News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Codex for almost everything by woeirua on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:01PM (#47798721)
Just reading the comments here it's amazing how many people seemingly don't know that Claude Desktop and Cowork basically already does all of this. Codex isn't pioneering these features, it's mostly just catching up.
Re:Codex for almost everything by solenoid0937 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:14PM (#47798887)
Codex is HN's darling now because Anthropic lowered rate limits for individuals due to compute constraints. OAI has so few enterprise users they can afford to subsidize compute for this group a lot more than Anthropic.

Eventually once they have more users they'll do the same thing as Anthropic, of course.

It's all a transparent PR play and it's kind of absurd to see the X/HN crowd fall for it hook, line, and sinker.

Re:Codex for almost everything by someotherperson on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:17PM (#47798931)
Competition is bad? Who cares - let the big players subsidize and compete between each other. That's what we want. We want strong models at a low price, and we'll hype up whoever is doing it.

Simultaneously, we also hype up the open models that are catching up. That are significantly more discounted, that also put pressure on the big players and keep them in check.

People aren't falling for PR; people are encouraging the PR to put pressure on the competition. It's not that hard.

Re:Codex for almost everything by frank_nitti on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:41PM (#47799219)
Interesting to see your observation where I have observed the opposite: posts that share big news about open-weight local models have many upvoted comments arguing local models shouldn’t be taken seriously and promoting the SOTA commercial models as the only viable options for serious developers.

Here and on AI tech subreddits (ones that aren’t specifically about local or FOSS) seem to have this dynamic, to the degree I’ve suspected astroturfing.

So it’s refreshing to see maybe that’s just a coincidence or confirmation bias on my end.

Re:Codex for almost everything by lxgr on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:27PM (#47799717)
Both can be true at the same time. I currently wouldn't waste my time with open models for almost all use cases, but they're crucial from a data privacy and competitive perspective, and I can't wait for them to catch up enough to be as useful as the current frontier models.
Re:Codex for almost everything by organsnyder on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:03PM (#47800097)
I've found qwen3 to be very usable on my local machine (a Framework Desktop with 128gb RAM). I doubt it could handle the complex tasks I throw at Claude Opus at work, but it's more than capable of doing a surprising number of tasks, with good performance.
Re:Codex for almost everything by dotancohen on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:14PM (#47800214)
What tasks do you use qwen3 for? Coding? Are you running it on CPU or GPU? What GPU does that Framework have?

Thanks!

Re:Codex for almost everything by girvo on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:44PM (#47800457)
I have an Asus GX10 that I run Qwen3.5 122B A10B on, and I use it for coding through the Pi coding agent (and my own); I have to put more work in to ensure that the model verifies what it does, but if you do so its quite capable.

It makes using my Claude Pro sub actually feasible: write a plan with it, pick it up with my local model and implement it, now I'm not running out of tokens haha.

Is it worth it from a unit economics POV? Probably not, but I bought this thing to learn how to deploy and serve models with vLLM and SGLang, and to learn how to fine tune and train models with the 128GB of memory it gets to work with. Adding up two 40GB vectors in CUDA was quite fun :)

I also use Z.ai's Lite plan for the moment for GLM-5.1 which is very capable in my experience.

I was using Alibaba's Lite Coding Plan... but they killed it entirely after two months haha, too cheap obviously. Or all the *claw users killed it.

Re:Codex for almost everything by dotancohen on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:56PM (#47800564)
Thank you. I've been using ollama for a much more modest local inference system. I'll research some of the things you've mentioned.
Re:Codex for almost everything by jeremyjh on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:06PM (#47801463)
GLM 5.1 is extremely good, and ridiculously cheap on their coding plan. Its far better than Sonnet, and a fifth of the cost at API rates. I don't know if the American providers can compete long-term; what good is it to be more innovative it only buys them a six month lead andthey can't build the data center capacity fast enough for demand? Chinese providers have a huge advantage in electrical grid capacity.
Re:Codex for almost everything by girvo on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:07PM (#47801784)
True but Z.ai also just silently raised the price, and the entire Chinese frontier set is having to make profit now... hence Alibaba killing the Lite plan and not letting people sign up to their Pro one either; and why MiniMax has their non-commercial license, etc. etc.

So I agree with you, its better than Sonnet but way cheaper. I do wonder how long that will last though

Re:Codex for almost everything by fragmede on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:00AM (#47802574)
Z.ai does really well at the carwash question!
Re:Codex for almost everything by organsnyder on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:21PM (#47800276)
The Framework Desktop has a Ryzen 395 chip that is able to allocate memory to either the CPU or GPU. I've been able to allocate 100+gb to the GPU, so even big models can run there.

Most recently I used it to develop a script to help me manage email. The implementation included interacting with my provider over JMAP, taking various actions, and implementing an automated unsubscribe flow. It was greenfield, and quite trivial compared to the codebases I normally interact with, but it was definitely useful.

