News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by armenarmen on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:16PM (#45282603)
The right, has for the past decade or so taken a moral high ground with regards to cancelation. Seems that now they've adopted a "turnaround is fair play" mentality.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wrs on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:19PM (#45282639)
Turns out they're not all that big on "free speech" in general! Who knew.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by armenarmen on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:24PM (#45282690)
not taking a position other than cancelation is bad, but it was just a couple years ago when the left was saying "freedom of speech does not equal freedom from consequences"
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:25PM (#45282699)
That remains true!

But the First Amendment very clearly says it can’t be the government doing the consequencing.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by thatswrong0 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:04PM (#45283073)
The FCC chairman threatened to pull ABC's broadcast license over Kimmel's comments. That's pretty much a direct 1st amendment violation.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by bigyabai on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:43PM (#45282868)
Which is why we're all shocked that the order came from the FCC chair and not the business owner.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by rat87 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:34PM (#45282786)
The right was also calling to cancel people back then. They've just gotten more flagrant now. I'm not sure you can even call it hypocrisy since they don't even pretend to have principles besides whatever Trump wants. The government is blackmailing private companies now. I don't watch Kimmel but looking up stories his comments didn't seem at all offensive, please tell me what I missed.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by good8675309 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:29PM (#45283301)
And they also shared this: https://xkcd.com/1357/
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by acdha on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:38PM (#45283370)
Which is describing a very different situation: if ABC decided not to renew Kimmel’s contract, that’s their right as a business. Their listeners didn’t ask for this, the government made an illegal threat to force their business to stop allowing their listeners to have a choice.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by thatswrong0 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:34PM (#45283338)
The FCC Chairman threatened ABC over Kimmel's comments. This is not applicable.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by keernan on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:34PM (#45283343)
That saying is absolutely true so long as the consequence isn't imposed by the government which has zero right to become involved in what Americans think, like, or say.

And there is something seriously wrong when large corporations have to worry about kissing the government's ass because they are awaiting government approval for a business venture. Obviously that's always been a worry, but Trump has taken that to a sickening new level.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by paxys on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:17PM (#45282621)
The right is simply good at PR. People forget that they invented cancel culture. Dixie Chicks anyone?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by xnx on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:23PM (#45282674)
> The right is simply good at PR

One of the defining characteristics of the right is not placing any value on logical consistency. Being a hypocrite will not lose you any support with them.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by pupppet on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:46PM (#45282898)
They protect their own above all else. Is their own a POS? Oh well.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by asdff on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:02AM (#45285624)
Not always. See what they said about the old guard such as mccain.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by user982 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:44PM (#45282880)
Hypocrisy is a show of power.
[dead]
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kelnos on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:21PM (#45284881)
No it doesn't, and I'm so tired of these garbage false equivalencies.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by mrtesthah on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:17PM (#45283713)
The right (and by that I specifically mean fascists) will use words in whatever way maximizes their power over others.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by suzdude on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:38PM (#45283899)
> Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition …There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by VikingCoder on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:23PM (#45282681)
Sorry, I thought you were going to end your line with "McCarthyism".
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by armenarmen on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:18PM (#45282625)
I had totally forgotten about that!
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by XorNot on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:21PM (#45282654)
Video games all through the 90s as well.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by panarchy on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:48PM (#45283460)
Satanic Panic before that.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by justin66 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:10PM (#45283658)
> People forget that they invented cancel culture. Dixie Chicks anyone?

You can go a lot further back than that. McCarthyism was a powerful cancel culture and vestiges of that still manifest today. Linguistically, the weird and inexplicable way anything to the left of fascism in America can be described as "communism" if someone is in the mood to be pejorative is a vestige of McCarthy, or something even further back from the First Red Scare, I think.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ndiddy on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:01PM (#45284126)
Freedom Fries, Satanic Panic, Save our Children, Red Scare. If anything the liberals being able to cancel people is a historical anomaly, and now we're seeing things return to their natural order.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by yongjik on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:33PM (#45282781)
IMO, being able to cry louder for persecution complex does not equal a moral high ground.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by tptacek on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:32PM (#45282771)
This is one of those interminable sprawling message board arguments that has a really simple resolution nobody wants to accept, which is that commitment to free expression and "right/left" are mostly orthogonal, and both the right and the left weaponize commitment to free expression when it makes sense for them to.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by somewholeother on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:53PM (#45282966)
The horseshoe is a bit like a boomerang in that regard, both in form and function!
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by GuinansEyebrows on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:46PM (#45282901)
i get what you're saying but "the left" has basically zero political power in the united states. it never has. the closest we ever were was with FDR but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

