News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by isodev on Thursday June 05, 2025 @01:38AM (#44188595)
At this point, why anyone would opt to buy a Tesla is beyond my understanding. The fact that regulation is lacking to such an extent as to allow Tesla to wait for airbag deployment for something to count as a crash is kind of sad.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:08AM (#44188768)
Well because Tesla's are excellent cars and are still ranked at the top compared to the rest of the market.

The only part I don't know why people would trust is the FSD/Autopilot of which I wouldn't recommend people to buy. But as an EV its an excellent car.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by otherme123 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:19AM (#44188820)
They are actually lacking. Their reliability is low (https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2024-us-vehi...), even comparing with ICEs, and as electric vehicles they should be naturally more reliable. They are also known to refuse to participate in quality studies (https://www.motorbiscuit.com/dumb-reason-tesla-ineligible-j-...). In 2023 they were at the bottom of the reliability list by JD Power (https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2023-us-init...).
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:48AM (#44189009)
These studies don't really show a decent comparison between EV's, just car makers in general. We aren't trying to argue whether Tesla's are better than ICE car makers, but whether they're consistent or better against other EV's of other car makers.

However, if you look at the latest press release by JDPower (https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2025-us-vehi...) you'll see that Tesla now ranks right near the average. Significantly better than in previous years and ahead of other common car makers.

The dependability study could do with a segment purely on EV's, given that EV's as a whole are improving by roughly 33 PP100 per year.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by nindalf on Thursday June 05, 2025 @03:07AM (#44189134)
Your link calls out Tesla in particular as “Note: Brand is not rank eligible because it does not meet study award criteria.”

You are citing a study that specifically excludes Tesla. And even then you’re bragging about Tesla being … average?

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:05AM (#44189468)
I used the same links as the commenter above, of which I cited a more recent study and shows that Tesla isn’t as bad as they perhaps used to be.

If they really wanted to exclude them they wouldn’t have included them all.

I cited the study, because it was the same study commented above where the most recent study wasn’t mentioned.

I’m not bragging at all, but they’re just not as bad of a car as some people are giving them a wrap for. Heck they had the same number of problem reported as Ford, does that mean Fords are bad cars? No.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by otherme123 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:37AM (#44190601)
What I'm saying is just that Tesla are not "excellent cars and are still ranked at the top compared to the rest of the market" as you said. The fact that they move from the bottom to average still don't support Tesla as excellent cars when compared to the rest of the market. Note that I'm not asserting that "Tesla are the worst cars".
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:11AM (#44191899)
That was my mistake in that I'd meant to compare them with other EV's, not ICEs.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by robertlagrant on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:53AM (#44190710)
> And even then you’re bragging about Tesla being … average?

If you think about issues this way, I think it's fully unproductive. No one was bragging. The fact you see this as either unthinking bragging or unthinking criticism makes it very hard to talk about what matters: the facts of the matter.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by acdha on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:05AM (#44190798)
They absolutely were bragging when they said this:

> Tesla's are excellent cars and are still ranked at the top compared to the rest of the market.

The actual facts show otherwise, of course, so now he’s trying the squid ink approach of emitting a lot of verbiage trying to say that average and excellent mean the same thing, but that’s just a distraction from the fact that their first statement was based on brand loyalty, not data.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by robertlagrant on Thursday June 05, 2025 @09:31AM (#44191552)
This is what I mean - my impression is you can't tell the difference between someone commenting on a product and someone boasting about something they made or did. The OP (as far as we know) is not in a position to brag about the general status of Tesla cars, unless they are a senior person at Tesla.

If I said "BMWs are excellent cars" would I be bragging?

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:18AM (#44191960)
I wasn't bragging, I can't brag about them because I don't own a Tesla nor serve to gain any validation or benefit if they do well or not.

A study has found that perhaps I was wrong in the eyes of a dependability study, but I still think they're an excellent car. I still think that if a Ford owner said that they think their Ford Ranger is an excellent car people wouldn't disagree because a dependability study put them as average.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by csomar on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:49AM (#44190341)
> Tesla's are excellent cars and are still ranked at the top compared to the rest of the market.

