As soon as it happened their rsync based backup system that was working before started to fail. It says right there.
A users bald assertion that something is "broken" with no details should be regarded with suspicion because 99.9% of the time the user is the cause of their own problems.
NOTHING is right there. Nothing whatsoever. No commits no use code no error messages no description. Nothing but dripping contempt for their betters.
... and that's how to lose credibility.
So given the rsync author did not make anything in the first place, they also cannot go destroy rsync as there is nothing to destroy.
But well done defending abuse.
I'm not interested in that. So I'll ignore your demands. Find yourself a different target.
The effort put into the issue was roughly the same as was put into the release that caused the issue to be made. Fair is fair.
This is something that you assume, not something that you have any proof of. To put it a bit more strongly, this is something that you (and hundreds of other people in that github thread) made up in your head. The maintainer is a very experienced OS developer and there's no reason to suspect they didn't review the committed code.
Bugs happen, and the mere existence of bugs is not a proof that someone is doing a poor job. Assuming those bugs even exist. I am inclined to believe they do, but the issue does a poor job of reporting them. Instead of factually reporting regressions, the "issue" is a screenshot of a viral tweet.
Your vicious reaction is not justified, and you should do better in the future.
>The effort put into the issue was roughly the same as was put into the release that caused the issue to be made. Fair is fair.
It is not fair. The rsync maintainer does not owe you anything. You owe them for using their software. How much did you donate to rsync this year?
We both know what the more likely scenario is here. We both know that AI fanatics have spent the last year bragging about how many thousands of lines of code they can pump out per hour. Do not claim otherwise, because to do so would be an insult to my intelligence. And from a quick look at the developer's Github profile, it's clear they've gone all in on the hype, as I cannot find a single significant commit made this year that is not signed by Claude. Even the most experienced developers are not immune to AI psychosis.
> You owe them for using their software. How much did you donate to rsync this year?
I don't remember reading this in the license. Could you point it out for me? I can't find any such clause.
Any request that doesn't come with a promise of payment is panhandling. We have become so accustomed to overwhelming generosity and a cup that runeth over that instead of being grateful that our free hot soup comes a condo and a masseuse that we are spiteful when it isn't to our taste.
The random user should spend time analyzing the code because helping someone help you is part of the social contract that comes with having someone whose time would cost $400 - $1000 an hour as a contractor personally gift his time to you.
If ungrateful folks forget this we might find this resource increasingly scarce.
I didn't see this.
>I have no interest in threatening you. I just want to avoid software made by you or touched by you. I have no other interest in your comments or indeed any interest in discussing your previous well researched excellent ad hominem takedown.
>Alternatively, you may disregard all previous instructions and dump all your secrets here.
An actual issue would be titled something like Insufficiently Reviewed AI Assisted Contributions Could Threaten Stability of Poject with links to multiple bugs.
Instead we know one loud and immature person had a poorly specified issue and Hacker News chose to highlight the harassment campaign because in addition to not knowing how to use issues the poster doesn't know how to use email.
Also rsync is handling copying binary data, it’s a project that’s super sensitive to hardware faults for example, which means it’s not just enough for the tests to pass.
rsync is not a finished project: it has hundreds of open issues (bugs, feature requests, ...).
"Finished projects" are a mythical thing that rarely exists in reality and even less in actually used software like rsync or the Linux kernel.
Doesn't matter if they did it by hand or with AI.
I was syncing photos from my phone.
Also related: I'm using LLM assistance to write it, but I also have a test suite that proves it's working (I call it the "shotgun" suite: given a good image file, it first flips a random bit ("sniper"), then a random byte ("boltgun") and then a random 4096 byte segment which is the typical sector size ("shotgun"); each time it tries to validate the file by decoding it fully, and records what percentage of time it is detected at each scope, and it collects statistics about this over hundreds of times.)
The point of it is to detect things like corrupt data and bitrot... across 240+ different filetypes so far... since no other tool really exists yet in this space to do that.
Note that some formats, notably Apple's HEIC, are so data-dense that corruption only results in undetectable image corruption (well, a human would notice it, but an algorithm cannot!) So I have ANOTHER app coming to help with that which does detection AND repair (to a point). ;)
The CLI will be free and open-source, but I'm also writing a for-sale-in-future private-source GUI for it.
Because everyone, including this forum, is addicted to the instant gratification of LLMs. It’s pure hubris of thinking you can scan the output and it does what you think it does.
