News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gkoberger on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:27AM (#42642195)
This case is such an interesting crossroads. He has such insane support — I went to two improv shows this past week where he was the crowd choice for a topic and the shows received insane applause. But what he did was objectively what we consider to be bad… in our society, vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is considered to be wrong.

I don’t know what SO should have done (well, probably not ban someone for asking questions, assuming we have the full story). But it’s so fascinating to see how companies have no playbook to work off of.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Timothee on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:40AM (#42642267)
“especially against nonviolent offenders”

Following the murder, I was thinking about how much non physical violence there is, that isn’t usually seen and judged as violence. Things like denying healthcare, shutting down companies and laying off people to benefit private equity investors, forcing people into bankruptcy, losing their homes, charging overdraft fees, etc.

The people behind that kind of violence can hide behind the layers of indirection.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by wahnfrieden on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:24AM (#42642618)
“Social murder” is the term
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:51AM (#42642327)
Any healthcare system must deny healthcare. No healthcare system existing anywhere on this planet provides infinite healthcare to everyone. Denying healthcare is not violence.

In any economic system, units of economic organizations must sometimes dissolve, and people must be laid off. This is unavoidable. Laying people off is not violence.

In any society, debts are expected to be paid off. If people could just stop paying their debts, nobody would make any loans anymore. Forcing people into bankruptcy is not violence.

Frankly, your comment strikes me as exceedingly naive. "I only want ever nice things to happen, and bad things happening to people are violence". I suggest thinking about why these things happen, what would be alternative, and so we put up with these.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by jbaiter on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:14AM (#42642537)
> Any healthcare system must deny healthcare. No healthcare system existing anywhere on this planet provides infinite healthcare to everyone. Denying healthcare is not violence.

Nobody argues against that, but United Healthcare had a denial rate of more than 30%, which is the highest among the major health insurance companies in the US. Coupled with the fact that they make profits off of those denials, it's hard not to call this non physical violence with the aim to generate more capital for share holders and executives.

> In any economic system, units of economic organizations must sometimes dissolve, and people must be laid off. This is unavoidable. Laying people off is not violence.

Again, absolutely agree. But it can be argued that doing so without any regard for individuals, their history with the economic unit and personal circumstances, is non-physical violence. Look at e.g. European employment laws for how this can be mitigated (not without some drawbacks ofc).

> In any society, debts are expected to be paid off. If people could just stop paying their debts, nobody would make any loans anymore. Forcing people into bankruptcy is not violence.

In every just society, the debtor has a responsibility as well to not lend money to people who cannot afford it. Giving somebody a loan they cannot afford and then bankrupting them is definitely non-physical violence.

> I suggest thinking about why these things happen, what would be alternative, and so we put up with these.

You put up with these because the US is a violent society with little regards for individual lives. Great for entrepreneurs and people with access to capital, not so great for much of the rest.

The alternatives have of course their own share of problems, but don't act as if the system is the only reasonable one.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:25AM (#42642628)
> Nobody argues against that, but United Healthcare had a denial rate of more than 30%, which is the highest among the major health insurance companies in the US.

As it happens, there will always exist a health insurance company with highest denial rate among all companies. That's a simple mathematical fact: a finite set of numbers has a maximum number. You need to do more legwork to show any actual wrongdoing on anyone's part here.

> In every just society, the debtor has a responsibility as well to not lend money to people who cannot afford it. Giving somebody a loan they cannot afford and then bankrupting them is definitely non-physical violence.

This is absurd. When your debtors go bankrupt, you lose money. Nobody wants to lend money to people who cannot afford it.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Freedom2 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:56AM (#42643264)
> As it happens, there will always exist a health insurance company with highest denial rate among all companies. That's a simple mathematical fact: a finite set of numbers has a maximum number. You need to do more legwork to show any actual wrongdoing on anyone's part here.

This isn't correct. Mathematically (as you say), you can have all health companies have a denial rate of 0%.

Realistically it's impossible, but you did say mathematically.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by brokenmachine on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:04PM (#42652034)
This is pedantry at it's finest, but at the risk of adding more... Wouldn't the mathematical maximum be 0 in that case?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Freedom2 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:09PM (#42652061)
Correct! I was more-so addressing the following statement, not necessarily the mathematical maximum one:

> As it happens, there will always exist a health insurance company with highest denial rate among all companies

If OP was going to start leaning onto "mathematical fact[s]" to support their argument, they should probably be accurate as well. Specifically there will be "multiple" health insurance companies with the highest denial rate (0), not "a" company.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mandmandam on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:11AM (#42643726)
> This is absurd. When your debtors go bankrupt, you lose money. Nobody wants to lend money to people who cannot afford it.

Weren't you just calling someone's comment "exceedingly naive"?

The poor and financially vulnerable (ie, most Americans) are at a systemic disadvantage when dealing with debt, bankruptcy laws, and the justice system. They are preyed upon by all sorts of people offering debt, at a higher rate than ever before, anywhere.

Not to mention government bailouts, which really changed the game with regard to balancing risk.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by marcus0x62 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:04AM (#42644423)
> This is absurd. When your debtors go bankrupt, you lose money. Nobody wants to lend money to people who cannot afford it.

That depends, amongst other things, on how much interest you charge in the interim. Payday lenders makes lots of money off of people who a) cannot afford their loans by any reasonable metric and b) default on those loans.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:19PM (#42647740)
No. Whether you charge large or small interest, you never want your debtor to go bankrupt, because it means cessation of the interest payments.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by marcus0x62 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:56PM (#42648125)
If you think payday lenders care one iota about debtors going bankrupt after collecting multiples of the original loan amount in interest, I cannot help you.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:01PM (#42648785)
Of course they care, they’d rather the debtor never go bankrupt, so that they can keep collecting. Do you understand how loans work?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by marcus0x62 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:11PM (#42649405)
I get that you have an ideological position to defend and, based on your other comments in this thread have either an inability or an unwillingness to cede any ground. So while, yes, I do understand how loans work, I do not have any further interest in talking to you about payday lenders. Have a nice day.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by the_gipsy on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:02AM (#42642410)
Ah, so it's the system that's bad. Can't do anything about it, only shrug and follow orders. Somebody else would have switched the gas chamber on anyway.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:17AM (#42642569)
Ah, so by saying that denying insurance claims is not violence, because all insurance systems must deny some claims, I'm basically Hitler.

I encourage you to think more carefully about the reality. Consider, for example, a public health insurance system like Germany. Do you think that Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung never denies claims? That it never denies care? Is it also violence when it does so?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by the_gipsy on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:08AM (#42643335)
> Ah, so by saying that denying insurance claims is not violence, because all insurance systems must deny some claims, I'm basically Hitler.

You're probably purposefully derailing the conversation, but for the sake of others let me bite: pointing out the resemblance of following orders of a killing system and excusing the individuals working in this system as "order followers", has nothing to do with calling anybody "literally Hitler".

> Do you think that Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung never denies claims? That it never denies care? Is it also violence when it does so?

IIUC, those are also private companies or at least to a degree. So probably similar to american healthcare, just more regulated.

Let's take a look at a 100% pure public healthcare instead, for example La Seguridad Social in Spain.

It denies some claims, care, and can cause some suffering and death. The institution is administered directly by some leadership individuals, and to some degree even by the elected government. Those individuals are not driven directly by the "financial obligation to make the maximum profit" out of healthcare. However they indirectly are, there are decisions to be made on spending, and budget is not magically infinite. These decisions are hard: you can't make everyone happy and healthy, whatever the result, some people suffer and die. See the trolley problem.

