News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by haswell on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:40PM (#43928001)
There are some people in my circles who have remained convinced that tariffs won’t actually amount to anything and that it’s all bluster.

It seems we’re now entering the “find out” stage, and it’s incredibly frustrating.

As a tinkerer who loves building things, this is heartbreaking stuff. I have projects in progress that may have to be put on hold.

I tend to order things as I need them, but it’s tempting to stockpile the basics. But I don’t think it will help much in the long run if this continues, and truly hope this madness will be seen for what it is and an appropriate backlash/correction will follow.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by scoofy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:27PM (#43928726)
I actually moved a bunch of money around after the recovery from April 2nd. I just sat their thinking... wow, short term bonds have a really decent interest rate, and I don't think people are taking seriously the fact that the markets can actually fall apart because business is an incredibly complex, multi-variate process, and right now where just throwing wrenches into the gears for funsies.

I'm not even completely anti-tariff. I just think the way we're going about doing these tariffs is pretty much the opposite way anyone who was trying to bring manufacturing back to the US would do them. Low, clear ratcheting up tariffs are tariffs that allow businesses time to change their strategy without disrupting their income streams. Instead, we're going to bankrupt basically anyone who isn't already a multi-national.

Maybe I'm an idiot and I'm missing something clear, but to me, the reason why the S&P500 and passive investing have been so successful since basically the 1940's is simply that we have had competent, technocratic administrations for the last hundred years. Other countries' markets have not fared so "efficiently."

Again, maybe I'm missing something, but I'm looking at this much more defensively than I did under the first administration. The one thing I can't figure out is the dollar. My brother is obsessed with the "dollar milkshake" theory, whereas it seems clear that we are messing with reserve status and are trying to intentionally weaken the dollar... I just don't know. It doesn't really make much sense what we're doing, and I haven't found anyone who can make an argument that makes sense to me.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by gopher_space on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:05PM (#43930069)
The vibe on /r/wallstreetbets seems to be "this all makes sense as a massive pump and dump". Very useful source of info if you view them as essentially black boxing the stock market.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Thrymr on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:30PM (#43930358)
Game recognize game.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by scoofy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:16PM (#43930197)
I mean, WSB isn’t a serious place, but they have their moments. I just have no idea who would or even could “pump” the entire S&P 500. My best theory of the last month is just basic “sell in May and go away” theory where you get rosier fundamentals in spring because everyone buries the bad news in Q1 reports, but it’s more difficult to hide as the fiscal year actually happens.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by 6stringmerc on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:40PM (#43930468)
The signal to noise ratio is difficult but now and then a factoid pops up - like the amount of retail investors piling in recently. It aligns with messaging in other forms of media that they, well, only use as indicators and frequently don’t take seriously. I’m using it often as a useful tool for counter-balancing my long term plans with the impatient gambling mentality which feeds the machine there. I learned my lesson ages ago from ZeroHedge about being overly bearish and things didn’t play out, so WSB is helpful in my situation because in principle I agree with the market is distorted assertion but believe the collapse will manifest months from now and this is a sucker’s market. Q2 earnings calls are going to be telling.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by scoofy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:47PM (#43930550)
I don’t think any collapse is coming. I just think the risk profile doesn’t justify many of my smaller cap investments, and where I am in life.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by inamorty on Thursday May 08, 2025 @05:00PM (#43931316)
A factoid is something that is masquerading as a fact, not a small fact.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by irthomasthomas on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:56PM (#43932844)
Indeed, the suffix '-oid,' when appended to nominal stems, frequently functions as a significant etymological marker, often denoting mere semblance, superficial imitation, or, with particular pertinence to the present deliberation, an inherent spuriousness or ersatz quality. Accordingly, the primordial definition of 'factoid'—a term whose coinage is frequently attributed to Norman Mailer—designates an item of information presented as if it were an established fact but which is, in reality, unverified or demonstrably fallacious, yet achieves widespread acceptance as truth through its persistent promulgation, especially within journalistic or mass media contexts. The subsequent, more contemporary construal of 'factoid' as merely signifying a 'trivial' or 'minor piece of information' represents a notable semantic deviation, a misconception whose widespread dissemination has been paradoxically facilitated by the very media channels implicated in the term's original, pejorative sense. Ergo, in a compelling instance of recursive irony, this now prevalent, albeit technically inaccurate, understanding of 'factoid' (as a diminutive datum) has itself metamorphosed into a quintessential exemplar of a 'factoid' according to its original definition: an unsubstantiated assertion that has gained popular currency through sustained, uncritical repetition.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by cosmicgadget on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:42PM (#43932455)
> I just have no idea who would or even could “pump” the entire S&P 500.

Have you not been paying attention? Tariff announcements.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by refurb on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:41PM (#43932770)
Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

It’s not like WSB has any inside info, and we conspiracy theories are always “fun”.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by overfeed on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:41AM (#43934089)
> I just have no idea who would or even could “pump” the entire S&P 500.

The White House, evidently. After the 90-day pause was "leaked" on Twitter[1], the market gained trillions in value, which it promptly lost when the White House disavowed it, before gaining back after the president posted that "It [was] a good time to buy DJT" (paraphrasing), and then formally announcing the 90-day tariff pause a few hours later.

1. The jury is still out whether that was an actual leak, or a guess that later became policy.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by chneu on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:49PM (#43932138)
Anyone can see this is a pump and dump. Trump literally tweeted that it's a great time to buy right before announcing tariffs.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by chii on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:34PM (#43933315)
> it's a great time to buy right before announcing tariffs.

you mean annoucing the pause?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by chneu on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @01:39PM (#43987228)
he flip flops so much i have no idea what's goign on anymore.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pupperino on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:29PM (#43929586)
As a Latin American, I can't help but buy the American Exceptionalism thesis, and seeing you guys in this situation humanizes you so much. The US has such a strong bureaucracy and high bar for competence that you generally lack the immune system required for detecting con artists and social climbers - at least in politics. Ask a random Argentinian or Brazilian what politicians Trump reminds them of, and you'll get a seemingly endless lists of genuinely stupid, borderline sociopath populists. Follow up with a question on what are the consequences of having arbitrary, ever-changing tariffs on most goods for the purpose of industrialization, and you'll get a laugh, then a sad face.

Import-substitution is bad for econ 101 reasons that most people who have an axe to grind against Dems would've been absolutely capable of grasping only a few years ago. Now, it seems so many are willing to turn off a part of their brains for this short-sighted wishful thinking. "Well, the official narrative is that we're doing this to get manufacturing back, so let's wait and see" is something most people would immediately perceive as bs if a Dem was sitting in the Oval Office. Seeing a politician campaign on a stupid platform, and then getting surprised he actually shoots himself in the foot spending political capital pursuing is also very Latin American.

