News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by akkartik on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @01:24AM (#44506571)
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by vasco on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @01:42AM (#44506653)
> This means that if these prints are displayed for three months at 50 lux, they should be stored in the dark for at least a year before they are displayed again

> While these measures will not stop fading from occurring altogether, they will ensure that these world-famous prints fade so slowly that they will be seen by countless generations of visitors to the Museum in the future.

This trade-off is interesting, are we maximizing for number of people watching works? Or are we purely maximizing time? Because its not obvious to me that more people will see a work if it lasts 1000 more years but spends 80% of that time in storage, vs lasting 100 more years spending 0% of the time in storage.

Also lets say you go to the museum today and are lucky that it happens to be on display. But your friend travels to see it, it happens to be in 80% storage time, then the friend goes back home and dies without seeing it so that some future person that doesn't exist yet even can see it later without fading. Why is the future person more important than the current person, in a sense?

Storing it assumes a lot, that humanity will survive, that people will be interested in seeing it, that some fire isn't going to destroy their storage, etc. Meanwhile real life people would've seen it already. I don't have an answer, just questions though.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by qq66 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:08AM (#44506766)
By limiting the hours today, it helps make sure that the people who do see it are the ones most interested in seeing it. Those are the ones who will look up the schedule, schedule their trip around it, etc... while if it's just permanently up, many of the viewers will be random passersby (and the number of viewers per hour of illumination will probably be lower)
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by qalmakka on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @03:00AM (#44507056)
Exactly this. When I was younger they did an exhibit of the Great Wave and Ukiyo-e next to where I lived, so I saved the date when the ticket office opened on my calendar. I then found friends interested in coming with me and grabbed some tickets before they ran out. If you just put it on display every day it will just fade away while being yet another print in a museum full of paintings. You're denying future generations the chance love this print and cherish the opportunity to see one in person. Art is not just taking a photo and passing by, it's about appreciating the fact some human made some very special thing we can now enjoy
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by MangoToupe on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @04:37AM (#44507606)
> You're denying future generations the chance love this print and cherish the opportunity to see one in person. Art is not just taking a photo and passing by, it's about appreciating the fact some human made some very special thing we can now enjoy

I personally don't get this attitude, but I also don't understand a lot of what draws people to museums when we have photographs of works of art. Which is not to say that I don't get why people view works i n person. I just don't understand neurotically trying to preserve a physical work when the author likely didn't even care that much or consider a more preservable medium to begin with.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by nkrisc on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @08:14AM (#44509083)
Paintings are not simple two-dimensional images. You can't view a painting from different angles from a photo. You can't see the light reflecting off the texture of the paint from different viewing angles. You can't get close and observe the brush strokes. A photo of a painting is superficially similar to the painting, but there's much that it lacks.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by GolDDranks on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @10:30AM (#44510498)
However, in this case, we are not talking about a painting, but a woodblock print. (Not disagreeing with your point in general, though.)
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by Angostura on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @07:58AM (#44508920)
For many works, even the best photographs don't entirely capture the physical object - particularly those where texture, including brush strokes is important. Many pigments can't be duplicated via the standard printing gamut. This particular work is a woodblock print, so perhaps photography is adequate - I don't know.

I'm not clear that the original artist's materials, with respect to longevity is really relevant, assuming the artist didn't explicitly intend it to be ephemeral.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by refactor_master on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @11:03AM (#44510890)
Tangentially I saw this exhibition in Tokyo on modern ukiyo-e https://www.tnm.jp/modules/r_free_page/index.php?id=2693&lan... and I was blown away by the incredible level of detail the artists were able to pack into woodblock print. From a distance it looks almost like print, but up close you can really see the textures, and interestingly also the physical limitations compared to real print (the colors being layered by individually carved woodblocks).

With that being said, I’m sure they could make a replica that would be almost impossible to tell apart from the real. After all, this technique was specifically invented for mass production.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by MangoToupe on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @09:58PM (#44516484)
> assuming the artist didn't explicitly intend it to be ephemeral.