we have a right wing and then a righter wing. bernie sanders is an anomaly, elizabeth warren is just left of center, and i can't think of too many other current politicians at the national level who actually lean left. i guess nominally "the squad" but they mostly present fairly centrist platforms by worldwide standards. no current politicians at the national stage are talking about meaningful economic reform (as in, away from capitalism), police abolition, nationalized health care, or any other typical leftist ideas - not that i'm trying to argue any of these points in this thread - just providing examples of what i mean by "leftist".

whether or not "the left" weaponizes commitment to free expression, "the right" is the only side of that binary who has ever wielded serious political power, and they use it to extremely destructive ends at all times.

maybe someday if we ever have a political party that actually represents leftwing politics we can judge them as harshly. i'll wait.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:07PM (#45283106)
...but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

And that's my cue to take yet another hit to my HN karma by asking, incredulously, "WTF are they teaching kids in school these days?"

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:10PM (#45283128)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

> During World War II, the United States forcibly relocated and incarcerated about 120,000 people of Japanese descent in ten concentration camps operated by the War Relocation Authority (WRA), mostly in the western interior of the country.

> During World War II, the camps were referred to both as relocation centers and concentration camps by government officials and in the press. Roosevelt himself referred to the camps as concentration camps on different occasions, including at a press conference held on October 20, 1942.

> In a 1961 interview, Harry S. Truman stated "They were concentration camps. They called it relocation but they put them in concentration camps, and I was against it. We were in a period of emergency, but it was still the wrong thing to do."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_camp

> Not to be confused with Extermination camp. A concentration camp is a prison or other facility used for the internment of political prisoners or politically targeted demographics, such as members of national or ethnic minority groups, on the grounds of national security, or for exploitation or punishment.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:16PM (#45283187)
Very good, you've addressed half of the proposition. Now do the other half, specifically the part about how True Leftists don't do things like that.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:20PM (#45283228)
I mean, they don’t. Just like True Conservatives don’t leverage the government to interfere like this.

People are more contradictory than pure theory. FDR was progressive in some aspects, regressive in others. A leftie, he wasn’t, and there’s more to politics than mere left/right, or we wouldn’t have trans Trump supporters.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:22PM (#45283253)
How about Lenin, Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot? Were they lefties?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by suzdude on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:40PM (#45283927)
By U.S.A. standards, authoritarian leaders who use violence as a means of political gain does not align with the Democratic Party of today.

During Jim Crow, at the State level in the south, it would be applicable, but that doesn't mean much in today's terms.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by GuinansEyebrows on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:25PM (#45284926)
Hi Bob, we’re talking about American politicians.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#45285657)
'Sup, 'brows. Tell me, what's special about American politicians as opposed to those in the rest of the world, in your view?

Education?

Religious values?

Neanderthal versus Cro-Magnon genelines?

A more-enlightened electorate?

Nothing but your own empty prejudices and comforting assumptions?

It can happen here, and it can happen to your party, too. It just didn't this time.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:43PM (#45283412)
Same shit as Trump - the self-proclaimed label and the actions are wildly disparate.

They - and Hitler - are notable for their totalitarianism. I bear no illusions that folks like Stalin wanted anything more than power.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:08PM (#45284217)
Communism is far left, fascism far right. Both often slide into totalitarianism, which commonly includes camps.

FDR’s era, the furthest left the U.S. has been, true to form had this element... showing how concentrated state power, left or right, risks curtailing freedom.

In modern times, we've seen Guantánamo survive multiple admins on both sides.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:06AM (#45285247)
Well far-right and far-left usually put people in camps due to ideological or related reasons.

In this case I’m not sure if that was inherently related to Roosevelt’s progressive/left policies. A moderate or rightwing government likely would have done something similar at the time.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:22AM (#45285356)
They also tend to put the 'other' in them.

My argument is that New Deal policies paved the way - culturally, institutionally, legislatively - for the United States to quickly mobilize for war, which also significantly reduced the friction for something like this to occur.

