The word "imprecise" is also factually incorrect. AFAIK, all Imperial units are now defined in metric. An inch is not "approximately" 2.54 centimeters, it is defined to be 2.54 centimeters, or, if you prefer, 2.540000000000... centimeters. A pound is defined as 0.45359237 kilograms.
It may be very precise specification of a value that is unpleasant and hard to work with, but there is no more and no less precision in the Imperial system than there is in the metric system, because technically Imperial is now just a flavor of metric. In that sense, we are metric already. This is definitely not the sense that people mean, but it is not entirely invalid, either.
I say that, and I still stick to my Vim and won't use Emacs keybindings :-D
And if it's indeed the law since 1875, we wouldn't have needed the Metric Conversion Act from 1975, would we?
We're still on Imperial units because the U.S. commitment to metric units has been patchy and haphazard since the beginning. Unless we're willing to mandate the use of metric units only for all state business, especially in education, we're going to be stuck with furlongs per fortnight.
Yes, in theory the US is a country that supports metric. In practice, go and ask anybody in the country outside of the military for the following:
- An M10 bolt
- a 16mm wrench to drive it with
- a 3 meter long 50 mm od pvc drainpipe
- a tape-measure that measures only in metric
- a highway sign that is posted in km
And so on. See how many people can point you to any of these.
Then try this:
- a 3/8th " bolt
- a 9/16th " wrench to drive it with
- a 10' long 2" od pvc drainpipe
- a tape measure that only measures in Imperial
- a highway sign posted in Miles.
The petition is dead on in the way the US approaches the metric system, in practice it is imperial all the way. As long as the practice doesn't change what the technical situation is won't matter one bit.
The only way to get out of this is to change the law, and to deprecate Imperial in favor of metric.
Every hardware store I've ever been to has a section for metric. Our lab, for instance, keeps a supply of bolts, and as far as I remember /only/ has metric.
Also every socket set I've ever used has a metric and standard set.
Why would you care about road signs? And why would you care about a tape measure that is /only/ in metric? The second one seems kindof silly.
The only thing I know of that isn't available commonly in metric sizes are machining tools like mills. As far as I know, machining is always done in "mils", or thousands of an inch.
I believe so. Maybe a couple of times. Or maybe I practically lived in one for a couple of years.
Would this do for you?
http://pics.ww.com/v/jacques/trips/jansvisit/?g2_page=6
Yes, there is a section for metric in the hardware store.
It's the bit at the back with about 1/2 the sizes missing and only the stuff that you don't need in stock. I've had a machine shop in Canada (which officially had metric) and it was quite hard to get metric stuff. So hard that in the end we standardized on Imperial. In the US it was way worse.
Socket sets have standard and metric. Metric mostly for working on Japanese or European cars. But the most tools 'at hand' will be imperial. Maybe your experience is different but I've had plenty of bolts on my Japanese car wrecked by a shop putting imperial tools on them and plowing ahead. Works especially good if you use airtools, instant roundness.
You care about road signs because they're a sign that you really are standardizing. If your road signs are still in Miles then you're not a 'metric' country.
And you care about a tape measure only in metric because that's all you use in a metric country.
Machine tools - of which I owned a small fortune worth of - have things called morse tapers for the various tool bits. Morse tapers are adapters that allow you to quickly switch bits, most of the tooling that fits them is in Imperial. Collets, the elements that hold tooling for a mill or a lathe are all in imperial sizes. Unless you order from a very large catalogue it is very difficult to get mills in metric, but that is much more frustrating is that it can even be hard to source drills in metric.
Machining is done to thousands of an inch in the US. The rest of the world uses 1/100th of a mm for both turning and milling, and a series of fittings for more precise work.
The good news is that the bigger bearing companies all do carry metric if you need it. And if they don't have it in stock it 's usually only a day away.
Unless you've actually tried to design a somewhat complex chunk of machinery you might be given the impression that 'metric is easy'. In practice stuff like shafts, gears, supports and so on are all easier to source in Imperial than in Metric both in the US and in Canada too.
You want to order in Imperial, just one moment while I get your order form the warehouse out back. You want to order in Metric. That's perfectly fine, we're a metric country after all. Would it suit you to pick your order up in early march, possibly the middle of april before it is complete?
I have built plenty of complex machinery. It's actually significantly easier for me to source 50mm flywheels/pulleys, or v-belts, or whatever, than it is to try to get someone to give me reasonable tolerances on imperial.