> you'll see that Tesla now ranks right near the average. Significantly better than in previous years and ahead of other common car makers.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:10AM (#44191893)
What I was referring to was in comparison to other EV's not all ICE's.

That was my mistake

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by potato3732842 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @01:31PM (#44193826)
>These studies don't really show a decent comparison between EV's, just car makers in general

Which is an absolutely asinine axis of comparison seeing as we live in a reality where different brands take different product lines seriously.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by timewizard on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:12AM (#44189512)
I dislike Tesla as a brand; however, they're not particularly lacking considering their size and price point. JD Power's "ratings" are almost entirely based on surveys and are essentially worthless.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mistercheph on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:29AM (#44189608)
Bruh, JD Power is a joke, they said the Chevy Equinox is the most reliable compact SUV of 2024, look at any of their rankings, it’s all basically random, meaningless noise. I assume they just create hundreds of oveRlapping categories to make sure everyone has something they will pay the license fee to talk about in a commercial
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:29AM (#44189610)
It depends on the segment and time range and market. MotorEasy conducted a survey in 2024 in the U.K. with 29,967 respondents. (https://www.whatcar.com/news/most-reliable-cars/n27337) The Tesla Model Y was the 9th (equal) most reliable car. However Teslas tend to fare poorly in the Consumer Reports survey in the U.S. I suspect one of the reasons for the discrepancy between this market and the U.S. is that the U.K. received Tesla shipments a lot later for new models - years, in fact. This gave Tesla time to iron out first-model issues. Another is potentially the location of manufacture. Most Teslas sold in the U.K. come from China and Germany. Most Teslas sold in the U.S. come from Fremont, California. There were widespread reports of strange manufacturing practises at the Fremont plan during the covid outbreak, like spray-painting cars in makeshift tents.

Interestingly, MotorEasy found that gas and hybrids were the most reliable. Diesel were the least reliable.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by MisterTea on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:58AM (#44192926)
I'd chalk up the low diesel reliability to all the emission systems. Before all the Mercedes D's would run forever, million miles. Even the heavy truck engines could reach a million miles. Now the emission systems including EGR, SCR, and DPF, add injectors, plumbing and electronics. The EGR and DPF systems clog up with soot or burn up from regen
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hartator on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:33AM (#44192679)
Isn’t Tesla Model S Plaid still ranked the fastest (maybe 1 or 2 $300k super cars are faster) while being the safest and have arguably the most advanced self drive available in the market?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by dreamcompiler on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:34AM (#44192686)
My Model Y is the most reliable car I've ever owned, except it eats tires quickly because it's so heavy. Just one anecdote of course.

I'll never buy another one as long as Elon Musk is associated with the company, but I'd be crazy to sell it now because it's paid for and it's a great car.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by bobsomers on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:24AM (#44188852)
They're not actually that great of an EV anymore. The build quality is lackluster and the ride on the Model 3 in particular is quite harsh.

Some of the comments I hear almost universally from prior Model 3 owners when they switch to an Ioniq 5 is how much nicer the ride quality is and how nice it is to have buttons on the dash again.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:34AM (#44188918)
The new Model 3 released in Jan 2024 has resolved the ride harshness
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by nindalf on Thursday June 05, 2025 @03:05AM (#44189116)
Is this like how Full Self Driving is always 12 months away? All the shortcomings of the Tesla you know and hate were solved in the latest model!
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @03:16AM (#44189185)
It’s nothing like that.

There have been comments around the ride harshness of the model 3. In the latest model it has been specifically fixed.

I think any self driving tech at the moment is just terrible and shouldn’t be used, for the record

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hkpack on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:34AM (#44189633)
Should all the current owners are expected to be happy for the new version they did’t own?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Toutouxc on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:18AM (#44190179)
No, but prospective buyers don't need to worry about ride harshness anymore.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hkpack on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:44AM (#44190316)
Supposedly. As far as I understand, whether it was fixed or not will be decided by a completely separate group of people. At some point, Tesla can just lie, and don't expect people will be able to verify.

