News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by UltraSane on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:57PM (#42361826)
You have zero expectation of privacy in public
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by crooked-v on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:59PM (#42361839)
There's a huge difference between the historical intent of that principle and the way that these days everyone in a given space can be exhaustively recorded and tracked 24/7.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by hibikir on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:45PM (#42362092)
The availability of cheap sick is what makes the lack of privacy naturally different. There was a time where a police department could identify a suspect, talk to a judge, and then had that person followed for a while, dedicating multiple people to the efforts. With enough cameras and disk space, you now identify a person, and they were pre-followed for who knows how long.

Then again, it depends on where you are. One could have thought that finding a specific guy in NYC after you had him on camera at a given time would be easy, but they aren't so easy to locate immediately.

Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by wpietri on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:57PM (#42362145)
For sure, and I think a key change here is asymmetry. Previously in public I'd have a reasonable chance of knowing that somebody was watching or following me. Between cameras, networks, and high-capacity recording, that's all out the window.

I'd feel much better about if we heavily surveilled the use of surveillance. E.g., every access is recorded both in terms of metadata and in terms of generating video of whoever's looking. And if I'm in something they're looking at, I get notified (barring temporary legal exceptions for open investigations and the like).

Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by HeatrayEnjoyer on Sunday December 08, 2024 @07:52PM (#42362123)
This saying isn't even true. Many countries have cultural expectations and legal structures providing some level of privacy in public. The very first GDPR fine issued stemmed from a business security camera that needlessly recorded people on the sidewalk.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by UltraSane on Sunday December 08, 2024 @08:30PM (#42362300)
How can you expect privacy when an unlimited number of cameras could be recording you?
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by itishappy on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:27PM (#42368160)
You reasonably can't. As a society, we need to choose between individual privacy and the pervasive use of invasive cameras. Regulations can be made to protect one or the other. The US seems to be going one way, the EU another.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by UltraSane on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:13PM (#42372567)
How can you regulate the use of cameras in private company buildings or outside? Is it currently illegal for a EU company to have every square foot of a office building covered by 2 cameras and have a sophisticated analytics program that records exactly where every employee is at any time and what they are likely doing?
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by itishappy on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:33PM (#42373115)
Pass and enforce regulations? For instance, it's illegal in the US to put a security camera facing directly into your neighbors bedroom. In you office example, I suspect they have at least the same protections we have in the US about recording in bathrooms.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by UltraSane on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @10:48AM (#42388940)
But there is a legitimate public safety argument for some level of surveillance so it is a very tricky balance to get right.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by gosub100 on Monday December 09, 2024 @02:30PM (#42369588)
Merely recording is a necessary, but not sufficient condition to invasion of privacy.
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by Mashimo on Monday December 09, 2024 @06:21AM (#42365101)
I actually have, by law even :)
Re:How Much Do I Need to Change My Face to Avoid Facial Reco... by unethical_ban on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:34AM (#42366548)
The ease of mass surveillance and analysis/tracking makes it worse. Machine powered automatic analysis and tracking is more than just video recording. I hope that difference is apparent.