News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by pessimizer on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:14PM (#50224161)
European governments have been pretending to drop Microsoft for 20 years, I suppose the first one that did it got a big discount, and now they do it whenever they want to reduce costs. Europe will never slow, and in fact will continually increase, its dependency on the US forever.

We propagandize them against all alternatives, like Russian energy and Chinese everything, and employ all of their academics and politicians at our nonprofits and universities, sprinkling credentials all over them. Europeans love a credential; makes them feel superior. Money well spent.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by cowlevel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:16PM (#50224188)
It's all well and good to evangelize but the problem is that we are only evangelizing and not actually making alternatives. Programmers tend to accept an MVP as an alternative because we can deal with the rough edges, but real users don't see it that way.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by card_zero on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:26PM (#50224283)
The other day I was watching a manager wrestle with Excel. He couldn't select information to send it to somebody who wanted it, because it was trying to do a collaborative spreadsheet thing and had got itself locked up somehow. He ended up taking a photo of the screen and texting it.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by spwa4 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:07PM (#50225296)
You know, now with AI assuming the other side actually knows what they're doing this can work surprisingly well, to the point that I do it sometimes.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by izacus on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:43PM (#50224426)
This. I've been around these kind of pushes in my part oif EU for a long time and the reality is: there's a lot of talk and demands and not many people signing up for tenders, development or maintenance work.

The opinion is that "the public workers don't need it" for every feature missing in Linux or LibreOffice. I can only imagine how a fight to upstream such features would look like even if someone took on a support contract.

With Microsoft at least the governments get shared fate with large corpos who also need enterprise features.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by nikanj on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:04PM (#50224610)
It's usually clear to all parties that the tendering process is theatre, and they've already picked the company that'll get the contract
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by izacus on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:38AM (#50229203)
Which doesn't change the fact that you need a corporate entity to be there to actually deploy and maintain the software you're pushing - and for a longer time than a few months before you get bored.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by dvdkon on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:54PM (#50225164)
I'd sign up for tenders, but they all seem to require a company with "1 million EUR revenue in public sector <whatever> projects" and 5 people with various roles, degrees and X years of experience in <whatever>.

I'm just a freelancer with FLOSS experience and some commercial experience, and so are plenty other FLOSS contributors. Nobody's going to create a company and hire staff just to have a chance at getting selected in the one tender a year that allows outsiders in.

The idea might be that only companies which have already proven themselves elsewhere can enter, but 1) then why the "public sector work revenue" requirement? And 2) that's not going to work for industries where government interest is much larger than private interest, like FLOSS.

But I suppose governments prefer the certainty that Accenture or local equivalents bring - a price an order of magnitude too high for a mediocre result and a 25% chance that the project will be fucked up and shelved, over the uncertainty of a small startup, who could either deliver something great, or overexert themselves and not finish at all...

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by cowlevel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:22PM (#50227269)
I think a lot of these massive tendering companies got started by meeting tenders they didn't get. Like for Microsoft, first they added all the features that were necessary for the tenders, and only after that, they started winning tenders. That's the story of the Windows NT POSIX subsystem that nobody ever needed.

It also helps to be flexible with the truth. If you get this one million dollar tender then you'll be doing one million dollars of business with the government so you can check that box.

If you meet all checkboxes, have the lowest price and still don't get the tender, you can usually sue the government for corruption. These processes are strictly regulated to avoid that.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by dvdkon on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:17AM (#50229096)
It should be about features and price, but those only matter after you clear the bar. At least in the Czech Republic, you can't bullshit your way through the requirements like you can with job interviews, these things are actually checked.

Also here you can't sue directly, you can file a complaint with the oversight bureau, which regularly happens just because a competitor is mad at not being selected, but that's a different problem...

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by cowlevel on Sunday October 25, 2026 @09:31AM (#50231390)
Beware the fundamental attribution bias. They are just mad they didn't get selected, but I deserved to be selected...
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by dvdkon on Sunday October 25, 2026 @11:31AM (#50232644)
Sure, I don't want to take their right to appeal, and I only make that comment as a neutral observer. This is my smallest issue with the process, the discriminatory requirements are a bigger problem.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by impizulu on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:57PM (#50225774)
100%. Most people are not programmers. Most people do not see software as something interesting to figure out. It's just a tool for them to do their job.

To get the average office worker to want to switch, you not only have to provide a finished product that works smoothly, but also one that feels familiar. Most office workers grind through their day doing repetitive tasks in familiar software they have been using for a decade. When the top of the food chain says they are overhauling the entire software suite that people have been grown accustomed to for their entire career, the new software better have real benefits that incentivise employees to actually engage with learning it. Otherwise productivity will simply crater.

