News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by DanielBMarkham on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:30PM (#5921434)
So now is the time to identify the federal prosecutors who filed this and petition the government to have them fired. In addition, of course, to asking for a complete pardon for Snowden.

It also should be noted that any of the Congressional investigations into this mess are perfectly capable of giving Snowden a grant of immunity from prosecution.

People ask what to do. There are at least two avenues open to nip this completely in the bud before prosecutors get rolling, and several other ways of notifying our elected representatives that going down this path is unacceptable.

These are political charges, and as the governed we should stand up to the people who are supposed to be working for us and demand that they be dropped. Immediately.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by DanielRibeiro on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:47PM (#5921532)
The pardon petition also only needs more 7k signatures: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/pardon-edward-snow...

Remember that the goal is to get the government address the issue, and show that the people are not fine with the NSA's actions. It would be nice to get them to actually pardon him, but that is a much harder goal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by evilduck on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:34PM (#5921730)
Has any whitehouse.gov petition ever led to actual action being taken?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bbatsell on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:57PM (#5921840)
Here are the ones I can recall off the top of my head:

* CISPA veto threat/defeat [https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/cybersecurity-legi...]

* New open-access rules [https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/increasing-public-...]

* Halting use of animals in military training [https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/immediately-halt-c...]

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by dragonwriter on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:03PM (#5921875)
The animals one obviously doesn't count [1], since the petition was created September 27th, 2011, and the order halting the use of animals was issued September 20th, 2011.

[1] Barring time travel

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:47PM (#5922354)
Perhaps the order and the petition were quantumly entangled, thus allowing for the measurement of the petition to affect the known outcome of the order.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:14PM (#5921912)
I am pretty sure the CISPA veto and the open access rules were only tangentially affected by the petitions. The open access rules were a response to the treatment of Aaron Swartz, which was creating a media storm that was causing more people to notice the general abuses of power by prosecutors in this country. The CISPA veto threat followed pressure from lobbyists and well-connected corporations.

Did the petitions matter at all? Maybe, but they were not even remotely close to being sufficient to get the administration to do anything. The Obama administration already knows how people feel about the Snowden situation; the petition is basically irrelevant.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fusiongyro on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:33AM (#5922690)
It takes ten seconds and costs nothing. I honestly don't understand the argument against it. It may be no better than nothing, but it can hardly be worse.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by InclinedPlane on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:03AM (#5923031)
It does cost something. It makes you feel like you've done something, so you perhaps have less motivation to do something more substantive such as writing your congressional reps and senators.

Which is a far more meaningful act than signing these useless online petitions.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fusiongyro on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:17PM (#5933882)
There are always ways to do more, but in my experience this line of reasoning actually deflates more than it inspires. If someone has 10 seconds to sign the petition, let them sign the petition and go about their day rather than wasting 10 seconds making them feel guilty for not doing more.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by corin_ on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:57AM (#5922832)
It could perhaps be worse, either because it makes 100,000 people (or however many) think "well I've done by part now!" so they become complacent, or because the administration thinks "well they've got it off their chest with a petition, that will keep them away from doing anything stronger so let's keep going with what we were doing".

Definitely subjective, though.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fearlessleader on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:18AM (#5922858)
What if the 'buzz' generated by all of these people inspires a few people to actually do substantive? Kinda like how spam only needs a few clicks per million to generate a profit.

This is just speculation but it helps me cope with the facebook activism.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by corin_ on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:21AM (#5922862)
I should clarify that I wasn't warning against signing the petition, merely adding a thought to the "well at the very worst it can't do any harm" logic. Make up your own mind on whether signing it is good, bad, or neither :)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mseebach on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:43AM (#5923001)
The argument is the same, but from the opposite end: Because it costs nothing and takes ten seconds. Why should I care about an opinion if the proponent can't invest more than that into it (say, a phone call to your congressman). What other artefacts of zero-cost, (near-) zero-effort expression should be considered in the legislative process?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by exiva on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:38PM (#5921748)
The White House Honey Ale recipe was released from a we the people petition... So, no.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobzimuta on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:40PM (#5921753)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by techtalsky on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:32PM (#5922319)
My opinion about it is that it's ONE way for them to take the temperature of the people. Of course 100,000 signatures alone isn't going to create meaningful action but it does allow for a certain amount of visibility into what's bubbling up to the surface. Thus, it's valuable... just not as valuable as some hope it will be.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by sneak on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:45AM (#5923003)
No.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mverwijs on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:38AM (#5922885)
I'm surprised that I, as a non-US citizen living in the Netherlands, could sign that.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by espadrine on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:34AM (#5923067)
Watching Hulu.com videos should clearly be US-only, while a petition website targeted at US citizen is for everybody!
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mverwijs on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:01PM (#5924959)
Well, it's really very logical. After all, we non-US folk are the ones being spied on as well. Or mostly, even.

It's only fair that we have a say in the politics of the US, as their politicians seem to find it fair to meddle in ours.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by nebula on Saturday June 22, 2013 @09:55AM (#5923578)
Just don't tell anyone in the whitehouse :)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by matchu on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:47PM (#5922185)
Down to 5.5k two hours after your comment. At this rate, we should be done pretty darn soon.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by intelliot on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:49AM (#5922728)
Down to 1.9k six hours after his comment. Good progress :)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by nebula on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:49AM (#5922730)
Only 2.7K needed now.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by piyush_soni on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:41PM (#5924211)
Done now :).
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by chid on Saturday June 22, 2013 @09:19AM (#5923494)
Down to 0 signatures needed :) Reached the 100k! (100,162 right now)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by systematical on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:51PM (#5924915)
Signed, thanks for posting!
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by joering2 on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:35PM (#5921990)
I have a great respect towards Snowden for what he did. Knowing his life will be over, he was brave enough to continue believing in his citizen's duty and pledge to the Constitution and all American people (not to the Administration that just happened to be more tyrannical as the days go by) and decided he couldn't stand the abuse anymore. I personally believe the only reason we do not have a full speed tyranny in this country and more wars with american troops involved all over the world is because of the people like Assange, Bradley and Snowden. They put a real time breaks on internal abuse; many times before pulling the trigger those in charge ask themselves: "damn what if another 'traitor' will leak this out and my name [and crimes] will come to the light?". We have grown very dangerous government that WE founded and WE continue to pay for and we seem to forget about that...