I think Elon found a glitch it tech-bro reasoning: you promise a product, people believe you and buy it, then they realise that it is not what was advertised, but it is OK, because new version has it now, so you can't complain, it is your fault in the eyes of your peers, you should have made a better research or whatever.

Your FSD has almost got you killed? Don't worry, this is your fault, and anyway the bug was already fixed in the update. Probably. This time for sure.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:24AM (#44192020)
Sorry but its clear you aren't thinking logically.

The changes in the new 2024 version, specifically changed the suspension setup and you can mechanically verify the difference between the models because there were mechanical changes.

You need to drop the FSD rhetoric, there are an enormous amount of Tesla drivers who couldn't care about FSD, but simply enjoying the car as an EV.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hkpack on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:55AM (#44192285)
You are thinking logically only if you are a shareholder. Then it makes absolute sense to think like that to stay hopeful.

From the consumer POV who doesn't own shares in the brand, it makes no sense at all.

> enormous amount of Tesla drivers who couldn't care about FSD but simply enjoying the car as an EV

Are there an enormous amount of disappointed Tesla drivers as well who stuck with it because of a sunk cost fallacy?

Should, for example, CyberTruck owners who spend 150K on a bullet-proof car be happy that in the new 2026 version the panels finally will stop falling off?

Should the few million people who purchased Tesla Model 3 feel better that the new version finally drives like a car?

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @12:19PM (#44193099)
All cars have pain points and whilst people in an existing Model 3 might be annoyed ride quality has been improved in the new model, it is good that the specific pain point has been addressed. Afterall you wouldn't stop improving your car simply because you didn't want to annoy existing customers.

Either way, in prior comments you couldn't come to terms with them possibly fixing something like that in the first place.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by samrus on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:59AM (#44190396)
And what will the prospective buyers need to worry about that the next next version will solve?

Tesla is a low-trust company. Too much grifting

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by jsight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:04AM (#44191833)
No, but they should test drive the car before they buy it and decide if it is acceptable, just like everyone does when they buy a car.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by c0brac0bra on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:49AM (#44192224)
If you bought a first gen android should you be mad that you didn't buy a second gen android?

Is this the new "how would you feel if you didn't eat breakfast yesterday?"?

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by panick21_ on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:02AM (#44192366)
You should relax a bit. Model 3 ride was a bit 'sporty' compared to others. Some people like that, other prefer it softer. There really isn't a clear 'right' and 'wrong' here. But on avg. people seem to prefer it a bit softer, so they adjusted it slightly.

Successive version always do slight changes like that over time, that how car companies work. Old owners don't need to be happy about it, or think about it at all.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:31AM (#44189620)
No it's pretty good now. This isn't a software update. It's either softer or it's not. Of course it is subjective. There are plenty of cars with even softer rides, but they tend to feel a lot more floaty, especially in corners, and I personally don't like that.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by _s_a_m_ on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:46AM (#44188989)
is that you again Elmo?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by LightBug1 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:45AM (#44190323)
Still ugly af. Wouldn't touch it. The only well designed car ever made was the model S, and even that is long in the tooth now and was due a refresh 5 years ago. But CYbeRtrUck ...

Combine that with FSD rubbish bait and switch, nutjob CEO, and the cratering of any brand goodwill ... I won't touch those cars if you paid me (seriously).

And honestly, I recognise the innate progression of the technology ... but others have caught and surpassed to the point that I don't have to worry about buying the lesser car anymore when I go elsewhere.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by markdog12 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:06AM (#44190430)
I have a Model 3 2024 and the "ride quality" is beyond any other vehicle I've been in. I genuinely get a little excited every time I drive it. Best car I've ever been in or drove, and it's not close.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by noitpmeder on Thursday June 05, 2025 @09:25AM (#44191498)
If you want to provide anything other than your isolated impression it'd be helpful to know what cars you're comparing it too. Civics? Audis? Ford F150s?

