News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zhivota on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:08PM (#43938384)
I worked at two National Laboratories, Argonne and Idaho, on NSF funded internship grants. The second one turned into a full time job, again on an NSF grant.

The first one was on supercomputing, writing proof of concept code for a new supercomputing operating system (ZeptoOS). The second was on the automated stitching of imagery from UAVs for military applications (at a time when this was not commoditized at all, we were building UAVs in a garage and I was writing code derived from research papers).

Seeing all the programs that launched my career get dismantled like this is really saddening. There are/were thousands and thousands of college students getting exposed to cutting edge research via these humble programs, and I assume that is all now over. It didn't even cost much money. I got paid a pretty low stipend, which was nonetheless plenty to sustain my 20 year old self just fine. I think the whole program may have cost the government maybe $10k total.

$10k to build knowledge of cutting edge science that filters into industry. $10k to help give needed manpower to research projects that need it. $10k to give people who otherwise didn't have a road into science, exactly what they need to get their foot in the door.

I don't know how to describe what's happening here, but it's really, really stupid.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjtheblunt on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:11PM (#43938419)
> and I assume that is all now over.

it's quite possible it's the first step of a reorg, though. i say that as also someone who worked on supercomputing and with an NSF grant myself.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zhivota on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:16PM (#43938474)
You could be right... I'm just going off of what I've seen in the other departments they touched. Let's hope at least this program would be left untouched.

https://www.nsf.gov/funding/initiatives/reu

There are tons more though, this is only the tip of the iceberg of what the NSF funds of course.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjtheblunt on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:18PM (#43938496)
agreed, and yeah reorg makes more sense, but we'll see.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by davrosthedalek on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:20AM (#43943203)
It seems a lot of REUs were not funded this year. One of my students applied to 25 REUs. He says about a third of them evaporated because of funding stops.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by netsharc on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:19PM (#43938510)
How is it possible that you still see the chance that the actions are being done in "good faith"? In my opinion you'd have to construct a lot of "visual barriers" in order to not see the "full picture" of what kind of people the current regime is made of, and what their motivations would be...

You'd have to be looking away, because looking at it would mean admitting you've been wrong.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjtheblunt on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:23PM (#43938551)
i didn't say what you said. i just observed there might be a reorg, good faith or not, happening.

that's a hell of a lot of extrapolating and guesswork you use, all wrong, incidentally.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by unethical_ban on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:37PM (#43940265)
If it isn't happening in good faith, then you can't call it a "reorg". That's like shooting something in the head and saying you "reorganized" their brain matter.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjtheblunt on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:14PM (#43941414)
The article itself says it's a reorg...but isn't clear if it's more.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by magicalist on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:08PM (#43941776)
> The article itself says it's a reorg...but isn't clear if it's more.

It also says they're firing a bunch of subject matter experts and want to slash the budget by 55%. What other "more" are you looking for?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by dontlikeyoueith on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:23PM (#43939163)
It's quite possible tariffs will make us all rich too.

Why post something this useless?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kevin_thibedeau on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:37PM (#43938694)
Hard to declare that the earth is only 6000 years old with all those science hippies in the way. Gotta set priorities.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by baxtr on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:05PM (#43938999)
What do you mean when you say "only"?!
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by dredmorbius on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:59PM (#43940396)
The Ussher Chronology, held fast to by many Christian religious fundamentalists / extremists through Young Earth Creationism:

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ussher_chronology>

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young_Earth_creationism>

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tobyjsullivan on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:55PM (#43941268)
Many scientists believe the earth is, in fact, much older than that.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by 47282847 on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:57PM (#43941691)
One is religious freedom, the other is science. You pick which is which. ;)
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kens on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:28PM (#43942999)
A bit over 6000 years old: the specific date that Ussher determined for creation is October 23, 4004 BC, an amusing level of precision.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by croon on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @09:54AM (#43984592)
Just had to check, and that date was a Sunday, but that's when the big guy rested, so I'd argue that date is inconsistent within the lore to begin with.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by prox on Saturday May 10, 2025 @01:46AM (#43943480)
It is said jokingly, but wait until you read this, go the goals section.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_Network_Charismati...

This network is closely aligned with Trump. Paula White did the invocation at the 2016 inauguration.

[dead]
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kjkjadksj on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:20PM (#43939137)
Must be why you pay for college right, no demand otherwise they’d be paying you!
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tristor on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:06PM (#43939561)
In some ways, actually yes. College has gotten more expensive over time, partly because demand for college has outweighed the benefits of college on the other side. It is a shift in the education market away from the cost profile being aligned with outputs, to being focused on prestige/experience as the primary selling point. It's also largely related to the glut of paying foreign students nearly outnumbering Americans.

Prior to these shifts, college was much much much less expensive.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by guywithahat on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:55PM (#43939439)
I think you messed up your grammar which makes the sentence hard to read but I think what you're getting at is right. College is a service, which is why you pay for it. If it didn't provide value, nobody would use it. Free college is a danger because there's no good way to assess its market value or whether we need it at all.

It's only by adding value that we create wealth, and some of these NSF grants are just jobs programs for engineers.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by SequoiaHope on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:31PM (#43941538)
> Free college is a danger because there's no good way to assess its market value or whether we need it at all.

You should figure out why free college is so successful for Germany.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by SequoiaHope on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:32PM (#43939243)
Efficient market fallacy.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by overfeed on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:21PM (#43939149)
>$10k to give people who otherwise didn't have a road into science, exactly what they need to get their foot in the door.