But in NO MEANS the Government will EVER let him off the hook. Never. Its not that they are vicious or anything, its simply because the system is broken and corrupt to its inner core (by corruption I do not mean someone giving an envelope under the table to win some contract. I am talking about high ranked generals that with no serious evidence just by "believing we are protecting american people" are sending thousands on the war the they damn well know is not being waged in the name of security, but the name of satisfying Industrial Military Complex, in a monetary way). You can see military lock down of entire cities due to the riots on the streets, and yet they will not change their mind, because that would be a warm invitation to anyone else witnessing shit being done under government seal to come forward. It would be a total reboot of the system. Another 4th of July. And what they think about founding fathers [1] is not what you would assume they do.

[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6oP1Ke70Mi8

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bertm on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:42PM (#5922013)
It happened in the 70s to Daniel Ellsberg, the Pentagon Paper's leaker.

"Judge Byrne dismissed all charges against Ellsberg."

"He and Russo faced charges under the Espionage Act of 1917 and other charges including theft and conspiracy, carrying a total maximum sentence of 115 years."

-http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Ellsberg

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by georgemcbay on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:03PM (#5922065)
The charges against Ellsberg were dropped on what was basically a technicality, though.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by brandall10 on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:18PM (#5922288)
If the public sentiment sways in such a direction, I'm sure a technicality will be found in this case as well.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rhizome on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:29PM (#5922460)
The DOJ has spent the last 40 years plugging those holes.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by samaparicio on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:25AM (#5922782)
The charges against Ellsberg were dropped when it became public that the government had spied on Ellsberg by wiretapping Ellsberg's psychiatric visits.

So maybe all Snowden has to do is to show the government spying on him. Which would be kind of meta, as it would put the government on trial for PRISM itself, while probably acquitting Snowden

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:42PM (#5921499)
I actually don't think charging him is inherently bad. If he in fact took 4 government property laptops with him, that's a crime, at the very least.

Ideally, pre-trial investigation and a trial would be fair way to find facts. It's entirely possible minor crimes (violating classified NDA, taking laptops, etc.) would be non-conviction based on other information, but on its face, I don't really have a problem with initial steps to investigate.

Congress would probably be a better venue for this than the courts, though.

Being charged is also pretty much necessary for asylum somewhere, too. (not essential, but it strongly helps)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by vehementi on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:53PM (#5921561)
It's kind of hard to be a whistleblower without breaking some sort of secrecy law.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:08PM (#5921615)
There actually are whistleblower protections he could have taken advantage of... but it would have meant working within the system (for example, taking his concerns to Congress or the NSA's Inspector General rather than a reporter) and it only applies if he uncovered fraud or illegal activity. AFAIK there isn't any proof that he uncovered anything illegal.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by corford on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:58PM (#5921850)
To see how working within the system went the last time an NSA employee tried to blow the whistle, go and watch these videos: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/16/snowd...
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:29AM (#5922685)
Trying to work with the system doesn't work. See the case Billy Malone and the National Park Service, etc.

You can go straight to the inspector general, they'll find that someone's life was unjustly ruined, and then sweep it under the rug after writing a report.

(http://unmpress.com/books.php?ID=12391155859919&Page=book, http://www.hcn.org/issues/43.7/a-misguided-investigation-end..., etc. for reference.)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mtgx on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:40PM (#5922009)
Binney tried to do exactly that - and they sent the FBI to raid his house.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:08PM (#5922413)
Binney, Drake, Radack, Edmunds, Tice, how many people have to try and fail with the silly "legit" whistleblower farce before people realize that it doesn't work, and isn't ever going to work.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by PavlovsCat on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:50PM (#5922363)
Nothing like having a gun pointed at you while you're in the shower to say "We aren't brownshirts, we are just so excited to hear your genuine criticism; please speak your mind freely."
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by tptacek on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:09PM (#5921623)
The national security establishment is more or less exempted from the whistleblower statutes.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:12PM (#5921635)
Going to NSA IG or the PSCI's in Congress are protected (the whole point of NSA IG is internal malfeasance, it's not just for stealing cafeteria trays...). The problem is that route of reporting may be ineffective, and once you start, you'll lose all future access, come under suspicion, and may actually still be charged (the whistleblower stuff helps more with not getting convicted).

I was originally thinking "he should have gone to IG/Congress rather than the press", but seeing the Binney/Drake/Wiebe interview where they all had gone through the IG/Congress process themselves, recognized they'd accomplished fuck-all, and supported Snowden's decision to go directly to the press/public, kind of convinced me.

I personally might have considered going to someone else in government, other than IG or H/SPSCI -- like to Udall or Rand Paul or maybe even a judge or governor -- as more effective than the "official" channels, but less illegal than a journalist.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:26PM (#5921962)
"Going to NSA IG or the PSCI's in Congress are protected"

Protected and utterly pointless. Congress already knew what was happening. The NSA's IG is not an unbiased observer.

Unfortunately, the official channels are broken here. You have members of Congress talking about how these revelations are just the tip of the iceberg. That means that they know more, that they know details that will shock people, and that they are doing nothing about it. What good would it do to go to them with this information?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by res0nat0r on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:21PM (#5922442)
Do we know for sure that the charges he is alleging are actually illegal? That I think is the crux of this whole situation. Many people in Congress might know about it and not be doing anything because like we've seen with 'enhanced interrogation techniques', is that the law has been interpreted such that all of this is technically lawful. That looks to be the real problem here.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timdev2 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:22AM (#5922951)
> Do we know for sure that the charges he is alleging are actually illegal?

No. We don't know their legality. As far as I can tell, there have been pseudo-legal rulings on the subject. But the existence, never-mind the substance, of those rulings are classified. Some people have a problem with that.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:45PM (#5922024)
Not everyone in Congress knows everything; nor do all federal judges.

