There's significant evidence "add solar panels" is an optimization to at least some kinds of farmland.
No one's banning hay fields. You can do both.
> Reasons like this are why this type of tech will always be popular on HN but they just can't figure out why farmers don't want it.
Farmers come in different sizes and shapes.
The largest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cattle_station is several times the size of the state of Rhode Island, and chances are there're some spots where a bit of shade is welcome.
What do you think "trim" is here, and why do you think anyone would do it?
How much do you think a hay field would grow in six weeks?
The animals are doing the trimming instead of the mowers. This isn't super complicated logistically; each takes tall grass and turns it into short grass. You can rent goats to clean up shit like poison ivy, even.
> How much do you think a hay field would grow in six weeks?
The one by my house grows maybe a foot in that time, which is why they rotate pastures. Even a handful of horses can keep an acre worth of pasture quite well cropped.
The animals keep the grass and weeds under the solar panels trimmed, saving on mowing. This also provides food to the animals, who love grass, meaning you don’t need as much hay during the spring/summer seasons.
Leave a grassy field untrimmed for a few months and guess what you wind up with? A hay field.
The solar field is productive all year. It is a grazing pasture for animals for much of the year. You also produce hay - in another field - just like you'd do without a solar field - for the winter.
People literally are doing this and you're acting like I'm describing FTL travel. Is there a language barrier or something?
Not in terms of producing electricity, no.
> It is a grazing pasture for animals for much of the year.
No, only for about three or four months of the year. There's not much growth in it for the rest of the year, even as far south here as 56°, and if you overgraze it, it'll just be a mudpit.
Yes, they do. Less, but absolutely productive. Certainly more so than an empty field would've been in said winter.
> No, only for about three or four months of the year. There's not much growth in it for the rest of the year, even as far south here as 56°, and if you overgraze it, it'll just be a mudpit.
That's an argument for more solar fields you rotate the cattle through.
(And as one of my citations noted, the shade helps the grass grow in the summer.)
Nor are farmers immune to the "vote against your own interests" political bullshit that often comes up around renewables. Look at how many voted for the guy who started a trade war as a thank you.
I suggest you work on that.
As much as I want solar everywhere - it far from a sure thing for making/saving money.
they also have to be able to get "bumped" by a brush hog, plow, and whatever else without collapsing and taking down a bunch of panels.
Please omit snarky phrases like this from comments on HN. The guidelines make it clear we're trying for something better here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
The source can be attacked, the transmission infra can be attacked, the delivery point can be censored.
I think most people want highly distributed, reliable, affordable power. That's why off-grid tech is experiencing such a boom.
I live in a 36' skoolie, so I'm nomad-indexed, but I can confirm that over the past 10 years or so, most RV-lifers have transitioned their focus from recreation / comfort to off-grid experimentation. Essentially everywhere I go in the US, if I'm camped near others, they are going to have minimum viability for boondocking. That was not the case when I started.
Especially amidst the current political instability and apparent looming collapse of the US state, one of the simplest things that most of us can do is stabilize off-grid power in our neighborhoods, and that is quietly happening all over the place.
So, the role of vertically integrated solar (both literally and metaphorically) has more to do with the grid shape that serves our stability needs, and less to do with large-scale differences in efficiency.
Can you elaborate, please? What exactly has changed, and over what time period?
The big changes seem to have been:
* Better / more varied solar panels
* Lithium batteries (which I don't use for a house bank, but still benefit from by dint of them having driven the price deep-cycle lead batteries down)
* USB-C everything
When I first started this lifestyle, almost everyone had lead-acid batteries powering an inverter, and a zillion wall warts converting power back to DC. Some people had solar for sure, but a solid majority only camped where they were able to plug in.
At festivals, powered sites sold out quickly and at a premium. Dispersed camping in national forests was the purview of tent campers, truck campers, and people who don't use much power (ie, not a ton of remote workers). New campgrounds always focused on power pedestals and seemed to regard that as the MVP.
