News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by arjie on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:23PM (#48787566)
These kinds of caps have for years been a dampener on human flourishing. My observation has been that those in stagnation or decline tend to attach themselves to these desires to hold the status quo. Anti-energy, anti-housing, anti-industry and so on because they've reached a local maxima in their ability to live and have chosen to spend their life in leisure.

But there is the rest of the world, and if I'm told that the Africans should not have access to high-speed satellite Internet[0] so that the Europeans can use one specific method of looking at the stars, I don't find that convincing. In time, as we expand, space-based observation will become fairly feasible for everyone. And the satellites we have will decay to the Earth should we fail to keep them up there.

We will build Earth orbital structures and swarms, and we will build Sun orbital structures and swarms, and we will go to the stars, and it will be better for humanity as a whole.

0: https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2026/07/02/...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Normal_gaussian on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:41PM (#48787707)
I think that "Africans should not have access to high-speed satellite Internet" is something you've just made up; the article you link talks about African people turning to Starlink because of local infrastructure issues, and the original article notes that the current satellite count is currently around 14k satellites. 100k is more than enough satellites to provide high-speed satellite internet globally.

The article makes mention of specific endeavours, like the night-time mirror satellites, which are particularly disruptive to astronomy, and the general risks of high numbers of satellites.

The ability to do Earth based astronomy is something that is of value to all the peoples of Earth, and is mainly funded by the western nations because of their current position as the people with more money.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:49PM (#48787794)
The article doesn’t consider that in a world with a million satellites in orbit, launching space-based telescopes—including into deep space—becomes an order of magnitude cheaper.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by acdha on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:51PM (#48787814)
Does it? My understanding was that it’s less helpful for anything which isn’t in low-earth orbit because the commercial launch engineers are optimizing for the lucrative satellite business, not larger and higher payloads.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:54PM (#48787841)
> commercial launch engineers are optimizing for the lucrative satellite business, not larger and higher payloads

Commercial satellites are getting bigger and heavier. Launch that can put big and heavy in LEO can put big and slightly less heavy higher up. Add to that things like in-orbit propellant transfer and there is a good chance astronomy sees a golden age in the coming decades (in countries with space access).

I’m not dismissing the problem. Just this analysis as meriting any conclusions. It’s a start. But it’s only part of a full model of how these changes would affect astronomy.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Teever on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:21PM (#48788116)
I get where you're coming from but we haven't really seen any sort of space based telescope designs that take advantage of the Falcon launch paradigm of cheap and reliable launches.

Some sort of modular telescope array that could be launched in pieces and self-assemble in orbit. Something that improves in capacity as more pieces are added.

Everything seems to have stalled in this field, as if it's just waiting for a Starship which may never come.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:25PM (#48788145)
> we haven't really seen any sort of space based telescope designs

We’re only starting to truly mass manufacture satellites. A world with millions of satellites means one with lots of satellite production and design economies of scale. (Same for all manner of sensors and optics.)

> as if it's just waiting for a Starship which may never come

Or it may. We’ll know in a couple years. Building a scaling production system for Falcon right now would be silly.

And if Starship never works out, we probably don’t see millions of satellites. It’s a fundamentally tied problem, which is why I say the analysis is incomplete.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:02PM (#48789867)
There are hundreds of Dove Satellites with telescopes in the Flock constellations from Planet Lab: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Labs

Most of them launched on the Falcon 9. They just point down to the Earth by default. ;-)

And there are other cubesats testing stuff for x-ray astronomy or gamma ray burst detection, such as:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VZLUSAT-2

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Tuna-Fish on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:01PM (#48787920)
Larger rockets are inherently more efficient, which is why all the commercial providers are moving towards them. And while yes, most of the providers are targeting primarily for LEO, if you have high payload capacity to LEO you can solve your issue of getting anywhere by packing in a kick stage. And cheap third-party kick stages are available and more are in development.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by onion2k on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:46PM (#48788331)
Google says that James Webb telescope cost a total of $10bn. That's not a lot of money in the grand scheme of things. Private citizens could afford to put similar things into space if they chose to. We don't need them to be cheaper.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788350)
> James Webb telescope cost a total of $10bn

I’d love to see an estimate of what a JWST-class telescope would cost to design, build and launch in a world maintaining a million-satellite fleet. My guess is less than $2bn.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by HPsquared on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:59PM (#48788447)
A big part of the complexity of JWST was the way everything had to fold and fit into a small launch vehicle. With larger vehicles (e.g. Starship) the JWST mirror could have been built in one piece, which is much simpler. The whole thing was engineered to the max to fit within tight constraints, which is very expensive.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:06PM (#48788494)
> With larger vehicles (e.g. Starship) the JWST mirror could have been built in one piece, which is much simpler

Not just the complexity of design, but also cost and complexity of cryo-vacuum testing hundreds of deployment mechanisms any one of whose failure critcially endangers the project. The mirror could also be conventionally manufactured versus requiring gold-plated beryllium [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_Telescope_Element

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:07PM (#48789892)
Not to mention it would be much cheaper and quicker to launch if it could have any form of robotic or human servicing/tuning available.

Designing it to not fail at the start & then work without any help for decades must have also made it much more expensive.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:32PM (#48788206)
Currently writing a draft blog post on all the issues (and non-issues) with these things, it is now long enough (7k words) I'm slightly wondering if it's less "a blog post" and more "one section of a decent sized book on why we can't have nice things".

