I don't even live in CA/NY (so my gross pay multiple isn't quite as high, but income net tax/cost of living is pretty great) and there's just no comparison. I probably make 60-80% more total comp in the USA than I would expect in a major Canadian city, and that's not even accounting for higher taxes (depending on state/province), frothy Canadian real estate valuations, and higher consumer prices almost across the board.
But Canada sure is a great place to live and I miss it dearly. I still hope to move back one day.
I don't understand this. If the "average" engineer in SV makes 120Kish, then the same engineer is making 40K in Canada? And they can make 240K in NY (with no additional experience)?
Are those number correct?
If they are: I'd note that salaries in Australia are more closely aligned with SV salaries than Canadian. Just in case anyone is looking to move somewhere...
AVG: Software developer : 58K
Also in Quebec, you cannot call yourself an engineer unless you want to an engineer school and are part of their order.
Fortunately there are multiple job titles in computing that mean the same thing, so this should never be a real problem in computing.
That is actually true in most (all?) provinces.
I rent in San Jose, have private health insurance, and am sole provider for a family of four. Our necessary expenses to maintain our standard of living for last year totaled around $40k. That year I had been offered (and turned down for unrelated reasons) a $115k job on the peninsula. Even assuming a worst-case tax situation, I still could have been saving $40k/year.
That's approximately the going rate in Quebec for the work I do.
And the Canadians get health care for that money.
That said I've done the cost of living numbers between here (NYC) vs. Vancouver, Toronto, and Montreal, and even with the insane rent here I'm still coming out ahead - way ahead. The salary difference is truly mind-boggling.
More than the salary difference, the kind of work you're doing as a $200K engineer in SV/SF/NYC is very different than the kind of work you're doing as a $70K engineer in Toronto. There is a conspicuous lack of this level of work in Canada overall.
http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/tx/ndvdls/fq/txrts-eng.html
http://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0411/do-canadians...
That being said, with the recent tax increases in the US and the lower of provincial income taxes in many Canadian provinces (I'm looking at you BC), the difference isn't as great as one would think.
Of course, it can be argued that there would be fewer jobs for them without it, so that is not to say that there has been no benefit -- it's just kind of hard to quantify. But it has not helped make salaries in Canada more competitive.
Another 2x? 3x? 4x? Why make us guess? It's valuable info that helps inform people's decisions for the future.
Thank you for the datapoints.
The fact of the matter is that other industries are starved for talent. If you can keep up in silicon valley, where all anyone talks about is technology, you will be godly in a different marketplace with more capital flow.
Finance in particular has way too many people who think things like this are a good idea and The Right Thing To Do: https://github.com/goldmansachs/gs-collections
I think that's a pretty unfair criticism.
Firstly, it isn't clear exactly what you don't like about it. That it is Java? That it exists?
You need to put its existence into historical context. When it came out, it was before Google's Guava collections libraries were open source, so there were no decent collections libraries that did more than what the JDK libraries did.
That's the context GS Collections were built for.
(Disclaimer: I've never used them, but I do remember when they were released)
- Seattle salaries were ~70% higher than what I would've gotten in Canada at the time (mostly looking at Toronto area market, though it's all fairly similar)
- SF salaries were ~30% higher than Seattle. I didn't know it at the time but that meant I took an effective pay cut. My total comp was about 1.8x what I would receive in Canada at the time.
- NYC salaries were another ~30% higher than SF (64% higher than Seattle). Cost of living here is lower than SF (weirdly enough), so I effectively got a large raise moving. I've been here for a while, and looking at the Canadian market now I'd reckon I'm about 2.2x higher than a similar position in Canada.
All of the above were done while staying in the same "field" - i.e., did not go into finance. And all of the above assumes I'd be fetching top-10th-percentile salaries for my position in Canada (itself far from a guarantee). If I do "just average" for compensation in Canada my NYC salary would be about 2.6x.
The one overarching trend is that the gap widens as you gain experience and seniority. Canadian salaries never catches up, and in fact continues to fall further and further behind as you go up the ladder.
Even significant health costs per month are ignored in a corporate environment in the US, though small startups may be different. For entrepreneurs, health care costs would matter before the company was large enough to have figured out benefits.
Any startup employees\founders willing to comment on how health insurance is generally handled at US startups?
I have a chronic health condition that needs some fairly expensive drugs and relatively frequent doctor visits and procedures. My total out of pocket healthcare expenses are less than $500 per year.
I'm up-to-date as of 2011, I'm sure things have (and still are) radically changing - but the health insurance situation in the US was a horrible mess until recently - Everything worked fine until the day it didn't, and then you were possibly shut out of healthcare.
I found it obnoxious and annoying, and it's one of the reasons I'll probably never move to that cesspool. The idea that I should have 5 years knocked off my career because I came up in New York (which is a far better city than San Francisco, and far less expensive relative to opportunity and urban amenity) is one I just can't accept.
I don't think this is much of a valid criticism, since most people in the States can also move to SV/NYC and make 2x or 3x their current salaries as well. Hell, those cities probably have the highest numbers (so ignoring CoL) than most places in the world.
