News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:30AM (#49432834)
Things that are more expensive in the US for no reason:

  Healthcare

  Internet access

  College
sighs and adds "The very act of making a purchase"

At least we have cheap gas? farts

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by Gormo on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:45AM (#49433073)
Internet access isn't particularly expensive in the US.

Healthcare, education, and housing are expensive in the US for the same primary reason: political interventions that simultaneously subsidize demand and restrict supply.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by red-iron-pine on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:09AM (#49434451)
it is for what you get. the US LEC and CLEC system sucks, and I had wayyyy more options in the EU, and in fairly upfront and straightforward ways.

e.g. https://documentscontractuels.orange.fr/les-offres-orange-mo...

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by jimbob45 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:27AM (#49445647)
The EU doesn’t have the challenging scope and geography of the US, no?
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by db48x on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:29AM (#49446640)
The problem in the US is less of a geography problem and more of a regulatory one. Many towns and cities in the US gave the cable companies local monopolies back in the 50s and 60s. There are technical reasons why this worked ok (not well but perhaps better than the alternatives) for television, but now that the same rules have stretched to apply to delivery of internet access they no longer have any technical basis. So at this point they’re just a barrier to competition and exist only to raise prices.

The good news is that modern fiber systems blow cable internet out of the water. It is far cheaper to supply symmetric gigabit internet to every customer over fiber than over cable. Fiber just has more bandwidth to go around. And because it’s a different technology it is not subject to the same local monopolies that cable is encumbered with. This means that the free market is correcting the problem and has been for a decade. In many parts of the country it is now possible to get internet that is faster and cheaper than what is available in the even the best built parts of Europe. The main obstacle to that build–out is probably local permitting. Many large cities require new permits, with public comment periods for each and every one of them, for every single block that an ISP lays fiber for. Cities like San Francisco have imposed a glacial pace on their ISPs.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by toast0 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:54AM (#49450257)
> And because it’s a different technology it is not subject to the same local monopolies that cable is encumbered with.

Exclusive francise agreements between municipalities and cable operators have been outlawed since 1992. But it's generally uneconomic to overbuild a new network with the potential to touch every home unless a large portion will subscribe.

Fiber internet is typically much better than cable internet, but cable internet is good enough for most people, so they're unlikely to switch unless it's significantly cheaper, which it often isn't -- especially since local incumbents tend to lower prices or rollout better service when a new entrant is entering the market (or announces they will ... Google Fiber city selection announcements drove lots of competing rollouts even though Google didn't install anything in those cities).

Regulation requiring wholesale access / line sharing / or strict separation of first mile and service infrastructure would allow for competition in service and routing, without having to build a 3rd last mile network. Congress did this in 1996, but the FCC walked it back for cable, the courts said if it doesn't apply to cable, it doesn't apply to telephone, and the FCC said internet over power lines exists and provides competition despite the lack of providers. Congress never came back to make clear that it wanted line sharing, so it disappeared from the mainstream.

I have municipal fiber where the municipality handles last mile only and I have a choice of IP service providers. But installation was very expensive and monthly service is also expensive relative to the ILEC and the cable company, although the cable company service on my street ends before it reaches me.

The cable and telephone companies have a major cost advantage that they can rebuild their networks with a good expectation of customer uptake; and they're allowed to manage the finances of build out however they see fit. The muni fiber (in my state anyway) has to bill customers for the costs of install and even if it could self-finance a build out to service all homes, wouldn't see a lot of uptake because most people find their current service to be good enough.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:00AM (#49450379)
The federal government subsidized a planned, massive fiber build-out almost 3 decades ago. The telcos pocketed the money and then refused to complete the build-out, complaining that the last mile was too expensive. Municipalities pull teeth and the telcos have slowly rolled out to-home fiber piecemeal in the intervening years, as the local capacity to handle their extortionate rates appears. Alternatively, they will lay cable to your unconnected house/neighborhood for payments in the six- and seven-figure range.

