News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by simonw on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:58PM (#42111534)
This is great. I particularly liked this observation:

> Shipping is a social construct within a company. Concretely, that means that a project is shipped when the important people at your company believe it is shipped.

A lot of the ideas in here resonated with me a lot. This is the kind of article I wish I'd read before I spent a few years leading an engineering team at a medium-sized tech company!

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by didibus on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:32PM (#42111738)
Ya, I think this is a great insight. In today's world, code is not released as a versioned artifact sold on a disc or downloaded. The idea of "shipping" is fuzzy. You might be 100% in production with some change and it could still leave edge case, deficiencies, etc. You can decide to address them now or later. And it's all just perception. You can say it's good enough, we shipped, let's forget about this whole thing and move to another. Or you can keep ironing out the quirks.

I've "shipped" things in the past that were turned on to less than 1% of the time, and we left it at that, and moved on to other things. It was considered "shipped". Everyone was worried to increase it to beyond 1%, so we all patted ourselves in the back for the great launch and went to work on other things.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by bigiain on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @01:53AM (#42113384)
There was always something intensely satisfying about walking into some retail store and seeing boxes on the shelf containing CDs with software I'd written.

(On the flip side, there was that one time we had to destroy 5,000 CDs because they had a Quicktime Autostart virus on them...)

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by OnlyMortal on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:18AM (#42113714)
Heh. I can relate to seeing your product on a shelf.

I recall seeing IBM ViaVoice X on shelves a Circuit City. It was rather an ego trip.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by Aeolun on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:10AM (#42114572)
Sometimes it’s odd to realize there’s people that can say this while simultaneously not being my grandfather. There’s a whole period of computer history I skipped.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by bigiain on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:01PM (#42120841)
FWIW, I'm 57 soon. Old enough that I could totally be some random HN poster's grandfather...
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by levysoft on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:33AM (#42124826)
I bought it back in 1998 and started using it right away... it truly felt like the future!
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by OnlyMortal on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @02:13PM (#42128943)
:-) I worked in the first OSX version. I did the AppKit UI being one of the few on the planet who had a NeXT background.

It came with a UK language model as the US model didn’t recognise my accent.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by NBJack on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:17PM (#42111629)
This is the reality. And if you happen to be in an environment with less cooperative folks, get your requirements to ship in writing, agreed upon, and as up front as possible. Hold them to it. Otherwise, it just opens you up for nitpicking, and in some cases goalkeeping, by folks whom end up delaying your shipping.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by anshulbhide on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:13PM (#42112453)
IMO most engineers completely forget or don't appreciate the importance of optics, especially when working with non-technical founders or management.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by klabb3 on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:51PM (#42112639)
Yes but otoh that might be more of a “I refuse to accept a culture of optics on principle” kinda situation, rather than not understanding it. I liked the post because it’s honest and doesn’t put a value judgment on things, just explains how it works. It’s up to each and everyone to act accordingly, and one of those actions is to not participate in the lunacy that often arises in the higher echelons. Many people are fine keeping their integrity, mostly left alone to code, avoiding social deception games at the expense of not being promoted out of what they fell in love with in the first place. People are just different.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by superhuzza on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:27AM (#42126353)
Refusing to accept a culture of optics is tantamount to not understanding optics though. The reality is that if you work on any kind of product, optics do matter - the perception of something working is often just as important as it actually working.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by Hasu on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:33AM (#42126398)
It can't possibly be "just as important" - in some cases, I will accept "almost as important", but any situation where the optics are "it works" and the reality is "it doesn't work" is eventually going to come crashing down on someone's head.

If it doesn't need to work, then it doesn't matter and the optics also don't matter. Of course, it might be more important for your promotion that the optics are correct, no matter what the ground reality is, and the crash could come down on someone else's head instead of yours, but in this scenario someone who is against a culture of optics rather has a point.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tharkun__ on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:00PM (#42133051)
Definitely just as important.

If you shipped and nobody important enough knows, then you haven't shipped in the eyes of the most important people.

I'm the first person to agree with you that it sucks that optics are important. But they are. You can definitely ship shit with great optics and get a promotion and be far away before that shit hits the fan.

