News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by grg0 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:36PM (#43666410)
Cars in cities, let alone designing cities around cars, is one of the greatest tragedies of modern life.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by epolanski on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:09PM (#43666675)
And it's one of the biggest promoters of inequality.

I am an European who studied at OSU in Columbus for a semester and it was absurd to me how on one side there was lots of work downtown, yet you could live 20 miles of it and it would take you two hours by public transport to get there, an odyssey.

People without a car, insurance, poorer parts of the society were cut off from the job market for not having a way to connect.

Suburbs are cute, but they are a tragedy of city planning, let alone the tragedy they are on a social level, where people will put everything in their houses including movie rooms, entertainment rooms, anything to avoid having to go out and socialize. Terrible.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:45PM (#43666947)
In the USA, the working poor generally don't work downtown, and it's really the industrial areas where there is awful transit service. So cheapo used cars are a must for these folks.

There is some awful HN bias here where young healthy well-paid tech workers live in some boogie part of SF/NYC/Boston/etc and enjoy the "car-free lifestyle" (and I've been there), without any idea how the other half lives.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by epolanski on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:18PM (#43667611)
The working poor struggles to find work and stays poor also because mobility.

By the way that's not something I'm making up, it was literally told me by several people in struggling neighborhoods, lacking a car can be easily make a difference for many between being able or not to have different opportunities in life.

Might be different elsewhere but it made sense to me.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:49PM (#43668535)
I've heard the same thing, because there's a lot of jobs out in suburban industrial parks and etc. (Some local transit agencies have tried to solve this, but the situation still isn't good.)
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by skort on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:00PM (#43667047)
I've seen this "car free utopia" idea dismissed as an idea by and for "elites" (see Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's comments on people who ride the subway in NYC) plenty of times as a tactic to avoid doing anything about reducing dependence on cars. It's quite a counterproductive argument in my opinion. Even if there are well paid tech workers who are able to enjoy a "car-free lifestyle", why should it end there?

Just because the system we created means that currently the only affordable place for the working poor is in suburbs where they must rely on cars doesn't mean that it needs to continue to be that way. You can support building infill housing and adding transit to eventually reduce the need for so many people to have cars.

It's one thing to call it "bias" and use that as an argument to not make things better instead of coming up with ways to help make car independence available to everyone across classes.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:23PM (#43667224)
Because the truth is nobody has any real idea how to retrofit the last 70 years of American suburbia so that mass transit is actually effective and useful for people. "Transit-oriented development" really only helps downtown workers and doesn't get you to the grocery store or daycare. (And even in NYC, the subway is not great out in Queens/etc, so people own cars.)

But it is nice to live in the Mission and take the techbus to Mountain View and handwave all the hard trillion dollar problems and say let the poors eat cake. Which is effectively how these discussions seem to go.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by cycomanic on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:07PM (#43667554)
I find it fascinating how the debate around cars in cities evolves. Initially counter arguments always are that reducing cars is not desirable "nobody wants less cars in cities, people need to do their weekly groceries, nobody wants to bike in bad weather...". Once these points are refuted it always evolves into "yes it would be great, but it can't be done, because it's too expensive, politically controversial...". It's almost like there is an irrational fear of less cars in cities.

Regarding it can't be done I encourage anyone to read up on how the investment into public transport transformed Bogota. Which is both much poorer and in a much more challenging geographical environment than most US cities. So if they can do it, why can't US cities?

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:36PM (#43667754)
You are putting a lot of pointless words in my mouth. As I said, I have actually lived the San Francisco car-free bike and streetcar lifestyle, and quite enjoyed it. So I have the perspective of why it does or does not work (for Americans). I would love to see some concrete solutions proposed here other than just the usual Cars Bad/Cars Good handwaving and downvoting.

(I just looked at Bodega in Google Maps, and it is significantly more dense than all but the most "boogie" American cities. Compare it to say Chicago.)

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by im3w1l on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:46PM (#43668525)
Self driving cars will make it much more viable to use cars for last mile on either side of a public transport trip.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by cycomanic on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:12AM (#43671027)
Chicago has a density of 4500 people per sq km compared to Bogota at 4100 so Chicago is denser? That said I actually meant Medellin not Bogota which is significantly denser. However Medellin topology makes it extremely challenging to build infrastructure, the central valley floor is more than 1000m lower than most of the suburbs. Moreover the GDP of Medellin is 70 billion compared to a GDP of Chicago of 800 billion and Chicago can't build public transport infrastructure because it's 1.5 less dense? That doesn't make any sense.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:30AM (#43671110)
Genuinely curious, do you have a good article about Bogota? Because your entire demeanor is acting like you have some "gotcha", without advocating for anything concrete.

For example, from my brief perusal of Google Maps, it looks like they have some sort of growth boundary, because it goes from dense city to farms in a sharp line. For historical reasons, America is not organized that way. (And Chicago is fucked-up, so be it.)

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sriacha on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:18AM (#43673403)
Bogota is interesting for their bus rapid transit (dedicated bus lanes), which as far as I know was built out for a fraction of the cost of a metro system.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/12/07/headway/bogot...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:25AM (#43678042)
Yep, San Francisco's BRT line has been a huge success (despite being typically way late and over-budget). And actually SF has had 'proto-BRT' for a long time, but IMO they still need more subways.

Bodega does have a growth boundary, per google. (IMO the lack of that is the 'root of all evil' of USA development patterns.)

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by panick21_ on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:15AM (#43670497)
Except that many European cities copied US cities in their development styles, and then later reversed them. So we absolutely do know how to reverse it.

> But it is nice to live in the Mission and take the techbus to Mountain View and handwave all the hard trillion dollar problems and say let the poors eat cake. Which is effectively how these discussions seem to go.

Every study shows that the poor are hurt the most because of car centric development.

Here is a guide on how to improve American cities that are surrounded by lots of suberbia:

- Remove/close all highways that go across the city, only keep the ring road. People will simple reclaim those space for recreational uses as soon as cars are gone.

- Increase price of parking space or eliminate them completely. Most parking in city is not used by residents anyway.

- Redo even if its with paint and few concrete bolders, the city streets according to Dutch street regulations. Massively increase safety for everybody.

- That frees up lots of space for bike lanes (as US cities tend to have far to many car lanes). This is actually a benefit to the history of US cities, we can't do that in some of the older dense cities.

- Change your zoning code and other access regulations, so proper urban development is actually allowed to happen. The US could adopt something like Japan zoning laws. A heavy use of mixed use and allow living in almost any zone. The US has a hilarious amount of commercial development land that completely underutilized. This also means no more minimum parking space and all that nonsense. See maybe like this: https://www.realestate-tokyo.com/news/land-use-zones-in-japa...

- This will make it so suburbs can go from single house only to a mix of single house, duplex, fourplexes, townhouses and so on. Like suburbs used to be. And it will make it so that light commercial developments can happen in subburbs. Meaning a single house can turn into small shops, coffees and such.

- In the city select a few core blocks in different places in the city, make those pedestrian only. Or like Montreal does, a whole long street. Each year add more of those pedestrian zone, improve walking infrastructure between them.

- Make it so subburban residents start to pay full price for their utilities including water and other infrastructure. New subburban developments are often hilariously subsidized, needing more water pumps and such.

- Redevelop current stroads into much fewer lanes and create separate access roads to the commercial developments. This improves flow on the stroads, reduce accidents and makes walking and biking along those stroads safer. Of course some of those lanes would turn into bike infrastructure.

- In the subburbs, also reduce road with, install protected cycle lanes. Break open the horrible cul-de-sac, the city can buy part of peoples garden to create cross connects between different cul-de-sacs and surrounding developments (cross connects for people and bikes, not cars).

- Make all the bus services public, heir a real transportation engineer to come up with a plan. Consisting of a few main routes, using the old stroads and highways, and smaller buses that serve as connectors to these major routes. Of course for that you would make some lanes on the highway, busways. Despite what some people in the US think, you can actually do decent bus service in suberbia. Combine that with public on demand service, that gets you cheaply to the next closes major public transport node. Maybe start planning a tram route along the major bus-routes.

- Look at your old rail infrastructure and develop a plan for a decent regional service. Develop a 50 year rail plan.

- The city can also simply buy up some cul-de-sacs that are strategically located and redevelop them into proper nice walkable neighborhoods. The city can even own the land and only rent half of the appartments, some at affordable price. This worked well in Britain and still does work well in Austria. And of course develop a transportation plan for those new neighborhoods. See an example, where old soviet style neighborhoods were developed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfonhlM6I7w

- Change your property tax into a land tax, or a property tax heavily focused on land. Or potentially do more with sales or what taxes, importantly, just don't do property tax.