Where we are is very much not a function of the free market.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by db48x on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:25PM (#49458263)
Oh, I agree. There are huge distortions that have delayed the roll out of fiber internet by decades. But money talks, and ISPs are now building huge fiber networks in some parts of the country in spite of the best efforts of our government. I subscribe to Ziply Fiber (<https://ziplyfiber.com/internet>) which is building a large network in the Pacific Northwest that provides superb service to millions. They’re not perfect, but they’ll provide up to 50Gbps (symmetric) service to residential customers across four states. Compared to Comcast/Xfinity, which tops out at 2Gbps × 300Mbs, Ziply is amazing. That’s the free market fixing the problem in spite of the distortions introduced by local monopolies.

And that competition is definitely a good thing. Xfinity’s offering was far worse before they had competition because there was no incentive to offer anything better. They’ve even introduced a new idea to the market in order to win people back away from fiber: guaranteed fixed prices for five years. No surprises when promotional rates expire, no price increases, no shenanigans at all for five whole years. That alone is a breath of fresh air compared to their own business practices of just a year or two ago. Ziply had to respond by lowering their prices and ending promotional rates because they were losing customers. You know the old saying: as iron sharpens iron, so too does man sharpen man.

It would be better, of course, if the government were not mismanaging things. Switzerland’s solution is the better way to go than what we have today. Their government paid to build a nation–wide fiber network, and any ISP can service any customer on that network. That allows ISPs to compete on price and features without worrying about having to build their own competing and overlapping network. This is already how electric service works in many states, so it’s not even like we can’t make it work.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:18AM (#49464471)
It's not the government, and I'm calling bullshit on your narrative because there's no mention of municipal fiber, and the industry's successful lobbying to make it illegal in most of the country. THAT would have been REAL competition.

>Their government paid to build a nation–wide fiber network

So did we. The last step is nationalizing that network and finishing the build-out in-house.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by db48x on Friday August 28, 2026 @12:11AM (#49474267)
Municipal fiber exists in some places, but not most. It’s actually fairly common up here in the Pacific Northwest. Dozens of towns dotted around the map have their own municipal fiber networks, but Ziply serves more customers than all of them combined. Thus I say that the free market is fixing the problem that the government created. Another good example is Starlink. They provide service to millions in very rural areas that are out of reach of other ISPs.

When we paid for national broadband access here in the US, it was not for fiber to the home. It was for DSL. Worse, the FCC measured coverage not by service address as it does today, but by census district. The phone companies merely had to assert that they could provide service to an address in the district and the FCC would count the whole district as covered. The districts aren’t very big, so in dense areas that was not a bad estimation. In less dense areas it was just a giant loophole. They could provide service to one house on the edge of the district and not bother with the hundreds of homes miles away out in the countryside. Officially we got exactly what we paid for.

As you say we could still nationalize these fiber networks and stitch them together into a real national network. Of course they don’t all use exactly the same technology, and it would be a huge political fight, but in principle I could see a government agency gradually buying networks from the ISPs and integrating them. Of course you know that if Trump proposes it then the Democrats will immediately oppose it on the general principle that Trump proposed it.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:35AM (#49499037)
The reason municipal fiber doesn't serve more customers is, again, because states were lobbied by telcos to make it illegal. Likewise, the loopholes that allowed the intended broadband buildout to be stymied. The problem is ultimately one of hobbled regulation allowing corporations to move and abuse freely. That makes the problem the free market.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by db48x on Monday August 31, 2026 @10:51AM (#49510502)
Regulation is not the free market. Of course companies are going to lobby for more regulations if they think that they can get away with it. It only works because the legislators are idiots who think that free markets _must_ be regulated. It is easy to hoodwink them into passing idiotic regulations. They boast about the accomplishment in their press releases as if they had saved the country.

Municipal fiber is not outlawed here in Oregon, so there are quite a few municipal networks here. But they are not expanding as fast as even a single ISP like Ziply Fiber. None of them have expanded beyond their small town to serve unincorporated areas near by. All of them are funded more by taxes than by subscribers.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by xyzelement on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:34AM (#49447912)
// subsidize demand and restrict supply

I have never seen anyone articulate this so crisply.

