Two possible outcomes:
1. No one cares. No one pays for it. Nothing changes and nobody loses anything.
2. Enough people pay for it to keep the product healthy and the user-centric promise alive. The Internet is saved.
So why isn't anyone trying to replace Mozilla yet, with a more sane business model than living on the back of Google's fear of antitrust investigation? What's the worse that can happen?
Just sell a bonafide paid version alongside the free one, don't just rely on donations. There is a massive difference between offering a paid product and begging passers-by to spare some change.
There is a reason I get my email via fastmail: they differentiate themselves on privacy features. I also have my own domain, so if fastmail does turn evil they know I can easially move away. I can run my own email server, but having done that I know it is harder than I want. There are other services I'd pay for if I could find someone I could trust to take a small amount of money. (small is key - plenty would do this for thousands, but I don't have that much free cash)
Don't get me wrong, the above is not very large, but it is still something.
Yes, Trust is at the foundation of the whole problem with the Tech Industry:
/1/ users (consumers) expect to be protected (not injured, not cheated, not surveilled) by the products that they use, and
/2/ the WWW is a monstrosity, the only software that we can in fact trust is never connected to the Internet (in other words, we don't trust any software)
Ergo...
Given /2/, we cannot trust any software, full stop. Even paying $CORP for its products is no guarantee of care, safety, and security.
and
Given /1/, which software do we accept? For OS, I prefer Linux by far. Even where usability is a little rough, I can exclude components that I do not want. When obliged to use Windows, I hold my nose and try as much as possible to foil all the bloat, anti-user patterns, and telemetry. I resent it all the way!
I prefer Firefox because I like the features and I insist on a small set of extensions: uBlock Origin, Multi-Account Containers, Privacy Badger. Google is a nasty surveillance ecosystem and Microsoft is a Spaghetti Western: by turns good, bad, and ugly.
If it will fund further development and maintain the current commitment to respect for privacy, I am willing to allow Mozilla to do some aggregate analysis of my browsing habits, just as I am willing to provide survey answers for products that I buy.
I don't love the aggregate analysis, but Mozilla needs to do browser business in the modern world.
1. We won't show ads in our product -> We'll show skippable unobtrusive adds in our free product only -> We'll show bottom-of-the-barrel scum ads in our free product only -> Those skippable ads are now not skippable -> We'll add a few vetted ads to the paid product -> We're going to shove ads onto every surface of the product we can find!
2. We don't collect or sell data about you -> We will collect limited data for "telemetry." -> We'll also collect some demographic data "to improve the product." -> We're going to collect everything we can get our hands on, but we won't sell it. -> We share your data with only vetted, trusted "partners." -> We share your data with everyone we do business with -> We firehose your data to anyone willing to pay for it!
It's the same progression every time, but users keep thinking this time it will be different.
e.g. if you have a CEO/lead developer that's initially acting responsibly, but has a "bankruptcy threshold" beyond which they'll start selling your data, a revenue stream will stave that point off.
It's currently macOS and iPad/iPhone only, but a Linux version is being worked on. I don't know their plans for a Windows version.
Also, they claim "zero telemetry", so I don't really know what's going on, I know it's not leaving my computer.
I find that currently even if it's far from perfection, Orion is the lesser evil in the browser scenario.
Accounting for lifetime anything is hard (I don't know how to do the math, I'm sure people that do debate a lot of complex issues), but I'm again going to suggest that a lifetime subscription needs to be 20x the yearly fee to give a number to start the debate at.
Because writing manifestos is easy and making a browser is proper hard work ?
I'm wondering why don't they try to step it up further by selling a paid version alongside their open source product. What is the worst that can happen? Nobody pays for it and they continue making $0 just like they are happily doing now.
The hard part is the rendering engine and security. Both are done by the maintainer of the upstream source, i.e. Mozilla.
Something like this is regarded as the enshitification process, so what typically happens is they (e.g. VC) want to do such after they lured in their users. Which Firefox has (or arguably: had), but Waterfox and Librewolf have not.