The good part is that the soon-to-be-coming recession the federal government just fabricated out of thin air is fully self-inflicted, and therefore somewhat easy to fix. The bad part is you have (at least) 4 more years of this lunacy, so it might take a while.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by shantara on Thursday May 08, 2025 @04:10PM (#43930782)
As someone who grew up in Eastern Europe, I had a completely identical reaction. We had so many similar populists and idiots in power, one cannot help but recognize the obvious pattern.

Many people in America seem to be convinced that their involvement in the democracy ended after voting in the elections, and cannot conceptualize how to deal with an adversarial government. The scale of the protests and pushback Trump administration has received is laughably small compared to the scale of America as a country. People are lacking a basic political immune system, or even a sense of self preservation.

And the most puzzling part is that the entire situation is 100% self-inflicted. It usually takes a major war or a sustained external campaign to inflict the kind of damage Trump administration has done to the country in such a short period of time.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by 20after4 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @09:20PM (#43932982)
There has been a sustained campaign of propaganda, stoking division and culture wars. There has also been a sustained class warfare and concentration of wealth at the very top as most people can't seem to get ahead. Both political parties sold out their constituents a long time ago and the supreme court has been stacked with several criminally corrupt and treacherous villains.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by AlecSchueler on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:33AM (#43934329)
This is the exceptionalism they were talking about. These things happen elsewhere also.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by senko on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:45AM (#43934936)
That's just Wednesday in Eastern Europe.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pupperino on Friday May 16, 2025 @12:49AM (#44001934)
This is every country, buddy.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by smeg_it on Sunday May 11, 2025 @11:42AM (#43954544)
I'm definitely no economist but the current administration doesn't seem to listen to them anyway. To me, this is going to be an extremely high tax on lower and middle income people, as well as small businesses. Most of us buy Chinese products all the time or, at least, ones that have Chinese in the supply chain somewhere. I know there has been a trade imbalance and maybe tariffs is a tool that could have been used, but I learned in high school(maybe in collage too) that it's most effective when you present a united front with other allies. Unfortunately, we really don't have allies like we used to. The current admin has destroyed, or at least highly eroded trust and partnerships we had in the past. By attacking almost every country, we stand truly alone. There was an article about Vietnam recently which explained that because we have/are fighting with them too, they have great leverage to get what they want by leveraging the U.S. against China. To me, we've just given away all our leverage by not being trustworthy and attacking all other countries at once (figuratively, for now at least). I'm simply not hopeful for our future from a majority of citizens point of view. For our GDP per capita, we do absolutely horrible, in what seems like most international indexes, comparatively. The areas we do "well" are not good ones. Like number of our citizens incarcerated. I think we beat China, Russia, and most every country in that. From the perspective of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", I think we've failed. I don't know, exactly, but from what I've read our Cost/Benefit ratio on healthcare is one of the most dismal in the world. We don't rate well, in almost any category that is a positive for our populous, especially considering our GDP per capita.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pstuart on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:16PM (#43929421)
> I haven't found anyone who can make an argument that makes sense to me.

The goal is to eliminate income taxes and replace it with tariffs. An added bonus (for the administration), is that tariffs can be changed if the party in question pays for access to make their case.

The stated reasoning of supporting domestic industry is a smoke screen for the above.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by scoofy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:22PM (#43929491)
Right, except that’s self-defeating and won’t work. The idea that we can plausibly generate enough revenue from tariffs to replace the income tax is inherently self-defeating, because if the tariffs work at bringing back manufacturing, we’ll stop imports. If they don’t, we’ll consume significantly less, more people will become poorer, and expenditures will increase as revenues decrease.

Maybe there is an equilibrium in there, but I don’t see it.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pupperino on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:32PM (#43929619)
Baked in this plan is the idea that the revenue from tariffs will be much smaller than income tax revenues, and therefore that the federal government will also get smaller.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by scoofy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:44PM (#43929798)
Right, but that implies that spending is controlled by revenues… when it’s clearly not. That just means higher deficits, threatening a default of US Bonds, which is a worst case scenario for American prosperity.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pupperino on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:48PM (#43929840)
I'm confident the people pursuing this mad agenda don't know the first thing about US budget laws and think they can just cut spending DOGE-style forever.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pstuart on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:32PM (#43930373)
Considering that the driver of all this is surrounded by yes-men and has spent his entire entitled life getting his way, I think their goal is to will it into being. And when it fails, blame the other party.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by cosmicgadget on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:48PM (#43932487)
I don't think the policy working out for the country was considered in deciding to go this route.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by beAbU on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:24PM (#43930294)
Replacing taxes with import tarriffs will dramatically reduce consumption, and therefore tax revenue.

Taxes don't incentivise earning less, but tarriffs most definitely incentivises spending less!

This theory does not make sense.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pstuart on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:30PM (#43930359)
> This theory does not make sense.

The theory "makes sense" in that it's what he's stated as a goal. But as policy, it's nonsensical. This is our world now.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by spacemadness on Thursday May 08, 2025 @05:14PM (#43931431)
I think the burden of proof is entirely on the admin in the White House who seem completely incapable of keeping their story straight and providing anything of value to sooth anyones fears other than "trust me, bro!"
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by datavirtue on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:19PM (#43932319)
I don't think the metric of success is how much mfg comes back to America, it's just a simple slogan that plays well. The real movement is the mfg flocking out of China and into our allies countries.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by eagleislandsong on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:31PM (#43932710)
> The real movement is the mfg flocking out of China and into our allies countries.

If Trump cared so much about America's allies, why has he also imposed tariffs on Canada and repeatedly threatened to annex it? Why has he repeatedly talked about annexing Greenland?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by yupitsme123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:03AM (#43933703)
Is this actually happening? I figured the result would be China simply swooping in and picking up all the trade partners we've alienated. And also all the soft power we've abandoned.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by worik on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:34PM (#43940239)
The USA is 20% of Chinese exports

China has been moving the manufacturing to their allies for years, as their labour force climbs the value chain.

Here in Aotearoa I am looking forward to continued booming trade with China and it's allies, hoping our government (we have a particularly bad one too currently) do not try to suck up to Mr Trump.

But the insanity in USA is bad for everyone. Hopefully we will get used to it soon and adjust to living without USA trade, and dollars

That will be good for everyone but the USA

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ruraljuror on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:17PM (#43933505)
> the reason why the S&P500 and passive investing have been so successful since basically the 1940's is simply that we have had competent, technocratic administrations for the last hundred years

Yes and, to your point, with an independent federal reserve. If that gets messed with, things could get much worse for the U.S..