Here's a visual to consider the implications of things you can do with actually one million satellites of the kind of size scale being discussed:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenWheatley/blog/refs/head...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:35PM (#48788242)
> Yes, they really would be this closely spaced: Earth's circumference is 40 million meters

Satellites don’t orbit on the ground, which makes the 40m spacing nonsense. And nobody proposes putting a million 120 kW satellites in a single orbit.

They really would never be that closely spaced. To approach those densities in a single orbital shell you’d need hundreds of billions of birds in orbit. Spread across all of LEO (and only LEO) we’re talking orders of magnitudes more satellites (like, quadrillions).

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by HPsquared on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:07PM (#48788510)
Can all orbits be completely filled at once, though? They'll intersect at some point (I had originally said poles but that's only polar orbits..) ... I suppose you have phase, altitude and inclination (and eccentricity which adds another couple of variables). But they do intersect, don't they?
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:17PM (#48788617)
> Can all orbits be completely filled at once, though? They’ll intersect

Correct. I wasn’t proposing a realistic configuration. Just showing why OP’s visual doesn’t work for the numbers it gives. (It 1D space fills. I expand that to 2 and 3D.)

Millions of satellites is currently accepted as the maximum carrying capacity of LEO before collisions becomes a PITA.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:29PM (#48789272)
Can't take advantage of the 3D-ness when you want them all to be in terminator-following SSOs. Best you get is 2D, and with current safety margins, even that fills up fast.

However, this was not the point of the illustration, which is more "if you can do this at all, you can do better".

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:42PM (#48788892)
> Satellites don’t orbit on the ground, which makes the 40m spacing nonsense.

Hence why the horizontal scale bar says "40 m to 43 m": Going to 500 km doesn't add much to the orbit's circumference.

> And nobody proposes putting a million 120 kW satellites in a single orbit.

One of my tentative conclusions is that it would be an improvement if they did. But also, there's better contiguous structures to build if you could put that much up.

It's in my blog post because I'm considering all possible arrangements of ways to do this. Current list:

  • Spread them out by altitude while still keeping them in sun-synchronous low earth orbit like SpaceX plan
  • Put them all of them in a single sun-synchronous low earth orbit so none of them can hit each other
  • Spread them out like Starlink currently is
  • Have swarms, where each group has many satellites significantly closer to each other than the usual safety separation, like Google's Project Suncatcher
  • Have fewer, bigger satellites, like Starcloud
> To approach those densities in a single orbital shell you’d need hundreds of billions of birds in orbit. Spread across all of LEO (and only LEO) we’re talking orders of magnitudes more satellites (like, quadrillions).

Matters less than I expected when I started writing. How much so depends on what I end up adding by treating gaps in "full" (up to the safety margin) orbits as the thing of interest and seeing if someone's done a version of this on spherical geometry and also add a time component: https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/270937/how-can-you-...

(That I'm researching such questions should explain both why I'm at 7k words and why I've not published it yet).

(One big surprise to me while researching this: along-track, cross-track, and radial positional error per unit time are all much higher than I would have guessed: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/smallsat/2015/all2015/58/).

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by rcxdude on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:49PM (#48787797)
Not to mention starlink is not a solution for internet for everyone on the planet: it cannot serve everyone in a densely populated area, no matter how many satellites they have in their constellation. It's a useful piece of infrastructure, but it's far from the panacea people seem to think it is.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by fc417fc802 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:30PM (#48788189)
> it cannot serve everyone in a densely populated area,

I also suspect that to be the case but in order to be more objective I wonder. What's the theoretical maximum bandwidth per square meter (or other unit area) that it can deliver?

[dead]
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by fc417fc802 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:01PM (#48789065)
> suppose one Starlink beam covers about 63 square miles

Is that the actual figure though?

> even a 100x improvement only gets you to about 300 kbps/person.

TBF even that would be quite useful for lots of things seeing as it's faster than the DSL service I once had. However agreed that it isn't going to replace fiber service and overbuilding to such an extent for outliers would be absurd.

Still, that's quite decent considering it's an estimate of a near worst case scenario.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by IncreasePosts on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:13PM (#48788045)
Ground based infrastructure is much easier to justify in densely populated areas. So, dense areas get ground infra, and the dispersed rural population can get satellite infra
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ethin on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:20PM (#48788651)
Starlink is already over-congested and physics says that it is not possible to scale it up to serve 100000000 subscribers let alone 5-6 billion or more. We would need some kind of physics breakthrough for that to scale properly, and I'm not even sure if physically it would even be possible to do that no matter what you threw at it. Starlink isn't magic as a lot of people seem to think it is.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ck2 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:21PM (#48788113)
note that including dead things in orbit

(that we currently have no way to remove)

is actually 32,000 not just 14,000

what we need is the investment for "space roombas" that go around bumping things out of orbit that are dead or did not de-orbit properly

the problem is all that atmospheric burnup creates a lot of toxic pollution

* https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-space-orbit-satellit...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788360)
> we currently have no way to remove

Nature takes care of this for us in LEO. I’ve seen no serious plans to put millions of anything anywhere else.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by solid_fuel on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:36PM (#48788245)
> These kinds of caps have for years been a dampener on human flourishing.

I don't think blocking the view of the night sky is necessary for "human flourishing", actually. Your attitude reminds me of the Victorians, who saw their coal-smoke filled skies as a sign of virtuous progress.

More reasonable minds prevailed, in the end, and now most people have a more balanced view - with the understanding that progress and industry must be balanced with the ecosystem we live in and depend upon for life.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tekne on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:02PM (#48789069)
Controversial opinion: at the time, it was.

