News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:42PM (#5921499)
I actually don't think charging him is inherently bad. If he in fact took 4 government property laptops with him, that's a crime, at the very least.

Ideally, pre-trial investigation and a trial would be fair way to find facts. It's entirely possible minor crimes (violating classified NDA, taking laptops, etc.) would be non-conviction based on other information, but on its face, I don't really have a problem with initial steps to investigate.

Congress would probably be a better venue for this than the courts, though.

Being charged is also pretty much necessary for asylum somewhere, too. (not essential, but it strongly helps)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by vehementi on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:53PM (#5921561)
It's kind of hard to be a whistleblower without breaking some sort of secrecy law.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:08PM (#5921615)
There actually are whistleblower protections he could have taken advantage of... but it would have meant working within the system (for example, taking his concerns to Congress or the NSA's Inspector General rather than a reporter) and it only applies if he uncovered fraud or illegal activity. AFAIK there isn't any proof that he uncovered anything illegal.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by corford on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:58PM (#5921850)
To see how working within the system went the last time an NSA employee tried to blow the whistle, go and watch these videos: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/16/snowd...
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:29AM (#5922685)
Trying to work with the system doesn't work. See the case Billy Malone and the National Park Service, etc.

You can go straight to the inspector general, they'll find that someone's life was unjustly ruined, and then sweep it under the rug after writing a report.

(http://unmpress.com/books.php?ID=12391155859919&Page=book, http://www.hcn.org/issues/43.7/a-misguided-investigation-end..., etc. for reference.)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mtgx on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:40PM (#5922009)
Binney tried to do exactly that - and they sent the FBI to raid his house.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:08PM (#5922413)
Binney, Drake, Radack, Edmunds, Tice, how many people have to try and fail with the silly "legit" whistleblower farce before people realize that it doesn't work, and isn't ever going to work.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by PavlovsCat on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:50PM (#5922363)
Nothing like having a gun pointed at you while you're in the shower to say "We aren't brownshirts, we are just so excited to hear your genuine criticism; please speak your mind freely."
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by tptacek on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:09PM (#5921623)
The national security establishment is more or less exempted from the whistleblower statutes.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:12PM (#5921635)
Going to NSA IG or the PSCI's in Congress are protected (the whole point of NSA IG is internal malfeasance, it's not just for stealing cafeteria trays...). The problem is that route of reporting may be ineffective, and once you start, you'll lose all future access, come under suspicion, and may actually still be charged (the whistleblower stuff helps more with not getting convicted).

I was originally thinking "he should have gone to IG/Congress rather than the press", but seeing the Binney/Drake/Wiebe interview where they all had gone through the IG/Congress process themselves, recognized they'd accomplished fuck-all, and supported Snowden's decision to go directly to the press/public, kind of convinced me.

I personally might have considered going to someone else in government, other than IG or H/SPSCI -- like to Udall or Rand Paul or maybe even a judge or governor -- as more effective than the "official" channels, but less illegal than a journalist.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:26PM (#5921962)
"Going to NSA IG or the PSCI's in Congress are protected"

Protected and utterly pointless. Congress already knew what was happening. The NSA's IG is not an unbiased observer.

Unfortunately, the official channels are broken here. You have members of Congress talking about how these revelations are just the tip of the iceberg. That means that they know more, that they know details that will shock people, and that they are doing nothing about it. What good would it do to go to them with this information?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by res0nat0r on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:21PM (#5922442)
Do we know for sure that the charges he is alleging are actually illegal? That I think is the crux of this whole situation. Many people in Congress might know about it and not be doing anything because like we've seen with 'enhanced interrogation techniques', is that the law has been interpreted such that all of this is technically lawful. That looks to be the real problem here.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by timdev2 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:22AM (#5922951)
> Do we know for sure that the charges he is alleging are actually illegal?

No. We don't know their legality. As far as I can tell, there have been pseudo-legal rulings on the subject. But the existence, never-mind the substance, of those rulings are classified. Some people have a problem with that.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:45PM (#5922024)
Not everyone in Congress knows everything; nor do all federal judges.