The current admin thinks those $10k grants are better spent by giving them to some billionaire via tax cuts. Impoverishing the many to enrich a few is a 3rd-world, banana-republic mindset, and unfortunately is not self-correcting.

The politically-connected will see the pile of money controlled by the treasury as easy money, unless there is some organization with enough independence and (arresting) power keeping a check on them.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by trhway on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:59PM (#43939488)
That $10K breeds a Democratic/progressive voter. The actions of the current admin are pretty logical if one considers the goal of increasing political power of the conservative populist mass (i don't say "voters" here as making voting meaningless is among the end-games here)

I'm waiting for an analog of my "favorite" AETA laws to be made into federal law (FETA - Federal Enterprise Terrorism Act) criminalizing any anti-government speech/protest into terrorist/extremist hell. Note about the First Amendment - AETA doesn't seem to be affected by it, and so FETA would be safe from it too. Would be pretty similar to the Russia's discreditation laws and those China' security laws being used against democratic opposition in Hong Kong for example.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by schmidtleonard on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:52PM (#43940760)
For those who think this is exaggeration, remember that JD Vance wrote a heartfelt endorsement for the skull book, the one arguing that anyone who opposes MAGA is a secret communist revolutionary who needs to be crushed by any means necessary to avoid an imagined communist genocide that they allege we are all plotting. Absolutely wild shit.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unhumans

It's not even midterm season yet, they are already testing the waters by conducting extrajudicial deportations of random Hispanics to labor camps in El Salvador, and the sitting US President is on record saying the El Salvador labor camps need to be expanded by 5x to accommodate the "home growns."

Dark times ahead.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by trhway on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:42PM (#43941178)
The issues of speech, hate, deportations are the very visible ones. The less visible is for example changing the nature of US government.

The old government bureaucracy which was focused on protecting people - consumer protection, EPA, civil rights, etc. - is being dismantled, and new bureaucracy is being built in place to enforce myriad of new restrictions and dole out import/export/tariff quotas, exceptions, and other government favors (those being given out as favors is a key here). The old bureaucracy was progressive. The new is conservative and oppressive, and will be keeping tight chockhold on the main drivers of the progressivism - free trade and tech innovation. (don't take my word for it, just look at such bureaucracies in other countries)

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by yupitsme123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:06PM (#43942916)
The old bureaucracy stopped being progressive long ago. I believe the EPA protects the environment about as much as I believe DOGE is about creating efficiencies.

At this point these organizations are just tools for the administration in power to hand out favors and therefore maintain support. The worthwhile work they do is secondary.

Trump is simply getting rid of the ones that aided democrats and creating new ones that will allow him to aid his own supporters.

Also I don't see the connection between progressivism and free trade/tech innovation. If anything, the latter only aid the status quo rather than helping it to progress.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kashunstva on Saturday May 10, 2025 @02:38AM (#43943645)
> believe the EPA protects the environment about as much as I believe DOGE is about creating efficiencies.

The EPA is (was?) an enormous set of programs encompassing a range of environmental concerns. Undoubtedly some are more effective than others. But to claim without evidence that it is ineffective is disingenuous. I was around in the 60’s and 70’s.

Interestingly, the EPA was established by Richard Nixon, in an age when his party was also about creating things rather than indiscriminately dismantling them.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by graycat on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:41PM (#43941170)
> some billionaire via tax cuts

The current noisy news is taxes for the rich the same or higher, not "cuts".

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by vel0city on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:17PM (#43942727)
Only for those too ignorant to actually understand what's being extremely loosely proposed. And he's totally non-committal about the whole vague thing.

Hiking income taxes on W2 salaries isn't going to touch those billionaires. They'll still get massive tax cuts.

And that's assuming he's actually saying these things in good faith.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by graycat on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:46AM (#43944409)
"noisy news"
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by moralestapia on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:40PM (#43939301)
>I don't know how to describe what's happening here, but it's really, really stupid.

We don't really know what's going on so we cannot jump into conclusions, as you appropriately admit, perhaps there's a very good reason behind all of this.

As the popular saying goes, "Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened" :). Seems to me that you enjoyed many years of a comfy job where you also had a lot of fun, that's a privilege very few people find themselves enjoying, I wish I had that on my early career!

Edit: "Hey, I'm glad you had those things!" turns into downvotes somehow? Weird.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ChrisLTD on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:47PM (#43939370)
If there is a good reason, the administration is welcome to communicate to the public. This is reportedly a democracy, after all.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Arainach on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:58PM (#43939968)
We do know what's going on because they wrote all of this down including their motives and end goals well before the elections.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by lmeyerov on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:35PM (#43940246)
I started a company that makes a bunch of many every year based off of NSF research, and Nvidia is making even more based on our work that spun out. I'm not a unique story, yet they cut half the NSF budget and half the NSF-funded STEM grad students (NSF GRFP, ...).

So no, whatever the NSF was doing, we should be encouraging more of it, not half of it. NSF/NIH are much more valuable investments than billionaire tax cuts as they're some of the most valuable things humanity can be doing in general, dollar-for-dollar.