Re:Codex for almost everything by dotancohen on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:58PM (#47800595)
That's great. Ostensibly my system could also allocate some of the 32 GB of system memory to argument the 12 GB VRAM, but I've not been able to get it to load models over 20B. I should spend some more time on it.
Re:Codex for almost everything by bloppe on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:10PM (#47799532)
I'm just waiting till I can afford a GPU again
Re:Codex for almost everything by nl on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:47PM (#47801686)
I've invested significant time into getting open models to work, and investigating what works well.

The TL;DR is that unless you are doing it as a hobby or working in an environment where none of the data privacy options supported by Anthropic/OpenAI (including running on Azure/Bedrock with ZDR) work for you then it's not worth it.

The best open models are around the Sonnet 4.6 level. That's excellent, but the level of tasks you can give to GPT 5.4 or Opus 4.6 is just so much higher it doesn't compare (and Opus 4.7 seems noticeably better in my few hours of testing too).

I have my own benchmarks, but I like this much under-publicized OpenHands page: https://index.openhands.dev/home

It shows for every task they test closed models do the best. The closest and open model gets is Minmax 2.7 on issue resolution where it's ~1% worse than the leaders.

That matches my experience - fine for small problems, but well behind has the task gets bigger.

Re:Codex for almost everything by echelon on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:48PM (#47801688)
> Interesting to see your observation where I have observed the opposite: posts that share big news about open-weight local models have many upvoted comments arguing local models shouldn’t be taken seriously and promoting the SOTA commercial models as the only viable options for serious developers.

When I argue this, my point is that FOSS shouldn't target the desktop with open weights - it should target H200s. Really big parameter models with big VRAM requirements.

Those can always be distilled down, but you can't really go the other way.

Re:Codex for almost everything by adamsmark on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:54PM (#47808654)
Local isn't viable yet on an economic basis, API costs are so low that you're better off taking advantage of the bonanza. As local models become more performant, so too will the ability of providers via Openrouter be able to offer them cheaper than your likely payoff period for a $4K Mac Studio 128GB. e.g Gemma 4 31B is impressive, but it costs practically nothing via Openrouter. Given that there are a ton of providers for open models, I doubt there's any subsidy going on because the providers are faceless and interchangeable.

At least, that's my theory.

The big advantages of local on a business level are:

- Freezing your model's exact settings once you've locked in some kind of workflow that works just fine. - Guarding against insane token usage from LLMs who have been told to never stop until they figure out the solution OR setting up an LLM run incorrectly. (The last one happened to me with Gemini 3.1 Pro) - PII or some need for on-premise only LLMs.

Re:Codex for almost everything by whymememe on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:24PM (#47799017)
I agree but I’d like to add that people are definitely falling for PR, people are always falling for PR or no one would bother with PR
Re:Codex for almost everything by daveguy on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:29PM (#47799739)
> Competition is bad? Who cares - let the big players subsidize and compete between each other.

Subsidizing is the opposite of competing. It's literally the practice of underpricing your product to box out competition. If everyone was competing on a level playing field they would all price their products above cost.

All these tech oligarch asshat companies need to be regulated to hell and back.

Re:Codex for almost everything by ipaddr on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:43PM (#47799895)
The moat was already too large for smaller players. Let them subsidize. Take from investors and give to us buying me time to beef up my local stack to run local models.

For many things now you need to go local and in the future if you want any privacy you'll need to go local.

Re:Codex for almost everything by daveguy on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:00PM (#47800074)
Excellent point, but I still think the oligarchs have gotten a little monopoly-happy.
Re:Codex for almost everything by agentifysh on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:43PM (#47800444)
What's the alternative, move to North Korea ?
Re:Codex for almost everything by daveguy on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:14PM (#47800727)
Well, that's a great big wtf out of left field.
Re:Codex for almost everything by agentifysh on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:32PM (#47810261)
You didn't seem to like competition or market forces pricing things. Just a suggestion.
Re:Codex for almost everything by watwut on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:45PM (#47799270)
Big players subsidizing is what kills medium and small players which then kills competition. What follows is monopoly.

Big players operating at loss to distort the market is not a good thing overall.

Re:Codex for almost everything by someotherperson on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:22PM (#47799659)
The medium and small players are literally just distilling the larger models.

It's not the smaller players spending billions on training data.

Re:Codex for almost everything by sofixa on Thursday April 16, 2026 @11:35PM (#47802228)
No, the medium and small players are the Mistals, DeepSeek and H Company of the world, with their own models using quirky optimisation techniques to be able to compete.
Re:Codex for almost everything by badrequest on Thursday April 16, 2026 @11:33PM (#47802220)
It's hilarious how much this post reads as drafted by an LLM. The emdash, "it's not X, it's Y" framing, incredible.
Re:Codex for almost everything by sph on Thursday April 16, 2026 @11:45PM (#47802276)
Dogfooding by the slop factory. The artificial centipede.
Re:Codex for almost everything by someotherperson on Friday April 17, 2026 @12:51AM (#47802538)
I wrote my post myself.
Re:Codex for almost everything by subscribed on Friday April 17, 2026 @04:01AM (#47803561)
People use em-dashes all the time. This is why LLMs use it too. Also guess how LLMs learnt to use "it's not X, it's Y".
Re:Codex for almost everything by dmix on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:00AM (#47802573)
This assumes people are in touch with reality and aren't just motivated by vibes and insta-reactions on social media
Re:Codex for almost everything by luddit3 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:27PM (#47799053)
So Anthropic degraded their product. OAI updated their product to meet for exceeded Anthropic old product.

