News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:42PM (#47158343)
I have been a Strong Towns follower/member for about 6 years. I really don't think people realize the world of pain we're signing up for by not actually fixing the underlying problem of lack of density and walk-ability and their effect on the municipal budgets of American cities.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_Towns

I know municipal finance is about as exciting socks for Christmas, but if the Strong Towns thesis is correct, we've basically found ourselves in slow moving crisis, where city budgets start very slowly, but very surely, become unsustainable, and by the time anyone notices, it's mostly too late to do anything about it. Pipes cost money, repaving costs money, replacing your wastewater system costs money... lots of money. The fact that they only have to be replaced every 30-50 years doesn't mean the costs go away... they just disappear temporarily. Deferring that maintenance doesn't actually do anything except make the problem worse tomorrow.

The idea that LA literally can't afford to bring it's sidewalks up to ADA code is insane. The idea that they're engaging in penny-smart, pound-foolish solutions is a strong signal that the city budget is already deeply broken, and likely is not fixable under the current paradigm of LA politics.

California cities could trivially fix their budget problems by satisfying the demand for housing by adding density, but it seems they are determined to do nothing until the wheels finally fall off, and the city's budget crisis spirals out of control. Even then, I wonder if they will take the Detroit-route and declare bankruptcy before actually addressing the problem.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by doug_durham on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:36PM (#47159038)
You use the phrase "trivially fix". If your definition of "trivially" means several decades with the investment of billions of dollars, then perhaps. There are no "trivial fixes" in city infrastructure. Re-zoning only works if there are developers who want to redevelop the land. For existing neighborhoods this means buying dozens of SFH from people who don't want to move. This drives the price of any development up making it unprofitable in most cases. I'm sorry but I can't take you seriously.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:48PM (#47159164)
When I say "trivially fix" I mean that, if the City/State wanted to fix the problem, they could.

>Re-zoning only works if there are developers who want to redevelop the land.

Developers very obviously want to redevelop the vast majority of LA. The marginal cost of a housing unit is vastly higher than the cost of building that unit. To raise long-term tax revenues, LA could not just legalize redevelopment. They could actually incentivize it.

>For existing neighborhoods this means buying dozens of SFH from people who don't want to move.

The people living in SFH don't want to move exactly because they're not generating enough tax revenue to keep the city afloat (mostly due to Prop 13). Eventually the city will start having to raise taxes very dramatically or declare bankruptcy. That's the entire message from Strong Towns.

The more we put it off, the bigger the impact will be. When your city is effectively long-run insolvent, but you have the ability to change that even if it's politically unpopular (and LA does), then it's "trivially" doable, it's just that people don't want to.

That's not the case in many other cities.

In other cities demand isn't there. People will just leave when taxes go up, and the town will declare bankruptcy. At that point, they will effectively lose most of their population, or people will just live without things like clean water. An example of this happening is Jackson Mississippi, where the water system failed, and the city didn't have the money to fix it. The ultimate solution was just a federal bailout, which is not sustainable if these types of crises become endemic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jackson,_Mississippi_water_cri...

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:07PM (#47159964)
Every time I look at a city/county budget, the schools absolutely dwarf everything else (it's not quick to disentangle different levels of government, but roughly speaking, it seems like schools are usually roughly the same cost as all other services combined where I've looked), which makes it hard for me to take seriously the idea that it's infrastructure like roads and sewage specifically leading to unsustainable budgets. e.g. if I remember correctly, special ed programs cost more than roads when I looked at the previous metro I lived in's budget, and sewers were revenue neutral with a county sewer fee.

Strongtowns seems a bit motivated in their analysis, to put it mildly.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:17PM (#47160066)
When you are looking at your city budget... you're probably looking at cash-based accounting:

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cashaccounting.asp

This looks at current costs. The school is a cost every year, so every year that cost shows up on the budget. The problem is that road/water/sewer maintenance often doesn't show up on these budgets because these systems are usually built all at once. Because of this they usually also need to be replaced all at once. To see those costs before they happen, you need to use accrual accounting:

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/accrualaccounting.asp

The entire message from Strong Towns is exactly that because cities often use cash accounting instead of accrual accounting in their budgetary processes these lingering issues of deferred maintenance don't show up until they do, and when they do, those costs will simply be too large for the city to cover without very politically unpopular interventions.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:06PM (#47160441)
That’s absolutely untrue. The only reason companies track depreciation as they do is because it allows them to defer taxation. Public works projects are not paid out of current cash.

Strong Towns makes good arguments about certain things and are critical in a reasonable way of how civil engineering organizations rate the need for more civil engineering works. But the budget discussion makes zero sense.

The biggest expenses for county, city, town, village government are: schools, police & fire, Medicaid share in states that do that, and employee retirement and health. A small/midsize city spends 60% of its budget on police.

Capital projects are capitalized with bonds. Governments have the lowest bond expenses due to tax exemptions. Roadwork is not done in a cash basis. It’s bonded for 10-30 years depending on the job.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:23PM (#47160594)
Yes, the problem is that our cities are already leveraged up to their eyeballs. At some point, the actual humans buying those bonds start becoming skeptical of the city’s ability to pay them back.

LA currently has about a billion dollars of outstanding general obligation bonds (edit: but that does not include all their future liabilities). They're still rated AA, but I presume that is because the credit writing agencies understand how many untapped revenue streams LA has, but again, those will require unpalatable political change. You can’t keep refinancing forever.

Philadelphia, Miami, and Chicago are getting close to junk bond status, and when that happens, the option to refinance starts evaporating very quickly.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:37PM (#47160685)
Wikipedia says the GDP of the LA metro is ~1.5T. I think they could handle 1B in bonds. If they choose not to, it's not because it's some impossibility. Certainly not because roads are impossibly expensive.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:21PM (#47160993)
I said general obligation bonds, not general liabilities. These technically are what makes this discussion so difficult.

My point is that much of what the city can tax has little to do with the city's GDP. Either the landscape of the city will have to change or the current taxation paradigm will have to change.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @10:38PM (#47161513)
What they can tax does have to do with the GDP though. If they have a 1B deficit, they need to somehow tax <0.1% of activity (or cut services), whether through property tax, income tax, sales tax, corporate tax, or some other scheme. What they don't need to do is radically increase density, and since almost all of the costs scale with population, not area, density wouldn't even help that much (or might hurt if it leads to a lower percentage of net contributors).

