News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:23PM (#43666780)
The problem is that, among casualties, you create an environment that is hostile for families and disabled people.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:05PM (#43667082)
If there are fewer cars on the road, there is a lot less traffic, and driving because much easier for those who are car-dependent. Example: the Netherlands.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:11PM (#43667125)
Netherlands have as many cars as most the developed nations.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:16PM (#43667155)
Yes, but they're used less frequently. Most middle class people have a car, but they're often only used for irregular trips. Commuting and errands use alternative means at much higher rates than elsewhere.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:21PM (#43667206)
Point is, they still need cars if they have them. And Netherlands are very far from Paris, infrastructure-wise. In Paris, for instance, leaving your cargo or e-bike outside for the night means finding nothing when you wake up (I got two bikes stolen already, and they were the cheapest available).
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by bryanlarsen on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:50PM (#43667428)
The topic of the original post is air pollution. Unused cars don't cause air pollution. The topic of this thread is inconveniencing the disabled. Unused cars don't cause traffic that inconveniences the disabled.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @04:14PM (#43667592)
Paris tackled the problem by making it very hard to own a car. It's the same for Amsterdam, too. We all hate pollution, it's just that the solutions available in the Dutch countryside are a bit different than in Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Mawr on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:48PM (#43668860)
Your "point" doesn't exist. You're essentially attempting to equate the transit situation in the US with the Netherlands, which is plain ridiculous.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by loloquwowndueo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:26PM (#43666802)
Only if you just remove the cars without replacing them with good public transportation (family friendly, accessible, with special modes for disabled people).
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:32PM (#43667301)
Which doesn't exist and is hardly possible in Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by alistairSH on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:25PM (#43667235)
That’s not a given. Nobody here is talking about outright bans on all vehicles. Limited access for taxis and commercial use is a thing. Buses can be built with wheelchair access. Etc.

And with less space reserved for cars and only cars, there’s more space for wide/accessible sidewalks. Less chance of being run over by a car. Less air and noise pollution.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:32PM (#43667298)
Well if you have less space for cars, parking spots are more expensive as a result. In Paris it's around a year of living wage. And currently, sidewalks are getting smaller due to the need to build bicycle lanes.

My initial post was that in Paris, they removed cars but did not improve public transports, so buses are overcrowded and hostile to strollers.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jenadine on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:04PM (#43668629)
People with disabilities gets a special pass that allow them to park on special parking places that are reserved for them.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by chadd on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:29PM (#43666823)
i'm not sure this is true, for instance NYC ranks as the second most disabled-friendly city

https://www.amny.com/lifestyle/new-york-city-ranks-2nd-in-a-...

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by flomo on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:54PM (#43667003)
Surprising, considering the NYC subway has been ignoring the ADA as much as possible.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by rangestransform on Saturday April 12, 2025 @07:03PM (#43668621)
What else do you expect when elevators are 100M apiece
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:44PM (#43666935)
In Paris, 90% of the metro transportation system isn't accessible to wheelchairs and strollers. Buses are overcrowded and slow. Who doesn't enjoy to see someone cough on their newborn while fighting for a space for their stoller ?
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:52PM (#43666987)
Buses are perfectly accessible in Paris. They are crowded but acceptably so for a city of 10 millions. It’s not fair to expect the collectivity to accept the externalities of cars so rich people can avoid some slight discomfort.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:09PM (#43667113)
Paris is not a city of 10 millions, it has only two million habitants. And cars are not reserved to rich people, why would they be? I grew up in Paris, my parents weren't rich, we were living in public housing and we had a car.

Families are not second-tier citizens, and currently the public transports are not suited for them. On top of the other problems, such as the pleasure of having to deal with crackheads and various homeless people in the metro when you have a baby.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Paris

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by jltsiren on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:37PM (#43667336)
When it comes to traffic and urban planning, Paris is best understood as a city of 10+ million people. The administrative subdivision called Paris has only ~2 million people, but the city doesn't end at its borders.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:59PM (#43667491)
Yes, however there is little urban planning for whole metro, and the administrative level we are talking about here is the intra-muros one. When the mayor decided to reduce the speed on the outer loop, she didn't notify nor discussed with the rest of the metro, for instance. And the measures discussed in the article are specific to Paris.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:18PM (#43668015)
> Yes, however there is little urban planning for whole metro

Paris biggest infrastructure project for the past 20 years is called "Grand Paris" and revolve entirely around the whole metro. Actually there is literally no urban planning not involving the whole metro. And yes, lowering the speed limit involved multiple consultations with the prefect and the region because it impacts the whole metro.

Considering Paris without its metropole doesn’t make sense. Paris intra-muros is ridiculously small, one eightieth of London, 80% of San Francisco.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:50PM (#43669133)
Le Grand Paris...mostly doesn't involve Paris, as it's a new metro loop around it.

