My theory is that people are fundamentally averse to the thought and effort it takes to write a good quality email. Then there’s probably some underlying belief that more volume shows more effort, which people will perceive positively. And finally, there's the worry that if you write the email yourself, you might make some embarrassing wording, grammar, or spelling mistake.
Don't send me your compiled code, send me your prompt. Let it be rude, if the wording is awkward I guarantee I can understand it just as well as an LLM, ignore the fact that my daughter just graduated and offering hallucinated platitudes.
Send me the actual question, don't make me try and decompile a big blob of empty text to the ten word prompt that contains all the actual meaning.
AI is a useful tool for a variety of purposes, what it is not useful for is expanding a short statement to an essay and reducing an essay to a short statement. Either the communication deserves to be an essay or ten words will get it done.
How insane is it to advocate the usage of these non-deterministic compilers, where each time you compile may produce different semantics?
And then people resort to saving and hand-editing the compiled output.
But when they want to change the source, they recompile and have to start over hand-editing the output again.
I want to be reading, writing, testing and maintaining the software at the same layer. Right now extreme AI usage leads to reading, testing and maintaining happening in a less expressive language than writing and guess which of those four activities developers enjoy the least and find the hardest - it sure isn't writing.
ie the prompt "Send 'bob' an email with a description of why the VPN bridge isn't working so they can debug their side" is a mostly useless as a prompt for anyone, it's only useful when the LLM has all the context of some analysis of the particular issue and what is going on and then injects it into the email.
1. You are restating the information because you don't believe the recipient understood it the first time and thus you should be very precise in your expression to make sure it isn't too arcane for them 2. The recipient appears to understand the information already in which case why restate it?
I guess if someone is writing like a big fancy email to send out in bulk, maybe using an LLM to improve would make sense... but just emailing some coworkers it seems super lazy and insulting to send an LLM output :-I
Also, if it's wall-o-text or "staging must be updated before our os version is deprecated sunday" I prefer the latter.
Most people I know are happy to receive a focused email rather than an LLM-enhanced, 6 paragraph wall of text.
And no, they are not all raging assholes.
Which is promptly and ironically summarized by AI on the receiving side
Hopefully, LLMs will kill that attitude in the long run
So LLMs have no place for me in this regard.
I didn't have time to write a short letter, so I wrote a long one instead. - M. Twain
The earliest source we have for it is a letter by Blaise Pascal, some 250 before Twain ever thought about writing letters, or anything else for that matter.
(Did an LLM write your post?)
- write verbose tickets
- summaries the verbose tickets
I'm certainly not going to be the first to stake my job or my promotion on that particular hill. So I can fully understand why people will still turn "We need the database changes ASAP, you promised they'd be done. Get it done!" into half a page of drivel.
You can imagine this spread into dating as well, so you just have sex efficiently to optimize the breeding and hedonism.
At some point the protocol of expanding and then compacting with AI will also be removed to optimize the unneeded inference and people will again talk to each other but using the caveman language, stripped away from centuries of culture.
I absolutely agree with your opinion and I loathe it.
What really grinds my gears is when the clearly desired response is a few words or a single sentence, and what I get is a link to an obviously llm generated 3 page pdf full of em-dashes and emoji bullet pointed lists with very little relevance or context about the question.
If I wanted Claude or ChatGPT's response, I would have asked them. If I'm going to bother a cow orker with a question, it's because I want domain specific knowledge or workplace experience that might be important.
I'm more and more often internally reacting with "if you didn't bother writing it, I don't need to bother reading it".
I would welcome your 30 min or half day turnaround with a well written and thought response, over lazy/disrespectful colleges who are just doing the instant 2026 version of "just fucking google it".
In the modern world we've got comments written by LLMs because "You've got to write a comment, of course, it's required!" but now the actually significant comments (the Why comments - as opposed to the What ones) are lost in a sea of LLM slop so no one will read them. Considering it'd be just as easy for the reader to point a conversational LLM at the codefile if they want the LLM interpretation of what's happening why are we bothering committing it at all?
