News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Normal_gaussian on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:41PM (#48787707)
I think that "Africans should not have access to high-speed satellite Internet" is something you've just made up; the article you link talks about African people turning to Starlink because of local infrastructure issues, and the original article notes that the current satellite count is currently around 14k satellites. 100k is more than enough satellites to provide high-speed satellite internet globally.

The article makes mention of specific endeavours, like the night-time mirror satellites, which are particularly disruptive to astronomy, and the general risks of high numbers of satellites.

The ability to do Earth based astronomy is something that is of value to all the peoples of Earth, and is mainly funded by the western nations because of their current position as the people with more money.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:49PM (#48787794)
The article doesn’t consider that in a world with a million satellites in orbit, launching space-based telescopes—including into deep space—becomes an order of magnitude cheaper.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by acdha on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:51PM (#48787814)
Does it? My understanding was that it’s less helpful for anything which isn’t in low-earth orbit because the commercial launch engineers are optimizing for the lucrative satellite business, not larger and higher payloads.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:54PM (#48787841)
> commercial launch engineers are optimizing for the lucrative satellite business, not larger and higher payloads

Commercial satellites are getting bigger and heavier. Launch that can put big and heavy in LEO can put big and slightly less heavy higher up. Add to that things like in-orbit propellant transfer and there is a good chance astronomy sees a golden age in the coming decades (in countries with space access).

I’m not dismissing the problem. Just this analysis as meriting any conclusions. It’s a start. But it’s only part of a full model of how these changes would affect astronomy.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Teever on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:21PM (#48788116)
I get where you're coming from but we haven't really seen any sort of space based telescope designs that take advantage of the Falcon launch paradigm of cheap and reliable launches.

Some sort of modular telescope array that could be launched in pieces and self-assemble in orbit. Something that improves in capacity as more pieces are added.

Everything seems to have stalled in this field, as if it's just waiting for a Starship which may never come.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:25PM (#48788145)
> we haven't really seen any sort of space based telescope designs

We’re only starting to truly mass manufacture satellites. A world with millions of satellites means one with lots of satellite production and design economies of scale. (Same for all manner of sensors and optics.)

> as if it's just waiting for a Starship which may never come

Or it may. We’ll know in a couple years. Building a scaling production system for Falcon right now would be silly.

And if Starship never works out, we probably don’t see millions of satellites. It’s a fundamentally tied problem, which is why I say the analysis is incomplete.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:02PM (#48789867)
There are hundreds of Dove Satellites with telescopes in the Flock constellations from Planet Lab: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Labs

Most of them launched on the Falcon 9. They just point down to the Earth by default. ;-)

And there are other cubesats testing stuff for x-ray astronomy or gamma ray burst detection, such as:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VZLUSAT-2

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by Tuna-Fish on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:01PM (#48787920)
Larger rockets are inherently more efficient, which is why all the commercial providers are moving towards them. And while yes, most of the providers are targeting primarily for LEO, if you have high payload capacity to LEO you can solve your issue of getting anywhere by packing in a kick stage. And cheap third-party kick stages are available and more are in development.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by onion2k on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:46PM (#48788331)
Google says that James Webb telescope cost a total of $10bn. That's not a lot of money in the grand scheme of things. Private citizens could afford to put similar things into space if they chose to. We don't need them to be cheaper.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788350)
> James Webb telescope cost a total of $10bn

I’d love to see an estimate of what a JWST-class telescope would cost to design, build and launch in a world maintaining a million-satellite fleet. My guess is less than $2bn.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by HPsquared on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:59PM (#48788447)
A big part of the complexity of JWST was the way everything had to fold and fit into a small launch vehicle. With larger vehicles (e.g. Starship) the JWST mirror could have been built in one piece, which is much simpler. The whole thing was engineered to the max to fit within tight constraints, which is very expensive.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:06PM (#48788494)
> With larger vehicles (e.g. Starship) the JWST mirror could have been built in one piece, which is much simpler

Not just the complexity of design, but also cost and complexity of cryo-vacuum testing hundreds of deployment mechanisms any one of whose failure critcially endangers the project. The mirror could also be conventionally manufactured versus requiring gold-plated beryllium [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_Telescope_Element

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by m4rtink on Saturday July 04, 2026 @07:07PM (#48789892)
Not to mention it would be much cheaper and quicker to launch if it could have any form of robotic or human servicing/tuning available.

Designing it to not fail at the start & then work without any help for decades must have also made it much more expensive.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:32PM (#48788206)
Currently writing a draft blog post on all the issues (and non-issues) with these things, it is now long enough (7k words) I'm slightly wondering if it's less "a blog post" and more "one section of a decent sized book on why we can't have nice things".

Here's a visual to consider the implications of things you can do with actually one million satellites of the kind of size scale being discussed:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenWheatley/blog/refs/head...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:35PM (#48788242)
> Yes, they really would be this closely spaced: Earth's circumference is 40 million meters

Satellites don’t orbit on the ground, which makes the 40m spacing nonsense. And nobody proposes putting a million 120 kW satellites in a single orbit.