I agree the NSA IG and PSCI's are essentially insiders, but "deal with this or I will go public" would give the minority members some cover.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wildster on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:31PM (#5921714)
That didn't work out very well for Thomas Drake. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Andrews_Drake
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921739)
Well, sort of. All the charges against him were dropped except a single misdemeanor. He got one year probation and community service. A very different set of circumstances than Snowden, though.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:48PM (#5921794)
And loss of pension (he was 5 years away), is now working in an Apple retail store, etc. Given that he was about as morally upstanding and cautious a whistleblower as I can imagine, it was still a pretty harsh punishment.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:31PM (#5921716)
Most of the regular statues, yes. But the Intelligence Community Whistleblower Protection Act specifically covers the national security establishment.

I will grant you that it's not the greatest law and I'm not sure I would avail myself of it if in his shoes. It does exist, though.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by baddox on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:13PM (#5922273)
And all other laws, if they choose to be.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wisty on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:13PM (#5922274)
AFAIK, other whistleblowers in the NSA have tried. The fact that it was all swept under the rug may have made Snowden consider a more rash course of action.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Andrew_Quentin on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:44AM (#5923265)
Arguably the whole programme is illegal.
[deleted]
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wavesounds on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:27PM (#5921702)
Not if your a whistleblower. What if instead of a domestic spying program he leaked a secret program by his bosses to round up every red haired and freckled person and put them in a concentration camp? Then would you still have to charge him with a crime for revealing a 'secret' program before he could be pardoned and treated as a hero? Of course not, thats ridiculous and so is this.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by brown9-2 on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921741)
But he didn't do that.

Are you a whistleblower if what you reveal isn't illegal?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:18PM (#5921931)
Yes, if what you reveal is unethical but legal. Laws are not handed down from the heavens; laws are created by a notoriously corrupt set of human beings (politicians), and can easily become disconnected from morality.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:22PM (#5922126)
The better question is: Are you a whistleblower in a legal sense if what you reveal is legal?

The government doesn't operate on unicorns and happy thoughts, it operates on the law. It's the job of the people to elect representatives such that the law conforms as much as possible to unicorns and happy thoughts.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by shawnz on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:01PM (#5922233)
Yes (or at least, possibly).

> A federal agency violates the Whistleblower Protection Act if it takes or fails to take (or threatens to take or fail to take) a personnel action with respect to any employee or applicant because of any disclosure of information by the employee or applicant that he or she reasonably believes evidences a violation of a law, rule or regulation; gross mismanagement; gross waste of funds; an abuse of authority; or a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety.

Source: http://www.sec.gov/eeoinfo/whistleblowers.htm

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:17PM (#5922285)
Looking up the Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 [1] even more closely, it appears it won't apply to Snowden here. If the material is protected from disclosure by law or E.O. (like this was) then you can only report it to the Office of Special Counsel or the agency I.G. and receive whistleblower protection.

It's in fact arguable that things like PRISM even violated any of those provisions, which makes it risky (on a legal basis) to leak even if he wasn't in the intelligence community.

[1] http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c101:1:./temp/~c101m8S...:

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:38AM (#5922615)
There is a difference between full protection (not being allowed to be fired) and not being convicted for 25-life under espionage act.

It would be insane to retain Snowden in his former role. He is an untrustworthy SCIF sysadmin. He might be worthwhile in the IG office or some public facing role, but I am fine if he is fired, clearance revoked, etc pre trial, even if his disclosures ultimately are positive and lead to legal changes and he isn't convicted.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:51AM (#5924007)
Good point, though that does make me wonder if he might have technically fallen under Whistleblower Protection (technically an HR thing) and still been liable to imprisonment based on the Espionage Act. Seems weird they'd be orthogonal, but then we're in a weird situation.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:52PM (#5922205)
laws are created by a notoriously corrupt set of human beings (politicians)

Your argument is flawed, because you're mistaking your personal opinions for fact and then trying to build logical arguments on them. Politicians are people, they're not 'a notoriously corrupt set of human beings' distinct from the normal mass of humanity.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by trobertson on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:15PM (#5922429)
Even disregarding the corruption part, his point still stands. Laws are made by people. People are not infallible. People make mistakes. It is therefore obvious that there is potential for bad and unjust laws.

Adding in the corruption part, you can then see that there is potential for laws and policies that are purposefully unjust.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:24PM (#5922451)
Of course there is! My objection is that he starts from the premise that politicians are inherently evil.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:02AM (#5922535)
It's a fact that politicians are more notorious for corruption than the average person. But even ignoring that, his argument does not depend on politicians being more evil than the average person. You're seeing a fatal flaw where there is only a molehill.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mchusma on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:23PM (#5921945)
There was a lot of illegal activity, or at least potential illegal activity, uncovered. Most notably perjury by officials, and violation of a FISA strikedown (which the EFF is trying to dig into).

The level of illegality is unclear, because we cannot investigate and the only court that can determine that consists of government officials, in secret, and no oversight. Almost every action they are taking could be completely illegal, we have no way of knowing or assessing.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:20AM (#5922672)
What he revealed is clearly unconstitutional. To say otherwise suggests that you lack basic reading comprehension or never had American history taught in 5th grade or middle school.

(...Or that our teachers taught us lies on purpose, I guess... rolls eyes)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jbooth on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:55PM (#5921832)
A number of people hold that this is illegal under the 4th amendment and founding principles of our country.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:22AM (#5922674)
I think there are good arguments that many of the policies regarding tapping, surveillance, and secret lists and trials extend into violation of not just the 4th, but the 1st, 5th, and 6th also.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by cbhl on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:16PM (#5921925)
It would be (relatively) trivial for congress to decide to make it so that "rounding up every red haired and freckled person and putting them in a concentration camp" would be legal.

The question isn't legality, per se - it's whether we believe that it follows the values and principles that we want our country to have.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by michaelhoney on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:49PM (#5922030)
.. and it's not like it hasn't been done before, to Japanese Americans in WWII.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Andrew_Quentin on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:41AM (#5923256)
Who said it is legal or illegal?