So if a public healthcare system works badly, and causes too much pain and suffering, then some of these individuals can also be held responsible. It's just that in practice, in general any public system works more towards the benefit of society than for some shareholders.

To be blunt: if the government individuals take decisions that degrade the public healthcare system, for their own benefit, whatever that is, then those individuals should maybe be shot in public too. This kind of violence, terrorism, works historically well, especially if it isn't targeted at random civilians. Democracy is not simply the rule of the majority.

It's not a matter of awareness, the public knows how perverse the incentives of private health insurance are, and how a public system can do much better. But the private system will never be replaced in the current american political landscape - without violence.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:49PM (#42649684)
OK, I’m glad that we agree that any healthcare system will deny care to some people. That’s my point: this is necessarily the case, so it cannot be automatically “violence” when that happens. It is extremely naive to believe that whenever that happens, the cause must be necessarily nefarious.

> It's just that in practice, in general any public system works more towards the benefit of society than for some shareholders.

I think that this is simply empirically false. You cannot just assert something like this, you need to provide evidence for it.

> To be blunt: if the government individuals take decisions that degrade the public healthcare system, for their own benefit, whatever that is, then those individuals should maybe be shot in public too.

And here is the critical question: is there any evidence whatsoever that Bryan Thompson made any decision like that? As far as I can tell, there is absolutely zero. Many just decided he must be guilty of something, but nobody actually points to anything in particular.

> It's not a matter of awareness, the public knows how perverse the incentives of private health insurance are, and how a public system can do much better.

Again, you are asserting something that’s far from being universally agreed on. Public healthcare systems have their troubles too, and if you ask anyone with experience with both, you will not find people universally preferring their public experience. Ask Canadians or Brits how long it takes to get a visit at a specialist, for example.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by the_gipsy on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:16AM (#42654970)
You originally claimed that:

> Denying healthcare is not violence.

Now you say:

> That’s my point: this is necessarily the case, so it cannot be automatically “violence” when that happens.

You're going in circles around an argument that you made up yourself. Do you want a pat on the back?

> I think that this is simply empirically false. You cannot just assert something like this, you need to provide evidence for it.

Now read that out back again loud.

> Again, you are asserting something that’s far from being universally agreed on.

I said: "It's not a matter of awareness, the public knows". That cannot be read as "universally agreed on" in good faith.

> Public healthcare systems have their troubles too, and if you ask anyone with experience with both, you will not find people universally preferring their public experience.

I never claimed public healthcare is perfect, on the contrary.

You will find rich people preferring private healthcare, which are a vocal minority.

> Ask Canadians or Brits how long it takes to get a visit at a specialist, for example.

I don't have to ask nobody because I live in a country with fully public healthcare. I am glad that poor people have the same access as rich people, and that triage by urgency, not money, works well (again not claiming that it's perfect, since you give everything your own meaning).

The USA on the other hand are infamous for the healthcare bankruptcy and literal horror stories. I think you don't realize how non-existant your safety net is. It only works well for you when you don't have a major health problem, and while you have a relatively very good paying job.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by kaoD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:06AM (#42642926)
> so by saying that denying insurance claims is not violence, because all insurance systems must deny some claims, I'm basically Hitler

No. They're saying you're the person justifying the guy who opened the gas valve.

Or perhaps that you're justifying Hitler because he didn't open the gas valve so he himself didn't commit any physical violence.

(Not saying that's right or wrong, just that you're strawmanning hard on this one.)

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:54AM (#42642836)
> Ah, so by saying that denying insurance claims is not violence, because all insurance systems must deny some claims

> Consider, for example, a public health insurance system like Germany. Do you think that Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung never denies claims? That it never denies care? Is it also violence when it does so?

Denying claims can be violence, it can also not be violence. There are other factors which you keep ignoring. Stop doing that.

> I'm basically Hitler.

If you say so. No one else is.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:01AM (#42642893)
There are other factors which you keep ignoring.

I am ignoring that? This thread is literally full of people who take any insurance denial as automatically wrong. It is me who's asking people to think carefully about this!

If you say so. No one else is.

Did you miss the "gas chambers" part in the comment I replied to?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by the_gipsy on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:05AM (#42642913)
> This thread is literally full of people who take any insurance denial as automatically wrong.

Then go and reply to those people (if they are really in the room with us). In _this_ subthread nobody has said or implied that ANY insurance denials is automatically wrong.

"Literally hitler" wasn't directed at you personally, obviously, but you couldn't help but pick it up that way.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:04AM (#42642909)
> I am ignoring that?

Yes.

> It is me who's asking people to think carefully about this!

You should take your own advice, and actually think carefully about this.

> Did you miss the "gas chambers" part in the comment I replied to?

Hitler never switched on a gas chamber.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:40AM (#42643502)
> Did you miss the "gas chambers" part in the comment I replied to?

The analogy was clearly with those denying healthcare. Have you personally denied people healthcare?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by BriggyDwiggs42 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:56AM (#42642856)
It’s impossible for all instances of these things to constitute violence. I do, however, find the idea that they are sometimes akin to violence very enticing. Can you argue that? Can the actions of a stereotypical slumlord, one behaving within local law and never physically touching one of his tenants, potentially constitute violence? If not, how are you defining it?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by jl6 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:29AM (#42643095)
What are stereotypical slumlords and what have they done?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by BriggyDwiggs42 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:48PM (#42648642)
Just a wikipedia definition of slumlord https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slumlord#Operation
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by jl6 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:08PM (#42649809)
Running a shitty business, even an exploitative one, isn’t violence.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:39PM (#42650044)
> Running a shitty business, even an exploitative one, isn’t violence.

You know, it just hit me: the issue here might just be a semantic one, where people feel the need to lump very unacceptable and wrong actions into the category of "violence," because of the consensus belief that violence is almost always wrong.

There are things that are as unacceptable and wrong as violence but are not violence.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:29AM (#42655048)
I really don’t think it’s that simple. The violence we’re talking about might be most easily defined as a particularly extreme form of coercion, one which causes deep trauma and/or physical harm. Doesn’t this capture the nature of a lot of violence? Isn’t it also evident that this wouldn’t always require physical contact by the aggressor, or even a single, tangible aggressor at all? I’d argue, for example, that whether or not hitler personally pulled the trigger on holocaust victims, he absolutely did violence against them. The level of indirection doesn’t preclude this.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @03:54AM (#42664425)
People lump the inappropriate denial of necessary resources into "violence", as well as actions which happen because of the threat of physical harm.

For example, if a slumlord wants to evict me, even though I'm still paying the rent, the eviction is violence. It can either go two ways: either armed thugs will come to the building and physically grab me, rough me up and throw me on the street (at best) or in jail (at worst). Or I'll anticipate that happening, and lock myself out of the building in advance. In the latter case, is it still violence? Many people say yes, a shortcut around violence, coerced by the certainty that violence will happen otherwise, is still violence.

Or consider an abusive relationship: she knows he will beat her if she doesn't obey, so she obeys. No beating actually happens. A lot of people consider this violence too.

And consider a siege on a city (there's at least one happening right now). The people try to grow their own food in city parks, but whenever they do they, the parks are hit with big bombs dropped from planes. So they call on their allies to deliver food in. The first food trucks are also bombed. The second food trucks don't go in, they try to negotiate safe passage first. Is it violence against the people in the city (who have never been hit by a bomb)? Many people say yes.