But if you ship the greatest thing since sliced bread and nobody notices, then you might as well not have shipped at all.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by klabb3 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @05:15PM (#42141786)
Lots of things are popularity contests. It’s very difficult to escape when you’re in it, but they always fizzle out, leaving remarkably little behind. Your promotion at Enron has no meaning today, but at least the little string parsing library you wrote may still be in use and someone is happy about it, decades later.

The point is that your impact isn’t defined by a McKinsey trained head of HR who gamified a career ladder for you, or the opinion of “important people”. In fact, what impact means depends on where and (crucially) when you measure it.

Some professions have longer reward cycles than a human lifetime. Great writers, artists and thinkers are often recognized posthumously. Doesn’t mean everyone should write poems, but we shouldn’t exacerbate a culture where you’re useless if you can’t charm your closest mediocre middle manager. Life is more.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tharkun__ on Thursday November 14, 2024 @09:58PM (#42143596)
Oh absolutely agreed on lots of things being popularity contests. And I don't like that fact either.

It's still important unfortunately.

Your promotion at Enron still has meaning today because it bumped you up the career ladder early on in your career and your next job after that was a step up from that etc. 20 years of elevated salary because you climbed the career ladder early adds up to real dollars in your investment accounts.

Do I like it? Absolutely not and I am trying to stay at the level I'm at right now for as long as I possibly can, because my job is not entirely a popularity contest and still has real good software engineering and actually building software that real people use and love in it. If I "climbed" any further all day every day would be a popularity contest. But I do recognize that being allowed to continue building that software requires (as in "it's important") to take part in some of these popularity contests.

(talking paid work wise here - if you're OK to live in a basement doing meaningful open source work that will outlive you for the rest of your life and it makes you happy, then power to you - not most people's reality)

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by klabb3 on Saturday November 16, 2024 @09:36AM (#42156654)
I see your point, and I agree. I think it comes down to weighing strategy, tactics and values. Values can really only have impact once you have some form of influence. And tactics can be necessary to establish yourself, even more so in a world increasingly governed by micro-algorithmic engagement and short termism. But it can also be dangerous in the sense of perpetuating values you don’t agree with, not least within yourself - a tactical win but a strategic failure. Some people pull it off - like Dave Chappelle, getting “fuck you money” early and staying real.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by amonith on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:07AM (#42113931)
"Appreciate" is a weird word. At least for me (not an English speaker) it has a positive connotation so with that in mind I sure hope nobody appreciates the importance of optics. The concept is dumb but it is important and we have to play the game to achieve anything.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by afandian on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:34AM (#42115024)
Appreciate has at least three tiny different meanings that I can think of.

1. To be grateful for something.

2. To fully understand something.

3. To increase in value

I’m sure there are more.

I read this as option 2.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by anshulbhide on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:57AM (#42115138)
Correct.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by amonith on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:41AM (#42115393)
Why did you read that as 2 though? Is there a context clue I'm missing or is there some grammar rule I don't know of? Honest question, I'm Polish.

For me there's a huge gap between 1 and 2 so it might cause misunderstandings when used in a sentence. I despise a lot of things I fully understand and if I said I "appreciate" them - sounds weird.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by afandian on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:23AM (#42115692)
It's heuristics, not grammar. You usually appreciate a noun or noun phrase in a transitive sentence (X appreciates Y).

Case 1: If it's something useful (e.g. 'your help', 'what you did') then it's more likely about being thankful.

This use of 'appreciate' is also a social action. You say it to make someone feel good for helping.

Case 2: If it's an abstract thing (e.g. 'the importance of', 'the difficulty of') then it's more likely you're talking about understanding.

Usually when you talk about this usage it's because the _fact_ of understanding is important to the speech act. If someone explains the law of gravity you don't say "I appreciate that", you say "I understand that". But if you fell from a height and hurt yourself you can say "I didn't appreciate the law of gravity".

Case 3: If it's intransitive and it's about money ('the car appreciated in value', 'the house appreciated in value').

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by yurishimo on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:52PM (#42123026)
As someone learning a second language as an adult, I appreciate you writing this all out!