If some law contravenes the constitution that law is not legal therefore whatever the law says should not be done is legal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by 3825 on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:55PM (#5921833)
yes
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:49PM (#5922192)
What if my aunt were my uncle? Inventing an alternative set of facts to support your argument is the surest sign that something is seriously wrong wrong with your argument.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by devb on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:18PM (#5921665)
> Someone needs to be charged with a crime before a pardon can occur.

Incorrect, see Gerald Ford's preemptive pardon of Richard Nixon in 1974.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by dllthomas on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:28PM (#5921707)
My understanding is that there've been other such cases, too, though obviously lower profile.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by signed0 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:32AM (#5922602)
I doubt he actually intended to steal the laptops. Had he attempted to return them they would have caught on to his plan. It's unlikely that he would have taken them with him to Hong Kong as they would phone home.

They are probably sitting at his home just waiting for the NSA to pick them up.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:31AM (#5922688)
The laptops with files on them do demonstrate provenance of the data on them somewhat more so than standalone files, so he may have retained them for that purpose.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by e3pi on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:14PM (#5924360)
This Achilles heel of `theft of laptops' minimally should be listed in the `Don't List' of `Whistle Blowing For Dummies' to alternatively rather fatten up a Fry's $70 terra usb drive, cloud store it, etc.

Proving provenance of the data? No. If he can list it, he can edit, `touch' re-timestamp it, etc, ie, falsify it.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by gohrt on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:33PM (#5921724)
However, espionage != theft.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:54PM (#5921828)
My understanding is that he took laptops belonging to the government.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:13PM (#5922424)
Who cares? We're talking about widespread malfeasance and lawbreaking by the gov't against every citizen, and the world, vs a few crappy laptops.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:26PM (#5922453)
It possibly matters a great deal in regards to his defense.

I know i'll probably just be accused of being a pedant for pointing this out, but theft is still a crime, and theft of laptops containing classified material is really a crime, and at the very least (assuming the government didn't just make this charge up whole cloth), stealing laptops full of classified material and running off to China with them after spilling your guts to the Guardian might not tilt a jury in his favor.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rooshdi on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:42PM (#5922493)
True, but sometimes crimes against authority are necessary to counter crimes against humanity.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:55PM (#5922516)
I agree.

Nevertheless it's the kind of concrete detail I think a case can hinge on. Public opinion, too.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:26AM (#5922588)
The parent comment seemed to be questioning why he was charged with theft of government property.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:40AM (#5923952)
The theft charge is just a ruse to get the HK authorities to extradite him. If they only charged him with espionage, then there's no problem for Snowden's atty's to make the case for political persecution. The HK courts will see this for the ruse that it is.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/snowden-not...

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:53PM (#5922368)
Source? I haven't heard that charge till now.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by cLeEOGPw on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:58AM (#5923088)
But there is no legal way to show people evidence of such things. It is only made to be a crime to protect government, not people.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by pinaceae on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:37AM (#5922803)
hey, non-US citizen here. assuming you're a US citizen based on your "outrage".

the point of your defence budget (how large is it again) is to project power through the military and intelligence services.

it is ASTOUNDING that only now you seem to have realized what the US intelligennce apparatus is doing. of course they are collecting all the data, they are basically replicating google to be able to search within digital data. maybe only on foreigners, but what kind of stupid distinction is that? we have a found an al-kaida member, but he is US so hands off?

welcome to the rest of the world. ever travelled? your data is one of many intelligence databases.

i am human being, but somehow it is ok for you to spend gobs of money on monitoring ME, but once you realize it might affect YOU you suddenly get "outraged".

seriously, what DID you THINK all those intelligence services with multi-billion budgets were DOING?

looking forward to the protest by US neckbeards around the country. hope time-warner produces enough guy fawkes masks, should raise the price too. USA USA USA.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by zanny on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:30AM (#5922873)
Myself and plenty of other US citizens and residents understand the imperialistic tyrrany of the fed.

The problem is that 90% of the population isn't engaged, is brainwashed by national news networks, and is complacent in their lives eating McDonalds and watching Desperate Housewives. They accept being exploited and the atrocities they vote in with their amazing public service of going to a polling place for 10 minutes every 2 or 4 years (and they never vote for their local mayors or judges).

The only way anything would truly change in the USA is if that massive body that spans 2 deviations of income in both directions of the bell curve lost their ability to keep fattening themselves up or if they tv went out.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by kimlelly on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:34AM (#5922878)
"...your defence budget (how large is it again)"

It's about the size of the 10 biggest following countries COMBINED! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_e...

That is YOUR hard earned tax money at work AGAINST YOU.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timdev2 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:18AM (#5922939)
>> hey, non-US citizen here.

> That is YOUR hard earned tax money at work AGAINST YOU.

The guy you're yelling at is a non-US citizen who's point is "for the love of god, you ignorant american, how did you not see what's been happening until now?"

It's completely stupid that this is even a topic on HN, but the worst part is the amount of mindless shitposting going on. I mean, you just replied to a person who starts off with a disclaimer about being a not-american, and your response culimates in righteous but misplaced indignation.

Fooey.

[deleted]
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timdev2 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:21AM (#5923057)
This is a threaded discussion platform. If you're going to make an impassioned "me too" sort of reply, it's best to respect the context and make that clear.

After all, this is the internet.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by o0-0o on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:55AM (#5922907)
Black projects are not listed in a public budget. The premise of it being tax money is also suspect. The US government does not get all of the money from taxes despite the popular notion. I agree with your gist however; A modern day human sacrifice.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by avn2109 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:59AM (#5924041)
Could you list some of the other sources of government funding? The only one I can think of is the alleged CIA drug trafficking scandals from decades past.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by kragen on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:45PM (#5925252)
Illegal arms trafficking, which was somewhat more thoroughly proven than the CIA making a profit from its illegal drug trafficking. Its involvement, however, was pretty cut-and-dried, and goes far beyond being an "alleged scandal".
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Tloewald on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:15AM (#5927446)
The CIA's drug trafficking activities over the decades are a matter of historical record:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Politics_of_Heroin_in_South...