While it's true machining is done to thousandths of an inch in the US, most of those machining tools are using chucks/collets/etc whose sizes/TIR/etc is all actually metric.
(IE the 1/2" chuck/collet/whatever is really machined to 12.7mm)
But I'll believe it when the construction industry let's go of the foot and the inch.
A 12.7 mm collet is not a metric collet. A metric collet would be a 12 or 13 mm.
This was my point about the collet, too. It's true they collets are not meant to be holding metric sized end mills/etc, but the collet itself is milled using metric sizes. They are not milled to 0.50000, they are milled to 12.70mm.
I'm glad we got that cleared up. Since the Inch is specified as 25.4 mm you can convert any measurement in Inches into an exact equivalent in metric. But that does not make it a metric size.
Inches: 1/8, 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, 1" etc and various measures in between (5/32nd for instance).
Metric: 1mm, 2mm, 3mm, 4mm, 5mm, 6mm, etc. and various measures in between (5.5 mm for instance).
So you buy your lumber in Imperial measures (apparently except for thickness), and the rest of the world buys theirs in meters (or mm). That's the difference between 'working in Imperial' and 'working in metric'.
If you want only integer or half integer metric sizes, that's something different than "metric sized"
That said, rough lumber outside of plywood/framing lumber is weird in both the US and Europe anyway. Nobody is trying to hit any exact sizes of anything, except that the lumber needs to be able plane down to certain thicknesses. Grading is based on percentage of clear cutting, not on thickness or width or length. If your lumber supplier doesn't give you lumber in thicknesses that can be planed down to the right size, you get a new supplier. Same in Europe.
But I can't seem to get around your mental block that the system you are working in is Imperial, not metric so I'll leave it at this.
Same with hardwood lumber, in fact.
Considering i build about 20 pieces of fine furniture a year, and have built 3 houses, all of which are things "beyond a picnic table", as well as being active in a number of the industry associations that define this stuff (in my spare time), and you apparently know more, maybe you could explain the logic to me.
FWIW: I have no mental block, i actually work in both systems all the time. The whole exercise here has been pointing out your claims are wrong, not about me at all.
If you go to a home depot and ask for something 2x4x8ft, it will not be 2.00 by 4.00 inches or 8ft long, when measured with a caliper. Its weird in the sense that the stated sizes are only approximate, quite unlike hardware or fasteners, wrenches etc.
The keep their name though. This is a convention and a quite confusing one if you're not familiar with the process.
So, would your proposed law to switch the USA to the metric system require hardware stores to stock every size and always have what you need in stock?
Tape measures have standard units because they're standard where tape measures are used - in construction.
Where it makes sense, metric is common, e.g. soft drink bottles.
Not really, those are all pretty practical examples. I've dealt with each and every one of those.
> Americans with wrenches tend to have both SAE and metric sizes.
The metric ones will be brand new if they have them, the imperial ones will be well worn.
> The thread pitches of metric bolts differs from SAE standards
Indeed they do. In the EU Ford vehicles are all metric unless they were private imports from the USA. I'm not sure what the situation is today but when I still lived in Canada the ford we had had all imperial sizes bolts as far as they were exposed.
> Tape measures have standard units because they're standard where tape measures are used - in construction.
Yes, and as long as you don't change that that's they way it will stay. The English drive on the left because they do. But that doesn't mean they can say that they've adopted driving on the right side of the road because they could. They haven't. So construction is almost entirely in Imperial.
In a metric country, metric is used everywhere, because it makes sense.
Some of my older metric tools predate that. I owned a '64 Baja bug - thereby learning the art of static timing adjustment.
Changing tape measures isn't going to change US construction practice. Lumber has to change. Cold formed steel manufacturing standards have to change. Steel mills have to change.
All the engineering tables have to change. And insurance underwriters have to be willing to eat claims based on any confusion which this creates - it's kind of like the Hubble telescope without NASA redundancy, except that people will probably die.
Agreed with all the other points and that is exactly why I think this will not happen.
I can't think of a situation where "metric is common" for consumer items.
Every OTC pharmaceutical I've ever seen, pretty much.
So I wouldn't say the 2 L bottle is the sole anomaly, but metric is definitely not the prevalent system for beverages.
On my wife's Suzuki their M10 will not work with a 3/8" socket, and if you get into anywhere serious on a GM or Ford - those bolt heads will be exact metric with no room for imperial.
The ford I had had a surprising amount of imperial on it about a decade ago. Presumably under the hood and inside the engine it was all metric though.