So yes, it could have happened under more centrist regimes entering the war, but the scale and timing would likely have been minimized in comparison.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:58AM (#45285592)
In the sense that the government had the logistical capacity and capability to do something like this, yes.

Culturally I don’t see it as somehow exceptional. US government regularly employed highly authoritarian policies to suppress or remove people based on racial or ideological grounds since the very beginning.

Even in WW1 German Americans had the benefit of being white and forming a very significant proportion of the population so anything like this was obviously infeasible. But their cultural and linguistic identity was suppressed and they were forced to assimilate under the threat of violence.

When you take the Sedition Act and other similar policies in relation to how much of a threat US faced in WW1 compared to WW2 I’d day what Roosevelt did wasn’t that extreme.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#45285660)
I agree repression has always existed in the U.S, but the difference is scale.

In WWI the country was smaller, less centralized, and suppression was cruder - local violence, language bans, mobs.

By WWII the U.S. was far larger, more cohesive, and had a strong federal state; without that scale and central capacity, something like internment would have been much harder to pull off.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kelnos on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:29PM (#45284967)
> but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

I consider myself a leftist, but it's a bit naive to think that "this bad, horrible thing" must be associated only with right-leaning ideology. Leftists can do bad, horrible things just as much as right-wing folks can. "Putting people in concentration camps" isn't a right-wing or left-wing thing, it's a totalitarian/anti-human-rights thing. We can argue that, as of late, right-wing people seem to have more of an appetite for that sort of thing, and I'd probably agree, but that doesn't make concentration camps a "right-wing thing".

I would absolutely consider FDR to be one of the most (if not the most) leftist presidents the US has had. His putting people in concentration camps doesn't change that; it just makes him a racist piece of shit, like so many others of his time (not that the time period excuses it).

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:02AM (#45285223)
> wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch

Well.. if you exclude all the very successful political movements which considered themselves “leftist”.

Bit of a no true Scotsman thing.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by Bratmon on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:55PM (#45284066)
But there is a massive difference here. The left uses social pressure to silence people they don't like, the right uses government power to silence people they don't like.

These are not even close to the same.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by elktown on Thursday September 18, 2025 @02:30PM (#45293274)
This is the exact type of cowardly but comfortable fence-sitting that we were warned against after WW2.

It's devoid of proportionality & it accepts a narrative crafted by the right-wingers themselves through repetition for exactly this purpose. There was never ever any doubt that all the hyperbolic outrage from the right about grassroots "cancel culture" was going to be used by the authors to excuse actual censorship as far as their current power and societal normalization allows them to. Preparing the ground for a "You did it first!" is not exactly innovative, it's fascism 101.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kiitos on Thursday September 18, 2025 @06:18PM (#45295716)
cool post, what are you trying to communicate with it? everything is the same, all positions are equivalent, there is no right or wrong?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by throwawa14223 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:35PM (#45282804)
I believe they changed when the government put pressure on social media during COVID. I think that caused a huge attitude shift among the right.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by zzgo on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:40PM (#45282835)
Bill Maher rather famously lost his job on ABC 20+ years ago related to his comments about the 9/11 hijackers. I don't think conservatives cancelling people in the media for speech they don't like is anything new within the last 5 years.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:20PM (#45283236)
Wasn't a lot of that pressure coming from a right wing government? COVID's initial year and a bit was under the first Trump admin.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by epicureanideal on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:19PM (#45282640)
Is there some way the two sides could reliably arrive at a truce on the issue of cancellation?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kulahan on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:38PM (#45282825)
I don’t think they need to. I think they just need to shake hands and say it’s okay to have a different opinion.

There have been a number of studies around the world, plus some real world examples (Utah gubernatorial 2020) where showing your opponents in a sympathetic light can make a big difference in reductions in political polarization.

It’s especially effective when signaled by the “elite”: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/00323217241300...

Edit: I hear plenty of stories of people abandoning family members over a difference of political opinion. My MIL won’t talk to a niece of hers after the niece made the same decision. I won’t go so far as to say that’s never warranted, but it seems these days that it’s happening a lot more.

To me, this implies we’re losing acceptability of political “others”.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by suzdude on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:03PM (#45284158)
It's rough when very basic premises, "political violence, no matter who causes it, is abhorrent," are up for debate. The minority people who support, defend, ignore, or rationalize actions which have no place in this country is a major part of the issue.