On the whole seems a little... over enthusiastic...

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by strix_varius on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:05AM (#44192396)
All this tells me is that you haven't driven very many types of vehicle.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by speedgoose on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:25AM (#44190534)
Is the 2025 Ioniq 5 still running a laggy and old looking Android 4 for its infotainment?
[dead]
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by tomhow on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:12PM (#44195350)
Please edit swipes out of comments. It's one of the first and most important things we ask for in the Comments section of the guidelines.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by misiti3780 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:56PM (#44195695)
"the Ioniq 5 is a piece of garbage compared to a 2025 model 3"
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by misiti3780 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:25PM (#44196811)
[flagged]
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by tomhow on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:57PM (#44197454)
Not that it should matter but those downvoting your comments have high karma and long histories of making positive contributions here.

Please just make an effort to use HN as it's intended. It's only a place where people want to participate because so many people put effort into keeping it that way.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mattmanser on Thursday June 05, 2025 @03:18AM (#44189200)
The cybertruck is an excellent car?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by NoPicklez on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:27AM (#44189599)
I wouldn’t know but I was speaking on behalf of the model 3/Y.

It’s easy to pick the worst model of the lot and use it to disregard the entire brand, but I can’t expect any more critical thought from some online

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by guappa on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:48AM (#44189716)
> I can’t expect any more critical thought from some online

Thank you for contributing to lower the overall amount of critical thinking on the internet.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by sirdvd on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:33AM (#44189631)
> Well because Tesla's are excellent cars and are still ranked at the top compared to the rest of the market.

whilst surely top ranked, they apparently share the top with others makers (https://www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-rewards/latest-safety-ra...) (Large Family Cars category, last two years, order by occupant protection).

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by dashundchen on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:32AM (#44191038)
Tesla came out last in a 2-3 and 4-5 reliability comparison by the German inspection service TÜV, for the past two years.

https://www.carscoops.com/2024/11/tesla-model-3-comes-bottom...

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mmmlinux on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:04AM (#44191838)
Do they have CarPlay yet?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by jmyeet on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:30AM (#44192080)
But they aren't. What Tesla has going for them primarily is the Supercharger network.

The Cybertruck is a complete disaster of a vehicle with so many issues (eg [1]) that the only reason people buy them is to make a political statement from a group that 3+ years ago wouldn't have been caught buying an EV.

Teslas are drivable iPads. Many people (myself included) not only hate this (because it's hard to use without looking) but it's also lazy design. By this I mean, it allows manufacturers to say "we'll fix it with a software update" (and then probably never get around to it) whereas haptic controls require more thought and effort to be put into the UI/UX during manufacturing.

For other Teslas, there have been a host of other issues, some small, some not. For example, the seats were unreliable if adjusted too often so Tesla made an OTA update to limit how much you can adjust the seats to avoid failure [2].

The only thing propping up Tesla sales now are trade restrictions on BYD.

[1]: https://apnews.com/article/cybertruck-recall-tesla-elon-musk...

[2]: https://driveteslacanada.ca/news/tesla-now-monitors-how-ofte...

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by horns4lyfe on Thursday June 05, 2025 @09:15PM (#44197027)
So what it has going for it is the most importantly part of the EV ecosystem?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by neepi on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:06AM (#44188755)
I don't understand it either. Anybody I know recently in the UK only got one for political reasons or to stick it to the system in some naive way. I wish I was joking. This is even more sad.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by pavlov on Thursday June 05, 2025 @03:32AM (#44189278)
These are the same people who are staunchly opposed to regulating emissions in any way.

So in a way it’s great that they’ve been convinced to buy zero-emissions vehicles by giving them a reactionary edgelord option that’s just like every other EV. (Except for the suicide FSD mode which is more like a Darwin awards filter.)

