Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by oblio on Thursday June 05, 2025 @08:26AM
(#44190992)
Doesn't Tesla measure the trunk volume up to the ceiling while everyone else does it up to about pillar height (i.e. not obstructing view)?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by jsight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @10:17AM
(#44191954)
AFAIK, the whole industry is really inconsistent on this making comparison of factory #s nearly impossible. Things like Bjorn's banana box test are better as practical measures, IMO. The Ioniq 5 and Y are virtually the same, with the winner being decided by whether the seats can be down or not.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by Gareth321 on Thursday June 05, 2025 @11:59AM
(#44192931)
I just watched both videos. I think the difference is in the shape. The Y is very curved. The Ioniq is much more square. This is going to favour a test using very square and rigid boxes. It’s useful to understand that fact but most of the time I’m not hauling only very square suitcases.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by oblio on Thursday June 05, 2025 @12:06PM
(#44192989)
In my experience square is better. Most stuff you will carry will just fit better, I say this as someone who puts a lot of random stuff in there.
And for when I want to carry weirder stuff I fold the backseats. I've carried entire Ikea wardrobes like this.
And the point remains, Tesla learns harder into the deception and lying.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by Gareth321 on Friday June 06, 2025 @01:08AM
(#44197958)
That’s fair. Square does make it easier than playing Tetris with luggage. Still, that extra 63% space, though odd-shaped, has been very useful for us.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by oblio on Friday June 06, 2025 @02:54AM
(#44198405)
That's my point, it isn't "63% extra space". Unless you measured everything yourself. Tesla measures it all the way to the ceiling, Hyundai doesn't. I don't know how much the Hyundai doesn't measure but fairly sure it isn't 63%.
Companies used to play these tricks in the 90s. I am NOT happy that Tesla is trying to bring them back.
Re:Tesla seeks to guard crash data from public disclosure
by jsight on Thursday June 05, 2025 @05:49PM
(#44196114)
That is a fair point. I own a Y and have had both sides to this. Sometimes I carry very irregular cargo that fits perfectly and the space is really incredible.
Other times, I have something that should fit, but can't readily fit through the oddly shaped rear hatch and it becomes a problem.
I'd agree with you with regard to luggage. That's a scenario that really hits the strength of the Y setup, especially with the relatively large frunk. I often end up with a few backpack sized items up there on longer trips.