They really would never be that closely spaced. To approach those densities in a single orbital shell you’d need hundreds of billions of birds in orbit. Spread across all of LEO (and only LEO) we’re talking orders of magnitudes more satellites (like, quadrillions).

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by HPsquared on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:07PM (#48788510)
Can all orbits be completely filled at once, though? They'll intersect at some point (I had originally said poles but that's only polar orbits..) ... I suppose you have phase, altitude and inclination (and eccentricity which adds another couple of variables). But they do intersect, don't they?
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:17PM (#48788617)
> Can all orbits be completely filled at once, though? They’ll intersect

Correct. I wasn’t proposing a realistic configuration. Just showing why OP’s visual doesn’t work for the numbers it gives. (It 1D space fills. I expand that to 2 and 3D.)

Millions of satellites is currently accepted as the maximum carrying capacity of LEO before collisions becomes a PITA.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:29PM (#48789272)
Can't take advantage of the 3D-ness when you want them all to be in terminator-following SSOs. Best you get is 2D, and with current safety margins, even that fills up fast.

However, this was not the point of the illustration, which is more "if you can do this at all, you can do better".

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ben_w on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:42PM (#48788892)
> Satellites don’t orbit on the ground, which makes the 40m spacing nonsense.

Hence why the horizontal scale bar says "40 m to 43 m": Going to 500 km doesn't add much to the orbit's circumference.

> And nobody proposes putting a million 120 kW satellites in a single orbit.

One of my tentative conclusions is that it would be an improvement if they did. But also, there's better contiguous structures to build if you could put that much up.

It's in my blog post because I'm considering all possible arrangements of ways to do this. Current list:

  • Spread them out by altitude while still keeping them in sun-synchronous low earth orbit like SpaceX plan
  • Put them all of them in a single sun-synchronous low earth orbit so none of them can hit each other
  • Spread them out like Starlink currently is
  • Have swarms, where each group has many satellites significantly closer to each other than the usual safety separation, like Google's Project Suncatcher
  • Have fewer, bigger satellites, like Starcloud
> To approach those densities in a single orbital shell you’d need hundreds of billions of birds in orbit. Spread across all of LEO (and only LEO) we’re talking orders of magnitudes more satellites (like, quadrillions).

Matters less than I expected when I started writing. How much so depends on what I end up adding by treating gaps in "full" (up to the safety margin) orbits as the thing of interest and seeing if someone's done a version of this on spherical geometry and also add a time component: https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/270937/how-can-you-...

(That I'm researching such questions should explain both why I'm at 7k words and why I've not published it yet).

(One big surprise to me while researching this: along-track, cross-track, and radial positional error per unit time are all much higher than I would have guessed: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/smallsat/2015/all2015/58/).

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by rcxdude on Saturday July 04, 2026 @02:49PM (#48787797)
Not to mention starlink is not a solution for internet for everyone on the planet: it cannot serve everyone in a densely populated area, no matter how many satellites they have in their constellation. It's a useful piece of infrastructure, but it's far from the panacea people seem to think it is.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by fc417fc802 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:30PM (#48788189)
> it cannot serve everyone in a densely populated area,

I also suspect that to be the case but in order to be more objective I wonder. What's the theoretical maximum bandwidth per square meter (or other unit area) that it can deliver?

[dead]
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by fc417fc802 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @05:01PM (#48789065)
> suppose one Starlink beam covers about 63 square miles

Is that the actual figure though?

> even a 100x improvement only gets you to about 300 kbps/person.

TBF even that would be quite useful for lots of things seeing as it's faster than the DSL service I once had. However agreed that it isn't going to replace fiber service and overbuilding to such an extent for outliers would be absurd.

Still, that's quite decent considering it's an estimate of a near worst case scenario.

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by IncreasePosts on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:13PM (#48788045)
Ground based infrastructure is much easier to justify in densely populated areas. So, dense areas get ground infra, and the dispersed rural population can get satellite infra
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ethin on Saturday July 04, 2026 @04:20PM (#48788651)
Starlink is already over-congested and physics says that it is not possible to scale it up to serve 100000000 subscribers let alone 5-6 billion or more. We would need some kind of physics breakthrough for that to scale properly, and I'm not even sure if physically it would even be possible to do that no matter what you threw at it. Starlink isn't magic as a lot of people seem to think it is.
Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by ck2 on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:21PM (#48788113)
note that including dead things in orbit

(that we currently have no way to remove)

is actually 32,000 not just 14,000

what we need is the investment for "space roombas" that go around bumping things out of orbit that are dead or did not de-orbit properly

the problem is all that atmospheric burnup creates a lot of toxic pollution

* https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-space-orbit-satellit...

Re:No more than 100 000 faint satellites should orbit Earth by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 04, 2026 @03:49PM (#48788360)
> we currently have no way to remove

Nature takes care of this for us in LEO. I’ve seen no serious plans to put millions of anything anywhere else.