You don't have to have your photo taken to enter the US if you're a citizen, but who wants to deal with the hassle? And on and on it goes.
go ahead and decline while the cop is holding your passport.
It's much, much more annoying in Ireland, where US immigration happens in Dublin (an affront to Irish sovereignty, but that's another matter) - so being delayed can mean missing your flight.
I’ll bite. Why do you think it’s an affront to their sovereignty? It’s entirely voluntary and it’s something the Dublin airport (and the dozens of other airports in Canada) actively seek out to get direct access to the domestic side in the US.
The US does not force any airports into these arrangements.
(The popularity of that airport for CIA torture flights also doesn't help the case, even if not directly linked)
FWIW, I recall reading that the program in Canada is reciprocal, and it is simply the case that Canada hasn't decided to operate any corresponding facility in the US.
Let's talk about Toronto or Vancouver to set aside CIA whatever. What particular convenience does it provide for the US government to do it there vs on the US side? AFAICT that would save the airline that brought a person who got denied a bit of trouble - vs having to take them back to their departure airport - but not be a particularly huge convenience or burden for either government at a higher-up level.
It reduces legal accountability (I know the US courts have generally exempted border operations from the constitution anyway, but that interpretation could change in the future) and makes it easier to prevent people from e.g. landing and claiming asylum (yes there are measures to penalise airlines and oblige them to return passengers, but they're not always fully effective). More subtly it means there's less pressure to have reasonable border rules, since turning someone away before they board is lower-stakes. And having an official, pseudo-law-enforcement presence in a country is valuable almost in itself.
Well maybe. What happens when you try to exercise that right? If it turns out that those US border officials falsely imprisoned you (under Canadian law - if the Canadian courts are even willing to hear the case), what consequences will they face?
As said policies become increasingly inhumane I think Ireland should consider removing this arrangement. But you are right, Dublin Airport themselves do benefit since it makes them more attractive, especially as a transfer airport for people going to the US from Europe.
If anything, it seems to me that the USA agreeing to perform immigration checks in Ireland and accept them when you reach the USA is a(n extremely mild) limitation to US sovereignty, not to Irish sovereignty.
When my spouse and I crossed through US customs this past spring, they called us by our names and waved us on before even getting our passports out to hand to the customs officer. This was at BWI, fwiw.
Immigration - which is the process of becoming a US permanent resident and/or citizen - is handled (mostly) by USCIS.
Other visas are handled by the State Department (foreign ministry).
Not an expert, but this is my understanding.
I have Global Entry but I don't think the US even has a customs form any longer.
>very few exceptions
You've got it backwards. If you're an American you're probably traveling through freeports or low tax regimes like Singapore, UK, etc. and don't realise how regressive most regimes are. In places like Hungary, Angola, SEA -- where tax can be in the range of 30-50% you will be lucky not to be shaken down by a customs agent before leaving the luggage carousel.
This is just as interesting as it is creepy, but that's the world we live and this is hacker news. So, how quickly was was quickly. You made your report, they get the proper people involved, and then they show you the video. How much time passed before you were viewing the video?
For someone that plays with quickly assembling an edited video from a library of video content using a database full of cuepoints, this is a very interesting problem to solve. What did the final video look like? Was it an assembled video with cuts like in a spy movie with the best angles selected in sequence? Was it each of the cameras in a multi-cam like view just starting from the time they ID'd the flight you arrived on? Did they draw the boxes around you to show the system "knew" you?
I'm really curious how dystopian we actually are with the facial recognition systems like this.
It records the license plates of all cars entering and leaving the parking lots. You can associate names to faces which we do for all employees and the system automatically records when people enter and leave buildings. You can even just tell it to find all people with a blue shirt in a particular camera in a time window. It can automatically detect people shouting.
No idea how widespread it is, but in Singapore airport the system is tightly integrated. You are "tagged" when you check in, and "tagged out" as you board, with your appearance associated with your intended flight details. If you miss your flight or otherwise spend too much time in the secure zone, you are highlighted in the system and will eventually be approached. Arriving passengers are also given a time limit to take their next action, be it clear immigration or enter transit, and lingering will also trigger a response.
All in the name of safety and security but I can't help but feel a measure of discomfort with it all.
Other cases, like games where the user's voice changes due to excitement/stress, were incredibly bad.
rub my jeans sailor. no 3d xrays for me.
Someone got fired that day.
Case in point - one time the cash machine on the bank exterior disbursed an extra 20 to me. I counted it carefully, sure enough, an extra one. So I went around to the other side, went in, and handed it to the teller with an explanation. She about fell over in shock.
It's kinda sad, actually.