Finding people that can explain these types of examples to new language learners can be quite difficult, even on language focused platforms/forums.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by amonith on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @03:11AM (#42123876)
It's a pity that heuristics are not mentioned in most language books or dictionaries. At least I wasn't taught any in school (10+ years ago). This should be next to the word definition.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by mmcnl on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:08PM (#42119157)
Optics are not dumb. Corporates are very noisy. It is difficult to extract the signal from the noise if you're not working on a project full-time (as most people are, except for you, the tech lead), and it will definitely not happen by accident. That's why you need to manage optics.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by amonith on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:01PM (#42120246)
I agree that they are very important but I still call it dumb in a "it's stupid that we have to do this because we suck as a human species" kind of way.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by lioeters on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:06PM (#42121846)
I think that's what the word "appreciate" is hinting at in the phrase: "most engineers..don't appreciate the importance of optics."

Optics is subjective and often superficial, a performative illusion for the sake of whoever is looking at you. But that doesn't mean it's not valuable or useful in a social context.

Here, I read the word "appreciate" to mean, to recognize the value of a thing even if you disagree with it.

For example, someone could be a pacifist and still appreciate the need for weapons for national defense. They may not agree with the means but still admit it has value and effect.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by CalRobert on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:06PM (#42119712)
Similar is "enjoy", which is almost always possible but sometimes can be used in a more... detached sense? "Perspectives in nature we rarely enjoy" as seen in The Far Side here, for instance.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/89/b2/2b/89b22b4b18dd3ed630a0...

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by dclowd9901 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:23AM (#42114015)
Weirdly, optics have never mattered at all in small or startup companies. And they manage to do pretty well, ship a lot of product and become large companies.

Maybe the problem isn’t the engineers, but the need for optics…

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by conjectures on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:36AM (#42114094)
Nah, I think optics can matter at startups too.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:56AM (#42114821)
For a lot of the ones that fail, yes.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tightbookkeeper on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:33AM (#42114074)
No organization with more than 1 person is immune from the effects of optics. If you think so, you may be blind to it.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:57AM (#42114829)
It definitely gets worse as the organisation grows. There isn't much room to hide in a five person company whereas it's hard to be seen in a 5000 person organisation.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by jimbokun on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:17PM (#42119256)
In that case it's the optics with the customers that matter.

Which can be more rewarding to satisfy than the optics of just management. But still needs to be managed appropriately.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by brundolf on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @06:06PM (#42131221)
It's a matter of scale. "Optics" (as a separate concern) don't matter at orgs that are small enough that everyone can see everything (and/or has full trust in the people who do). Visibility and trust don't scale, hence the necessary evil of pageantry
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by amiljkovic on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:18AM (#42116118)
What is optics??
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by kridsdale1 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:19PM (#42119278)
The emotional perception of the quality of you, the worker, in the eyes of the leadership who pays you. It is distinct from your true value and contributions. It is maximized by you optimizing the visibility of things that boost reputation and minimizing the visibility of embarrassing things.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by rglynn on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:10PM (#42122510)
It's a term that has been adopted to sound more professional than "keeping up appearances" which is an age-old concept. It is about how things are/will be perceived by others, rather than the truth of the matter.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by jrh3 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:18AM (#42126284)
Perception is reality. (For better or worse.)
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by dsr_ on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:27PM (#42121129)
I wear glasses, so I appreciate the importance of optics every day.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by benreesman on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:29AM (#42113049)
This is a reasonably good if somewhat depressing blog post about how to do well in the performance cycle at a big company. Now part of that is shipping product, but that’s pretty clearly of secondary concern for the author.

It sounds to me like this person is good at getting paid no matter how it goes for the shareholders or the rest of the team.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by tdb7893 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @01:37AM (#42113320)
When I worked at a big company I did a lot of mentoring and the dissonance between what people I mentored thought was the "right thing to do" and what it seemed like the organization wanted them to do (enforced via performance reviews or other mechanisms) was a huge hurdle for new engineers. Especially early in your career you're just one engineer in a huge org and most people eventually decide it's easier to go with the flow than fight against it (or they leave) but it was a struggle for people to get there.

This post seems the logical conclusion of that. Why spend your time and stress doing work that your boss doesn't appreciate? Just give them what they want, it's their job to align that with greater organizational goals.

All this being said I did not love working at a big company, partially for these exact reasons.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by crabbone on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:23AM (#42116183)
Not sure if / who am I quoting, but this thought isn't my for sure: the more layers of management the company has, the more times the incentives are inverted between the planning at the very top and the implementation at the very bottom.