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by thrance on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:04AM (#44189461)
Vice signalling? They are the best way to advertise to the world that you hate muslims and trans people.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by JKCalhoun on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:07AM (#44190439)
Ha ha, vice signaling. Good phrase for pickup trucks "rolling coal".
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by UberFly on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:11AM (#44188786)
I get the feeling you didn't actually read the article.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by para_parolu on Thursday June 05, 2025 @01:55AM (#44188696)
Can’t say for everyone but there are not many alternatives with similar features on us market
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by seanhunter on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:48AM (#44189007)
That may have been true 4 years ago but it’s far from true now. The only feature Tesla has that no other car seems to have is that minimalist “dentist’s waiting room decorated in the 1990s to seem futuristic” energy from the interior, which definitely sets Tesla apart although not entirely in a good way.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by para_parolu on Friday June 06, 2025 @10:27AM (#44201274)
I don’t think this discussion makes sense without pointing to specific models. And discussing specific models doesn’t make sense without establishing what are the set of required properties (which is different for everyone). I was just pointing out that for some people (including me) there are no other cars with similar properties that I need.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:27AM (#44189595)
As someone who recently bought a Tesla, nothing comes close for the price to the Model Y in terms of range, performance, trunk space, and software. If you want an EV and value those things, the Model Y is the clear choice.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by MagicMoonlight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @05:18AM (#44189853)
Ioniq 5

Teslas don’t even have a Speedo, let alone a HUD. It’s just an iPad with proprietary software which can’t sync with your phone. Terrible

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:11AM (#44190148)
I'll compare the top spec Ioniq 5 N line with the Model Y AWD Long Range as they're priced the same here in Denmark. The Ioniq has 520 liters of trunk space vs 854 in the Model Y. The Ioniq has 495km of range vs the Y's 586. Software isn't even close - I have tried both. The Tesla wins hands down on software. The only metric the Ioniq wins on is acceleration. Specifically when using special boost mode from stopped. It can do 0-100 in 3.4s vs the Y's 4.8s, which is fast.

For me this is a clear win for Tesla. Anything under 5s is crazy fast to me anyway, so the other things I mention are worth a lot more.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hgomersall on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:08AM (#44190445)
The top spec actually has a smaller boot and a lower range due to using dual motors. If you care about such things, good news because you can pay less money, surrendering acceleration which you don't care about.

Subjectively, the boot of the Ioniq 5 on the normal models is huge, and I say that as someone for whom boot size was the primary requirement. Moving the seats forward creates epic amounts of space at the cost of reduced leg room for rear passengers.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:49AM (#44192222)
According to their website the RWD long range (84kw battery) has the same 520L trunk space, 570km range, and only 7.5s 0-100. It’s cheaper but it’s a big downgrade on performance, trunk space, and software.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hgomersall on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:07PM (#44194126)
Well if you actually looked inside one you'd realise that wasn't true. Experience shows that manufacturers' quoted boot space is not worth much.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by hgomersall on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:51PM (#44195660)
FWIW, Hyundai seem to totally hide the false floor in the boot, which turns the so-so boot space into a much more substantial and usable space. The AWD variant does not seem to have anything like as much space under the false floor. Perhaps they don't want to bring attention to the deficiencies of the more expensive variant.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by oblio on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:26AM (#44190992)
Doesn't Tesla measure the trunk volume up to the ceiling while everyone else does it up to about pillar height (i.e. not obstructing view)?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by jsight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:17AM (#44191954)
AFAIK, the whole industry is really inconsistent on this making comparison of factory #s nearly impossible. Things like Bjorn's banana box test are better as practical measures, IMO. The Ioniq 5 and Y are virtually the same, with the winner being decided by whether the seats can be down or not.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:59AM (#44192931)
I just watched both videos. I think the difference is in the shape. The Y is very curved. The Ioniq is much more square. This is going to favour a test using very square and rigid boxes. It’s useful to understand that fact but most of the time I’m not hauling only very square suitcases.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by oblio on Thursday June 05, 2025 @12:06PM (#44192989)
In my experience square is better. Most stuff you will carry will just fit better, I say this as someone who puts a lot of random stuff in there.

And for when I want to carry weirder stuff I fold the backseats. I've carried entire Ikea wardrobes like this.