The government has created a situation with the student loans thing where basically anyone can borrow 500k to get an obviously useless degree.

Are the colleges going to ensure they collect that money? Obviously yes.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by Gormo on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:51AM (#49448205)
> The government has created a situation with the student loans thing where basically anyone can borrow 500k to get an obviously useless degree.

The point applies even to the useful degrees, and more broadly to the universities irrespective of any particular degree program. Student loans and scholarships make demand almost completely inelastic -- totally insensitive to price increases. Universities compete to attract the best students, and a major mechanism for doing that is to invest in non-academic amenities, such that tuition prices are funding much more than literal tuition. Combine these two factors together, and you have a feedback loop of continuous price inflation.

Similar factors are at work in the healthcare and housing sectors, with the most important element being that external subsidies eliminate price elasticity on the demand side of the equation, and completely obliterate the dynamics that ensure downward price pressure in normal markets.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by joenot443 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:06AM (#49433344)
Bit for bit, internet access is cheaper in America than it is in Canada or Australia.

Canadians like myself have ~40% of our provincial taxes spent on healthcare, so in my case about ~8% of my gross income. Somewhere in the tune of $20k/yr. While I was living in Seattle and filing American, quite a bit less of my gross income went to healthcare. Just food for thought.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by StrauXX on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:23AM (#49433618)
But that is not because it's less efficient. With the Canadian system being socialzed and 20k$ being just 8% of your income it is to be expected that you would pay moch more than the median person into the system.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:31AM (#49433738)
"I make $250k CAD a year, my experiences must be representative of, and relevant to, the masses," is a wild thought to have.

Well, maybe I spoke too soon, because my private American healthcare turns out to also be about 8% of my gross income (of $60k)(before copays and my deductible)(and also it's crap). Twinsies!

But yes I agree that it would be awful to have my health needs taken care of and a mere ~160k USD left to spend on everything else.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by joenot443 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:36PM (#49437654)
Oh I certainly don’t think it’s representative to that of the masses, I was sharing an anecdote.

I think either way both of us are in really good shape. In my experience the quality of American care is better in nearly every regard (having experienced both pretty intimately), but the simplicity and the peace of mind of the Canadian system has its benefits too. In either case you end up paying.

> But yes I agree that it would be awful to have my health needs taken care of and a mere ~160k USD left to spend on everything else.

I’m confused - do you actually think it’s awful?

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by bluealienpie on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:03AM (#49445488)
I think the main issue that the NHS model of 10+ years ago worked when fully funded. The Canadian model is a mix match of US healthcare and Medicare. Some drugs aren’t covered, some procedures take forever, and you don’t get guaranteed doctor. Many European healthcare system have solved the issues we have, but Canada has refused to adopt any sensible system.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by 59percentmore on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:52AM (#49450223)
You're being disingenuous. You clearly meant your anecdote to be representative, at least for "Canadians like [yourself]". But I suspect that it was meant to be a broader statement, and you're only backtracking now because the ridiculousness of that notion is apparent.

>I think either way both of us are in really good shape.

I'm lying in bed with non-specific upper abdominal discomfort that I'm hoping isn't related to digestive issues (pancreatic) that I've had for years, but which I can't get treated for because my insurance-related circumstances have made it very difficult to get consistent access to, and then to be taken seriously by, relevant specialists. These issues have combined with chronic injuries that were poorly managed in their acute phase and poor access to quality nutrition to make it difficult for me to exercise consistently. Contrarily and consequently, I'm quite out-of-shape.

The best and most consistent care I've ever gotten was while I was on Medicaid (which was still yet hampered by the professional stigma against accepting Medicaid and treating Medicid patients well).

>In my experience the quality of American care is better in nearly every regard (having experienced both pretty intimately

You experienced the quality of care available to rich people. That quality of care is not widely available, not for lack of institutional capacity, but primarily due to lack of profit.

