Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by slibhb on Saturday March 07, 2026 @12:13PM
(#47289452)
> Currently, the most plausible theory emerging from her team’s research points to metabolism: Healthy and cancerous cells may process reactive oxygen species—unstable oxygen-containing molecules generated during radiation—in very different ways.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by hinkley on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:46PM
(#47290333)
There was also a study that showed that chemotherapy efficacy was enhanced by fasting before treatment.
It seems that when calories are scarce, healthy cells turtle up while cancer cells keep consuming, so fasting reduces absorption rates in healthy tissues and thus collateral damage.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by sl_convertible on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:24PM
(#47290639)
Healthy cells CAN turtle-up, whereas cancer cells engage in unregulated reproduction. Also, some cancer cells can only consume glucose. Which, in a fasted state, would mean that the majority of energy would be in ketones(if the individual were metabolically healthy), starving the cancer cells to death.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by nick__m on Saturday March 07, 2026 @04:00PM
(#47291449)
Because the cancers cells adapt! (fast reproduction and high mutation rate of the cancerous cells make that process quicker than antibiotics resistance)
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by spopejoy on Saturday March 07, 2026 @10:32PM
(#47294122)
Please don't throw around random "a study that showed" about cancer treatments and chemotherapy. If you really think it needs to be shared, share the study and while you're at it, check in with a good oncologist or knowledgeable friend too. In my ~10 years of enduring chemo and other treatments, the amount of garbage you have to wade through from "well meaning" anecdata like "wheat grass" or "smoke huge bongloads" or "don't eat sugar" makes an already horrible process worse.
And yes I checked this with my onc at MSK. Dietary glucose in particular -- if you cut out enough sugar to starve cancer cells you would be doing lots of damage elsewhere as well.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by spopejoy on Sunday March 08, 2026 @03:51PM
(#47300640)
I'm saying that cancer treatments are some of the most scientifically-validated procedures out there, because there's essentially unlimited money to pay for them. They have eliminated or modulated any negative side effect they can, via improved anti-nausea drugs, careful dosing+timing, etc.
Still, you can experience all sorts of discomforts during the tmt. I nearly fainted and got horrible chills when getting oxaliplatin for the first time. You're saying I should have _fasted_ for this?
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by yread on Sunday March 08, 2026 @10:47AM
(#47297768)
There is this review that havent found any effects:
https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/15/12/2666
Note that they excluded 274 out of 283 studies, considering only 9. It's in mdpi which is not great.So, the jury is still out I guess
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by spopejoy on Sunday March 08, 2026 @04:03PM
(#47300815)
The jury is not out -- it's an unconfirmed hunch that, as the study you link notes, risks harming patients who are having trouble keeping down food as it is.
This is just keto and fasting fans pushing their obsession on cancer patients. Same for marijuanauts -- anti-nausea drugs have long outperformed cannibinoids but you still have stoner friends offering you spliffs (ok, save them for later)
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by bilbo0s on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:52AM
(#47289279)
Exactly what I thought as soon as I learned the name.
It's like, man, how to kill a product?
No pun intended.
It could even work? But you put yourself behind such a poorly placed 8 ball when you do these things. Even among researchers, people are a little superstitious about stuff like this. It's always in the back of everyone's mind.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by leptons on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:28PM
(#47290158)
I doubt any of that is valid. Therac-25 happened 44 years ago, that's a very long time, and many people involved in cancer research today weren't even alive when it happened.
"Theryq" and "Therac" are not quite the same either. The word "therapy" and derivatives of it using "thera" are still used widely across the medical industry.
So I'm not really sure why anyone here is making a big deal about the name of the company being "Theryq".
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by Aurornis on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:44PM
(#47290321)
> Even among researchers, people are a little superstitious about stuff like this.
Being superstitious is not common in the medical treatment world, where weird product names are common.
A doctor isn’t going to include the device’s brand name in their decision process for treating a cancer patient.
The Therac-25 case study is noted in the medical world but not to the same extent as in engineering. The case was a tragedy of bad engineering, but the doctors involved in directing the treatments were not at fault for the radiation over exposures.