- Like in Japan, require anybody that wants to own a car in a city, to first prove the have a private place to part.

- Make all car registrations based on weight, meaning you pay more for a heavier car.

- Focus development on the city and the first suburban ring around the city. Offer intensives for people in the outer rings to move into the inner rings. So for example somebody that owns a small house in the far outer ring of the city, could move into a duplex in the inner rings.

- If yours city has repair backlog (and most cities do) focus on the city core and the inner ring of subberbia.

- Do not develop more land, US cities already are far to wide spread. Simply announce no new infrastructure or roads. And not taking over into city property stuff that developers have built.

I could list more, pretty much all of these have been discussed in urbanism research.

Pretty much all of these have been done in different places at different times. And the all pretty much work. Doing them all together hasn't been done but there is no reason to believe it wouldn't work.

Of course this does not mean that for 1 day to the next everybody will go from suberbinate to die hard city person. But the culture after 1-2 decades of such changes will be dramatically different.

I also suggest to see this video about comparing two cities over time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4uqbsueNvag

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:16AM (#43671045)
It's funny, seems like people had me pegged as some Suburb Guy, when that couldn't be further from the truth. (I have mostly walked the talk, which is more than I can say of some of the Bike Guys I have known.) Anyway, I completely agree with much of this, just a couple nits:

> Every study shows that the poor are hurt the most because of car centric development.

Yes, the poor always lose out versus Hypothetical Utopia. I'm referring to reality as it exists in the current and near future where many many poor & middle-class people need cars. You can't just take them away because of a dumb student-type notion that "cars are only for rich people".

> Change your zoning code and other access regulations (etc)

Yes, I would love to tell Silicon Valley how to zone, but even the popular governor is having trouble doing that.

(Meanwhile, my urban SF neighbors are arguing about what paint colors should be allowed, like it is a HOA or something.)

> Develop a 50 year rail plan.

We have that, but it doesn't actually help because it's mostly about building rail out to new suburbs where people can get into city center office jobs (and the rail agency can get tax money). In the meanwhile, we built an urban subway with 3! stations.

Like I said, it's a trillion dollar problem, and there's no easy button. Just incremental improvements.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by panick21_ on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:35AM (#43671758)
> It's funny, seems like people had me pegged as some Suburb Guy, when that couldn't be further from the truth.

I didn't, I read your comment. I think you are just haven't done the necessary level of research or you just have a doomer outlook.

> Yes, the poor always lose out versus Hypothetical Utopia.

But they are not comparing to Utopia, but rather the comparable situation where changes have been made. Or to the same city before and after some change.

Unless you are making the argument that no objective knowledge can exist, the research is pretty clear.

> I'm referring to reality as it exists in the current and near future where many many poor & middle-class people need cars.

Nobody is questioning that. Literally nobody. That why its called 'car centric design'. Who are you arguing against?

> You can't just take them away because of a dumb student-type notion that "cars are only for rich people".

Again, literally nobody is arguing that! You have constructed a complete straw man of urbanist.

The argument is to encourage policy that will make people want to live without cars in the future.

Unless you think, restricting parts of the city center or closing some urban highways is 'taking cars away', you are literally arguing against nobody.

> Yes, I would love to tell Silicon Valley how to zone, but even the popular governor is having trouble doing that.

Yes, all of my suggesting involve politics. And of course not all of them can be implemented practically depending on location. This is always true with literally any suggestion about anything political.

But your claim wasn't 'its politically difficult' rather your claim was 'nobody knows how'.

> We have that, but it doesn't actually help because it's mostly about building rail out to new suburbs where people can get into city center office jobs (and the rail agency can get tax money). In the meanwhile, we built an urban subway with 3! stations.

If be 'we' you mean California, yes there is one. And that is already a lot better then what many other places have. You might not think its enough, but it better then nothing. And the claim that it is bad because its only 'new suburbs' is also factually wrong as part of the rail plan you just had Caltrain electrification, and future improvement to existing rail Caltrain. I'm not an expert on California rail, but the claim that it serves 100% new subburbs is certainty false.

> Like I said, it's a trillion dollar problem, and there's no easy button. Just incremental improvements.

I have no idea why you are claiming its a 'trillion $' problem. That can be said about not doing anything at all too. When we are talking about the infrastructure of 300 million people (assuming we are talking US) then of course, any decision you make its a trillion $. But in that context 1 trillion $ also isn't that much.

And if you actually look at the research you will see that actually many of the suggestion I have SAVE MONEY. The idea that all of this cost unbelievable amounts of money is simply not true.

Lets go threw examples:

- Saver roads pay for themselves because accidents have a really high cost. And the new safer roads will decease avg speed, leaing to easier to maintain roads. In the US today there is a massive amount of overbuilding of incrastructure that simply isn't needed if you were builing roads according to modern scientific principles, rather then some book some engineer wrote in 1960s that just so happens to have been adopted as 'the standard'. And the principles aren't that hard or expensive to implement. This is a clear money safer. Think about all the idiotic lights the US uses at every intersection, each set of lights is expensive, sound road planning would eliminate many of these.

- Closing down urban freeways increases property taxes. Gives the city new land to redevelop and sell, or keep as parks. Also reduces maintenance burden on state level.

- Rezoning pays for itself many, many, many times over, its not even close.

- Increase parking price can raise money for the city. If you don't want to remove them. Removing them is very easy and cheap.

- Putting down protected bike lanes with simple concrete protection is very very cheap and tons of research shows that it is very beneficial. More people on bikes means less car, means less time wasted in traffic. It has also been repeatedly shown that it improves retail on those roads and it also improves property prices.

- Setting up pedestrian zones is also incredibly cheap. Literally a few concert blocks or at most a few bulliards that you can fold down for emergency access. Incredibly cheap, increases property prices and retail.

- Increasing prices on suberbia to reflect actual cost, raises money, rather then losing it.

- Redeveloping stroads is a bit more expensive, but I'm not proposing building anything new, but rather changing the way access and priority works. Cost money but not that much and in the long term it saves a lot of money.

- City buying and developing land does cost money, but since the new mixed use areas will be popular they can actually make a lot of money. Money for this can be raised by cities.

- Setting up a bus network is also really not that expensive. That is some amount of running cost, but if your buses have good priority lanes and are frequent you can cover a lot of the operation. This certainty not a 'trillion $' and each city can handle this themselves, like the do in most of the world. And again, this is increasing tax revenue along bus routes as has repeatedly been shown.

- All the revenue increases are doubly relevant if you switch from property tax to land tax.

The only thing that is at all expensive that I proposed is a long term rail plan. But in terms of your long term transportation plan, you have a lot of cost anyway. And rail is a better long term investment.

I formulate all of my points specifically so they were something cheap that can be done. I didn't propose building huge new parks, or huge metro systems. Or high speed rail. Or anything like that.

You can literally do 95% of what is needed by with paint, concrete blocks, a bunch of buses and bus drivers and a few legal chances. The city will actually increase its revenue a huge amount over time.

The current model of trying to support ever increasingly distant suburbs is what is actually bankrupting cities.

I suggest you look at the detailed research from Urban3. They clearly show how cities that have done many of the chances I propose, are good for the cities finances. In fact, some cities have implemented some of these changes specifically because they are out of money.

So please do not spread the idea that American cities can't change because its to expensive. That is the sort of thing far-right wing people spread, the whole 'we can't afford bike-lanes' nonsense.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:32AM (#43678079)
Not getting into some back-n-forth when I agree with much of this, and doing what I can locally.

> Again, literally nobody is arguing that! You have constructed a complete straw man of urbanist.

I actually made my post to head the scarecrows off at the pass. Otherwise these HN threads tend to just turn into reddit fuckcars.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by 7speter on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:53PM (#43668886)
Poor people live in the parts of cities you avoid until your rent gets expensive, too.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by mtalantikite on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:09PM (#43667562)
When I look around on the subway here in NYC I see every type of person imaginable. There are wealthy people going to work and unhoused people and everyone in between. There are certainly transit deserts and I have friends that live in them who do have cars -- largely out in Queens, East New York, etc -- but many of the people I know in the city with cars are financially doing just fine.