It does often feel like Chinese whispers to the people at the very bottom: the orders make no sense whatsoever due to the distortion coming from the middle management. And, I totally agree with your assessment that OP sounds kind of sarcastic about the whole thing. Also the way they phrase it suggests it: it's not even what your boss wants, it's what's going to make your boss happy (if the boss is an idiot, they might want things that will end up making them feel sad, but that only makes your job harder as now you should also anticipate what would actually make them feel happy rather than dully following their advice.)

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by baxtr on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:45AM (#42113115)
I think you’re describing any person’s life within a larger social construct.

I don’t see how you can achieve any meaningful goal without collaborating with people in power.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by 0xpgm on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:22AM (#42114002)
> I don’t see how you can achieve any meaningful goal without collaborating with people in power.

Depends on how you define meaningful. Raising happy & healthy kids, helping someone in need etc, can be meaningful to many people, but don't require 'collaborating with people in power'.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by idra on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:39AM (#42114105)
But it does. At the very least, you need to keep paying off the people in power and do everything within the framework of their rules, otherwise you’re in trouble
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by Aeolun on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:05AM (#42114548)
I’m fairly certain you can go live somewhere off-grid and do everything however you want.

It’s only a tradeoff if you also want all the convenience of modern society.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by xenocratus on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:20AM (#42114629)
I'm fairly certain statistically you can't, because you need a place to go do that, the skills to pull it off, and have a family that's not only willing but actively supporting it, otherwise when the reality kicks in everything _will_ fall apart. Either that or some of you die. But hey, technically you'd be correct in that case.

Or maybe I just have a gloomy view of what "living off the grid" looks like :] I'll just leave this [1] here, regarding that.

[1] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/this-russian-family-l...

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by lioeters on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:03AM (#42115524)
> live somewhere off-grid

That's the thing, the grid covers everyone everywhere now. There is no escape from the planet of the apes.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by sfn42 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:42AM (#42126009)
Not really. It's just that people don't realize how much they rely on modern society. You could go all Primitive Technology and go live in a mud hut somewhere or whatever, nobody's forcing you to buy toothpaste and electricity and all that stuff.

The problem is that sucks, so people don't actually want to live off grid. They just want to not work but also get the benefits of modern society.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by gaussiandistro on Thursday November 14, 2024 @06:05AM (#42135052)
A human can't survive without somehow exploiting the resources in their environment, at minimum you need a certain amount of baseline calories from either harvesting or hunting food. Do you think there is a square inch of arable land, areas suitable for livestock, or regions with plentiful wild fruits and animals, which is not currently claimed by some existing power structure who already claims exclusive rights over the exploitation of those resources and with whom you would need to negotiate with in order to access?

The issue isn't merely that you give up the benefits of modernity, the issue is that industrialized states and corporations have spent the last 200 or so years claiming every resource in the world as their property- that's why you see living off the grid as being in a "mud hut" or something, the resources left unclaimed are the ones that weren't valuable enough for someone to snag them already!

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by sfn42 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @07:04AM (#42135410)
I don't disagree with you on that, but the reason I said mud hut is because I was taking the off grid thing very literally - you don't have an axe to build a log cabin.

I imagine a motivated individual could find some remote place where they could live undisturbed for a long time but without owning the land there's no guarantee you won't be chased off eventually.

But my main point is that's all kind of irrelevant because no one really wants to live that way. They want a somewhat modern home and access to utilities and vehicles and fuel and medicine and so on. They just don't want to pay taxes. They want to have the cake and eat it too.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by red-iron-pine on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:28AM (#42115720)
there is no "off grid", and even then those homesteaders aren't building houses themselves with tools they crafted themselves -- they're 100% dependent on tools and skills they learned in society.

even remote and rural they're often still trucking into town weekly for gas and groceries.

source: in laws in rural AB tried homesteading off the grid. all it meant was that their kid was homeschooled and can't do multiplication and they learned how difficult farming is.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by mbesto on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:32AM (#42115329)
> but don't require 'collaborating with people in power'.

You missed this qualifier: "person’s life within a larger social construct."

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by InDubioProRubio on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:15AM (#42113695)
Now imagine, the product being 50 % income generator at start, but a liability generator of support cost in the long run. Means, you launch the product and its success kills you over time as a bloated giant. All we ever had todo, to be more succesfull, was sell more of the product... famous last words
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:55AM (#42113868)
do you have an example of this scenario? I mean reading it, sounds true but then support is mostly determined by the company's willingness to support (outside of some legal requirements) and so I find it actually difficult to imagine where selling more of the product is a great income generator but the support actually kills you (destroys company) in the long run.