Turn on the largest mainstream media "news" channel, and you'll hear nothing but mindless hate for 20 hours a day, without consideration for what actual news is occurring.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:09AM (#45285273)
> support, defend, ignore, or rationalize actions

So up until this point it was perfectly acceptable? Or is this only an issue when the wrong side does it in a fairly moderate way (since the other side regularly and openly embraces and encourages political violence).

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by suzdude on Thursday September 18, 2025 @02:08AM (#45286052)
For rational people, it has never been acceptable, it will never be acceptable.

However, some people support and vote for, a president who has told his supporters to perform acts of violence against those whose speech he disagrees with, clearly a portion of the population doesn't mind.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by doom2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:40PM (#45284554)
> this implies we’re losing acceptability of political “others”.

I think this is being seriously accelerated by Trump. Why should I treat those I disagree with with dignity and respect when the President (who theoretically is a leader for all Americans, not just the people who voted for him) says things like this?

"And when you look at the agitator, you look at the scum that speaks so badly of our country, the American flag burnings all over the place, that’s the left. That’s not the right."

When Trump and Vance start setting a positive example for others to follow, maybe I'll rethink my position, but leadership and accountability start at the top.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by dfxm12 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:46PM (#45284601)
Counterpoint: dehumanizing trans people, black people, other minorities, women, is not acceptable. It's not "a different opinion". When Republican politicians or prominent conservative talking heads talk about replacement theory, other conservatives shoot up synagogues or super markets in a minority neighborhood. I don't want to talk to you if this is what you support, unless what you're saying is you've had a change of heart.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kulahan on Thursday September 18, 2025 @07:13PM (#45296154)
Why would they have a change of heart when the only people interested in that happening refuse to engage?

All you’re doing is ensuring the strength of their beliefs.

Edit: You don’t have to like someone to not actively attack them at every opportunity, even if what they believe is reprehensible to you.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by armenarmen on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:22PM (#45282666)
Prisoners' dilemma at scale. I don't think a truce is doable unless reporting someone for having what you believe to be unsavory opinions becomes a major social faux pas
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by XorNot on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:24PM (#45282692)
Who do you imagine represents the "sides" in negotiations? Do they have names and group bodies which they represent? Are they able to sign and enforce diplomatic agreements?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by fullshark on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:32PM (#45282776)
Not gonna happen until the left acknowledges its cultural dominance and how it's shaped public discourse the past 15 years via fear.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by UtopiaPunk on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:01PM (#45283045)
Pronouns? Or do you mean something else?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by lawlessone on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:39PM (#45282830)
Are things like racism and sexism being bad exclusive to the left?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by techpineapple on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:27PM (#45282720)
I think the problem is it’s not the moderate 80% of each party that’s doing it, so all of the people who might be inclined to a truce are already at the table waiting.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by xp84 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:38PM (#45282828)
Couldn't agree more with this. The majority of Americans think that the "leftest and rightest" people they know are absolute wackos.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by rat87 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:38PM (#45282826)
What truce? Sometimes cancelation is good, sometimes it's not. It depends on the why. Also Republican principles these days are just to blindly follow whatever Trump wants including complaining about cancelation and renaming bases to confederate generals and blackmailing companies into firing people
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by binary132 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:43PM (#45283416)
Someone was just murdered for his opinions so no, that doesn’t seem likely. I think that’s one cancelation too far, and I don’t think there’s going to be any meaningful coming back from it.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:21PM (#45283753)
Why is this the turning point and not, say, the attempts (and successful assassination of one) on Minnesota lawmakers a few months ago?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by FillardMillmore on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:33AM (#45285434)
Just a guess, but in that case, very few people really knew who those lawmakers were, and there wasn't camera footage of the murder in that case to be spread virally on social media.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by sigwinch on Thursday September 18, 2025 @09:09AM (#45289210)
A lot of the media coverage this week begins with an introduction to Mr. Kirk. Do you think he was a household name?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by asdff on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:11AM (#45285673)
The left 'cancelling' a product or a public figure is literally just exercising consumer choice. People get fired because they are bleeding ad dollars over lack of views. I'm not sure how you can prevent that without being even more authoritarian.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:24PM (#45282691)
> The right, has for the past decade or so taken a moral high ground with regards to cancelation.