I try to avoid Left/Right topics, but as others point out, this one is more like Russian Talking Points for US Special Interest Groups, and beyond being anti-american, is anti-human.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by unethical_ban on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:36PM (#43940256)
Don't cry because [the United States has decided to turn its back on science and research and foreign aid], smile because we were great once :)

You didn't say "I'm glad you had those things". And if that's what you meant, then you are listening to this person's story as some personal tale of nostalgia instead of a reflection on what is being broken in our country.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by SalmoShalazar on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:15PM (#43940091)
You’re getting downvoted because of your childlike naïveté and/or willful ignorance. There is no hidden “very good reason” lurking somewhere. They are slashing and burning the federal government.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by moralestapia on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:56PM (#43942879)
Personal attacks are not allowed here.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by saagarjha on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:31AM (#43944095)
That's not a personal attack. You're just wrong.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by moralestapia on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:18AM (#43945839)
In your dreams.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by calmbonsai on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:50PM (#43939401)
Preach! It even touched high-schoolers.

I got a high school internship on an NSF grant to study ground penetrating radar for landmine detection. It was my first exposure to Maxwell's equations, Unix, networking, and most importantly how real research gets done.

I took away lifelong management and research mores, a love of Unix, and ended up getting my degree in EE.

These cuts will have huge follow-on costs that we can't later simply re-budget to recover.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by whycome on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:37PM (#43939786)
Yeah but those problems will happen under a democratic president and that will allow republicans to blame them
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sitkack on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:52PM (#43939913)
What makes you think there will be another democratic president to blame?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by CamperBob2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:12PM (#43939605)
I don't know how to describe what's happening here

You can describe it as a deliberate and very successful attack by America's enemies, because that's what it is.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sheepscreek on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:32PM (#43939750)
What’s in it for people like the current Trade and Treasury Secretaries, heck even the V.P? In their previous lives, they seemed levelheaded - yet here we are.

Is it just pure selfishness, “if I don’t do it, someone else will” mentality?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by generic92034 on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:11PM (#43940055)
There never was any shortage of opportunists.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sixothree on Saturday May 10, 2025 @02:55AM (#43943724)
The VP seems level-headed? He's a moldable piece of wet clay. How can you even begin to suggest stability would come from this person?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sheepscreek on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:29PM (#43946868)
“seemed” - past-tense. Before he became VP nominee. He had an arguably strong vocal stance against many things he stands for now. Truly perplexing. You’re both right in basically calling this “opportunistic” or supremely mouldable, perhaps even morally flex and incompetent behaviour. It’s a shame.

Still I wonder if post current admin, there is a way these people could still redeem themselves. I want to think that at least some are using the new found focus to get shit done for good, perhaps at the expense of looking like puppets or yes men/women (publicly).

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by CamperBob2 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:52PM (#43947071)
I want to think that at least some are using the new found focus to get shit done for good, perhaps at the expense of looking like puppets or yes men/women (publicly).

I imagine a lot of them rationalized their decisions that way, as you suggested earlier. "If I don't take this job with Trump, he'll give it to a corrupt crony or some random nutcase. But if I do take it, I can work for positive change from the inside. Hmm. I really don't have a choice, do I?"

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sheepscreek on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:19PM (#43950743)
> If I don't take this job with Trump, he'll give it to a corrupt crony or some random nutcase. But if I do take it, I can work for positive change from the inside. Hmm. I really don't have a choice, do I?

True though, isn’t it? Election has already been won. If you get ostracized from the party, won’t do any good to anyone.

Hmm. Extending that logic, maybe there isn’t a clear right or wrong. Just decisions and consequences. Do what you can and hope for the best. Not a fun way to work (or live).

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by lossolo on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:31PM (#43939747)
> I don't know how to describe what's happening here, but it's really, really stupid.

It's just a cynical game to get the highest tax cuts for their buddies and sponsors.

https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2025/05/08/congress/jo...

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by rcpt on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:35PM (#43940244)
There are no tax cuts because of this. The money saved is a rounding error in the federal budget.

This is an ideological purge.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by lesuorac on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:04PM (#43940427)
Only if you constrain yourself with reality.

Musk was floating a DOGE dividend with all the money being saved. It'll of course be funded the same was covid checks were but that doesn't mean you have to be honest about how its funded.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by hackyhacky on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:35PM (#43940248)
> It's just a cynical game to get the highest tax cuts for their buddies and sponsors.

Not at all. We mustn't forget that it's also a cynical punishment for universities who consistently vote for the wrong person.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by bitmasher9 on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:43PM (#43940299)
The upcoming generation will be plenty happy with factory jobs instead of jobs in supercomputing or science.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Frost1x on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:49PM (#43940730)
I know you’re being facetious, but I think there’s some nugget buried in this sarcasm.

One issue with our ever increasingly intellectual focused economy is that it leaves behind people who may just not be cut out for these such careers. I’m not against having these economies (I too used to work in supercomputing, with national labs), they’re very necessary, but we need to find a way for people who might not fit very well in such positions to still feel productive in society, and most importantly, still live comfortably in society. Industry and jobs need to exist for people who can’t do science and supercomputing or at least aren’t cut out for it as a career day in/out to still live comfortably.

Bringing back manufacturing isn’t the answer to that, but at some point as competition pulls the bar up so high and specific, we leave a lot of people behind, and I’m not sure it’s a good thing. They surely have plenty of other skills that contribute to society as well and even if they don’t, they should also be taken care of for at least trying. Maybe it’s just a lack of opportunity in education and training that fixes it, maybe it’s other careers that pay will, maybe it’s government subsidies, but I think plenty of the discourse now promoting these ideas like manufacturing are founded on shrinking of the middle class, and that’s partly due to how demanding it is now to live at that level of general financial security.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by bitmasher9 on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:15PM (#43940934)
I have a bit of a bias in advocating more for enabling excellence than accommodating average. I will concede we have done a terrible job at sharing the harvest, but it’s often the excellent that are responsible for our harvest being so plentiful to begin with.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by reverius42 on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:47PM (#43941998)
This is a great explanation for why "no child left behind" is not the right strategy for education.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sfpotter on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:07PM (#43941370)
Expand your view of what constitutes excellence.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by roenxi on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:26PM (#43942222)
I agree with the perspective, the part I have trouble marrying it back to is the taxpayer funding and the NSF. The excellent & the people who benefit from their work tend to have lots of money and earning opportunities and are more than capable of just funding the research themselves.

