Lockstep processors, hardware security modules with immutable unreadable keys, and PKI keys that the mfg holds the private for that can only be accessed on their online services.
It’s locked down now and this started in 2018 or so. It’s just worse now.
To automotive, there is really still no right to repair. They get around it by selling “3 day passes” to their service, but with their hardware and at their prices.
They’re all moving the Tesla system of more centralized brain systems which will be even more protected.
Let's be clear that it's just incentives. If the EU economy was based on creating companies and new products there would not be as many incentives for consumer "rights" there.
Not for auto owners. Auto makers and dealers get away with a lot of shady shit fucking over their customers in the EU all the time.
Like sibling said, there are incentives to regulate stuff that has no impact on EU businesses, shit like USB-C or replaceable batteries, but they won't touch the auto industry to mandate easier repairs and less lock-downs.
Pure battery EVs are considered to have no emissions-related components, which is why Tesla gets away with that they do.
You want to use it? Go ahead and buy a 1,3,7,30 day pass to the mfg’s service. Then, good luck with your J2534 because they only approve a couple, and better find a windows machine because their .NET program only runs on Windows 10.
We do, but everything is "software defined car" now and loopholes usually get closed with mandatory software updates done with the mandatory inspections. They put everything in one basket together with safety critical systems because that justifies any lockdown.
> Right to repair laws laws usually give you the right to use non-OEM parts.
Manufacturers already make that very expensive. Mechanics have to be certified, they need special and very expensive tools, everything is wrapped in cryptography and the manufacturer has to be in the middle of everything, for a price. [0] So go ahead, use your OEM part, you'll still pay thousands for the mechanic that has the necessary prerequisites and for the manufacturer's services.
I pray I'm wrong but we need strong regulation and enforcement, and the manufacturers can still maliciously comply.
Nothing prevents you from unplugging the cell modem. The car will still work.
Why would they? They just need to fund lobbyist to make it illegal for any AI to reverse engineer anything copyrighted or with IP.
Sure, you can use open source AI to do it but not everyone will/can do it.
So, they don't need to ban everyone, they just need to make sure the final code isn't available freely on GitHub. That would minimize the damage, it's not a perfect solution but more than enough to protect the company.
Making something impossible to do is more thorough than making it illegal to do
Unless your company's moat is in the thing that was reversed engineer, I don't think most company cared enough to spend huge amount of resource to prevent it technically. The only thing that they need to prevent is the liability that comes after the product is used inappropriately or illegally.
And it you can defend something with AI, there's no reason why you can't attack it AI.
Don’t hold your breath.
I suspect you're right BUT still maintain a bit of optimism. We miiiight end up in a future where most hardware comes with an OK-ish app/interface and some sort of LLM-Friendly technical documentation so if you don't like $aspect of the device, you're free to roll your own after indemnifying the manufacturer via something like an eFuse.
or maybe I really am naive :(
I think most people on here fail to realize the demand to customize and build things hasnt gone up. Just because llms exist now doesnt mean normies all of a sudden want to start getting into programming, they dont care.
The only number thats gone up is people who were slightly interested in programming/CS before but were too undisciplined to learn things themselves. Llms are great for those lazy people.
I still get the joy of translating ideas and orchestrating and architecting solutions to problems I have in real life, but just at a quicker pace.
If some of those tools and solutions can help other people, that's great. If not, that's okay too. I hope everyone sort of has that mindset who's building today.
Me!
haha I dont even know github I use it as google
Yes I have full time IT job xD
I spent years and years learning coding, but when I finally got old enough, I realized I needed to graduate uni, get a job, get money, and get out of my parents house ASAP.
So I had to hone all the things I'd learned and just focus on one path. (Over generalization but whatever front/back/fullstack is, as that's what a majority of the jobs are).
I was always going to have discipline for things related to my job, but no way in hell was I ever going to learn: The insides of my car, am I getting scammed on the price of tyres, what's the best diet/nutrition, how to fix a door, how does the AC work.
Even on the job, what's the best way to do XYZ. Well, I want the best way possible, but that's just not going to happen. (Talking about pre LLM coding).
With all the new LLMs and coding agents, I'm quite happy to say, that I can figure out how to do all these things much more lazily, and efficiently. I definitely see a future where I can now learn to fix my own car, my door, etc.
Is this just "vibes"? Maybe, but I now have a full, verified spec, against which to build software for myself, also with a little bit of "vibes".
Is this a good or bad thing?
that is entirely dependent how accurate the spec is
> verified spec
I'm currently teasing apart numerous ancient Text to Speech synthesizers with Sol and the amount of times I ask a follow up question that forces it to correct 5 things it's already said/documented is ridiculous.
What degree of verification would make you say it's worth something?
But this is your unspecified expensive device. A verified spec wouldn't have you send a command or configure a table that bricks or damages it. A vibe verified spec very well might. How much is that worth to you? What are you willing to lose?
Hard to judge though, most people are just winging it though and shoving it out the door as if its impressive.
But yes, I think its probably bad because you probably didnt learn all that much and became more reliant on Anthropic. Unless you dont care about learning, then who cares.
I have been using my videcoded clone of Adobe Illustrator for a while now.
No intentions of releasing/selling it, as I'm sure everyone else can now do similar things too.
Just because you've chosen to turn off your brain and prompt your way to whatever, and your 10 MAU app works fine does not mean large systems, critical devices and critical infrastructure's code will no longer need reviewed. Sorry your dad's pacemakers firmware code, and the ancillary systems that enable its development will need its code reviewed. Along with aircraft, satellites, municiple traffic systems, countless medical devices ect ect. I could go on forever.
Not everything is non serious SaaS platforms with little users. Just because you have success writing slop that exists under no load, and nothing relies on it doesn't mean the world is now different.
You have SEVERE dunning kruger syndrome, and unfortunately a lot of other people have this same ailment and the worlds systems are decaying as everyone turns off their brain and offshores everything difficult to language models, because humans like you are lazy and will always try to get the free lunch that doesn't exist. People will die because of this attitude.
stopping it would require outright putting DRM on the GPU and any other hardware that can run it, good luck with that (and not having the LLM itself be used to break out of it)
(to stay within physical machinery, like the post.)
actually I have no idea what would llm do to make their machines better
Lack of imagination on here can sometimes be disheartening
people were able to revive, repair, optimize a lot of day to day devices, very nice view. that said cars and heavy appliances.. should be done in a big public warehouse safety lab