This of course does not cover Afghanistan and Iran/Contra.

Here's a paper examining CIA Black Funding simply by looking at the trillion or so dollars of misallocated DoD money over fifty or so years:

http://www1.american.edu/salla/Articles/BB-CIA.htm

A trillion here and there and pretty soon you're talking real money.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:21PM (#5921673)
These are political charges, and as the governed we should stand up to the people who are supposed to be working for us and demand that they be dropped. Immediately.

Did or did not Edward Snowden leak classified material to the press?

Does or does not the government have a duty to attempt to prosecute him?

You make it sound like he didn't actually break any laws, when he actually did break a couple. Whether the charges brought can be proven remains to be seen, but let's not assume this is a sham and a kangaroo court because you consider what Snowden did to be heroic. It may have been, but that still doesn't make it legal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eatitraw on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:48PM (#5921793)
Why such obsession about the law? Some laws are good, and that's good that they are enforced. Some laws are bad, and it is bad that they are enforced.

The whole concept of "legality" is (sadly) appropriated by governments. The government invents the rules for itself and other organizations and individuums. They ca invent whatever rules they like. Gulag was perfectly legal. Nazi concentration camps were perfectly legal.

It is stupid to assume that one's actions are bad just because they are against the law.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by lkbm on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:35AM (#5922694)
The obsession with the law is because we're a democracy, albeit far from a perfectly functioning one.

In the governments of the past, we had laws, but the king could overrule them as desired. The move to democracy involved to things: the laws being dictated by the people and the LAW being king--there's no higher power to overrule it. It can only be changed under the established procedures. That procedure is cumbersome and slow, by design (and perhaps now somewhat corrupted, sadly), but still better than the whims of the monarch.

There's a lot to be said for "what's right is king" rather than "law is king". Ideally "what's right" (probably a subset of what's right--e.g., I should be allowed to be a jerk so long as I don't violate important rights) should be democratically codified into law.

Alas, what we have now is secret, undemocratic codification of laws. Obama said in the programs' defense, "We're going to have to make some choices as a society". That's the key issue, I think: they decided to make the decision to the exclusion of society.

So maybe you're right and what's legal is less relevant than it would be in a fully functional democracy. At this point, the social contract to follow the proper democratic procedure has been violated by the makers and enforcers of the law, and following the law is consequently much less of a moral imperative.

Still, I think if we're not ready for armed revolution, legal procedure isn't entirely irrelevant. MLK's letter from Birmingham Jail is something I turn to a lot on this issue: there are times when you should break the unjust law, but when doing so, you must accept the legal repercussions.

Of course, MLK's legal consequences were a small amount of jail time. Snowden's are already significantly harsher, even without them taking him in.

(I think the gulag is a poor example, because it wasn't democratically established. The Nazi concentration camps seem like a pretty good comparison, but not because I consider them perfectly legal. Hitler was democratically elected, but I don't believe many Germans at that time were even aware of the concentration camps. They're a lot like the NSA programs in that way. They needed to make that decision as a society, but weren't given the opportunity. Thus, I don't consider them perfectly legal.)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:51PM (#5921814)
I'm not obsessed about the law. And honestly, I agree personally with everything Snowden did.

I'm just disagreeing with the premise that even having a trial is itself unjust.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by enraged_camel on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:34PM (#5922154)
If the trial is a mechanism to enforce the bad laws, of course it is unjust.

The dictionary definition is justice is "the quality of being fair and reasonable." Is there anything fair ad reasonable about how Snowden is about to be treated?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:56PM (#5922222)
And who is in charge of deciding which laws are bad? What if two people disagree about the goodness or badness of a particular law, who should prevail?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:12PM (#5922272)
If only there were some adversarial process by which these issues could be decided....
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:16PM (#5922282)
...we could enshrine it in our constitution!
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by sneak on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:51AM (#5923012)
And then invent distributed email cryptography systems to keep them from spying on us! And buy that sweet new Nirvana album!
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:25PM (#5925552)
Nirvana? Meh. They just ripped off the Pixies.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:08PM (#5922261)
You seem to be presuming absolute corruption on the part of the legal system and absolute innocence on the part of Edward Snowden. What would you expect to happen, under these circumstances?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by schreiaj on Saturday June 22, 2013 @09:48PM (#5925933)
> It is stupid to assume that one's actions are bad just because they are against the law.

Yeah, it is. But the law is there and we still have to follow it until we can change it. Part of what makes people that conscientiously break the law for personal beliefs heroes (insert civil rights activist of choice here) is that they do so knowing that they are going against the law and willingly face that.

I respect a person who will take a stand and face the consequences of their actions.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jychang on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:49PM (#5921797)
Soldiers are supposed to disobey their military superiors if told to commit crimes against humanity.

Breaking a law, especially when doing something obviously right, does not mean that you need to have charges brought against you. Say you see a dog about to drown in a creek on private property. If you ran in and saved it, the owner could charge you for trespassing. That doesn't mean they SHOULD.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timr on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:08PM (#5922084)
"Soldiers are supposed to disobey their military superiors if told to commit crimes against humanity."

Well, no. A soldier isn't supposed to say "I think that command is illegal under international law, therefore I will choose not to follow it." They'll be court-martialed, and rightly so. Choosing to make that call is intentionally risky, because it's supposed to be rare.

Likewise, Snowden will be prosecuted...and rightly so. He broke a bunch of laws. Maybe he did that out of a sense of righteousness, but the greater legality of his decision is not for him to decide.

But even ignoring all of that, the premise of your metaphor is absurd: Snowden revealed information about legal surveillance programs that weren't acutely harming anyone, and he might have hurt national security in the process. That's a far cry from preventing "crimes against humanity". Perspective, please.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:14PM (#5922426)
> * They'll be court-martialed, and rightly so.*

Rightly so?

You are saying that a soldier who understands an order to be in violation of law (in this instance, to commit some unspecified crimes against humanity) would be justly court-martialed, and that it should happen?

