News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dvrp on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:11AM (#45370066)
Paul Graham Essay and early YC: live your life, don’t start a company in your 20s. You are young only once.

Post Paul Graham YC: reserve your YC spot now. There’s no downside!

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by Maro on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:44AM (#45370252)
I can't quite put my finger on it, but this announcement gives me bad vibes.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by gjgtcbkj on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:10AM (#45370739)
They just want warm bodies. Why else would they focus on people that don’t have experience?
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by epolanski on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:04AM (#45371055)
Neither experience nor hard skills, let alone soft ones.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by gjgtcbkj on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:49AM (#45371376)
Something tells me the business is became the product.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by theplatman on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:51AM (#45370965)
For awhile now I’ve felt like YC has turned into another badge for the type people who are obsessed with prestige. It’s all about checking a box and not about the substance of what they want to do.

This is evident in how disappointed certain people are when they’re rejected from YC. Their startup is merely a vehicle to get into the club.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by mnky9800n on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:53AM (#45371404)
Better to start our own club then.

All things have a life cycle. Despite what yc wants you to believe, it will come and go. Perhaps it’s becoming a prestige institution in the hopes to increase its longevity.

That being said, belonging to a group is a central component of being a human as we are highly social animals. So it’s not wrong to want to belong to a group and then being sad when you are rejected. It requires a lot of maturity and stoicism to cut your own path. This is somewhat ironic since traditionally founding your own company is considered cutting your own path but I think yc and others have made it much less so. There is a formula now to follow which is why there is now an in group and an out group. Cutting your own path by definition does not include a set formula.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by epolanski on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:04AM (#45371046)
Asking people without experience, skills and maturity to know what they want in their life to commit to YC way before graduating comes off as simply too much.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by this_user on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:14AM (#45371137)
Interestingly, this mirrors the kind of thing that has been happening in finance, especially in private equity. Normally, you start out at an investment bank, do two years as an analyst there, learn the basics, then make a choice whether you want to stay in IB or move to PE (or somewhere else).

Eventually, PE started recruiting earlier and earlier to the point where they were hiring college graduates for two years in the future who hadn't even started their IB role. Obviously, these people don't even know what they like doing, and you have no idea if they are any good at their job.

The end result was Jamie Dimon of JPM slamming his fist on the table to knock it off. This has led other banks to follow suit and major PE firms to commit to stop recruiting this early. At least for now.

But it seems that something similar is now happening on the VC side.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by ulfw on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:32AM (#45371265)
It's all about riding that idiotic AI bubble until the huge burst
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by fud101 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:42AM (#45372552)
PG has always been a grifter. He takes advantage of impressionable folk and uses their naivety to boost his own brand. He unmasked himself fully right before the last election with his anti woke hit piece.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by bko on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:42AM (#45371329)
I think a few things:

Wanting to finish school is a negative signal. Also

> Also we know that many students spend a lot of time in Fall or during their final year applying for jobs or internships. Early Decision gives students another option: apply to YC and bet on yourself.

So now YC is an alternative to searching and apply for jobs? I think if you're marginal on trying to find a corporate job or starting something, then you should prob find a corp job. Objectively starting a startup is worse, you work harder, lower odds of success, more stress, less money, etc. You have to be a little crazy and hardheaded to make it work

Finally everything that YC does to increase it's applicant pool so they still maintain exclusivity. If you have 2% acceptance rate, why are you trying to maximize the top of the funnel? You should discourage people to apply.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by skeeter2020 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:12AM (#45372277)
honest question: do you think that in a job market where it seems to be ridiculously hard to land that junior corporate job maybe starting your own thing is a increasingly valid alternative? I'm not sure this is aligned with the properties that YC is necessarily shopping for (they seem to compete with companies eager to hire the same people) but maybe if you're a newish grad from a lesser-known school? My sample size of one includes someone who did that in the 90's and built a $B+ valued company.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by majormajor on Thursday September 25, 2025 @12:18PM (#45374766)
VC investment has rebounded but it's also been extremely concentrated in AI in the last couple of years.