Good thought experiment.
It ain't the first drama or controversy with regards to Mozilla, who have had a long tendency which didn't occur recently (and included the time Eich was there). Nostalgia just makes people forget the bad.
However, the default assumption is that all open source software is free to download and use.
Of course, there's the matter of revenue. If you get 100 dollars or 1000 dollars a month, is that significant to do anything useful for the project?
I'd donate to Firefox for no additional service if they would guarantee my money only goes to the browser and not crypto or AI initiatives.
Note donate. As in one time payments at a time of my choice. They also try to push towards subscriptions when you hit that donate button.
Rather, I wish we would stop accepting web standards that don’t come with reference implementations. Then, we could have a reference browser, and just run that. I don’t expect it to be performant, but I also don’t think browser performance matters much at all. Web pages are not HPC applications.
Currently we’re accepting the anti-competitive behavior of Google, just DDoSing the community with new standards to implement. This is the root problem. The fact that Mozilla is being killed by funding problems is downstream of the fact that maintaining a web browser requires multiple full time engineers.
Librewolf doesn't want to deal with the administrative overhead of donations - which if they'd only get a few donations makes sense. It likely costs several hundred a month just to hire the accountants and lawyers needed to get the paper work right (you can do it yourself at cost of time doing other things. Often you can find accountants and lawyers who will donate their services, but it is still several hundred dollars worth)
Especially in a crowded market, where we're arguing extensively about a browser that has 2.54% of the market share. Chrome (67%), Safari (18%), Edge (5.2%) [1]
[1] https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share
Most of those also have a browser mostly as add-ons, bundling, ecosystem value, or trademark / brand name trojans.
Admittedly, if you're looking to make a browser, there's a lot of various prior attempts that remain in existence, yet have never really received that much attention. [2]
[2] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/74/Timeline...
Personal preference is that somebody would implement a scripting language alternative other than Javascript. Anybody heard of TCL lately? It's supposed to be a browser scripting language alternative according to the w3.org specification [3] Really, almost anything other than Javascript as an alternative. Just for some variety.
Question is: how many people would jump ship, and then how much money would that represent to pay devs.
please do tip a fork. Right now this money seems to go to one person, but if that person starts making significant money we can probably talk them into hiring others to work on the project.
also, slightly related, people should look into / take inspiration tor browser. they're really great at releasing regular updates with high quality and features, surely they know how to handle this kind of projects
I'm personally not a fan of paypal so I look for alternatives, though I have no idea if this is a good one.
There's also Ladybird and several Webkit wrappers.
You can contribute code [3] or money [4] to accelerate this process.
[1] per 2/25 subscriber newsletter: “What’s coming in 2025? … We started working on Orion for Linux!”
[2] https://orionfeedback.org/d/2321-orion-for-windows-android-l...
[3] https://help.kagi.com/orion/support-and-community/contribute...
How exactly? The link doesn't say. Orion appears to be closed source.
Kagi has several repos open for contributions [1] but Orion isn’t fully open source yet [2]:
> Is Orion open-source? > > We're working on it! We've started with some of our components and intend to open more in the future. > > Forking WebKit, porting hundreds of APIs, and writing a browser app from scratch has been challenging for our small team. Properly maintaining an open-source project takes time and resources that we are currently short on. If you would like to contribute, please consider becoming active on orionfeedback.org.
It’s not obvious to me which of their public repos are Orion components.
You can contribute translations [3], bugs [4], and docs [5]. Orion is based on WebKit, so you can contribute upstream there [6]. Oodles of open issues on their bugzilla [7]
[1] https://github.com/kagisearch
[2] https://help.kagi.com/orion/faq/faq.html#oss
[3] https://help.kagi.com/orion/support-and-community/contribute...
[4] https://help.kagi.com/orion/support-and-community/troublesho...
[5] https://help.kagi.com/orion/support-and-community/contribute...
[6] https://webkit.org/contributing-code/
[7] https://bugs.webkit.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=NEW&product=W...