In the narrow definition, violence is only when my fist hits your face, but in the broader definition, violence is whenever I use the laws of physics to force something to happen to you - whenever I take away your agency.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by BriggyDwiggs42 on Saturday January 11, 2025 @05:13PM (#42669352)
Nice job. You articulated it more clearly.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:17AM (#42654977)
We can define violence as “that guy hit that guy,” and leave it at that and you’d be right. I think this alternative view is a recognition that a lot of other behaviors look very similar in how they work, like when the slumlord chains the emergency fire exit and a family burns alive because of it (an extreme example, but I do recall reading about a case along those lines). I feel like calling that sort of thing violence perpetrated by the slumlord is accurate to everyone but the pedant. It captures the essence of the behavior to me, this bringing about of great personal harm through either malice or sociopathic apathy.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by midnightblue on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:53AM (#42642833)
This is an insane comment what you wrote.

I live in a European country with public free healthcare. Sure, you pay a portion of your income towards healthcare, so it's not really free etc. etc. If you don't have income, the state pays it for you.

There isn't any denial of healthcare. I never heard about anything like that. Sure, there are limits on availability of healthcare, particularly if it's some advanced or expensive procedure. For example, there is a place where they do radio surgery on the brain. There may only be one such place in the country (it's a small country). If you need that kind of procedure done, obviously there is a waiting list. And certainly some of those on a waiting list must have died.

But there is no denial of healthcare per se with someone making a decision to deny healthcare.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:57AM (#42642861)
I'm confused, you said that there isn't any denial of healthcare where you are, but then described very clearly and explicitly how some people are denied healthcare, and they sometimes die as a result. Maybe you understand the word "deny" differently?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gorororog on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:45AM (#42643195)
I think you understand the word "deny" differently.

Accepted but didn't happen in time doesn't equal denial.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:49AM (#42643566)
Of course it does. The patients wanted care early enough to save their live. They denied them that care. Hypothetical care after death is worthless.

Whether they denied that care by not paying for it (which means people could have gotten that care if they would have had the means), or by limiting the amount of care in a period of time, doesn't really matters for the person who didn't get it.

Why do you think the healthcare resources (number of beds, hospitals etc) are limited? Why isn't there a second hospital?

By the way, would they have paid for an operation in a different country if space would be available there? No? So they denied that healthcare.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gorororog on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:04AM (#42644060)
Except it just doesn't, denial of claim has a very specific meaning, there's no reason to go all philosophical.

I'm sure there's plenty of cases where United health approved the claim and the patient also didn't get treated in time, it doesn't count as a denied claim.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:46AM (#42647414)
This sub-thread is about denying healthcare. Not about denying claims. In fact, denying a claim (i.e. payment for healthcare services) has the moral implications discussed here mainly if not only because denial of payment is tantamount to denial of healthcare.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by em-bee on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:32AM (#42643857)
the big point you are missing is the denial of paying for treatment after it has been applied.

in germany (and probably most other european countries) you can be denied treatment if it is deemed unimportant and it is known that insurance does not cover it. you will never be put in a situation where treatment is applied but then the insurance doesn't pay leaving you with the bill unless you were made aware that the treatment is optional or you specifically chose a treatment that you could not be sure would be paid. payment for any treatment that is not optional can not be denied. if there is uncertainty you can also ask your insurer in advance, and they must give you a binding response whether the proposed treatment will be paid or not.

most importantly the doctors must inform the patient in advance if the treatment is insured or not. if they don't tell them that something is not insured then they can't demand payment from the patient.

you will never face a surprise bill.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by torified on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:23PM (#42652123)
Because you mentioned Germany and surprise bills...

My partner suffered a medical episode while we were traveling in Germany. Bystanders called an ambulance which turned up and checked her out and asked her to be taken to hospital for more tests.

She/we elected to not go with them.

To our surprise, about 6 months later after we returned home (to Australia), we received a letter in the mail (in German) that said we owed something like $500 for the ambulance, I forget the exact number.

How does that line up with "you will never face a surprise bill" in Germany? Or is it because we are foreigners?

We never paid but I sometimes wonder if something would happen should we return to Germany.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by em-bee on Friday January 10, 2025 @05:08AM (#42654316)
it's most likely because you didn't have insurance at all. if you had travel insurance you should have forwarded that to them. (but see below about calling an ambulance that is not needed)

if you don't have insurance you have to pay for everything of course. the surprise in your case comes from the unusual situation that the people who called the ambulance didn't know that you had no insurance, or more likely and you weren't even aware of how your situation is going to be handled.

it's unlikely that anything will happen if you return since the ones issuing the bill would not be notified in any way that you entered the country.

it is also possible that you could have disputed the payment since you didn't call the ambulance yourself (and i assume didn't ask anyone to call them). on the other hand if you had insurance you should have gone to the hospital because apparently insurance doesn't pay if an ambulance is called but not used. so actually, you didn't receive a surprise medical bill, but a bill for calling a service that was not needed (and potentially inconveniencing someone else who might have needed the ambulance, but now had to wait).

however, if you didn't ask anyone to call the ambulance then the bill is inappropriate because the law here is that if you call an ambulance but you don't need it, you pay, but if someone else calls the ambulance without you asking them, and it turns out to be unnecessary, then nobody pays.

since i lived in china i also don't have insurance in europe, so when we were visiting and needed treatment for a burn we had to shop around different hospitals to find out which one charged the least. costs for an ER visit ranged from 80€ to 250€ if i remember, and later we found a special hospital that was funded by a charity for the uninsured were we could go for after care for free. that works because the number of people without insurance is extremely small. mostly foreigners who somehow fell through the gap.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by torified on Sunday January 12, 2025 @06:31PM (#42678195)
Interesting.

We didn't ask for anyone to call the ambulance, although personally I am happy that it was called and she was checked out.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by em-bee on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @12:41AM (#42694071)
indeed. while i was reading up on this i kept wondering if there is no way to call a doctor without calling an ambulance. i know there are private doctors that you can call (i recently saw a report about a doctor who said that he gets called specifically because his patients do not want to be taken to a hospital (and don't need to)), but when you call emergency services then an ambulance seems to be the only option.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by torified on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @05:06PM (#42704572)
Here in Australia we have a line you can call, I think it was started during covid.

No idea how useful it'd be for non-covid calls though. Probably not very.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Kiro on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:25AM (#42643813)
I live in a Nordic country and the state-owned insurance provider often denies healthcare, much like health insurance companies in the US.

Denying healthcare doesn't necessarily mean "leaving someone bleeding to death on the street" but rather refusing to provide certain treatments or medications. This issue isn't unique to the US. Granted, the healthcare system in the US is, in my opinion, significantly worse but claiming that healthcare denial doesn't happen elsewhere is simply incorrect.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by brokenmachine on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:08PM (#42652053)
In the US they deny treatment that is considered essential by their own doctors. I know you were saying the same thing, but your comment seems to minimize the difference.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:08AM (#42642488)
> Any healthcare system must deny healthcare. No healthcare system existing anywhere on this planet provides infinite healthcare to everyone. Denying healthcare is not violence.

It is when the care is necessary; when the denial is part of a strategy to goose profits.

There are similar issues with the other statements you made.

> Frankly, your comment strikes me as exceedingly naive.

Frankly, your comment strikes me as willfully blind.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:27AM (#42642647)
> It is when the care is necessary

So when the insurance denies coverage, and so the doctors don't work for free on the case, and the patient dies, are the doctors perpetrating violence too?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:47AM (#42642798)
In your contrarian urge to defend some of the worst of the status quo, you forget the insurance company's whole role is to pay for medical care.

I suggest you read up on this. IIRC, it was UHG's practice to deny claims indiscriminately to increase the personal burden of accessing medical care. Because, you know, if people pay their premiums to the company but it doesn't pay out, it makes lots more money for the shareholders.