It's also important to note that the extreme cost of living in Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn is relatively recent. My friends that grew up here in the 80s, taking the subway to school, were far from bougie. They were living a car free lifestyle then and now just because that's how the environment of many parts of NYC is built. It's not like NYC was constructed as a walking paradise only for wealthy people in the 19th century.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:40PM (#43668138)
True, I'm an old urbanite/suburb-hater. But because of ppl like me, I don't think there's any place left in the USA which has 'good' transit and isn't expensive. (And solutions like congestion tolls only work because of the boogieness.) What's done is done.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by mtalantikite on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:11AM (#43673359)
Yeah, agreed. We built the country for the car and there’s no easy path out of that. Every time I’m in LA I think “man we could have had a city like Barcelona” and get bummed it’s just a sprawling car dependent amalgamation of suburbs. There’s clearly demand for more cities like NYC in the US, but we’re not going to get it.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:36AM (#43678092)
Yeah, some local billionaires want to build "San Francisco by the Sacramento Delta", and it's been nothing but NIMBY opposition. My guess it will be McMansions in 20 years instead. Politically, we can't even build one high-density suburb.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Zigurd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:05PM (#43667083)
A friend of mine is writing a history of the Massachusetts Hill towns. The Strathmore paper company plays a big part in that history the mill owners built housing for their workers within walking distance of the mills.

I also know of a tourism industry company that is buying up older hotels that are no longer competitive in the local market to use as seasonal worker housing.

There are solutions other than having someone drive a beater for 45 minutes to get to a low paying job.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:27PM (#43667264)
Yeah, "company towns" were another issue that cars solved.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by KennyBlanken on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:54PM (#43667447)
On what planet do you think that people living in company housing could afford cars? People living in company housing were the poorest of the poor.

Please just....stop. Stop trying to talk about how poor people lived or live.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:26PM (#43667687)
Correct, it was a terrible situation despite the lack of cars.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by KennyBlanken on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:40PM (#43667359)
Speaking as "the other half": this is wildly condescending, ignorant, and ironic. The irony of declaring that HN doesn't understand "how the other half lives"...

...while also declaring that "used cars are a must" for poor people (if you can afford a car in a city, you're substantially above a huge number of people, and car ownership rate goes up dramatically with wealth. It rises higher than 1 car/person once you start hitting the single digits. A huge number of service industry people, not to mention students, get around on foot or bicycle. They just don't commute 9-5, and they don't live in your neighborhoods, so you don't see them)

...while also making wildly sweeping generalization about where transit does and doesn't go (in my city, poor people get busses, rich people get trolleys and light rail and commuter rail, and it's pretty clearly purposeful that it is very difficult to get to the rich residential parts from the poor residential parts)

...while also making wildly sweeping generalizations that working poor don't work downtown, and only work in "industrial" areas in cities. It really goes to show how invisible we all are to you....even when you're wagging your finger at the rest of HN for not understanding people like us, lol.

Downtown, who exactly do you think handles all the cleaning, maintenance, repair, delivery, food service, retail, etc in the "downtown" area of a city?

Who do you think delivers the paper towels and bottled water and k-cups? Everything around you in your office - every single fucking thing down to the carpet you're standing on - is there because a poor person put it there.

Who do you think is driving the busses and taxis and trucks and vans?

Who do you think works the "gig" "jobs" delivering everything from dry cleaning to laundry to a fancy lunch for to those "young healthy well-paid tech workers"? (and FYI, your boss/admin assistant/office manager, when they order that big lunch from the fancy place across town? They're shit tippers. And bad communicators. And take forever to show up to grab the order.)

Do you realize that even in the "boogie" (sic) part of the city, the guy running the cash register at that hip coffee joint is making as close to minimum wage as the company thinks they can get away with, which is likely, at best, a buck or two an hour more than average?

Who exactly do you think fills all the entry-level jobs, including in tech companies? What do you think the front desk receptionist is paid? The desktop support person?

I feel like you all think that someone who cleans the offices for the big dot-com or white-shoe law office...or someone who dishwashes or busses or does prep work for a fancy restaurant where a plate costs $50, is getting paid anything remotely proportional to the difference in cost from a restaurant a plate for $18 or the hourly rate of that law firm.

It's the opposite - the fanciest places and the biggest name corps squeeze people the hardest. That's how they got to where they are.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:21PM (#43667634)
Criticism accepted, I am not trying to generalize everyone. I am an urban dweller from back in the days when that was the cheap (and less desirable) way to live. So I obviously wish we had much better transit and more affordable housing, and all of the good things. Its not like people want to spend an hour in traffic in a beater-ass car, they do it because they have to. (Because all of the shit you mention is even worse in the suburbs.) I would just like to see some real solutions which don't involve taxing the fuck out of the little guy or nuking the suburbs or the usual Cars Bad handwaving. It's a hard problem which nobody has a real good answer for.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Vinnl on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:22PM (#43667642)
Wasn't GP specifically complaining about the other half not being able to enjoy the "car-free lifestyle"? (/not be forced to use the car to live their life.)
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:52PM (#43667866)
I'm not unsympathetic, but I don't think a "European who studied at OSU for a semester" really knows what they are talking about.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by epolanski on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:48AM (#43671813)
You might be right, I was just sharing my experience and what I've heard from locals.

Anyway, there's an abundant literature that links inequality with transport opportunities.

But those topics are so touchy for you Americans tbh, it's like arguing about weapons, it's too heated of an argument for rational discourse.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:46AM (#43678133)
Yeah, "mobility opportunities". I recognize the issues, and the lack of easy answers, so I think I'm only "touchy" about is simplistic solutions.

European car commuter rates are almost identical to USA's. But I know little about the details, so don't really have any commentary, other than not all of Europe some glorious bike/transit boogie utopia. (And some ppl get "touchy" about that.)

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by timeon on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @05:13AM (#43690599)
> European car commuter rates are almost identical to USA's.

Do you have source for this? I believe this could be true now but I find this kind of arguing dismissive and missing the point.

I'm not from environment you have described. Still remmeber people in my East European corner were able to easily commute to work by bus/train without car. However since they got richer they adopted American commuter patterns more and this led to deterioration of public transport outside of urban areas.

No wonder people get "touchy" because you are not really arguing for those who are not "young healthy well-paid tech workers". But against them. It is not about just ditching the cars but changing whole design of living around the need of cars - which is the point that actually started this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43666410

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by mytailorisrich on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @02:40PM (#43696826)
The thing is that public transport outside of dense urban areas is very expensive compared to the number of journeys.

So as soon as you start considering cost and return on investment services tend to be reduced or shut down.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 19, 2025 @02:42AM (#43734681)
> Do you have source for this?

Great, some discord found this a couple days later and wants a google-a-thon. Since I don't know anything about "Europe", I don't care who is "european" enough to qualify for the 50% or 70% or whatever. Just that they have much better public transit, but still largely drive to work.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @01:37PM (#43696046)
> European car commuter rates are almost identical to USA's.

Hilariously untrue. Using the bus and bike to go to work is normal here. Buses and cycle paths are full of people during rush hour. In the US using those gets you weird looks. Depends on what part of Europe and what part of US we're talking about of course, but in general this holds true.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by 7speter on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:52PM (#43668883)
Thank you for saying this. My household is smack dab in the middle of a food dessert. We have a 25 year old car we got 10 years ago for $2000, and we use it primarily to go to the nice supermarket because you can get fresh, non moldy food at prices better than you can at the sketchy “supermarkets” and bodegas that always have rotting, moldy and non rotated food products on shelves. I do most of the shopping and I keep the freezer full of meat we can get on sale (just got 7 pounds of chicken wings for 2.49 a pound this week) and cook through that. A lot of the types in spaces like these don’t know how to cook and just use services like grubhub, and thinks everyone should too, or they buy 8 dollar a pound organic chicken thighs from Whole foods the day of. Everybody doesn’t live this way.

Also, I use the bus and train to go downtown and places where it would take an hour to find a parking spot. I even lug big bags of food from Aldi on the crowded bus at rush hour weekly. I don’t know why it has to be either you drive everywhere or never need a car in these discussions. Use what you need to use given the situation.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by saltysalt on Sunday April 13, 2025 @05:48AM (#43671506)
You are completely correct about the bias on HN against cars: that will change when they get older and have kids. Not everyone is a young single urbanite working remotely or downtown.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sensanaty on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:49AM (#43671816)
I don't have kids but I do have 4 nephews. They all take their bikes or if not possible for whatever reason, buses/trains/trams/metro to school and elsewhere. My 1 sister lives in the countryside and her kids still take the bike to school, which is ~10km away from their house, and if they go to another city they can take their bikes on the train.