I agree the NSA IG and PSCI's are essentially insiders, but "deal with this or I will go public" would give the minority members some cover.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wildster on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:31PM (#5921714)
That didn't work out very well for Thomas Drake. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Andrews_Drake
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921739)
Well, sort of. All the charges against him were dropped except a single misdemeanor. He got one year probation and community service. A very different set of circumstances than Snowden, though.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:48PM (#5921794)
And loss of pension (he was 5 years away), is now working in an Apple retail store, etc. Given that he was about as morally upstanding and cautious a whistleblower as I can imagine, it was still a pretty harsh punishment.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:31PM (#5921716)
Most of the regular statues, yes. But the Intelligence Community Whistleblower Protection Act specifically covers the national security establishment.

I will grant you that it's not the greatest law and I'm not sure I would avail myself of it if in his shoes. It does exist, though.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by baddox on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:13PM (#5922273)
And all other laws, if they choose to be.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wisty on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:13PM (#5922274)
AFAIK, other whistleblowers in the NSA have tried. The fact that it was all swept under the rug may have made Snowden consider a more rash course of action.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Andrew_Quentin on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:44AM (#5923265)
Arguably the whole programme is illegal.
[deleted]
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by wavesounds on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:27PM (#5921702)
Not if your a whistleblower. What if instead of a domestic spying program he leaked a secret program by his bosses to round up every red haired and freckled person and put them in a concentration camp? Then would you still have to charge him with a crime for revealing a 'secret' program before he could be pardoned and treated as a hero? Of course not, thats ridiculous and so is this.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by brown9-2 on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:36PM (#5921741)
But he didn't do that.

Are you a whistleblower if what you reveal isn't illegal?

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by betterunix on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:18PM (#5921931)
Yes, if what you reveal is unethical but legal. Laws are not handed down from the heavens; laws are created by a notoriously corrupt set of human beings (politicians), and can easily become disconnected from morality.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:22PM (#5922126)
The better question is: Are you a whistleblower in a legal sense if what you reveal is legal?

The government doesn't operate on unicorns and happy thoughts, it operates on the law. It's the job of the people to elect representatives such that the law conforms as much as possible to unicorns and happy thoughts.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by shawnz on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:01PM (#5922233)
Yes (or at least, possibly).

> A federal agency violates the Whistleblower Protection Act if it takes or fails to take (or threatens to take or fail to take) a personnel action with respect to any employee or applicant because of any disclosure of information by the employee or applicant that he or she reasonably believes evidences a violation of a law, rule or regulation; gross mismanagement; gross waste of funds; an abuse of authority; or a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety.

Source: http://www.sec.gov/eeoinfo/whistleblowers.htm

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:17PM (#5922285)
Looking up the Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 [1] even more closely, it appears it won't apply to Snowden here. If the material is protected from disclosure by law or E.O. (like this was) then you can only report it to the Office of Special Counsel or the agency I.G. and receive whistleblower protection.

It's in fact arguable that things like PRISM even violated any of those provisions, which makes it risky (on a legal basis) to leak even if he wasn't in the intelligence community.

[1] http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c101:1:./temp/~c101m8S...:

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:38AM (#5922615)
There is a difference between full protection (not being allowed to be fired) and not being convicted for 25-life under espionage act.

It would be insane to retain Snowden in his former role. He is an untrustworthy SCIF sysadmin. He might be worthwhile in the IG office or some public facing role, but I am fine if he is fired, clearance revoked, etc pre trial, even if his disclosures ultimately are positive and lead to legal changes and he isn't convicted.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mpyne on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:51AM (#5924007)
Good point, though that does make me wonder if he might have technically fallen under Whistleblower Protection (technically an HR thing) and still been liable to imprisonment based on the Espionage Act. Seems weird they'd be orthogonal, but then we're in a weird situation.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:52PM (#5922205)
laws are created by a notoriously corrupt set of human beings (politicians)

Your argument is flawed, because you're mistaking your personal opinions for fact and then trying to build logical arguments on them. Politicians are people, they're not 'a notoriously corrupt set of human beings' distinct from the normal mass of humanity.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by trobertson on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:15PM (#5922429)
Even disregarding the corruption part, his point still stands. Laws are made by people. People are not infallible. People make mistakes. It is therefore obvious that there is potential for bad and unjust laws.

Adding in the corruption part, you can then see that there is potential for laws and policies that are purposefully unjust.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:24PM (#5922451)
Of course there is! My objection is that he starts from the premise that politicians are inherently evil.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:02AM (#5922535)
It's a fact that politicians are more notorious for corruption than the average person. But even ignoring that, his argument does not depend on politicians being more evil than the average person. You're seeing a fatal flaw where there is only a molehill.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by mchusma on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:23PM (#5921945)
There was a lot of illegal activity, or at least potential illegal activity, uncovered. Most notably perjury by officials, and violation of a FISA strikedown (which the EFF is trying to dig into).