Gosh that really grinds my gears. It's definitely a tangent but that being encouraged is a huge red flag for me.
I've seen some very incomprehensibly-written communication in my time, including from people who speak English as a first language.
The most frustrating group of consistent offenders I've seen was comprised of folks who absolutely should know better: School teachers.
For example, a tenant emails me about some issue relating to a specific property. It can go through my leases, find the right one, check other emails to see I ordered a new appliance to that specific address, track shipping/install, all that, then reply appropriately.
But if you're writing to someone with the intention of communicating personally, using AI anyway shows a lack of effort.
The weird thing is, if I commented on a channel and they sent me an AI-generated reply, I'd just hate them forever.
Personally, when I message people I respect I either don't use AI or ask it "please fix typos only", but if it's someone I don't give a fuck about, then AI-generated slop it is, because assuming that the recipient is a random person, AI-generated slop has the highest chance of actually getting shit done.
If someone reading does this, please, do not. Imperfect English is a lot more pleasant to read than AI slop. It will not sound better, it will sound worse.
And currently many phrases we've been taught to use for formality are being seen as a sign of LLM usage...
I had a high school teacher (algebra II), my favorite coincidentally, who was actually functionally illiterate. He knew some words, and had a solid understanding of the alphabet, but ask him to parse a sentence or god forbid an essay, and he was completely lost.
He was a native born american, english as only language, and simply could not interact with the written language. If he could have written (in 2009) "give 20 question test for week 1 algebra II student with answer guide" he'd have gotten (based on the prompt I just submitted):
Week 1 — Algebra II: 20 Practice Questions
Simplify: 3(x + 4) − 2(2x − 5).
Solve for x: 5x − 7 = 2x + 11.
Solve: 2(x − 3) = 3(x + 1).
Solve and check: (x/4) + 5 = 11.
Factor: x^2 + 5x + 6.
Factor: 4x^2 − 9.
Factor completely: x^2 − 6x + 9.
Multiply and simplify: (2x − 3)(x + 4).
Expand: (x + 2)^2.
Solve quadratic by factoring: x^2 − x − 12 = 0.
Use the quadratic formula to solve: x^2 + 4x + 1 = 0.
Simplify: (3x^2y)(2xy^3).
Simplify: (x^5)/(x^2).
Solve for x: 2^(x+1) = 16.
Evaluate: f(x) = 2x^2 − 3x + 1; find f(2).
Write equation of a line in slope-intercept form with slope 3 and y-intercept −2.
Find slope of the line through points (1, 4) and (5, −2).
Solve the system by substitution: y = 2x + 1 and 3x − y = 4.
Solve the system by elimination: 2x + 3y = 7 and 4x − 3y = 5.
Simplify and write in simplest radical form: sqrt(50).
Answer Key 3x + 12 − 4x + 10 = −x + 22
5x − 2x = 11 + 7 → 3x = 18 → x = 6
2x − 6 = 3x + 3 → −6 − 3 = x → x = −9
x/4 = 6 → x = 24
(x + 2)(x + 3)
(2x − 3)(2x + 3)
(x − 3)^2
2x^2 + 8x − 3x − 12 = 2x^2 + 5x − 12
x^2 + 4x + 4
(x − 4)(x + 3) = 0 → x = 4 or x = −3
x = [−4 ± sqrt(16 − 4)]/2 = [−4 ± sqrt(12)]/2 = [−4 ± 2√3]/2 = −2 ± √3
6x^3y^4
x^3 (assuming x ≠ 0)
2^(x+1) = 16 = 2^4 → x + 1 = 4 → x = 3
f(2) = 2(4) − 3(2) + 1 = 8 − 6 + 1 = 3
y = 3x − 2
slope = (−2 − 4)/(5 − 1) = (−6)/4 = −3/2
Substitute y: 3x − (2x + 1) = 4 → 3x − 2x − 1 = 4 → x = 5 → y = 2(5)+1 = 11
Add equations: (2x+3y)+(4x−3y)=7+5 → 6x = 12 → x = 2. Then 2(2)+3y=7 → 4+3y=7 → 3y=3 → y=1
sqrt(50) = sqrt(25·2) = 5√2
I'm sure there are many more accesibility stories surrounding these fancy auto-completes.(edit: I’m not going to resist)
> If he could have written (in 2009) "give 20 question test for week 1 algebra II student with answer guide"
Is the “could” here just about AI not existing back then, or does “could not interact with the written language” imply that he could not have written this prompt? Why would he need the output, given that most of it is math? (If we assume he can speech-to-text the prompt, why can’t he do the same for other writing?) If the level of writing of “Write equation of a line in slope-intercept form with slope 3 and y-intercept −2” is the challenge, is he able to read it? What if the output is wrong – who’s going to verify it? Are you presenting this as a good thing? How did/would he grade handwritten written-answer questions?