Again, putting $1B in some perspective, the LA Unified School District budget (which is county-level, so not directly comparable to the city, but anyway) is just under $19B. Maybe someone else can ballpark how much of that is associated to the city. Or look the other things that scale with population: police, medical, waste, social programs, etc.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Thursday February 26, 2026 @12:28AM (#47162227)
Again, they have $1B in the current deficit. The have $1B in outstanding bonds. They have myriad other outstanding obligations that won't show up on the balance sheet for 20+ years.

Strong Towns wrote an entire piece on this: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2025-10-27-ground-zero-l...

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Thursday February 26, 2026 @09:01AM (#47166204)
Okay, but relative to their resources, that's nothing. So they can just pay for those things. It's like worrying about a water heater replacement when you make well into six figures. At a macro level, it is obvious that the suburban model itself is not somehow financially unsustainable.

The city budget is $14B. So they need to make a ~7% adjustment somehow, which amounts to less than a 1% tweak to the local economy. That's not a broken system. It's not a ponzi scheme. It just means they should pay their bills and maybe reduce some waste. You yourself said it's trivial for residents to afford to just pay for the deficit.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:46PM (#47160741)
LA County has a bigger economy than many European countries, and would displace Illinois by GDP if it were a state.

LA is fine.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:37PM (#47161108)
I also think LA will be fine in the long run, I just think that their tax structure will force significant changes. The tax base is able to cover the cities liabilities, it's just that the residents don't want to pay those extra taxes, and don't want to change in ways that let other people pay them.

The city has a billion dollar deficit right now. Trivial for residents to afford ($83 per person), but difficult to actually implement politically.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:48PM (#47160299)
Capital improvements don't need to be paid all at once; that's what financing is for. And debt service does appear on budgets. In any case, why are we to believe that e.g. $1B in maintenance that's been deferred for decades is "the" problem when the school budget is $500M/year?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:17PM (#47160546)
You’re making an argument about school budgets being too high. That’s fine. I’m arguing that, our school budgets are set, in large part, by our available resources. Viewing our resources from a long run perspective helps us set our current budgets.

If we cut the school budget only when we need to repave roads, we are playing fast and loose with our children’s future. When we set our budgets to be sustainable, we don’t rug pull parents who are trying to build a life in our cities.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:25PM (#47160610)
I'm not even saying school budgets are necessarily too high. I'm just saying that if someone is claiming that what amounts to 5-10% of the budget is why cities go bankrupt, and that's why they need to entirely reshape how they develop to fit some idyllic vision of a pedestrian city, then I'm going to go ahead and doubt their analysis.

Like I'm happy that my (suburban) city requires new developments to connect to a city-wide bike trail network. That's great. I just don't think Strong Towns/Not Just Bikes presents a realistic mental model of the world. They seem to clearly be pushing for a specific vision regardless of facts.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by imtringued on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:36AM (#47163891)
I'm not sure I understand your argument. You can defer maintenance but school, police, firefighter, etc spending is constant. If your infrastructure is in trouble and your budget can't pay for the maintenance, you can limit the costs to 5% or 10% of the budget, but your infrastructure will continue decaying.

Los Angeles has about 7500 miles of roads. At a reasonable cost of $5 million per mile that is 37.5 billion USD. Assuming a lifespan of 35 years, that is basically a billion USD per year spent on servicing road infrastructure costs. If they don't spend that billion every year or put it aside for future repairs, their road infrastructure is going to decay. It might not sound like much in comparison to the full budget, but since the road network is the largest man made structure in the city, it will affect everyone and be the most noticeable failure on part of the government. Lack of police or fire fighting can show up in the form of stochastic damage that doesn't necessarily impact every citizen directly.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ndriscoll on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:34AM (#47165875)
Sure, if you treat all other things as impossible to tweak except the thing you want to argue is the problem, I guess. But taking a quick look at the city budget, I see they spent $200M on overtime for police. So there's a place where they could save like $70M with no change to service with correct staffing? I'm sure there are other places where they are not currently 100% efficient. Or, since they have ~4M residents in the city, they could raise taxes by $250/person-year. That doesn't sound unsustainable to me. Certainly not a "suburbs are a fundamentally broken model" level problem.

Lots of suburban cities in the US are really nice, well run places. LA even as an example of a poorly run area doesn't actually seem to be in much of a financial pickle.

The point is

> you can limit the costs to 5% or 10% of the budget, but your infrastructure will continue decaying

Is just confused. The $1B/year you came up with as sufficient is ~7% of the LA city budget (~$14B), and that's excluding major expenses like schools since that's the county budget. If you look more holistically at just "what's the local government spending", the amount you say is needed to properly maintain the roads is more like 3-4%. Roads are just not a financial problem. Strongtowns guy just doesn't like them.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by danudey on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:19PM (#47174402)
Overtime for police can often be largely attributed to special events or occasions; for example, the city might have an entirely correct amount of officers for most of the year, but then during superbowl, presidential visits, Fourth of July parties, Pride, etc. They have a much higher need for patrol units, escorts, traffic management, etc. for those denser areas with more going on. They can't simply transfer officers around because that would leave other areas of the city under-patrolled, which runs the risk of unacceptably higher response times.

As a result, officers that worked Saturday through Thursday might also come in for a shift on Friday/Saturday, or might work a longer shift or split shift that day.

So the problem might not be that the police force needs 30% more staffing, but that the police force needs 80% more staffing on extremely rare occasions.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by stinkbeetle on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:02PM (#47174865)
This is how lobby groups in general operate. They have settled on a solution and work backward from there to develop a problem that only their solution can fix and if other citizens and voters don't like it, they are the problem (NIMBY, greedy, selfish, populism, etc).
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by xethos on Thursday February 26, 2026 @11:51PM (#47176668)
Just a note about police overtime: The correct amount of overtime for a union employee is not zero. Paying overtime for a few weeks each year to cover vacation can absolutely be cheaper than funding a pension and other benefits for several decades.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by danudey on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:15PM (#47174353)
So you get 40 years of "sewers cost us almost nothing to maintain woo" and then five years of "sewer maintenance is costing us hundreds of millions of dollars this year".
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by skrtskrt on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:08PM (#47160895)
Take a look at LA’s budget then, it’s literally all police and police liability payouts which are already hundreds of millions of dollars over the budget for them.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ibejoeb on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:47PM (#47159749)
>The people living in SFH don't want to move exactly because they're not generating enough tax revenue to keep the city afloat

So the kernel of the argument is that 1) someone bought a single-family home and based on ground truth (property tax, cost of living, etc.) and 2) that property tax isn't sufficient to fund the city?

