We sure do need a reset.
The reset is prone to happen by other means.
…assuming the AI pace of progress slows down enough that there are still meaningful white collar jobs to have.
(also I suspect the anti-globalization discourse will get even more pointed)
Perhaps LLM's (or something better) will develop to be more efficient and quickly become something most people run on local hardware. Perhaps fad-obsessed management types will move onto the next big thing and AI will start being used more judiciously. Perhaps society will set sane regulatory limits that shape the direction AI is going in, from models that take jobs people want to models that, given the right hardware, can do the jobs few want.
Anthropic and OpenAI don't have to succeed for AI to succeed. If they turn out to be a bubble that bursts and torches a lot of investors, it might actually be a fundamentally good thing for everybody else.
If this current building spree ends in massive solar and other power generation being overbuilt and cutting energy costs, we've had a really good outcome.
If you look at SpaceX plans and ambitions, they hope to deploy massive compute to orbit (multiple Terrawatts, hundreds of thousands of sats). If their ambitions even slightly materialise it would make ground based compute pale in comparison.
Whether or not they succeed in their plans is beside the point - the point is they know that terrestrial electric infra can't sustain the growth they need
> Whether or not they succeed in their plans is beside the point
No, I think that does matter eventually? Maybe for the IPO value?
> In an interview, McCalip says his initial rough calculations a few years ago suggested that data centers in space would cost in the range of 7 to 10 times more, per gigawatt of capacity, than their terrestrial counterparts. “It just wasn’t practical,” he says. “Not even close.” But when Elon Musk began publicly backing the idea, McCalip revisited the numbers using publicly available information about Starlink’s and Tesla’s technologies and capabilities.
> The radiator surface area problem also scales uncomfortably. At 838 watts per square meter, rejecting 1 megawatt of waste heat requires roughly 1,200 square meters of radiator. Deploying that much surface area on a satellite is a structural engineering challenge that gets harder with every order of magnitude. The ISS solar arrays span about 2,500 square meters total.
So even a 2MW data centre in space requires a cooling array rivalling the international space station. Starcloud launched a single H100 in November and they were unable to run it 24/7 due to heat buildup.
Even with novel solutions to make heat transfer to the fins more efficient, like phase-change liquids, the limiting factor is that the vacuum of space is a tremendous insulator.
https://thecoolingreport.com/intel/starcloud-orbital-data-ce...
https://satnews.com/2026/03/17/the-physics-wall-orbiting-dat...
Nobody who suggests the idea has ever presented a model that is even remotely close to reality
I can't believe the people who actually listen to this guy can tie their own shoelaces. And somehow he became the richest person on earth. Humans are irredeemable.
Tbh I think it’s already happening in real terms, but the CPIs aren’t fully showing it yet.
Why though? This isn't a bank run situation. Sure, it's unwise to bet against "US President does something stupid", but the rationale is missing.
The oil situation remains very concerning, and you can't print oil.
There’s lots of precedent for this over the past decades, both in the U.S. and over the pond.
Unless you are not company and you don't have some "enterprise deal". And you need an enterprise deal, as 1) it guarantees that your (and your customers) data will not be sold to someone else 2) you are scared that your competitor will have such deal and become much more productive.
This is what we have now. What will be the future?
Well, soon, if you want something like financial advice or medical advice or job search/CV polishing you will be told, that your $20/$200 is not covering that, you need to purchase additional model to have that. Will you do that? It depends how much you are desperate to get medical advice or find a job.
Anthropic Mythos is an example. Soon, if you are programmer and you will ask AI Agent to spot a bugs, AI Agent will tell you that you need to buy extra model for this. Same with performance analysis, same with the design using tool X, Y or Z.
This is pretty scary, as it will put our well-being, productivity in the hands of few corps. It will be event worst that Google Search monopoly we used to have (until AI chats broke this, replacing Google Monopoly with a few other vendors monopoly).
Can this be prevented? Surely. Hopefully we will have capable open models and consumer-level hardware will catch up. But I think this is the place where governments should step in, invest into alternative models which will be at least comparable with flagships.
Chinese models shows that this is doable, DeepSeek is worst than Chat GPT/Claude/Gemini, but not that much and is clearly better than Grok (which is a huge disappointment for me). I guess India would join this game (especially with nationalist like Modi as the leader).
Europe could join this game, the problem is it kills its capabilities with high energy prices and inability to come out with some reasonable, well financed solution. So the only thing EU was able to come up with is some set of regulations that are blocking fast AI development in Europe...
There is French Mistral, but it is French, it is under-financed, it is only-French, as France would not like to lose control over it.
Germany have totally different strategy, they invest into manufacturing oriented AI, what makes a lot of sense, but does not help with the dangers we are facing.
The rest of the Europe is just too poor to spend billions on AI.
There is still time to buckle up for Europe, but given the course of events, stupidity of Brussels elites who does not see the storm coming I am not optimistic.