If there is a large group of people who aren't benefiting they don't need to be involved in the funding and the organising either. It is a mistake to make research subject to political pressure if there is a significant political faction who doesn't think it is worthwhile for them.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by 1auralynn on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:05PM (#43942912)
No not all talented scientists are independently wealthy or have the charisma to raise VC funding. What you're advocating for is the return of the era of the "gentleman scientist" where the only people allowed to do science are those lucky enough to be born into wealth (or some other privilege e.g. extreme good looks).
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by rsfern on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:26PM (#43942532)
I’ve served as a reviewer for a couple of NSF panels, and one of the things I really liked about the program I reviewed for is that a lot of the proposals included collaborations with local trade and vocational schools to involve and train future technicians and operators in addition to researchers and scientists. I think that’s really important for actually succeeding at the technology transfer goals of NSF, and if I’m reading your comment it does at least partly address delivering direct value for a broader chunk of the population
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by taurath on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:33PM (#43942554)
Expand your definition of "responsible". Not all stories are the Heroes Journey. Its just the one that gets people to accept the most exploitation and work the hardest.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zero-sharp on Saturday May 10, 2025 @07:53AM (#43944953)
I can't tell if you actually read the comment that you're responding to because you seem to be ringing the same bell. The issue at hand is creating opportunities for people who are clearly not cut out for white collar work. Framing this as "enabling excellence vs accommodating average" is out of touch and sounds extremely arrogant.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by fakedang on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:20PM (#43940977)
Well they ought to learn to code /s

Or try out braindead jobs like HR /s

Jibs aside, the key issue is that a lot of folks just seem to stop learning after a certain point, even if it's their chosen occupation since decades. And it's not just limited to the factory workers themselves - how many of us have met a stubborn doctor unwilling to try out a new treatment mode, or a senior banker too stubborn to learn basic Excel functions. While those folks enjoy secure jobs regardless of their proficiency in modern technology, the folks at the lower rungs of the manufacturing ladder don't. Even if they do have the desire to learn, learning anew today has become an onerous process in most fields.

We really have a Continuous Learning problem that has to be solved here - helping people reskill or deepskill easier, if they have the mentality to improve upon themselves.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by MegaButts on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:44PM (#43941975)
> if they have the mentality to improve upon themselves

There's the rub. In my experience, and I understand anecdata is only so useful, people that really want to keep learning more than they have to are quite rare. I doubt that group is even 10% of people. If you only surround yourself with nerds who code for fun, you are going to have an extremely biased view on this issue.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by rwyinuse on Saturday May 10, 2025 @03:29AM (#43943869)
Nerds who code for fun often also have the advantage of being single and childless. One's capability for learning and self-improvement really diminishes once you have one or two small kids at home. It's pretty much like working two full time jobs until they go to school and become more independent.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by dfedbeef on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:06AM (#43943143)
Uh... I think it's more likely this is all the result of the 24 hour for-profit entertainment 'news' network which has been pushing this conspiracy theory bs for the last 40 years.

You have a media ecosystem devoted to encouraging division, inventing problems when there are none, and finding people to blame for things.

Use your eyes and ears. It's right there.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by watwut on Saturday May 10, 2025 @11:12AM (#43946311)
The agencies and programs paying for poor youth work preparation and education were slashed last week or so. Mind you, it was not college education, but basic skills for more manual jobs.

These were also people who would order parts from china for their niche board game or whatever. These were people working fire prevention, people whose lungs are the most affected when there are no safety and environmental regulations.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by voidspark on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:02PM (#43942078)
"The budget request explicitly states it "cuts funding for: climate; clean energy; woke social, behavioral, and economic sciences; and programs in low priority areas of science," while maintaining funding for AI and quantum information sciences at current levels."
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by bigbadfeline on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:46PM (#43949260)
> "and programs in low priority areas of science"

One man's low priority is another man's life-saving research.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by alephnan on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:57AM (#43944220)
If putting fries in the bag at McDonald’s payed half as much as being a FANG engineer, I would pick McDonald’s
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by abraae on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:17PM (#43940506)
It's the American experience that decisions are made at the executive level based on faulty intelligence, while people working at the coal face such as yourself have a much better understanding of what's really going on.

Case in point the Vietnam war, which cost thousands of lives because decisions were based on statistics from the field which had been heavily manipulated as they percolated upwards.

Right now, just as one tiny example, we see the effect of tariffs on prototyping services such as JLPCB, a chinese-based company which makes on demand printed circuit boards.

There is no way that it makes sense to dramatically increase the costs to US companies and citizens of creating PCBs which are critical components at the heart of many new products. All that will do is to drive innovation away from the gifted hacker working from his garage in Michigan, and towards countries other than the USA who can order PCBs at reasonable prices. I'll guarantee that no one understands this at the level where these decisions are made.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by benzible on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:03PM (#43942081)
"Faulty intelligence" accepts that DOGE / Russell Vought / Project 2025 are sincerely concerned with government spending. The evidence says that this is deliberate sabotage of government functions to erode public trust. Consider:

Douglas Holtz-Eakin (former Republican CBO director) noted DOGE is specifically "going into agencies they disagree with" for ideological reasons, targeting programs that are a tiny fraction of the federal budget. https://thefulcrum.us/governance-legislation/doge-layoffs-tr...