This is normal behavior and not a cause for such a hyperbolic response.

Re:Codex for almost everything by solenoid0937 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:53PM (#47800537)
There is good competition and bad competition.

Pricing your product unsustainably vs a competitor to gain market share is regarded as "bad competition" and has historically been seen as anticompetitive.

It does not benefit the consumer in the long run, because the goal is to use your increased funding or cash reserve to wipe your competition out of the market, decreasing competition in the long term.

Then, once your competition is gone, and you've entrenched yourself, you do a rug pull.

Re:Codex for almost everything by byzantinegene on Thursday April 16, 2026 @11:20PM (#47802133)
you're right but for now it doesn't matter if both competitors are running on infinite vc money, we as consumers benefit from it. it only matters if they cause negative externalities in the meantime
Re:Codex for almost everything by pizzly on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:57PM (#47799407)
This is the benefits of competition in action
Re:Codex for almost everything by solenoid0937 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:45PM (#47800475)
To be clear, unsustainably hemorrhaging money to gain marketshare over a competitor is generally considered an anticompetitive practice.
Re:Codex for almost everything by toraway on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:57PM (#47800581)
What if both competitors are doing it?
Re:Codex for almost everything by justapassenger on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:18PM (#47801539)
It’s also THE playbook of the Silicon Valley.
Re:Codex for almost everything by guzfip on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:20PM (#47801550)
Also why there’s so much enthusiasm for it on HN
Re:Codex for almost everything by greenavocado on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:29PM (#47799083)
Not only that, but anthropic is now forcing users to give their biometric information to palantir

They're doing a slow rollout

Re:Codex for almost everything by solenoid0937 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:57PM (#47800576)
OAI already requires this. They both require identity verification in some cases
Re:Codex for almost everything by BrokenCogs on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:33PM (#47799135)
There's a systematic marketing campaign from oai on reddit and HN - there's a huge uptick of "codex is better than claude code" comments and posts this last week which is perfectly timed with the claude code increased limits
Re:Codex for almost everything by CuriouslyC on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:15PM (#47800744)
To be fair, GPT 5.4 is mostly a better model than Opus 4.6 in terms of quality of work. The tradeoff is it's less autonomous and it takes longer to complete equivalent tasks.
Re:Codex for almost everything by unsupp0rted on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:40PM (#47799200)
Go to /r/codex and see how pissed off people are by the new Codex Plus plan 5-hour limits (they're a sliver of what they were a week ago). Whatever OpenAI is doing to market on Reddit isn't working.
Re:Codex for almost everything by toraway on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:00PM (#47799451)
I'm not sure what changed or what the complaint is ... But personally, I have still never hit the rate limit on the $20/mo ChatGPT Plus plan, while I was constantly getting kicked off the Claude Pro plan until I got fed up and cancelled a few months ago.
Re:Codex for almost everything by unsupp0rted on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:28PM (#47799720)
I can get about 20 ~ 40 minutes of my 5-hour limit using Codex 5.4 medium to say write a patch script in typescript for a Firebase + BigQuery app. That's including about 10 minutes of first writing a planning.md doc with 5.2 High.

A couple weeks ago I'd get roughly 2~3 hours. And a month before that I couldn't break the 5-hour limit.

Re:Codex for almost everything by CuriouslyC on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:16PM (#47800753)
They were running a 2x rate limit promo last month.
Re:Codex for almost everything by unsupp0rted on Friday April 17, 2026 @06:26AM (#47804396)
Theoretically yes. In practice even a few weeks before it ended, the actual rate limit was down to what it was before the promo. And now I'm getting roughly 0.25x of what I got before the promo.
Re:Codex for almost everything by boomskats on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:43PM (#47799235)
Thing is, Codex 5.3 is a better and more consistent model than anything Anthropic have come out with. It can deal with larger codebases, has compaction that works, and has much less of a tendency to resort to sycophantic hallucination as it runs out of ideas. I also appreciate their approach to third party harnesses like opencode, which is obviously the complete opposite to Anthropic and their scramble to keep their crumbling garden walls upright.

Which makes it even more of a shame that Sam Altman is such a psychopathic jackass.

Re:Codex for almost everything by yoyohello13 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:35PM (#47799157)
There was brief consternation when OpenAI swooped in to snatch up those DoD contracts but then the next model released and all is forgiven.
Re:Codex for almost everything by olcay_ on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:57PM (#47800038)
Anthropic coming out to say they won't surveil Americans wasn't actually a positive for me. It meant they're okay with surveilling the rest of the world, which in turn signaled "fuck you, you're inferior, deal with it" to me (as someone from the aforementioned rest of the world).

When OpenAI snatched those contracts, it made me think no worse of OpenAI. The surveillance was already factored into how I saw them (both).