Now, festivals are a sea of solar and/or off-grid-cooled beers. Campgrounds are often a de-facto swap meet of usb-c oddities (I have a USB-C coffee grinder - what a world!). Dispersed camping in national forests are often transient standing desk communities. Nary an inverter in sight - everything is direct-to-USB-C.
The difference between most people needing to plug in within a few hours in order to have their basic comforts vs. being able to live indefinitely without the grid has significantly changed what it feels like to be on the road.
Who cares? One isolated field of solar represents a negligible amount of power at grid scale. Nobody is going to bother to go around attacking each individual field because the "ROI" of attacking a high-voltage transmission line (the kind that brings power from multiple thermal plants to a city) is so much higher.
Just take a look at the multiple fridge freezer attacks in the EU this year.
I hope anyone building networked infrastructure TODAY would take security more seriously.
Maybe I was unclear: that's exactly my point! That's the problem with grid scale for most everyday uses.
In 2026, it's fairly trivial to have a setup such that, if "the grid" fails, I don't even notice for days. That's a nice feature! And it makes sense to build out communities that way from now on.
"The grid" is great for industry, but for residential, micro-grids are clearly the future. Allowing the state and the electric company to cut us off - intentionally or otherwise, let alone having no power during a disaster when it's needed most, is a very silly thing to trade for a tiny efficiency increase.
I sleep well at night knowing I have four bigass AGMs under me.
Tiny deployments of off-grid solar beat the pants off that model.
How many tiny off-grid solar deployments are required to power the people and industries of a small city of two million?
Many acres of grain are required to feed such a city, why not many fields of solar panels, community batteries (roughly one per 1-2 hundred houses), smart grids, etc.
I think we're gonna see more and more EVs double as off-grid power banks, for example.
Cool, cool.
So what do you run the engine on? How many single points of failure?
Mechanically, almost every component is a single-point-of-failure: drivetrain, brakes, cooling system, etc.
But I don't actually move all that much; I only move from place to place maybe a dozen times a year - less some years.
And while I'm stationary, it's pretty easy for me to have fully off-grid power. And a composting toilet lasts me a full loop around the USA without needing to empty the solid container.
But I didn't mean for my point to be about mobile living, just identifying that one of the main benefits of solar as opposed to nuclear is that control over power distribution can be scaled radically downward.
So it looks like nuclear would be a pretty good option here.
What are we comparing against exactly that’s more resilient?
The real world however, a farmer owns a specific plot of land, has $w of capital in the back, owes $x in loans, owes y tons of crop, owns z tractors and seeds. Without centralized planning, plopping down solar panels in an optimal place isn't how things work.
The real world however, a farmer owns a specific plot of land, has $w of capital in the back, owes $x in loans, owes y tons of crop, owns z tractors and seeds. Without centralized planning, plopping down solar panels in an optimal place isn't how the real world works.
is it?
Even in the US there may be small land holders that want to exploit their land densely, and aren’t doing million-acre optimization.
Everyone forgets about Hawaii. Hawaii is quite constrained on any land for any use. Putting PV over farmlands where we can is probably very smart for a place like Hawaii.
But surely only certain places need to do this? for the UK, you need to make hay for the winter, assuming that your meadows flood, or are otherwise muddy. But if your in one of the more temperate areas of the southern USA, surely you don't need to do that?
The silage that you get, then, is basically like a kind of grass sauerkraut, and smells exactly like you'd expect.
That combined with "draff" - distillery mash, the spent malt from brewing "pot ale" for making whisky, and a certain amount of shredded sugar beet tends to make up the majority of winter fodder.
Draff is great because it's still fermenting slowly and generating a lot of heat, so the cows are eating hot food in the winter. It's mostly the fibrey bits of the barley malt, which we can't eat but which cows and sheep - having cellulase in at least one of their stomachs - do incredibly well on. It's absolutely no use for anything else, humans can't eat it and it doesn't really compost down. It just rots, stinks, and emits masses of carbon dioxide and methane when it does. Far better for the environment to lock all that up in a cow.
Ideally your fields don't flood because you plant crops in the autumn that stay in the ground over winter to germinate in the spring, and if they get flooded that's it, you've lost the lot.