Another interesting part of the story is the user element. The issue was most often triggered by fast, experienced technicians who were able to key commands more quickly than Therac engineers anticipated:
> After strenuous work, the physicist and operator were able to reproduce the error 54 message. They determined that speed in editing the data entry was a key factor in producing error 54.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by throwyawayyyy on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:01PM
(#47290467)
I learned about Therac at college in the 90s.
Some years later, I interviewed at Knight Capital, just a couple of weeks before their blowup. (Dreadful interview at which I did dreadfully, being asked to write C _over the phone_ by a supremely uninterested engineer. Quite a red flag in retrospect.)
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by ErroneousBosh on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:57PM
(#47290940)
> Therac-25 is a great case study for software engineers too, recommend reading the Wikipedia article for anyone who hasn't, it's not too long.
I re-read the original paper every few months, more frequently if I'm working on Safety-of-Life-Critical equipment. Which, given my day job, means I'm re-reading it every couple of weeks at most.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by elromulous on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:57PM
(#47290439)
The audience of this website is disproportionately aware of the Therac-25 compared to the general public. For the obvious reason, engineering, but also geographically: The Therac-25 being a North American incident that affected Canada and the US. Whereas Theryc is a French company.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by tjoff on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:06PM
(#47290508)
While I do agree with your point, as a Swede not even born when the incidents happen I still knew about it, was brought up in a computer science class.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by XorNot on Sunday March 08, 2026 @09:01AM
(#47296970)
If I have cancer then whether to trust the radiation machine due to the name is certainly a choice I can make, but you get to own your own priorities in that case.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by scythe on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:40AM
(#47289164)
Hey, FLASH finally hit Hacker News! I remember my professors talking about this in graduate school. It's a fairly well-established effect: the tumor selectivity of radiation is much better at ultra-high dose rates. It is still unclear exactly why. But there are a lot of studies about it:
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by toss1 on Saturday March 07, 2026 @12:05PM
(#47289394)
Interesting the effect's reason is still unclear.
I was starting to infer there was a better focusing ability so it could start and exit as a broad cone of radiation and keep the peak intensity at the tip of the focal cones at the tumor-tissue, and the short pulse also helped the healthy tissue.
But the way this sounds, it's more like a straight beam delivering similar intensity to healthy and tumor tissue but the biological effect strongly differs between healthy vs tumor tissue?
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by scythe on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:02PM
(#47289925)
Yes, the radiation dose under the conventional metric (energy divided by mass) is the same, but the effects on biological systems change. I included a little speculation on the chemistry in my response to a sibling comment.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by LoganDark on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:53AM
(#47289293)
My guess would be that the radiation doesn't itself care but that tumors have some other characteristic (like multiplying rapidly) that makes them more susceptible to it. Similarly to how you can sometimes attack them with medication that inhibits cell division.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by scythe on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:00PM
(#47289902)
Yeah that's the conventional dose rate effect, not the FLASH effect. The FLASH effect happens on timescales so short that ordinary considerations like the cell cycle or DNA repair mechanisms are inherently ruled out. Instead it might have to do with the type of radical species that form in normal cells versus tumors, possibly related to oxygenation, pH, glycolysis byproducts, etc.
The first interaction of radiation with tissue is usually this:
H2O + ħv >> H2O+ + e- (fugitive)
The radical ion H2O+ is extremely reactive and usually protonates another water molecule immediately:
H2O+ + H2O >> H3O+ + OH*
The hydroxyl radical has a half life of about a nanosecond and will usually be the main "reagent", diffusing until it runs into an organic molecule which will be oxidized and thus degraded. At high enough dose rates, the peak concentration of hydroxyl radicals and more stable radicals like superoxide could be much higher, leading to "nonlinear" effects, i.e. byproducts of multiple radicals interacting with each other or a protein.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by amluto on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:05PM
(#47291888)
One thing I found confusing about the nature article is that it mostly discusses conventional linear accelerator + bremsstrahlung X-ray radiation versus very high dose rate FLASH in the form of electron beams, proton beams, or even carbon ion beams.
Do we know that what the chemical mechanism for damage from charged particle beams is? Is it similar enough to compare directly like this? Are the timescales short enough that charge deposition might matter?