Why wouldn't you want your kid to be independent like this? Why force them to have to rely on you and your car if they want to go out and see their friends? It inconveniences you and makes their life much more dull and restricted, not to mention the health benefits of taking the bike vs sitting in a car for a kid.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by saltysalt on Sunday April 13, 2025 @09:36AM (#43672715)
Why judge others for how they live, when you don't even know their circumstances?
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sensanaty on Sunday April 13, 2025 @09:44AM (#43672753)
Didn't really intend to be judgy, but are you not doing the same when calling out the "Young single urbanites who work from home/downtown"?
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by saltysalt on Sunday April 13, 2025 @10:27AM (#43673048)
I'm not judging them for choosing to use public transport or bicycles, that's their right. They should not judge car drivers, but they often do and want them banned.

The secret to successful urban living is tolerance, but sadly that is in short supply.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by itsmartapuntocm on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:10PM (#43667122)
It’s all by design. Car dependent suburbs with no transit access make it easier to keep “undesirables” out of your neck of the woods.

Robert Moses infamously made great use of infrastructure and urban planning to reinforce redlining.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by alistairSH on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:16PM (#43667171)
Just one example. He required bridges be built too low for buses to pass, limiting access to parks and beaches to those who owned cars…

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-09/robert-mo...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rufus_foreman on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:22PM (#43668047)
Here's the sub-heading from the article you linked to:

"The story: Robert Moses ordered engineers to build the Southern State Parkway’s bridges extra-low, to prevent poor people in buses from using the highway. The truth? It’s a little more complex"

[dead]
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rufus_foreman on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:14PM (#43668325)
"to prevent poor people in buses from using the highway"

No evidence whatsoever for that motivation. You could take the bus to the beach.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dghlsakjg on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:12PM (#43677740)
You are quoting yourself not the article or me?

No evidence besides the direct testimony of a person that worked on the project given to one of the best biographers in a piece of work that won a Pulitzer Prize. Also, the physical evidence of the bridges. Circumstantially, the man was openly racist, and openly used design to segregate.

The assertion isn’t that you couldn’t take a bus to the beach. The assertion is that you couldn’t take a bus from the inner city neighborhoods to Jones Beach, which was true.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by potato3732842 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:25PM (#43668741)
>ust one example. He required bridges be built too low for buses to pass, limiting access to parks and beaches to those who owned cars… >https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-09/robert-mo...

If you're gonna claim something don't cite an article that's all about debunking that thing.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dghlsakjg on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:13PM (#43677743)
Read the article. It doesn’t debunk that assertion. It more or less confirms it.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by EasyMark on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:35PM (#43666868)
Suburbs are fine. We are in 2025, not 1925, there is no reason why work from home isn't an option for information workers and others who don't need to be physically on premises. You are completely ignoring how much that cuts down on traffic and would lower the cost of real estate, so more people who aren't millionaires could live downtown. We also have electric cars that have basically zero emissions, there is a technical solution for this; not everyone wants to ride a bus or train.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by clayhacks on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:38PM (#43666892)
Work from home is great, but there’s more to life than work. Being walking distance or public transport distance to the rest of life’s activities is also great. And EVs aren’t saving the planet they are saving the car industry. They still cause tire particulate pollution, noise pollution, light pollution, and need tons of rare earth minerals
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bluecalm on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:16PM (#43667165)
Don't forget the most important scarce resource they require: space. We waste so much space for parking and other car friendly infrastructure there often is not enough left for a a bike line or even a sidewalk let alone some actually pleasant peaceful passage people could use.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dullcrisp on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:09PM (#43667559)
Not everyone has to ride a bus or a train. They can stay home if they want.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Zigurd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:11PM (#43667124)
Private cars are an economic sinkhole. They make no financial sense. My town in the exurbs used to have rail service and stagecoaches. The necessity of private cars is a marketing triumph. Not a choice.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by goatlover on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:55PM (#43667459)
I like the freedom a private car gives me. I can go anywhere at anytime. I have nothing against public transportation and want it to be good. But you can't go everywhere at anytime. Here I'm including the country side and smaller towns.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dullcrisp on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:07PM (#43667556)
That’s fine, take your private car and drive it away from the city.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by fzeroracer on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:22PM (#43668046)
> But you can't go everywhere at anytime

This is a solved problem in countries with modern public transportation. In Japan for example you can go across the entire country without needing a single car, and indeed it's both cheaper and more available than doing so while driving. If you need to go somewhere really far out of the way that is not reachable by foot or bicycle, then you can rent a car.

All of this results in a system that is far cheaper for you and far more open for the average individual.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dublinben on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:22PM (#43668374)
Nothing says freedom like being required to spend thousands of dollars just to get around and participate in society. Imagine how "free" the roughly one-third of folks who are too young, too old, too disabled, etc. to drive a car feel when trying to go about their lives.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0MVCyOjvtk

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:34PM (#43668787)
So the state of public transportation in your area is bad enough you have to own a car. Being forced to own one is freedom, and so is needing a government-issued driver's license and a license plate.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Sloowms on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:05AM (#43670702)
Anywhere where a road is. Or anywhere you could park a car. This means the car does not give you the freedom but the entire car transportation network. If instead there was no car infrastructure but only public transport you would say you can't go everywhere at anytime with a car.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sokoloff on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:08PM (#43667104)
I drive an EV. I am not under the mistaken impression that it’s zero emission (or even close).

It emits particulates locally and power-generation-related emissions at the fossil fuel plant that provides the majority of my grid power.

Is it better than an ICE? Probably. Is it “basically zero emission”? Nope.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by afthonos on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:53PM (#43666999)
I understand a large amount of car pollution these days is due to the tires.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by pjmlp on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:34PM (#43667741)
Yet RTO is in full enforcement all over the place, sadly.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by andrepd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:40PM (#43666903)
Suburbs are also financially subsidised by the city centres. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IsMeKl-Sv0
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by newZWhoDis on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:37PM (#43666880)
Posts like these reverse cause and effect.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bslalwn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:55PM (#43667014)
In Europe, it’s literally the opposite. Before we went crazy with ulez and regulations, everybody could afford a beater and drive it anywhere. Now, only rich people can drive in city centres, and the prices of cars have skyrocketed. Very, very equal and just!
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:13PM (#43667143)
The prices of cars have “skyrocketed” because the price is now closer to what they actually cost. Meaning, less is being externalized.

Cars are inequality-creators because the drivers offload the cost to everyone, including those who don’t drive. Car centric decisions, air pollution, interstates and freeways, parking lots.

It’s very much akin to tobacco. Tobacco used to be cheap - when the tobacco wouldn’t pay for your addiction, or your COPD, or your eventual death. Now they do - a tiny bit - and tobacco is expensive.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bslalwn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:41PM (#43667371)
>The prices of cars have “skyrocketed” because the price is now closer to what they actually cost. Meaning, less is being externalized.

This is false. There are no “externalities” that are now getting paid. You don’t pay for the right to drive upfront, you already have a permit for that, and that permit is what pays for road maintenance, etc. Maybe the current price is not fair, but that permit hasn’t increased in price. The reality is that Europe let all manufacturers buy one another so they don't have to compete anymore. So they can do whatever they want with prices.

>Cars are inequality-creators because the drivers offload the cost to everyone, including those who don’t drive.

Which wasn't a problem when everybody could afford to drive before Europe ruined everything.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:02PM (#43667510)
> Which wasn't a problem when everybody could afford to drive before Europe ruined everything.

It was still a problem, because a lot of those people died or had reduced quality of life. The reality is driving is very dangerous. In the US, it's the primary cause of death for many age groups.

And the pollution kills. And it kills pedestrians. And car-dependence is a lot like heroin. You depend on cars, so you build things further, so you must drive more. It's a self-eating beast.

Once cars started becoming less polluting and less deadly, i.e. _less cost was externalized_, they got more expensive.

If you truly think Europe is "ruined" because morbidly-obese people aren't puttering around in stinky automobiles for 2-3 hours a day, then I don't know what to tell you. To me, it's nice to have beautiful cities were people can walk. It's nice to go to work and not have a sudden urge to kill yourself.

These people can always move to the Land of the Free, of course. Suburban concrete hellscape after suburban concrete hellscape. I'm referring to the US, of course. The land of varicose veins, fatty liver disease, suicide and smog. Ah, beautiful.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bslalwn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:15PM (#43667604)
There isn’t a single sentence in your comment that isn’t hyperbolic.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:56PM (#43667886)
It's only hyperbole because you have a car-centric point of view. From an objective point of view, there are A LOT of problems with cars.

It's not hyperbolic to say that cars kill people on the scale of tobacco and alcohol. It's literally true. Again, the primary cause of death for a lot of demographics in the US is driving. You would, literally, have a lower mortality if you walked to work and smoked a Capri methanol on the way.