You tend not to see soya-based or other leguminous food here very much, because it's expensive, it has to be shipped halfway round the planet, and it's ineffective - you get shitty meat that no-one wants to buy.
You need the cows to graze pasture, chew up the grass, break down all that tough cellulose and poo it out as incredibly highly refined fertiliser.
We eat, just about everywhere in the world, because there's six inches of earth, it rains sometimes, and cows and pigs shit solid gold.
Don’t they just.. release it?
It doesn't, of course, the most of it gets turned into cow.
This works for trees, which you can turn into, say, a house, where it might last hundreds of years.
I'm curious about how you think the physics of it work for a cow.
Methane release varies by animal type: https://reporter.anu.edu.au/all-stories/kangaroos-the-soluti...
Understanding why is ongoing: https://www.uow.edu.au/media/2015/why-kangaroos-really-emit-...
That meat gets eaten and largely turned into poo and gas (as byproduct of using up that stored energy), yeah? You're sequestering it maybe for a few years; meat cows live about two years.
> “Kangaroos have a very different stomach from that of ruminants such as sheep and cows,” Professor Clauss said. “We think that the methane is low because of the way food moves through the kangaroo stomach, and not because of a unique gut fauna.”
> Dr Munn and Professor Clauss are critical of efforts to try to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from ruminant livestock by replacing their gut fauna with that from kangaroos or other low-methane emitting animals, which they believe is unlikely to succeed.
You're not raising kangaroos in Scotland, right?
So yes, you're correct - I'm not raising roos in Scotland, but we do look into ruminants, biomes, etc here.
These are complex chains that make up the surface level carbon cycle.
The problematic carbons are those that are additional - those once buried across the course of millions of years, some millions of years ago and now being bought to the surface in an extremely short timescale (one century and half, roughly)
This all goes to your question if you care to look into it.
In Scotland?
> The problematic carbons are those that are additional - those once buried across the course of millions of years, some millions of years ago and now being bought to the surface in an extremely short timescale (one century and half, roughly)
Meat production accounts for somewhere between 15 and 20% of human emissions. It is a significant part of the problem.
> the gas creation ratios can be tweaked by the paths taken.
To a point. Producing and consuming meat is gonna emit carbon. This isn’t disputable.
Already answered. Engage brain, treat it as a puzzle.
> Meat production accounts for somewhere between 15 and 20% of human emissions. It is a significant part of the problem.
Is it? Or is it just cycling the carbon in the land / sea close surface layer?
> To a point.
The point being it is something that can be modified and addressed.
> Producing and consuming meat is gonna emit carbon.
Recycle carbon, rather than dredge up and release fossil carbon might be a better framing for any wanting to get to the root of the issue.
> and consuming meat
Shooting and eating kangaroos, feral camels, goats, donkeys, clean skin bulls, etc. somehow adds in a significant manner to AGW ?
Are you _sure_ about that?
We know it isn't. Immense amounts of crops like alfalfa are grown, with extensive fertilizing via petroleum products, to feed inefficiently to cattle.
> The point being it is something that can be modified and addressed.
It's enough of a fight over clearly-better extant solutions like solar. The near-term fix to climate change isn't gonna be evolving cows to burp less.
> Recycle carbon, rather than dredge up and release fossil carbon might be a better framing for any wanting to get to the root of the issue.
This describes a tiny percentage of cattle raising practices.
> Shooting and eating kangaroos, feral camels, goats, donkeys, clean skin bulls, etc. somehow adds in a significant manner to AGW ?
This describes a tiny percentage of meat production. You're not going to feed Australia off the kangaroo population, let alone the world.
Only if you assume that the finger-in-the-air guesswork around how much emissions you get from livestock is correct.
What do you think would be better?
Less meat? 10-50x as many calories per ton of CO2 generated.
Americans, in particular, eat far more red meat than they need to.
Poultry are difficult to keep at scale; they need very expensive feed. This has an impact on your suggestion of eggs too.
Fish farming is horrible for the environment.