When this topic has been discussed on Hacker News in the past, it has also been pointed out that developing a browser with feature parity to Firefox or Chrome would be prohibitively expensive.
That makes it a bit easier to trust, but it does run into the issue that it stops working if Mozilla hits a certain level of untrustworthiness.
Yes, it may be that we are jumping from the frying pan into the fire. On the bright-side this opens up an opportunity for a company, or a suite of companies, to fund an alternative browser. Such an entity might have Signal at its lead, or similar, who's mission is solely to "tighten up" the software stack on which it runs.
Truly independent
No code from other browsers. We're building a new engine, based on web standards.
Singular focus
We are focused on one thing: the web browser.
No monetization
No "default search deals", crypto tokens, or other forms of user monetization, ever.
"I appreciate the constant existential wobble Firefox faces"
I would also love to face $7B existential wobbles.
With the same argument you could probably retire, after all you already earned (years you've been working) * (average salary).
It's not that silly, because that's a huge amount of money. What do you think the gross expense of building software like this should be? Because this may be the end of the line.
Big numbers without context are not useful outside of taking advantage of people who don't think critically.
A 2m lump sump at 20 would allow me to live a lifestyle of a 20k/year life, not good enough.
Had I lived that over the last 20 years and saved the rest of the 100k in an 8% return fund then I'd have 4m today and could drawdown a 40k/year life at 1%.
Had I been given a lump sum of 100 times my desired salary though, or 10m, then sure, no need to work.
I stand corrected, I would want to face the $400M+ per year existential wobble.
Put another way, does the Linux kernel or the Python language need to be run by a company, or will foundations does these jobs ok?
There are plenty of open source projects that are enormously successful without a single lawyer or project manager in sight.
We repeatedly see attacks on freedom and privacy by the people who are supposed to protect them, those so-called "regulators": chatcontrol, recent UK backdoor wishes, repeated French proposals to enforce DRM even on opensource. And I wouldn't even google Russia, China, or other less democratic states.
Regulated is probably worse than some anarchistic who-knows-by-whom software, but FOSS and auditable these days, tbh. Especially as everyone's audit capabilities grow day by day with AI. It's kind of good at grinding tons of code.
A heavily regulated entity with all licenses in the world might be more hostile toward users than some niche project.
I feel you. Regulatory bodies have definitely fallen short in many cases, and we've seen concerning proposals from governments that threaten digital privacy and freedom. "Who watches the watchmen" seems incredibly apt nowadays.
However, I feel there's a fundamental difference between imperfect accountability and no accountability at all. With a legal entity governed by stated policies, users have:
1. Transparency about who makes decisions and how
2. Clear terms that create binding commitments
3. Legal mechanisms for recourse if those commitments are violated
4. A persistent entity that can't simply disappear overnight
Perfect? Not really. The ICO in the UK, for example, hasn't been amazing at enforcing data protection. But the existence of these frameworks means that accountability is at least possible - there are levers that can be pulled if someone can be bothered to.
In contrast, with software maintained by anonymous or loosely affiliated individuals, there's no structural accountability whatsoever. If privacy promises are broken, users have no recourse beyond abandoning the software.
FOSS and auditability are valuable safeguards, sure, but they primarily protect against unintentional privacy violations that might be discovered in code reviews. They don't address the human element of intentional policy changes or decisions about data collection.
Many regulatory bodies seem to constantly fall short of what they are supposed to do and then demand more money and powers to continue to fail at what they are supposed to do.
At what point would you accept that they maybe not fit for purpose and other solutions should be considered?
It maybe better to put resources into educating people on how to protect themselves from privacy breaches or minimise the impact.
The only thing I've ever seen from the ICO is a letter saying that if I have customer data I have to pay them a fee or pay a fine. Then I have to go through the inconvenience of telling them I don't have any, so I don't have to pay this fee.
It happens quite often after a big failure. I've worked in government myself as a contractor and seen huge amounts of waste while completely failing what they were supposed to be doing. I left after a few months (I was asked to stay) because I was utterly disgusted by it.