We just don't view driving in this way because, unlike tobacco, it is a necessary evil. As soon as you dismantle the assumption that it's necessary the rest falls into place.

There is a direct link between car-centric infrastructure and most things that are killing you and making your life worse. The fact you choose to ignore it does not mean it doesn't exist. And, to be fair, ignoring it is good practice. If I had to come to terms with my own mortality before every commute I'd probably kill myself. Ignorance is bliss.

If you simply look at the places world-wide associated with higher quality of life you'll notice a common denominator. More greenery, more walking, fresher food, more public transit, and less cars. It's not a coincidence, it's pretty obvious when you sit down and put the pieces together.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by paulcole on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:00PM (#43667045)
At least in the US people absolutely fucking love their cars.

They will lie about how much they hate them but ask them to actually change their behavior and you get nothing but a litany of excuses.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by alistairSH on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:20PM (#43667195)
I walk to work. In the suburbs.

My wife rides a bike. In the suburbs.

We chose a home that has grocers, schools, and dining within a walk or bike ride.

We own cars because there are things beyond ~2 miles and transit options aren’t good.

Sadly, doing this usually requires money. Lots of it.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by beastman82 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:30PM (#43667289)
I love mine and so does everyone else, and I don't feel ashamed at all. They're incredible.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Vinnl on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:23PM (#43667655)
There are probably more reasons for that, but if it's the only thing that allows me to get somewhere, of course I'd love it.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jmilloy on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:40PM (#43667775)
I hate cars. Not using my car wouldn't change any of the things I hate about cars or car infrastructure. It's not lying.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rufus_foreman on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:25PM (#43668069)
I'm not going to lie about it. I feel safest of all in my car. I can lock my car doors. It's the only way to live. In cars.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by cryptopian on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:11PM (#43668303)
I think you're getting cause and effect mixed up. Save for a few petrolheads and train enthusiasts, people use whatever happens to be the most convenient method to get around. In North America, most cities prioritise infrastructure for private cars to such an extent that any other mode is almost useless

Since private cars scale badly, you want to encourage people to take other modes, but in order to change behaviour, the alternatives need to be attractive - cycle layouts that are safe, buses and trains that are frequent and reliable, city layouts that don't involve a long drive to buy food. You can't convince people out of taking the rational choice. You have to build it

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by paulcole on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:59PM (#43668597)
Like I said, litany of excuses.

If you really don’t like cars, you’ll find a way to minimize use of them.

If you really don’t mind cars that much you’ll make up stories about how if buses and trains and bike lanes were more attractive then people would use them more.

I guarantee that if every American city had an ideal bus and train system, people would still find excuses and reasons to justify driving their cars.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Sloowms on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:10AM (#43670714)
There is literally an example of a city with great public transport and 90% of people there use it exclusively. So most people will not make excuses but just use the thing that is easy.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by globular-toast on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:36AM (#43671765)
Everyone loves their car, but hates everyone else's cars. Remember, your car is transport, everyone else's cars are traffic.

Saying "people love cars" is false. Some people love cars. Those are the ones doing their own work/maintenance/restorations etc and just spending time in the garage with their cars. A few more people love driving, they don't just love cars for their own sake, but they will go and just drive for fun. But most people don't do any of that. They just use cars as part of their boring, routine lives.

You might as well say US people fucking love washing machines or knives and forks.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by paulcole on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:48AM (#43673640)
> You might as well say US people fucking love washing machines or knives and forks.

Yeah, you’re getting it.

Nobody will say they love washing machines but they clearly do. We see it in their actions. Same as with cars. Everything they do tells us that they love cars. They drive comically short distances. They spend money they barely have to buy them.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jfengel on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:45PM (#43666480)
It is, though the problem predates the cars. At the time cars were seen as a huge win over the vast piles of horse poop.

Cities do need to be reconsidered for more public transit and more opportunities to walk, but other issues (delivery, emergency, disability, etc) have to figure in.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by SequoiaHope on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:57PM (#43666567)
There was a time in between, where electric streetcars (trains) were a common mode of transport. But those got torn up for cars. That’s a real tragedy in hindsight.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:11PM (#43666685)
That's the myth. Streetcars were actually torn up because busses were much cheaper, there was no conspiracy. The streetcars were also old and cold and ppl hated them.

(I lived in a streetcar part of SF, and loved it, fwiw. But the only reason it's still there is a tunnel.)

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by isametry on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:55PM (#43667012)
Trains are expensive upfront, which might favor buses when expanding into new areas. But if the infrastructure is already there, a train line will always be more economical in the long run than the equivalent bus line.

So ripping out existing serviceable train tracks is stupid (or alternatively: evil) if you think in the long term.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:45PM (#43667399)
As I said in another post, train tracks don't last forever and are expensive to replace. And trains really only benefit from dedicated ROW, a streetcar is worse than a bus in many respects. (Except appeal.) People back in the 1950s were not stupid or evil, they made a decision which made a lot of sense at the time.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by adrian_b on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:52PM (#43666993)
Establishing a new bus service in an area where public transportation had not existed must be indeed much cheaper.

However it is impossible for the operational and maintenance costs for a bus service and for the roads on which the buses go to be cheaper than for an electric streetcar, unless some prices are fake.

It is true that I have seen enough cases where electric streetcars have been replaced by buses, but I cannot see other explanation except bribes, because it was extremely visible that the buses were more expensive, both because of the fuel consumption and because of the much more frequent repairs both for the buses and for the roads.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:08PM (#43667108)
It's interesting, in San Francisco, the streetcars got too heavy for the old tracks so they replaced them with about 4 feet deep of concrete. That is actual infrastructure and not "fake". (along with all the stops and handicap ramps and etc. obviously, a paved street is going to exist either way.)

Bribes and the mafia may have been a factor[0], but that's how American cities do things.

[0] eg. https://www2.startribune.com/streetcars-buses-minneapolis-st...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jmward01 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:47PM (#43666957)
That is a statement that really needs citation and qualification to back it up. I'd argue that 'cheaper' is used in a vacuum here. By that I mean that the point of mass transit isn't how much it costs, but how much value it provides. By that measure the bus services that replaced streetcars and other mass transit really doesn't stack up. Busses have led to much lower ridership which has led to a massive amount of bad secondary effects. Looking at how congestion pricing in NYC has increased mass transit use AND economic activity it is pretty clear that 'cheaper' has led to secondary effects that far outweigh any narrow operational gains from switching to busses.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:12PM (#43667131)
The citation is every American transit system in the 1950s. Even SF only kept the streetcars where they couldn't replace with a bus line.

I think you're making a different argument, where trains attract a more well-heeled commuter. Which is why many cities have brought back LRT as part of a redevelopment plan.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jmward01 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:40PM (#43667774)
The argument I am making is that you can only say something was cheaper if it provided the same level of service or better for less money. In the case of the bus transition it provided worse service as indicated by utilization dropping. I am also making the argument that evaluating the value of transit shouldn't rest entirely on the cost of that service and ridership but on the value as a whole it brings to a city. I mentioned NYC because the evidence there (and in other cities that have implemented congestion pricing) is that as ridership goes up the economic, environment, and social health of a city also goes up. Point being, the bus transition had a very negative value impact. I will also add a final argument, as your ridership drops things like busses may appear less costly per ride simply because you are loosing volume and low volume routes are likely easier to service by bus so, again, cheaper but not an apples to apples comparison.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:58PM (#43667895)
Yes, I like trains and wish we had better transit. I'm responding to the claim streetcars were "torn up for cars", which was not really the case (and frequently subject to a conspiracy theory).
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rsynnott on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:33AM (#43671121)
So… it kind of made sense at the time (if you ignored a couple of factors which didn’t become obvious until much later, and which ultimately made it a disaster), and it’s not just an American thing. In 1928, Dublin had 28 tramlines. By 1950, it had zero, with the tram routes being replaced by bus routes (many older Dublin Bus routes basically follow old tram routes even today). It didn’t have trams again til 2004; today it has two lines.

But _at the time_, buses were very competitive with trams; there wasn’t all that much other road traffic, so they weren’t really slower (and they could use the tram lines, while they existed, as a right of way), the trams of the time were non-articulated, so buses had similar or higher capacity, and they were more flexible. It’s easy to see how it happened, and it only became apparent that there was a problem when it was far too late to reverse.

There are really two problems with buses vs trams; buses are slow when there is lots of other traffic, and, _with modern articulated trams_, higher total capacities are achievable (one of Dublin’s modern tramlines has trams that take over 400 people with a frequency of under 3 minutes between trams at peak, which is a level of capacity that you just can’t really get with buses). Neither of these were factors when the first-generation trams died.