I can verify its 30 mm with my wheels/hubs on my car. Supposedly that's "unusual" and most cars that size are 28mm or 32mm so people end up mystified why their 28 doesn't fit something that looks visually at a distance like a 28, or they use a way too big 32 and neatly round off the corners of the nut when it slips. I imagine using an imperial impact wrench is an effective way to round off the wheel nuts on a Saturn.
I would imagine if you bought aftermarket wheels/studs alloy or steel you could have most any size within a narrow range that's compatible with the hub.
"hitch"
LOL at the idea of my tiny little 2-door subcompact towing anything like those giant RV trailers. I do know standard american trailer hitch on pickup trucks has been 2 inch square for a century or something like that. Kind of like how we're not going to change every piece of railroad track and rolling stock in the USA to a metric equivalent rail gauge any time soon, until the end of time we'll be stuck with 50.8mm trailer hitches. I bet you could slam a european 50mm in the hole within manufacturing/rust tolerances.
The explorer is metric in a lot of places. The engine is SAE since it's based on the 302 which was originally designed in the early '60s. Pretty much anything that was designed from the mid 80s or later will be 100% metric hardware unless it needs to work with something that isn't. And even then it'll will sometimes be metric until it hits the non-metric piece. For example, the Tremec T-5 transmission is metric but mates up to the Ford 302 which is SAE.
So basically, it's usually metric except when it's not.
When it comes to highways and tape measures, you're right though. A tape measure is most commonly used in carpentry, which is almost entirely imperial. Our cars all have speedometers that display MPH in large type, so I don't see that changing without some mandate.
Simply deprecating customary units won't be enough to make the switch, you would actually have to make it illegal, and Hell will freeze over before you'll see that pass in the U.S. ("Doesn't Congress have actual problems to fix???")
We built structures and equipment that went around the world... all using imperial.
Every socket set i have contains both SAE and metric. Half of my power tools are in metric (festool).
All plywood that you buy from the hardware store in the US is really metric sized nowadays.
Every screw/fastener on every tool I own is metric or metric sized. I haven't used my SAE hex keys in eons.
Home Depot does not agree with you.
From http://www.homedepot.com/h_d1/N-5yc1vZbu0m/h_d2/Navigation?c...
this is my absolute favorite: "5.2 mm x 2 ft. x 4 ft. Sanded project panel", all the rest is in Imperial.
The width/length is not in metric, the actual thickness is, though they come up with an imperial equivalent that is within a few thousandths.
In other words, they tell folks 1/4 plywood is 15/64, 1/2" plywood is 15/32, etc. In reality, they are undersized to the nearest mm.
No non-hardwood plywood, even 1/4" plywood, is oversized, and 6.45mm would be oversized at .2539 inches. If it was actual 1/4" (hardwood plywood), it would be 6.4mm per APA (american plywood association) standards.
Outside of hardwood plywood, thicknesses are really done in metric.
1/4" nominal plywood nowadays is sized at "15/64" imperial, or in reality, 6mm.
1/2" nominal plywood is 12mm, or "15/32".
(the actual sizes are metric, but are close enough in tolerance to imperial /32 or /64 sizes that they work)
The only plywood you will find that is "actual" size in imperial is domestically produced hardwood plywood.
This is not a large percentage of produced plywood :)
Actual thickness you mean...
All construction sheet goods available in the US come in 4x8 sheets (drywall excepted, which I believe can be as long as 12').
Just because you can express "4ft by 8ft" as "Xmm by Ymm" (and that very well may be the official spec) doesn't make it 'metric' lumber in any meaninful way.
In any case, let me make this very simple:
All non-domestically produced (and most domestically produced) sheet goods are produced to metric sizes that are close to 4ft x 8ft x whatever thickness. They are whole number integer metric sizes. They are metric sheet goods. They are produced and measured metrically by every producer and exporter.
They get sold as imperial sizes in the US. However, the fact that they are close to some imperial size does not make them imperial sized lumber in any meaningful way.
If i take a bunch of things that were produced as squares, sell them as circles, and people keep calling them circles, that doesn't make them circles.
You can call a 4ft x 8ft x 1/2" piece of sheathing 4ft x 8ft x 1/2" if you like. But it's neither 4ft, nor 8ft, nor 1/2".
If you don't believe that sheet goods produced and measured metrically to whole number metric sizes are metric sized simply because someone in the US decides to call it something different, we'll have to simply agree to disagree as to whether they are metric.
I'm happy to agree that folks in the US don't work with the metric system intentionally, but they are working with it, whether they know it or not.