Have you been in a coma for that decade?

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by PaulHoule on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:35PM (#45282803)
I first saw a moral panic over ‘cancel culture’ circa 2013 from The Atlantic and the opinion page of the New York Times. (The first because it’s demo is the naive liberal and pearl clutching parents of college students and the second because folks like Brooks and Blow don’t want to be canceled themselves). It was until 2017 or so that conservatives noticed the phenomenon and started to talk about it in The National Review and such.

Ezra Klein, who I generally respect, said he got more crap over

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/11/opinion/charlie-kirk-assa...

than anything else he’s written but I think it was unfortunate that he chose the words because Kirk, among other things, promoted Trump’s lies about the 2000 election, bussed people to the Jan 6 riot, and had a hit list of professors he wanted to punish just like David Horowitz, dad of the Andressen-Horowitz Horowitz. That bit about “prove me wrong” was always disingenuous, it would fool the pearl clutching parents who read The Atlantic and the likes of Ezra Klein. Probably the most harmful thing about illiberal campus leftists is that they allowed illiberal rightists to appear to take the high ground.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kelnos on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:37PM (#45285040)
Cancel culture has been a thing a lot longer than since 2013. McCarthyism, anyone? Funny how cancellation has historically been wielded by the right, but once the left gets a few (comparatively minor) cancel-jabs in, it's a Real Problem.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by asdff on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:10AM (#45285663)
The important distinction is that the left cancels by utilizing consumer choice vs the government.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by gsf_emergency_2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:23AM (#45285749)
Government the Father, consumer choice the Mother.

To push a domestic metaphor

(Or are the gender roles switched)

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by gsf_emergency_2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:28AM (#45285399)
"Cancel culture" gets piled on by conservatives sometimes because it's such an obvious own goal that used to be a prerogative of the right

I might be off my rocker on this, but!

>prove me wrong

Is such a right-wing to say.

Because it signals that a conservative believes that

  *self-improvement is possible*.
(Their actions tend to suggest otherwise-- Thiel and Wolfram are my go-to not even mala (fide) examples. Lack of faith in learning happens in liberals or self-styled moderates, but we'd call that pessimism ("depression" in the empathetic or clinical). With thinking right wingers it's normally narcissism..Ezra is a pessimist but he carelessly assists the own goals)

Calling out cancel culture today: the youngest kid signals that they give up on self-improvement in favor of acting out, so the elder sibling, who used to be punished for a very similar thing, jumps (gleefully) on it . "Mama look at what she just did!" knowing the parents gonna wring their hands

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by PaulHoule on Thursday September 18, 2025 @10:18AM (#45290027)
Yeah. Klein did a good interview with Ben Shapiro in his last pod

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EAqG00FUOK8

who covers a lot of ground: Shapiro seems rather strong when it comes to articulating that idea of personal responsibility but his satanization of the economic left (e.g. Bernie Sanders) seems forced and unreasonable and Klein sorta "owns" him when it comes to pointing out that many of Trump and Vance's policies and viewpoints are examples of the envy and resentment-based "scavenger" thinking that Shaprio discusses in a dehumanizing way.

Shapiro's attempt to foreclose any difference on economic issues is mirrored, I think, by a certain wish on the left to foreclose difference on cultural issues. One one hand there is an axis that runs through Trotskyites to centrists like Klein who would like to shut down the culture wars because as soon as the culture wars started we started losing [1] [2] but the leftist who enjoys the culture wars is more inclined to satanize the "christofascist" as opposed to the likes of Milton Freedman [3]

There's a tendency on the right to say there is an "objective" reality (the Bible, Ayn Rand's philosophy) whereas Marxism leads you to see there are "two sides" to any issue. It gets the left in no end of trouble thinking about Blacks because if you go talk to Black people you will find they really do see things differently from white people in the aggregate but that they also see things differently from one another.

So like Rhett Butler or Han Solo if I'm asked to take a side on something like "cancel culture" I'm going to say "my side". I'm sure someone got canceled who deserved it and someone got canceled who didn't deserve it. There is no "due process" but there's also a feeling (see Klein) that due process is as much a problem as it is a solution. I sure as hell hate the "debate" over it.