It's weird how you seem to consistently elide motivations even when extremely relevant.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by comp_throw7 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:16AM (#42642994)
An insurance company's "role" is to distribute risk, not to "pay for medical care" without question. The perversion of what constitutes "insurance" in the US medical industry is the fault of our legal system and tax code, and the insane cost of medical care (which is ultimately the root cause of most of these problems) is down to the medical cartel (also legally enforced).
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by kaibee on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:12AM (#42643346)
> The perversion of what constitutes "insurance" in the US medical industry is the fault of our legal system and tax code

The ACA's public option was killed by a Senator who had a lot Health Insurance industry backing and support.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:42AM (#42643520)
> are the doctors perpetrating violence too?

No, the politicians who insist on keeping this medieval practice in place are.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ars on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:01AM (#42643293)
> It is when the care is necessary; when the denial is part of a strategy to goose profits.

Denying claims does NOT increases profits, in the US it actually decreases them. Read more here if you like: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42642405

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mondrian on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:50AM (#42642818)
There are systems that cannot deny life saving care, and where everyone is necessarily insured.

It’s facetious to compare those to a system where 30 million have zero coverage and the rest are systematically denied life saving care as a profit making mechanism.

And yeah letting someone die when you could help them live is violence. When it’s baked into the rules it’s called systemic violence.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:18AM (#42643013)
There are no systems anywhere in the world which don’t deny life saving care. All systems make life and death decisions. British NHS, for example, will generally deny life saving care, if such procedure will cost more than 30,000 pounds per quality-adjusted year of life you’re expected to gain as a result of the procedure.

Again, my point is that denying healthcare is not automatically something wrong or evil. This is something that must necessarily happen, and so the details as to why some healthcare was denied are very important. You can’t just say that someone being denied care is basically murder, like some people here, or point to some percentage of denied claims and pretend that this is prima facie evidence of wrongdoing. No, you need to actually do some legwork, and the haters of murder victim are not interested in that, they just want some release by dunking on a literal scapegoat.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mondrian on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:53PM (#42651998)
I mean it seems you’re dunking on a strawman yourself. Like if I said Denmark virtually denies no life saving claims, and when it happens it’s due to edge cases, you’ll insist just because it occurs it’s indistinguishable from a system where it happens systemically and regularly?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:53AM (#42643596)
Name one.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by h_tbob on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:43AM (#42642774)
I believe that healthcare is deliberately limited by insane policy. Contrary to opinion insurance is not the problem. It’s doctors charging exorbitant fees.

We allow this because we let them scare us into voting for strict education.

But the reality is education could be fixed to cut the price by probably 80% - making the much smaller insurance amount negligible.

I hate to say it but pinning it on a ceo doesn’t seem right. His job was to ration a scarce resource. But why is it scare? Because the authorities thru the police force puts an end to unlicensed people regardless of their skills.

I was talking to a friend/acquaintance. Her dad was a doctor did all kinds of innovative surgeries on animals. But wasn’t licensed. She said he’d be called in by doctors to do surgeries all the time because he was the best.

But he wasn’t licensed. So California shut it all down.

The price of healthcare is 5x because we let people go to jail without a crime. If they went to jail for reckless I e untrained practice of medicine i understand. But seriously right now the problem is lack of supply that has to be rationed.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:50AM (#42642815)
Thank you for your comment, I thought that there's nobody left here who understands this.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:19PM (#42650426)
> Thank you for your comment, I thought that there's nobody left here who understands this.

Dude, plenty of people understand that. However, it's no good playing the circular pass-the-buck game, where the insurance apologists blame the doctors for everything, then the doctor-apologists blame the insurers for everything, everyone blaming someone else for everything, ad nauseam; with the end-result of the status-quo being defended by mentally exhausting everyone.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by h_tbob on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:52PM (#42662217)
Bro the numbers don’t lie. Look at the average income of doctors and price of medical equipment. Then look at % profit of insurance.

Insurance makes 20%. Doctors and suppliers make 5x what normal people make.

So the problem is with the laws preventing folks from becoming doctors.

I’m gonna fix this, it’s actually so easy, just need people to trust me.

I’m really good at this kind of stuff I just hate dealing with people because the average person is so certain the world can’t get better.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @03:57AM (#42664440)
And why do doctors make 5x what normal people make? It's because they have to pay off a million dollars in school debt and risk ruining their entire lives if they fail.

btw is that doctors or hospital administrators?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by FireBeyond on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:20AM (#42642594)
> Any healthcare system must deny healthcare.

And a healthcare system enabled by UHC will deny healthcare at a rate 3 times that of the rest of the industry.

So is every other insurer "under-denying" healthcare?

Or is UHC choosing to deny healthcare more than it needs to?

> In any society, debts are expected to be paid off. If people could just stop paying their debts, nobody would make any loans anymore. Forcing people into bankruptcy is not violence.

Insurance is the reason that these debts are so exorbitant in the first place.

Do you really think the ER trip and a few tests cost the hospital eighty thousand dollars, and UHC, magician negotiators that they are, managed to talk the bill down to $4,000?

And yet the hospital will charge you, the uninsured, $80K. Yeah, you might be able to negotiate it down some, but not like that.

The US is the only country in the world where deathbed divorce is a thing, so families won't be burdened with medical bills[1].

But I feel like you'd find that immoral, too.

[1] Lack of legal obligation to the debt (even beyond this, to family members in general) won't stop the hospital calling your family and heavily beating on you to pay the bill of your recently departed, even if you had no financial responsibility, using everything from appealing to a sense of pride, to outright deception and claims that they can sue for the unpaid bill.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bigstrat2003 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:36AM (#42642716)
> Things like denying healthcare, shutting down companies and laying off people to benefit private equity investors, forcing people into bankruptcy, losing their homes, charging overdraft fees, etc.

These things are objectively not violence. Violence isn't a word for "things that harm people", it very specifically means direct, purposeful physical harm. Don't distort the meaning of words for rhetorical flair.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Philpax on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:48AM (#42642799)
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by jl6 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:10AM (#42642954)
Distorting the meaning of words is how these people justify their actions. Not giving them what they want? That’s violence now! Thus justifying retaliatory - or even pre-emptive - violence.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:53AM (#42643591)
This is the same 'get out clause' that the antagonist in the Saw films uses: "I didn't harm those people directly, I only created the conditions under which they would be harmed."

The WHO defines four types of violence: a) physical, b) sexual, c) psychological, and d) deprivation. Denying healthcare feels incredibly close to d) and — semi-indirectly — involves a bit of c) and a) too.

> These things are objectively not violence.

Semantics cannot possibly be 'objective'.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by _Algernon_ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:01AM (#42644897)
Structural violence[1] and institutional violence has been concepts in academia for ages, even if you don't like it.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structural_violence

By your strict definition of violence (direct harm) Hitler would walk free because he didn't personally gass the jews. Luckily we had trials[2] to determine that we still indirect perpetrators responsible.

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_trials

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by _Algernon_ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:00AM (#42644036)
"The people behind that kind of violence can hide behind the layers of indirection."

>[B]ureaucrats can be expected to embrace a technology that helps to create the illusion that decisions are not under their control. Because of its seeming intelligence and impartiality, a computer has an almost magical tendency to direct attention away from the people in charge of bureaucratic functions and toward itself, as if the computer were the true source of authority. A bureaucrat armed with a computer is the unacknowledged legislator of our age, and a terrible burden to bear. *We cannot dismiss the possibility that, if Adolf Eichmann had been able to say that it was not he but a battery of computers that directed the Jews to the appropriate crematoria, he might never have been asked to answer for his actions.*

Neil Postman, Technopoly (Emphasis mine)

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pcthrowaway on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:50AM (#42646174)
Extremely pertinent in the age where civilians are routinely slaughtered by AI targeting systems.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gostsamo on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:39AM (#42642262)
His case shows that people do not believe that their society is a just one. If the high class do not act on this signal, they leave space for further radicalization and even more disruptive actors will utilize the discontent. Currently, they are attacking the symptoms in the new version of "beatings will continue until morale improves".
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by stackghost on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:44AM (#42642288)
>His case shows that people do not believe that their society is a just one.