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by helij on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:40AM (#43935727)
Same as you I'm in defense mode. I exited the market in early February since something was not right. All I have (not much) sits in money market fund now at 5%.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pclmulqdq on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:47PM (#43928087)
I stockpiled the basics for my projects before I learned how fast the basics can shift.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by haswell on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:50PM (#43928128)
That’s a really good point that makes this so much worse.

It’s not just that I may not be able to continue some projects, but that I may not be able to continue pushing the boundaries of my knowledge and experience as I learn more.

Thinking about this in terms of younger aspiring builders, this will stagnate the technical growth of a generation.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by alabastervlog on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:11PM (#43929345)
This getting-ahead-of-the-tax-hikes/inflation thing was probably why the segment of households with meaningful disposable income (top quintile or so) increased spending in Q1 even as everyone else was pulling back.

We did it with air conditioner upgrades, among other things. Now? Five figures of previously-probable, but optional, spending for the rest of the year is on hold indefinitely. Prices on lots of things (construction materials, holy shit) are already way up, so we'll be sitting on as much cash as we can until that eases up. We don't need that much, really....

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Scoundreller on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:06PM (#43928390)
I've been "stockpiling" car parts for years for various maintenance I need to do... I guess I should get to doing that actual maintenance but those strut springs still scare me.

When covid hit, I def sold a lot of junk that I had sitting around for years

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by zamalek on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:54PM (#43929127)
> As a tinkerer who loves building things, this is heartbreaking stuff.

Tinkers are inventors, which are future entrepreneurs. This administration can't think as far ahead as its nose.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by bigbadfeline on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:44PM (#43932776)
> Tinkers are inventors, which are future entrepreneurs. This administration can't think as far ahead as its nose.

I don't see any evidence that they can't or don't think far ahead. These are people who think that "Competition is for losers". Past that, they're smart cookies.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by sharken on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:51PM (#43928146)
The madness is the total reliance on cheap Chinese products, with very few or zero US alternatives. But building knowhow and sourcing rare metals will be a very tough challenge.

It seems that China has the upper hand for now, so it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by breakyerself on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:54PM (#43928195)
China has the upper hand and the US is being run by morons. With the US cutting itself off from the largest supplier of electronics while simultaneously destroying the basic research infrastructure that keeps America on the bleeding edge you can expect a brain drain towards Europe and Asia. The damage from this administration will last generations.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Workaccount2 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:04PM (#43928357)
But think of the coal mining jobs...

In all seriousness though, China is also not some young slick economic powerhouse. It's largely propped up facade with serious structural issues that the US doesn't have.

Also keep in mind that while countries are annoyed with the US, that doesn't mean they are going to welcome Chinese ships into their waters.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by woooooo on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:51PM (#43929097)
They are far and away the leaders in manufacturing. Also the only country with a tech sector on near parity with the US.

Yes, their housing market is messed up and that causes problems in the financial sector, but it's a real stretch to call everything else in the country "propped up".

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by datavirtue on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:41PM (#43932446)
Any mfg that can is leaving China right now. This happened on a smaller level with Trump's last Tariffs.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by crote on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:28PM (#43932696)
Are they really, though?

Other countries simply don't have the same supply lines and trained workforce. There are no other countries with anything even remotely comparable to something like Shenzhen's electronics market, for example. Who wants to go to a different country when your product will take longer to ship, will have a worse quality, and will be more expensive to manufacture?

Besides, the US doesn't have a stable foreign policy. Moving your manufacturing to a different country takes years, why would anyone start that process when there is zero guarantee that the same tariffs will be in place a month from now, let alone a year or two from now?

And where would you move to? Any country which attracts a significant amount of manufacturing is pretty much guaranteed to be hit with the same kind of tariffs. The only safe option is the US itself - but it's often cheaper to just accept the tariffs!

I bet a lot of companies are just going to accept the revenue loss and wait for the US to stop acting crazy. The tariffs are only just starting to hit and people are already getting mad. This won't last forever.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by spwa4 on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:58AM (#43935819)
> Other countries simply don't have the same supply lines and trained workforce

This is tempered, isn't it?

1) the whole advantage of China that we exploited WAS a large untrained uneducated workforce. That wasn't worth it anymore and things like textiles have already largely moved.

Of course, this doesn't apply to a number of sectors like electronics. But:

2) anyone educated and/or with money is scrambling to leave China, and this is nothing new.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by zelda420 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:59PM (#43929217)
Are Chinese ships not already delivering products and welcomed?

I was Peru last year and saw nothing but Chinese made electronics, especially phones, and a lot of cars. I see more and more Chinese electric cars in Mexico too. Talking to the locals they seem to like Chinese tourists just wish they spent as much as Americans.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Workaccount2 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:14PM (#43929392)
Warships.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by datavirtue on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:44PM (#43932463)
Nope. All other Asian countries are putting transshipment controls in place to prevent Chinese trade getting funnelled through. They went around Trump in his first term and now he is out for revenge. Mfgs must leave China now if they want access to the US market. He just skull fucked Chinas economy.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by bigbadfeline on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:54PM (#43932836)
> They went around Trump in his first term and now he is out for revenge.

Sounds like high IQ statesman's behavior.

> He just skull fucked Chinas economy.

There, we get high IQ commentary as well... seems like, we're lucky today.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by bilbo0s on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:45PM (#43928981)
At this point that ship has sailed.

I think the answer fairly conclusively in the global south is that, yes, yes they will let Chinese ships in their waters.

It will be bizarro-land if we have people in Kenya, Colombia, South Africa, and Peru driving around in 10000 dollar Chinese EVs and using 5000 dollar Chinese robots to clean their homes. While we pay 5 to 10 times that for the same conveniences.

I seriously think there's a really good chance the world 25 years from now may have a fundamentally different structure than it has had for the past 100 years.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pclmulqdq on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:51PM (#43929084)
It's time to open your eyes to the way the rest of the world lives because "bizzaro land" is basically here. Cheap Chinese roomba replacements clean people's homes, $15000 Chinese EVs are insanely popular, and the price of all these goods certified for the US market is 200-300% higher, so many Chinese companies don't bother.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Izkata on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:52PM (#43929109)
Some quick searches on car costs and converting between South African rand and USD, it looks like US consumers already pay around 2-3x as much for a car (just in general using averages, didn't look for specific models or EVs).
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by alabastervlog on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:14PM (#43929391)
Car prices in the US are way up over the last few years—prices, which were already trending up, spiked with "Covid shortages" and then just kept going up after those should have been alleviated. Was the ratio as bad in, say, 2015? (I really don't know)
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by littlecorner on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:24PM (#43929510)
The brain drain started decades ago. We've been importing people for STEM jobs and exporting manufacturing for a while, leaving behind large numbers of people with no hope for a better future. Now the rest of the country faces that prospect as well
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by deepsquirrelnet on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:14PM (#43933497)
Yep, was there 20 years ago. The secret is having first class universities and a stable, thriving economy that attracts bright students. American exceptionalism is that momentum.