To be able to live well now with much less of that may not have been possible without the sacrifices that came before.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ajam1507 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:34AM (#48795043)
I don't think viewing the night sky is necessary for "human flourishing"
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:56PM (#48787869)
As a literal leftist by any reasonable metric, the recent trend towards “I wish it was 1995” and “AI is the worst” and “tech sucks now” from people I agree with on many other points frustrates me to no end.

“You guys know we could basically live in a Star Trek style utopia if we get this right, right?”

“The DATA cenTERS are STEALING the water and breaking Taleckshual ProPerty LERRS!”

Like, I thought we were for piracy, and against capital colonizing the space of creative ideas? But I guess what a lot of people were fond of was feeling important.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by hack1312 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:10PM (#48788008)
“if we get this right” is doing a whole lot of heavy lifting here.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:34PM (#48788232)
But that’s the thing! We could and we can!
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by roughly on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:12PM (#48788555)
None of the problems with building a utopia are technological, all of the problems are social and political. What the people arguing with you are telling you is that if you ignore the social and political problems, you're going to continue to create exactly the same kinds of problems that have been caused by every other attempt to solve social and political problems with technology. When you can figure out why people in the richest country on earth lack access to health care and food, neither of which are currently limited by actual abundance or availability, we can start talking about whatever other material things you think we need to live in paradise.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:21PM (#48788652)
> None of the problems with building a utopia are technological

Of course they are. Pre-Green revolution humanity probably couldn’t make a utopia. Currently, I’d argue we need way more energy to make utopia-like conditions available to all.

Technology isn’t sufficient. But I wouldn’t go so far as to say it’s unnecessary, unless one’s utopia permits dying horribly of infection due to minor cuts and abrasions.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by roughly on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:36PM (#48788817)
> Pre-Green revolution humanity probably couldn’t make a utopia.

Post-Green revolution humanity hasn’t pulled it off either.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:34PM (#48789316)
Not entirely, but we have entirely eliminated at least one disease that was once so common there was a specific goddess to whom you prayed if you wanted to be cured of it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shitala
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by robocat on Saturday July 04, 2026 @06:47PM (#48789788)
We've also done pretty well at reducing deficiency diseases. How common in wealthy countries is it to know someone with scurvy, pellagra, rickets, goitre, or beriberi. Common words from the past.

First world problems (many of which were previously uncommon) are quite different.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by roughly on Saturday July 04, 2026 @06:23PM (#48789618)
What is your story for how smallpox was eliminated?
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @06:35PM (#48789709)
How, or when?

How is a lot of things, including the rich paying for it to be eliminated even in the poor nations who had no strong government to do this themselves.

When is where: https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/many-people-alive-t...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by roughly on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:28PM (#48789994)
Yeah, to shortcut the debate here, I think the crux of the argument is that, starting in the 80s, the capital & tech sets both started pointing to things like the smallpox vaccine and the green revolution and saying "See? This is why you need to get out of our way and just let us do our thing," whereas the rest of the world has been saying "the only reason any of that worked is because we built the social and political systems during the 50s, 60s, and 70s to get those solutions into the hands of the people." The argument to ignore the social, economic, and political effects of technology because eventually it makes the world better ignores the process by which it eventually makes the world better, and also ignores that it does not de-facto make the world better without those social and political processes. Technology should be encouraged, and also when you look around and see people starving or dying from preventable diseases while billionaires shoot people into space for the hell of it, the balance is off.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:30AM (#48791759)
Agreed, that argument seems sound.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:14PM (#48789160)
It's a lot better than it was for the average human on earth than it was a couple centuries ago. Utopia can't happen overnight.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by expedition32 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @06:43AM (#48793024)
Infamously the 19th century saw declining living conditions in my country despite the technological and scientific progress.

It is socialism that gets us to utopia not the technology.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:56AM (#48795234)
It needs both together; the 20th century had a variety of attempts at (and degrees of) socialism, and the ones which politicised the science and technology didn't work out too well either.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by throwaway-11-1 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:04PM (#48788476)
“We” can’t even effectively distribute food, healthcare and housing yet but yeah I’m sure capital will totally figure it out if we build enough machines that just accumulate more wealth to the richest people in history. I love cool new tech but I’m perfectly aware it will not do shit to solve any problem other than “eliminate or make labor cheaper”
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:12PM (#48788557)
I mean, there are less starving people than there were in most of the world. We've made progress. In my lifetime we've made progress! I mean, there are momentary set backs and they are egregious, I agree with that for sure, but the world is wildly better than it was in the early 90s or early 00s.

I was there (cue Elrond meme), I remember.

And god forbid you were gay back then, or had an ailment that needed some high tech treatment, or needed to talk to someone on the other side of the planet for any reason, or wanted to have access to knoeledge.

We've come so far, and the people yapping about how "everything is the worst" are reactionary. Yes there are problems, I don't want to downplay them. But largely, until very recently, things were getting better en masse and zoomed out enough in time that trend will likely continue if we don't blow it all up or do something stupid like decide that science is too scary to do.

What I mostly see in these threads is "Capitalist Realism" - people can't even imagine things turning out some way other than "capital controls everything forever."