Re:Codex for almost everything by keeganpoppen on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:12PM (#47799560)
everyone seems to unconditionally love anthropic, but openai has always had the best models… it just requires a bit more effort on behalf of the user to actually leverage it.
Re:Codex for almost everything by kar1181 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:14PM (#47799578)
This is true. But Anthropic did us dirty most recently and so it’s their turn on the pitch fork. Sam will do us too. Just not yet.
Re:Codex for almost everything by the__alchemist on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:39PM (#47799850)
Call it fall for it, but here are my two experiences, with both applications open. ($20/month plan for both)

  - Claude: Good for ~20 minutes of work once every 4 hours
  - Codex: Good for however long I want to use it.  
Claude nerfed their product so that it's not usable, so I use something else.
Re:Codex for almost everything by CrazyStat on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:51PM (#47799972)
Since we’re sharing anecdata: I also have the $20 month plan for codex, and I hit the five hour limit after about an hour of work every single time I open it. I use it for personal side projects primarily in the evening after kids are in bed, so my strategy is to launch it about 4pm and send a simple prompt to prime the 5 hour window to end at 9pm, start working about 8pm, and then I can use up the existing 5 hour window and the next one by about 10pm.
Re:Codex for almost everything by botanrice on Thursday April 16, 2026 @08:17PM (#47801123)
What kind of side projects do you need to run these models for that many hours? I haven't experimented with Opus to that extent and mostly supervise it and/or am prompting it every 5-10min to fix something up.
Re:Codex for almost everything by CrazyStat on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:13PM (#47801506)
I've done a variety of things with it:

- sysadmin tasks for my home server which runs home assistant, plex, and minecraft servers. Being able to tell it "Set up a minecraft fabric server with this list of mods" is pretty nice, and it's fairly competent at putting together home assistant dashboards and automations (make sure you have backups of anything it's allowed to touch, though--it may delete stuff without warning).

- Several small web apps primarily for my own use.

- Currently working on an opinionated desktop writing app for my own use.

Re:Codex for almost everything by KronisLV on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:50PM (#47799967)
I'm on the 100 USD plan with Anthropic, I hit the 5 hour limits about 75% of the time during working hours, but almost never the weekly ones - by the time they're reset I've usually used up between 50% - 75% of the quota. There are periods of more intense usage ofc, but this is the approx. situation I'm in (also it doesn't work on tasks while I'm asleep, because I occasionally like having a look at WIP stuff and intervene if needed).

The Anthropic 20 USD plan would more or less be a non-starter for agentic development, at least for the projects that I work on, even while only working on a single codebase or task at a time (I usually do 1-3 at a time).

I would be absolutely bankrupt if I had to pay per-token. That said, I do mostly just throw Opus at everything (though it sometimes picks Sonnet/Haiku for sub-agents for specific tasks, which is okay), so probably not a 100% optional approach, but I've wasted too much time and effort in the past on sub-optimal (non-SOTA) models anyways. I wonder which is closer to the actual cost and how much subsidizing there is going on.

Re:Codex for almost everything by bitmasher9 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:15PM (#47800733)
The $200 openai plan feels like 10x the limit as the $100 claude plan.

But Opus is both smarter and faster than GPT, so I can get a lot more done during the Claude limits.

Re:Codex for almost everything by lsdmtme on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:29PM (#47801893)
for now... right now you are getting 2x usage as a promo
Re:Codex for almost everything by the__alchemist on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:05PM (#47800123)
Concur, re the ratio of weekly vs hourly limits: I hit the hourly one much more often than weekly.
Re:Codex for almost everything by ipaddr on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:58PM (#47800050)
Wow the 20 dollar Claude plan sounds awful. I use Claude at work which has metered billing and have to carefully not to hit my four figure max cap.

For me $20 a month is more than I want to spend I just use the free tiers. If I use AI in an app or site I use older models mostly chatgpt3.5. The challenge is more fun and it means I can do more like, make more api calls - 100x more.

Re:Codex for almost everything by XDataY on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:14PM (#47801824)
I use $20 plan for my side projects and in the beginning I was hitting limits very fast but after creating proper .md files and running /clear, it seems to work fine for my use. I am really curious how people are using $100-$200 plans. Maybe I am not utilizing to its full capacity??
Re:Codex for almost everything by chaos_emergent on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:40PM (#47799863)
Thinking in counterfactuals, how would the hype around Codex would be different if it was organic and because they had built a genuinely good product? Asking as someone who genuinely loves Codex and has been in the OpenAI camp for months after buying a Claude Max plan from November to February.
Re:Codex for almost everything by peyton on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:45PM (#47799918)
I haven’t noticed much hype around Codex. I have both and use Claude for broad work off my phone and Codex on my computer to clean up the mess. Crank reasoning to the highest setting for each. Claude is extremely unreliable for me, and Codex feels like more of a real tool. I’d say Codex has a bit of a learning curve. Nothing much has changed for me in the past month or two (whenever GPT 5.4 came out).
Re:Codex for almost everything by jsemrau on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:10PM (#47800184)
Codex is much worse than Anthropics model. My experience is that I burn 10x the tokens using Codex compared to Sonnet 4.6
Re:Codex for almost everything by HWR_14 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:29PM (#47800350)
And hopefully Anthropic has extra capacity then and I can return there.
Re:Codex for almost everything by raincole on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:48PM (#47800494)
> because Anthropic lowered rate limits for individuals due to compute constraints

It's because they don't support OpenCode.