Can you really blame someone for not sacrificing his position under these circumstances? If I'm meeting my obligation, what do I stand to gain from leaving my house and moving into an apartment? That's saying "I need you to move so that someone else can take your property." It's not going to go over well.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by prawn on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:02PM (#47159920)
Zoning changes would generally make your property more value as a baseline. Then you could either stay put, or you could elect to move elsewhere while redeveloping your original place. This is common in Australia.

A common zoning change here is based on street frontage for semi-detached homes - the new ones are still 3-4BR, just attached at the garage and with smaller yards. If development required 15m frontage, but then that changed to 12-13m, that would mobilise a lot of owners to take advantage, though obviously others can just stay as is if they prefer.

It usually happens that an $800k lot value becomes $1m, regardless of the state of the house. The owner can then demolish a decades old house, build two places for $600k, sell one as a new home for $800k-1m to finance the build (and costs of moving out during that phase), and end up in a new house themselves. Often they've sacrificed yard that they found annoying to maintain anyway.

The above can be adjusted where it's possible to build 3-4 on a block, or a larger development of apartments.

Zone changes typically allow change, not force it, surely? An owner can just keep their SFH and large yard if they prefer. What they can't always control and often vote against is the composition of their neighbourhood.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:07PM (#47159966)
>Can you really blame someone for not sacrificing his position under these circumstances?

What? There is a structural deficit problem. The ship is sinking. Complaining about how "we shouldn't have to change anything about the ship" isn't really a reasonable argument. We live on this ship... we have every incentive to make sure it stays above water.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ibejoeb on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:29PM (#47160170)
I still don't get it though. Am I right that the proposition is: voluntarily accept a lower quality of life, or we'll either take your property or let it the neighborhood go to pot until you decide to give it up? People are not going to accept that. Look at the fiasco at defunding the fire department. I'll just patch my own sidewalk. I'm not vacating so that the next guy gets a deal. There's plenty of land. Develop there. Why not?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by jojomodding on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:23PM (#47160593)
The three options you presented are the three available options. There is no fourth. Make a choice.

You might think there is option 4--municipal bankruptcy--but that is just option 2 and 3 combined.

Building buildings somewhere else will not fix your neighborhood.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ibejoeb on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:43PM (#47160729)
I'm not giving you a hard time. I'm saying that I made my choice. I'm going to stay in my home.

I don't really think those are the only three choices, though. The government can fail and be replaced with a new one that will shape things up. Then it'll be replaced by another that thinks it's too big and well off to fail, squander it, and fail. That's the typical cycle.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by imtringued on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:52AM (#47163990)
The problem is that you're camouflaging the implicit position of "I'm going to stay in my home, even if I have to see the world burn." as the seemingly reasonable position "I'm going to stay in my home", while being utterly ignorant to the consequences based on absurd levels of wishful thinking.

You're saying the government is going to fail, but actually it's not really going to fail. Someone is going to bail you out every single time. If the government failed, but I'm still in the house, it didn't fail hard enough. They should get better and more competent at failing. The failure needs to be more absolute and its consequences should be unavoidable. The bare minimum required is that they thoroughly crush my spirit and desire to keep living in this place.

People with a semblance of sanity left in their brain understand that getting the things they want, also means dealing with the associated costs and that if they insist on those things, they also implicitly insist on the costs associated with those things. When people refuse this cost benefit trade off, they will end up losing the things they want.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by afpx on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:32AM (#47165164)
I'm trying to follow this but unclear of the root of the problem. Is it beacause building roads in L.A. is inherantly more expensive than elsewhere? I thought one of the selling points of cities was scale: costs are spread over more people. But, it sounds like road building is cheaper per resident in my small city. Sounds more like a corruption problem.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ibejoeb on Thursday February 26, 2026 @11:59AM (#47168707)
>costs are spread over more people

I'm suggesting that this isn't the actual answer. The thread started with the premise that the city doesn't have enough revenue, and that the way to increase that revenue is to bring in more people who pay more tax. Next, bringing in more people requires more housing, so that requires incentives for developers to displace people residing in SFH so that the can replace those with high density housing. There's a big problem: more people require more services beyond fancy curb cuts, like police, fire, water, electricity, schools, hospitals, etc. That cost that is spread also grows proportionally with the number of people, and you can't ignore that.

On the cost of building roads: there are cement and asphalt plants right in LA city proper, and also in weho and inglewood, among others in the county. LA has a price problem, not a cost problem.

There are more specters, too, which are bound to be political fights. For one, when you dig up a road, there are numerous places that will require displacing very large homeless camps. Now, credit where it's due, LA has shown that it is able to do that sometimes, like around Echo Park, which is the junction of several major thoroughfares like glendale blvd and the 101. Still, these are non-trivial projects that take years.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by amluto on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:06PM (#47159333)
> The marginal cost of a housing unit is vastly higher than the cost of building that unit.

The cost of building a housing unit is rather out of control in LA right now, due to a number of factors. Some of those factors involve permitting, but some involve complexities of complying with building regulation, and there is also insufficient availability of contractors and insufficient availability of labor.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:29PM (#47159564)
The demand is there: https://la.urbanize.city/post/plan-skyline-altering-tower-ab...

The point is that the vast majority of budgetary issues in LA could be solved by just legalizing, and streamlining the production of something as simple as three-story row housing like the kind that's normal in San Francisco (which has a surprisingly good long-term outlook despite their current budget woes).