The entire point of refusing to obey orders that violate the law, or of refusing to abide by an unjust law, or refusing to be complicit in systemic abuses of secret interpretations of a given law that one believes to violate other laws and/or established principles (e.g., the Constitution) is to call attention to the wrongness of that which one is refusing to do. It is to call attention to wrongdoing, whether that be to actions or laws that violate the greater body of law and principles of a given civil society. The proper response would be an evaluation and public reflection upon the practices/acts to which the public's attention has been focused.

In Snowden's case, as with other whistleblowers, it is extremely difficult to properly blow the whistle without breaking some law(s). There are so many laws out there, that if everyone who broke a law was prosecuted, we'd wind up with 100% of the adult citizenry with criminal records and jail time. The goal of justice is not to indiscriminately prosecute every person who attempts to protect and improve our society by refusing to follow unjust laws and their associated actions. Would that more citizens and public officials would refuse to act in a way that even remotely resembles violating anyone's constitutionally delineated rights, and all those not so delineated, which are reserved to the states and to the People.

If indiscriminate prosecution was the goal of justice, we'd better update our positions accordingly on everything. That means we need to look back and say a good century's worth of prosecuting black people for drinking from the wrong fountain was just. We should start prosecuting those who violate laws that prohibit you from throwing away mail that isn't addressed to you. We should stand up and call for the prosecution of homosexuals and heterosexuals under state sodomy laws and, when they are so prosecuted, we should sit back in our armchairs, cross our legs, and declare, "Rightly so."

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:29PM (#5922140)
Actually, in the U.S. servicemembers are supposed to refuse to follow orders that are not lawful.

You are right that such cases are (and are meant to be) exceptionally rare. The U.S. Supreme Court gives exceptionally wide latitude in what counts as a lawful order, and as far as I know no servicemember has ever been tried (much less convicted) for following a valid order (even if they thought it was illegal).

But with that said I agree with your overall point that Snowden did break the law with at least some of his disclosures. If so much as one document he leaked was found to describe action that was legal (even if unethical) he would fall afoul of various U.S. laws protecting classified information.

Likewise, even if he leaked information describing activities found to be illegal, he may still get in trouble for not following Congress's approved route for such leaks (I'm not sure if that would be technically criminal or administrative in nature though).

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timr on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:08PM (#5922260)
"The U.S. Supreme Court gives exceptionally wide latitude in what counts as a lawful order, and as far as I know no servicemember has ever been tried (much less convicted) for following a valid order (even if they thought it was illegal)."

Yes, exactly. And of course, there have been many examples of soldiers who were court-martialed for disobeying orders. The risk of disobeying is on the soldier -- they're taking their life in their hands when they make the decision to cross a superior. It's not as if the military says: "oh, you thought that order was illegal? We won't court-martial you, then."

The parent comment was totally specious, because Snowden is being treated exactly the way any soldier would be treated for a similar behavior. We don't just automatically pardon people for breaking laws because they broke laws with patriotic intent.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:15PM (#5922428)
Snowden is not, nor ought he be treated like or held to the standard of being, a soldier.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by XorNot on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:55AM (#5922739)
He signed the relevant NDAs and was granted Top Secret clearance. He's being held to the standard of anyone else who does that without enjoying some type of exceptional legal protection.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:45PM (#5924699)
That is not the same thing as the comment to which I responded. Moreover, this isn't a simple matter of violating NDAs and TS clearance by mentioning classified information to some random persons. The situation is more profound and nuanced. He violated the NDAs and TS clearance to call the People's attention to unconstitutional programs that violate our rights and laws as a whistleblower. There is "some type of exceptional legal protection" to be evaluated there.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:55PM (#5924736)
Just for the flipside though, he did this to call attention to unconstitutional programs in his opinion.

There is a reason we don't generally allow individuals to each individually determine what the Constitution does or does not mean.

There is a famous example in the military of an Army major (doctor) who refused to deploy to Afghanistan because he claimed it was unconstitutional.

You might think he was referring to the war, but instead he was referring to his Commander-in-Chief himself (Pres. Obama), who this major personally felt was a Muslim Kenyan who somehow managed to finagle himself into the Presidency.

It's hardly conclusive that what Snowden has revealed so far is even likely unconstitutional. It seems the most you can say is that the NSA is simply not being very nice at all to the rest of the world, but the Supreme Court decisions up to this point (including recent ones relating to Guantanamo's prison) have generally treated the rest of the world as not worthy of any but the most basic Constitutional protections.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by glurgh on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:43PM (#5922170)
He's in Hong Kong talking about US intelligence operations in Hong Kong. Short of the government not charging him for that specific thing (say, to avoid talking about it altogether), there's doesn't seem to be any way to avoid getting in trouble for it.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by btilly on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:14AM (#5922559)
Everyone seems to be mad about that one.

However I've yet to see ANYONE in the mainstream press point out that the Obama administration was recently trying to pass legislation that reduced privacy protection for Americans as a response to the Chinese doing exactly what we are doing to the Chinese. There is a high level of hypocrisy here.

Call me an idealist, but my belief is that the USA as a country should take the moral high ground, even if it costs us tactically in the short run.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by lern_too_spel on Saturday June 22, 2013 @03:36AM (#5922882)
Obama threatened to veto CISPA if it landed on his desk without the privacy issues fixed.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by btilly on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:06AM (#5922922)
Yes, once it was clear in polling that the bill was a political nonstarter nation-wide, Obama took that position. At the same time, as http://rt.com/usa/epic-foia-internet-surveillance-350/ among others pointed out at that point, his administration was already violating privacy in all the ways that his rhetoric would say were bad.

Of course that was before the NSA revelations revealed the true extent of the spying going on.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by glurgh on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:32PM (#5922148)
Well, yes. Soldiers are very much supposed to disobey unlawful orders - following unlawful orders is what can get you courtmartialed and 'I was just following orders' isn't going to be an effective defense.

Of course, this is all a bit moot because Snowden definitely did something illegal and it's not clear yet whether anything he reported was itself illegal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by DennisP on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:03AM (#5923818)
Fwiw, enlisted soldiers swear an oath to obey. Officers do not. And both swear to defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic, which certainly applies in this case.