Re:Codex for almost everything by m3nu on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:50PM (#47800512)
I have a feeling that Codex is also getting lower limits. Got this email just now. Basically they copy Claude's $100 tier.

> To help you go further with Codex, we’re introducing a new €114 Pro tier designed for longer, high-intensity sessions.

> At launch, this new tier includes a limited-time Codex usage boost, with up to 10x more Codex usage than Plus (typically 5x).

> As the Codex promotion on Plus winds down today, we’re rebalancing Plus usage to support more sessions across the week, rather than longer high-intensity sessions on a single day.

Re:Codex for almost everything by giancarlostoro on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:13PM (#47800721)
They didnt just lower limits they keep messing with peoples local settings and I wish it would be called out drastically more because it could cause serious issues. A coding agents settings are a contract, even the default ones, if they worked for me for 9 months and now you are changing defaults on me, you shouldnt just force new defaults on me without warning, Claude can and will goof up hard if misconfigured.
Re:Codex for almost everything by zmmmmm on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:26PM (#47801574)
It's one of the things I really dislike about providers hyping "inference time scaling" as a concept. Apart from being a blatant misnomer (there's nothing scalable about it), it's so transparently a dial they can manipulate to shape perception. If they want a model to seem more intelligent than it really is, just dial up the "thinking" and burn tokens. Then once you have people fooled, you can dial it down again. Everyone will assume its their own fault that their AI suddenly isn't working properly. And since it's almost entirely unmeasurable you can do it selectively for any given product you want to pitch for any period of time you like and then pull the rug.

We need to force them back into being providers of commodity services and hit this assumption they can mold things in real time on the head.

Re:Codex for almost everything by AlexCoventry on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:31PM (#47801607)
It's quite likely that OpenAI is running a significant PR campaign to compensate for the bad rep they earned by stepping in to meet the demands of the Trump administration, after Anthropic refused to assist the administration with mass domestic surveillance and development of lethal autonomous weapons. Presumably OpenAI didn't buy the podcast TBPN just because they like the guys.

https://paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Re:Codex for almost everything by ra on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:02PM (#47801760)
Anthropic don't seem to know how to look after and keep customers.
Re:Codex for almost everything by iterateoften on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:07PM (#47801781)
No it’s because Anthropic can’t message anything to its customers without lying.
Re:Codex for almost everything by a34729t on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:48PM (#47801979)
Uber, but AI!
Re:Codex for almost everything by khacvy on Friday April 17, 2026 @12:42AM (#47802507)
I really hate this kind of behavior. Yeah, Anthropic may do some bad things, I don't know, but we all see that Anthropic is always one step ahead of OpenAI. And just because Anthropic lowered rates for some people, people now start saying that Codex is way better than Claude Code / Claude Desktop.
Re:Codex for almost everything by xnx on Saturday April 18, 2026 @03:26PM (#47818753)
If only there were a third major player, maybe one who was even much more established as a cloud provider...
Re:Codex for almost everything by firloop on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:10PM (#47798830)
I don't think Claude has this part yet:

> With background computer use, Codex can now use all of the apps on your computer by seeing, clicking, and typing with its own cursor. Multiple agents can work on your Mac in parallel, without interfering with your own work in other apps.

Re:Codex for almost everything by krackers on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:32PM (#47799128)
>background computer use

How does that even work technically? macOS doesn't support multiple cursors. On native Cocoa apps you can pass input to a window without raising via command+click so possibly they synthesized those events, but fewer and fewer apps support that these days. And AppleScript is basically dead, so they can't be using that either.

I also read they acquired the Sky team (who I think were former Apple employees). No wonder they were able to pull of something so slick.

Re:Codex for almost everything by antimatter15 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:17PM (#47799609)
I remember looking trying to build something like this 6 years ago[0]. There are some interesting APIs for injecting click/keystroke events directly into Cocoa, and other APIs for reading framebuffers for apps that aren't in the foreground.

In particular there was some prior art that I found for doing it from the OpenQwaQ project, which was a GPLv2 3D virtual world project in Squeak/Smalltalk started by Alan Kay[1] back in 2011.

If I recall correctly, it worked well for native apps, but didn't work well for Chromium/Electron apps because they would use an API for grabbing the global mouse position rather than reading coordinates from events.

[0]: https://github.com/antimatter15/microtask/blob/master/cocoa/... [1]: https://github.com/OpenFora/openqwaq/blob/189d6b0da1fb136118...

Re:Codex for almost everything by jjk7 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:45PM (#47799278)
Probably accessibility APIs
Re:Codex for almost everything by krackers on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:56PM (#47799403)
Which specific ones though allow you to send input to a window without raising it? People have been trying to do "focus follows mouse [without auto raise]" for a long time on mac, and the synthetic event equivalent to command+click is the only discovered method I'm aware of, e.g. used in https://github.com/sbmpost/AutoRaise

There is also this old blog post by Yegge [1] which mentions `AXUIElementPostKeyboardEvent` but there were plenty of bugs with that, and I haven't seen anyone else build on it. I guess the modern equivalent is `CGEventPostToPSN`/`CGEventPostToPid`. I guess it's a good candidate though, perhaps the Sky team they acquired knows the right private APIs to use to get this working.