It's not rocket science here. If you make it easy to build housing, the industry grow to meet demand. If you make it difficult, it will be dominated by a handful of major players who can navigate the process.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by amluto on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:16PM (#47160056)
I recently reviewed a bid from a not-particularly-fancy contractor for nearly $1M to build ~1200 sq ft in an empty lot in Los Angeles. This isn’t just a planning permit probem.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:31PM (#47160660)
Even in cheaper areas without earthquake or hurricane construction codes, minimum $/ft is like $250 (for lowest quality components) and realistically more like $400.

Inflation for materials and labor makes any build incredibly expensive.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by DANmode on Thursday February 26, 2026 @10:24AM (#47167319)
Did you pay it?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by AngryData on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:26PM (#47160620)
Plenty of labor and contractors other places in the US that could be brought in if someone was willing to offer stable work and pay. Even with the out-of-town bonus, many midwestern contractors and laborers would come out to near the same cost as locals because they were already making a fraction the wage out in the midwest.

But non-union construction is known to be unstable even outside construction's general boom-bust cycles and nobody is going to travel 1500 miles away without a contract guaranteeing they will have work/pay past the first 2 weeks. Too many workers have gotten burned being given great offers to travel for work only to get screwed over before they can recuperate their costs. Hell our own President is famous for screwing over construction companies and people just accept it as normal for the industry.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by prawn on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:51PM (#47159795)
In Australia, as zoning changes, developers and owners alike tend to take advantage. If a house was being rented out, they might rebuild as 2-4 homes and rent those out. Otherwise, an owner might rebuild as two semi-detached homes, live in one and sell/rent the second to finance the build. If it is owned by someone who prefers to keep what they have, the next generation might not feel the same. Where there are opportunities, developers (and owners) will find them.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by lelandbatey on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:33PM (#47160669)
If you change the zoning, people will build to take advantage of that more flexible zoning. I own land in the city, I'd absolutely pursue the financing and coordinate the redevelopment of that land if:

- I could make more money

- if the zoning allowed it.

As it is right now, it'd be profitable, but the zoning isn't there for it.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by array_key_first on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @11:05PM (#47161701)
It's trivial in the sense that it's easier than not doing nothing, because rather than create problems what we've actually done is systematically installed impediments to solutions. We only need to remove impediments, and the solution finds itself.

Obviously that's very simplified, but the point is we've built this Tower of Babylon that exists around property value that is completely optional and just makes everything harder.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by wooger on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:28AM (#47163847)
>For existing neighborhoods this means buying dozens of SFH from people who don't want to move.

This is closely coupled to the whole 'grandfathered in to very low property taxes from 50 years ago' problem.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by BariumBlue on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:02PM (#47158637)
To add to what the central city budget problem is - each new piece of street and road in LA has, on average, not paid for itself in terms of increased revenue from taxes or otherwise.

So for each new street widening, new road, and piece of highway capacity, LA was increasing it's financial liability to revenue ratio.

Add over decades all of the street and road construction that LA has done, and it now has a unsustainable amount of road maintenance it's responsible for compared to the amount of revenue it pulls in. I'm having a hard time finding numbers though so please correct me or add numbers if you can find them.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:04PM (#47158666)
Strong Towns has already done the financial analysis for Los Angeles. It's not looking very good: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2025-10-27-ground-zero-l...
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by strictnein on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:38PM (#47161119)
Unless things are really different in California from where I'm at, I find it unlikely that the city is responsible for maintaining state and federal highways.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by amanaplanacanal on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:26AM (#47165763)
At least in my state, state and federal highways are all the responsibility of the state DOT, which is massively subsidized out of general fund tax dollars and federal grants. There have been recent attempts to increase fuel taxes, but they get regularly shut down by the electorate. It's not looking good for highway maintenance, either.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by lokar on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:01PM (#47160406)
The city of Los Angeles is pretty dense.

Also, in 2025 they spent 3 times as much dealing with legal fallout from police misconduct compared to street maintenance.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by GorbachevyChase on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:19PM (#47158857)
I think Chuck Marone and his group make good points but their admonition by ASCE is also deserved. He really went too far with disparaging the profession because of differences in purely value judgments. Furthermore, the type of infrastructure you get is a political decision. Civil engineers don’t tell your mayor or your highway commission what to build, their only job is to figure out how it can be built. The “what” is never a designers decision.

Now I think this is a problem with reflecting on. Why is it that given the choice, many people with financial means move away from America’s cities? I did. I promise you the reasons have nothing to do with zoning.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ak217 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:44PM (#47159119)
> Civil engineers don’t tell your mayor or your highway commission what to build, their only job is to figure out how it can be built.

I would disagree. The engineers absolutely steer the space of available solutions. Caltrans is a prime example, I have personally met Caltrans engineers who might as well have stepped out of a time machine from 1970. This absolutely influences the priorities of both the state and the cities that depends on the framework it sets up.

And yes city politics is separately a major problem.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by bsder on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:36PM (#47159622)
> I have personally met Caltrans engineers who might as well have stepped out of a time machine from 1970.

This is the problem with outsourcing everything in the name of "efficiency".

If you don't actually do things in house, you don't know how to do them.

Everybody wants the US to manufacturer and build more until they have to cut a check.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:23PM (#47158916)
Not liking Chuck Marone is irrelevant. The question is whether or not the thesis is correct, and it seems correct.

Everyone hates Nassim Taleb and he can be an asshole, but his math is impeccable. When your concern is with someone's personality because you don't like their math, then you've lost the plot.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by saghm on Thursday February 26, 2026 @05:13PM (#47172715)
Personality is not relevant when determining if someone is correct or not, but it does empirically matter in terms of how likely someone is to get something done based on that. If you think being right is the only thing that should matter, you've achieved your goal already once you reach that step, so congrats! If you agree that it's not the success criteria, it makes sense to start paying attention to those other factors, or else you'll end up only being right and not successful.

I'd argue that if these issues are important to you, and you want to convince people, you'll be more effective if you find a more compelling argument than "you aren't allowed to care about what you just told me you care about".

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by xxpor on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:27PM (#47158950)
>I promise you the reasons have nothing to do with zoning.

I am willing to guess they probably did, even if it doesn't seem directly related.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:37PM (#47160689)
The engineers are a big part of the problem and drive regulations that featherbed themselves.