Legumes, great, so how do you grow those without livestock farming? Plough up vast swathes of forest, blast everything with Monsanto biocides until it's as sterile as the Moon, blast it with Monsanto fertilisers, and then plant Monsanto beans for a couple of years until the soil is utterly barren? Great idea. Oh, and even better, do it half a planet away so the beans have to be shipped over on vast container ships that burn a city's worth of diesel every day. Brilliant.
Root vegetables? Well we already grow carrots and potatoes, and sugar beet and mangels are good for feeding livestock and pretty beneficial to the ground, but other than that you can't really live off just carrots and potatoes.
What America does isn't really relevant. They don't have any safe or sustainable food sources there.
We're talking globally, which includes America.
> Poultry are difficult to keep at scale; they need very expensive feed. This has an impact on your suggestion of eggs too. Fish farming is horrible for the environment.
And beef's worse than either.
> Legumes, great, so how do you grow those without livestock farming?
They are already grown in the way you describe - with fossil fuel derived fertilizers. So's a lot of the animal feed. Making some solar in the fields is a nice win to offset that a bit.
> What America does isn't really relevant.
As the world's second largest (formerly #1) polluter, that's a fairly laughable statement.
Okay, but you can't grow them everywhere. Real farms are not Farmville.
> So's a lot of the animal feed.
Like what?
Forests used to cover ~60% of the planet's land mass. You can grow them pretty much anywhere.
> Like what?
70 million kilos of alfalfa pellets a year for the UK, as an example? https://wits.worldbank.org/trade/comtrade/en/country/GBR/yea...
You grow the trees elsewhere. Like we currently do. Forests make good carbon sinks.
This is like the people who think you can grow human food on the land you raise cows on.
But there are quite a few places you can.
> This is like the people who think you can grow human food on the land you raise cows on.
No one has asserted that here. (Although cows do eat a shitload of corn.)
You can have cows eat the grass that grows underneath solar panels, as we've been discussing.
Actually no, no-one here feeds cows on corn. They eat grass, often in the form of silage, and barley in the form of spent grains from breweries, but it's hopelessly inefficient to feed cows on just corn.
You get shitty greasy meat that no-one will buy and it costs a fortune to produce.
A well managed grass meadow is a carbon sink. As the parent says, the cows graze and shite which causes more growth. if you rotate your cow out before they eat everything back to the earth, it makes the grass grow thicker.
because not all of the grass is eaten, a fair portion is left to eventually die off and form the next layer of soil, trapping the carbon there.
The reason why cows are considered global warming is because forests tend to be felled to form feeding lots. Or in more tropical areas, grasslands that then decay precipitously. (see dustbowl causes in the prairies and why the USA spent a huge amount on soil preservation)
Its not a one size fits all thing. In Aus, over grazing leads to desertification, which causes sun baking. This means the soil is baked into a water resisting layer that causes flash floods. But, because its flash flooding, the water isn't dwelling and soaking in, causing the place to get drier.
In Yorkshire, overgrazing lead to the tree-less desolate expanse which is the dales.
In the lowlands of Scotland, they went and planted a shit tonne of pine to try and compensate/bring back forestry, but that turned the soil acid and killed the streams.
This is not the sole reason, no.
Immense amounts of fossil fuel (and water) go into fertilizing alfalfa, corn, etc. fields that are grown to inefficiently feed cattle with.
And - crucially - any other crops that you grow there.
If you just keep growing crops to feed people in there then after about five years the soil is exhausted, dry powdery stuff that blows away in the wind or washes away in the rain.
Without livestock farming we have about half a dozen harvests before the ecology collapses and we starve.
Can they mow a 1,000 acres and get through ruts from feral hogs and everything else? If so, then that's awesome (i really don't know) but you have to think of the scale.
We could grow some crops in that 1% of land and provide reams of clean power to the world. And the more we restore land to nature, as opposed to our mono-crops and cows, the more co-benefits we reap.
Often these "solutions" introduce more problems than they solves. One example being a solar farm designed to be grazed by sheep where the panels are so low to the ground that farmers can't bring in tractors and cut hay when the ruminants are gone for a season.
The best solution is still to put solar panels and farmland in different places where each can be optimized without concern for the other.