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by throwaway-11-1 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:32PM (#48789297)
Your response is not addressing my claims, homelessness is increasing, life expectancy is lagging poorer countries and there are still food security issues not being addressed in the richest country in history. I’m discussing material outcomes and you want to focus on social progress….which is fine I guess? Anyway I have receipts

https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/u-s-lif...

https://www.unc.edu/discover/u-s-life-expectancy-drop-caused...

https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/fo...

https://www.security.org/resources/homeless-statistics/

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:39PM (#48789354)
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by throwaway-11-1 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:35AM (#48791495)
Yeah that’s totally fair and really good to see. It’s maybe the one perspective that gives me some hope
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by omicronxt on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:20AM (#48793667)
Our world in data is neoliberal think tank supported by billionares. They got bad reputation of misrepresenting data to favor capitalism as inherently progressive.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by bit-anarchist on Tuesday July 07, 2026 @06:27PM (#48824867)
> Our world in data is neoliberal think tank

How so?

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piperswe on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:08PM (#48787982)
If politics were trending left I’d agree with you, but as-is the bourgeoisie are the only ones that will get any upside from modern tech.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by matthewdgreen on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:21PM (#48788111)
Even Star Trek admits that there are horrible events that lie between our world and the utopia.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:06PM (#48788493)
then perhaps we should strive not to have those horrible events, not by having nostalgia but by dreaming of a better future.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tadfisher on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:27PM (#48788158)
In Star Trek canon, humanity figured out how to live in utopia by destroying all existing power structures in a Third World War.

What is happening now is we have all our existing structure, and the existing requirement to earn money to live within this structure, and the human creative output we want in our eventual utopia is used to train automata with the express goal to replace humans in those creative endeavors, removing the ability for humans to earn money by being creative themselves.

It is not hard to see things from this perspective when a significant portion of writing is becoming obvious slop, and your liberal friends are having a hard time getting hired or landing writing deals or selling artwork. I would feel less important too; I'm already feeling this way when I review a PR with obvious LLM-generated descriptions and comments that reference the prompt.

Ideally, feeling important wouldn't be pejorative. Ideally, we'd have a way for artists to have food and shelter and continue to produce art. The hopes that AI will cause this to happen are equivalent to hoping WWIII will come along and wipe out 2/3 of humanity so we can start over with United Earth and warp drives and replicators.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:22PM (#48788668)
> In Star Trek canon, humanity figured out how to live in utopia by destroying all existing power structures in a Third World War.

Perhaps we could try to destroy those power structures without having a giant war lol, just saying.

> What is happening now is we have all our existing structure, and the existing requirement to earn money to live within this structure, and the human creative output we want in our eventual utopia is used to train automata with the express goal to replace humans in those creative endeavors, removing the ability for humans to earn money by being creative themselves.

Right, I get the frustration, but how many "creators" were doing truly creative and expressive work writing ad copy or making up logos for shoe companies or whatever. The problem people have is capitalism, not the robots and it's short sighted of people to be angry at software tools rather than the system that has forced them to trade their time and skills for the right to exist.

I've literally lost my career before. The one thing that getting deathly ill has taught me is that "all things will come to an end." Someday, that will include me, but hopefully not today, and thanks to modern medicine, hopefully not any time soon. The idea that the only way an artist should be able to justify their right to survive is by shitting out jpgs on fiverr or whatever is as absurd as the idea that that was somehow meaningful work. If you're having a hard time getting hired, pivot. Adapt. Overcome. That's been my life for the last decade since I first got sick - and I'm not saying it's great, but you have to be able to adapt to new istuations. The world ain't going back. Do we become the Luddites and lose in the long run? Or do we "seize the means of computation and build something that strives for utopia?"

> Ideally, feeling important wouldn't be pejorative. Ideally, we'd have a way for artists to have food and shelter and continue to produce art.

I think food and shelter should be available for anyone on earth without any sort of need to justify it. But I do think that feeling really important should be a bit pejorative.

> The hopes that AI will cause this to happen are equivalent to hoping WWIII will come along and wipe out 2/3 of humanity so we can start over with United Earth and warp drives and replicators.

That's a false equivalency. Like, not even on the same planet.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by a34729t on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:30PM (#48788752)
> Right, I get the frustration, but how many "creators" were doing truly creative and expressive work writing ad copy or making up logos for shoe companies or whatever.

Exactly. The "creative" wankery is just people who got college degrees but don't want to work in offices and/or do things with numbers.

Sorry, jobs that are fun and desireable aren't in big supply. Do something difficult, boring, disgusting, unsexy and perhaps dangerous and you are set.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:41PM (#48788883)
The term "elite overproduction" comes to mind.

I had a career in something I loved that was "fun" and even desirable. It was great. I got sick and couldn't do it anymore. I have (begrudgingly, and at times angrily) moved on. I pivoted. I adapted. I did what I had to do to survive and moved forward. I'm not saying I want other people to have to experience that, but I'd say it's given me a sense of clarity about the world that I otherwise wouldn't have.

If you cannot be flexible and adjust under pressure you're going to have a bad time. I think that a lot of people are unwilling to accept change and move forward.

Like, you can also choose to enjoy other things. You can choose to do things that are meaningful that other people don't want to do. Or just... you know, do your own thing. Figure it out. Adapt and do something different. Keep throwing shit against the wall until some of it sticks!

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by zzrrt on Sunday July 05, 2026 @03:17AM (#48791974)
> Perhaps we could try to destroy those power structures without having a giant war

The power structure is what is putting out the satellites and datacenters that you hope will bring the Star Trek utopia. Not sure you can both destroy it and reap its fruit, or that the fruit is not poisoned by the immorality and antisociality of the current power structure anyway.