>I’m confused

I really don't think you are.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:13AM (#49446007)
> Canadians like myself have ~40% of our provincial taxes spent on healthcare

Worth noting that taxes in the US are a lot lower than they should be because a large portion of government expenses are financed with debt. Canada owns over 400B in US debt, so that's Canada "subsidizing" US taxes.

Also, yes, that's how healthcare works: when you're young and less sick, you tend to pay more than you get out of it, and then it reverses as you get older.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by goalieca on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:34AM (#49447196)
Canada has a huge debt problem at the provincial and federal level. The provincial level even covers for the cities spending problems.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by bvanheu on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:18AM (#49450703)
there is a big chunk of people who wouldn't afford healthcare in the USA but still have access to in Canada. I don't mind paying more taxes if this means everyone has healthcare access.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by NewJazz on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:07AM (#49460007)
What do you mean "quite a bit less of my gross income went to healthcare"? Are you factoring in the insurance premiums paid by your employer? For many people that is both an invisible and significant health care cost.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by corranh on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:28AM (#49466424)
That’s pretty comparable actually. The most recent quote I received for private healthcare in the US was just under $2,000 per month ($24,000 per year).
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by api on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:31AM (#49432852)
Internet access sort of has a reason: the US is geographically huge and more sprawled out. But that's not enough to explain all of the difference.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by stefanfisk on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:32AM (#49433753)
That’s not the reason. The required build out has actually already been been paid for: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/the-book-of-broken-promis_b_5.... But the US is so politically broken that corporations could just pocket the money without actually providing the infrastructure.

That does even begin to touch on crazy laws banning people from setting up their own ISP to compete: https://www.techdirt.com/2024/11/07/16-u-s-states-still-ban-....

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by Ekaros on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:36AM (#49432943)
That really explains only small parts. Even the horrible suburbs have little real reason to be that expensive. In the end it is really about lacking actual free market and enabling corporate capture as voted by the voters.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by alistairSH on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:52AM (#49433160)
That might explain internet pricing in North Dakota, but it doesn't explain it in NYC or DC or LA.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by joenot443 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:08AM (#49433367)
I pay $40/mo for 500mbps in my Bushwick apartment - is that considered expensive?
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by alistairSH on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:22AM (#49433584)
By US standards? No, probably not.

But, a quick search indicates you can get similar broadband in Glasgow, Scotland for ~15 GBP/month. And Rome, Italy looks like ~25EUR/month.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by stefanfisk on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:38AM (#49433871)
I’m in Stockholm, and our condo HOA (BRF) includes 1Gbps per unit in the fee for all units because billing individually would cost more in admin than the service itself. We have FTTP and then cat6 to each unit.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by joenot443 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:32PM (#49437605)
That sounds really convenient! Is it a new building? I know the odd American or Canadian build will have that, but only the newer and more expensive ones.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by stefanfisk on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:35PM (#49439446)
The building is from the 1940s.

But this is a pretty common setup for condos in Swedish cities. Rentals usually have access to the same infrastructure but at higher prices due to kickbacks demanded by the landlords from the ISPs.

The backbone of it all is a state owned fiber connecting the cities together with municipal fiber.

But even outside of the cities FTTP is quite common. There are companies which specialize in finding rural areas where there’s enough interest to justify the cost of connecting them and then coordinating getting an economic association setup to own and manage the local infrastructure.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by Hikikomori on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:00PM (#49442900)
I had that in Sweden 20 years ago. Typically our local municipality put fiber whenever they dug up anything, so fiber is everywhere.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by whizzter on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:16AM (#49445577)
This is something to underscore, US people always talks about how "big and sprawling" the US is, but there's fiber at my fathers house in Northern Sweden that's in an area with similar population density to Wisconsin or whatever rural US state you want to pick.

Some kind of city(iirc) managed fiber and he can switch commercial operators (And speeds/prices) by contacting them to get new terms, that's an actually free market.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by Symbiote on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:31AM (#49447156)
In Copenhagen mine is billed individually, and is 75kr for 1Gb/s. About $10.