Edit: The thread at [2] also has some interesting tidbits, such as Automator.app having "Watch Me Do" which can also do this, and a CLI tool that claims to use the CGEventPostToPid API [3]. Maybe there's more ways to do it than I realized.

[1] https://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2008/04/settling-osx-focus-... [2] https://www.macscripter.net/t/keystroke-to-background-app-as... [3] https://github.com/socsieng/sendkeys

Re:Codex for almost everything by kristophph on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:56AM (#47803193)
Maybe they used Claude to come up with a good method to do this. /s

But I was also wondering, how this even works. The AI agent can have its own cursors and none of its actions interrupt my own workflow at all? Maybe I need to try this.

Also, this sounds like it would be very expensive since from my understanding each app frame needs to be analysed as an image first, which is pretty token intensive.

Re:Codex for almost everything by saagarjha on Friday April 17, 2026 @08:45AM (#47805336)
There are better ways to analyze on-screen content than images.
Re:Codex for almost everything by saagarjha on Friday April 17, 2026 @08:44AM (#47805330)
You don't actually need to send CGEvents to UI elements to make them do things ;)
Re:Codex for almost everything by krackers on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:19PM (#47808941)
Could you elaborate on what you mean? My understanding of the Cocoa event loop was that ultimately everything is received as an NSEvent at the application layer (maybe that's wrong though).

Do you mean that you can just AXUIElementPerformAction once you have a reference to it and the OS will internally synthesize the right type of event, even if it's not in the foreground?

Re:Codex for almost everything by fifafu on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:43PM (#47809186)
yes you can do a lot background UI interaction using the AX APIs. Displaying a second cursor is also simple, just a borderless, transparent window that moves around.

For the few things you cannot achieve with the Accessibility API's there are ways to post events directly to an app - even though CGEventPostToPid is mostly broken when used on its own. These require a combination of CGEventPostToPid and CGEventTapCreateForPid. (I have done a lot of this stuff in my BetterTouchTool app)

Re:Codex for almost everything by krackers on Friday April 17, 2026 @07:02PM (#47811515)
Neat, good to know! And it does seem my mental model of event loop was broken. Accessibility related interactions don't have any related NSEvent.

They are handled as part of the "conceptual" run loop, but they seem to be dispatched internally by AXRuntime library from a callback off some mach port. And because of this, the call to nextEventMatchingEventMask in the main -[NSApplication run] loop never even sees any such NSEvent.

    -[NSApplication(NSEvent) _nextEventMatchingEventMask:untilDate:inMode:dequeue:]  (in AppKit)
        _DPSNextEvent  (in AppKit)
          _BlockUntilNextEventMatchingListInModeWithFilter  (in HIToolbox)
            ReceiveNextEventCommon  (in HIToolbox)
              RunCurrentEventLoopInMode  (in HIToolbox)
                CFRunLoopRunSpecific  (in CoreFoundation)
                  __CFRunLoopRun  (in CoreFoundation)
                    __CFRunLoopDoSource1  (in CoreFoundation)
                      __CFRUNLOOP_IS_CALLING_OUT_TO_A_SOURCE1_PERFORM_FUNCTION__  (in CoreFoundation)
                        mshMIGPerform  (in HIServices)
                          _XPerformAction  (in HIServices)
                            _AXXMIGPerformAction  (in HIServices)

In some sense this is sort of similar to apple events, which are also "hidden" from the caller of nextEventMatchingEventMask. From what I can see those are handled by DPSNextEvent, which sorts based on the raw carbon EventRef. aevt types have `AEProcessAppleEvent` called on them, then the event is just consumed silently. Others get converted to a CGEvent and returned back to caller for it to handle. But of course accessibility events didn't exist in Classic mac, so they can't be handled at this layer so they were pushed further down. You can almost see the historical legacy here..

[1] https://www.cocoawithlove.com/2009/01/demystifying-nsapplica...

Re:Codex for almost everything by chrisstanchak on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:37PM (#47799825)
Citrix