In software at least support costs can be decreased by fixing bugs or identifying high support low value features.

So - I would like to see a company that actually got killed by support costs but was doing good from product sales.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by ben_w on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:27AM (#42114046)
I think most social media counts as such, with the specific example in my head of Twitter only making a profit two years before Musk bought it, cut it to the bone, and increased its legal troubles.

Income starts off proportional to number of users and how much they use it.

Support depends on how many people are anywhere between unpleasant and unlawful.

"Unpleasant" is like weeds, if you're not keeping up they take over and keeping up becomes harder.

"Unlawful" can suddenly get a lot more complex when other legal jurisdictions notice you and (sometimes with or without changing the law because of you) remind you that anyone operating in their jurisdiction must follow their laws and not whichever one you put in your T&C — constitutionally guaranteed freedom of speech in one country can be constitutionally unlawful speech in another.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by anon7000 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @02:53AM (#42113612)
I mean, being misaligned with company leadership is a great way to loose your job. I worked at a medium sized company which is known for having a good culture. Everyone was kind & helpful, there was loads of autonomy, never any kind of layoffs.

At some point, a team I worked closely with got unexpectedly fired. The entire team, including manager, just gone one day. Not for financial reasons, but because they were “not performing well.” (There were multiple people on the team who had consistently good performance reviews.)

I spent a fair amount of time trying to figure out why that happened. Obviously if that could happen to them (fired despite good feedback), it could happen to anyone.

As far as I could tell, it’s because the CEO or CTO didn’t think the type of work they were doing was worth doing, and also didn’t think they were making a difference.

It’s good to be a self-starter, to advocate for best practices, and to keep users in mind. But at the end of the day, if that doesn’t fit into what your bosses expect from you, you’re done.

That’s why it’s important to communicate with stakeholders. Your boss needs to understand why spending time on preventative maintenance pays dividends on the long run. You can’t spend 75% of your time on stuff that doesn't look productive (which is subjective) and also not be proactive in being on the same page as your stakeholders about what’s important. At some point, they’ll get confused about what you’re actually doing day to day, and your job’s on the line.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by rytis on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:55AM (#42113869)
> As far as I could tell, it’s because the CEO or CTO didn’t think the type of work they were doing was worth doing, and also didn’t think they were making a difference.

So the CEO/CTO weren't able to express their concerns and priorities and instead just fired the whole team?

If, as you say, there were no financial reasons, then the team could've been re-purposed to do more meaningful (at least in CEO/CTO eyes) work.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by smugglerFlynn on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:34AM (#42114372)
You are coming from a rational position with the focus on optimization. Large organizations are not rational, and rarely optimal.

Executive backlogs are so deep that purposefully re-fitting whole team to another job will never end up on the top list. You might see sometimes organization will rehire a whole new team with exact same skillset, and set them to do similar tasks. It happens because execs know how to setup things from scratch quickly, but running a re-fit is a custom project that requires problem solving and large amount of exec drive, and exec resources are extremely scarce and expensive.

From the outside this will seem totally irrational and suboptimal, not to mention unfair. But that's how large orgs operate.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by d0gsg0w00f on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:30AM (#42114673)
IME working as a team in large companies is dangerously entrepreneurial. What I mean is that there is loose guidance on what needs solving and then it's up to you to figure out how to solve using what you have. If you stray from the original problem too far, you'd better be good at explaining why. It's dangerous because there's a lot of autonomy with the illusion of security.

Keep the original problem in mind always. Keep your head up looking out for competitor teams who might be solving your problem. Know them, align with them.

If you show up on an exec budget spreadsheet and the exec can't defend your value, then you're toast (or transferred).