And the point remains, Tesla learns harder into the deception and lying.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Friday June 06, 2025 @01:08AM (#44197958)
That’s fair. Square does make it easier than playing Tetris with luggage. Still, that extra 63% space, though odd-shaped, has been very useful for us.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by oblio on Friday June 06, 2025 @02:54AM (#44198405)
That's my point, it isn't "63% extra space". Unless you measured everything yourself. Tesla measures it all the way to the ceiling, Hyundai doesn't. I don't know how much the Hyundai doesn't measure but fairly sure it isn't 63%.

Companies used to play these tricks in the 90s. I am NOT happy that Tesla is trying to bring them back.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by jsight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @05:49PM (#44196114)
That is a fair point. I own a Y and have had both sides to this. Sometimes I carry very irregular cargo that fits perfectly and the space is really incredible.

Other times, I have something that should fit, but can't readily fit through the oddly shaped rear hatch and it becomes a problem.

I'd agree with you with regard to luggage. That's a scenario that really hits the strength of the Y setup, especially with the relatively large frunk. I often end up with a few backpack sized items up there on longer trips.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by MagicMoonlight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @02:36PM (#44194458)
>If I put all the seats down the boot is bigger in the Y than with the seats up in the Ioniq

That’s great but you’re missing the fact that the Ioniq has a HUD. What does the Tesla have? Everything you’ve mentioned is irrelevant. The Ioniq has CarPlay so you don’t touch the software.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Friday June 06, 2025 @01:05AM (#44197949)
The quote you made is not from me. The Y has substantially more trunk space both with the back seats up and down. If you value a HUD more than range, trunk space, and software, more power to you. I don’t. CarPlay only controls the entertainment and navigation. There are many controls hidden behind a crappy UX in the Ioniq.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by seb1204 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @05:49AM (#44190036)
What do you want to sync? I was able to use my phone book contacts and addresses. Use my phone's WiFi for data and play music or videos from any app on my phone. I was able to send destination POI to the car GPS to navigate there. Ticked all my boxes.

Bidirectional charging would be great, everything else is already far up there.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Toutouxc on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:22AM (#44190205)
Well TMY is really efficient for the size, while I've seen hilarious consumption figures for Ioniq 5. Doesn't matter if you charge from solar, but at European electricity prices, TMY is probably significantly cheaper to run.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by cebert on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:21AM (#44190203)
I purchased a 2026 Model Y in April. I love it and it’s the best vehicle I’ve even owned. My Apple phone pairs with the car just fine. I can call my contacts, play audio from my phone etc.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by misiti3780 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:24AM (#44192028)
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by randomcarbloke on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:04AM (#44190114)
Boot-space is literally all it has going for it, you can equal or surpass the other categories for less here in Europe, and if you buy used since used EV's are dirt cheap you could get something significantly better with far better badge-appeal for about the same price.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:13AM (#44190159)
I have a family and a wife who doesn't pack light so it's a pretty important one for us. There are options if I'm willing to drop some of those things, but the Y gives me all of it for a reasonable price.

Do you mean I could get something significantly better if I choose not to get the things which are important to me? Because that would be worse for me, not better. I have never cared about the badge.

Out of interest, if I reduced the trunk space a little, which similarly priced EVs could you recommend with more range and better performance than the Model Y AWD Long Range?

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by randomcarbloke on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:02AM (#44190409)
if range and space make all the difference it rather begs the question...why buy a disposable plastic toy when a real car would be better suited?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @12:58PM (#44193454)
I like the performance of an EV. The acceleration and instant torque is incredible. Plus we’re spending a lot less on gas/power now.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by tpxl on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:21AM (#44190199)
What gets at least equal mileage and is also not tiny? A friend is looking to buy and EV, and his problem specifically is nothing comes close to Teslas range.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by vel0city on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:55AM (#44191241)
Nothing comes close to Tesla's published range because the numbers they post on their marketing aren't real. They're by far more inflated than any other automaker.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:01PM (#44196717)
Tesla inflates their ranges.