Exactly this. That was a watershed moment, I think.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by cbozeman on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06AM (#42642455)
If we actually lived in a "just" system, when people are executed for murdering a single individual, which many people have been, we would certainly execute people for things like, say, losing billions of dollars in pensions for the elderly with greedy mathematical trickery.

In a just world, hundreds would have been executed for the financial crimes of 2008.

"Justice" only exists when there's threat of punishment. It isn't enough to have the moral high ground; you have to have the might and the will to enforce the moral ground on others.

Humanity will always live under systems of "oppression", but it's what that oppression looks like that matters, because there'll always be someone who takes advantage of a system's goodwill, and that must be punished swiftly and brutally, to deter anyone from abusing the system's goodwill.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by weaksauce on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:37AM (#42642250)
> vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is wrong.

is it non-violent when they wield the system in a way to cause immense harm to the point where they are prolific killers indirectly and maybe even straight up directly? 90+ percent error rates in the AI that united used to deny claims is a violence. they denied 30+ percent of all claims.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Vampiero on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:03AM (#42642421)
No, violence is violence only when it's physical and direct. For example, mental violence doesn't exist. Verbal abuse does not exist. And in this case, United Healthcare had committed no sin at all, because due to being a non-physical entity incapable of physically interacting with the world, it didn't physically hurt anyone. Therefore it committed no violence. QED.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:10AM (#42642508)
Since this is HN, I can't tell if that's satire or not.

Bravo!

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by wang_li on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:05AM (#42642453)
Strange rationale. By that logic you are also a prolific mass murderer as you have not paid physicians to provide medical care to patients. Indirectly you have killed, well, everyone because you didn’t pay infinite money to provide unbounded medical care for every person who has died.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pzo on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:25AM (#42643816)
This is strange logic because anyone who is insured pay for other indirectly - that’s how insurance works: pull the money together so that anyone that will have bad luck of getting sick will use money from that pull. The assumption is majority of people won’t get seriously ill but once ill normally it would be financially devastating.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by CaptainFever on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:03AM (#42644054)
Related, this in fact what Peter Singer said: https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/get-involved/videos-books-an...

Basically, it is your moral obligation to donate everything you have, except for what little you need to survive. If we put that essay into this context, then not donating would indeed be violence, such as not saving a drowning child just because you don't want to.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tevon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:50AM (#42642324)
Yes, it is. If you want another system build it. Murder in the street is never justified, how is this even an argument?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Vampiero on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06AM (#42642454)
Applying moral and ethical justifications to an event that is fundamentally caused by an ever-widening social rift is pointless.

It doesn't matter if he's right or wrong or justified or evil or a saint. This happened because tensions among non-filthy-rich and filthy-rich people are increasing to a point of non return.

It's a consequence. An effect.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by kergonath on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:00AM (#42642391)
You are not replying to their point. It was not that murder was non-violent, it was that statistical violence is indeed violence. Even if you hold a “denied and go die bankrupt” stamp and not a gun.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bigstrat2003 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:38AM (#42642732)
No, that is not violence. Violence is not just a word that means "you did something bad to someone".
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:58AM (#42643629)
And causing someone's death is more than just "doing bad" to them.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by wizzwizz4 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:04AM (#42643674)
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by stackghost on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:03AM (#42642418)
You really suggesting that if, let's say, Josef Mengele was walking down the street you wouldn't shoot him?

Because I would.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by technol0gic on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:57AM (#42642372)
not to justify murder in the street, but i'm fairly certain you'd be systematically prevented, logistically and businesswise, from building an alternative system.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by wang_li on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:19AM (#42642579)
Nope. You are free to establish an alternate system if you like. There are medical facilities that are flat rate and cash only, like the Surgery Center of Oklahoma, https://surgerycenterok.com/. There are also many cost sharing services, like this one https://altruahealthshare.org. Ultimately you also have the personal option of becoming a physician and setting any rate you choose for your services, including $0.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:10AM (#42646998)
I guess that means the only reason healthcare in this country sucks so bad is because everyone already likes the way it is!
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Glyptodon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:25AM (#42642631)
Oh please, like if it's 1930 and you're walking behind Hitler knowing the future, you probably stab him. Or maybe if you're walking behind Ted Bundy in 1970. At least if you're a future-knowing trolley problem type person.

It's obvious that there are plenty of situations where murder in the streets is justified. Just that we rarely know of them in the moment.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:58AM (#42643625)
> Murder in the street is never justified

If a terrorist is running down fifth avenue with a bomb, would it be justified to shoot and kill them? What if the shooter isn't a police officer, but a member of the public?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by emchammer on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:24PM (#42649936)
I think the people making those arguments are suggesting not that the murder that Luigi Mangione committed was is right, but that it was good. It is not right by the laws of our nation; it is illegal because it is not right. It is the government's function to investigate and prosecute that crime. The overwhelming popular support for Luigi suggests that there is a collectively-recognized significant justification for the crime. Like Ken McElroy, the town bully who was murdered in 1981, in broad daylight in the town square, by bullets coming in from different angles, and nobody saw a thing.

Hitler was well on his rise to power by 1930. None of us can know who the next Hitler is. We are all familiar with Ray Bradbury and Back to the Future, which told us about how you cannot really know the future or bend it to your will. Furthermore, vigilantism is against the law, and the justice system of the government also has the job of preventing violent uprisings for various and good reasons.

The collective feeling that everybody, and I mean everybody displays, and is clearly being censored on media, is that there is a weighing of the collective morality of the situation which does not add up. This young man has been charged with a multitude of crimes. He has been charged with terrorism. Like, I went to school for international law, and I am going back to my resources, looking at the definitions, and trying to figure out how that fits. To me, a terrorist is somebody who plotted or crashed the planes into the towers. The idea that Mangione's victim, through the decisions of the company, might have caused millions of unnecessary deaths, when there could have been different paths taken, it is an leap, but it is not abstraction that is out of the grasp of many persons who have faced the medical system, specifically with treatment denial letters, on an individual level. By the way, that school that I attended was in another country which gave me free public healthcare during the length of my studies.

New York Penal Law Section 490.25 "Crime of terrorism", which is one of the statues of the second count under which Luigi has been charged, reads: A person is guilty of a crime of terrorism when, with intent to intimidate or coerce a civilian population, influence the policy of a unit of government by intimidation or coercion, or affect the conduct of a unit of government by murder, assassination or kidnapping, he or she commits a specified offense.

I do not believe that the Luigi has intimated the civilian population. A shop in his hometown has a portrait of him depicted as Jesus. Luigi did not attempt to target a unit of government; he wrote an explanatory note to "The Feds".

I think that many what many people are saying is that universal, single-payer health care is expected to be a function of government, and in fact something like the opposite is being protected.