Enlisted oath: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oath_of_enlistment

Officers' oath: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Uniformed_Service...

Not that Snowden is either, but you were talking about when soldiers may disobey their superiors so I thought this might be tangentially interesting.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by lotharbot on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:58PM (#5921851)
There are provisions built into the law for circumstances when you did "something obviously right" but are charged with a crime which was technically committed in the process of doing the right thing.

"the defendant must affirmatively show (i.e., introduce some evidence) that (a) the harm he sought to avoid outweighs the danger of the prohibited conduct he is charged with; (b) he had no reasonable alternative; (c) he ceased to engage in the prohibited conduct as soon as the danger passed; and (d) he did not himself create the danger he sought to avoid."

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity , which is a specific case of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by gohrt on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921740)
The executive has a duty to examine the situation and decide whether the NSA's activities were wrong, and whether Snowden was acting in the national interest when he leaked.

Now every law is legal, that's why we have a Supreme Court. Ergo, not every lawbreak is illegal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by zacharyvoase on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:14PM (#5921646)
The role of the prosecutor is to prosecute the interests of the State, which in this case they have done.

I’m wondering how grand juries play into this—the Fifth Amendment states that “no person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury” (except for those in the military, which I think he wouldn’t classify as).

There’s a great article here which describes the power which Grand Juries used to wield in the indictment process, specifically the ability to act on their own, investigate, and actually challenge the federal prosecutor rather than just rubber-stamping each case: http://constitution.org/lrev/roots/runaway.htm

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by neurotech1 on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:13PM (#5921910)
I remember reading several points(Wikipedia) 98% Grand Juries return an indictment, rarely narrowing or broadening the charges;

90% of Federal Criminal Cases are Plea Bargained before trial;

90% of Federal Criminal trials result in a conviction;

This is why the Aaron Swartz was so wrong, once the prosecutor decided to overzealously present the charges to a grand jury, the odds were stacked against him.

Snowden is in big trouble, because in this case its highly unlikely that President Obama will pardon him, although popularly requested to do so.

So yes, the whole prosecution process has runaway from the original goal of justice.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:15PM (#5922432)
Snowden will still be in HK courts after the next presidential election.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:28PM (#5921968)
"The role of the prosecutor is to prosecute the interests of the State"

One would think that, as public servants, their role is to prosecute in the interests of the public at large. That might mean going against the interests of the state, if the state is working against the public.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by baddox on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:16PM (#5922281)
That would only be in the case of a government that represents the people and has their consent to govern.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by pfortuny on Monday June 24, 2013 @05:46AM (#5931935)
You are mistaking State for Government. The State simply exists, that is why it has to be defended. The State does not act by itself (it is the Government, "in its name"). This is why the State would be defenseless if prosecutors did not exist, and this is why separation of powers is so important.

I know I am speaking roughly and without technicalities, but the fact that the Government does something does not imply that the State wants is (which is, for example, why the 4th amendment exists: in order to protect, in some way, the State from the Government). And that is why the Constitution is above all mandates of the Government, even if they have been approved by Congress and the military are 'pushing' them.

"The interests of the public at large" is what is meant by the State.

That is why trials (those dealing with the Federation) begin with the words "The US vs whomever", not "The Government of the US" or "The President of the US".

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by skwirl on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:46PM (#5921525)
I don't think putting pressure on the government to fire the prosecutor who filed the petition is likely to work. A poll earlier this week found that the majority of Americans want Snowden charged and disapprove of what he has done. You need to start with petitioning your fellow Americans.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by gohrt on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:39PM (#5921750)
Majority is not how criminal issues are decided, so that's not an appropriate bar for public opinion.

For example (similar, but exactly the same angle), a conviction requires a unanimous vote, not a majority vote.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by skwirl on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:43PM (#5922017)
I was replying to someone who wanted to pressure the administration into firing a prosecutor for prosecuting Snowden. It seems unlikely that they will be swayed when the majority of Americans want Snowden prosecuted.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by stefanix on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:59PM (#5921581)
Was it one of these polls where they only call landlines? Not sure this means anything without exactly specifying how the poll was conducted.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by skwirl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:28PM (#5921704)
No. Most of the major polling organizations call cell phones now, except for automated ones like Rasmussen. This was from Pew. From http://www.people-press.org/methodology/our-survey-methodolo...:

"The typical Pew Research Center for the People & the Press national survey selects a random digit sample of both landline and cell phone numbers in all 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia. As the proportion of Americans who rely solely or mostly on cell phones for their telephone service continues to grow, sampling both landline and cell phone numbers helps to ensure that our surveys represent all adults who have access to either (only about 2% of households in the U.S. do not have access to any phone)."

Here are the full results: http://www.people-press.org/2013/06/17/public-split-over-imp...

And just because it is interesting:

"People under 30 are the only age group in which a clear majority (60%) says that the release of classified information about the NSA phone and email data collection program serves the public interest."

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by coolhandluke on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:30PM (#5922316)
> "People under 30 are the only age group in which a clear majority (60%) says that the release of classified information about the NSA phone and email data collection program serves the public interest."

I wonder if that's because, as if often said, that the people in this age group have grown up in a time when posting your "private information" (including your activities, who you associate with, etc.) is the norm.

Many of the so-called "Facebook generation", for example, seem to not give a damn about the surveillance and spying (based upon my admittedly small sample size) that is being conducted. They are already accustomed to so much more of their "private" data being public -- many of them, in fact, are quite happy to make it public.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by dllthomas on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:30PM (#5921712)
Though of course, people who are deeply concerned about their privacy are likely to be under-represented in any poll.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by skwirl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921742)
Perhaps not. In the same poll, 63% said that if Snowden's claims were true, they would feel that their personal privacy has been violated. It just doesn't translate into the public wanting him to walk free.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by dllthomas on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:38PM (#5921746)
There's a significant space between "deeply concerned" and "unconcerned."
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by nanidin on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:41PM (#5921763)
I generally don't answer my cell phone unless I know who is calling. If I did answer and it was a poll, 99% of the time I would just hang up.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:47PM (#5921529)
Huh? Why would the prosecutor be fired?