Also, in Starlink's case, if utopic United Earth becomes real, it will probably be cheaper to lay fiber and cell towers, so it's maybe just a bootstrap and not a final end state.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by well_ackshually on Sunday July 05, 2026 @05:23AM (#48792611)
>Perhaps we could try to destroy those power structures without having a giant war lol, just saying.

Does not, will not and cannot happen. Power structures are made to keep themselves alive at any cost necessary. There will be a bloodbath one way or another, and these structures will either disappear, or march ever forward towards enslaving you.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tsunagatta on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:08PM (#48787984)
AI is not going to give us a star trek utopia, AI is an attempt by the bourgeoise to alienate the average person from the capital that has previously always come free with their human life. AI promises a feudalist future where there is no capital that isn't owned by the ruling class. Its power is not democratized, it is concentrated in the hands of those building the data centers. That is why I'm against the data centers. I feel like all leftists should be.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788351)
> AI promises a feudalist future where there is no capital that isn't owned by the ruling class.

We may get that, but only if the ruling class want what the Victorians called a "folly": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folly

AI is wildly, wildly divergent in the possible futures it brings. It's really important to influence what happens, but don't limit the potential downside to only as bad as feudalism (neither neo-feudalist nor re-enacted): much worse monsters exist than the typical feudal lord.

(Was going to say "among those rulers who needed us alive to fight their wars and grow their food", but then I remembered Cambodia and Pol Pot).

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:11PM (#48788020)
> Its power is not democratized, it is concentrated in the hands of those building the data centers. That is why I'm against the data centers

If you really believe this (and I’m not saying I don’t, I just don’t have confidence in it), blocking domestic. datacenters doesn’t preserve that labour value. It just ensures whoever builds those datacenters controls production from afar.

Like, if AI really replaces human labour, does Africa and Europe having few AI datacenters protect it from America and China? Of course not. Not outside a symbolic level that even then would have to exist with the implied consent of the powers who produce.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tadfisher on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:29PM (#48788183)
Sorry, do Memphis residents get to control xAI's production? I think we're already in this situation.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:33PM (#48788216)
> we're already in this situation

xAI’s datacenters aren’t currently measurably replacing labour. So no, we’re not. If AI becomes economically competitive with broad sections of human labor, those who control it do have the power to replace humans.

But banning domestic datacenters doesn’t stop them from existing; it just stops them from existing here. If that precondition arises, that’s just a recipe for domestic deindustrialisation.

If you believe AI will replace human labor, blocking datacenters is silly. You want labor (or the public) to build and control them. I’m not convinced AI will replace labor, so I’m not yet at that step.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by fc417fc802 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:36PM (#48788818)
I think the point being made regarding xAI was that even if the datacenter is local that doesn't necessarily result in any meaningful difference. In other words, having more AI datacenters under your jurisdiction might or might not provide a meaningful ability to regulate in a way that shapes the impact of AI on the economy. (I do agree with you that it's almost certainly a good idea to have them though.)
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:40PM (#48788867)
> the point being made regarding xAI was that even if the datacenter is local that doesn't necessarily result in any meaningful difference

Oh, absolutely agree. But the datacentre in Memphis is within its jurisdiction. If Nashville decides to stick it with a tax to fund a UBI, they can. Sacramento and Columbus don't have that option.

To be clear, I am not arguing for more datacenters being built the way they are being built. But if you believe AI will replace labour, you want to control those datacenters. Blocking them explicitly cedes that control.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:07PM (#48788506)
Fleet Street in London used to print all the UK newspapers. They had unions who resisted automation.

In the 80s, Rupert Murdoch built, in secret, a new fully computerised printing plant built in Wapping.

The workers went on strike, so he fired them. Didn't even lose a single day of output*:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wapping_dispute

That is what you should fear from AI. Not the data centres themselves, that we could all be fired and the rich lose nothing as a result.

* [citation needed] :P

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:12PM (#48788562)
> That is what you should fear from AI. Not the data centres themselves, that we could all be fired and the rich lose nothing as a result

Sure. But what would have been better for the Fleet Street workers. The UK banning computerised printing? Or the union owning one?

If AI is going to be to jobs in general as computerised printing was to newspaper printing, just blocking it doesn't make sense. That's my argument.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:17PM (#48788616)
I think you may have misunderstood, I'm agreeing with you :)

> Sure. But what would have been better for the Fleet Street workers. The UK banning computerised printing? Or the union owning one?

Oh, definitely the latter.

The only way I see e.g. UBI working long-term is democratic* governments owning the means of production, and in the case of AI futures that means owning the compute, and the power supply for the compute.

Right now, the UK power supply is… privatised.

* small-d, not The Dems, I'm not an American

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:27PM (#48788712)
This is totally the "near term" solution.

Like, worker ownership of the means of production and the assets in general is idea. But I'm speaking as an Alaskan who is quite fond of the PFD and think it doesn't go far enough.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by afpx on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:27PM (#48788163)
In 1990 I hoped my grandkids would be able to join starfleet. After watching most of the gains go to the worst, I just hope they can escape the borg.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:42PM (#48788299)
I was a kid in the 90s. Kinda surprised we got the (almost) universal translator before we got fusion.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:20PM (#48789955)
This does happen quite often actually - the logical progression from telegraph to digital Internet networks was interrupted by the invention and deployment of the analog telephone network.