Without it, I think all the gingers would have pointed at me rather than me being tired and making a mistake.
You may be overestimating how many unique/different people travel through airports, especially more than once or twice to notice the tracking. People who travel once or twice total in their life by air, (are usually easy to spot), far more concerned with getting through a confusing hectic situation then noticing or even knowing that using facial recognition is new and not simply a special thing (because 9/11). And, the majority of Americans have travelled to zero or one country, last time I saw numbers on it. That country is usually Mexico or Canada where they drive (or walk).
I think once it starts trying to hit close to home where people have a routine and are not as stressed by a new situation and have the bandwidth to--at a minimum--take a pause, will ask questions about what is going on.
From a practical point of view to avoid getting caught if you look at the phone snatchers, they wear hoodies, balaclava type cycle masks and generic black tracksuit like clothing. If you look at the photos of the NYC shooter he slipped up in not wearing a balaclava type mask and in having distinctive clothing and backpack.
Well that’s the norm with all surveillance: it pretty much never helps you and might hurt you, regardless of the promises. Obviously after decades of constant spying, men are still getting ads intended for women and vice versa, and yet micro targeting is changing election outcomes. Banks and governments watch every single transaction, but it doesn’t reduce the administrative burden of compliance for tax paperwork. Airport experiences are worse than ever and at greater expense, but anyone with a few brain cells to rub together knows that it’s just security theater. Even more basically.. google reads all your email and searching for that exact phrase you know you read or wrote just a few weeks ago somehow turns up zero results.
This will all just get worse, because as the amount of data collected increases, everyone can be suspected of something just because of coincidence. Your insurance company is getting the memo about your poor diet or know that you’re driving too fast, and just won’t bother to find out about your healthy exercise regimen or that your job is driving an ambulance! To be presumed innocent you’ll need to opt into more data collection or disclosures of course, that’s the way it goes, but this only makes things worse because the extra data is just more stuff that can be used in a case against you.
Out of sight, out of mind. If there isn't a large video camera tracking them as they move across a shop or down the street, I'm not sure many people will even notice.
Privacy advocacy orgs should have contests for tracking people using publicaly available video feeds, or something of the sort.
Let people search their license plate to see how easy it is to track all of your movements. Maybe put up a few high res webcams in the vicinity of a legislature building for maximum effect.
Also, practically, the advocacy groups would need to get access to the surveillance feeds or deploy their own hardware - which I just don't see happening
The problem I keep running into is a real world take on the Trolley problem[0].
Do you publicly publish all data, which:
1. Reduces its sellable value
2. Makes people aware of how much they are being tracked and profiled
3. Gives back a small bit of agency over ones data by knowing where to send delete/remove request to make data brokers honour local laws
However, doing so would also:
1. Give easy access to abuse victim data, putting them in further harm
2. Give actual stalkers an easier path to their targets
3. Other harm that I can not fathom at this point in time
I don't know the answer, maybe mask the address part, or do like Strava and set a blocking geo fence around home/work addresses. For location tracking keep it months behind and remove/mask anything remotely related to health services (mental and physical).
Just like everyone though, I’m just going to gripe here and move on with my life as the mass surveillance infrastructure rollout proceeds
You're right about just trying to get through the process. I was the only one in our family who was like, "No idea why they were taking pictures of everybody when they just whisked us through customs." My Dad snapped that it was because of 9/11 and we weren't lawbreakers so just deal with it.
The comment was interesting since my Dad worked for Lockheed Martin for 30 years and used to travel constantly. He mentioned the idea of a "high trust society" is now gone forever and facial recognition and other technologies are now necessary to give that trust back to the general public so they can feel safe with air travel.
But for nation wide public search the false positive rate is just way to high for it to work well.
Once someone managed to leave a "local/time" context (e.g. known accident at known location and time) without leaving too many traces (in the US easy due to wide use of private cars everyone) the false positive rate makes such systems often practically hardly helpful.
Then again, it depends on where you are. One could have thought that finding a specific guy in NYC after you had him on camera at a given time would be easy, but they aren't so easy to locate immediately.
I'd feel much better about if we heavily surveilled the use of surveillance. E.g., every access is recorded both in terms of metadata and in terms of generating video of whoever's looking. And if I'm in something they're looking at, I get notified (barring temporary legal exceptions for open investigations and the like).
Because my business is my business and nobody else's. Full stop.
So, it stops being solely your business, and starts to become slightly others', as well.
Whose? And under what circumstances? Please be specific and include appropriate legal precedents. Thanks!
[1] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-yor...
[2] https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/madison-square-gard...
[3] https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/newyorkcity/latest/NYC...