OMB Director Russell Vought explicitly stated his intention for federal workers to be "traumatically affected" - showing disruption is the intended goal. https://www.govexec.com/transition/2025/04/project-2025-want...

DOGE cut specialized IRS teams that brought in billions despite small costs. One team of <10 people had recovered $5 billion over four years before being fired. https://www.propublica.org/article/how-doge-irs-cuts-will-co...

DOGE has repeatedly made fraud claims that "none have held up under scrutiny" - appearing designed to undermine public trust rather than address actual problems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Department_of_Government_Effic...

The pattern is clear: target high-visibility but relatively low-cost programs (like NSF internships) that provide tangible benefits to citizens. When services deteriorate, people naturally ask "why am I paying taxes for this?" - which is exactly the intended outcome.

A $10k internship that launches careers and advances American innovation is precisely the type of program that makes visible the value of government - which is why it's being targeted despite minimal fiscal impact.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Loughla on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:42PM (#43942303)
Something, something small enough to drown it in the bathtub.

This isn't new. Republicans have always worked to erode government offerings to justify further cuts. What is new is the scale and speed.

Is there literally nothing Congress can do or are they just doing nothing?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by breckenedge on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:59PM (#43942397)
They’ve been doing nothing for decades.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ethbr1 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:20PM (#43942738)
> They’ve been doing nothing for decades.

Here's a list of the 250+ pieces of nothing that the 118th Congress passed.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acts_of_the_118th_Un...

If you're going to reach for hyperbole, at least make it defensible.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by elevation on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:15PM (#43942955)
Congress hasn't passed a budget in decades, and hasn't done it consistently for decades more.

Instead, they consistently cede their legislative authority to bureaucrats by creating office after office of unelected regulators who generate reams of rules with the power of law but with no democratic oversight.

They haven't been doing nothing in the literal sense, but when it comes to governing they're institutionally derelict in their duties.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by throwup238 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:53PM (#43943098)
> Instead, they consistently cede their legislative authority to bureaucrats by creating office after office of unelected regulators who generate reams of rules with the power of law but with no democratic oversight.

The irony of saying that in a thread about the NSF getting gutted is palpable.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by scheme271 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:52AM (#43943318)
That's clearly not accurate. Congress has passed continuing resolutions in some years but they've also passed budgets. E.g in 2024, they passed this: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/4366 .
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zvorygin on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:31AM (#43944349)
The Wikipedia article you link states:

> It has been called one of the least productive Congresses since 1951

Let’s not measure productivity in terms of count of bills passed like measuring output by lines of code.

Healthcare reform, SS reform, fiscal sustainability, electoral reform, climate, immigration, information environment, cybersecurity, how many of these pressing issues have been tackled and solved by congress?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ethbr1 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @07:13AM (#43944763)
If "nothing for decades" isn't true, then parent can use different words.

"Least productive" != "nothing"

If language collapses into describing a different reality just because of the way someone feels, then communicating is going to be difficult.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ggandv on Saturday May 10, 2025 @08:18AM (#43945050)
Exactly. They raise campaign funds and appear on tv and cross examine industry leaders like Altman and Zuckerberg. Clearly that is not “nothing”. But some worry that is not enough to keep pace with emerging threats and opportunities and that’s given justification for presidents to increasingly fill that gap, to disastrous effect. Some argue that a single strong leader calling the shots via EOs is better than having congress try to get up to speed on complex, emerging matters (ie AI export controls) but I’m unconvinced.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ethbr1 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:29PM (#43948725)
Something 'taking an Act of Congress' (to indicate that it's difficult and time-consuming) is in the lexicon for a reason. It's been true of the US legislative process for that long.

But!

That isn't to say that after the gears grind, Congress doesn't complete important and essential work, even in toxic times.

The nihilism of a blatently false claim that Congress is doing nothing just feeds into 'so let someone else do it' fervor. Untrue memes can be dangerous.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by watwut on Saturday May 10, 2025 @11:06AM (#43946252)
Congress has two parties in ut and one of them is strictly opposed to all of these. The issue is not doing nothing, the issue is large parts of population and their political representation being actively against it.

Talking about it in abstract, to make it sound like the congress ia a monolith where all are ambivalent ... is part of the problem.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by hedora on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:11PM (#43942940)
Ten democrats in the senate voted with the republicans, giving Trump (filibuster-proof) free rein for his entire agenda for the rest of 2025.

So, yeah, there’s stuff they can do, and they’ve already accomplished a lot this year.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by benzible on Saturday May 10, 2025 @03:28PM (#43948188)
Yes, but Grover Norquist thought the path was tax cuts → Congressionally mandated spending cuts → worse government. Trump/2025/DOGE's big innovation has been skipping the first step and simply ignoring Congress' "power of the purse" and unilaterally (and illegally) withholding spending as they see fit [1]

The US constitutional system was always built on "norms," good faith, and an assumption that even personally corrupt actors in power won't act to burn the whole system down, or will fear the consequences of the rule of law. It's always been the case that Congress and the Supreme Court don't have cops or soldiers at their command, so the enforcement powers of 2 out of 3 branches of the federal government rely to some extent on fears that the system will find some way to dole out consequences, or a good faith belief in the rule of law. Even Nixon resigned once the Supreme Court ruled that he had to release the tapes.