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by sjmcmahon on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:26PM
(#47292060)
The article is a bit unclear, but we have both a very wide range of X-ray vs charged particle studies, and increasingly of conventional vs FLASH studies with a range of modalities (e.g. the seminal FLASH paper was FLASH electrons vs conventional electrons). FLASH photon vs conventional photons are also increasingly being generated, although they've been more of a pain to generate.
So it's clear there is a temporal FLASH effect, which is not purely a question of radiation type.
That's not to say it's necessarily exactly the same effect - we still don't have a perfect quantitative understanding of the effects of different radiation types even at normal dose rates, let alone when FLASH differences are added into the mix.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by tiderpenger on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:34AM
(#47289106)
I generally don't trust cancer-communication if it's juiced up like this incredible headline. There has been huge amounts of progress. We don't need silicon valley idiots starting to make proclamations. It's doing fine without your mediocrity.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by the8472 on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:50PM
(#47290887)
The sidebar mentions heavier particles having a pronounced Bragg Peak[0] and also existing approaches like multi-beam targeting. The FLASH effect in the article is yet another tool to limit the surrounding damage.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by hinkley on Saturday March 07, 2026 @01:50PM
(#47290364)
I recall someone was analyzing the refractive index of various tissues in order to tighten the target area for multi beam radiation therapy. Particularly for brain cancers. By hitting from multiple angles the dosage in surrounding tissues is lower, and by calculating how the head lenses the beam you reduce the high dose area in the middle, like a 3d Venn diagram.
But I don’t remember is whether that experiment became SOP or not.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by hinkley on Saturday March 07, 2026 @02:07PM
(#47290512)
Seems not in this case. But I believe the use case was deep brain tumors, like the hippocampus, where any beam alignment problems could be life altering.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by owenthejumper on Saturday March 07, 2026 @03:45PM
(#47291299)
The major issue isn't the speed of delivery, and the cancer.
The key question is how do you spare normal tissue, and how do you prove the normal tissue is spared in the long term. Current answer is: You break it apart into multiple sessions, the anti-thesis of FLASH.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by nick__m on Saturday March 07, 2026 @03:53PM
(#47291378)
from the article (pay attention to the part in italics):
FLASH radiotherapy flips the conventional approach on its head, delivering a single dose of ultrahigh-power radiation in a burst that typically lasts less than one-tenth of a second. In study after study, this technique causes significantly less injury to normal tissue than conventional radiation does, without compromising its antitumor effect.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by sjmcmahon on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:19PM
(#47292007)
That phrasing isn't perfectly clear, as there's two things at play.
If you're delivering a large dose D all at once, FLASH spares normal tissue compared to conventional rate irradiations, with maintained anti-tumour effect.
But, you can instead deliver your treatment in a number of smaller doses, say n "fractions" of dose d. This also spares normal tissue (1). This latter approach - fractionation - is the way radiotherapy was delivered for most of its history. But at these low doses, FLASH sparing is small to negligible.
So, we have two demands in tension - and its unclear which is actually optimal. Some of the early results in FLASH showed huge sparing, but lots of more recent studies have shown more modest effects which may not be worth giving up benefits of fractionation for(2). And to date I think we have basically no meaningful in-human data to guide this, so there's still a lot of uncertainty.
1 - Fractionation also spares tumours, a bit, but you can offset this by increasing the total dose a bit and still see benefit.
2 - There is a general move to somewhat larger, fewer fractions even in normal radiotherapy, although almost all of these are still below the threshold where FLASH sparing is seen.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by aix1 on Sunday March 08, 2026 @03:01AM
(#47295228)
Another potential factor at play is the accuracy of delivery. It is generally easier to accurately deliver one quick dose vs daily doses over multiple weeks (due to patient positioning errors, the patient losing weight, soft tissues moving around etc).
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by imglorp on Sunday March 08, 2026 @09:36AM
(#47297222)
It saddens me with a survivor in my family that the primary therapies are still cut, burn, and poison. They are horrific to experience and just slightly better than the disease.
There are so many biological cures on the horizon; they can't arrive fast enough.
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by oofbey on Sunday March 08, 2026 @01:58PM
(#47299420)
What I find really sad is how slowly this science moves. As I read the article, the “a ha!” breakthrough was in the 1990s. Why did it take them 15-20 years to publish anything??? Coming from the tech industry this is mind boggling.