IMHO even analog television and microwave oven look kinda out of place with the technology deployed at the same time.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by antonvs on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:52AM (#48793915)
You know what else we’re going to get before fusion? Everything. Commercially viable fusion energy is still a fantasy, essentially. Anyone who claims it’s only X years away is implicitly assuming that somehow, in those X years, we’ll find solutions to several fundamental problems that may not in fact have viable solutions.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:16PM (#48789936)
Imperial Guard will welcome them with an open embrace once they reach conscription age! ;-)
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:37PM (#48788258)
Mm. I know a (US) Green party campaigner who is a self-described communist (I forget which variety), who has yet to realise the contradiction between her love of trade unions and support of the environment when it presents itself in support of the famous UK coal miner's strikes.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by hack1312 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @11:00PM (#48790924)
There isn’t a contradiction supporting working class coal miners when there’s no plan to transform their labor into green energy.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by AngryData on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:00PM (#48787909)
The problem is people don't see the near future as a Star Trek utopia, they see it going more towards a dystopian landscape with handfuls of extremely wealthy elite dictating how they can live their life.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by brandensilva on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:27PM (#48788170)
It's easy to see why people fear AI when our leaders talk of a future where many are jobless and replaced with no solutions to fill in the gaps.

AI adoption is a leadership failure more than a tech one right now. If you make people feel empowered with it, it can liberate work-free lives that humanity benefits from. If you use it to destroy people's livelihoods with no options it's not going to survive a revolution.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by CookieCrisp on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:11PM (#48788018)
Which would make sense if they chose strategies that might stop that from happening. Instead the ones I know refuse to even learn what AI can do and refuse to see that they're not going to slow it's adoption down by sealing themselves off.

The world was already heading towards a dystopian landscape without AI. So many people on this planet live in a horrific dystopia right now, and here comes along something that might help them. Might give us what we need to stop global warming. I'd rather choose something with a 1% chance of working out than what we had before, 0%.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by AngryData on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:27PM (#48788162)
But our top 2 problems are political shenanigans and energy production. And neither are going to be solved by AI, both are made worse with AI.

AI is a useful tool, but tools aren't always used to improve lives.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by SidewaysView on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:45PM (#48788321)
God you techbro dorks are so fucking annoying.

Kill. All. Trekkies. Now!

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by phikappa on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:59PM (#48788446)
I think we'd be better off limiting whom to kill to one person only.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:07PM (#48788505)
Why exactly are you here?
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by SidewaysView on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:26PM (#48788701)
I would think "dealing with neckbeard nerds who don't know when to sit down" was obvious. Your arrogance is astonishing and intolerable.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:00PM (#48789059)
Mine is? You don't even know me lol. But you know, good for you.

Neck beard, well maybe, I am taking the day off and I haven't shaved, though, I rarely shave anyway.

But if you think I developed these views of the world because of a lack of experience in it, you'd be wrong. I've seen life and death and many many things in between. I've written poetry and cried at sunsets. I've seen good men die and bad men win. I've seen justice too. And injustice. I've lived and struggled and fought and made art and raised a family and written code and built things and suffered and read literature in other tongues and loved and laughed and protested and been tear gassed and done things I regret and done things I've been proud of. I've seen the northern lights from the arctic in winter. I've seen salmon streams so think it looked as if you could cross them on foot. I know words in dying languages and worked to preserve them. You know nothing of me.

You think you can understand me because I yearn for a world that's not based on the transactional need to produce economically useful output. You think you can understand the totality of me because I'd like us to strive for an utopic vision of the world. You think you know me because a science fiction show gives me some hope for us building a better world? You know nothing of me.

But seriously, like, what is your optimal view of the world? What would you have if you were allowed to set policy or chart the course of human events or some other such thing?

Personally, I want to see everyone fed, sheltered, and comfortably able to spend their days doing what they want and not having to churn out crap to justify their right to survive. If you disagree with that, then that's your right, but I would be surprised if you disagreed with that.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by SidewaysView on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:12PM (#48789138)
I understand you because I can read your posts.

(God, the fedora.)

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:16PM (#48789177)
Ok, go ahead and troll away elsewhere, I am hip to your game. Have a nice day and I sincerely hope that you are happier in the future than you are now.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by SidewaysView on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:32PM (#48789300)
(Seriously, can someone please explain how you write this paean to creepy uncle sci-fi without realizing how it sounds? Anyone?)
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by piloto_ciego on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:51PM (#48789430)
Genuinely, have a happy life.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tomhow on Saturday July 04, 2026 @06:25PM (#48789636)
We've banned this account.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by jdub on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:17AM (#48791694)
You reckon large language models run by this mob of billionaire boot-licking dweebs will lead to a Star Trek style utopia? Come on.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by matthewdgreen on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:17PM (#48788079)
I didn't understand what these satellites were really like until I visited Zion National Park two weeks ago. Zion is an International Dark Sky park, and so I was really looking forward to seeing the stars. Instead we sat outside and watched dozens and dozens of fast-moving stars zip around on all sorts of trajectories. I'm not saying it ruined the experience (I'm not an astronomer, and it was kind of fun.) But it really brought home how fundamentally we've changed the sky. I also hope we're able to lay enough fiber in developing countries that this many satellites don't need to stay up there forever.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by qntmfred on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:37PM (#48788260)
for reference https://x.com/Jeremyrand101/status/1981564984154005876

I frequently hang out in my driveway in the early evenings shooting basketball and listening to podcasts. I'll see easily several dozen satellites over the course of the hour or two that I typically stay out there. and I don't even live out in the country or anything. I think mostly people are just not aware (yet?) of how rapidly the number of satellites have grown in the last couple years.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by phainopepla2 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:25PM (#48788142)
I had the same experience visit Mojave National Preserve. It was very distracting while trying to stargaze. I had to stay up late to see the night sky I remember
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by pfisch on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:31PM (#48788204)
How can anyone see what is happening in Ukraine and not realize the future is not just 1 starlink, but also a Chinese one and a Europe at a minimum. Probably many other countries will make sure to have at least a regional one as well though.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:50PM (#48788364)
I could absolutely see Europe Greenpeace-nuking its way out of having a LEO constellation while everyone else builds them.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by verdverm on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:23PM (#48788129)
What time were you there? My understanding is that around dawn/dusk, the angles cause reflection, but for most of the time they are not visible.