And a Congressional pardon? Are you sure about that?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by sigzero on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:51PM (#5921545)
Neither of those is ever going to happen, petition or no petition.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jlgreco on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:53PM (#5921557)
Of course, but that is a poor reason to not make your voice heard.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by sigzero on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:10PM (#5921632)
Who do you think is reading that petition? I would postulate, only the signers. You also make it sound like that is the only way to get your voice "heard".
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jlgreco on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:12PM (#5921638)
You're right, I've wasted 30 seconds of my life. I am now filled with regret.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by cantos on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:05PM (#5921884)
I postulate that it would be a good place to start.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by baddox on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:15PM (#5922278)
The fact that the time it takes to sign a petition is worth more than the effect it will have is a good reason to not make your voice heard.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by logn on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:11AM (#5922552)
People need to organize and protest, online and in person. That means, an organized blackout like SOPA/PIPA and organized public (in real life) protests. I like the whitehouse.gov petitions, but I don't know of an instance where they've helped anything (in their short history). The Baby Boomers got plenty done with protests. And Google/Wikipedia/etc stopped SOPA/PIPA with a massive online blackout. Of course, the tech industry largely benefits from intelligence spending, so I'm not sure how much of a protest could be organized online. Perhaps the users themselves need to boycott any company not opposed to surveillance (say, replacing their avatar with some indication of their boycott and deleting all their content).

Also, I think we need the Republicans (or anyone) to impeach Obama, for the good of the country.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by laureny on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:07PM (#5922254)
> These are political charges

What does this mean exactly? "Political charge" is absurd.

Besides, are you seriously suggesting that a petition should be enough to drop criminal charges brought upon someone? That's not how things work in any civilized country.

I tend to side with him at the moment but there is no way I will trust my judgment, or that of 90,000 angry online petition signers, to decide justice for me. Let the trial happen, let's see everything that's going on, this will bring up a lot of things up in the open.

Maybe we'll find he's a hero and he's done nothing wrong, or maybe we'll find that he has sold intelligence to the Chinese or whatever.

Either way, the right way is to go through the judiciary system.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by B0Z on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:32PM (#5921445)
Does anyone else smell "Friday Night News Dump"?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jlgreco on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:35PM (#5921457)
Yes, though it is important to keep in mind that 40% of all sickdays are taken on Mondays or Fridays.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by scw on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:40PM (#5921488)
Isn't Monday and Friday 40% of the work week?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jlgreco on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:44PM (#5921517)
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:43PM (#5921512)
Yes, I am surprised at how quiet they've been this week. Must've grown tired of having every new denial answered with a new document showing them to be lying again.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by SCAQTony on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:50PM (#5921806)
In a way that is good indicator that they are beginning to worry their timing so as limit the political damage from the "huddled masses yearning to breathe free."
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by saurabhnanda on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:53PM (#5922510)
There's another way to demonstrate just how unhappy you are with the trampling of your basic rigthts.

Guns.

Go out on the streets in meaningful numbers brandishing unloaded guns to show the govt how serious you are about the issue. It's a much stronger form of protest IMO.

(PS: I know I'll get downvoted for such radical comments, but moderation has stopped working with govts)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:00AM (#5922529)
What would even be the point if the guns weren't loaded? You shouldn't be willing to march en masse into the streets with weapons you're not prepared to use, otherwise it's an idle threat. Signs and slogans would literally be more useful. Then at least, the news media might report on the message and not the guns.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by alex_doom on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:03AM (#5922539)
Needs a better catch phrase like "You can take away my ability to share digital files that the public needs to know about when you pry them from my cold dead hands!"
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rwmj on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:02AM (#5922918)
The Rule of Law here pretty clearly says Snowdon should be charged, and convicted if guilty. The prosecutors are doing their jobs by arresting him.

Pardoning him would be the Rule of Man.

Just sayin' ..

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:49AM (#5922632)
So now is the time to identify the federal prosecutors who filed this and petition the government to have them fired.

For what, doing their jobs? Protest by all means, but demanding that prosecutors be fired for executing the law is just ridiculous.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Amadou on Saturday June 22, 2013 @08:34AM (#5923374)
I don't think it is all that ridiculous. Prosecutors have tremendous amounts of discretion regarding who they prosecute and what for. They aren't just "doing their jobs" they are explicitly targeting Snowden. The fact that it is their legal prerogative to do so does not necessarily make it ethically correct.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @06:50PM (#5925438)
I would love to see some examples of people who have engaged in similar practices that we didn't bother to prosecute. Like people complaining about 'Obama's war on Leakers,' these assertions of prosecutorial vindictiveness are meaningless without context.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by nhangen on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:07PM (#5922080)
I'm sure the prosecutors that filed this did so at the behest of their superiors, and/or the POTUS, Justice Department, and everyone with a dog in this fight. Going after them would probably be the best thing that could happen for the rest. Have to aim higher.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by blueprint on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:01PM (#5921866)
How should we go about identifying the federal prosecutors?
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by coolhandluke on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:32PM (#5922320)
The charging documents (which should be public) will contain an affirmation/confirmation section that includes the prosecutor's name and signature.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by o0-0o on Saturday June 22, 2013 @02:44AM (#5922813)
The charges are sealed.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by theklub on Saturday June 22, 2013 @09:24AM (#5923504)
If someone can kickstart a fund for Turkey why can't get do it for Snowden? Lets get some full page ads out there!
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by throwaway10001 on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:34PM (#5922327)
So now is the time to identify the federal prosecutors who filed this and petition the government to have them fired.

That's the wrong target, Snowden clearly broke the law, and that's what the prosecutors are alleging. You could argue that the laws are unjust (Call Congress!) and so on but apparently everything NSA did was rubber stamped by judges so they have the seal of approval. Snowden knows it too, he himself said that he will be made to suffer.

Obama will never pardon him, imagine the precedent? He will have to take whatever is coming and let history judge him, espionage or civil disobedience?