Is there another option? Even sculpture hewn from rock is ephemeral.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by umanwizard on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @01:27PM (#44512690)
Photographs of paintings don't look the same as paintings. Dunno about woodblock prints but I'd imagine the same is true.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by bombcar on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @10:17PM (#44516585)
And if you’ve not been to an art museum you may not realize just how massive some paintings really are.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by Yeul on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @04:29PM (#44514426)
There's a nice Japan museum in the Netherlands which was founded by one of the greatest weebs of the 19th century. It's basically his giant house filled with Japanese memorabilia. Watching katanas, kimonos and Japanese lacquer boxes in reality is quite different from watching them in a book!
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by southernplaces7 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @06:20PM (#44515288)
We enjoy seeing art in person because it better transmits the essential human creative spirit of whoever was behind it, in a way that photographs of an artwork simply don't do. This is one main reason why people want to see art in person, those who can't understand that maybe don't have the same emotional notions about art. I wonder if some of them are similar in mind to those who think an AI-generated drawing is no different than anything made by a human creator for their sterile, impersonal apartment walls.

As for why these pieces should be preserved even if their creators were sometimes sloppy about doing the original legwork. Well, in the case of many famous works, they're literal pieces of history dude. Choosing how often and when to display them isn't just about "optimizing viewership". These aren't blog posts or IG reels. It's also about saving their literal existence for as long as possible.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by intull on Thursday July 10, 2025 @04:40PM (#44525340)
The worth and value of something, especially in art, is often assigned wrong in the moment. But on the axis of history, it has a life of its own.

Just 200 years ago, in a world without most of the technologies we take for granted today, art played a fundamentally representative role in stretching the boundaries of ideas, imagination, possibilities, and in extension, human cognition and social impact.

Preservation is the point. Art is made in the moment. Yeah there can be scientifically proven ways of longer-lasting / preservable mediums, inks/paints, etc. Pieces of art capture inspirations and ideas of the creators and pass that feeling along to future generations to also be inspired with new ideas for their times. They can be a snapshot of one place, at one moment in time, but they can also be timeless.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by vasco on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:16AM (#44506816)
Ok that is adding an interesting variable of perceived interest and then it's not about # of people anymore, but rather time plus # of _interested_ people. I guess that has to be the reasoning because it does make sense if that's the optimization goal.

Though I'd imagine mostly its going to be a random sample of people that happen to be there that day. I imagine there's likely under 1% of museum visitors actually chasing single works and planning trips like that. So most people that would see it are still just random "museum people" (which under the "interest" metric is still better than purely random people).

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by eru on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @03:28AM (#44507191)
> By limiting the hours today, it helps make sure that the people who do see it are the ones most interested in seeing it.

We should auction off the visitor spots, then.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by msephton on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @04:26AM (#44507529)
You joke, but visitor slots are limited. I missed it at the British Museum because I turned up without a reservation. Also, BM have two impressions and rotates them meaning that people can see "it" (actually one or the other) for longer. Some institutions like Boston have a handful of impressions so can show "it" more frequently: the last time they cycled three.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by pimlottc on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @01:54PM (#44512980)
Similar to this, the Munch Museum in Oslo has three variations of "The Scream" on rotation, with only one of them shown each day [0]. So you're always guaranteed to be able to see it in some form, but you'll have go to multiple days if you want to see them all.

0: https://www.munch.no/en/The-Scream/where-can-i-see-the-screa...

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by prmoustache on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @06:23AM (#44508215)
Money is not a direct factor of who is interested the most so it is not necessary fair.

An example: my partner is working in a relatively expensive "wellness" service. Some people reserve and never show up even though they have reserved for a whole family and lose more than a thousand euros. I am pretty sure a lot of people that cannot afford this service at this price on a regular basis would if it was less expensive for them. I know I do as I only profit from it because I have a 50% discount and my partner doesn't have to pay so we pay a quarter of the price everytime we go together.