Very few tram systems worldwide actually survived from the early 20th century to today; while there are lots of trams today, most are second-generation systems put in from the 80s on.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:42PM (#43666922)
Many other places just... upgraded the trams.

You know, the less radical solution.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:45AM (#43671171)
A bus is the least radical thing IMO, but yeah it took too long in most of USA to get some mass transit better than streetcars.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by ximeng on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:17PM (#43666732)
Just like the promise of EVs to replace the exhaust from ICE cars is seen as a win.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:53PM (#43666538)
Let's be real here, a huge chunk of car traffic in cities is purely for convenience.

Once that's reduced by say, 50%, everything becomes much better, but nobody gives up convenience voluntarily.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:23PM (#43666780)
The problem is that, among casualties, you create an environment that is hostile for families and disabled people.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:05PM (#43667082)
If there are fewer cars on the road, there is a lot less traffic, and driving because much easier for those who are car-dependent. Example: the Netherlands.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:11PM (#43667125)
Netherlands have as many cars as most the developed nations.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:16PM (#43667155)
Yes, but they're used less frequently. Most middle class people have a car, but they're often only used for irregular trips. Commuting and errands use alternative means at much higher rates than elsewhere.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:21PM (#43667206)
Point is, they still need cars if they have them. And Netherlands are very far from Paris, infrastructure-wise. In Paris, for instance, leaving your cargo or e-bike outside for the night means finding nothing when you wake up (I got two bikes stolen already, and they were the cheapest available).
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:50PM (#43667428)
The topic of the original post is air pollution. Unused cars don't cause air pollution. The topic of this thread is inconveniencing the disabled. Unused cars don't cause traffic that inconveniences the disabled.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:14PM (#43667592)
Paris tackled the problem by making it very hard to own a car. It's the same for Amsterdam, too. We all hate pollution, it's just that the solutions available in the Dutch countryside are a bit different than in Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:48PM (#43668860)
Your "point" doesn't exist. You're essentially attempting to equate the transit situation in the US with the Netherlands, which is plain ridiculous.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by loloquwowndueo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:26PM (#43666802)
Only if you just remove the cars without replacing them with good public transportation (family friendly, accessible, with special modes for disabled people).
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:32PM (#43667301)
Which doesn't exist and is hardly possible in Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by alistairSH on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:25PM (#43667235)
That’s not a given. Nobody here is talking about outright bans on all vehicles. Limited access for taxis and commercial use is a thing. Buses can be built with wheelchair access. Etc.

And with less space reserved for cars and only cars, there’s more space for wide/accessible sidewalks. Less chance of being run over by a car. Less air and noise pollution.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:32PM (#43667298)
Well if you have less space for cars, parking spots are more expensive as a result. In Paris it's around a year of living wage. And currently, sidewalks are getting smaller due to the need to build bicycle lanes.

My initial post was that in Paris, they removed cars but did not improve public transports, so buses are overcrowded and hostile to strollers.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jenadine on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:04PM (#43668629)
People with disabilities gets a special pass that allow them to park on special parking places that are reserved for them.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by chadd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:29PM (#43666823)
i'm not sure this is true, for instance NYC ranks as the second most disabled-friendly city

https://www.amny.com/lifestyle/new-york-city-ranks-2nd-in-a-...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:54PM (#43667003)
Surprising, considering the NYC subway has been ignoring the ADA as much as possible.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rangestransform on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:03PM (#43668621)
What else do you expect when elevators are 100M apiece
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:44PM (#43666935)
In Paris, 90% of the metro transportation system isn't accessible to wheelchairs and strollers. Buses are overcrowded and slow. Who doesn't enjoy to see someone cough on their newborn while fighting for a space for their stoller ?
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:52PM (#43666987)
Buses are perfectly accessible in Paris. They are crowded but acceptably so for a city of 10 millions. It’s not fair to expect the collectivity to accept the externalities of cars so rich people can avoid some slight discomfort.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:09PM (#43667113)
Paris is not a city of 10 millions, it has only two million habitants. And cars are not reserved to rich people, why would they be? I grew up in Paris, my parents weren't rich, we were living in public housing and we had a car.

Families are not second-tier citizens, and currently the public transports are not suited for them. On top of the other problems, such as the pleasure of having to deal with crackheads and various homeless people in the metro when you have a baby.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Paris

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jltsiren on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:37PM (#43667336)
When it comes to traffic and urban planning, Paris is best understood as a city of 10+ million people. The administrative subdivision called Paris has only ~2 million people, but the city doesn't end at its borders.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:59PM (#43667491)
Yes, however there is little urban planning for whole metro, and the administrative level we are talking about here is the intra-muros one. When the mayor decided to reduce the speed on the outer loop, she didn't notify nor discussed with the rest of the metro, for instance. And the measures discussed in the article are specific to Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:18PM (#43668015)
> Yes, however there is little urban planning for whole metro

Paris biggest infrastructure project for the past 20 years is called "Grand Paris" and revolve entirely around the whole metro. Actually there is literally no urban planning not involving the whole metro. And yes, lowering the speed limit involved multiple consultations with the prefect and the region because it impacts the whole metro.

Considering Paris without its metropole doesn’t make sense. Paris intra-muros is ridiculously small, one eightieth of London, 80% of San Francisco.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:50PM (#43669133)
Le Grand Paris...mostly doesn't involve Paris, as it's a new metro loop around it.

Besides, what your say about the speed limit is false, the mayor didn't wait for the State's answer and decided unilaterally. The State and the region didn't agree with her: https://www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2024/09/09/anne-hid... https://www.lepoint.fr/politique/la-region-ile-de-france-ref...

You can consider as much as you want, it is not unified. The result is that Paris has an anti-car policy, but the neighboring towns are very pro-car, creating a system where Parisians can't own one, but have to bear their neighbor's who use them to get into the city.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:51PM (#43676764)
Le Grand Paris is the loop and the prolongation of all the inner lines deserving it. It very much involves Paris as its name implies.

> Besides, what your say about the speed limit is false, the mayor didn't wait for the State's answer and decided unilaterally. The State and the region didn't agree with her: https://www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2024/09/09/anne-hid...

The article you quote says the opposite of what you pretend. I invite you to read the paragraph "Une décision sous le contrôle de l’Etat, rappelle le ministère". It explains in details than the mayor could do nothing without the state agreeing to it.

> You can consider as much as you want, it is not unified.

It is unified. The city and its suburb are one economic unit. Where do you think all the service workers live? You have to be an extremely narrow minded inner city dweller to fail to see this.

> creating a system where Parisians can't own one, but have to bear their neighbor's who use them to get into the city.

I kindly invite you to check the average salary of Paris inhabitants vs the one in the suburbs then take a minute to think about what you just wrote.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:54PM (#43676777)
> Families are not second-tier citizens, and currently the public transports are not suited for them.

My family and the dozens I see every day in the Paris public transports beg to differ.

I suggest you might be a bit prejudiced (well more than a bit to be fair).

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:43PM (#43666930)
Shocker, both disabled people and families are easily identifiable and can be exempt from such measures.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:52PM (#43666988)
Well, they aren't exempt. Many French greens will tell you anyway that having children is bad for the planet and that you should abstain. And, as our population grows older, the accessibility problem will be larger and larger.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:41AM (#43679290)
The Greens have less than 7% of the places in the French Parliament.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Der_Einzige on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:05PM (#43667080)
A lot of car drivers will respond with “good” and Darwinian arguments about their lack of fitness for the harshness of life.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by seszett on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:30PM (#43668094)
> an environment that is hostile for families

I don't understand this part, I read it quite often but... well, we are a family with young children, and although we do have a car we only use it once a week to go to the grand-parents that live 100 km away from here.

A city with less cars is great especially for families (though I would argue that cities themselves are not so great for children, but the comparison here is between cities that are car-centric or that are not). It makes going out easier and more spontaneous.

It's much less of a hassle to hop in the cargo bike and go wherever (including stopping en route if you see something interesting) than having to use the car, sit in traffic, hope you can find parking space at your destination, and pay for it.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by enaaem on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:50PM (#43668189)
In the 60s, Dutch anti-car protestors had the slogan "Stop the child murder!". People were used to traditional cities where children could safely cycle around, but then cars came and started killing them.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:56PM (#43669152)
I have very two kids, plan to have three. Cargo bikes are not practical, are easily stolen, and are not safe to transport children, especially under 6 years old. Besides, when doing groceries for 5 once a week, I regularly fill my 500L car boot, so an equivalent cargo bike with at least 3 seats and a large boot... would just be a car. Which you have, and use once a week.