If you thought there was even a chance you were sitting on a realization that could literally “cure cancer” wouldn’t you want to scream it from the rooftops as loud and fast as possible?
Re:The Millisecond That Could Change Cancer Treatment
by pas on Sunday March 08, 2026 @07:53PM
(#47302985)
every researcher who believes in their idea shouts (to grant organizations) that their thing is the best. but gathering actual data is difficult.
usually research is super inefficient, academia is full of people who are ... true believers. (sometimes only in their own greatness, and that leads to fraud.) which is amazing, but it's not really conductive to figuring out what's the best way to set up a high-throughput process to generate data.
in many cases it would require them to stop most of what they do and let a specialist team build said pipeline for them. (but that runs into cost problems. and that immediately leads us back to the grant organizations allocating resources.)
and just an anecdote, I have a friend who worked at a brain research group (they implanted electrodes into rodents, put them into mazes, and then see whether they dream about the maze) and ... it was cool, but IMHO that public money was mostly wasted.
Reminds me of this which I (think) was linked here a while ago: https://www.nature.com/articles/s12276-020-0384-2
It really does feel like all these piecemeal cancer treatments are converging on something resembling a cure.
It seems that when calories are scarce, healthy cells turtle up while cancer cells keep consuming, so fasting reduces absorption rates in healthy tissues and thus collateral damage.
I guess it was too good to be true.
And yes I checked this with my onc at MSK. Dietary glucose in particular -- if you cut out enough sugar to starve cancer cells you would be doing lots of damage elsewhere as well.
Still, you can experience all sorts of discomforts during the tmt. I nearly fainted and got horrible chills when getting oxaliplatin for the first time. You're saying I should have _fasted_ for this?
Of these risks it's the potential veering into liver and kidney problems that deserves the closest monitoring.
See: https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/should-you-tr...
~ Howard E. LeWine, MD, Chief Medical Editor, Harvard Health Publishing
This is just keto and fasting fans pushing their obsession on cancer patients. Same for marijuanauts -- anti-nausea drugs have long outperformed cannibinoids but you still have stoner friends offering you spliffs (ok, save them for later)
It's like, man, how to kill a product?
No pun intended.
It could even work? But you put yourself behind such a poorly placed 8 ball when you do these things. Even among researchers, people are a little superstitious about stuff like this. It's always in the back of everyone's mind.
"Theryq" and "Therac" are not quite the same either. The word "therapy" and derivatives of it using "thera" are still used widely across the medical industry.
So I'm not really sure why anyone here is making a big deal about the name of the company being "Theryq".
Being superstitious is not common in the medical treatment world, where weird product names are common.
A doctor isn’t going to include the device’s brand name in their decision process for treating a cancer patient.
The Therac-25 case study is noted in the medical world but not to the same extent as in engineering. The case was a tragedy of bad engineering, but the doctors involved in directing the treatments were not at fault for the radiation over exposures.
"This name makes me uncomfortable. I think I'd rather die of cancer."
> Previous models had hardware interlocks to prevent such faults, but the Therac-25 had removed them, depending instead on software checks for safety.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
Another interesting part of the story is the user element. The issue was most often triggered by fast, experienced technicians who were able to key commands more quickly than Therac engineers anticipated:
> After strenuous work, the physicist and operator were able to reproduce the error 54 message. They determined that speed in editing the data entry was a key factor in producing error 54.
Some years later, I interviewed at Knight Capital, just a couple of weeks before their blowup. (Dreadful interview at which I did dreadfully, being asked to write C _over the phone_ by a supremely uninterested engineer. Quite a red flag in retrospect.)
No pun intended?
I re-read the original paper every few months, more frequently if I'm working on Safety-of-Life-Critical equipment. Which, given my day job, means I'm re-reading it every couple of weeks at most.
Keeps you sharp, doesn't it?
CGR who provided the accelerators and basic PDP11-based computing platform were a French company.
> Whereas Theryc is a French company.
I have been a Citroën enthusiast for about 30 years. I love French cars.
I have repaired lots of Valeo electronics modules for vehicles.