/s

Re:Codex for almost everything by ahmadyan on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:24PM (#47800810)
They aquired Vercep, and their older agent Vy did have background agent. IIRC the recent computer-use agent in Claude is based on Vy, so i'm kinda surprised that feature didn't carry over to Claude desktop app.
Re:Codex for almost everything by iknowstuff on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:57PM (#47801735)
Imagine where we’d be if the restrictive iOS model was dominant in all computing. We’d never get anything like this
Re:Codex for almost everything by awestroke on Friday April 17, 2026 @06:12AM (#47804313)
Re:Codex for almost everything by firloop on Friday April 17, 2026 @08:14AM (#47805070)
I’m referring to how it can use your computer in the background.
Re:Codex for almost everything by awestroke on Friday April 17, 2026 @10:30AM (#47806366)
Me too
Re:Codex for almost everything by FlamingMoe on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:06PM (#47798779)
Claude Cowork is unusably slow on my M1 MacBook Pro. I wonder if Codex is any better; a quick search indicates that it is also an electron app
Re:Codex for almost everything by zozbot234 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:09PM (#47798819)
Codex is a rust TUI app, and it's available as open source. It has nothing to do with Electron.
Re:Codex for almost everything by 16bitvoid on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:14PM (#47798883)
Codex CLI is a TUI app, but Codex App is an actual desktop GUI app. If you actually look at the TFA, you'll see that all of the videos are of the desktop app.
Re:Codex for almost everything by conradev on Sunday April 19, 2026 @04:57AM (#47822866)
Yes! and if you install Computer Use from the Codex App you can also use it from the Codex CLI
Re:Codex for almost everything by gempir on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:14PM (#47798879)
Codex is both a macOS app and a CLI/TUI app.

Their naming is not very clear. The codex desktop app is somewhat of a frontend for the codex cli.

By the look and feel of it I would guess it is written with Electron.

Re:Codex for almost everything by ValentineC on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:15PM (#47798899)
> Codex is a rust TUI app, and it's available as open source. It has nothing to do with Electron.

I just updated Codex and looked inside the macOS app package. It is most definitely still an Electron app.

Re:Codex for almost everything by bdotdub on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:15PM (#47798897)
the codex desktop app is electron, as is claudes
Re:Codex for almost everything by btown on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:32PM (#47800375)
At least when I tried it last, Claude Cowork tried to spin up an entire virtual machine to sandbox itself properly - and not only is that sandboxing slow to start up, it also makes it difficult to actually interact freely across your filesystem. (Perhaps a feature, not a bug.)

Claude Code, on the other hand, has no such issues, if you've done some setup to allow all commands by default (perhaps then setting "ask" for rm, etc.).

Re:Codex for almost everything by dyauspitr on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:10PM (#47798834)
Yeah, it’s probably very similar to my experience where I just tried Codex because I had a ChatGPT subscription found it to be quite powerful and then because I was used to it just ended up getting the pro subscription so I am guessing folks like me have never really used Claude.
Re:Codex for almost everything by com2kid on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:35PM (#47799160)
IMHO no one is really pioneering. A lot more is possible than what is being done. I wrote a blog post about useful agents in a business setting (https://www.generativestorytelling.ai/blog/posts/useful-corp...) that highlights AI being proactive.

I mean table stakes stuff, why isn't an agent going through all my slack channels and giving me a morning summary of what I should be paying attention to? Why aren't all those meeting transcriptions being joined together into something actually useful? I should be given pre-meeting prep notes about what was discussed last time and who had what to do items assigned. Basic stuff that is already possible but that no one is doing.

I swear none of the AI companies have any sense of human centric design.

> pull relevant context from Slack, Notion, and your codebase, then provide you with a prioritized list of actions.

This is an improvement, but it isn't the central focus. It should be more than just on a single work item basis, more than on just code.

If we are going to be managing swarms of AI agents going forward, attention becomes our most valuable resource. AI should be laser focused on helping us decide where to be focused.

Re:Codex for almost everything by a1j9o94 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:43PM (#47799229)
Disclaimer I work at Zapier, but we're doing a ton of this. I have an agent that runs every morning and creates prep documents for my calls. Then a separate one that runs at the end of every week to give me feedback
Re:Codex for almost everything by com2kid on Thursday April 16, 2026 @04:48PM (#47799301)
In the full blog post I actually go into more detail about automatically creating a knowledge graph of what is being worked on throughout the whole company. There are some really powerful transformative efforts that can be accomplished right now, but that no one is doing.

Basic things like detecting common pain points, to automatically figuring out who is the SME for a topic. AIs are really good at categorizations and tagging, heck even before modern LLMs this is something ML could do.

But instead we have AI driven code reviews.

Code Reviews are rarely the blocker for productivity! As an industry, we need to stop automating the easy stuff and start helping people accomplish the hard stuff!

Re:Codex for almost everything by paulteehan on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:28PM (#47799718)
THANK YOU. I keep thinking this as well. I'm rolling my own skills to actually make my job easier, which is all about gathering, surfacing, and synthesizing information so I can make quick informed decisions. I feel like nobody is thinking this way and it's bizarre.
Re:Codex for almost everything by cuzitschat on Friday April 17, 2026 @03:04AM (#47803238)
I am completely convinced this is because of a gap in the intersection of knowledge. Somehow the people making the best agents are focused on extending the capabilities of the models, meanwhile the people who could best make an application layer because just think of LLM's as a chat prompt.

We need a product person, maybe with a turtle neck sweater and an horrid work-life attitude, to fix this up, instead of a weirdly philosophic basilisk fearing idealist.