The brightest people in the world want to come here and contribute to our economy and spend the money they earn here at your businesses. That’s a privilege, and it’s too bad we don’t value it more.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by worik on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:49PM (#43940342)
> The brightest people in the world want to come here

Not any more. Not the women, the queer, poc...

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by x0x0 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:58PM (#43928254)
We are being run by abject morons who will never be able to understand simple truths, one of which is China is in a far stronger position: their factories are missing dollars. We are missing goods. One of those is easy for a central bank / government to replace.

Watching these people discover where the world's rare earths come from is equally amazing and terrifying.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by nickff on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:03PM (#43928343)
Rare earth metals aren’t very rare, they’re just messy to extract and refine.

There are reasons that the Chinese (government) want so many dollars, and the external funds are not easy to replace (or they would have done it already). This is not to support the current trade ‘war’, but just to point out that it’s a bit more complicated than you can describe in a pithy comment.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by libertine on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:21PM (#43928629)
But now Greenland being annexed through military means is on the table - we can't make this up.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by pstuart on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:03PM (#43933171)
I just learned why the interest -- apparently the TechBros™ have eyes on using Greenland to host their new corporate city states.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by seanp2k2 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:05PM (#43928368)
Don't worry, we'll just mine everything we need ourselves in the active warzones in Ukraine! I bet Yosemite has tons of the rare earth we need, we just have to dynamite everything in there to find it! /s
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by photonthug on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:15PM (#43928518)
The sooner we kill all the animals, the quicker we can find where they are hiding all their gold.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by monocasa on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:14PM (#43928494)
I swear to god, if we set off the Yosemite supervolcano from heavy mining there...
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by BobaFloutist on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:50PM (#43929071)
The supervolcano is in the other iconic, international-destination national park starting with Y, Yellowstone.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by PKop on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:16PM (#43928548)
What do you think the point of rebalancing trade is? To get out of dependence on foreign suppliers. "China's economy, copmposed of massive domestic production, industrial capacity, and manufacturing inputs is in a stronger position"

Yes, sounds like something that should be changed to increase the strength of the US. China has protectionist economic policy and trade barriers. If that equals strength why shouldn't we do it too?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by no_wizard on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:24PM (#43928672)
>If that equals strength why shouldn't we do it too?

Tall order to prove this. Does it actually equal strength? What is strength and does China actually have said strength? None of this is defined.

Additionally, China has economic policies that if the US followed would be very, like the games they play with their currency valuation for example. They also have stringent capital controls, many of their largest businesses are the government has a large slice of the ownership, they subsidize export corporations to a much broader degree etc.

Are you also arguing for those things as well? Because its not simply tariffs that mark the only difference in economic policy between the US and China

The other asinine thing is we implemented tariffs against all countries, without a plan, and without a definitive proven reason as to why. As many economists have pointed out, the trade deficit is very deceiving and does not equate to there being a problem for the US inherently.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by x0x0 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:28PM (#43933286)
> without a definitive proven reason as to why.

profound, comprehensive stupidity

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by mindslight on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:25PM (#43928694)
The current nonsense is the opposite of strength - it is empty bluster, based on ideas two decades out of date, by a "man" who talks like he's had a frontal lobotomy and who can't even sit on a chair properly.

Actually righting the severe damage done to our industrial base would take constructive direction by the government to build it back - once again the complete opposite of what they're actually doing by attacking our still-existing educational/research institutions.

At best high tariff taxes are just closing the barn door long after the horse ran away. But really it's just the same old pattern of the same type of hollow politicians using pent up frustration about the last scam to drive support for their next scam.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by sharken on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:38AM (#43934351)
I agree with the barn door analogy and that the US badly needs a plan for building manufacturing.

It also needs a plan for mining rare earth minerals as well as a plan for processing them.

On the flip side the deal with Ukraine for rare earth minerals might just end the war, if not Russia see this as an opportunity to get all of the territory it currently occupies.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by 20after4 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @09:29PM (#43933020)
I think it's worse than generations. It will likely never recover. What's happening resembles when private equity takes over a company and runs it into the ground intentionally.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by melenaboija on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:00PM (#43928287)
Not sure why people keep insisting that goods from China are “cheap,” which always seems to carry a negative connotation when in reality, “cheap” is exactly what we seem to want as consumers in wealthier western countries.

And in many cases, these products are neither cheap nor expensive, they’re simply the only option, because no one else in the world manufactures them. So, what exactly are we comparing them to? And if the assumption is that producing the same goods in Europe or the US would be more expensive then that’s likely true but only because we still expect to earn a living wage, even in factory jobs

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by WarOnPrivacy on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:23PM (#43928658)
> these products are neither cheap nor expensive, they’re simply the only option, because no one else in the world manufactures them.

This is exactly it. And even if an item can be US-supplied, it's components are only available from China.

Tariffs are how we get it to stop being built in the US.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by haswell on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:54PM (#43928207)
I think the total reliance is a legitimate concern that needs to be addressed.

I still think this approach to addressing that issue is complete madness.

Not only is there no coherent plan for how that reliance will be reduced, but we’ve now crippled ourselves in the meantime.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by jacobyoder on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:05PM (#43929276)
> I think the total reliance is a legitimate concern that needs to be addressed.

> I still think this approach to addressing that issue is complete madness.

You're assuming the 'total reliance' argument and corresponding actions are being done in good faith. The original 'emergency' declarations justifying large initial tariffs in February were because of a 'fentanyl crisis'. Which then morphed in to 'well, we should be manufacturing here for defense purposes' and assorted other arguments along the way ("we're getting ripped off!", etc).

There's a danger in being cynical about this, but also danger in taking everything at face value. There's been no coherent communicated policy with justifications and expected outcomes or timelines ever put forward the same way twice from this administration.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by haswell on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:02PM (#43930027)
> You're assuming the 'total reliance' argument and corresponding actions are being done in good faith.

To clarify, I’m not assuming the administration is acting in good faith.

But in casual conversation, I try to assume the person who worries about total reliance is acting in good faith, so my reply was primarily directed at the comment itself which I have to assume comes from someone who may believe the administration is actually attempting to address the issue.

