News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:14PM (#9654656)
Why are you a liar? Ignorance or malevolence? Or are you willingly a propaganda sock-puppet?

Because if you aren't, you have a duty to educate yourself before you speak about things of this importance.

[Re: Downvotes] - Is being called out upsetting? Imagine someone being put in jail by your lies. That's a lot more upsetting.

[Re: Re: Downvotes] - Seriously. This isn't Uber vs Lyft, this is knowingly repeating false information to justify keeping someone in jail for treason. That's just steps under lying about someone to drum up support to get them killed. Does asking if a sock-puppet is a sock-puppet hurt HN more than allowing sock-puppets like that to use HN as a platform for hate? If it was Russia's propaganda machine, or a beloved hero like Nelson Mandela, we'd react strongly, but when it's our propaganda machine we give it a pass.

  > http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/feb/01/bradley-manning-wikileaks
  ...
  A dispute had arisen concerning 15 Iraqi detainees held by the national
  Iraqi police force on the grounds that they had been printing "anti-Iraqi
  literature".
  
  The police were refusing to work with the US forces over the matter,
  and Manning's job was to investigate and find out who the "bad guys"
  were. He got hold of the leaflet that the detained men were distributing
  and had it translated into English. He was astonished to find that it
  was in fact a scholarly critique against the Iraqi prime minister,
  Nouri al-Maliki, that tracked the corruption rife within his cabinet.
  
  "I immediately took that information and ran to the officer to explain
  what was going on," Manning later explained. "He didn't want to hear
  any of it … he told me to shut up and explain how we could assist
  the [Iraqi] police in finding MORE detainees."
  ...
The USA was cooperating in arresting innocent Iraqi civilians (and subjecting them to brutal torture when arrested). This is illegal. Under civilian and military law, illegal orders must be refused and reported. Manning had a legal duty to report the illegal orders. If Manning had not reported this, it would be a crime. Being told to ignore it doesn't change that.

If you're pissed off about criminals ruining the reputation and effectiveness of the USA Armed Forces, and you should be, you need to be mad at the officers and soldiers and leaders who committed the crimes not the messenger who told you about it.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:43PM (#9654850)
That doesn't seem to contradict anything I said. He was mad at the Army, so leaked a bunch of classified documents. To any extent which his leaks treat Iraqi police and/or U.S. forces detaining political prisoners, it is incidental -- the document dump was not discriminatory. Manning is not a whistleblower over events of illegal detention.

We already know that this wasn't Manning's motive for leaking docs anyway; he was mad that the Army did not respect his desires to live as a transsexual and that it disciplined him for tardiness and other job failures.

[0] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/12/bradley-manning...

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:12PM (#9655058)
> That doesn't seem to contradict anything I said.

It literally contradicts everything you said. Manning would be a criminal, by our existing laws, for not reporting the abuses.

The attempt to report war crimes was ignored before the leaks. He tried, and was rebuffed, but his responsibility didn't end there.

> He was mad at the Army.

Irrelevant. Manning had a legal duty to - more than just refuse the orders - make sure the illegal actions stopped.

Besides, can you imagine a mobster using this defense? "Sure, I kill people, but Bugsy only told you because he was angry I cut him out of some of the payment. If Bugsy wasn't a little bitch you never would have caught me." We'd laugh because it's irrelevant; a crime is a crime and an illegal order is an illegal order.

  > [link]
  "... Manning flipped a table during counseling ..."
Oh my god! Small emotional outburst cancels importance of illegal conspiracy.

I'm so sorry for the counsellor who had to witness that. It must be almost as traumatic as having your parents taken away and tortured or killed because of politically motivated false arrest. /s

You're only talking about the messenger to distract from the message. What are you afraid of? What are you covering up for?

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:34PM (#9655237)
I'm objecting only to the assertion that Manning acted out of "tremendous conscience". The evidence clearly shows that this is false. I didn't say anything about the content he leaked (other than it doesn't pertain to the "crime" you're claiming he was "attempting to report"), whether he deserved his sentence, whether this is a valid legal defense, or anything else you're talking about here. Manning dumped docs not out of "tremendous conscience", but immature rage. That's a settled fact of record, and that's all my comment was meant to point out.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @04:14PM (#9655534)
> The evidence clearly shows [...]

No, your source shows nothing of the sort. It doesn't even purport to address the issue of causality. There's nothing more than conjecture (anywhere) as to what the straw that broke Manning's conscience was, and it's irrelevant because it's just the straw. It's focusing on the messenger not the criminal.

What we do know is that Manning tried to report war crimes, first to a commander and then to the media, and was unable to be heard and stop the crimes. This didn't end the duty to report them, it just exhausted the "proper" channels.

> That's a settled fact of record, and that's all my comment was meant to point out.

Your comment was meant to be the same baseless slander that all other baseless, factless, slander-filled posts are. There are sources that directly contradict you and yet you choose to continue. Your posts are part of a campaign of lies to destroy the life of an innocent - if not a hero.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pc86 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:24PM (#9655163)
Your tone is overly personal and counter-productive.
Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @03:53PM (#9655382)
The other poster's words contribute to putting a hero in jail for treason. Mine might not be productive because they're accusatory. I'll take that chance considering the stakes.

How counter-productive would you feel this was if it was your family unlawfully detained?

And, if you'll note, their words are personal. They attack and denigrate Manning specifically and by name, despite evidence. I only refer to them in the abstract because I'm referring to anyone who feels or says what they do. This is important - their words follow Manning forever, mine are only here in this thread, only attached to their hate speech. If they walk away from the lies, they walk away from my judgements.

We shouldn't pretend that willful ignorance is a justifiable opinion that deserves respect - lies are lies, and these ones specifically are calculated to put an innocent in prison.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by pc86 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:54AM (#9659665)
> I'll take that chance considering the stakes.

Seriously? You're commenting on an internet forum. There are no "stakes." There is no reason not to be civil.

Re:WikiLeaks offers $100k for details of Obama’s trade deal by fineman on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:25PM (#9663522)
> You're commenting on an internet forum. There are no "stakes."

Whoosh. At risk is ... some incivility. Maybe. And we're already there because of the slanderer.

Attacking someone like that is cyber-bullying. To keep wrongly harassing someone with lasting, hurtful, and harmful messages.

The reason not to be civil and/or ignore the troll is precisely that it doesn't work. Calling them on it builds a culture of challenging lies - making it safer (and more polite) for everyone in the future.