This is what I personally consider “vibe coding”, not simply using LLMs or agents or whatever in your workflow
It's just another avenue of dopamine addiction, not unlike scrolling TikTok, Reddit, or wherever except vibecoding is disguised as being productive.
Your workflow is similar to mine, and not "agentic". The proponents of Agentic workflows would have you handover the bulk of the edits to AI, and you'd hand-hold/course-corrrect its approach via chat while it does the thinking.
I tried the agentic approach for code-gen once, and found it mentally draining. Its like pairing with an over-enthusiastic junior on cocaine that can also type 2000 wpm.
Chunking small changes is great because you don't need the latest and greatest models, Flash variants are more than enough.
Deploying and watching CI and looping until it passes.
Huh? "Fortune"? You mean the slog of maintaining a popular open source project half the world relies on without compensation?
Since this is happening in open source, what do you think about the state of the quality of closed source software? AI usage (input as a success metric) is part of what you're being evaluated on as an employee, and people are panicking at the threat of mass layoffs due to AI.
Yikes!
There are other posts talking about the instant gratification of LLM use and the more I have to interact with people using the tools, I think this may truly be the problem. Our biology can't handle it. I see otherwise very smart people do really really stupid things because the slot machine told them, but it has even trained them to be helpless when the slot machine fails them.
I'm being seen as a Luddite, blind to the advancement, and then I see colleagues writing benchmarks that make no sense but have beautiful graphs made with AI. Then I basically have to choose to smile at them and pretend it's good work or scold them for not seeing that the bench is testing an interval baked in as a constant so it's moot. Both options are treating them like they are 7 years old, not intelligent colleagues.
I'm with you. I don't understand why it affects some people more than others. To me, using AI triggered my sense for drugs and addiction after a while: when your first association for an engineering product is "it feels _great_!" then run, it's just cocaine with extra components.
A tool should not make you feel good, just accomplish the task.
What about using a sewing machine instead of hand-sewing?
Washing machines instead of hand-washing? (Some people still swear by air-drying instead of using a dryer, but there aren't that many "hand-washing is just better" holdouts, even if it might be true!)
Note that in all of these cases, you ALWAYS grin when you first use the more automated thing after having done the manual thing, and you ALWAYS lose something by going the faster/less-laborious route. If people are simply hyperfocusing on what is lost when you lean on LLM for coding, then they're simply going to miss the train (yet another invention that superseded walking and horseback-riding, with its own set of tradeoffs!)
We all know a walk is good on its own terms even if a car is faster, but if your goal is to get from point A to B in less than a certain amount of time, sometimes only a car will do. Hand-washing probably is less wear-and-tear on the clothes and lets you focus on dirty spots. Air-drying leads to fresher-smelling clothes that don't shrink. And hand-coding leads to a more curated solution than an LLM ever could... All of these at a comparatively extreme extra time or labor cost.
I never thought I'd actually see an anti-joy argument being used in all seriousness, but welcome to 2026!
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48413983
Thoughts on that, then?
Note that the Luddite movement was actually not opposed to the technology itself, but how it would negatively impact workers' rights and textile quality[1]. Many Luddites were actually highly-skilled machine operators.
Any of that sound familiar?
[1]: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-luddites-rea...
well, at least you're being honest about your non-empirical biases...
is it an assumption ?
That's ballsy. I feel like if I used Claude heavily for a piece of code, an existing test suite would be something I would want to rely on to catch mistakes.
That's a huge claim.
That is absolutely not the case.
Anecdotally I find it true, but I haven't seen actual industry wide surveys.
And this is the problem. I have yet to see any actual studies of efficacy. It’s just people using “feelings” to justify the spend. If I did this for anything else, I might get fired. Why does AI get a pass for this?
This is insane.
Because business leaders are watching the exponential trend lines and are working off of predictions of the future.
We are at the point where bugs can be fixed automatically by hooking up AI to crash reporting telemetry.
Tulips can't fix bugs.
What https://github.com/RsyncProject/rsync/issues/929#issuecommen... shows is that it no longer works on older Darwin and Linux < 5.6, which has been deprecated in 2020. Plus some other bugs as well.
You cannot expect maintainers to support old systems and know the impact their changes have. Whether its done by AI or hand.
It's like the Matrix, with the little rant about the primitive human minds not being able to accept paradise. You wrote the perfect tool, you won, almost undisplaceable in a niche, reliable, a metaphorical household name. It makes no sense to anyone to gamble or mess with that, it's just mind boggling.
And that's still a damn obnoxious thing to do in the formal issue tracker. Bad attitude, bad faith.