However, the Supreme Court has essentially ruled that a president (at least, a Republican president) is immune from personal consequences for everything, so at this point an authoritarian-minded president can behave as a king. Congressional Republicans would likely prefer not to cede their power but more than that, they don't want to cross Trump for fear of being defeated in a primary by a Trump-backed challenger. The appeal of a job that at this point almost exclusively consists of debasing oneself is beyond me.

[1] A great primer on exactly why this illegal withholding of congressional spending is unconstitutional can be found in Senator Murphy's confrontation with DHS Secretary Noem earlier this week. Murphy documents how the department is illegally impounding funds, violating Supreme Court orders, and ignoring statutory requirements - creating precisely the constitutional crisis predicted when an administration decides it can simply disregard Congress's power of the purse: https://www.murphy.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/murphy...

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by FrustratedMonky on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:33PM (#43949191)
"deliberate sabotage of government functions to erode public trust."

Is there any non-dystopian reason to do this? Is the end game really the collapse of the US?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by benzible on Sunday May 11, 2025 @12:13PM (#43954759)
One person's dystopia is another's Christian nationalist authoritarian paradise. Vought / Project 2025 have been quite explicit in their goals. They believe that they're at war with secular institutions and what they call the "administrative state" - any government function that operates independently of direct political control by the executive branch. That is an explicit goal of doing away with the US Constitutional system. Vought has justified this through conspiratorial nonsense, claiming that the "deep state" has already brought about a "post-Constitutional" order via bureaucratic overreach.

Their plan will mean impoverishment of most of the population, as well as removal of a substantial part of the population through deportation but they're not particularly concerned with that. In their eschatology, non-believers (which includes not just atheists but Catholics, Jews, Muslims, and even other Protestant denominations they deem insufficiently pure) are literally destined for eternal torture in hell. Some of the more extreme elements actively look forward to this as divine justice. Their apocalyptic worldview frames everyone outside their narrow in-group as either potential converts or enemies destined for damnation. Why worry about climate change, democratic institutions, or social welfare when the faithful will be raptured away while the unrighteous suffer? This theological framework makes it remarkably easy to dismiss the suffering of others as either deserved or irrelevant in cosmic terms.

Musk has a different set of motivations. Some of it is just straightforward corruption - killing off agencies and firing specific individuals who have pushed investigations of his various enterprises, as well as awarding contracts to himself (e.g. the FAA Starlink contract, which is genuinely terrifying).

But as far as his motivations to decimate government more generally, I think it's a combination of things. He seems to genuinely believe that dismantling government oversight will unshackle great men such as himself to bring about some techno-libertarian utopia. But I think a lot of it is that his brain has just been pickled by right-wing social media and he's a bit of a useful idiot. The fact that this aligns with Christian nationalist goals is just a convenient overlap.

Then there's the Stephen Miller wing, who are primarily motivated by racism (of course, all of these factions are extremeley racist).

It's all quite grim.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by mattgrice on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:07PM (#43942111)
Well, OK but none of this is based on faulty intelligence as you mean it. Faulty intelligence maybe in the sense that their brains are broken and that is a very different thing.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by decimalenough on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:54PM (#43941259)
> It's the American experience that decisions are made at the executive level based on faulty intelligence, while people working at the coal face such as yourself have a much better understanding of what's really going on.

The article notes that the people being axed are NSF execs making funding decisions, and contrasts this with the NIH, where panels of outside experts make the call.

I can't say I have personal experience with either, but all things being equal, the NIH's model sounds like it would work better, no?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by magicalist on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:57PM (#43941696)
> The article notes that the people being axed are NSF execs making funding decisions, and contrasts this with the NIH, where panels of outside experts make the call.

I believe you're mistaken on both counts? The contrast mentioned in the article is just that for the NSF, division directors alone can potentially scuttle approved grants.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sleet_spotter on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:55PM (#43941681)
NSF also uses expert panels to recommend grants for funding. The systems are very similar.
[dead]
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by umbcorp on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:22PM (#43940989)
I'm one of those garage hackers, I have a quote from PCBWay, $286 for 20 boards including assembly service. I also got quotes from companies in U.S.

- $2700 from a popular company in bay area - $2000 from another new pcb company.

With tarrifs, my PCBWay order is around $789.

I'm new to PCB Design, I cannot afford to do $2700 mistakes, with PCBWay hardware is more accessible.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by donnachangstein on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:32PM (#43941091)
Why are you building 20 boards if you are new to PCB design and can't afford mistakes? That's tremendously risky.

Even pros build a couple proto boards for the first run, and sometimes hand assemble them if able, not.... 20?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Henchman21 on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:12PM (#43940920)
These tariffs are designed to destroy the American economy and primacy on the world stage.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by myko on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:34PM (#43941114)
Pretty much this. Anyone who has paid attention to trump's work knows the goal is to destroy the USA
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by simpaticoder on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:57PM (#43941292)
I've paid attention, and I don't think his goal is to "destroy the USA". His goal is self-enrichment, and side-effects don't matter. He is a master at promising the world, and then deflecting blame when he doesn't deliver, and yet the people love him anyway. It is very easy to destroy something under those circumstances without having the goal of destruction. See Hanlon's Razor.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by gusgus01 on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:49PM (#43941649)
I prefer the corollary: Any sufficiently advanced stupidity is indistinguishable from malice.

