So yes, you're correct - I'm not raising roos in Scotland, but we do look into ruminants, biomes, etc here.
These are complex chains that make up the surface level carbon cycle.
The problematic carbons are those that are additional - those once buried across the course of millions of years, some millions of years ago and now being bought to the surface in an extremely short timescale (one century and half, roughly)
This all goes to your question if you care to look into it.
In Scotland?
> The problematic carbons are those that are additional - those once buried across the course of millions of years, some millions of years ago and now being bought to the surface in an extremely short timescale (one century and half, roughly)
Meat production accounts for somewhere between 15 and 20% of human emissions. It is a significant part of the problem.
> the gas creation ratios can be tweaked by the paths taken.
To a point. Producing and consuming meat is gonna emit carbon. This isn’t disputable.
Already answered. Engage brain, treat it as a puzzle.
> Meat production accounts for somewhere between 15 and 20% of human emissions. It is a significant part of the problem.
Is it? Or is it just cycling the carbon in the land / sea close surface layer?
> To a point.
The point being it is something that can be modified and addressed.
> Producing and consuming meat is gonna emit carbon.
Recycle carbon, rather than dredge up and release fossil carbon might be a better framing for any wanting to get to the root of the issue.
> and consuming meat
Shooting and eating kangaroos, feral camels, goats, donkeys, clean skin bulls, etc. somehow adds in a significant manner to AGW ?
Are you _sure_ about that?
We know it isn't. Immense amounts of crops like alfalfa are grown, with extensive fertilizing via petroleum products, to feed inefficiently to cattle.
> The point being it is something that can be modified and addressed.
It's enough of a fight over clearly-better extant solutions like solar. The near-term fix to climate change isn't gonna be evolving cows to burp less.
> Recycle carbon, rather than dredge up and release fossil carbon might be a better framing for any wanting to get to the root of the issue.
This describes a tiny percentage of cattle raising practices.
> Shooting and eating kangaroos, feral camels, goats, donkeys, clean skin bulls, etc. somehow adds in a significant manner to AGW ?
This describes a tiny percentage of meat production. You're not going to feed Australia off the kangaroo population, let alone the world.
Only if you assume that the finger-in-the-air guesswork around how much emissions you get from livestock is correct.
What do you think would be better?
Less meat? 10-50x as many calories per ton of CO2 generated.
Americans, in particular, eat far more red meat than they need to.
Poultry are difficult to keep at scale; they need very expensive feed. This has an impact on your suggestion of eggs too.
Fish farming is horrible for the environment.
Legumes, great, so how do you grow those without livestock farming? Plough up vast swathes of forest, blast everything with Monsanto biocides until it's as sterile as the Moon, blast it with Monsanto fertilisers, and then plant Monsanto beans for a couple of years until the soil is utterly barren? Great idea. Oh, and even better, do it half a planet away so the beans have to be shipped over on vast container ships that burn a city's worth of diesel every day. Brilliant.
Root vegetables? Well we already grow carrots and potatoes, and sugar beet and mangels are good for feeding livestock and pretty beneficial to the ground, but other than that you can't really live off just carrots and potatoes.
What America does isn't really relevant. They don't have any safe or sustainable food sources there.
We're talking globally, which includes America.
> Poultry are difficult to keep at scale; they need very expensive feed. This has an impact on your suggestion of eggs too. Fish farming is horrible for the environment.
And beef's worse than either.
> Legumes, great, so how do you grow those without livestock farming?
They are already grown in the way you describe - with fossil fuel derived fertilizers. So's a lot of the animal feed. Making some solar in the fields is a nice win to offset that a bit.
> What America does isn't really relevant.
As the world's second largest (formerly #1) polluter, that's a fairly laughable statement.
Okay, but you can't grow them everywhere. Real farms are not Farmville.
> So's a lot of the animal feed.
Like what?
Forests used to cover ~60% of the planet's land mass. You can grow them pretty much anywhere.
> Like what?
70 million kilos of alfalfa pellets a year for the UK, as an example? https://wits.worldbank.org/trade/comtrade/en/country/GBR/yea...
That meat gets eaten and largely turned into poo and gas (as byproduct of using up that stored energy), yeah? You're sequestering it maybe for a few years; meat cows live about two years.
> “Kangaroos have a very different stomach from that of ruminants such as sheep and cows,” Professor Clauss said. “We think that the methane is low because of the way food moves through the kangaroo stomach, and not because of a unique gut fauna.”
> Dr Munn and Professor Clauss are critical of efforts to try to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from ruminant livestock by replacing their gut fauna with that from kangaroos or other low-methane emitting animals, which they believe is unlikely to succeed.
You're not raising kangaroos in Scotland, right?