"Starting your own thing" in a vc-backed way (need a big exit, or bust) as a fresh college grad who now has to come up with a thing and sell it to a lot of customers within a couple of years sounds incredibly hard.

Especially when framed as "you won't have to look for a job" - not having the hustle skills to be at the top of the pack in the job-hunt vs your classmates doesn't really give a good signal for your hustle-and-build-and-sell-a-VC-startup alternative.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dheera on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:02PM (#45375531)
> Wanting to finish school is a negative signal

No. This sounds like VC trash advice and very bad career advice.

Startup chances of success are <5%, and many of the factors are beyond your control. A degree is still relevant in being able to easily get interviews and secure jobs, in the >95% case that you do not succeed on the first try.

I'd only recommend dropping out if you see mad traction and revenue and you are on a trajectory to be famous enough that people won't care if you don't have a degree. If you're still a "nobody", it's a really, really bad idea.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by floriferous on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:43AM (#45371337)
Exactly the same feeling here, it's such a strange thing to promise a kid they are accepted into a program, but it starts in like 4 years.

As if all of your education (and probably side-projects, life decisions) is meant to lead to YC.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by estearum on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:13AM (#45372291)
> Also, if you're not in your final year, you can still apply for Early Decision. You'll be able to finish the school year you're currently in,

It's a one-year early decision, like pretty much every other early decision program.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by DonHopkins on Thursday September 25, 2025 @07:04AM (#45371463)
I have been thoroughly enjoying re-watching HBO's Silicon Valley, appreciating all the little details and sub-plots I missed during my first watching long ago. It's aged so well.

It's telling how many people are afraid to watch that show and detest it because it's just so spot on accurate, and they cringe when they see themselves in its characters and their own lives in its plots.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by skeeter2020 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:20AM (#45372342)
I love the show and rewatch it often, but if you lived in that world during the show's timeframe you can see it's changed draamtically. It still holds up as the "vision" of what we thought a SW startup looks like, but the reality is these scrappy little altruistic startups are not lead by hands-on tech founders, they're all taking the money today - often from PE - and are already the people from the show we laughed at. Show a member of a YC25 class SV today and they'll think Gavin Belson is a "how-to" tutorial.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by DonHopkins on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:58AM (#45372703)
I agree, it's gotten much much worse, especially with all the MAGA/Trump/Musk/Thiel boot licking.

It's prime time for Silicon Valley: AI Bubble. Instead of hiring the original actors or artists or writers, it could be ironically AI animated in the style of South Park, with a storyline about infringing on copyright and intellectual property, and putting actors and artists and programmers out of work.

I wonder what kind of company names would Erlich Bachman come up with on ketamine instead of shrooms?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXqkkpnZDgU

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by ClimaxGravely on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:58PM (#45376419)
I suspect Erlich might have died of an opium overdose at this point.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by gghffguhvc on Thursday September 25, 2025 @08:21AM (#45371946)
The number of people we are talking about as a percentage of CS like graduates is tiny. They aren’t kids either. It seems like a low risk experiment on both sides.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by josfredo on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:18AM (#45370098)
Whatever statement is more relatable at the time hence better for their business.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by shafyy on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:50AM (#45370294)
Gives me weirdo Thiel vibes who pays (or used to pay) kids to drop out of college and start a company for him.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by sungam on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:02AM (#45370699)
In fairness, while I’m sure it didn’t work out for all of them, one of these students became one of the youngest self made billionaires in history
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by flkenosad on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:05AM (#45370710)
He did it to the smartest kid in our CS class. I feel bad now because I feel like he deserves a degree.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by ohyoutravel on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:51AM (#45371391)
A classmate of mine dropped out to do this. Failed, and ended up picking up later to finish the last two years of college. It really didn’t seem to have slowed them down, and finishing college a few years later (with some startup founders experience) seems to have been overall good. Unfortunately did end up going to Boston Consulting Group from on-campus recruiting, so not a great end to the story, but historically that’s a high-ish paying and hard to get job.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by skeeter2020 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:22AM (#45372362)
I get the feeling only very affluent and well-supported people follow this path, and they probably don't need THiel's money to do it. The vast majority don't have a few years at this stage of their life to play the lottery.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:10AM (#45372810)
Yeah, I hung out with one of the early batches of these people (my former supervisor was involved) and would agree that they tended to be from better off families. How much of that was the Ivy league selection bias vs anything else I dunno though.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by cinntaile on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:09AM (#45371100)
He'll receive plenty of opportunities regardless of degree so I don't see why you feel sorry for him.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by flkenosad on Thursday September 25, 2025 @07:03AM (#45371458)
He would have made a fantastic professor in my opinion. But I think also, certain opportunities just require a degree on a policy level.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by shafyy on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:01AM (#45371025)
Doesn't mean that this was a good thing for them. For example, many kid actors who become rich and famous are not happy.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by squigz on Thursday September 25, 2025 @08:01AM (#45371823)
I mean... is it self-made if a billionaire helped you?
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by Thorrez on Thursday September 25, 2025 @08:25AM (#45371975)
It seems kind of the opposite to me. YC is allowing you to finish school. You don't need to drop out.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by DonHopkins on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:21AM (#45372943)
Or weirdo Russ Hanneman vibes who bought a company called The Lady so he could use his phone as a parental remote control to raise his kid with AI:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGy5SGTuAGI&t=217s