I got into a fight with my city over nonexistent crosswalks (the adhesive line strips wore off) near my home in an area where drivers have a hard time realizing where pedestrians cross due to a unique road setup.

You can’t just paint lines. The project ended up costing about $1.2M and required a traffic study, some stupid ADA assessment and accommodation that frankly any layperson could have figured out, and a complete streets assessment.

Basically, they sent out a few engineering technicians who make $20/hr, billed out 80 hours at $120 to count cars and people, and printed some boilerplate analysis (@$250/hr). The end result was they painted new crosswalks and added textured curb surfaces for ADA compliance, which allowed for the use of recovery act funds.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by GorbachevyChase on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:14PM (#47160938)
I love a good rant, but you just have no idea what you’re talking about. First, real engineers (the kind with, education and experience requirements and personal liability for their work) have labor markups that are maybe 2 to 3 times raw rate. I don’t know if 6X margins are normal for people who collect a check to “maintain” a finished product. Second, any civil engineer will tell you that complete streets compliance for federal funding is a waste of everyone’s time. Engineers didn’t come up with that, congressmen elected by people like you came up with that. Third, the only reason they did all of that study is because the people you voted for wanted to use money that was tax farmed from me instead of your city funds. They could have just sent out a road crew. You could also cut the check yourself. Finally marked crosswalks alter pedestrian behavior, but not driver behavior. Marking crosswalks where there is high traffic and no controls like a signal with a dedicated pedestrian phase are actually more dangerous than no markings at all. I don’t expect you to know that, but that’s why you should hire people like me and not try to do this yourself.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by gamblor956 on Friday February 27, 2026 @03:47PM (#47185372)
A late addition to your comment: the reason for all the "wasteful" red tape was that the right demanded all the documentation to prove that the underlying activity itself was not wasteful...thus imposing extra costs on everything that resulted in is several magnitudes more waste.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Spooky23 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:18PM (#47197794)
In fairness, I should have said "engineering companies" vs. engineers. Like any scenario, the engineers themselves have to work in the scope they are allowed to. Those firms absolutely lobbied our state legislature for all sorts of things that generate make-work revenue for them. Most of the proof of work is farmed off to low dollar employees.

In this particular scenario, it's an usual configuration that can't be changed for a bunch of reasons. There are functional, adequate controls that were added about 15 years ago and were not altered by the project I'm thinking about. The crosswalks and lane markings are essential because drivers tend to stop at the wrong place.

While we may have been getting rope-a-doped, our neighborhood association was willing to contribute a pretty significant amount of money to have the city do the work. Our position was that it was becoming a dangerous intersection with significant pedestrian traffic. We were told it was illegal for the city dpw to do so without the study work.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by gamblor956 on Friday February 27, 2026 @03:40PM (#47185296)
Why is it that given the choice, many people with financial means move away from America’s cities?

This is actually generally the opposite of true. SFV is heavily Republican. Given the choice, self-made individuals prefer to live in or near blue cities despite the high taxes, because the lifestyle is objectively better than it is in the areas around red cities.

Indeed, a not-so-hidden secret of Fox News is that almost all of their anchors and personalities actually live in LA or NYC. (This is why Fox News personalities are so familiar with and obsessed with LA's problems. They're locals.) The Murdochs, for all their money prefer Los Angeles and NYC as their U.S. bases over no-tax states like Florida and Texas.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by harrall on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:55PM (#47159232)
Not true.

California is doing a ton of things to create housing — just look at the many state bills that have passed in a span of 2-3 years: https://cayimby.org/legislation/?_filter_by_status=signed

Sure, some cities are resisting or having trouble but even the state is overriding them with state policies.

It’s just going to take time between passing bills, incentives lining up, and getting money for building homes. That’s also why the state has focused on ADUs too — because individuals can get through a whole decision process to develop housing quicker than a big developer can. ADUs have a lot of problems but the state knows this and is attacking the issue on both short and long term scales.

You don’t just steer the 4th largest economy in the world. It’s built like a steakhouse and steers like one.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:03PM (#47159311)
Scott Wiener is my state senator. My point is exactly that many California cities are being forced to allow density, instead of just coming to that conclusion because it's a responsible one.

They don't want it, even if they need it. They're kicking and screaming and doing anything they can to stop it, while at the same time their city budgets are in the toilet. The only thing that's actually driving this reform is that housing prices are out of control, so you have a large demographics of people fighting to increase density.

Where this is not happening is everywhere else (think: Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Virginia, Arizona). Those areas don't have the same demand for density, but they still have the same long-term structural deficit problems.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by throwaway-11-1 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:06PM (#47159336)
I've been shocked by how much my rural / politically red city (pop ~80k) here in California has moved on this issue over the last 5 years. Doubled the allowed meters per lot, super relaxed ADU rules and city + developer funded 5 over 1's in the renovated city center for some impressive density. Also all the new construction for restaurants or whatever in the area requires adding apartments above. Not to mention a massive initiative for safe bike paths from the commercial areas to the park trails. They also bought some longtime closed hotels and converted them to housing for homeless. Really big stuff and huge quality of life improvements.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by csdreamer7 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:11PM (#47158758)
> California cities could trivially fix their budget problems by satisfying the demand for housing by adding density, but it seems they are determined to do nothing until the wheels finally fall off, and the city's budget crisis spirals out of control.

The state of California already mandated certain density improvements:

https://calmatters.org/housing/2025/10/newsom-signs-massive-...

There is another law that mandated local communities plan to manage housing to accommodate population growth or the local community loses it's ability to deny permits. Struggling to find that but it was well before 2025 I believe.

The more likely reasons is corruption and paying off rising CalPERS costs:

https://californiapolicycenter.org/repeat-pension-history/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/public-pensions-in-californ...

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:14PM (#47158797)
I live in CA. My state senator is Scott Wiener. We are making some progress.

Your argument might be plausible if it weren't for the fact that this issue is happening -- predictably -- in every major sprawling city in America. Strong Towns has literally built a tool to effectively convert cities' cash-accounting budgets into accrual-accounting budgets. You can see it happening over time... you just need to account for the future liabilities in the way you look at your budget instead of ignoring them until it's time to replace the infrastructure.

https://www.strongtowns.org/decoder

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by xenadu02 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:44PM (#47159130)
Indeed, the problem is the same in Texas which is about as opposite California as you can get. Sprawling suburbs over old farm fields. Installing infrastructure is vastly cheaper when you are doing so in an unoccupied empty field.