Where's the case law and precedent that says your business is only your own, even when on a public sidewalk or in a grocery store? If you're going to make such unreasonable demands, can we start with your own claims, since you made them first?
Public roads should be a clear case where your business is everyone else's business since you're hurtling down the road in an increasingly heavier vehicle, but we're far from being able to acknowledge that.
I'm admittedly biased from spending a few years steeped in the cryptocurrency community, where literally everything has a hidden (or not!) self-serving agenda, however. But even beyond that realm, I see far too many privacy advocates whose examples of "reasons why you should want privacy" end up being examples of hiding bad behavior (infidelity, etc). If you couple this with anti-social people being privacy advocates out of necessity, it ends up reflecting very poorly on the privacy community as a whole.
I guess we'll see, won't we?
Being seen by others, being recorded incidentally, being recorded constantly, and being recorded and analyzed by machines in real time?
How am I supposed to take you privacy advocates seriously when you make such wild logical leaps?
Most people don't expect others to look away while you pick your nose at the grocery store. The statement about defending privacy in public is almost always about tracking and the ease of it.
Please re-read the thread, without injecting your own pre-conceived notions into it? The statement was simply this:
"Because my business is my business and nobody else's. Full stop."
When it comes to being in public or at a grocery store, this is simply untrue. Being in public involves interacting with other people, at which point it inherently ceases to be just your business, and starts to be others', too.
That entitles them to some amount of say in it, however small it might be, depending on the context.
No where did I say anything about the degree of surveillance?
Because usually, when someone says "my business is my business", they don't mean "no one has the right to look at me when I'm out in public". That kind of statement about my business being mine in public, is usually tied to tracking and/or persistent, shareable surveillance video.
If others are free to observe you while you are in public with them, are they not also free to do whatever they wish with that information? Same as you are free to attempt to share as little as possible with them. Public spaces are commons, and private spaces are subject to the rules of their owners, as you are also bound by them, in some form.
Once you leave your own property, what you do ceases to be your business alone, and begins to also be someone else's. There are clearly matters of degree, but it's also impossible to be in public without broadcasting copious amounts of personal information. If others in public are equipped to collect that information in whatever form it takes, why is that suddenly wrong?
Disagreeing with that tells me that by saying "my business is only my business, and nobody else's" you really mean "no one has the right to observe me/interact with me in public". Otherwise, you'd have to agree with my earlier statements, right?
It is not. Full stop.
Legally, it may not be. But it's creepy and invasive. Doxxing is a net negative to society. And more than individuals catching me in photos or videos incidentally, is the problem of surveillance and tracking, something I have mentioned repeatedly and you have failed to acknowledge. First came CCTV, then comes ubiquitous cheap video storage, now comes AI that can analyze that video in real time for identification and behavioral analysis.
I'll flip your question on its head: why is it the default that people should consent to ubiquitous machine-based activity monitoring by all their peers and their government, just because the technology exists? What's the benefit?
If society has lived without ubiquitous surveillance and automated behavioral analytics and tracking for all history, why is it suddenly right?
Creepy to you, maybe. It's creepy to me that some people want to live their lives as faceless, nameless ghosts in a modern society!
> Doxxing is a net negative to society.
Is it? You're making a very bold claim here and stating it as fact, as if it's somehow self-evident. It isn't, though.
> And more than individuals catching me in photos or videos incidentally, is the problem of surveillance and tracking, something I have mentioned repeatedly and you have failed to acknowledge. First came CCTV, then comes ubiquitous cheap video storage, now comes AI that can analyze that video in real time for identification and behavioral analysis.
I haven't failed to acknowledge them at all! One of my first replies in this thread explicitly acknowledged such things.
I just fail to differentiate ubiquitous surveillance from incidental surveillance. To me, the latter is simply an extension of the former. Yes, scale can make things markedly different, but it's not inherently negative. The scale of our ability to communicate has increased drastically over the past few decades, and while it has come with some bad effects, increasing the scale of our ability to communicate is not inherently bad. In fact, I think a lot of the negatives that have come with mass communication come from the relative anonymity of the mediums.
You know, the good ol' "people feel perfectly fine saying things they wouldn't say to someone's face, when they're hiding behind a keyboard, screen, and pseudonym" problem. It's not always a problem, yes, but I see far more assholes taking advantage of it to escape societal consequences than I see afflicted minorities escaping unfair judgement.
> I'll flip your question on its head: why is it the default that people should consent to ubiquitous machine-based activity monitoring by all their peers and their government, just because the technology exists? What's the benefit?
I can think of all sorts of benefits!