I think there are numerous ways to split this:

- The reliance concern as a standalone consideration

- How the current administration sees/uses this concern

- How the public perceives this concern

- How the current administration claims they’re addressing it

- Whatever the current administration’s true goals are

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by justin66 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:05PM (#43928366)
Yeah. One thing among many that some in the US don't seem to get: only one side in this war needs to completely rearrange their economy in order to survive, and it's us.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by PKop on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:17PM (#43928569)
I think the people attempting to do that understand it
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by justin66 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:33PM (#43928816)
On the contrary, they give the appearance of simply assuming "the market" will solve the problem they've created.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by mullingitover on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:15PM (#43929405)
The people who believe government intervention can't do anything good are arguing that we're in an existential crisis because the Chinese government is executing too well.

And their approach is to cripple our own government.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by nickff on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:07PM (#43928407)
I have no idea what the administration’s plan or thoughts might be, but I suspect that one part of it is that they’ve seen how many governments (including their own, as well as allies like the EU) delay and defer as negotiation strategies. The EU even used delays and uncertainty against its very closest ally (the UK) in trade negotiations. As a result, sudden and ‘violent’ shifts are the only way to get things done in the current environment.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Izkata on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:17PM (#43929431)
Trump has said as much in interviews - just asking gets nothing done, and now all those governments are coming to him for deals.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Johnny555 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:24PM (#43928671)
The USA could bring manufacturing back, but not with tariffs.

They can't tell businesses "Look, we've dramatically increased your cost of doing business, made your products more expensive (which will likely lead to lower sales) and we're forcing you to spend extra capital by paying tariffs on your products... Now all you need to do is come up with billions of dollars to build the factories that build your product and eat the high costs for the 5 - 10 years it will take to build the factories. We don't care if you're a small business that only sells $1M of product a year, if you want to reduce your costs, you need to build the factories."

Of course, the question is whether Americans really want those factory jobs -- do parents aspire to have their children work in a factory assembling iPhones? There's only so many Robot Technician jobs to go around (despite the promise of unlimited high paid technician jobs, for the forseable future there will be plenty of menial factory jobs)

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by datavirtue on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:47PM (#43932484)
This has very little to do with "bringing mfg back."
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by more_corn on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:41PM (#43938735)
Expand on that. Because the stated reason is to bring manufacturing back to the US.

Perhaps you’re calling bullshit and proposing that something else is going on.

Calling that out specifically would be beneficial.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by drysart on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:35PM (#43941122)
A stated reason is bringing manufacturing back to the US, just one of many various, contradicting reasons that have been thrown out there. The administration has been throwing so many different justifications at the wall that shift over time; there hasn't been a commitment to any actual stated goal.

And indeed some of their actions don't even line up with bringing manufacturing back to the US as a goal; like the whole concept of 'reciprocal' tariffs being different country-by-country. And making a big deal out of 'making deals' with countries to lower tariffs.

Not to mention that if bringing manufacturing back to the US was really a primary goal, there are better ways to accomplish it than forcefully and recklessly driving the US into a deep economic contraction -- because it'll mean investing a lot of capital in building a lot of manufacturing capacity, and business doesn't like investing huge amounts of capital during a downturn, and we're on the cusp of the mother of all downturns because even if capital gets sank into rebuilding domestic manufacturing, it's going to take years before it can come online.

What I think is really going on is that a lot of wealthy people got wealthier by exploiting opportunities that arose from the 2008 crisis; and they want another bite at the apple, so one is being manufactured.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by smeg_it on Sunday May 11, 2025 @12:01PM (#43954682)
I don't know what jobs will be left. As our benefits have dried up. e.g. retirement, healthcare, job stability. Every article I've read basically said workers are going to need to be very adaptable. Forget about the lives your parents, and or grandparents had. That is gone. AI is only going to make things worse. I'm not anti-immigrant but H1-B has made the U.S. dependent on Indian labor, as it has done exactly what it was never supposed to do i.e. replace american workers with cheaper foreign labor, this is largely due to Indian Contract companies that are rife with fraud (both conservative and liberal administrations have found that). So, IT has lead the way to professional gig work i.e. contracts with either no benefits, are very high cost ones. Without protection, there just will not be stable jobs in this country. Forget retirement, most of us probably can't afford basic health care. Don't even think about dental care. In my mind, we are entering a new feudal age. No it won't be land based, but it's the same thing. Land was just the leverage for power, now it might just be net-worth and/or position. In general, American's are becoming poorer. I see us looking more like other nations with a largely poor populous. I'm guessing the rich already see most of us, like the nobles of old as peasants, with the same or similar justifications for bigotry. Divine right, or the rest are just dumb, and uneducated and only fit for manual labor, until we die (early).

P.S. I love sherlock holmes, and from that have some fascination of Victorian England, I just never thought we would go back to it. It was great if you were a noble and/or rich, but most of the populous wasn't either and suffered. All from my understanding, so historians or just more historically knowledgeable people can correct me.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by evantbyrne on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:13PM (#43928486)
The only way for China to lose influence in this fight is by playing ball. They can simply continue to trade with the rest of the world and be totally fine when it is US consumers paying the bill.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by bilbo0s on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:58PM (#43929190)
This is what I don't quite get? What is the impetus for their government to want to play ball with us?

The incentive for their companies is that they can access US markets. But their government is a bit different. That government has clearly been serious about 2 things for the past couple of decades, one is developing an internal market. (Which, prior to our imposition of tariffs, they were failing miserably at). The other is their pivot to the global south. (Which, prior to our imposition of tariffs, they were wildly successful at).

Now that we started a trade war, they will be more successful at both. Especially the pivot to the global south. I guess I just can't see why the government of China feels more urgency to talk with us, than it feels to accelerate their pivot to, and development of, markets in the global south for instance? Why is talking to us the better choice for their government strategically speaking?

I mean, if I were sitting in their shoes, I'd just be like, "Man, this is be the perfect illustration of why it was so important to pivot to the global south in the first place."

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by dtech on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:54PM (#43928201)
That's a valid argument, but a 125% tariff with basically zero notice - on manufacturing and shipping timelines - is not the solution.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by FpUser on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:59PM (#43928272)
>"... is not the solution"

The source thinks the opposite. You can complain directly. I don't think it gives a flying fuck

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by mcphage on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:46PM (#43932476)
The source proudly brags that he passes cognitive tests for dementia.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by RiverCrochet on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:24PM (#43930287)
Something my half-brother said ...

"Cheap foreign products are a necessity when so-called American companies don't love Americans enough to pay them what they're worth. It's the whole reason things went overseas in the first place. It's gonna be nice if we can finally get American companies to actually support America and pay citizens what they're worth."