[1] that theory would say that Reagan's economic policies didn't have any appeal to a mass base

[2] to be fair, almost always white male although sometimes gay

[3] and it's a credit to the rise of financialization: when I grew up I learned the financial advice that if I take care of my bank account my credit score will take care of itself; the paradigm for financial advise on both the internet and in magazines has been "(1) stop people from stealing your identity, and (2) use this one weird trick to raise your FICO score" since 2010 -- leftists once might have cared about labor, opportunity, taxes and such, today they care about insurance (e.g. health insurance) and credit (student loans). The idea that you might have your own money to spend on something you want to spend it on is right out of the 1950s like the stay at hom emome.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by gsf_emergency_2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:10PM (#45291397)
Got to the part where Ezra says he will have his kids read Shapiros neo-Randian fairytale lol.

Yep this is the disingenuity. If i were Ezra I'd have rehearsed with a unrepentant Randian 10x to come up with something more aggressive.

Self-help for Shapiros would not be writing Randian "bronze-age" fairytales, but to get as far away from Rand and the Iron Age as sanely possible. (but that'd require some hormonal injections or dissociative research substances ?)

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by gsf_emergency_2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @10:53AM (#45290456)
>leftist who enjoys the culture wars

Ah, here was a great place to substitute your coinage "identarian"-- Ime I can't distinguish the identarians who enjoy the culture wars in terms of left from right (unless we equate right with white, & that's something we have to amicably agree to disagree :) one could forgiveably id the killer of Kirk as a right-identarian, eg, but that still feels less correct than simply "identarian" (normal folks would not resort to moderately planned violence).. you can see by the shell engravings TR sort of took pleasure in the planning vs Luigi..

(Yes, in other words, the economic left, or more precisely the nonpractising left, was too welcoming of identarians in precisely the same way the churchgoing center wasnt- 1970s to mid 1980s)

Now as for "leftist" in [3] I'd assume you mean "what passes for a classic leftist (like Bernie & 2000s Paul) amongst the millennials/gen z". More to say here, insurance over taxes is imho the correct Marxist valuation.. ? After all "from each according to his ability etc etc" is a succinct description of insurance

>due process is as much a problem as it is a solution

Now this is an interesting take, well, I can see Klein saying it in exasperation (in the podcast-to-be-read-- thanks!), but what is your emotional-valence here? (I can guess, but the guess would be more intricate than I can jot down from the hip :)

A mini-shot though.. if one truly enjoys hard work, problems would be as much of a joy as solutions. Centrists (like PG and "functional" Grothendieck) would be careful to tolerate schlep without seeing value in labor-in-itself.. schizos right+epsilon of center, or stoics* left+epsilon a-ways.. however..

*I would substitute "epicureans" here, but "stoics" would do fine for pedantry

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by PaulHoule on Thursday September 18, 2025 @07:11PM (#45296137)
As for the shell casing I think the best commentary so far has been

https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/notes-on-the-heavenly-a...

https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/constituent-parts-of-a-...

I can't approve completely of his appropriate of dynamical systems theory but the idea that Kirk was "killed by memes" appeals to me as does Fred's description of these as "brainrot". People on the right are likely to see some transfurry in there [1] whereas left-leaning women are going to see anything coded young male as right wing. The FBI profile of the postmodern shooter is that he had a copy of The Communist Manifesto but he kept up his neighbors listening to Rush (the Canadian band) and people will make what they want of it.

As for Klein and due process I can say I am very frustrated not least because due process is frustrating but because we're in a dilemma because the alternatives are worse. (I can see how Curtis Yarvin's crypto-degrowth philosophy of "just wait until the dieoff and we can go back to solar-economy feudalism" could appeal to some) Of course that frustration with due process is the subject of his recent book Abundance which I have ambiguous feelings about: part of me wants to believe it, but I think it is a tough sell to many people who see it as warmed over neoliberalism [3] who think rent control is a good idea, like the populism of Matt Stoller, never mind this sort of usually unstated issue

https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/good-cities-cant-exist-without...

as it is people will complain that somebody else complains about not being safe downtown while they (1) live a hikkiomori lifestyle or (2) live in the suburbs and/or order a private taxi for their burrito instead of going to a restaurant.

[1] my take though is furries are even-headed, as a committed kemonomimi [2] I always trying to bait them based on their bad taste in art

[2] https://safebooru.donmai.us/posts/3773068

[3] "but wait... we're not talking liberating the private sector from the government, we're talking about liberating the government from the government!"