Besides, what your say about the speed limit is false, the mayor didn't wait for the State's answer and decided unilaterally. The State and the region didn't agree with her: https://www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2024/09/09/anne-hid... https://www.lepoint.fr/politique/la-region-ile-de-france-ref...

You can consider as much as you want, it is not unified. The result is that Paris has an anti-car policy, but the neighboring towns are very pro-car, creating a system where Parisians can't own one, but have to bear their neighbor's who use them to get into the city.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:51PM (#43676764)
Le Grand Paris is the loop and the prolongation of all the inner lines deserving it. It very much involves Paris as its name implies.

> Besides, what your say about the speed limit is false, the mayor didn't wait for the State's answer and decided unilaterally. The State and the region didn't agree with her: https://www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2024/09/09/anne-hid...

The article you quote says the opposite of what you pretend. I invite you to read the paragraph "Une décision sous le contrôle de l’Etat, rappelle le ministère". It explains in details than the mayor could do nothing without the state agreeing to it.

> You can consider as much as you want, it is not unified.

It is unified. The city and its suburb are one economic unit. Where do you think all the service workers live? You have to be an extremely narrow minded inner city dweller to fail to see this.

> creating a system where Parisians can't own one, but have to bear their neighbor's who use them to get into the city.

I kindly invite you to check the average salary of Paris inhabitants vs the one in the suburbs then take a minute to think about what you just wrote.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:54PM (#43676777)
> Families are not second-tier citizens, and currently the public transports are not suited for them.

My family and the dozens I see every day in the Paris public transports beg to differ.

I suggest you might be a bit prejudiced (well more than a bit to be fair).

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:43PM (#43666930)
Shocker, both disabled people and families are easily identifiable and can be exempt from such measures.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @02:52PM (#43666988)
Well, they aren't exempt. Many French greens will tell you anyway that having children is bad for the planet and that you should abstain. And, as our population grows older, the accessibility problem will be larger and larger.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:41AM (#43679290)
The Greens have less than 7% of the places in the French Parliament.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Der_Einzige on Saturday April 12, 2025 @03:05PM (#43667080)
A lot of car drivers will respond with “good” and Darwinian arguments about their lack of fitness for the harshness of life.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by seszett on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:30PM (#43668094)
> an environment that is hostile for families

I don't understand this part, I read it quite often but... well, we are a family with young children, and although we do have a car we only use it once a week to go to the grand-parents that live 100 km away from here.

A city with less cars is great especially for families (though I would argue that cities themselves are not so great for children, but the comparison here is between cities that are car-centric or that are not). It makes going out easier and more spontaneous.

It's much less of a hassle to hop in the cargo bike and go wherever (including stopping en route if you see something interesting) than having to use the car, sit in traffic, hope you can find parking space at your destination, and pay for it.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by enaaem on Saturday April 12, 2025 @05:50PM (#43668189)
In the 60s, Dutch anti-car protestors had the slogan "Stop the child murder!". People were used to traditional cities where children could safely cycle around, but then cars came and started killing them.
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by Saline9515 on Saturday April 12, 2025 @08:56PM (#43669152)
I have very two kids, plan to have three. Cargo bikes are not practical, are easily stolen, and are not safe to transport children, especially under 6 years old. Besides, when doing groceries for 5 once a week, I regularly fill my 500L car boot, so an equivalent cargo bike with at least 3 seats and a large boot... would just be a car. Which you have, and use once a week.

Or when you need to go to the doctor. Or when your wife is sick. Or if you have an urgency. So, as a family, you still need a car.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by seszett on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:07AM (#43670464)
Well I just have the reverse experience. My cargo bike is practical, has not been stolen yet and up to four children under 6 are fine to transport in it. I don't feel it especially unsafe.

I also use it for groceries. Sometimes using both the cargo bike and a bike trailer (on two different bikes). We don't buy nearly at many things though it seems. When I do use my car (doing groceries while the children are with the grandparents) I have to transfer them from the car to the bike anyway because I can rarely park close to my home.

My doctor (and my wife's doctor) is certainly easier to reach by foot than by car. And I guess I never have the kind of urgency that would require me to use a car in the city. If there's something urgent a bike is always faster in this city.

Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by oblio on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:54PM (#43675383)
People only look at extremes for this. Using your car less is still a win. We don't need to go to "you shouldn't use your car at all".
Re:Paris said au revoir to cars. Air pollution maps reveal a... by dghlsakjg on Saturday April 12, 2025 @06:17PM (#43668341)
I can assure you that there are disabled people who really don’t like car oriented environments since so many disabilities preclude driving.