None of those cities are saving money or even _planning_ for the inevitable repaving, pipe re-lining, etc. Worse: many of them were built up in waves so much of the city's infrastructure will "come due" around the same time.

I never imagined we would see San Francisco (of all places) overhaul its permit process. I can now build a deck in my backyard, add a story to my house, or build an ADU without having to pay DBI to send certified letters to all my neighbors asking if they'd like to object, then being forced in front of the planning commission when they do so. That's a direct result of the pro-housing legislation at the state level, something Wiener has been heavily involved in.

[dead]
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by hn_acc1 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:37PM (#47159060)
I think CA has bigger issues to tackle than repealing Prop 65 (IIRC, that's the one about carcinogen warnings). The other, may be happening in some places, but having lived here 20+ years in the Bay, I haven't seen even one example of either.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by GorbachevyChase on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:43PM (#47160726)
I saw all of these things driving through Sacramento twice. I think you’re probably just being dishonest or maybe you are in an are in an area where undesirables are priced out and you don’t leave your house.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by varenc on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:49PM (#47160771)
Any examples of the Strong Towns finance decoder already filled in for major cities?

edit: nevermind, found lots of example here! https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?mid=1iV3NEJqsY0y8N1...

sadly lots of the big cities I was interested not included. Guessing with these it's more difficult to get the input numbers.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by organsnyder on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:15PM (#47158807)
Those policies will take decades to make a difference in road costs, though—if they do at all (infill is often very hard to get financed).
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by toast0 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:19PM (#47159456)
> replacing your wastewater system costs money... lots of money. The fact that they only have to be replaced every 30-50 years doesn't mean the costs go away... they just disappear temporarily. Deferring that maintenance doesn't actually do anything except make the problem worse tomorrow.

I kind of disagree. Deferring maintenance does make emergency repairs more likely, but if you need to replace your sewer piping (for example) every 30-50 years, doing it at 33 year intervals means three installs in 100 years, and doing at 50 years means two installs in 100 years.

As long as you don't push the deferral so long that you end up having emergency repairs and remediation of significant leaks, deferring maintenance reduces the burdens of maintenance.

You do need to invest more in surveillance if you want to run your installed infrastructure longer, but surveillance is a good practice regardless, because sometimes 30-50 year infrastructure fails early. For sewers, the idea is camera inspections of all the municipal lines every 3-5 years to generate a prioritized list of maintenance/replacement projects; do the work as budget allows, rinse and repeat. Older sewer systems will benefit from more frequent inspections and newer systems can get by with less. You really shouldn't fully eliminate inspections on new systems, because earth movement and early material failure due to manufacturing error don't always happen on your schedule.

That said, a lot of sewers were initially installed in the post war boom times of the 1950s and deferred maintenance is coming due -- many portions may have been replaced as needed, but a lot of original pipes are hitting 70+ years of service life and are likely nearing the end of their life. There's an argument to be made that if they had been replaced at their forecast service life, things would be better now ... but that really just brings forward the next replacement.

IMHO, The City of Los Angeles really should be multiple municipalities. The boundary is pretty wonky, in part to capture the port of Los Angeles and Los Angeles International Airport, but also downtown vs San Fernando Valley; and that has got to make a lot of administration stuff significantly harder than if it were multiple geographically focused municipalities.

> California cities could trivially fix their budget problems by satisfying the demand for housing by adding density

I agree that density is likely the right way forward, but I don't think it's trivial. Especially since organic density increases have been suppressed for so long, it's helpful to coordinate rapid increases in density so that dense housing lands in places with appropriate transit and other services; but coordination is difficult.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by amluto on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:02PM (#47159294)
> lack of density

One interesting question: what is "density"? Is it number of people per road-mile? Number of households? Structures? Sales tax revenue? Property tax revenue? Property value per road mile?

LA has somewhat insane property values right now, and by the metric of millions of dollars of residential value per road-mile, I think one might imagine the density to be sufficient to afford decent streets. Of course, that does not translate to municipal budgets or even to disposable income of the owners or the residents in those properties.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:11PM (#47159379)
The Strong Towns argument is effectively talking about density as tax-revenue per road mile liability, and trying to keep that positive. Areas with high liabilities (sewer, water, buried electric, fiber, etc.) need to have higher tax-revenue per mile (more people, more businesses, etc) to support that infrastructure.

There are other ways around this though. If you force your citizens to maintain their own septic and well water (or even small-pipe potable water), and have unsurfaced roads, then you can do with much less revenue-per-road mile.

The point is that the federal government usually pays for the infrastructure up from (as an "investment"), but when that subsidized infrastructure is a net money-loser in the long run, cities growing actually makes the problem worse.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by skrtskrt on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:12PM (#47160927)
Tax revenue per area is generally a good metric in terms of the sustainability of a municipal budget. Very few suburbs in the world have enough people density to clear that bar, no matter how much they tax them. More people density lets you clear the bar so much easier even when the incomes are drastically lower.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by bradchris on Thursday February 26, 2026 @11:50AM (#47168571)
Fundamentally the issue, aside from lack of density, is Prop 13. In LA, and every other part of California, your tax rate will get frozen (forever, essentially) at what you buy your home for. So you have some people who now have a $7m home paying taxes as if it were $300k, because they bought it in 1978.

With a setup like that, of course SFHs, no matter how high they’re valued, will not provide enough tax revenue on their own

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by dccoolgai on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:07PM (#47158713)
50 years ago, the U.S. was a nation that _made things_ whereas today it's primarily people conference calling and making slide decks for each other (perhaps not for long, given the progress of LLMs). What if that's the real underlying problem and not how many layers of people we can stack on top of each other in a small space?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by davidw on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:40PM (#47159086)
Ironically, "how to stack dwelling units vertically in high-demand areas" is one of those things we seem to not be so good at _making_ these days.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by socalgal2 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:06PM (#47159344)
I'm of multiple minds about this. I like high density. I like a car-less lifestyle of the last 30 years I lived without a car.