I really hope that the District Attorney has the argument for the second count pinned down, or that it is dropped. I think that is where the ethical test for this crime lays.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:43AM (#42642286)
> But what he did was objectively what we consider to be bad… in our society, vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is wrong

In our society we don’t objectively consider it wrong, otherwise Batman (Superman, Spider-Man) wouldn’t be so popular.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bigstrat2003 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:42AM (#42642759)
That isn't true. Just because we find something entertaining in fiction does not mean we tolerate it in real life.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by whatevertrevor on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642463)
Batman is quite famous for non lethal vigilante justice. If anything Batman's position is antithetical to Luigi's.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642471)
Non lethal vigilante justice is still vigilante justice
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by whatevertrevor on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:34AM (#42642700)
Well I suspect the lethality of said justice in this case is quite critical to the judgment of being _objectively_ wrong.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Galacta7 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:45AM (#42647405)
I think if Luigi had merely assaulted the CEO to teach him a lesson, and not killed him, then we probably wouldn't be having this discussion nationally. Or at least not to the same level of debate. That (admittedly arbitrary) line is a reason most DC characters like Batman and Superman generally refuse to kill even the most deserving of villains.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by logicchains on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:04AM (#42642439)
>otherwise Batman (Superman, Spider-Man) wouldn’t be so popular.

Batman is the absolute opposite because he goes out of his way to avoid killing villains, even incredibly evil ones like the Joker.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Glyptodon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:31AM (#42642680)
It's not like the Punisher isn't popular.

Let's be real: the original super heroes avoided killing because children were their target market, and unlike with cowboys and outlaws or indians, it would have been unseemly by the standards of the time. Not because of some kind of big point about "just vigilantism."

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pzo on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:49AM (#42643949)
True. Dexter tv series was also popular - reason they made so many seasons.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pcthrowaway on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:57AM (#42646252)
A Dexter reboot where the protagonist targets extremely powerful people who commit mass violence within the confines of the law might actually be entertaining
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06AM (#42642458)
The goalposts were ‘ vigilante justice’ not killing people.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by cbozeman on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:10AM (#42642506)
Everyone you listed don't kill people. Very few people consider Batman, Superman, or Spider-Man to be objectively wrong. They consider them to be objectively right, and it's because they're enforcing the law when the police aren't around to do so.

"Law" is just another way of saying, "The bare minimum standard that we as a society will accept."

So when we have a society that sends a drunk driver to prison for 70 years for killing a family of four in a head-on collision, but we don't send people to prison for their lives for gambling with the pensions of teachers, firefighters, etc., for polluting the waterways and the earth itself, of course this is the ultimate, eventual outcome.

The only shocking thing to me about Luigi's case is that it didn't happen sooner.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:20AM (#42642590)
1 point by thowawatp302 0 minutes ago | root | parent | next | edit | delete [–]

Yeah I listed all of those because it’s funnier when people mistake the vigilante justice’ thing for a ‘not killing people’ thing and then I can trot out Clint Eastwood and Dirty Harry, which was so popular it gets quoted regularly and had four sequels.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by watwut on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:07AM (#42643700)
Batman, Superman and Spider-Man are not real. And that does matter. It is super normal to watch a movie and sympathize with what would be clearly bad guys in real life.

So yes, batman in particular would be considered bad by most people. He is just another gangster cause quite a lot of damage to the city on the regular. We do not care, because it is made up movie city.

Superman and Spider man afaik do not go around randomly assassinating people, but it is a long time since I watched that.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mahkeiro on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:40AM (#42642268)
Just a reflection, when you say: "especially against nonviolent offenders", I‘m pretty sure that a lot of people see it like this. People will directly die when a treatment is denied and for impacted people this is seen as a violent crime (even if indirect). This case is triggering more support as it has a potential impact on a the life of a lot of people.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Aurornis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:55AM (#42642357)
Mangione support is largely isolated to young age groups of certain demographics, according to polling numbers.

It’s actually really interesting to see when people think his support isn’t even a debated topic, when the numbers show most people, especially adults, don’t support his actions.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by anigbrowl on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:16AM (#42642557)
It's not most people, it's a plurality. There's a large 'don't know' contingent who either haven't made up their minds or don't want to share their opinion. Also, I would expect this data to skew toward younger people because anyone at or above retirement age is eligible for medicare, and thus not impacted by the decisions of private insurers to anything like the same degree.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by fullspectrumdev on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:00AM (#42642392)
A lot of folks who are sympathetic to his actions publicly go “oh no murder is bad” while privately being sympathetic.

I’m unsure how that shows with polling, tbh, but it certainly shows up in the discourse.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Glyptodon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:32AM (#42642692)
I know more older adults who just avoid the topic than say it was truly wrong.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Glyptodon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:13AM (#42642534)
Condemning people to death and bankruptcy is violence.

That said, we consider vigilante justice wrong because we believe there is supposed to be actual justice from a functional system. When the system does not function, extrajudicial attempts at justice will become more common. Just like people will poach more in a famine.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tivert on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:04AM (#42642435)
> This case is such an interesting crossroads. He has such insane support ... But what he did was objectively what we consider to be bad… in our society, vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is considered to be wrong.

It's worth noting that in our society lots of other things are also considered to be wrong, things which are done openly every day by some of the richest and most powerful people and organizations in the country.

That's why he has "insane support": the system is broken and has proven itself incapable of policing that other bad behavior.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by wesapien on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:17AM (#42642566)
Non-violence...lines get blurred while being cut throat and cold hearted when you do it to thousands or millions of people. I'm surprised the GFC didn't have anything like this given the damage it did.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by carabiner on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:02AM (#42642409)
There are like 4 pro-Luigi subreddits with 10k+ users.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by CaptainFever on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:37AM (#42643888)
Reddit is not real life.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Supermancho on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:17PM (#42648347)
> Reddit is not real life.

...then it follows HN isn't. I happen to know they are both real for the purposes of existing and as a meta commentary on topics, since I participate in both. I also don't know anyone who wouldn't give Luigi a pass on a Jury, and these people don't vote the same.

Disregarding the existence of the sentiment, is the kneejerk noise of people thinking they are uber-rational thinkers or arbiters of reality.

I'll assume, in good faith, what your wrote was simply not what you meant.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Y-bar on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:49AM (#42642317)
The ”nonviolent” part is interesting. We as a society has many examples of holding such people responsible for ”legal” and ”non-violent” actions that clearly resulted in deaths of lots of people.

Sorry about the rather extreme example and inviting Godwin. But consider for example Krupp (CEO) and Ribbentrop (Diplomat) who were both entirely ”non-violent” people, they personally did not draw a single drop of blod as far as I know. And the holocaust were perfectly legal according to the law at the time.

Violence with the stroke of a pen, killing via a rubber stamp, violence through withholding safety.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thefz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:27AM (#42643074)
Bringing justice to the person responsible to hundreds/thousands of deaths and immense suffering is right - was the murder of Mussolini unjust? Hitler's?

If the justice system won't take care of it, there has to come a tipping point, IMO.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:35AM (#42642244)
But what he did was objectively what we consider to be bad… in our society, vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is wrong.

What are you talking about? What "vigilante justice"? The innocent victim, Brian Thompson, was murdered by a lunatic. He was not an offender. It was no justice.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:38AM (#42642259)
By some accounts Thompson was a killer of thousands.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:42AM (#42642281)
Using such a weasel phrase like "by some accounts" means that there's absolutely nothing standing behind this. If there was any concrete thing Brian Thompson did that was any kind of legal crime or moral error, you'd be able to name it.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:00AM (#42642399)
My intent was merely to point out that it is a commonly held belief, because it seemed like you were not aware. I didn't want to champion that belief.