Also, what about planes? Those also cause similar light streaks. Another understanding I currently hold is that there is already a method for removing these artifacts

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by reaperducer on Saturday July 04, 2026 @11:34PM (#48791032)
Also, what about planes? Those also cause similar light streaks.

Watch a time-lapse animation of aircraft movement. They follow fairly precise paths, and the number of them diminishes significantly at night.

In places like the ones listed above, they are uncommon at night. I've been to both. You might see one once an hour, if that.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by gordonhart on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:36PM (#48787666)
In related news, earlier this year Chile cancelled plans for a gigawatt-scale solar/wind powered hydrogen production plant nearby the ESO facility in the Atacama desert after light pollution complaints from European scientists.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by hombre_fatal on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:53PM (#48788387)
This is a good point.

A similar thread that links your examples together is how we all want to be the last person up the ladder. The last person to move into some neighborhood or into the last apartment complex. Or into a country. The last person to have internet access. Now we want to freeze how it is. Everyone after us threatens our experience.

An American with access to good internet for decades is annoyed that their stargazing session isn't what it used to be now that the city is growing and creating more light or that other people are getting to tech up.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by isatty on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:35PM (#48787653)
Well, if you build too many satellites in the swarms, at some point you will lose the ability to see or go to the stars.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:25PM (#48789987)
Unless you literally make Earth be indoors like in the Blame manga megastructure, any realistic satellite or debris swarm will either be in low orbit and will relatively soon burn up or in high orbit & spread over such a big area that with well planned trajectory it will not cause you any further issues.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by pshirshov on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:03PM (#48787933)
> we will build Sun orbital structures and swarms,

Another episode of arrogant fantasy in the ponyworld.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by SidewaysView on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:39PM (#48789350)
Hear, hear! Promote this man!

Shut these ridiculous baboons out of society. Take their TESCREAL libertarian nonsense with them.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JBorrow on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:11PM (#48788010)
Moving all of astronomy to space based observations is entirely incompatible with the way that instruments are funded, built, and deployed. It is only valid for a set of highly specific and well funded observatories that take decades to get off the ground and can never be updated, improved, or modified to search new scientific directions.

Why don’t “we” just build more cell towers?

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:40PM (#48788273)
> Why don’t “we” just build more cell towers?

Why is littering our landscape with cell towers and power and fiber lines inherently better than putting this stuff in space?

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by stouset on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788355)
Google “Kessler syndrome”.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:52PM (#48788386)
I am aware of no orbital solutions for a catastrophic Kessler cascade in LEO. The only place you could engineer one is in GEO, because that’s a singular orbit, not a plane much less a volume.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by stouset on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:20PM (#48788647)
First, you never specified LEO, only “space”.

Second, the situation is already so bad that current satellites in LEO already require active collision avoidance systems in order to avoid becoming sources of debris themselves. Starlink alone reports over 1,600 close encounters each week.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:22PM (#48788670)
> you never specified LEO, only “space”

What I said applies to space, too, outside GEO, for the number of satellites anyone is currently talking about launching.

> the situation is already so bad that current satellites in LEO already require active collision avoidance systems in order to avoid becoming sources of debris themselves

They require collision avoidance to avoid being lost. There is no risk of a Kessler cascade in LEO right now and nobody who can do orbital mechanics is claiming as much.

We’d need millions more satellites than we have right now to start approaching the point where atmospheric clearance falls below the rate of new-debris production. And even then, you’re talking about a problem in specific orbits for months, maybe years. In the meantime, you get to allow nature to reclaim huge amounts of land from cell towers and conduit.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by happytoexplain on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:06PM (#48787966)
This is unrealistic, uncharitable, and tribalistic.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by snovv_crash on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:37PM (#48787675)
Maybe a fair allocation of sattelites would be proportional to the number of citizens with voting rights in the country. Maybe with some modifier about how impactful that voting can actually be (eg. citizen initiatives vs. just electing representatives from a preselected pool).
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:55PM (#48787859)
> a fair allocation

Who is doing this allocation? Who is going to tell Pyongyang, Beijing or Moscow they can’t launch anymore?

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by guelo on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:09PM (#48787992)
If we weren't busy stupidly destroying the institutions for international cooperation, it would be a UN body.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:12PM (#48788035)
> it would be a UN body

No UN body can command a nuclear sovereign. They ultimately continually consent to oversight.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by vova_hn2 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:27PM (#48788172)
> No UN body can command a nuclear sovereign.

Why not, though? If any country violates their limit, just issue a concern. If they ignore it, upgrade it to a grave concern. Then they will surely have to obey, I mean, it's grave concern we're talking about, what else they could do?