The level of illegality is unclear, because we cannot investigate and the only court that can determine that consists of government officials, in secret, and no oversight. Almost every action they are taking could be completely illegal, we have no way of knowing or assessing.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:20AM (#5922672)
What he revealed is clearly unconstitutional. To say otherwise suggests that you lack basic reading comprehension or never had American history taught in 5th grade or middle school.

(...Or that our teachers taught us lies on purpose, I guess... rolls eyes)

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by jbooth on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:55PM (#5921832)
A number of people hold that this is illegal under the 4th amendment and founding principles of our country.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Glyptodon on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:22AM (#5922674)
I think there are good arguments that many of the policies regarding tapping, surveillance, and secret lists and trials extend into violation of not just the 4th, but the 1st, 5th, and 6th also.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by cbhl on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:16PM (#5921925)
It would be (relatively) trivial for congress to decide to make it so that "rounding up every red haired and freckled person and putting them in a concentration camp" would be legal.

The question isn't legality, per se - it's whether we believe that it follows the values and principles that we want our country to have.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by michaelhoney on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:49PM (#5922030)
.. and it's not like it hasn't been done before, to Japanese Americans in WWII.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by Andrew_Quentin on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:41AM (#5923256)
Who said it is legal or illegal?

If some law contravenes the constitution that law is not legal therefore whatever the law says should not be done is legal.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by 3825 on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:55PM (#5921833)
yes
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:49PM (#5922192)
What if my aunt were my uncle? Inventing an alternative set of facts to support your argument is the surest sign that something is seriously wrong wrong with your argument.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by devb on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:18PM (#5921665)
> Someone needs to be charged with a crime before a pardon can occur.

Incorrect, see Gerald Ford's preemptive pardon of Richard Nixon in 1974.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by dllthomas on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:28PM (#5921707)
My understanding is that there've been other such cases, too, though obviously lower profile.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by signed0 on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:32AM (#5922602)
I doubt he actually intended to steal the laptops. Had he attempted to return them they would have caught on to his plan. It's unlikely that he would have taken them with him to Hong Kong as they would phone home.

They are probably sitting at his home just waiting for the NSA to pick them up.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rdl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:31AM (#5922688)
The laptops with files on them do demonstrate provenance of the data on them somewhat more so than standalone files, so he may have retained them for that purpose.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by e3pi on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:14PM (#5924360)
This Achilles heel of `theft of laptops' minimally should be listed in the `Don't List' of `Whistle Blowing For Dummies' to alternatively rather fatten up a Fry's $70 terra usb drive, cloud store it, etc.

Proving provenance of the data? No. If he can list it, he can edit, `touch' re-timestamp it, etc, ie, falsify it.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by gohrt on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:33PM (#5921724)
However, espionage != theft.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:54PM (#5921828)
My understanding is that he took laptops belonging to the government.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:13PM (#5922424)
Who cares? We're talking about widespread malfeasance and lawbreaking by the gov't against every citizen, and the world, vs a few crappy laptops.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:26PM (#5922453)
It possibly matters a great deal in regards to his defense.

I know i'll probably just be accused of being a pedant for pointing this out, but theft is still a crime, and theft of laptops containing classified material is really a crime, and at the very least (assuming the government didn't just make this charge up whole cloth), stealing laptops full of classified material and running off to China with them after spilling your guts to the Guardian might not tilt a jury in his favor.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by rooshdi on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:42PM (#5922493)
True, but sometimes crimes against authority are necessary to counter crimes against humanity.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by krapp on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:55PM (#5922516)
I agree.

Nevertheless it's the kind of concrete detail I think a case can hinge on. Public opinion, too.

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by eli on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:26AM (#5922588)
The parent comment seemed to be questioning why he was charged with theft of government property.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:40AM (#5923952)
The theft charge is just a ruse to get the HK authorities to extradite him. If they only charged him with espionage, then there's no problem for Snowden's atty's to make the case for political persecution. The HK courts will see this for the ruse that it is.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/snowden-not...

Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by bobwaycott on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:53PM (#5922368)
Source? I haven't heard that charge till now.
Re:U.S. charges Edward Snowden with espionage by cLeEOGPw on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:58AM (#5923088)
But there is no legal way to show people evidence of such things. It is only made to be a crime to protect government, not people.