That said, currently I live in West LA. Traffic is atrocious! Doubling or tripling density will make it even worse, probably exponentially worse. Adding non-car transit options just isn't in the cards in any reasonable time frame because of all the people that block construction and because the USA, like most countries, refuses to setup a win-win situation for transit (like Japan) and instead continues to insist it be government based and therefore most likely to go over budget during construction and then under budgeted during operation.

At the same time, I wish our entire coast was 30-50 story high-rises. It's ridiculous to me that only a few elites get to view the ocean from their homes on the coast and everyone else is shut out because no one is allowed to build the high-rises.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by outside1234 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:38PM (#47159066)
A number of cities in Northern California are doing just this. We have at least 12 high density projects being built in Santa Cruz and we are a small city.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Teever on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:05PM (#47158674)
I've been thinking recently about how with the impending demographics crunch hitting a lot of countries soonish you're going to see a sort of day of reckoning for municipalities that were run poorly in the past because people will just move to ones that that don't have horrible budget and infrastructure deficits and the one sthat do will just shrivel up and die.

Tha perpetually increasing population growth is no more and that means no more growing tax base to paper over terrible decisions to pass them onto another generation.

For the first time in a long while we're looking at actual, real selection pressures on municiptalities.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by throwpoaster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:59PM (#47158570)
Once I became a Dad, getting socks for Christmas suddenly turned into one of the most thoughtful gifts possible. A self-care item. The flip was very sudden and surprising.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:00PM (#47158605)
I actually chose "socks for Christmas" as a metaphor because the types of people who like socks for Christmas are grown-ups, and grown-ups tend to actually view municipal finance as important and interesting.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:05PM (#47158686)
so the story is about a silly law requiring bike lanes and handicap curbs and your proposal is to kick everyone out of their homes and remigrate them into the cities?

ADA code is insanely expensive. We did a couple blocks of those silly dimple ramps for $250,000 . You could hire every blind person in town a personal guide for less than it would be to ADA all the side walks.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by scoofy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:09PM (#47158738)
I suspect you don't understand how serious the problem is. The problem isn't "we need to add bike lanes." The problem is that the streets have to be repaved anyway and if the city can't afford to simply bring them up to code in the short run, then they can't afford to keep repaving them at all in the long run.

The sidewalks are going to have to be completely replaced eventually... not just the sections that need ramps. Right now the city can't afford to replaces just the ramp sections.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:38PM (#47159070)
"the code" is the issue. This isn't building code like protecting earthquakes, electrical, fire safety. When people hear "the code" -- they think critical safety measures.

Activists came up with a doorjamb law to require bike lanes, ADA and road diets on every block that receives repair. That's just not practical in LA. You can't punish drivers into riding a bike to work.

this is coming from someone who biked and bussed to work in LA for 10+ years.

It's reckless policy that will only undermine your efforts and never reach the desired outcome.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ak217 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:05PM (#47160881)
As someone who has biked and rode trains to work for the past 30 years and continues to do so, I think requiring bike lanes whenever streets are repaved is a pretty awesome idea. ADA ramps are pretty great too, they are not just for disabled people, though the ADA lawsuit regime where private companies get sued needs to stop.

Yes I understand there is a funding issue, it needs to be solved by making the design and approval process more flexible and efficient, not by perpetuating the insane car-only design that kills pedestrians and cyclists.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Thursday February 26, 2026 @02:13PM (#47170650)
Awesome ideas are not often practical
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ak217 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @06:46PM (#47174031)
Oh it's quite practical, many cities have done it. It just requires standing up to a bunch of selfish assholes who would rather pave over every bit of available space so they can drive around really fast in their giant SUVs while pedestrians and cyclists scurry about on the broken pavement of the 5% of the street right of way given to them, and get run over when they don't get out of the way of the SUVs fast enough.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:10PM (#47174300)
this attitude really helps improve cyclists' reputation.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ak217 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:50PM (#47174749)
To be honest with you I really don't give a shit about my reputation when it comes to this, I care about me and my kids not getting splatted by a speeding SUV when we dare to use the street, because I face this situation daily.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:35PM (#47175157)
You'll never succeed with this attitude.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ak217 on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:22PM (#47188720)
Where I live, our work has definitely been successful. The cities I bike in have been steadily improving their bike lane and pedestrian networks, and increasingly prioritizing them in plans and projects - though there is a long way to go.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Mawr on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:45PM (#47188939)
No worries, it's already happening and your resistance to the status quo changing is expected and accounted for.

Try to bike to work sometime — it's good for the soul. And your health of course.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:08PM (#47198393)
How smug of you.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Mawr on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:17PM (#47188677)
What attitude do you expect from marginalized groups? Suffragists, slaves? Ring a bell?

If you think I'm exaggerating or something, I'm really not. You were born into a world already bulldozed for cars so you literally can't imagine an alternative reality. You're broken — can't see the world for what it is objectively.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:09PM (#47198412)
Are rollerbladers marginalized? Cross country skiers ? It’s a hobby. This isn’t a civil rights movement, and it’s insulting to call cyclists “marginalized” like blacks , women and gays were.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by moss_dog on Thursday February 26, 2026 @01:09AM (#47162478)
It's interesting that you frame building bike lanes and reducing car speeds as "punishing drivers", seemingly ignoring that such changes enable micro-mobility users to commute to work safely.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Thursday February 26, 2026 @02:15PM (#47170689)
That’s what it is . Remove capacity, increase travel times , increase driver frustration and in theory increase cycling and public transit. But the second part never happens . Travel times have been increasing for 40 years and cycling is still a fringe hobby
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by Mawr on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:30PM (#47188806)
Removing car capacity by 50% and adding 1000% bike capacity at 1% of the cost is good, actually. It's not really 1000% of course, it's infinity% — the average cyclist is not capable of cycling on the roadway, so a bike lane literally enables them to do the activity at all; the value is immeasurable.

That you think cycling is a hobby is exactly the issue. I don't get to work by bike as a hobby, I do it to get to work, and get all the benefits of cycling at the same time. Win-win.