But since you've invited me to name the moral error, sure. Accepting a fiduciary responsibility to chase after profits in a context where that very clearly means finding ways to deny people access to healthcare is a moral error. If you can't ethically do a job you shouldn't take that job. At best you're lying to shareholders, at worst you're killing people. The only ethical path is to go find a different job.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:05AM (#42642449)
There is absolutely no way to run an insurance scheme without denying some people coverage. No system anywhere in the world, public or private, accepts every single claim. You must deny some claims, there's no way around it. This means that according to you, there's no ethical way to run health insurance system. I disagree, I think we need insurance to exist, and given that someone needs to run insurance, I don't think that taking such a job is inherently a moral error.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xvinci on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:24AM (#42642617)
You are right, BUT: Those denials have to follow contractual terms. I know a local (Europe) real world example where a friend of a friend (insurance company area manager) literally was told "this is your sum of money on claims that you can accept in this quarter, it cannot go above that". Which either you get lucky and make the quota, or you screw people over and hope they don't sue. And since we live in a world where the company wants "a little more" each year, well.. I don't see how this ends well.

The same problem does not apply to our social services (including health insurance) as they dont have to make profits at all costs.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:21AM (#42642603)
It's really just for-profit health insurance systems that I think can't be made ethical. If you have to deny some claims based on resource availability, that's an uncomfortable necessity, but we can do insurance-like things without asking people to balance human life against shareholder greed.

It seems pretty obvious that opting into a position where you'll have to do that might make you unpopular with the humans.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:35AM (#42642703)
What is "resource availability"? In a non-profit healthcare systems, how exactly the amount of available resources is determined? Is there no person involved making a decision that causes the amount of available resources to change? Think about it. Consider, for example, politicians who set the healthcare tax rate. If they set it 1% higher, there will be more resources available. Does it mean that by not doing so, they deny care to some?

I strongly encourage you to think very carefully about this. Once you do, you'll find that there are no simple answers: you'll always have limited resources, and you'll always have to deny care to some people, and in fact it will always include some people personally making the call to deny care to some people. Any system that actually exists, public or private, does this.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:18AM (#42643011)
> In a non-profit healthcare systems, how exactly the amount of available resources is determined?

You would generally count them. Like, if you have three people in need of a ventilator and you only have two ventilators, then one person is getting denied a ventilator today.

> Any system that actually exists, public or private, does this.

That's true, and I don't have a problem with it. Tradeoffs have to happen. What I have a problem with is incentive structures that attribute greater success for the people at the top when they create outcomes that involve more death for the people at the bottom.

Plenty of systems which actually exist don't congratulate leadership for reducing quality of care.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:23AM (#42643048)
OK, but why is there only two ventilators? Who made this decision, and based on what? Try to think a couple of steps ahead.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:37AM (#42643144)
Presumably somebody involved in deciding budgets, a politician perhaps, or somebody with a rather political role in the hospital. Whoever they are, in most cases they're balancing ventilators against test kits or against hiring more doctors or against letting people keep more of their paychecks, or all kinds of other things which might indeed be more important for the patients/citizens/etc...

There's no fundamental reason why they have to be in a position where screwing the people who receive the care would ever be considered the ideal option. But that's how it is when you have a group of shareholders who have no stake in the quality of care. Thompson opted into a conflict of interest which need not exist in order to provide insurance.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:18AM (#42643777)
More likely they balance the need to increase healthcare taxes against their chance of being reelected.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:39AM (#42645318)
Sure, and that's not exactly comfortable (maybe "reelected" shouldn't be a thing, idk). But if the people reelecting you are also the patients then the particular conflict of interest I'm worried about is not present.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:41AM (#42647366)
Yes, that's why NHS is so well funded. Oh, wait, it isn't.

Government-organized resource allocation is, more likely than not, bad to very bad.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:48PM (#42650652)
True, and we need to get our shit together about that, but it's not an apples to apples comparison. A government allocates 100% of the available healthcare funding towards healthcare outcomes. A corporation (in the US) allocates 80%. You can tolerate a sloppier slicing if you're starting with a bigger pie.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:05AM (#42643686)
The line is on why you are doing the denying. Are you doing so because providing the healthcare is literally impossible, or are you doing so in order to make more money?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:16AM (#42643760)
I think you need to specify this more.

In most insurance fields, it would be possible to only deny false claims. Take insurance of your house. The rates could be calculated that they can pay out all real damages to the full amount. Because the maximum damage amount is limited.

That's not true for health insurance, because the total possible damage (cost of treatments) is almost arbitrarily high, so that you cannot pay everything for everyone.

I don't want to defend the US system here. But it's not a problem that any country really solved, and one could argue about advantages and disadvantages of the different systems all day long.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:46AM (#42642301)
I’m standing behind this.

I think that Brian Thompson was a mass murderer. His actions as CEO put profit before people and caused many people’s lives to be lost.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:53AM (#42642346)
What actions? What did he do? You're just repeating empty phrases to smear the murder victim.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:03AM (#42642424)
> UnitedHealthcare in particular denied coverage for post-acute care, or services and support needed after a hospitalization. In 2019, the insurance provider’s initial denial rate for post-acute care prior authorization requests was 8.7%; by 2022, it had increased to 22.7%.

Buck stop with him; between 2021 and 2022 he did that. Being the CEO and all.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642466)
And what's the crime here? What's the moral error? Can you elucidate? I hope you're not trying to argue that insurance should not be allowed to ever deny claims?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by anigbrowl on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:18AM (#42642577)
I think you understand very clearly what point is being made, and are just pretending not to get it.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:23AM (#42642610)
I think they've been playing that game for a while now.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:43AM (#42642765)
My understanding is that people are twisting themselves into pretzels to blame the murder victim for something, but they have extremely hard time finding anything explicit to point to, so they just throw allusions, hoping that the reader will complete the bogus argument in their head.

Here, for example, the parent poster brings up some statistic that some very specific category of insurance claim denial went up in some period. The allusion is that this is nefarious, and is a result of some specific action by the murder victim. The reader is supposed to interpret it this way. Of course, there's absolutely zero evidence for any of these claims, and when you lay it down like that, it sounds pretty stupid without anything backing this up.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:25AM (#42647181)
Just goes to show you how incompatible your morals are from others, I suppose.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by anigbrowl on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:12PM (#42647672)
It's a general category (all claim denials) and it did not go up, it more than doubled; as you are probably aware, it's far, far above the industry average. Also you're misusing the word 'allusion' which means 'to refer to something. You probably meant 'implication'.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:26PM (#42647825)
No, denial of “post-acute care, or services and support needed after a hospitalization” claims is a narrow category, it’s not all claim denials.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by thowawatp302 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:08AM (#42642486)
Why not, I pay them. Do you pay your phone company to not provide service?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:37AM (#42642727)
Of course, there are plenty of places and circumstances where my phone company does not provide me service.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:40AM (#42645327)
You don't see a moral error with a health insurance company going out of their way to more than double the claims they deny, not because it's ethical or necessary but because they find ways to do so legally and the motive is profit?

Perhaps you're not well equipped to evaluate moral errors in the first place.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Philpax on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:46AM (#42642303)
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:58AM (#42642378)
The only potential crime that article lists is allegation that the murder victim failed to disclose some material fact to the company investors. Are you saying that Luigi Mangione killed Thomson on behalf of the stock holders, who lost money by holding UnitedHealthcare stock?

Your comment is pretty clear example of the attitude around the case. People hate CEOs of companies that must make difficult decision, and so when they are murdered, they will twist themselves into pretzels to somehow justify that they had it coming.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by impossiblefork on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:00AM (#42643641)
Yes, but if there were a crime, then there'd be a legal remedy, so any vigilante action would be unjustified.

That something harmful is legal or effectively legal is a necessary requirement for a vigilante action to morally acceptable.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by davrosthedalek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:24AM (#42643808)
Wouldn't the moral acceptable way be to try making the harmful thing illegal?

And if people in their majority, in their stupidity or cleverness, reject your argument, isn't then vigilante action deeply anti-democratic?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by impossiblefork on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:13AM (#42644117)
I suppose it depends on how you view things and what tradition you're from.