I'm not sticking my head in a French fucking particle accelerator.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41571-022-00697-z
I was starting to infer there was a better focusing ability so it could start and exit as a broad cone of radiation and keep the peak intensity at the tip of the focal cones at the tumor-tissue, and the short pulse also helped the healthy tissue.
But the way this sounds, it's more like a straight beam delivering similar intensity to healthy and tumor tissue but the biological effect strongly differs between healthy vs tumor tissue?
The first interaction of radiation with tissue is usually this:
H2O + ħv >> H2O+ + e- (fugitive)
The radical ion H2O+ is extremely reactive and usually protonates another water molecule immediately:
H2O+ + H2O >> H3O+ + OH*
The hydroxyl radical has a half life of about a nanosecond and will usually be the main "reagent", diffusing until it runs into an organic molecule which will be oxidized and thus degraded. At high enough dose rates, the peak concentration of hydroxyl radicals and more stable radicals like superoxide could be much higher, leading to "nonlinear" effects, i.e. byproducts of multiple radicals interacting with each other or a protein.
Do we know that what the chemical mechanism for damage from charged particle beams is? Is it similar enough to compare directly like this? Are the timescales short enough that charge deposition might matter?
So it's clear there is a temporal FLASH effect, which is not purely a question of radiation type.
That's not to say it's necessarily exactly the same effect - we still don't have a perfect quantitative understanding of the effects of different radiation types even at normal dose rates, let alone when FLASH differences are added into the mix.
It'll be nice when we figure it out, then we can understand the unintended consequences better.
Not that it should prevent its use or anything; fuck cancer.
Those aren’t superstition, just common sense.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bragg_peak
But I don’t remember is whether that experiment became SOP or not.
However that’s the current theory, of a long line of theories that did not pan out.
The key question is how do you spare normal tissue, and how do you prove the normal tissue is spared in the long term. Current answer is: You break it apart into multiple sessions, the anti-thesis of FLASH.
Source: my wife is a radiation oncologist.
FLASH radiotherapy flips the conventional approach on its head, delivering a single dose of ultrahigh-power radiation in a burst that typically lasts less than one-tenth of a second. In study after study, this technique causes significantly less injury to normal tissue than conventional radiation does, without compromising its antitumor effect.
If you're delivering a large dose D all at once, FLASH spares normal tissue compared to conventional rate irradiations, with maintained anti-tumour effect.
But, you can instead deliver your treatment in a number of smaller doses, say n "fractions" of dose d. This also spares normal tissue (1). This latter approach - fractionation - is the way radiotherapy was delivered for most of its history. But at these low doses, FLASH sparing is small to negligible.
So, we have two demands in tension - and its unclear which is actually optimal. Some of the early results in FLASH showed huge sparing, but lots of more recent studies have shown more modest effects which may not be worth giving up benefits of fractionation for(2). And to date I think we have basically no meaningful in-human data to guide this, so there's still a lot of uncertainty.
1 - Fractionation also spares tumours, a bit, but you can offset this by increasing the total dose a bit and still see benefit.
2 - There is a general move to somewhat larger, fewer fractions even in normal radiotherapy, although almost all of these are still below the threshold where FLASH sparing is seen.
There are so many biological cures on the horizon; they can't arrive fast enough.
If you thought there was even a chance you were sitting on a realization that could literally “cure cancer” wouldn’t you want to scream it from the rooftops as loud and fast as possible?
usually research is super inefficient, academia is full of people who are ... true believers. (sometimes only in their own greatness, and that leads to fraud.) which is amazing, but it's not really conductive to figuring out what's the best way to set up a high-throughput process to generate data.
in many cases it would require them to stop most of what they do and let a specialist team build said pipeline for them. (but that runs into cost problems. and that immediately leads us back to the grant organizations allocating resources.)
for example see how many problems the paper from 2014 had: https://pubpeer.com/publications/A32D7989007655CBF8D9DB2A250...
also see how fiendishly difficult it was initially to create transgenic mice embryos: https://www.astralcodexten.com/i/167092138/prerequisites-dex...
and just an anecdote, I have a friend who worked at a brain research group (they implanted electrodes into rodents, put them into mazes, and then see whether they dream about the maze) and ... it was cool, but IMHO that public money was mostly wasted.