> That's private companies and law enforcement, respectively.
Law Enforcement most certainly, but private companies that just isn't true.
Maybe if you are at some large corporation, however generally waste at large corporations I've seen is due to having to cancel projects because of situations changes e.g. I was working on a large project to that was to integrate the platform with Russia, that got cancelled for geopolitical reasons.
Most private companies aren't large corporations though and most work is done by a few super stars in the company.
2. When (not in your lifetime obviously) Waterfox is broken, what canaries do you have deployed that we can archive now, like Mozilla's tell here?
3. What keeps waterfox afloat? Where/how do you accept funds?
4. How do I find a sync alternative or provide my own? Such that, I'm not reliant on Mozilla sync/backend? ... If none exists, how much would it cost for you to embed one? Would you accept a serious bounty for it assuming the focus is self hosted / no Waterfox backend services?
This is so melodramatic. It’s a set of patch files applied to the Firefox source tree. If an evil maintainer hatches a maniacal plan to collect user statistics and deletes the patch that removes telemetry or whatever, you can just `git revert`.
do they still make ot worthwhile for developers? are any on the payroll still?
i think the community should mobilize to sign up for adopting A single fork* as the official fork and completely drop mozilla from existence.
* only criteria should be the fork that is most convenient for all the other forks to just point to instead of mozilla and continue to ship with their patches. and that one fork should have the minimum resources to respond to security disclosures in place of mozilla, nothing else as a requirement.
Considering what has happened to Firefox, that's not encouraging.
the second part, it looks like you ignored my whole comment.
there should be no more mozilla. if they exist by means of opensource contributors. i question if they have their own developers on payroll still? which might be slightly harder to replace.
The wobble seems to somewhat artificial. I'm having trouble believing Firefox could ever not be able to afford to continue browser development — there are way too many interests at stake. Google alone would have no choice but to bail Firefox out because Chrome can't be the only browser without being regulated to hell and back.
For it to be self-imposed there needs to be an comparable amount of money ready to spring forth if Google ever pulled out that Mozilla is somehow keeping a lid on.
The context to keep in mind here is that Mozilla purchased an ad company back in June. They spent money on it, and they will move to earn a return on investment.
Absent that context this could just be another tone deaf policy choice that gets rolled back when there's enough heat, but with that context in mind it's far more likely to be them laying the legal foundation to incorporate Anonym's targeted advertising into Firefox.
From the Register article about the acquisition:
> Arielle Garcia, director of intelligence for ad watchdog Check My Ads, told The Register in an email that she's generally skeptical of claims about privacy-preserving ad technology.
> "For example, how do Anonym’s audience capabilities, like their lookalike modeling, jibe with what Mozilla considers to be 'exploitative models of data extraction?' The data that is 'securely shared' by platforms and advertisers to enable ad targeting and measurement have to come from somewhere – and there’s more to privacy than not leaking user IDs."
https://www.theregister.com/2024/06/18/mozilla_buys_anonym_b...
Individuals that care about these things have a far better track record than any business with employees, bills to pay, and investors.
That just shows that trust in Mozilla has sunk below "random stranger" levels. IMO that shift is entirely deserved.
When Mitchell Baker took the reins, Mozilla became rather more heavy-handed towards us - the irony being that Waterfox was once proudly displayed on the Mozilla website under their "Powered By" banner.
I appreciate the constant existential wobble Firefox faces, but they've made some peculiar decisions as of late.
On one hand, they're finally implementing features users have been clamouring for ages (tab groups, vertical tabs and the likes) - on the other, rather odd policy choices.
I should point out, it seems daft to me when others suggest using forks with no well-established governance of their own, essentially shifting trust from an organisation at least answerable to certain regulations, to individuals with no proper framework or guidelines.
I've done my best with Waterfox over the years to have it represented by a proper legal entity with policies to follow; so if anyone is interested take a look.
Edit: FWIW I've written some more thoughts on it here: https://www.waterfox.net/blog/a-comment-on-mozilla-changes/