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tick_tock_tick on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:05AM (#48791390)
lol and who's going to enforce it? The only things enforced are when USA/Russia/China care about it.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JuniperMesos on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:42PM (#48787730)
As a California resident I really don't like the idea of a legal framework that encourages more citizen initiatives. They would be used to try to prevent building more housing.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by snovv_crash on Sunday July 05, 2026 @03:51AM (#48792148)
Citizen initiatives are the only thing that can cut across partisan lines and stop politics from turning into tribal warfare.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:35AM (#48793336)
Maybe fix the system so there are not just two parties & bad parties fail to be voted in?
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by snovv_crash on Tuesday July 07, 2026 @01:27PM (#48820900)
Then you need combinatorial parties to support every possible political combination. Rather just have people vote on the policies themselves.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by rockemsockem on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:40PM (#48787695)
Starlink satellites can provide anyone with Internet.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Normal_gaussian on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:41PM (#48787717)
Can, but won't.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by kibwen on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:10PM (#48788003)
> These kinds of caps have for years been a dampener on human flourishing. My observation has been that those in stagnation or decline tend to attach themselves to these desires to hold the status quo. Anti-energy, anti-housing, anti-industry and so on because they've reached a local maxima in their ability to live and have chosen to spend their life in leisure.

This kind of attitude has for millenia been a dampener on human flourishing. My observation has been that those without empathy or foresight tend to attach themselves to these initiatives to obliterate our shared human heritage to satisfy their own ridiculous misconception of progress. Anti-intellectual, anti-curious, anti-social and so on because they've reached a local maxima in their ability to give a damn about what it means to live a good life and have chosen to spend their life in self-satisfied ignorance.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by umpalumpaaa on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:37PM (#48787671)
And swarms
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by toasty228 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:50PM (#48787805)
> But there is the rest of the world, and if I'm told that the Africans

When the average African live like the average American we'll be truly fucked, probably even before that. We should raise the bottom for sure but we definitely need to cure the degeneracy of the top too

Technosolutionism is a cult. We either put the caps on ourself or nature will hard cap us anyways, in a much harsher way.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tekne on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:14PM (#48789155)
I'll wear the dunce hat if I have to, but I don't want to be an animal. I am one, now, but I don't have to be one. I refuse to be limited by what is "naturally" possible -- my nature is to be a being with a mind, and so the only limit I must respect is the raw laws of physics, whatever they are.

And physics lets me get a lot further than "8 billion Americans."

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Peanuts99 on Sunday July 05, 2026 @05:24AM (#48792613)
But that's just what OP is saying, you can 'refuse' to be limited to nature, but nature will have other plans for you.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by tekne on Sunday July 05, 2026 @02:38PM (#48796721)
I suppose there's nature -- i.e. physics -- and Nature, i.e. the false god of the status quo. These are not, in fact, the same thing.

Small-n nature says (as best as I can tell) that I must obey conservation of mass and can't go faster than light -- and hence that I probably cannot, in fact, sustain a population of a 100 billion on Earth alone without significantly cutting down individual resource access.

Until very recently big-N Nature said we'd never have heavier-than-air-flight, an automatic translation program (see: plot point in A Fire upon the Deep), or, before the Green Revolution, a population above a few billion -- but just as there's no fundamental physical law forbidding these things (and hence they came to pass) so there really is no fundamental physical law stopping all of current humanity from living a decent life (happy to be proved otherwise).

It may be impossible with current technology, sure, but there's no new physics required to make it possible -- the physics we have now permit it, with sufficient technology.

In fact -- interestingly enough -- before nuclear energy you'd have a far stronger point (though solar energy now means even without nuclear we can probably scrape by enough energy -- but coal does in fact have a Malthusian problem)

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by api on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:17PM (#48788081)
“Anti” is a kind of super-meme that took over discourse in a lot of spheres, especially anywhere near academia, starting in the 1970s.

If I had to trace it to one source it would probably be the Club of Rome and Limits to Growth. Paul Erlich would be a close second with The Population Bomb.

Here’s a great podcast on the latter:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nn1gieFMuWI

This stuff sounds right because obviously you can’t have infinite growth in population or resource use on a finite planet. That means it won’t happen. The question is “how will it not happen?” The answer right now looks like “as people get wealthier they have fewer kids.” There are other possible answers like dematerialization of the economy which is also a thing.

Before the 70s this stuff would have been called far right and identified with ideologies like authoritarian eugenics and fascism. The 70s is when a lot of “volkisch” proto-fascist and crypto-fascist ideas got a lefty hippie makeover. The other big one is the idea that “natural” is inherently good.

I finally see this stuff getting some challenge from all across the political spectrum, even from the left. In previous decades you only ever saw it get challenged from the right or from what were once called libertarians.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by bluegatty on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:30PM (#48788746)
Rubbish. Its 99% of the time people trying to make money and that's it.

As though Africans aren't interested in the stars, or climate change, or that they can't figure out fibre optics is borderline racist.

Europe - and soon the rest of us - are facing massive heat waves that are likely driven by climate change, it's a real problem.

That's 'actual science'.

By all means, build what you like, but you don't get to dump your externalizations on everyone else. There is no 'We' in your projects, you don't speak for us.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by browningstreet on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:36PM (#48788813)
The "let builders and capitalists do anything because the future will be better for it" isn't a technically considered position. It's a tautology.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by reaperducer on Saturday July 04, 2026 @11:26PM (#48791010)
These kinds of caps have for years been a dampener on human flourishing.

I am a human being. I flourish when I can see the planets and stars.

The utopia you describe sounds more like technological fetishism that benefits a select few, not the entirety of humanity.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by garbagewoman on Saturday July 04, 2026 @11:39PM (#48791061)
Can you expand more on your plans to give Africans more access to high speed internet?