It's not a valid criticism if the gov. footing 80% allows these companies to now offer SV/NY competitive salaries. Which I suspect will happen if they do it right (both the governement and the entrepreneurs).
I think, what a lot Americans overlook, is that most people in the rest of developed world want more from life than a high salary. Moving from somewhere with the highest standards of living in the world, such as Toronto, to somewhere that doesn't even make the list of top 5/10 in North America alone such as NYC, might come with a salary increase but it's a significant trade off in terms of other factors.
Looks a lot of Canadians have overlooked it too - all but 2 people in my graduating cohort are writing code in the US.
You are welcome to delude yourself into thinking that "real" Canadians don't value a high salary, but in reality it's causing a massive brain out of the country.
Ample parking, day or night: $2500/yr
People smiling; kindly neighbors: $5000/yr
Public schools that don't suck: $15000/yr
Parks/public spaces that you actually want to visit: $2500/yr
Low violent and property crime rates: $5000/yr
Political and cultural compatibility: $2500/yr
Good local television and radio stations: $1250/yr
Things like that add up, and are highly subjective. But when I see significantly higher salaries in very specific geographical regions, what I see is one of two things: either people there tend to be more valuable than others, or they are demanding compensation for all the crap they have to put up with and/or purchase that they can get for free or at reduced cost elsewhere.
For instance, in Chicago, I had to pay an extra $100 a month for a parking space behind my apartment. That's $1200 a year already. Never mind if you actually wanted to go anywhere in your car and park in the same ZIP code. That costs you additional time and walking distance or additional cash. And it certainly impacts your property and casualty insurance premiums.
Having grown up in a different city, where parking had never been an issue, that threw my own freedom of movement up in stark contrast, as something that had calculatable value to me, and which likely differed significantly from other people. The costs of having a car in Chicago were only partially mitigated by having CTA and Metra commuter service. Grocery shopping is a lot different when you can only buy what you are willing to carry in your arms for as long as it takes to get home. You buy a lot less of the things that are mostly air (additional volume) or mostly water (additional weight).
That was but one of the reasons that I found the local pay was not worth the local costs, and moved.
For a variety of reasons, the people deciding on the location of a business do not value those local costs in the same way, and do not realize that their employees may demand more in compensation because of them. Or they just don't care.
As for myself, I could probably get 1.5x my current pay in SV or 2x in NYC. But it would have to be 3-5x to be worth it. I currently rent a 3br 2.5ba house for about 12% of my gross pay, and can drive to work in 20 minutes. Is that even possible in SV or NYC on income less than $15 million a year?
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-snFyhK5zhAg/UOW2AzMTNEI/AAAAAAAAAR...
or "poutine galvaude" (with chicken and peas):
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-s8Qv78uyb88/ToDfKVqZzdI/AAAAAAAAAC...
There are 'hidden costs' to living in LA/California.
It just depends on what you prefer and where your priorities are.
I would love to move back to Vancouver, because when you consider gas (living close to work vs living in a suburban sprawl), property (yes, you get a bigger house here, but unsafe neighbourhoods are just around the corner, and bad air), quality of education (Canadian primary and secondary schools outperform American ones), then is it really worth the trade off?
For example, in LA, the concept of 'you get what you pay for' is truly taken seriously. You want the best? Get ready to pay thousands and thousands of dollars (more expensive than Canada, usually). If you just want mediocrity and barely get by, LA is super cheap, affordable, and you can raise 10 kids here, no problems.
EDIT: With regard to poutine, that looks like the fancy poutines you get in Santa Monica. Savages! All of them!
EDIT2: Added clarification
I'm sure my cost of living is less. On the other hand, looking at the figures makes you feel a little undervalued.
You must be from outside Quebec. Fresh cheese curds, (they'll squeak as you chew them), won't melt in the gravy, only soften a bit. Melted cheese curds means that they've been sitting in a fridge for a few days or more.
Poutine is just fries, gravy and cheese curds where I'm from!
The comp rebate is nice, but not why we are in YVR.
Transportation costs in the Bay Area are also much higher than the GVRD. Parking in San Francisco costs a fortune and public transit is a mess. You can get a three zone bus pass in Vancouver for far less than I spent each month on BART and the Caltrain. Because there's only one transit company that bus pass is good everywhere. In SFO you need passes for each service. BART doesn't do monthly passes and if you need to go to Oakland bring cash. Your clipper card isn't good there.
If I was looking at equal compensation there is no way I'd choose to live in SFO.
Isn't that the evening out factor, at least for new grads, for a job in say Toronto or Waterloo vs the valley?
also doesn't factor in time commuting, quality of life, avg hrs worked per day, etc... would love to see a pay breakdown $$ / hr worked (at office).
One of the reasons I'm bearish about NYC's future as a tech hub is that, although Manhattan cost of living is extremely high, engineer salaries still seem to have the $150k ceiling, except in finance. Which means you'll have plenty of under-30 talent but few long-term, highly experienced engineers.
But really, I want to say this: as a Canadian, I find that image of poutine extremely offensive. What is that yellow stuff on top, Curry? Are those even proper cheese curds? They're not melted. Is that scallion?
How can this article be trusted when their choice of stock photo is so wrong I question if they've ever even had the dish?