At this point, whether it's stupidity, or others taking advantage of that stupidity to induce malicious actions. It doesn't really matter and they should be regarded as malicious and stopped.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by simpaticoder on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:12PM (#43942715)
There is a sense in which wilful ignorance IS malicious. Whether the fruits of that ignorance are therefore malicious is another question. I'm not a lawyer, but I know that they make a clear distinction between intent and ignorance. That is how, in fact, ignorance (or its appearance), becomes a strength. You cannot lie if you don't know. Even better is when you display ignorance but then somehow also have millions of people convinced they can read between the lines that you are not ignorant. "The best way to lie is to tell the truth and not be believed," as Twain once said.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Henchman21 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @01:40PM (#43947428)
I agree with what you’re saying here, but I think it’s important to note that as much as Mr. Trump is convinced he is in charge, there are quite obviously people pulling his strings. He’s a useful tool for more powerful people to wield, and their goals loosely align.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by abraae on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:15PM (#43940942)
> If you don't like it: learn to wire wrap

Actually I know how to wire wrap. I last did it 40 years ago. Technology's moved on.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by donnachangstein on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:30PM (#43941071)
I know, the real tragedy of the impending war with Taiwan will be not being able to order cheap boards for that Arduino card shuffler you built in your garage.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by theshackleford on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:11PM (#43940902)
> In case it wasn't completely clear: stop sending the Chinese money

This is the same thing I’m working to sell people on, only in regards to the US. Working hard to get them to dump US software products and services.

Fingers crossed!

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by throwawaymaths on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:40PM (#43943052)
thats not entirely accurate. a great conterexample was the mark XIV torpedo during world war two. it was faulty and the workers at the bureau of navy ordinance couldnt get their heads out of their asses to fix the problem. meanwhile sailors were dying. admirals and captains kept trying to fix the problem until finally one admiral (king iirc) got so pissed off he shoved the changes through and reformed the bureau of ordinance.

https://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/USN/Admin-Hist/USN-Admin/US...

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by abraae on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:34AM (#43943263)
A great counterexample indeed. Top down hustle getting things moving.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by SpaceNoodled on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:30PM (#43940611)
> it's really, really stupid.

That's it, you've described it.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by donnachangstein on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:53PM (#43940768)
> I think the whole program may have cost the government maybe $10k total.

Your numbers are off by an order of magnitude. There is no government program in existence that costs $10k total, you are almost assuredly ignoring overhead and all other costs. It's like calling a contractor to repair something, then crying foul when he charges $350 because you found the part on Amazon for $15.

But let's assume it was $10k.

> $10k to build knowledge of cutting edge science that filters into industry. $10k to help give needed manpower to research projects that need it. $10k to give people who otherwise didn't have a road into science, exactly what they need to get their foot in the door.

To be blunt, you are upset because you got to work on a fun boondoggle project and others are being denied that privilege. I won't doubt it was fun and educational but I can't in all honesty pretend that is a good value for the taxpayers.

Unless you are producing something of value to the public, it's wasteful, and that $10k deserves to be returned to the taxpayers.

Taxpayers are not on the hook to keep you busy with pointless yet fun busy-work. That is private industry's job.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by schmidtleonard on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:01PM (#43940823)
Money "wasted" by the NSF is far better spent than money wasted in, say, the Google Graveyard or any other monument to private malinvestment. This is because science has a value capture problem by design, making it systematically uninvestable by the private market, making opportunities plentiful -- and making it an archetypal example of a place where government investment has a role to play, because we can capture value as a country that is impossible to capture as a company.

The real scandal is that we don't do more of it: our global competitors do not share the same contempt for science that is increasingly infecting the USA, and slowing our jog as they pass us is the worst strategy I can possibly imagine.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by donnachangstein on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:12PM (#43940918)
This is an opportunity for private industry to step up and step in, while drastically reducing the size of government.

I hear the Juicero had an outstanding power supply.

For all the waste, some folks probably learned a lot about power electronics.

It seems odd to me that of all places, a forum run by a VC outfit, thinks a government jobs program to churn STEM grads with nonsense projects is the way to go.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by counters on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:56PM (#43941284)
> This is an opportunity for private industry to step up and step in, while drastically reducing the size of government.

Did... you actually read the comment you're replying to? They're explicitly stating that there is a large pool of work that _the private sector is actively disincentivized to invest in_, and the only way it gets done is for other mechanisms to fill the gap.

The alternative to federal investment in research isn't the private sector picking up slack. It's for the old patronage system of the 1800's to come back. But that system was effective only when the size of problems was relatively "small" - we need to leverage economies of scale to efficiently pursue many types of cutting edge research.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by intended on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:51PM (#43941659)
Being in such a forum doesn’t mean that many of us aren’t educated about economics.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by schmidtleonard on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:02PM (#43941737)
Also, I bet VCs are far _more_ aware than the average Joe of the wide body of worthwhile but uninvestable ideas. After all, they are responsible for saying "no" to them and gently redirecting them to government/patronage/charity while asking to keep in touch in case the field becomes investable (because that's the story of how their boss got rich).

"Value capture problems don't exist because capitalism is perfect" is the kind of misconception that can only survive far away from the actual process of finding investments and making returns.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by warkdarrior on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:10PM (#43941394)
Those STEM grads took years to train through NSF-funded programs. Why would private industry waste their quarterly revenues on STEM grads who will become useful only after 4-6 years of training?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by int_19h on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:02AM (#43943129)
Perhaps consider why it is that even here, of all places, so many people see this kind of bullshit for what it is?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by saagarjha on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:37AM (#43944122)
Do you think Juicero wanted to end up with a bunch of people who learned how to make an outstanding power supply and nothing else to show for it? Did the actual work on the power supply end up being available to anyone else? Maybe we should have an organization that actively wants to invest in things like this, rather than depending on the waste of VCs?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by counters on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:56PM (#43940790)
> I won't doubt it was fun and educational but I can't in all honesty pretend that is a good value for the taxpayers.