The above sounds nice, but it's oversimplified, like a lot of political rhetoric recently. Now, if this does end up making real living wages for the American worker a commonplace thing, that's awesome, but I'm pessimistic given the history of things, how money can influence politics, and how corporate lawyers can find loopholes.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by onesociety2022 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:42PM (#43932453)
I'm not sure if it would pan out like how your half-brother wants it to be. Let's assume the manufacturing jobs return here and you are getting paid American wages. But if you try to turn around and spend it on anything, it will just be more expensive because everything else you want to buy is also being made in US factories and those workers are also getting pay similar to yours? You might have a manufacturing job finally but now you are paying $350 for a Nike shoe that used to be $150 when it was made in China. You want to buy a new TV? It costs more now. You want to upgrade your old iPhone? It costs more now.

So will the American manufacturing wages actually translate to living wages or will you just be getting paid more on paper but you still feel poor because the things you want to buy are all more expensive now?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by throwaway69123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:47AM (#43935401)
what if the manufacturing is largely automated and state side ?
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ModernMech on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:56AM (#43936815)
If everything is automated then where do people work?

If only some things are automated, then yes those places will have an advantage when it comes to labor costs, but they will use it to pad their profit margin.

Factory X employs humans ands sells widgets for $100, but their costs are $90, so profit is $10.

Factory Y is automated and they have costs of $10. Do they sell their widget at $30, thus earning a handsome profit of $20? No, they charge $90 and earn an obscene profit of $80. The worker gets screwed, the shareholders get richer.

This whole thing only works if workers have ownership in the corporation, but that's gasp socialism and we can't have that.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by throwaway69123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:09PM (#43942126)
the same places they work now, displacing foreign workers shouldn’t effect American workers?

if the goods are made and exported from American factories the owners of those factories will be increasing the local, state and federal tax bases, how is that not an improvement over offshoring production?

workers are currently being screwed by globalist companies offshoring production and also using that as a way to offshore profits also, i doubt any workers will shed tears if that stops.

socialism as you described is fine, not sure how its relevant in this case, its perfectly legal to start coops and they exist even in the tech world, most people dont seek them out and it appears they underperform their peers, where are all the major coop tech companies?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ModernMech on Sunday May 11, 2025 @09:00AM (#43953516)
> “It's gonna be nice if we can finally get American companies to actually support America and pay citizens what they're worth.”

Posters are skeptical because prices will raise across the board for these good. You ask:

> “what if they are largely automated”

If that’s the case, and they work where they work now as you say, then Americans will just get poorer as things become more expensive due to tariffs. The factory owner is keeps all the protectionist profits. Maybe some of that goes back into the tax base but we know these types are good at paying 0% taxes.

The rich get richer, the poor get poorer. That’s why socialism is relevant, because that’s the system under which this idea at a national scale actually helps workers, whereas this idea under capitalism helps mainly capitalists. Which is why I’m so confused because you keep talking about workers in your post, but that’s not who this is for.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by overflow897 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:36AM (#43938007)
Genuine question but did folks feel poor during the heyday of the middle class? It seems like there was a period post-ww2 where you could make a living wage and still buy a house and sends your kids to college.

I'm not sure what the answer here is, but it does seem like this is something that has existed. Consumerism was pretty rampant in the 50s and 60s when a lot more was still made in the US.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by mafuy on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:42PM (#43939319)
growing wealth inequality :)
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by slater on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:43PM (#43939329)
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by LPisGood on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:53PM (#43928184)
Global trade is goodness, not madness.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by jl6 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:57PM (#43928233)
There is surely a balance to be struck to get some of the benefits of global trade, without creating a dependency that can be exploited to create leverage against you.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by collingreen on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:01PM (#43928311)
There surely is and there are many paths toward that and many options for timelines that make it more or less impactful on businesses and consumers.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ToucanLoucan on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:04PM (#43928348)
I struggle to comprehend this viewpoint, echoed by many, with respect to: what possible benefit of global trade is the United States (well, previous to tariffs anyway) already not receiving?

We can buy goods by printing money, which no other nation can lay claim to, because the U.S. Dollar is the default world currency. Everyone accepts USD, and wants USD. Every other nation on Earth in fact is always looking to buy dollars, because dollars are what everything is purchased in. Further, our standing in the globe and favorable geographic location means we can import anything from virtually anywhere, but most especially China, Korea, and Japan.

Yeah we don't "make things" here anymore, the pundits say, apart from dozens of product categories over hundreds of industries. "Everything comes from China!" Okay, and? I don't want a job in a factory and I suspect a shitload of other people here also don't, and my source for that is every factory and logistics center near me is constantly trying to hire people and seemingly being unable to.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by PKop on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:20PM (#43928615)
There's no permanence here, and you don't understand history or even business if you think this imbalance and dependence doesn't equal weakness at some point in the future. Just because we want China to always work for us and give us what we want doesn't mean completely ceding control of the decision means it will work out. Does any business (operating in much less cut throat stakes than great-power geopolitics) even bank all their supply on external sources, let alone one, let alone that one being their biggest adversary? Madness.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ToucanLoucan on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:27PM (#43928715)
But we have every reason to believe China will continue working for us because China benefits from that work. And insofar as the U.S. and China are adversaries at all seems to be purely culture war nonsense. China is not setting out to destroy the United States, they're setting out to sell the United States shit and we are setting out to buy it. The only reason there is even contention in this at all is that many pundits and analysts see the collapse of the American manufacturing sector as somehow the devious plans of a foreign adversary, and not the result of American business people seeking cheaper labor that works more efficiently overseas.

If we assume China is an adversary, then I would say it logically follows that the vast majority of American executives are in fact collaborating with the enemy, because they played critical roles in getting China to where it is today.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Ajedi32 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:13PM (#43929374)
China is a potential adversary because they are an authoritarian, undemocratic regime making military threats against neighboring free, democratic nations (Taiwan). If everything stayed exactly the way it is today, except the Communist party rulership were dissolved and replaced by a multi-party constitutional republic with representatives appointed through free, open elections I don't think the US would have nearly the same incentive to divest from China.

Free markets don't care about moral concerns like that though, just what's most economically efficient. And in the absence of tariffs, trading with China is very economically efficient.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by edmundsauto on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:20PM (#43930246)
> <blank> is a potential adversary because they are an authoritarian, undemocratic regime making military threats against neighboring free, democratic nations

Fill in the blank with preferred major nation power of your choice.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ToucanLoucan on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:03PM (#43930048)
> China is a potential adversary because they are an authoritarian, undemocratic regime making military threats against neighboring free, democratic nations (Taiwan).

As opposed to an authoritarian, Democratic regime making military threats against neighboring free, democratic nations (Canada)?