Or when you need to go to the doctor. Or when your wife is sick. Or if you have an urgency. So, as a family, you still need a car.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by seszett on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:07AM (#43670464)
Well I just have the reverse experience. My cargo bike is practical, has not been stolen yet and up to four children under 6 are fine to transport in it. I don't feel it especially unsafe.

I also use it for groceries. Sometimes using both the cargo bike and a bike trailer (on two different bikes). We don't buy nearly at many things though it seems. When I do use my car (doing groceries while the children are with the grandparents) I have to transfer them from the car to the bike anyway because I can rarely park close to my home.

My doctor (and my wife's doctor) is certainly easier to reach by foot than by car. And I guess I never have the kind of urgency that would require me to use a car in the city. If there's something urgent a bike is always faster in this city.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:54PM (#43675383)
People only look at extremes for this. Using your car less is still a win. We don't need to go to "you shouldn't use your car at all".
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dghlsakjg on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:17PM (#43668341)
I can assure you that there are disabled people who really don’t like car oriented environments since so many disabilities preclude driving.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by EA-3167 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:48PM (#43666510)
Not just horse poop, but dead horses that were quite the chore to remove back in the day, and the danger posed to pedestrians by a bunch of quite large and easily panicked animals.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by 1over137 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @01:58PM (#43666577)
We still have that danger. But the animals are homo sapiens and they are surrounded by 2 tonnes of metal. :)
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Tade0 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:24PM (#43666785)
One of the early examples of the Poisson distribution was the rate at which soldiers in the Prussian army would be fatally kicked by horses.

Translates to a little over 30 deaths per year per million, so not a lot, though I suspect the number would have been much greater adjusted for distance travelled and even without that it's more than some countries achieve with their traffic.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by EA-3167 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:18PM (#43666748)
This is true, but from the perspective of the time, automobiles were far from "2 tons of metal" and quite a bit slower. They were also a rich man's conveyance, even more so than a nice carriage, and I doubt people understood early on just how widely adopted the automobile would become.

A lack of foresight is also very human.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by heresie-dabord on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:14PM (#43667145)
>A lack of foresight is also very human.

Let's call it what it really is. The stubborn unwillingness to consider scalability in our designs and planning — even in an era where a machine can do calculation for us.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:46PM (#43668843)
Those "other issues" are all worse with private cars than without.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by tzs on Sunday April 13, 2025 @12:46AM (#43670161)
They were also seen as a safety win [1][2]. Horses and horse drawn carts were a lot more dangerous than most people here probably think they were.

From the second link:

> It is easy to imagine that a hundred years ago, when cars were first appearing on our roads, they replaced previously peaceful, gentle and safe forms of travel. In fact, motor vehicles were welcomed as the answer to a desperate state of affairs. In 1900 it was calculated that in England and Wales there were around 100,000 horse drawn public passenger vehicles, half a million trade vehicles and about half a million private carriages. Towns in England had to cope with over 100 million tons of horse droppings a year (much of it was dumped at night in the slums) and countless gallons of urine. Men wore spats and women favoured outdoor ankle-length coats not out of a sense of fashion but because of the splash of liquified manure; and it was so noisy that straw had to be put down outside hospitals to muffle the clatter of horses’ hooves. Worst of all, with horses and carriages locked in immovable traffic jams, transport was grinding to a halt in London and other cities.

> Moreover, horse-drawn transport was not safe. Road traffic deaths from horse-drawn vehicles in England and Wales between 1901 and 1905 were about 2,500 a year. This works out as about 70 road traffic deaths per million population per year which is close to the annual rate of 80 to 100 deaths per million for road traffic accidents in the 1980s and 1990s, although we must not forget that many people who died from injuries sustained in road accidents in 1900 would probably have survived today thanks to our A&E departments.

> Motor vehicles were welcomed because they were faster, safer, unlikely to swerve or bolt, better able brake in an emergency, and took up less room: a single large lorry could pull a load that would take several teams of horses and wagons – and do so without producing any dung. By World War One industry had become dependent on lorries, traffic cruised freely down Oxford Street and Piccadilly, specialists parked their expensive cars ouside their houses in Harley and Wimpole Street, and the lives of general practitioners were transformed. By using even the cheapest of cars doctors no longer had to wake the stable lad and harness the horse to attend a night call. Instead it was ‘one pull of the handle and they were off’. Further, general practitioners could visit nearly twice as many patients in a day than they could in the days of the horse and trap.

[1] https://legallysociable.com/2012/09/07/figures-more-deaths-p...

[2]https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/31/cars-and-horse...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Sloowms on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:21AM (#43670771)
Emergency response times go down in almost any case where car use is restricted. In the Netherlands emergency vehicles take bike lane shortcuts because people on bikes can move out of the way more easily. In New York, congestion pricing reduced the response times of emergency services.

Disability needs an annotations for only specific disabilities that don't inhibit driving. Which is a small subset of disabilities.

Delivery of most things can be done with small cars/trucks.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by timewizard on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:27PM (#43666816)
There are cities not designed around cars. We just call them "rural." You could not have had your urban city without cars. There is absolutely nothing "tragic" about this.

Meanwhile you live in a world where petty wars are fought over resources to enhance the wealth of an extreme minority of the population. That's an actual tragedy.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by masklinn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:34PM (#43666863)
> There are cities not designed around cars. We just call them "rural." You could not have had your urban city without cars.

That is literally the opposite of reality.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rebolek on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:00PM (#43667048)
I lived car-free life in a (European) city without any hassle. I moved to "rural" and can't imagine I would be able to live there without a car. In city, you can afford to have public transport on every corner going every ten minutes. In the rural area it's impossible.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:45PM (#43666944)
The first "urban city" predates the car by about 5000 years.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by freen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:29PM (#43666828)
It seems we have very different definitions of “city”.

I am very curious to hear yours.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by timewizard on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:33PM (#43666861)
It seems you want to ignore half the problem.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by alistairSH on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:29PM (#43667279)
I’m still not sure what point you’re trying to make… you claimed cities can’t exist without cars. Yet London and Paris and Rome and damn near every big city in Europe did predate cars by centuries.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by masklinn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:28PM (#43667702)
Not just Europe either. Tokyo was not named after the Tokyo Motor Vehicles Ltd.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rsynnott on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:40AM (#43671149)
> You could not have had your urban city without cars.

… Eh? The city I live in has been here for a thousand years, and that doesn’t even make it a particularly old city. _Outer suburbs_ are a somewhat car-dependent phenomenon, but cities certainly are not.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:20PM (#43666757)
Paris didn't improve its public transportation system, as it made it impossible to own a car. It ends up as pure sadism for the inhabitants who are not childless, affluent 20/30 years old, and who have no alternative than having to take the piss-smelling cattle trains with no access the disabled people, or strollers.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:23PM (#43666779)
> A city improved the air quality

"Pure sadism!!!"

Yeah I'm sure everyone is real miserable, which is why they just voted in a referendum for more car-free streets.

Amazing how out of touch with reality the car-dominance types are.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:36PM (#43666873)
The improvement in air quality is overwhelmingly a result of banning diesel cars. It is, of course, possible to ban diesel cars rather than all cars.

The people who live in the city don't want cars because it's the people who can't afford to live in the city who need them to get there.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by masklinn on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:44PM (#43666937)
> it's the people who can't afford to live in the city who need them to get there.

What are you talking about. Paris's public transport reaches out 60km away from the city, and that's not including mainline trains (including high speed). The people who can't afford to live in the city have taken public transport to get there for 50 years.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:55PM (#43667015)
A lot of economic activity requires cars. Delivery, workers coming with equipment, waste management, and so on. Every construction worker in Paris will tell you that it's very difficult to work there, and that they have doubled their prices as a result.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:20PM (#43667196)
These people are HELPED by anti-car legislation because it clears the congestion for them to run their business.

Most small, and large, businesses would happily pay a small fee if it means half the transportation time. And it does, because traffic isn’t linear. Just a few more cars can be the difference between coasting at 30 or not moving at all.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:28PM (#43667269)
If it's really only a difference of a few cars then there should be a dozen other ways to get a similar effect without enacting a regressive tax.

Meanwhile doing it through financial deterrence requires that someone is actually deterred. And then is that going to be poor people and small businesses or rich people and major companies?

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:58PM (#43667477)
It's not a regressive tax, and it primarily assists commuters and small businesses, and I've already explained how.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 12, 2025 @10:42PM (#43669634)
> It's not a regressive tax

It's a compulsory fee charged by the government not based on income/consumption. That's the most regressive tax. Even sales tax is less regressive than that.

