News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Friday February 28, 2025 @07:30AM (#43204885)
The problem with paid versions, is that I don't really trust them either. MBA creep will happen and suddenly the TOS changes and my paid tier is going to have data collection and 'some' ads. I have to move to a high tier to avoid them. After a few cycles of that, one day all the tiers have data collection and ads.
Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by ibejoeb on Friday February 28, 2025 @08:50AM (#43205537)
Nothing is forever, but if you get a contract that prohibits their data play (collection, derivation, sale, all of it...) for a year or whatever, you're good for that long. That'd be enough for me.
Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by bluGill on Friday February 28, 2025 @09:02AM (#43205654)
Paid version have that problem somewhat less because they have a source of income that could dry up if they do. Paying someone means they are beholden to you as well, while free gives you nothing.

There is a reason I get my email via fastmail: they differentiate themselves on privacy features. I also have my own domain, so if fastmail does turn evil they know I can easially move away. I can run my own email server, but having done that I know it is harder than I want. There are other services I'd pay for if I could find someone I could trust to take a small amount of money. (small is key - plenty would do this for thousands, but I don't have that much free cash)

Don't get me wrong, the above is not very large, but it is still something.

Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by tremon on Friday February 28, 2025 @09:06AM (#43205724)
Yes, this. When Mozilla (or any other corporation) demonstrates positive cashflow, the odds of MBAs and other vulture capitalists descending on it increase massively. And I have never seen customer agreements like this survive a buy-out: the new owners are never constrained by the promises (or even contracts) of the previous company.
Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by heresie-dabord on Friday February 28, 2025 @09:27AM (#43205955)
> The problem with paid versions, is that I don't really trust them either.

Yes, Trust is at the foundation of the whole problem with the Tech Industry:

/1/ users (consumers) expect to be protected (not injured, not cheated, not surveilled) by the products that they use, and

/2/ the WWW is a monstrosity, the only software that we can in fact trust is never connected to the Internet (in other words, we don't trust any software)

Ergo...

Given /2/, we cannot trust any software, full stop. Even paying $CORP for its products is no guarantee of care, safety, and security.

and

Given /1/, which software do we accept? For OS, I prefer Linux by far. Even where usability is a little rough, I can exclude components that I do not want. When obliged to use Windows, I hold my nose and try as much as possible to foil all the bloat, anti-user patterns, and telemetry. I resent it all the way!

I prefer Firefox because I like the features and I insist on a small set of extensions: uBlock Origin, Multi-Account Containers, Privacy Badger. Google is a nasty surveillance ecosystem and Microsoft is a Spaghetti Western: by turns good, bad, and ugly.

If it will fund further development and maintain the current commitment to respect for privacy, I am willing to allow Mozilla to do some aggregate analysis of my browsing habits, just as I am willing to provide survey answers for products that I buy.

I don't love the aggregate analysis, but Mozilla needs to do browser business in the modern world.

Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by ryandrake on Friday February 28, 2025 @11:58AM (#43207784)
The tech industry is just one rug-pull after another, but still people line up to try standing on the rugs!

1. We won't show ads in our product -> We'll show skippable unobtrusive adds in our free product only -> We'll show bottom-of-the-barrel scum ads in our free product only -> Those skippable ads are now not skippable -> We'll add a few vetted ads to the paid product -> We're going to shove ads onto every surface of the product we can find!

2. We don't collect or sell data about you -> We will collect limited data for "telemetry." -> We'll also collect some demographic data "to improve the product." -> We're going to collect everything we can get our hands on, but we won't sell it. -> We share your data with only vetted, trusted "partners." -> We share your data with everyone we do business with -> We firehose your data to anyone willing to pay for it!

It's the same progression every time, but users keep thinking this time it will be different.

Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by throw10920 on Friday February 28, 2025 @09:41AM (#43206130)
You have to trust and/or monitor and apply active pressure to (something that virtually nobody does) the developers to some extent either way. The difference with a paid distribution is that there's at least some revenue that helps keep the project afloat, and with a free distribution there's not.

e.g. if you have a CEO/lead developer that's initially acting responsibly, but has a "bankruptcy threshold" beyond which they'll start selling your data, a revenue stream will stave that point off.

Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by winwang on Friday February 28, 2025 @06:50PM (#43213505)
Semi-crazy idea: Add clauses which destroy half the company if they change the deal without a year of advance notice.
Re:Mozilla deletes promise to never sell Firefox data by vetrom on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:55PM (#43244623)
A modern equivalent to the 'usenet death penalty' is what's really needed. Without a grassroots method to censure and more or less permanently injunct and/or eject bad actors, you can't stop them from harvesting profit from the ecosystem to the exclusion of all other concerns.