> If everything stayed exactly the way it is today, except the Communist party rulership were dissolved and replaced by a multi-party constitutional republic with representatives appointed through free, open elections I don't think the US would have nearly the same incentive to divest from China.

Why does the U.S. have the right to declare unilaterally what forms of government are acceptable and what aren't? And no I'm not saying we have to necessarily trade with them, obviously, apart from the fact that the CCP came into power in 1949. We're a bit late to suddenly have issues with their government NOW after nearly half a century spent working with them in the open, and giving them shit tons of money.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Ajedi32 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:42PM (#43930495)
The US's authoritarian tendencies are not in remotely the same league as China and it's absurd to pretend otherwise.

Our right to declare that rule apart from the consent of the governed is unacceptable comes from the fact that it is unacceptable, not because the US has any special rights to declare it so. We hold these truths to be self-evident, now just as we did then.

The US has always had that same fundamental issue with China's government; we've just chosen to react to that reality in different ways over the years. China being more of an economic powerhouse now makes it a larger threat to human freedom than it has been in the past, so there are valid reasons to re-consider the status quo.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by worik on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:02PM (#43940407)
> The US's authoritarian tendencies are not in remotely the same league as China

They are different. In the same league

* Iraq

* Vietnam

* Cuba

* Panama

* Grenada

* Gaza

That is just recent times, and I missed quite a few

The USA is a big bully, destroying lives and livelihoods all over the world since the genocide of American Indians stopped in their own backyard

Trump is making plain what every body with any brain worked out in 1962: The USA is a rouge nation

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ToucanLoucan on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:39PM (#43940675)
> and I missed quite a few

I would include:

* Korea

* Japan (the use of the atomic bomb was controversial even then as it was after it was obvious the empire was finished and it was merely a matter of paperwork)

* Laos

* Cambodia

* Afghanistan

* Puerto Rico

* NEARLY Honduras, over fucking bananas of all things

> The USA is a big bully, destroying lives and livelihoods all over the world since the genocide of American Indians stopped in their own backyard

And even the notion that the genocide has stopped is dubious. We may no longer be openly killing them, and I guess that isn't nothing, but their cultures are irreparably damaged and most natives in the States live lives of poverty and suffering.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Ajedi32 on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:52PM (#43940755)
I don't think you know what authoritarianism is. Military interventions in foreign affairs are a completely orthogonal issue.

On that subject though, the US has generally been a force for good around the world. Iraq was briefly a liberal democracy until the US military pulled back out and a theocratic regime took over again by force. Vietnam was a well-intentioned but bungled attempt to stop the spread of communism. When the US lost and pulled out the country turned into a one-party dictatorship. Other political parties there are outlawed. That's who the US was fighting against. The fact that these interventions ultimately failed doesn't make the attempts any less noble, though you can certainly make the case they were foolhardy to even try. Or perhaps if you're a pacifist you could argue any military intervention, even in the defense of human freedom, is immoral. I have mixed feelings on that subject myself, but it's ridiculous to compare anything the US did in recent history to what China or Russia are currently attempting or threatening to attempt. We never tried to conquer Iraq or Vietnam, just free them.

The US is a bully to dictatorial regimes and a friend to liberal democracies around the world. Trump's cage rattling is a tiny blip in the grand scheme of that legacy.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ToucanLoucan on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:07PM (#43940870)
> I don't think you know what authoritarianism is. Military interventions in foreign affairs are a completely orthogonal issue.

Then why did you cite them as the reason for China's authoritarianism becoming a problem?

> Iraq was briefly a liberal democracy until the US military pulled back out and a theocratic regime took over again by force.

You know the CIA funded the Taliban, right? We also installed Saddam Hussein.

> Vietnam was a well-intentioned but bungled attempt to stop the spread of communism.

Why is this a good thing? See previous question about "Why does the US get to unilaterally decide which forms of government are acceptable?"

> When the US lost and pulled out the country turned into a one-party dictatorship.

Or, if you were not on the U.S.'s side in this, you might be phrasing that more like: "When the U.S. pulled out, their puppet government collapsed immediately."

> The fact that these interventions ultimately failed doesn't make the attempts any less noble, though you can certainly make the case they were foolhardy to even try.

I would say they were both foolhardy and ignoble personally.

> Or perhaps if you're a pacifist you could argue any military intervention, even in the defense of human freedom, is immoral.

No pacifist would argue that.

> I have mixed feelings on that subject myself, but it's ridiculous to compare anything the US did in recent history to what China or Russia are currently attempting or threatening to attempt.

You can quibble about numbers and equivalence all you like. I'm not saying China is unambiguously good. I'm saying they are not guilty of anything the United States is not also guilty of and so the moral condemnation from said United States rings incredibly hollow and hypocritical. It feels more like the United States is upset that another country is beating it at the game it designed.

If I had my personal way, Xi Jinping and every president still living would be tried for the war crimes they are most definitely guilty of, along with dozens of other leaders from the so called "developed" world. A man can dream.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Ajedi32 on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:33PM (#43941105)
> why did you cite them as the reason for China's authoritarianism becoming a problem

China annexing Taiwan wouldn't merely be "intervening in foreign affairs". When an authoritarian regime conquers a liberal democracy, the people in the annexed area are no longer free. It's the same reason we couldn't just ignore Hitler taking over half of Europe. If he'd just stuck to oppressing the people in his own territory it's possible the rest of the world would have let him and Germany might still be an authoritarian dictatorship today.

> the CIA funded the Taliban

Iraqis were hardly free prior to that. Short of direct military intervention, you often have to choose between what you believe to be the lesser of several evils. I'd agree that was probably a misguided choice in this case.

> Why is this a good thing? See previous question about "Why does the US get to unilaterally decide which forms of government are acceptable?"

See my answer to that question. Human freedom is an inherent good.

> "When the U.S. pulled out, their puppet government collapsed immediately."

True democracies can't be puppets; they're controlled by the people they govern. And it wasn't voted out by the populace, it fell to a military attack by a theocratic regime.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by monero-xmr on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:59PM (#43928269)
If your trading partner is an authoritarian dictatorship that has publicly stated they are in a thousands-year struggle for global supremacy, then maybe we should shift some key imports away from them
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by foogazi on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:07PM (#43928400)
I thought this was about fentanyl and getting rich enough to remove the income tax

Have not heard anything about 1,000 years fight for global supremacy

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by kragen on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:03PM (#43929258)
It's 100 years, not 1000 years, and it's a fight for Chinese well-being, not global supremacy, though it's understandable that people who believe Chinese well-being is incompatible with US hegemony would confuse the two: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-long-game-chinas-gran...
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by LPisGood on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:31PM (#43928789)
Maybe USA should do that, but what’s been attempted is a horrible way to do that.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by exe34 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:28PM (#43929569)
What exactly were you importing from the penguins?
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by betterThanTexas on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:25PM (#43928693)
I don't see how the us is supposed to be any better. Why can't we use this energy to fight the rich people making this country a shithole rather than starting a beef we can only lose.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by jermaustin1 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:08PM (#43928419)
I get what you are saying, but the U.S. BUYS goods, because we are "too rich" to make them. We SELL services, because other countries are "too poor" to offer them.