This whole discussion started because one of the premises given was that things like construction sheet goods (and lumber, but let's stay simple) would have to change for folks to be able to use the metric system in the US.
As i've shown, this is simply false, they just need to pretending they are imperial sizes, because the construction sheet goods are already done to metric sizes.
- most people actually just get me exactly what I want
- nobody ever complained "why do you ask metrics, you're in the US we use imperial!!", ever
- nobody ever told me "I don't know what that makes in inches, do you know it in inches?" (or similar), ever
So while I'm just one person and all, I still have a feeling this could eventually work.
The key is, I think, start with the measurements you use in your daily life and start estimating in those terms. Use it in the office. It might be accelerated if there's a metrics app for the Google Glasses, automatically converting signs into metric. You start saying, "dude, that bouncer must be two meters tall!" and getting everyone around you to convert.
Nothing really changed, other than confirming by directive that EU member states uses the Metric system with one another. There are still Brits who complain that the weather reports are no longer in Fahrenheit, but in Celsius. But the EU has no control over that.
So yeah; pretty much the same. Oh and the Brits still weigh themselves in stones.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_Kingd...
One major way in which metrication is being introduced properly is via schools - nowadays schools generally only teach the metric system, and the generation below me genuinely do weigh themselves in kilos, and measure themselves in meters.
I have a vague idea of my height in feet and inches, I drink pints of beer and I drive miles in the car. That's about it. People may as well be talking to me in a foreign language if they give me imperial units outside of those contexts.
Liquid goods in the UK are listed in milliletres or litres. In the US, fluid ounces (fl oz) are still commonly used. (The exception in the UK is pints for beer and milk).
Similarly, walk into a UK supermarket and solid goods are labelled in grams and kilograms. In the US, it's common for goods to be listed in pounds (lbs) or ounces (oz).
Also in the UK, dimensions for goods/products is always in metres, centimetres or millimetres. A lot of people still use feet and inches to describe a persons' height.
So yes, we do use a mixture of metric and imperial in the UK. However, the UK and US are not "pretty much the same" when it comes to metric.
From what I recall, it was more that they were using Żywiec-branded glasses, which hold 0.3 and 0.5-litres respectively. UK law only allows beer to be sold in pint units.
I doubt they were doing it on purpose, but the small difference adds up quite quickly: serve 10 drinks at pint prices for only the cost of 9 pints.
Wine 12% = 0,1L
Whiskey 40% = 0,035L
One glass is about 10g alcohol. (Posted only in liters so it easy on people who are not used to it.)
I guess being worried that you might not get your full ~5.68 litres of beer when drinking ten pints is very British indeed ;-)
Really? What are those things called Half pints?
You may call it a pint but officially it is a 568ml glass.
Food stuff is typically bought in dekagrams for meat or cheese and kg for fruits or grocery (you skip "gram" in informal language, so it's "30 deko of this, and kilo of the apples, please").
Drinks are sold by liters, soda mostly in 1.5l ("one and a half" in Polish it's one word), alcohol in 0.75(default), 0.5 ("a half"), or 0.25 ("a quarter"). Everybody are used to it and it's quick.
Prices everywhere are per kg, sometimes also per 100g (I don't understand why, dividing by 10 is automatic, but anyway).
But I doubt that Washington D.C. uses kph on its speed signs, though.
I was in high school for a couple of those years. I drove 120 MPH frequently. I probably would have got pulled over for that. I had a friend who got pulled over for going 90 MPH. Ultimately, I think the ambiguity of "reasonable and prudent" led to the state enacting a 75 MPH speed limit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_in_the_United_Stat...
There are two incredibly beautiful national parks there, Glacier and Yellowstone. Yellowstone is one of the best known parks in America.
I suspect that metrication of the highway system in the US will only happen if a large state like California or Texas converts. But with the current budget situation, that's highly unlikely.
"the National Highway System Designation Act of 1995 prohibited the use of Federal-aid highway funds to convert existing signs or purchase new signs with metric units."
It appears from my reading of the law that the prohibition expired in 2000.
"However, Congress passed legislation in 1994 and 1995 that prohibited federal funding for converting highway signs, such as those for speed limits, to metric units."
This hasn't been true for years. Our current speed limits are in line with the rest of the country.
In British supermarkets, milk is usually sold in pints, except on the packaging it has to say "768 ml".
(By the way, I think your (U.S.) pints aren't the same as our (Imperial) pints.)