A company I'm funding, we call it The Lady.

I press the button, and The Lady tells Aspen when it's time for bed, time to take a bath, when his fucking mother's here to pick him up.

I get to be his friend, and she's the bad guy.

I've disrupted fatherhood!

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by doctorpangloss on Thursday September 25, 2025 @12:03PM (#45374529)
another POV is two people who are willing to risk a lot of money on pre-seed stage companies - no traction, only people and an idea - have arrived at a lot of the same mechanics for such investing

the better question is: how do these two investors differentiate themselves?

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by keiferski on Thursday September 25, 2025 @04:13AM (#45370438)
Honestly I think there are two different audiences. The type of person that is open to traveling, exploring jobs, etc. in their twenties is different from the “institutional pipeline” track of good high school > good college > good job.

This early decision thing is functionally going to move a few pipeline kids from the corporate world to the startup world, which probably isn’t a terrible outcome. But it also reflects how YC has become a marker of institutional pipeline success for a lot of people.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by skeeter2020 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:23AM (#45372372)
it's unclear to me which track you think YC runs on - stuffy corporate or hip & edgy explorer?
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by keiferski on Thursday September 25, 2025 @11:39AM (#45374119)
I wouldn't use either of those labels, more like...it is becoming / is already tied into the institutional definition of success. 15 years ago, it was still kind of unorthodox to turn down a BigTech job and start a company instead. Nowadays it's starting to feel like another credential or routine path that smart tech-adjacent people take.

IMO if you're trying to decide between a well-paid job and starting a company...you probably aren't cut out to start a company. But...the infrastructure for choosing the latter option is becoming developed and safe enough that realistically speaking, it may actually be the optimal non-entrepreneurial career choice.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by csomar on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:17AM (#45370777)
2030: YC kindergarten pre-preparation and selection program.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by penguin_booze on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:58AM (#45371429)
2031: Pregnant mothers are encouraged to signup their child before they're even born. No pressure.

2032: Sperm scan available for teenage boys for future child's YC eligibility.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by mnky9800n on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:54AM (#45371406)
They can make it just like tennis!
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by danielfalbo on Thursday September 25, 2025 @05:52AM (#45370969)
For whoever wants to re-read one of the articles that mentions the idea, there you go: https://paulgraham.com/before.html#f7n:~:text=You%20can%20do...
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dang on Thursday September 25, 2025 @02:17PM (#45376704)
What that article says is "don't start a startup in college". That is what pg has always said, and is not at all what the GP comment imputes to him.