When this administration focuses solely on one side of that (Goods vs Services), they miss the forest for the trees. I'm not saying we shouldn't bring back manufacturing, because we should, but we can't pretend that we get the short end of the stick in this trade partnership.

China makes the cheap shit that isn't economical here, and the only way to make it economical here is to pay a tax on the cheap shit we want if it isn't made here, but the crazy thing is we could do a 400% tariff on Chinese imports, and it is still too expensive to buy American for most goods. Not even getting to the point that we don't have the infrastructure here because that also costs money, which would rise the price for American goods even higher.

Does Bill Gates mow his own lawn? No!

Does Donald Trump grill his own Big Mac? No!

Because when you hit a certain "wealth bracket" you stop doing things that are below that and hire them out. We hired China because we were too rich.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by more_corn on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:56PM (#43938910)
Wait, so is the solution to make ourselves poor?
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by jermaustin1 on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @11:14AM (#43985549)
The solution is to not care that we've hired people to mow our lawns, because we don't want to mow our own lawns (as a society).

But if you do want to mow your own lawn, then do it, just expect that it will cost you more to mow your own lawn than to hire it out.

Replace "lawn mowing" with any other industry of your choice.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by iancmceachern on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:07PM (#43928397)
Wait till this person finds out he can't have his mandarin orange segments in his nightly Jello salad anymore and then I expect they'll have a different opinion.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by seanw444 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:01PM (#43928302)
I agree, and I am in favor of protectionist tariffs. But it does seem to be poor strategy to rush into high tariffs without the pieces put in the place for American industry to grow and benefit. That said, I don't believe Trump is that stupid (despite the trendy opinion to the contrary), and I think he knows this is doomed to fail if the goal is immediate American industry bloom. Which is why I don't believe these are intended to be long term. Based on how the other tariffs have gone, it seems to be more of a negotiation tactic to reduce tariffs on both sides, not protectionism. China has just put up more of a resistance to it than other nations have, so now it's turned into a game of chicken.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by alabastervlog on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:05PM (#43928369)
> That said, I don't believe Trump is that stupid

Do you think he's acting when he does things like keep preventing an interviewer from moving on because he wants to make extra sure everyone knows he entirely believes that obviously-photoshopped, not-trying-to-look-like-anything-but-an-overlay letters and numbers on a picture of someone's hand were in fact real tattoos?

[dead]
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by anonymars on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:29PM (#43928743)
It sure is easy to have an opinion if you don't care about evidence to the contrary
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by alabastervlog on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:31PM (#43928790)
I mean, it's one example. Do you think the constantly that he presents as conspicuously extremely stupid is all an act? Do you think the several people who've been close to him who describe him as breathtakingly stupid are lying, or incorrect (fooled by another part of that act, one supposes)?

I don't see what gets people to class as unlikely the notion that he might be a really stupid guy with some really dumb ideas who's being pulled multiple directions by other people who may or may not also be dumb but do have bad/evil ideas. To me that appears overwhelmingly to be the most likely explanation for... all of it, really. It may still be wrong! But why isn't it—at least—a top contender, explanation-wise?

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by busyant on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:25PM (#43932353)
> Do you think the several people who've been close to him who describe him as breathtakingly stupid are lying, or incorrect (fooled by another part of that act, one supposes)?

James Comey wrote that he was moderately intelligent (I forget Comey's exact phrasing).

And I think that's true.

He's smart enough to know when to lie to escape legal jeopardy, so I think that's a mark of some amount of intelligence.

But he is also horriffically broken in some part of his personality, to the point where he lacks empathy, and constantly lies to obtain advantage.

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ModernMech on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:04AM (#43936905)
Because if Trump is really truly an idiot, what does that make the people who willingly chose to vote for him and didn't see that? People just can't accept that possibility, so they have to pretend it's all an act.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ModernMech on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:04AM (#43936909)
Because if Trump is really truly an idiot, what does that make the people who willingly chose to vote for him and didn't see that? People just can't accept what that says about their own judgement, so they have to pretend it's all an act.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Moomoomoo309 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:24PM (#43928683)
They're trying to tell you that Trump is as stupid as he seems. For many people, they're faking being stupid. Trump, like George W Bush, is not. There's no 4D chess going on here, whatever seems like the simplest explanation with Trump is almost always exactly what's being done. Keep it simple. Trump likes simple.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by seanw444 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:28PM (#43928735)
Keeping it simple is knowing that people don't get to such high places via stupidity.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by alabastervlog on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:35PM (#43928839)
I've yet to gain access to a level of "high place" at which the distribution of competence and intelligence is a ton different from a median public high school classroom. It's been one of the more disturbing discoveries of my adult life, that every time I get insight into one of these it's barely better than anything else on that front, and usually worse in the ethics and trustworthiness department.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by ceejayoz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:30PM (#43928756)
History is full of stupid people in high positions.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by fzeroracer on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:39PM (#43928900)
If you've worked for any company for about a day or two, you'd know plenty of stupid people get to high positions.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by nobody9999 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:50PM (#43930574)
>Trump, like George W Bush, is not.

I hate to break it to you, but George W. Bush isn't stupid. While GW Bush did cultivate that "dumb hick" persona, that's all it was -- a fake persona.

This gubernatorial debate[0] (from 1994) between then Governor Ann Richards and George W. Bush will give the lie to the idea that 'Dubya' is dumb. Definitely an amoral jerk, but not dumb.

[0] https://www.c-span.org/program/public-affairs-event/texas-gu...

Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by betterThanTexas on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:22PM (#43928636)
What would an american upper hand look like?
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by spacemadness on Thursday May 08, 2025 @05:11PM (#43931405)
I think hobby areas involving anything produced overseas will get utterly annihilated. Board game companies are already shutting down. That whole industry went from a multi-year boom to a bust this year due to tariffs.
Re:High tariffs become 'real' with our first $36K bill by Andrex on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:23PM (#43941480)
I've been trying to put a TCG together, I might just get a printer and print my own cards until volume demands otherwise. At least there are still high-quality options in the US, like USPCC, but you'll pay for it.