My Model 3 Performance is rated for I think 300 miles. In the real world, it can be as low as 230 miles if it's 30F outside and I'm going 75 mph. If it's warm, I'm still looking at ~270 miles at 75 mph. The colder it gets, the lower your range because cold air is denser (increasing drag) and higher usage of the heater drains the battery.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by wilg on Thursday June 05, 2025 @04:57AM (#44189766)
I love my Model Y and would love to buy the new one, but unfortunately the CEO is a fascist traitor and is responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of children. I feel bad for all the engineers and designers who did such great work only to have it put at risk in this way.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mavhc on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:23AM (#44190212)
And every other car company faked their emission results, so are responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of children
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by delecti on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:53AM (#44191213)
I can be fairly confident in the emission results of other EVs.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mavhc on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:34AM (#44192103)
But there's no other mass market EV only company, so all the rest are complicit in Diesel-gate
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:13AM (#44192470)

    > there's no other mass market EV only company
BYD?
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by mavhc on Friday June 06, 2025 @07:45AM (#44199868)
They do make a lot of hybrids, but not mentioned in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_emissions_scandal

So as long as you think China's production methods are morally fine, and don't mind them being in control of your car's software, pick BYD

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:19AM (#44190187)
That sounds like unbelievable hyperbole but I'm not interested in getting into a culture war fight today. It's going to be hard to find a brand which hasn't been associated with bad things before but I wish you luck :)
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by jumpkick on Thursday June 05, 2025 @07:57AM (#44190736)
Deleting USAID may have escaped “cultural war” containment and gone on to becoming something with real, material impact.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by wilg on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:27AM (#44192611)
Rivian seems fine and makes the second best EVs.

But also it’s not hyperbole, though I agree it sounds like it.

Association comes in different strengths and forms. But currently owned and operated by a guy actively destroying my country is much more direct and urgent than most of these associations.

But the larger point is that it seems correct that the only people willing to buy a Tesla anymore have conservative politics.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by Corrado on Thursday June 05, 2025 @09:39AM (#44191614)
I'm the same. I loved my 2020 Model Y when I bought it new and I love my 2020 Model X that I bought used. Both are the best cars I've ever owned. I know that everyone likes to complain about fit and finish but honestly I never noticed a single thing wrong with either of them. They are performant, silent, efficient, and the MX doors make my grandkids giggle (that's worth quite a bit :).

I keep looking for the next EV to buy but every one that I test drive seems lacking, mostly in the software area. Tesla has the software nailed and nobody else can seem to figure it out. I recently drove a Rivian R1S and really liked it, but the software was not great (for a $100K car) and it really disappointing me.

I really feel like Tesla does great work but their leader needs to go. He's smeared the name so badly that I fear it might never recover.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by wilg on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:32AM (#44192656)
Yeah I’m hoping the R2 is an option but FSD has become very critical.

I don’t see how Tesla could even dissociate with him, he owns the board and would have to divest also. I think the only path back is if people forget, conservatives suddenly like EVs, or they strike gold with the robots or something.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by panick21_ on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:36AM (#44192701)
> deaths of hundreds of thousands of children

What? Do you think cutting of foreign aid was done only by Musk and if not for him Trump would personally feed starving kids?

And even if you want to assume that, a few 1000 maybe, for hundreds of thousands I need to see some evidence please.

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by wilg on Thursday June 05, 2025 @01:28PM (#44193802)
Yes I think Musk is personally responsible for the cuts he did as part of the thing he loudly and proudly claimed to be in charge of, enabled by the president he claims to have gotten elected.

I’m not sure why you’re so easy to write off 1000s of deaths, but 300,000 so far is one model, but even if it’s very wrong it’s going to be hundreds of thousands sometime this year in all likelihood. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/05/28/rubio-aid...

Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by csomar on Thursday June 05, 2025 @06:56AM (#44190383)
The Y/3 models are relatively decent and well priced (even competitively priced to the Chinese models). That's 90% of their sales.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure by 77pt77 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:17AM (#44192500)
Not without tariffs they are not.

And the chinese models are just much better.