More at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45375715.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by pclmulqdq on Thursday September 25, 2025 @08:45AM (#45372087)
As startup valuations have gone up quickly and the YC offer largely remains the same, YC has naturally moved downmarket. They have gone from being an exclusive, premium product aimed at people who have a serious chance of building a unicorn to a finishing school for venture-backed entrepreneurs. In my opinion, this is a great thing for YC because it's a more natural fit for their main value proposition, but it also means that the best time to do modern YC is essentially straight out of school.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by skeeter2020 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:08AM (#45372243)
I don't think this is a valuations vs. stagnant offer scenario. I think it has more to do with YC scaling up from dozens to hundreds and thousands of investments in a very competitive landscape. From a few early successes when no one was doing what they did, to having way more money to invest than there are good ideas and now it's spray & pray; trade on the YC name and with some luck hope there's a pay-off. If we start with the apocryphal "VCs look for 1 in 10 home runs", well the earliest YC classes only had like ten in a batch, so they had the time, energy and NEED to have a success. YC added a lot of partners who had a successful exit - or didn't - and surprise, they look like every other VC partner in the industry, at least minus the identical headshots in navy blue suits.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by vessenes on Thursday September 25, 2025 @12:58PM (#45375440)
This was absolutely Paul's strategy -- read his essay reflecting on returns from their early portfolio (AirBnB and Dropbox). His take -- "we should have done another 1000 investments to get a third hit" (coinbase, it turns out. And he was correct).

The math for YC's seed stage returns is overall inexorably towards more checks being written - the checks are incredibly cheap. YC's IRR is currently roughly 176%, yielding an 81,000x return since 2005 -- another way to say it: a single $25k investment from 2005 could be deployed into 81,000 $25k investments in 2026. Or another way to say it, for every check they wrote, they're able to write another check off that investment every 8 months, compounding all the way back.

YC's main problem is that there aren't 81,000 even slightly viable startups in the world. It's true they've lost their "exclusive" vibe, but to be honest, when they started it was more "small and quirky" which briefly became "gold standard exclusive." It was never their original brand, and I don't think it was ever really part of the strategy.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by fakedang on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:19AM (#45372332)
Doesn't PG actually argue for startups as the "surest" route to million dollar "success"?
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by siva7 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:27AM (#45372399)
> Paul Graham Essay and early YC: live your life, don’t start a company in your 20s. You are young only once.

I've been lurking on HN since 2008 and can't remember a time where i got the vibe from pg to be like "live your life" instead of "start a company now and apply". Can you point to some specific essay you had in mind?

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by abxyz on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:45AM (#45372572)
https://paulgraham.com/before.html

"Given this dichotomy, which of the two paths should you take? Be a real student and not start a startup, or start a real startup and not be a student? I can answer that one for you. Do not start a startup in college. How to start a startup is just a subset of a bigger problem you're trying to solve: how to have a good life. And though starting a startup can be part of a good life for a lot of ambitious people, age 20 is not the optimal time to do it. Starting a startup is like a brutally fast depth-first search. Most people should still be searching breadth-first at 20.

You can do things in your early 20s that you can't do as well before or after, like plunge deeply into projects on a whim and travel super cheaply with no sense of a deadline. For unambitious people, this sort of thing is the dreaded "failure to launch," but for the ambitious ones it can be an incomparably valuable sort of exploration. If you start a startup at 20 and you're sufficiently successful, you'll never get to do it. [7]"

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by cm2012 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:02AM (#45372748)
Totally disagree with Paul here. If you are growing up rich, you can take your time with no deadlines.

If you grew up with responsibilities, you cant ignore the ticking clock. You have to start working on a career path asap.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by siva7 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:36AM (#45372484)
If there is a single advice i would give the young folks here: Don't listen to VC's. Live your life. Startup founder is more comparable to an olympic athlete in terms of what you have to give up to get there - by definition 99% of people who try no matter how brilliant won't walk this path successfully - but both will lose many things on this way without being much happier than before. This is also where most of this community is being very dishonest be it co-founder search or success stories: Only a very small percentage of people is mentally suited (e.g. extreme resilience) to go on with this gamble yet we encourage everyone to try it out here.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by wslh on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:06AM (#45372782)
This. I'd also add that, in general, you don't need a large sum of money in the early stages, as long as your basic needs are covered. For instance, living with your parents for a while can be a smart move. More importantly, use time wisely: with discipline you can do or validate a lot over several quarters. By contrast, if you take the VC route, the metronome ticks much faster, often in a way that can be counterproductive for your startup. As unintuitive as it sounds.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by DonHopkins on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:06AM (#45372777)
>extreme resilience

You misspelled narcissistic psychopath.