It's also quite deluded to think the USA has been putting non-negligible effort towards improving cycling for the last 40 years, to the point that you'd notice any difference in car traffic. Hate to bring it to you, but the reason traffic's getting worse is there are more and more cars, but there's only so much space and cars scale horribly. Hence, bikes and public transportation. Those scale exceptionally well and are the perfect solution for 95% of all city trips.

The USA is in 99.9% designed for cars. You're essentially complaining that the most dominant mode of transport is getting mildly deprioritized and is on the path to being only 99% dominant. Cry me a river.

Oh, and the reason you drive a car and not say, use public transport, is that for the last 50+ years the USA has invested into car infrastructure instead of public transport. So the car is not a mode of transport that you have chosen, that you prefer, that you like, it's one that was forced upon you. That you can't see it is somewhat hilarious, but really — just sad.

Just ask yourself: Do you have any other real choice than to own a car and drive everywhere?

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by bmitc on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:22PM (#47158895)
Why does it cost so much?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by tonymet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:40PM (#47159095)
all the typical reasons, largesse, govt contractors, consultants, insurance , regulations, inflation etc etc.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by beastman82 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:45PM (#47159140)
Unions too
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by mikkupikku on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:39PM (#47159080)
We just need one more bike lane bro, then people will start using them for sure.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by doctorpangloss on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:04PM (#47160875)
this is coming from someone who lives in san francisco like you and has a 2 kid, 4 adult family with no car. it's been like 80 years of USA = cars. people seem to really like SFH + cars, they vote for it, they pay for it, and seem to accept even longer commutes than ever. consider why. it's not so simple.

> Strong Towns thesis is correct... slow moving crisis... The idea that LA literally can't afford to bring it's sidewalks up to ADA code is insane

see, this tells me you're not getting it at all. it is an insult to process, yes. But there's no crisis. Strong Towns is kind of obviously wrong.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by imtringued on Thursday February 26, 2026 @05:09AM (#47164090)
The entire point by Strong Towns is that people don't pay for it.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by doctorpangloss on Thursday February 26, 2026 @02:20PM (#47170741)
i like their positions. but. i don't know what the point of strong towns is. people feel very strongly (haha) about it.

i can advocate for all sorts of stuff that is unpopular. it's meaningless. this is the hard thing about advocacy! strong towns spends a lot of words on stuff, but none of it on why someone who is happy with SFH cars lifestyle do, whatever it is they are asking that person to do.

> The entire point by Strong Towns is that people don't pay for it.

okay, people aren't paying for the ADA stuff. that's bad. but it's not a crisis. SFH cars people are living in that status quo every day. and it's not because they don't care and or because they are not disabled. i don't know how much the ramp codes really matter, i am not an expert, i understand that some experts in some narrow sense say they matter, but the real problem is a lack of leadership on holistic, bigger-picture issues like how to balance the costs and benefits of these sorts of requirements. we arrive at that cost-benefit organically right now, over and over again, in the absence of leadership, and most people seem pretty happy with it, which is a huge refutation of what strong towns is saying. do you get it?

strong towns says, "paying for this shit that doesn't matter does matter", which is wrong!

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by b112 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @10:08AM (#47167126)
This always grinds my gears (pun intended). Forcing everyone to live in a horribly dense, stifling, unhealthy situation isn't the issue. And the concept of saying LA isn't dense enough is beyond mind boggling, the number of people living there is beyond absurd. And yes, I know it's spread out, but the numbers don't lie, there's already more density than many places.

What this really is, is backdoor environmentalism. And I say that as someone that wants emissions down, reduced carbon, but a cat is a cat. And focusing on density to remove cars, because certain segments of the population rail against cars, isn't the problem people claim they are trying to solve.

For the roads? The easy way to pay for the roads, is to tax gas appropriately, and then ensure that tax only pays for roads. Nothing else, roads.

The second? Very clear end of year municipal budgets, showing how those funds were used.

Eventually, you'll reach a situation where the gas tax is the cost of road maintenance. And that's how it should be.

Back to the overall question? Well, I suppose you have quakes in LA, but outside of that concept, the US south is just about the easiest place to maintain roads.

In Canadaland, we have road damage due to freezing and thawing. Frost greaves for example, are where water gets under the pavement, freezes, and breaks it upward as the ice expands. No amount of drainage can fully protect from this, it just happens. And the cost for daily snow removal, ice mitigation(salt, etc), dirt being spread, the same for all the sidewalks isn't free.

LA has none of that. The US south doesn't, generally speaking.

LA doesn't have a road problem. It doesn't have a revenue problem. It has absurd infighting, like the entire rest of the US, with team politics and an inability to act as a result. It also has poor fiscal constraint.

Smaller LA side roads should last decades with proper maintenance.

But that's part of the problem too.

A tiny crack can be sealed, but leave it a year and it becomes a pothole.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by ibejoeb on Thursday February 26, 2026 @12:06PM (#47168799)
All true. There's also a perverse incentive in getting involved in LA. It's a major market where overly ambitious people go to make bigger names for themselves. Their goals are not aligned with operating the city; it's a stepping stone to CA and the national stage. Most major markets have this problem, of course, but LA is at the top.
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by laurencerowe on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:11PM (#47172050)
LA is much less dense than Canadian cities. Taking the central municipalities which seem fairly comparable:

Toronto: 3.271M in 631 km2 = 5184/km2

Los Angeles: 3.879M in 1215 km2 = 3192/km2

Toronto's population is growing, up 17% 2021 to 2025, while Los Angeles is marginally down 0.5% 2020 to 2024.

Even smaller cities in Canada seem much more dense than their Californian equivalents, and they are more pleasant and walkable/cycleable because of that.

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by b112 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:59PM (#47172527)
Isn't half of LA mountains, beach, and water?
Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by KellyCriterion on Thursday February 26, 2026 @02:41PM (#47171023)
In one word:

Neoliberalism.

(and too much cars, of course)

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by learingsci on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:19PM (#47172138)
> California cities could trivially fix their budget problems by satisfying the demand for housing by adding density

I just wonder if that isn’t a totally naive, laughably unthinking remark to be making?

Re:Why isn't LA repaving streets? by enaaem on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:24AM (#47179246)
And people expect trains and metros to pay for themselves. Car infrastructure maintenance is bankrupting the government. And on top of that you have the opportunity cost of all the road and parking space.