Better security, more accountability for anti-social behaviors, better health management, discoveries of all sorts of social phenomena that can be empirically documented, etc etc. There are vast, untapped reserves of information that can and should be used to better society as a whole, rather than discarding it all as some kind of detritus.
The vast majority of any individual's "information footprint" is utterly wasted, and you're arguing for even more wastage. I'd love for there to be preventative diagnostics for health conditions, that can do things like tell me I have early stage cancer, because it can detect information I'm emitting in some form that would otherwise go undetected. Compared to the alternative, where I only go see the doctor when I notice some ill effects, which could potentially be too late for treatment? Yeah, that seems like a net positive to me, and a far better utilization of my information footprint than simply discarding all of it.
I'd also love for it to be harder to behave anti-socially in all contexts, and to feel confident that the person I'm transacting with isn't scamming me, etc.
> If society has lived without ubiquitous surveillance and automated behavioral analytics and tracking for all history, why is it suddenly right?
Let me flip this question on it's head: if we've been living in ignorance of something for all history, when we discover that ignorance, why should we endeavor to continue in it, when there are better alternatives?
I'm not arguing that such things like "anti-social behavior" are cut and dry things, nor that my definitions of such things should be accepted by all. These are things we can and should debate, and come to agreement on in democratic ways.
But to simply be against it because "it's too hard", "I don't like it", and "we've always done it that way" strike me as a terribly ignorant approach.
>Is it? You're making a very bold claim here and stating it as fact, as if it's somehow self-evident. It isn't, though.
Okay. Please post your full name, physical address, telephone number(s), employer, spouse and childrens' names, ages and birth dates.
If it's not a negative, you should have no problem doing so, right?
Faulty logic - it can be bad for specific individuals while being a net good for society at large.
NOTE: I am not the OG claimant, I'm not supporting their argument - I'm merely pointing out your rebuttal is weak (to the point of not working at all).
How is every person living in fear that they can be identified, stalked, subjected to abuse or even killed just because some rando doesn't like what they said on some internet forum a "net good for society at large"?
Please do explain.
As for my "rebuttal" being weak, I merely called for GP to have the courage of their convictions. And since (based on their participation in this discussions) they apparently have neither, I thought I'd point that up.
Don't like my writing style? Note my username and feel free to ignore me.
That has nothing to do with your argument above re: one specific person being weak to the point of nonexistent - you've gone off on a tangent.
> Please do explain.
It's self evident to those with a background in formal debate, mathematical logic, general reasoning, etc. If you honestly can't see that and are interested in improving your comment skills in a technical forum such as HN then you may want to look into that.
> I merely called for GP to have the courage of their convictions.
Their claim that Doxxing might be a net good has little to do with it being bad for individuals doxxed, nor even being bad for every individual actually doxxed.
"Net good" and metrics for good|bad are the concepts you'd need to firm up and address here.
> Don't like my writing style?
It's the unsubstantive rhetoric in the guise of reason I addressed - that done I suspect we're done.
Perhaps with practice you'll do better in future than lurking about sniping at week old comments secure in the knowledge they likely won't even see your fluff.
I'll be sure to give them the attention they deserve!
Have a great day!
Sorry for the late reply.
Exactly.
From a fairly broad perspective, I do mean "my business is my business," but as another commenter noted, it's not only my business. And I agree. It's also the concern of those with whom I interact, both directly (e.g., talking to a cashier as I make a purchase at a grocery store) or indirectly (e.g., whether or not I litter).
In those cases, it's also the cashier and whoever maintains the street's business as well. Which is so blindingly obvious I didn't think it needed explication. My apologies for any confusion.
In any case, I find the idea that I, Nobody9999, should be tracked, surveilled and/or otherwise profiled, in the course of my everyday activities to be quite offensive.
Unfortunately, unless I want to live "off the grid" (i.e., cower in a leanto out in the woods somewhere), I have to submit to some of that. And more's the pity.
But that doesn't mean I have to like it. Nor does it mean I have to pretend it's not a direct affront to my (and everyone else's) privacy.
I'm really confused, and you're not making any sense.
Some countries have strong privacy laws, such as Switzerland.
When I was in Mexico I filed a report with the airport after an employee selling timeshares was overly aggressive and grabbed my arm and try to block me from leaving. Quickly they showed me a video of my entire time with all my movements at the airport so they could pinpoint the employee.
Like the article says I think it is just a matter of time until such systems are everywhere. We are already getting normalized to it at public transportation hubs with almost 0 objections. Soon most municipalities or even private businesses will implement it and no one will care because it already happens to them at the airport, so why make a fuss about it at the grocery store or on a public sidewalk.