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by gsf_emergency_2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @08:25PM (#45296615)
[1] Ime transfurries even more so (tho I'm not clued enough in art history to comment on their aesthetic merits)

Thanks for the Klein pointers, I see the sections on rent are precisely what I require to formulate copy for an insurance-market-based ad to thoughtful Marxists :) TODO-- close-read those with a postulate that Klein has read & wrestled with late era Jacobs

Decarlos Brown is someone I'd ID as right-identarian & more specifically that kind of center-right+epsilon schizo I was hinting at (if I put myself in a Martian's shoes)

But reflecting on that with FredDeBoer freshly paged in: the left-identarians (predominantly women plus a smattering of depressive gays who haven't mustered the courage to experiment with hormone replacement therapy)

Just do a better job of publicly suppressing their glee vizavis less emotionally adroit young cis-males, black or white

Hikkikomori culture in the US is only barely an appropriation-- I'm sure the HKs in ah Saitama dont get distracted by young women loitering in the backstreets of Shibuya/Shinjuku: rather it's the superior habits in moral hygiene (outsiders would say it's indoctrination, but why then would the mtgow-equivalent in Tokyo proper not succeed?)

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kulahan on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:29PM (#45282740)
Man, can you at least elaborate? This kind of comment isn’t what I wanna see HN devolve into.

He’s definitely right with that sentence. Do you not think it’s generally true that the right has been on the defensive with regards to cancel culture, and thus is constantly preaching about how cancelling is wrong?

The few times they’ve gotten to go on the offensive, they play the same game, cancelling whoever it is they’re upset about. It’s horseshoe theory all over again.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:30PM (#45282749)
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kulahan on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:41PM (#45282846)
Never mind, please just read commenting rules moving forward.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:45PM (#45282896)
“Do not cite the Deep Magic to me, Witch! I was there when it was written.“
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kulahan on Sunday September 21, 2025 @04:59AM (#45321164)
You clearly forgot it ages ago, then
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by tonfreed on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:03PM (#45283063)
Why would we defend the rights of someone that refuses to defend ours?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by JohnFen on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:26PM (#45283285)
Because "their" rights and "our" rights (whoever "us" and "them" happen to be) are one and the same. You wouldn't be defending or attacking "their" rights, you'd be defending or attacking rights in general, and that includes yours.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by rat87 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:36PM (#45282806)
They have not in any sense taken any high ground

The right has consistently tried to cancel people, has tried to censor people, has complained/played the refs about moderation saying their rights to say racist stuff was being infringed even when it was a moderation decision by a private company not the government

And then under Trump it's only gotten worse/more divorced from any principles

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by bitlax on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:40PM (#45282842)
Dumb. We were talking about singing along with a rap song or dressing like Michael Jackson in 1985, not malicious false accusations of murder or cheering someone's assassination.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:52PM (#45282957)
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by bitlax on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:59PM (#45283037)
You're making my point.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by GeekyBear on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:43PM (#45282869)
> The right, has for the past decade or so taken a moral high ground with regards to cancelation.

If you are going to morally judge the actions behind cancellation attempts, "I don't find Dave Chappelle's jokes funny" is not morally equivalent to "I don't think people should celebrate the murder of those they disagree with."

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by maxerickson on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:49PM (#45282925)
Jimmy Kimmel didn't celebrate a murder. He criticized the cynical exploitation of a murder.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by bediger4000 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:57PM (#45283561)
I'm not denying what you've observed there, but how does this square up with cancel culture is bad, as we've heard at length from any number of moralizers, including many HN posters and the NYT editorial board. Was I to understand those moralizers as having said that cancelling conservatives was bad, but cancelling the more liberal is at least ok?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by FireBeyond on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:26PM (#45284944)
What utter garbage. It’s not the left canceling Starbucks at Christmas time, or any company that dares sport a rainbow in any marketing whatsoever.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by nxm on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:56PM (#45292027)
It is the left cancelling any right of Marx speaker at college campuses though
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by vjjsejj on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:30AM (#45285416)
I know time flies by.. but 2016 was almost 10 years ago.

Also, lets ignore the fact that there is a difference between consumers boycotting something and a government agency outright threatening a private company.