I have a very old-style view, where courts provide systems that substitute for private vengeance and thus become legitimate by being willing to hear complaints of harm, so from my point of view, if a court hear the matter, the affected person can take whatever measures they wish, which of course has important consequences in cases of legal immunity-- when my view is taken, legal immunity is something one desperately wants to avoid having, because whoever has it must contend with private vengeance.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:38AM (#42645301)
> People hate CEOs of companies that must make difficult decision,

No, People hate CEO's making greedy, selfish, unnecessary decisions that cost lives and cause suffering.

Be honest.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:05PM (#42648821)
Again, you exemplify the exact attitude I describe. Can you point to any single decision that Thompson made that cost live and causes suffering? You can’t, but you assume there must have been some, because you start with assumption that the victim here is guilty, and only then try to find reasons why.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:15PM (#42648910)
> Again, you exemplify the exact attitude I describe.

That's fine. I think you exemplify the attitude that lead to Thompson's murder and will lead to many more similar incidents.

> Can you point to any single decision that Thompson made that cost live and causes suffering? You can’t, but you assume there must have been some,

If denials tripled under his watch, as CEO you don't think he necessarily was involved in that? He clearly approved of profiting off of literal unnecessary deaths.

> because you start with assumption that the victim here is guilty

The most basic of reasoning shows he has some moral guilt, just not legal guilt.

P1 - He was the head decision maker

P2 - Decision was made to actively increase unnecessary deaths for monetary gain

C - He ultimately approved of that decision

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:59PM (#42649752)
If denials tripled under his watch, as CEO you don't think he necessarily was involved in that? He clearly approved of profiting off of literal unnecessary deaths.

You have yet to show that tripling denials of a particular category of claims is even wrong in the first place. Let me repeat: any system will deny some claims, so denied claims are not prima facie evidence of anything wrong.

Decision was made to actively increase unnecessary deaths for monetary gain

Nobody had shown any evidence whatsoever that anything like that happened. Not only are denied claims not automatically wrong, but also changes in denial rate do not even need to correspond to any decision or change in policy, but may instead result from changes of external factors.

He ultimately approved of that decision

What decision? You just assume that there had been some decision, that Bryan Thompson approved, and that it was nefarious. There is as of now zero evidence for this, this is just your speculation. Murdering people based on speculations like that is profoundly evil, and so is excusing it.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:01PM (#42650247)
> You have yet to show that tripling denials of a particular category of claims is even wrong in the first place.

Honestly this is a pretty bad faith argument. They are denying at a significantly higher rate than their competitors, their internal policy focused around denying, and enough people are getting screwed over that a murder was committed.

But yeah, sure, assume this is all business as normal and not at all morally wrong to make your argument if you must.

> Nobody had shown any evidence whatsoever that anything like that happened.

Basic. Reasoning.

If claim denials triple during a time when a particular CEO is in place, that CEO would have had to have something to do with that.

> Not only are denied claims not automatically wrong,

They are on this scale and when the denials are bad faith. I can't prove that to you unless their documents get leaked, but that's for legal matters. For moral matters, the evidence supports that the difference from the drastic increase were indeed bad faith denials.

> What decision? You just assume that there had been some decision, that Bryan Thompson approved, and that it was nefarious.

Exactly, because he was CEO.

> There is as of now zero evidence for this, this is just your speculation.

He was CEO.

> Murdering people based on speculations like that is profoundly evil, and so is excusing it.

He was CEO. He oversaw a company going out of their way to deny claims even if you want to play devils advocate and pretend to be ignorant and deny that.

What he did was far more evil than a single murder, and what you are doing in defending the system that caused someone to feel that they had to murder it also more evil, the system that allows for shitty health insurance companies to cause so much pain and suffering. THAT, is evil.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642464)
> moral error,

The moral error is by refining and endorsing a company policy that went out of it's way to cheat people out of their due insurance, killing significant amounts of people as a result and ensuring suffering for even more.

Our legal system can't really address this, not until the electoral college gets disbarred or red state voters realize rejecting socialized health care hurts more than it helps.

Until that happens. things are going to get worse and people are going to get frustrated and start acting out. It's what happens when you have such a broken system.

Talking about "we don't do that in society" is ignoring the problem at it's core. You can't expect people to just obey the rules and respect law and order when it clearly isn't working for them or people they care about.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by jimbob45 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:53AM (#42642345)
No one will have concrete answers until discovery during Mangione’s trial. That is, if United doesn’t find themselves their own Jack Ruby.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:13AM (#42642532)
What discovery? Are you suggesting that the defense in the murder case will be able to do any kind of discovery on UnitedHealthcare? How would that even be possible?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by madaxe_again on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:57AM (#42642373)
[flagged]
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by kergonath on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:03AM (#42642425)
Some turkeys are convinced that Christmas is a great thing. See also, Trump and nationalist populism.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xyzzyz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:01AM (#42642406)
Ah yes, let's murder people we feel (without even any concretes to support this) are not morally pure, what a perfect idea. Which other CEOs do you think it would be justified to murder? Or are there any that are morally pure enough to you that they can live?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642467)
Just a guess, but I think if we found a way to put together a list, perhaps by voting or something, 99% of CEOs would be fine. And if the fear of being found to be in that remaining 1% is an effective deterrent against bad behavior, well maybe we ought to be making such lists.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by CaptainFever on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:12AM (#42644107)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hated_in_the_Nation

Detective Chief Inspector Karin Parke and Trainee Detective Constable Blue Coulson unravel a deadly conspiracy involving autonomous drone insects (ADIs). After the controversial journalist Jo Powers dies in an apparent suicide, forensic evidence reveals an ADI embedded in her brain. The investigation escalates as similar ADI-related murders occur, including that of rapper Tusk, targeted after social media backlash.

The detectives uncover a sinister "Game of Consequences" launched by hacked ADIs, where the most-mentioned person under the hashtag #DeathTo is killed daily. The situation spirals out of control when the ADIs are used to surveil citizens, and public engagement with the hashtag results in mass casualties. A manifesto from Garrett Scholes, a former Granular employee and hacker, reveals his motive: to expose societal cruelty and complacency.

Efforts to neutralize the hacked ADIs fail, resulting in the death of 387,036 people who used the hashtag, including a member of Parke's team. The fallout leaves Coulson presumed dead by suicide, though Parke later receives evidence that Coulson is alive and pursuing Scholes abroad, leaving the case ominously unresolved.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by CaptainFever on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:10AM (#42644093)
Since anecdotes seem to be data points in this thread, I would say that as a non-American, the online public support for incident horrifies me and makes me think that this is a symptom of a collapsing society. It is also horrifying that so many Americans online seem to be bloodthirsty for more. Makes me not want to associate with them.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by chimpanzee on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:38AM (#42642256)
Justice isn’t confined to the law. Nor to any one person’s opinion.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by PhasmaFelis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:43AM (#42642285)
Everything Brian Thompson did was legal, which is not the same thing as being "innocent."
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by unrealhoang on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:40AM (#42643509)
Why would they (the companies) have to do anything should be the question.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by perlgeek on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:18AM (#42644146)
> I don’t know what SO should have done

Well, nothing.

Unless they have a general policy of scrubbing records of everybody indicted for (but not yet proven guilty of) violent crimes, why do anything at all?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lazide on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:49AM (#42644784)
It’s so weird to me that people say vigilante violence is so universally abhorred, when we literally have Batman and the Punisher as major draws at the theatre.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ruthmarx on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:04AM (#42645611)
> vigilante justice (especially against nonviolent offenders) is considered to be wrong.

I guess hiding behind the veil of legality and murdering thousands if not hundreds of thousands if considered worse. Rightfully IMO.