So making it an auction and you would still see a mix of interested people and vain but wealthy people for which paying for this would still be pocket change and would just take an "I've been there" selfie and move on without really being interested in the artwork itself. So more money for the museum but not necessarily representative of the interest of the visitors.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by eru on Thursday July 10, 2025 @05:10AM (#44518941)
Oh, you just suggested your own fix: if people don't show up, you just keep their money (and presumably you let the next guy on the queue in earlier.)
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by politelemon on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @03:08AM (#44507088)
Same here, no answers. I'd also question why we should feel entitled to see it, or have that privilege at all. The curators might, at a certain point in time, hold a great appreciation for it versus me Joe public, and then it would make sense to simply not show it anymore as the trade-off isn't worth it.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by pyrale on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:09AM (#44506769)
You mean, that hypothetical friend who wants to see this particular piece of art in situ so much but didn’t bother to plan their trip accordingly?
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by teekert on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:34AM (#44506920)
Scanners are also getting better. Perhaps this way it will make it all the way to the atomic cloning era. Just like we might all just make it until the “upload your consciousness” era, or the “we beat aging” era.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by Muromec on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:44AM (#44506973)
No need for scanners in case of wood block prints -- we can always get more originals whenever we want.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by plouffy on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:50AM (#44507005)
Unless you have access to the original woodblocks then not really. And even if you do, they’ve probably degraded quite a bit from the printing process so the result won’t be identical.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by pm215 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @04:47AM (#44507676)
I think another aspect here is that museums don't have infinite display space. So if famous items X, Y and Z are on permanent display that's less space available for other, less famous but perhaps equally interesting, items that are stuck in storage. Rotating the famous items into storage doesn't mean the museum has blank walls for a year.

Arguably there's more educational value and more chance of a visitor serendipitously encountering something that speaks to them if the museum has a big set of prints rotated through, rather than a more static one. After all, even if you haven't ever seen an original of the Great Wave you almost certainly already know the image and it's likely already made most of the impact on you that it ever will...

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by msephton on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @05:12AM (#44507825)
The British Museum have at least two impressions. Boston have five, showing a cycle of three the last time "it" was on view. So viewings can be more frequent than the 4 year gap, or they can keep the gap and have a longer exhibition. Either way, more people get to see it.
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by amelius on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @08:18AM (#44509125)
Can we just turn off the lights, move visitors into the room, then turn on the lights for a few seconds?
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by dylan604 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @02:47PM (#44513522)
As these are prints themselves, are we gaining anything by seeing these prints vs other prints? It's not like viewing an original Monet or anything where the thing being viewed was the work created by the artist's hands. While these prints might have been made by the artist, they are still not the originals.

When visiting DC, do we really think the Constitution under all of that glass is the actual Constitution? POTUS seems to think he has the actual, so there's conflict right there. For a document as beloved as the Constitution, why would you ever risk the original?

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by southernplaces7 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @06:23PM (#44515317)
>When visiting DC, do we really think the Constitution under all of that glass is the actual Constitution?

That's a damn good question actually, and for many other works in other places, like, say, the Magna Carta, or the Declaration of Independence. To the Wikipediamobile ADHDMan!

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by dylan604 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @06:38PM (#44515417)
Why do you think Wikipedia wouldn't be lying about the same thing?
Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by southernplaces7 on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @07:40PM (#44515833)
I can't be sure, no, but I can't think of a single reason why they would lie about something so banal as whether the displayed "originals" are really that. In any case, they do provide their sources.

For example, if you go to the Wikipedia page on the Taj Mahal, they plainly explain that the tombs that tourists see daily, of the Mughal emperor and his wife, aren't the real tombs. Those are down in the basement, below the fake ones.

Re:Where can I see Hokusai's Great Wave today? by sunrunner on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @05:00AM (#44507751)
Such a shame that Hokusai didn't get a chance to read Sarah Renae Clark's excellent investigation [1] into lightfastness (coincidentally linked yesterday).

[1] https://sarahrenaeclark.com/lightfast-testing-pencils/