Most office workers do not care to learn new software. They just want to get on with their job. For better or for worse. But if you can demonstrate a switch will make their lives easier and the UI UX of the new software is very familiar and intuitive (and it actually works) you may be able to pull off a clean switch and keep your employees happy.

An MVP is fine but I think it's crucial that the UI UX is very similar to the software that it is replacing because it means people don't have to relearn whatever habits they have developed over the years in the old stack. I think that's what creates the most resistance to change.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by kromokromo on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:18PM (#50224200)
Now that software is cheap, I don’t see why someone wouldn’t just build a clone. Cloud collaborative text editor and sheets and storage is all you really need. Plenty of good alternatives to Teams.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by Scarblac on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:51PM (#50224500)
The French government for instance sponsors LaSuite ( https://lasuite.numerique.gouv.fr/ , no English language web page of course ).

But I think the hardest thing to replace is Active Directory, Outlook, all the integration with Windows, all the admins certified on Microsoft technology. It's not about the actual application "MS Office", it's about all of IT (that line was not AI).

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by hvb2 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:15PM (#50224737)
> But I think the hardest thing to replace is Active Directory, Outlook, all the integration with Windows, all the admins certified on Microsoft technology

Nah, it's the users. Those are resistant to change even more. When they miss deadlines that they can now blame, sometimes rightfully, on the software change

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by cowlevel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:13PM (#50227603)
This can't be the reason because current Microsoft products change constantly.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by spwa4 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:11PM (#50225337)
> no English language web page of course

If it's AI ... the whole point this version of AI was invented was translation. That's what transformers are for. So why don't they build versions of the apps and pages in every language under the sun from Aztec to Zaparo, from Hieroglyphics to Cuneiform?

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by schubidubiduba on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:36PM (#50225602)
Because they can (partially) legally be held liable to the content of these pages. And because AI-translations often still feel cheap and unnatural
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by Scarblac on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:29AM (#50229713)
It's French, sponsored by the French government. They may well end up translating it to all those languages except English.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by spwa4 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @10:18AM (#50231873)
This seems like a spectacularly bad idea to write software that's meant to enable cooperation far and wide.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by ben_w on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:26PM (#50224285)
The open-source clones already exist, and have done for a long time. As do Google Docs, which may have the disadvantages of being both closed-source and American, but the advantage of being free.

People pay a lot of money for professional versions anyway.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by NetMageSCW on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:23PM (#50224835)
Those are not alternatives.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by ben_w on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:56PM (#50225189)
For many, they are. In particular, the person I'm replying to said:

> Cloud collaborative text editor and sheets and storage is all you really need. Plenty of good alternatives to Teams.

If the quotation were correct, the things I listed would always be, instead of sometimes being.

Google Docs and OpenOffice* have been alternatives to MS Office that were actually used in places I've worked, too.

* this was before LibraOffice

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by petcat on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:50PM (#50224499)
Unfortunately this is what happened when the EU tried to build their own Teams alternative:

https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-microsoft-teams-alternati...

> Absolute shit.

> The U.S. would “instantly” win a hypothetical tech war, an official moaned.

EU just has a long way to go. And the reality is that it will be so astronomically expensive that is is unlikely that they ever even truly try.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by fph on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:03PM (#50224606)
American big tech companies pay very few taxes, compared to European standards. This is part of what makes it very difficult to compete with them.

Everyone in Europe is saying that the CCP is illegally subsidizing EVs and solar panels to conquer the European market, and that we need to protect from them by imposing tariffs: but if you think about it, this isn't too different from what America is doing with tech.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by Aurornis on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:51PM (#50225133)
> American big tech companies pay very few taxes, compared to European standards. This is part of what makes it very difficult to compete with them.

American big tech companies have to pay their workers a lot more than European tech companies.

Microsoft has to pay local taxes on sales in those countries. They are not paying American tax rates on European sales.

Even their American corporate tax rates, if raised to European levels, would still have ample room for profit.

Your argument is not supported by the data.

> but if you think about it, this isn't too different from what America is doing with tech.

It’s nothing like economic dumping. America is not pumping money into Microsoft to dump Microsoft Office into European markets.

Those European companies could come to the US, open an office here, and be under the exact same rules as Microsoft.

The situation is not alike at all.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by schubidubiduba on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:46PM (#50225683)
I don't think American big tech pays their workers that much more once you factor in tax and social security contributions of the employer, actual hours worked (vs. vacation and sick days taken) etc. etc.

Nobody was talking about sales tax.

The collusion of US big tech with Ireland to pay very little taxes is well documented. You mention many unrelated facts that are mostly irrelevant to the discussion.

Further, America has definitely been pumping money into Microsoft, for instance with hefty defense and public administration contracts. It is incredibly naive to believe that the US allowed the Microsoft monopoly to corner the office market without the opportunity of establishing a digital hegemony being a significant factor.