The Best of Gavin Belson:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30WTWkFe910

The Best of Russ Hanneman:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGy5SGTuAGI

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by podgorniy on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:24AM (#45372975)
First time he gave that advise it was not directly affecting his company profit chances. Second time though is different.

--

Another good example of expressing and exersiging values, how easy to construct appealing narrative regardless of underlying subject and something else what I can't pinpoint at this stage...

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dang on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:34PM (#45376068)
PG never gave that advice (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45375715), and has been completely consistent about the advice he has given.

Not that everyone should always be consistent, but you guys could not have picked a worse example to seize on.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by zulban on Thursday September 25, 2025 @10:38AM (#45373131)
I've had to explain this to several people: YC goals are not our goals. For YC, it would be great for lots of people to burn down their lives for even the slimmest chance at success.
Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dangus on Thursday September 25, 2025 @12:31PM (#45374967)
Venture capital would love it if everyone worked overtime with no weekends to build “the next big thing.”

Your hobbies and interests should actually just be work and producing profit. Don’t spend the weekend taking a hike with your friends, you gotta get building.

The people doing that work are a probabilistic financial instrument to the VC system. The founders who fall for this trap instead of living a balanced life are just lowering the cost basis for the VC investors by giving away free labor.

In reality, you can build a startup while maintaining a work-life balance, but if everyone did that then VC firms would have to delay the purchase of their owners’ fifth yacht by a couple of months.

The only people who have the time and energy for the toxic startup founder lifestyle of thing are students and young people who haven’t yet established families and their optimism and interest is being exploited.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dang on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:14PM (#45375715)
I'm having a hard time understanding the 'gotcha' quality of this comment and this subthread. There's no inconsistency; PG has always said that people should finish college before starting a startup—I heard him say this over 15 years ago, and he went on about it at length at his most recent YC talk.

Edit: I think I understand the problem now. PG's actual advice has always been "finish college before starting a startup". Somehow somewhere that got distorted into "don't start a company in your 20s", which is certainly not what PG has been saying (the average graduation age is somewhere around 23). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45372572 quotes a representative passage, and if you read that essay you'll see that he's mostly saying "don't start a startup at 20".

(Edit: I deleted my last sentence which was irritable.)

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by foldr on Thursday September 25, 2025 @02:33PM (#45376943)
I don't have a strong personal opinion on this, but the PG essay mentioned in the comment you link to advises people not to start a startup while in college and to do other things in their "early 20s", while Early Decision is targeted specifically at people who are currently college students and (mostly) in their early 20s. I don't think there's a 'gotcha' there, but there is at least a tension, no?

While you're correct that the comment you're responding to is a bit sloppy in summarizing what PG said ("20s" instead of "early 20s"), its basic point still makes sense.

YC is not the Church of Paul Graham, so I don't see any need to dive into Pauline exegesis and attempt to reconcile YC's current admissions process with everything PG has ever said. YC can do what it likes, and people can note what may or may not have changed since PG was in charge of it.

Re:Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students by dang on Thursday September 25, 2025 @03:58PM (#45378158)
The early decision is for people who want to start a startup once they finish college. I don't see a tension between that and advising people to finish college.

The difference between "20s" and "early 20s" is huge; it's the difference between Google and not-Google (btw, that pg essay includes this information). Since not-not-funding-Google is, to a first approximation, the entire startup investment business, conflating the two is more than a bit sloppy, and the GP comment (imputing an inconsistency to PG that doesn't exist, with cynical implications), makes no sense once one adjusts for what pg really said. He's been consistent about this for many years! I'm being irritable again now though. but not with you!

You made me laugh with the Pauline bit!