How can anyone even write a proper prompt, or understand if the answer is correct, without being literate? I’ve been noticing on YouTube where people are delivering scripts that are clearly AI written. It makes me question if they are able to read something, understand it, and put it in their own words. This seems like a fundamental skill any adult should have, especially if they are trying to make a living giving advice to others, as was the case with these videos.
I’d also think literacy should be a basic requirement for a teacher, regardless of the subject. If we don’t hold that standard for our teachers, how can we expect it of our students? Continuously lowering standards is not helping anyone in the long run. It hurts the individual and society as a whole.
There's a big difference between running your input through DeepL and asking [ChatGPT] to rewrite it. I don't know how we got to the latter being the go-to
Things that seem trivial to someone well-read can be insurmountable tasks for millions of people.
Those people may do fine day to day, you don't need to write all that many emails for many if not most jobs, but when they do need to get their intentions across, things might get dicy.
Or course this solution is far from perfect. If you use LLMs to word your message because you're not very proficient in reading or writing, you may not understand what the output is saying, so you can't verify that it didn't misinterpret you.
Back when I did customer support, I occasionally dealt with people who lacked the capability to express themselves in written language. These weren't people born in other countries or people with some kind of intellectual disability, often they were just never taught how to read/write/compose a message.
There's also a social stigma to sending a job application written like "good. morning. sir i. wnt too. Wrk for ur Compny u. hve job. for Me im steven i.m" and so on, even if the job in question has nothing to do with any form of written communication.
Plus, there are plenty of things people just don't know how to do. I once had to Google "how do I write a letter of resignation" and Google will now generate a fulll message for you if you type "i want quit next month how write".
I think the author of this blog post assuming a prompt to help improve a message (obnoxious glowing button aside) somehow implies that Google thinks they're stupid showcases the perceived link between the ability to write and intelligence.
Obviously, using LLMs for this is just patching over the lack of resources put into (adult) education and literacy, as well as a societal shift to stop treating illiterate people badly. However, structural improvements take many years, probably several rounds of elections, and doesn't help someone today.
1. Use Google Eloquent or directly into ChatGPT to dictate the email.
2. Then ask AI to polish, simplify, summarize, and I provide my writing style [0].
That gets sent to the user. I am very careful to not allow the AI to write too much.
The alternative is I spend 20+ minutes writing and re-writing the email.
[0] - https://www.kcoleman.me/writing/slack/2023/03/11/writing-sty...
> Speak with confidence. “I think that I can possibly consider agreeing” . Don’t share weak decisions or opinions. Either agree, or disagree.
When I see those I mentally downgrade the whole text.
She uses chatgpt for such with appropriate checks afterwards, all the time. It saves her tons of time, and time is money, time is life spent with kids instead of useless bureaucratic work.
I have tons of similar stories, friends (surgeons, radiologists, all non-native speakers) using chatgpt to write some official application for work permits, motivation letters etc. Just because you don't have certain way of working or work situation doesn't mean its valid for all of us.
It's one thing if you don't speak English well and could use some help making yourself understood, but the amount of native speakers using this is so strange to me. How does this help you? If you can write to the LLM telling it what kind of email to write, you might as well just write the email.