The situation is, in fact, quite alike to chinese state-sponsored companies. The main difference being the tone of media coverage about it in the western world.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by samus on Saturday October 24, 2026 @06:28PM (#50226070)
> Further, America has definitely been pumping money into Microsoft, for instance with hefty defense and public administration contracts. It is incredibly naive to believe that the US allowed the Microsoft monopoly to corner the office market without the opportunity of establishing a digital hegemony being a significant factor.

That's not a subsidy. That's a customer paying for a product. Apart from that, the USA has Anti-Trust laws, and Microsoft has been at the receiving end of these in the past.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by schubidubiduba on Sunday October 25, 2026 @02:58AM (#50228998)
Sure, but if the customer is tax-funded and pays a lot more than the product is worth, that's just a hidden subsidy.

And yes Anti-Trust laws and enforcement exist in theory, and occasionally get applied, leading to small fines. Which is in line with what I wrote. Anti-Trust action has been severely lacking, and I assume that was by design.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by samus on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:26PM (#50235729)
Depends on your definition of overpaying. Governments are generally not the best at keeping costs down, for various reasons. To a certain degree it's simply organizational inefficiency.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by nradov on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:15PM (#50225387)
OK so lower corporate taxes then. Easy. If that enables European tech companies to grow and prosper then this will actually increase net tax revenue even if the rates are lower.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by philipallstar on Sunday October 25, 2026 @11:26AM (#50232587)
> American big tech companies pay very few taxes, compared to European standards.

Can you evidence this?

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by asanineassasin on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:57PM (#50224548)
Every citizen with potential to change the world- leaves europa for the us. The only "positive" exception- has been not the fat old west-west of europe, but the east. Jetbrains, CD Project Red, the svvedes- there is something subsversive and alive, software wise in the ashes of the USSR - and unlike germany and france, the old entrenched conglomerates can not sabotage that newcomers that easy there.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by fakedang on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:00PM (#50224576)
Everything is too expensive for European bureaucrats. Funny how the Europeans used to call the fledgling US in the 1700s a nation of shopkeepers, when right now, they are an entire continent's worth of lawyers and accountants (except for France and the UK, obv).
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by card_zero on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:50PM (#50225116)
Who aimed the "nation of shopkeepers" epithet at the US?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation_of_shopkeepers

It starts in Wealth of Nations, was picked up by a French revolutionary (still aimed at England, but in a more negative way), and Ben Franklin said something similar about Holland.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by rurban on Sunday October 25, 2026 @12:49AM (#50228429)
This famous Absolute shit quote is pure propaganda. In fact MS teams is the absolute shit, compared to Matrix.

Just fire the naysayers (for refusing to work) and you have one problem less.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by Arathorn on Sunday October 25, 2026 @05:58AM (#50229873)
If the European Commission actually thought Element was absolute shit, I don't think their management would have come along to The Matrix Conference last week and presented the project as a success: https://cfp.2026.matrix.org/matrix-conference-2026/talk/YHV8.... As someone else said, the quote is pure propaganda.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by philipallstar on Sunday October 25, 2026 @04:10PM (#50235572)
That seems a pretty weak signal. Individuals like presenting stuff and going on jollies.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by oblio on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:12PM (#50224711)
> Now that software is cheap

Despite what you hear techies say, "really bad software" didn't really exist before, except for some very small enterprise niches. Stuff like Windows, Photoshop or other categories that techies complain, has always hovered between "bad" and "above average" with some moments of hitting "quite good". Really bad software was software that barely did its main job.

Well, really bad software is now super cheap to create.

That won't really change software economics outside of corporate malpractice (those small enterprise niches) or regulatory capture.

Average software is probably only marginally cheaper and good software will be as expensive as always because expectations have shifted up.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by lunar_rover on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:53PM (#50224521)
You can't clone decades of history.
Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by samus on Saturday October 24, 2026 @06:25PM (#50226041)
The issue with building alternatives is always that it is quite easy to get something that can do 90% or more of the work, but the remainder takes a lot more time to pull off.

Implementation was never the bottleneck. The hard part is about usability engineering, which requires feedback cycles with actual users to have good results. That's a hard, time-consuming process; merely dogfooding the product won't work.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by jruohonen on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:20PM (#50224213)
> Europe will never slow

I am not sure about the word choice, but they, ...

> European governments

probably like BDSM or something.

Re:Danish Government silently drops plan to dump MS Office by aucisson_masque on Saturday October 24, 2026 @06:08PM (#50225875)
French gendarmerie ditched it a while ago, went to use Linux on all compares and been doing fine for decades.

There is no technical reason to be impossible, the issue is political.

Corruption promoted by American lobbies onto European government and preventing any actual decision.

When people in charge “have balls”, it does work.