News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by tptacek on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:32PM (#45282771)
This is one of those interminable sprawling message board arguments that has a really simple resolution nobody wants to accept, which is that commitment to free expression and "right/left" are mostly orthogonal, and both the right and the left weaponize commitment to free expression when it makes sense for them to.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by somewholeother on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:53PM (#45282966)
The horseshoe is a bit like a boomerang in that regard, both in form and function!
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by GuinansEyebrows on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @07:46PM (#45282901)
i get what you're saying but "the left" has basically zero political power in the united states. it never has. the closest we ever were was with FDR but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

we have a right wing and then a righter wing. bernie sanders is an anomaly, elizabeth warren is just left of center, and i can't think of too many other current politicians at the national level who actually lean left. i guess nominally "the squad" but they mostly present fairly centrist platforms by worldwide standards. no current politicians at the national stage are talking about meaningful economic reform (as in, away from capitalism), police abolition, nationalized health care, or any other typical leftist ideas - not that i'm trying to argue any of these points in this thread - just providing examples of what i mean by "leftist".

whether or not "the left" weaponizes commitment to free expression, "the right" is the only side of that binary who has ever wielded serious political power, and they use it to extremely destructive ends at all times.

maybe someday if we ever have a political party that actually represents leftwing politics we can judge them as harshly. i'll wait.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:07PM (#45283106)
...but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

And that's my cue to take yet another hit to my HN karma by asking, incredulously, "WTF are they teaching kids in school these days?"

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:10PM (#45283128)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

> During World War II, the United States forcibly relocated and incarcerated about 120,000 people of Japanese descent in ten concentration camps operated by the War Relocation Authority (WRA), mostly in the western interior of the country.

> During World War II, the camps were referred to both as relocation centers and concentration camps by government officials and in the press. Roosevelt himself referred to the camps as concentration camps on different occasions, including at a press conference held on October 20, 1942.

> In a 1961 interview, Harry S. Truman stated "They were concentration camps. They called it relocation but they put them in concentration camps, and I was against it. We were in a period of emergency, but it was still the wrong thing to do."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_camp

> Not to be confused with Extermination camp. A concentration camp is a prison or other facility used for the internment of political prisoners or politically targeted demographics, such as members of national or ethnic minority groups, on the grounds of national security, or for exploitation or punishment.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:16PM (#45283187)
Very good, you've addressed half of the proposition. Now do the other half, specifically the part about how True Leftists don't do things like that.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:20PM (#45283228)
I mean, they don’t. Just like True Conservatives don’t leverage the government to interfere like this.

People are more contradictory than pure theory. FDR was progressive in some aspects, regressive in others. A leftie, he wasn’t, and there’s more to politics than mere left/right, or we wouldn’t have trans Trump supporters.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:22PM (#45283253)
How about Lenin, Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot? Were they lefties?
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by suzdude on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:40PM (#45283927)
By U.S.A. standards, authoritarian leaders who use violence as a means of political gain does not align with the Democratic Party of today.

During Jim Crow, at the State level in the south, it would be applicable, but that doesn't mean much in today's terms.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by GuinansEyebrows on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:25PM (#45284926)
Hi Bob, we’re talking about American politicians.
Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by CamperBob2 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#45285657)
'Sup, 'brows. Tell me, what's special about American politicians as opposed to those in the rest of the world, in your view?

Education?

Religious values?

Neanderthal versus Cro-Magnon genelines?

A more-enlightened electorate?

Nothing but your own empty prejudices and comforting assumptions?

It can happen here, and it can happen to your party, too. It just didn't this time.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @08:43PM (#45283412)
Same shit as Trump - the self-proclaimed label and the actions are wildly disparate.

They - and Hitler - are notable for their totalitarianism. I bear no illusions that folks like Stalin wanted anything more than power.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:08PM (#45284217)
Communism is far left, fascism far right. Both often slide into totalitarianism, which commonly includes camps.

FDR’s era, the furthest left the U.S. has been, true to form had this element... showing how concentrated state power, left or right, risks curtailing freedom.

In modern times, we've seen Guantánamo survive multiple admins on both sides.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:06AM (#45285247)
Well far-right and far-left usually put people in camps due to ideological or related reasons.

In this case I’m not sure if that was inherently related to Roosevelt’s progressive/left policies. A moderate or rightwing government likely would have done something similar at the time.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:22AM (#45285356)
They also tend to put the 'other' in them.

My argument is that New Deal policies paved the way - culturally, institutionally, legislatively - for the United States to quickly mobilize for war, which also significantly reduced the friction for something like this to occur.

So yes, it could have happened under more centrist regimes entering the war, but the scale and timing would likely have been minimized in comparison.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:58AM (#45285592)
In the sense that the government had the logistical capacity and capability to do something like this, yes.

Culturally I don’t see it as somehow exceptional. US government regularly employed highly authoritarian policies to suppress or remove people based on racial or ideological grounds since the very beginning.

Even in WW1 German Americans had the benefit of being white and forming a very significant proportion of the population so anything like this was obviously infeasible. But their cultural and linguistic identity was suppressed and they were forced to assimilate under the threat of violence.

When you take the Sedition Act and other similar policies in relation to how much of a threat US faced in WW1 compared to WW2 I’d day what Roosevelt did wasn’t that extreme.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by brandall10 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#45285660)
I agree repression has always existed in the U.S, but the difference is scale.

In WWI the country was smaller, less centralized, and suppression was cruder - local violence, language bans, mobs.

By WWII the U.S. was far larger, more cohesive, and had a strong federal state; without that scale and central capacity, something like internment would have been much harder to pull off.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kelnos on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:29PM (#45284967)
> but i wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch.

I consider myself a leftist, but it's a bit naive to think that "this bad, horrible thing" must be associated only with right-leaning ideology. Leftists can do bad, horrible things just as much as right-wing folks can. "Putting people in concentration camps" isn't a right-wing or left-wing thing, it's a totalitarian/anti-human-rights thing. We can argue that, as of late, right-wing people seem to have more of an appetite for that sort of thing, and I'd probably agree, but that doesn't make concentration camps a "right-wing thing".

I would absolutely consider FDR to be one of the most (if not the most) leftist presidents the US has had. His putting people in concentration camps doesn't change that; it just makes him a racist piece of shit, like so many others of his time (not that the time period excuses it).

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by wqaatwt on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:02AM (#45285223)
> wouldn't consider a leader who operated concentration camps to be leftist by any stretch

Well.. if you exclude all the very successful political movements which considered themselves “leftist”.

Bit of a no true Scotsman thing.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by Bratmon on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @09:55PM (#45284066)
But there is a massive difference here. The left uses social pressure to silence people they don't like, the right uses government power to silence people they don't like.

These are not even close to the same.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by elktown on Thursday September 18, 2025 @02:30PM (#45293274)
This is the exact type of cowardly but comfortable fence-sitting that we were warned against after WW2.

It's devoid of proportionality & it accepts a narrative crafted by the right-wingers themselves through repetition for exactly this purpose. There was never ever any doubt that all the hyperbolic outrage from the right about grassroots "cancel culture" was going to be used by the authors to excuse actual censorship as far as their current power and societal normalization allows them to. Preparing the ground for a "You did it first!" is not exactly innovative, it's fascism 101.

Re:ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Live from the Air 'Indefinitely' by kiitos on Thursday September 18, 2025 @06:18PM (#45295716)
cool post, what are you trying to communicate with it? everything is the same, all positions are equivalent, there is no right or wrong?