Often you see milk in 1 litre bottles instead. I suspect the reason this goes on is because it looks like it's 2 pints, but of course it's actually less than 2 pints. So it's basically just a sales trick to make the milk look cheaper and to confuse customers.
Cream is practically always sold in 1/2 pints, which on the packaging is written as 284 ml. As far as I remember, I've never actually seen it written as 1/2 pint, but that's what it is. I think a lot of people don't even know that it's 1/2 pint of cream.
We still use the Imperial system for lots of other things, e.g. beer, waistlines, car speeds, etc.
Furthermore in speech, the idioms "kilometrestone", "millimetreing forward", "give a millimetre and he'll take a kilometre" just don't sound as good!
In the markets in Holland, you often hear people asking for a "pond" of carrots, or whatever. (You also see it written by the stallholders as "ponds".) In this case, they mean 500g, however (according to Wikipedia) a Dutch pond was actually 494.09 g. (An Imperial pound on the other hand is 453.59 g).
(By the way, I find it a bit embarassing to write "Imperial", but I've stuck with it.)
I would also like to point out that the French and the Italians still measure their computer monitors, and their bicycle wheels in inches! Not their horrible millimetres.
My Dad (who is an architect) tells me that boilers are still measured in BTU's. I don't know if that's still true.
I have to say that the Metric system is definitely easier when it comes to (a) science, (b) surveying, engineering, etc.
For everything else (e.g. toast, road signs, boilers, cream, trousers, etc.) I'd rather have Imperial units.
That's what happens in Colombia. We ask for a pound of meat, and we actually expect 500 grams.
Also we measure fuel in gallons, while the milk is in liters.
In open air markets, vegetables are sometimes sent by the pound (500g, une livre in French). That's about it AFAIK.
A UK pint is 568ml, which is some way off 454g. Unlike the US pint, which is much closer at 473ml.
"The United States is one of the few countries left in the world who still have not converted to using the Metric System as a standardized system of measurement. Instead of going along with what the rest of the world uses, we stubbornly still adhere to using the imprecise Imperial Unit - despite the fact that practically every other country that we interact with uses Metric."
This petition has the same problem most petitions submitted to the White House have--its factual premise is incorrect. I'm an American who has lived in another country (Taiwan) for years. The National Institute of Standards and Technology reports that "The United States is now the only industrialized country in the world that does not use the metric system as its predominant system of measurement."
http://www.nist.gov/pml/wmd/metric/upload/1136a.pdf
But the same government report notes that
". . . . In 1866, Congress authorized the use of the metric system in this country and supplied each state with a set of standard metric weights and measures.
"In 1875, the United States solidified its commitment to the development of the internationally recognized metric system by becoming one of the original seventeen signatory nations to the Treaty of the Meter."
In other words, the United States has treated the Metric System as official and legal since before my great-grandfather was born. The customary measurement system is, by contrast, simply customary, not mandatory. The United States has been metric since 1866 "in the sense that Americans have been free since that time to use the metric system as much as they like."
http://www.unc.edu/~rowlett/units/usmetric.html
If a particular individual or corporation engaged in manufacturing or trade wants to use metric measurements to meet customer needs and gain a profit, no one in the United States is stopping that. If someone desires to use customary measurements out of sheer habit from long-established custom, no one is stopping that either. My late dad the industrial engineer was aware of plenty of industries in the United States that from the 1970s, at the latest, had gone fully metric simply because those industries were involved in vigorous international trade. Perhaps the best governmental nudge that can be given for more use of metric measurements in the United States is more encouragement of developing international markets for domestic businesses.
I note that customary measurements are often used in other countries even long after metric measurements are adopted officially. For example, the Republic of China (the regime that governs Taiwan at present) has been officially metric since before I was born. Japan (the former governing country in Taiwan) was metric from the 1920s. But the unit of weight for vegetables bought in an open-air market in Taiwan is still the traditional 斤 (jin "catty," or Chinese pound), although that is now standardized at 500g. Prices are given in monetary units per 斤 for most fruits and vegetables to this day in markets in Taiwan (and in China).
A Facebook friend with a scientific education recently told me about the saying "A pint's a pound, the whole world round." If the United States begins using metric-standard units more for selling foods and the like, then perhaps a half-kilogram (500g) package will be considered to be one new "pound," just as a half-liter (500ml) package will be considered to be one new "pint." It is interesting to me that traditional Chinese culture and traditional British culture both had weight units in that range, about a half kilogram even before standardization to metric units. How are grocery measurements treated in Britain these days?