Re:Codex for almost everything by woeirua on Sunday April 19, 2026 @03:11PM (#47826774)
The value prop is tenuous and most people still think agents aren't capable of doing this type of work reliably yet (which is... kind of true). You won't get punished too much by users for false positives when summarizing tasks, but you will get absolutely eviscerated for false negatives (e.g. dropping a critical task from the summary). Can you guarantee that your agent won't forget to tell you about something super important?
Re:Codex for almost everything by irrationalfab on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:01PM (#47800087)
Agreed. It is ironic that in the AI race, the real differentiation may not come from how smart the model is, but from who builds the best application layer on top of it. And that application layer is built with the same kind of software these models are supposed to commoditize.
Re:Codex for almost everything by com2kid on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:10PM (#47800181)
This feels like *nix.

Developers built themselves really good OSes for doing developer things. Actually using it to do things was secondary.

Want to run a web server? Awesome choice. Want to write networking code? Great. Setup a reliable DB with automated backups? Easy peasy.

Want a stable desktop environment? Well after almost 30 years we just about have one. Kind of. It isn't consistent and I need to have a post it note on my monitor with the command to restart plasma shell, but things kind of work.

Current AI tools are so damn focused on building developer experiences, everything else is secondary. I get it, developers know how to fix developer pain points, and it monitizes well.

But holy shit. Other things are possible. Someone please do them. Or hell give me a 20 or 30 million and I'll do it.

But just.... The obvious is sitting out there for anyone who has spent 10 minutes not being just a developer.

Re:Codex for almost everything by lsdmtme on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:32PM (#47801913)
You should check out https://pieces.app/ ive been using it for months and I am surprised I have never seen anyone ever talk about it.

It does exactly what you are asking for, and it can do it completely locally or with a mixture of frontier models.

Re:Codex for almost everything by woeirua on Sunday April 19, 2026 @03:13PM (#47826792)
Is this just a wrapper on top of Beads?
Re:Codex for almost everything by woeirua on Sunday April 19, 2026 @03:09PM (#47826763)
This makes a lot of sense, but I can't see anyone paying for this because at its simplest layer it's just a Neo4j install + some skills + a local cron job for Claude Desktop. How long will it take for Anthropic to just bake this into Claude Desktop or OpenAI into Codex? Probably not that long.

I keep coming up with good ideas for how to use agents and keep walking away from them because there just is no defensible moat. Everything software related is just going to get totally consumed over the next year.

Re:Codex for almost everything by tempaccount5050 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:37PM (#47799820)
The first time I tried anthropics version it burned up all its tokens in like 10 minutes and left me stuck in a broken state. So I uninstalled it.
Re:Codex for almost everything by bze12 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:38PM (#47799829)
It mostly feels like they’re just converging on each other. The latest Claude Mac app release pushed a new UI that looks almost exactly like Codex’s.
Re:Codex for almost everything by jimbean78 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @05:46PM (#47799925)
I think your making assumptions without reading the entire thread and processing the general theme. This isn't about catching up or whos better. It really comes down two things. One, how far does your money go, and secondly which political narrative you subscribe too. Up until they started their beef with the u.s. government I was a subscriber. Between that and how fast my tokens depleted I switched to Codex. Best decision of my life and now I never run out of tokens.

It was the perfect storm and I would have never switched since the first AI I started with was Claude.

Re:Codex for almost everything by jswny on Thursday April 16, 2026 @10:26PM (#47801875)
You want to use the model that is potentially giving your data to the government vs the one that’s openly rejecting that partnership?
Re:Codex for almost everything by Rohunyyy on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:16AM (#47802642)
At this point you gotta pick and chose your morality Claude is screwing people on credits and tokens OoenAI is selling three molecules left of your privacy to the government Are those three molecules worth fighting for when your budget is really tight or you are unemployed? Everyone has different priorities
Re:Codex for almost everything by brikym on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:32PM (#47800369)
Clicking UI elements can also be done in Github copilot for vscode, and cursor.
Re:Codex for almost everything by risyachka on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:40PM (#47800421)
Its not like Claude is pioneering those. All that was done prior to all of them by some random startup.
Re:Codex for almost everything by bitexploder on Thursday April 16, 2026 @06:40PM (#47800422)
Antigravity off in the corner feeling sad about itself rn.
Re:Codex for almost everything by qingcharles on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:05PM (#47800657)
I love poor forgotten Antigravity. For one, you can use your Gemini account to churn Opus credits until they run out then switch to Gemini 3.1 to finish off.
Re:Codex for almost everything by pigpop on Thursday April 16, 2026 @07:09PM (#47800693)
Didn't the original ChatGPT desktop app have computer use first?
Re:Codex for almost everything by grkhetan on Thursday April 16, 2026 @08:17PM (#47801126)
??? Codex has more features than Claude Cowork (background computer use, etc)
Re:Codex for almost everything by Rekindle8090 on Thursday April 16, 2026 @09:14PM (#47801516)
It's not x, It's y.

:^)

Re:Codex for almost everything by Razengan on Friday April 17, 2026 @07:11AM (#47804626)
Codex has better UX/UI, but Claude is still way ahead in sheer schizophrenia: https://i.imgur.com/jYawPDY.png

Opus 4.6 has had many "oops you're right!" gaffes and other annoyances that I let my Claude subscription expire yesterday.

Codex has been more consistent and helpful, but it too is still not quite at the point where you can blindly trust it without verifying the output.