The students who work on these types of projects go on to create technology, companies, and jobs. The skills and experience they learn is a direct injection into our innovation economy.

And of course that's not even to mention that a lot of the things they work on will never get vetted in private industry, so we'll never even know if there is value hidden in the weeds.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by monooso on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:56PM (#43941280)
The assumption that if something doesn't have a clear and immediate ROI it can't possibly have any value is extremely myopic.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by avs733 on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:53PM (#43942038)
It’s also easily abused…the parent post is a pretty solid example of how that happens. More than any individual action by the administration, decades of reinforcement and reification of this thinking in a major segment of society is what is going to doom us.

People celebrating their own destruction by spouting the propaganda they’ve been fed is somehow both terrifying and uniquely interesting to me.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by yupitsme123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:18PM (#43942963)
Sure, but there needs to be some justification or measuring stick to decide what's worth researching and what isn't. Otherwise you're just burning up money and labor on fruitless tasks.

Reading some of the comments in this thread it sounds like people are in favor of spending any amount of money on researching any topic without any discrimination whatsoever. That doesn't sound like a good idea to me.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday May 10, 2025 @03:24AM (#43943850)
Strawman. No one is suggesting that. These programs are vetted by people whose job it is to assess realistic returns.

It's far more extreme - and far less rational - to assert they're worthless, and therefore need to end, based purely on vibes and ideology.

This entire discussion is a 180 from the truth.

These programs shouldn't need defending. Whatever the cranks believe, the returns have been proven decade after decade after decade.

The people who are axing them are the ones who need to justify themselves, not just economically but constitutionally and morally.

So far they've only tried to justify themselves ideologically, which is not even close to being a credible argument.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by intermerda on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:25PM (#43942214)
Who exactly made you in charge of speaking for all the taxpayers?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jasonfarnon on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:19PM (#43941841)
is this type of research really at risk? I thought the feds were after research with an ideological bent. Rather than speculate about how the feds might see certain research as ideological, can we have some concrete examples of the type of research projects that have been discontinued?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by MengerSponge on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:31PM (#43941894)
Okay, take a moment and think: what about this administration has given you the impression that they're going to take the time to carefully understand a system they're bent on dismantling?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jasonfarnon on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:50PM (#43942014)
well, this is kind of my point. We might have different ideas of which "system they're bent on dismantling".
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by saagarjha on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:33AM (#43944103)
You can look at what they're defunding!
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by hobs on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:24PM (#43941873)
Do you know that sealioning on the 1000th ridiculously bad cut is just in bad faith right? At this point we don't actually need to spend time proving how the Trump administration is doing a wrong thing actually, it can be inferred from the other EVERY SINGLE TIME.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by transcriptase on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:24PM (#43942981)
So you’re saying being the NPC who endlessly repeats “Orange man bad!” is not only the morally responsible thing to do, but the logical thing as well.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by saagarjha on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:34AM (#43944107)
Oh, you should be going "orange man bad", but there's no need to be an NPC about it. Organize against it.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by intermerda on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:21PM (#43942200)
But you see AI has a liberal bias. Even Musk's own AI is too woke because it isn't producing the "right" kind of humor - https://youtu.be/7qZl_5xHoBw?t=6159.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by NoahKAndrews on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:47PM (#43942618)
A few examples focusing on climate change, which I hope we can all agree is extremely critical.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2025/05/climate-disasters-th...

https://arstechnica.com/science/2025/04/trump-admin-may-be-t...

https://www.propublica.org/article/noaa-contracts-seattle-la... (damage is being done even when programs aren't explicitly cancelled)

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by vel0city on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:19PM (#43942733)
"ideological bent" like greenhouse gasses cause climate change and guns just might actually kill people and 2+2=4.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by mullingitover on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:20PM (#43942494)
“These geese which lay golden eggs are costing a lot of taxpayer dollars, we’re going to save a lot of money on corn when we butcher them.”
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by almosthere on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:24PM (#43942761)
I think the problem with seeing it this way, is someone was making $1M as overhead to hire you for 10k.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by davrosthedalek on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:18AM (#43943195)
Who do you think made $1M overhead on this 10k?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by plasma_beam on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:00PM (#43942895)
Proud to say that in the early-mid 2000s I was a consultant dev at NSF and worked on the research proposal submission and eval website called Fastlane. They’ve since moved the functionality to research.gov, but my code ran in production for 20ish? years? It was old school Java Struts, JSPs, EJB’s..typical J2EE of the time. Lots of people I worked with decided to leave consulting and became NSF employees. They were good and smart people.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zoklet-enjoyer on Saturday May 10, 2025 @07:49PM (#43950010)
>The second was on the automated stitching of imagery from UAVs for murder applications

Fixed that for you

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zhivota on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:40PM (#43950859)
FWIW the application was to send up UAVs after Air Force runways were attacked to isolate exact locations and sizes of damage, to allow for the fastest possible fixes to be made. In these situations, seconds and minutes matter as the planes in the air need a place to land before they run out of fuel.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zoklet-enjoyer on Sunday May 11, 2025 @12:33AM (#43951402)
Oh, that's pretty interesting