> it primarily assists commuters and small businesses

Relative to any alternative that reduces congestion without charging fees, it doesn't. Even relative to doing nothing, the people being deterred are the ones paying the cost, and the people being deterred are the most price sensitive ones, i.e. the poor.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:16PM (#43710478)
> Relative to any alternative that reduces congestion without charging fees, it doesn't.

These? Don't exist. We're not going to sit here and argue against hypothetical, made-up solutions.

> and the people being deterred are the most price sensitive ones, i.e. the poor.

Sigh. No, the most price sensitive people are riding the subway, because the subway is SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper and faster than owning and operating a car. This is targeting the people right above those people, who, because they have a bit more money, think they need to drive. They don't. They should be riding the subway. And now, they are. They might complain - but really, they're saving money.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:34PM (#43667314)
The infrastructure changes required to get cars out meant to reduce the flow speed of cars. As a result, even buses, who have dedicated lanes, are much slower.

[EDIT]: since I'm being answered that it isn't true, here is a chart made by the city hall about the decreasing speed on Paris' roads:

https://cdn.paris.fr/paris/2024/07/12/original-4ee2d20dafdc9...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by const_cast on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:58PM (#43667479)
This is just not true, sorry.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:29PM (#43669052)
Paris has an ever increasing congestion caused by those measures, as most of the drivers are professionals linked to the city's economic activity who need to get there. Deliveries, constructions vehicules and workers, and so on. It is so bad that surface public transports are being shunned and see usage decrease because they are too slow.

https://www.leparisien.fr/paris-75/paris-ville-la-plus-embou...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Saturday April 12, 2025 @09:32PM (#43669314)
Most of the cars are not people using them for "economic" reasons.

And even some of those can use bikes depending on the specific thing (some delivery workers).

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:30PM (#43683092)
That's not what they were talking about. Sure, some people need cars to transport things, but most of the people who complain about this kind of thing just wanna commute in their car.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:07PM (#43667100)
The ones who live directly adjacent to a rail line weren't generally the ones in cars to begin with, unless they were the ones using a vehicle to actually transport something.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:29PM (#43683074)
Unlikely, Paris has plenty of transit lines.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:33PM (#43666857)
You clearly have a non-existent knowledge of French political life. This referendum had a participation rate of 4%, and only 62% of the voters voted yes. So around 2% of the total voters.

By the way, the French metro's air is highly polluted, due to tire degradation and brake dust, making it unfit for children or pregnant women.

So yeah, it's manageable for young people. But when a baby arrives, it's hell. Same if you are old. Or disabled.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by anigbrowl on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:26PM (#43667246)
French metro's air is highly polluted, due to tire degradation and brake dust, making it unfit for children or pregnant women

These sound like...car problems.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rangestransform on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:11PM (#43667577)
I can insulate myself from these problems in a car with a hepa air filter
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 13, 2025 @01:39PM (#43674454)
Fuck them pedestrians, I guess.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:35PM (#43667319)
True, but the metro space is closed, so pollution can attain a very high level there.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by garbawarb on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:22PM (#43667212)
So only 1.5% of Paris voted against this? It sounds like they're going by the will of the voters.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:38PM (#43667344)
No, the vote was pure communication by the mayor, it didn't have a budget, nor a list of the streets, nor any details. Paris' administration is rife with corruption and mismanagement, so voters weren't very mobilized for another PR coup.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Agingcoder on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:56PM (#43668579)
Mismanagement is (very) well documented but corruption is a very serious accusation. Do you have examples ? ( that don’t go back to Jacques Chirac )
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:35PM (#43669071)
I would suggest to look into the various whimsical subsidies of the city hall, the very expensive procurement of useless products or the ruinous public housing policy, that all serve to help the friends of the mayor and the constellation of fake associations that support her. All has been also documented, and has been mentioned repeatedly by the press.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by SettembreNero on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:01PM (#43668609)
Informative panels about the vote where pretty much everywhere around the city.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:36PM (#43669078)
And yet they couldn't even name one street that would be turned into a pedestrian one! Or give a budget! World class management right here heh?
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by andrepd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:45PM (#43666946)
Dutch people seem to do just fine with baby seats on their bikes, or bakfiets if you have lots of kids.

Anecdotally, kids are also much happier when they can just bike to school/sports/activities with their friends instead of having their parents drive then everywhere on the back of the family SUV.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:02PM (#43667062)
Dutch people using bikes for everything is a meme, they have as many cars per inhabitants as most of the developed nations. Anecdotically, they are a small, dense, flat country, with an oceanic weather.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_territ...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by com on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:27PM (#43667265)
But those cars, as has been explained to you, don’t do nearly as many trips per year.

Mobility in families is actually higher, since each individual has sturdy legs, and highly likely, a bike after they’re about 5 years old. Kids often travel to school, after school events etc on foot, bike or public transport, not dependent as in many car-centric places on parents and their cars.

Grandma is as likely to bike over for dinner with the grandkids as drive.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:43PM (#43667388)
Yes, but they still own them. In Paris, and many commenters here argue that you shouldn't own one.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by com on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:01PM (#43667507)
That’s certainly not being posited in this particular thread.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by yard2010 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:34PM (#43667739)
Rome wasn't built in a day.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @01:54PM (#43696249)
You're comparing a city with a country. Yes, you generally speaking shouldn't need a car if you live in a city.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by numitus on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:54PM (#43667877)
85% of travels in Netherlands happens using car https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/TRAN_HV_MS_PS...
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by isthatafact on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:01PM (#43668238)
While disappointingly high, that figure ignores walking and cycling. There is no need to misrepresent the data to make your point.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sensanaty on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:18PM (#43667180)
We have cars here, but you're not dependent on them to get everywhere unless you live in the countryside (and even then, I knew plenty of kids who lived up in the North who biked 10+ km 1 way to school) or one of the super small cities where the sprinters are sparse. And isn't that the point most people make? It's not about complete eradication of cars, it's about having viable transport alternatives and the infrastructure to support those. It's just that we live in such a world where it's unthinkable to not have half our countries paved in asphalt to make sure cars can get places, so things like these always end up falling into a 2-sided extremist camp.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:41PM (#43667366)
But...you still have cars fr when you need one. What many commenters argue here, and what the Paris administration is arguing is that you shouldn't own one.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by sensanaty on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:42PM (#43668496)
I mean if you live in a city like Paris, then yeah I'd say that's legitimate. I see nothing wrong with making such dense urban centers car-free other than what's necessary like deliveries or ambulances and such, but for the former these days you've got tiny electric trucks that even fit on bike paths without causing a ruckus, usually you'll see those grocery delivery services use them.

Yes, people outside of urban cities like that (which, basically by definition means the majority of people in the country) still need cars to get around most likely, but at least we can ensure that inside the cities themselves, there are good alternatives for people to get around that benefits every single person who finds themselves in the city not inside a car, which will be the overwhelming majority of people.

I live in Utrecht in the Netherlands, and the single best thing the gov't did a few years ago is rip out the highway that was in the city center and instead turned it back into a canal surrounded by parks [1]. Literally nobody who has ever been to Utrecht would argue we were better off with the highway.

[1] https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2020/09/16/utrecht-correc...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:44PM (#43683231)
You should be able to comfortably not own one, without it being a real problem.

We lived in Munich for five years as a family of three with no car and it was fine. There were definitely some times where a car would be more convenient (going to Ikea or the mountains) but overall getting around with our electric cargo bike or public transit was fine.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Monday April 14, 2025 @12:34PM (#43683133)
Even the Dutch haven't invested nearly as much money into bike infrastructure as car infrastructure.

It's funny how much the car-dominance folks do their best to ignore that countries invariably have spent at least an order of magnitude more on cars than bikes, and typically more like two orders of magnitude.

The bike infrastructure the Dutch do have is very cool, but let's be real, one of those fancy "bike interchanges" is absolutely dwarfed by the cost of a highway interchange, and there are far more of the latter than the former.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @01:52PM (#43696211)
A meme you say?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqQSwQLDIK8

As for the excuses:

> they are a small

What does a size of a country have to do with how their cities are designed?

> dense

Same as above, unless you mean city density in which case there's nothing special about Dutch cities.

> flat

Yes, and?

> an oceanic weather

Yeah, it rains all the time and yet they cycle.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:35PM (#43675257)
So the people who voted yes still outnumbered the people who voted no.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by simonebrunozzi on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:31AM (#43679243)
That's one of the reasons why I moved to Venice, Italy. No cars. City is still the same it was 500 years ago, more or less.