Otherwise the same system.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by marcyb5st on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:36AM (#49447937)
Just did my internet contract for my apartment in rural Italy (a town of around 2k people in the Verona province). 1Gb symmetric is indeed 25EUR/month. I added a few stuff on top like static IPv4 and reached 32EUR/month.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by dawnerd on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:16AM (#49445582)
I’m paying 100 bucks for 2.5gb fiber in socal. I don’t consider that expensive either. I’ve seen internet prices internationally and they kinda suck outside of some areas that have decent providers - but that goes for the US too.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by topspin on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:04AM (#49446419)
> the US is geographically huge and more sprawled out.

There is ample historical evidence that this is a poor excuse.

Long ago, leaders in the US understood the value of universality. You'll likely recognize this as the Network Effect, Metcalfe's Law, etc. Back in the day, they called this "universal service." That thinking was central to the policies established for both electrification and phone service in the US: it wasn't then, and isn't now, truly universal, but what could be feasibly accommodated was, even when costs were/are quite high.

It wasn't lost on the people of those times that such policies inherently meant the cost of including sparsely populated, distant areas would be subsidized by concentrated areas. Before those systems appeared, the founders welded the same thinking into the US constitution in the form of the US postal service, with exactly the same knowledge and concerns.

We've lost that. The change happened prior to the advent of the internet. You're free to attribute this to whatever you wish; I won't offer my view on that, except to say there are no innocents: every argument that fingers ebil capitalists can be countered by examples of urban leaders damning government policies that subsidize non-urbanites. What I know with certainty is, if packet switched networking was somehow a thing in the 19th century, availability would be a given for almost any structure more significant than a hunting cabin in the US today, complete with common carrier, service baselines and rates established with clarity.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by mrguyorama on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:39PM (#49452958)
Why was that not a problem in the mid 1800s when we crisscrossed the entire country with railroads and telegraph cables?

Sure is funny how FDR had us spend a little cash 100 years ago to ensure even the remotest farm gets electricity, and we already gave ISPs a shitload of cash to do the same, but now "We can't" build telephone poles to rural places. Even though those same places already have telephone poles for power and telephone.

AT&T was able to leverage it's monopoly position and defense industry relationship to basically invent everything that runs the modern world (and were compelled to license those advancements out) while modern monopolies can't even dig some holes.

Sounds like we need some more "Consent Decrees" and a DoJ that makes large companies scared.

We damned every single river in the nation. We built so much railroad that it crashed the industry. We built those railroads purposely in places where nobody lived and then willed towns into existence around them. We built the interstate highway system.

Why can we suddenly not build anything? Maybe it's because people keep insisting, against all historical evidence, that we can't, and they don't even try.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by gnz11 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:18AM (#49446535)
You can add Pre-K education to that list. It's on par in terms of costs with sending your kids to college.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by pjc50 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:04AM (#49447527)
Healthcare and college are "Baumol cost disease": because they depend on skilled workers, much of that is the same as "American salaries are higher than in the rest of the world", and unlike manufacturing or software (+) you can't outsource it to lower-wage countries.

(+) there still seems to be a massive wage premium for "being physically in a San Francisco office" even if most of the work is being done by an AI, which cannot be sustainable

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by sharemywin on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:34AM (#49447913)
because code is only a small part of software development. don't forget ping pong tables. lol. I'm both making a valid point and making fun of it too.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by porkpieshoe on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:56PM (#49455793)
If it was this simple, then high costs would be limited to the labor-driven portion of the bills.

This is not the case.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by avadodin on Saturday August 29, 2026 @03:18AM (#49487683)
You can make all sort of excuses but we literally felt bad for 1:1 exchange students paying 2k a month while we paid 2k a year.

Their education was not 10x ours and their economy was only a few % over ours per capita.

Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by sharts on Saturday August 29, 2026 @02:05PM (#49491932)
I dunno, telehealth with foreign doctors while maybe in-person nurses could lower costs substantially.
Re:Credit Card Rewards Became a $9.2B Wealth Transfer by xyzelement on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:32AM (#49447873)
This is why people are moving out of the US in droves, the universities are empty and nobody goes to the doctor.