question Wikileaks as a trusted medium.

Aren't you overreacting? There are many possibilities why Wikileaks needs the money.

For one it might be that they had to pay the informant to get the information. Also they probably don't get their infrastructure (including legal) for free.

Last but not least I have to ask you this: Do you equally question every medium that charges for its services? I mean sure, the New York Times and Washington Post uses a different business model, but they charge nonetheless.

Edit: I also have to say that I doubt, Wikileaks wouldn't leak the data in any case.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by tedunangst on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:13PM (#9654651)
Do the Times and Post pay their government sources?
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by DominikR on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:25PM (#9654739)
What makes you think they never did? Maybe its are rare thing to do in the US, but with foreign governments, especially those where corruption is rampant I'd imagine this is nothing unheard of.

By the way, TPP is circulating within many governments. For example it could have been leaked by a Vietnamese government official.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by yAnonymous on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:02PM (#9653519)
Not true. They usually redact information they find unsuited for public release.