Quoting Modi is a joke which one cannot even remotely relate w.r.t to AI and don't even feel sorry for saying that since that man blabbers on every stage about non-sensical / non-existent stuff! Watching his videos is the best timepass one can have!
Having said that, the infra and mindset is definitely not there in India to even remotely to innovate or compete in AI race!
Academia is a huge BS where every other person is a backstabber!
A lot of talent is there for sure, but all wants to work for some company or another since there is absolutely zero support for entrepreneurs . No real innovation.
All copy cats as they have proven with mobile and robotics. Just copying or masking Chinese products with the local brand names and reselling. That's all they are good at and that's the irony.
So far, nothing has come from that country which is a real innovation or ground breaking. The day it happens probably one can consider that they are good.
But otherwise, they are good at selling / reselling and scamming the world and nothing else! They cannot produce anything or whatever they produce is taken control by a handful of big corporates from the western region. That's a narcistic corporate monopoly!
Extremely bad tax structure, endless corruption and useless and unqualified ministers occupying worst portfolios, people are really struggling to survive!
Where will they innovate or compete in the global AI race?
Everyone at every level just want to scam and make money to surive that's all!
Period.
Either that he's HN mods's favorites or we're experiencing a special case of xkcd 1053[0]: there are always ten thousand people haven't realized how wrong Ed Zitron is.
At this point I don't think even Ed himself believes what he writes. It's just fan service for subscribers. And that is totally reasonable if we view blogging as a business.
On Reddit, if 500 people like a submission and 500 people dislike it, then it'll end up with 0 points and fail to reach /r/all
But on HN, the same content will end up at 500 points since only the people who like it can affect its rank (unless it dies after getting mass flagged).
The end result is that HN's system favors "hot takes" while Reddit's system favors "preaching to the choir".
The two systems have their pros and cons, but personally I dislike being unable to downvote articles that are full of nonsense.
It's not common, but every so often one of these submissions will be flagged by the time I get around to clicking the notification.
What do you mean "clearly"? Do you know his engagement numbers? Or you just find the content engaging?
I don't wacth/read his content at all because I find AI-doomers really boring and tiresome.
80k * $7/month * 12 months/year = $6.7M/year
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/jan/19/ed-zitron...
from Zitron's own website [0]:
> I have 84,000 subscribers and a 55-60% open rate, as well as an 8-11% clickthrough rate.
if the 84k number was all paid subscribers, then the "55-60% open rate" would mean that ~40% of his paying audience doesn't bother to read the thing they're paying for, which does not add up.
also, that's in the "Can I Advertise On Your Newsletter?" section. if there were an even higher number of non-paying subscribers, he'd have an obvious incentive to mention that, because the total number of eyeballs is what a potential advertiser cares about.
— https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/ais-biggest-critic-has-lost...
If I start a climate crisis cult, doesn't mean my predictions are wrong
That said, I just wanted to point out the grift he is doing. He’s making money by telling some people what they want to hear.
If AI invents a cure for cancer, he will tell you it’s still useless because it didn’t invent immortality.
Here[0] is a fun selection of excerpts from his July 2024 post "How Does OpenAI Survive?"[1]
"I see no signs that the transformer-based architecture can do significantly more than it currently does."
[0]: https://xcancel.com/pathsnotchosen/status/206360940100129633...
I can’t believe it’s this profitable.
- tell lies to ones who want to hear lies -> riches
- tell truth to ones who want to hear truth -> modesty
- tell truth to ones who want to hear lies -> bankruptcy
p.s. read it on a blog name I dont remember :(
I agree with the general thesis that AI is a bubble and there's a lot of over/mal-investment, but that hasn't stopped me from riding the wave and making a considerable amount of money investing in AI-related stocks.
If I was more ambitious, I'd write a $70/year newsletter ranting about how AI is a massive bubble that could collapse at any moment to make money on both sides.
Personally, I see both parties making predictions.
Meanwhile, I still must labour. How many more yachts are needed before the earth becomes the utopia they keep selling everyone on? How many more communities must have their rights trampled against their expressed will?
Or do I need to scan my retinas and provide Alt-man a DNA sample for a handful of empty crypto currency first?
https://www.wheresyoured.at/subprimeai/
He is extremely vague in his predictions and timelines, and yet still manages to miss.
His predictions timing sucks but he’s right in pointing out the insane numbers involved.
I think AI is a wonderful tool but I also think that there are many wonderful tools that if we bet our entire economy on would result in a catastrophe.
> AI Cannot Afford To Slow Down — It Needs $3 Trillion Or More In Revenue By End Of 2030 To Sustain Its Existence
Is this true? With the total 2024 wages being 11.7 trillion USD [0], and nonfarm payrolls totaling 158,000 in the same year [1], it's an order of magnitude higher than my back of the napkin guesses I've made that AI needs to take or create 1/20 jobs minimum to break even.
[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BA06RC1A027NBEA [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PAYEMS