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by yosefk on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:55AM (#42114473)
He is probably good at getting paid and getting credit for what he does, but he would need to be good at it to do any good for any other stakeholder, even more than he would need it to be a happy parasite inside the company. We don't know from the text if he cares about benefitting other stakeholders; I would bet that he cares more than average or he would not openly admit various unsavory facts about how things actually work - there's nothing in it for him to be open about it and the typical bigco parasite is unlikely to be open about these things and instead will repeat the party line about the place being a perfect meritocracy.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by d0gsg0w00f on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:21AM (#42114635)
I did not get that from TFA. I interpreted it as "know your customers and communicate with them". This applies to everything in life. It's especially relevant in big companies because it's easy to forget that you are forgettable.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by jrochkind1 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:35AM (#42115778)
I mean, if by "customers" you mean "the important people at your company".

> Concretely, that means that a project is shipped when the important people at your company believe it is shipped. If you deploy your system, but your manager or VP or CEO is very unhappy with it, you did not ship.

> If you ship something users hate and makes no money, but your leadership team is happy, you still shipped. You can feel any way you like about that, but it’s true. If you don’t like it, you should probably go work for companies that really care how happy their users are.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by ryandrake on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @01:39PM (#42118313)
> I mean, if by "customers" you mean "the important people at your company".

I think that's exactly OP's (and TFA's) point: If you're working in most medium sized to large sized companies, just look at your org chart. Your manager, their manager, their manager's manager, and so on up to the CEO: Those are your customers. They are the ones that decide your comp, they are the ones that set your priorities and goals, they are the ones who are ultimately accountable when you fail or succeed. Your job is to deliver what they want. It's definitely a hard pill to swallow if you still have that idealistic view that you're working for end users.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by Aachen on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @02:24AM (#42123668)
You're not wrong. I think the issue people have with the post is that it disguises, to exaggerate a little, bootlicking with shipping. The recommendations are good for the reasons you mentioned, but job security or compensation maximisation are not the same as "how to ship things". If that happens to be the thing you do, it's a means to an end (to demonstrate you do your job well) but that's not the goal of shipping things by itself

But then, definition discrepancies are the origin of at least half the disagreements

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by consteval on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:27PM (#42119377)
> It sounds to me like this person is good at getting paid no matter how it goes for the shareholders or the rest of the team

The trouble is that your personal influence is remarkably small in most workplaces. Ultimately, you can't change much, and what you can change takes a lot of effort. It often requires being bullish, which can introduce risk to your job.

Sometimes, the choices are as follows: either have the big idea in mind and always strive for the best, sacrificing your mental health, making enemies, and potentially losing your job. Or, keeping your head down and following orders, being a perfect little sailor leading your ship towards the iceberg.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by neilv on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @01:27AM (#42113286)
Note that it can get trickier than it sounds. (Well, I don't know about big tech, but at least for medium and smaller.)

You need to figure out who the "important people" are, and somehow make sure that they understand and buy into the product definition, delivery dates, etc.

Even if they're 3 levels up from you, and you can't normally interface directly with them, try to find a way to double-check that all the "important people" are on the same page.

Organizational dysfunction happens, and you have to succeed despite that possibility.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by scott_w on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @01:40AM (#42113332)
Same here. What you highlighted makes a lot of sense to me and it’s something that happens at every company size.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by h1fra on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:01AM (#42113895)
Yes. Unfortunately, it comes with a side effect, you will see leadership use this to kill projects they don't like by not never mentioning them until people think it's a failure.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by jimbokun on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:18PM (#42119269)
If you are working on something the people deciding on the size of your paycheck want to kill, time to find a new project or a new company. Why fight a battle you're sure to lose?
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by bluGill on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:48AM (#42126505)
If only you could figure that out ahead of time. I've been on projects that were killed with no notice anyone could see even in hindsight. I've been on important projects that senior leaders decided to out source my job to China and my boss was forced to let me go. I've seen budgets run dry many times and important projects got killed/cut with no notice (sometimes there are signs that but you think your project is important enough to escape the cuts until it isn't). Sometimes you are doing working everyone tells you is critical the day before they show you out the door.

I've also seen people make careers out of taking over projects cut for the above reasons as customers still demand support. I've seen many downturns where my project was important enough to not be cut.

I've seen many downturns where my project had massive cuts, but I personally was not the person cut. Most often projects are not killed outright, instead they go through a long down spiral (not always, but typically) and you can make a lot of money being the expert on a product that is making money if you are able to hang on. Someone needs to leave as there isn't the budget to pay everyone, but that someone need not be you. Often these projects pay very nicely for working 9-5 with no pressure to do overtime.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by realaleris149 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @02:03AM (#42133755)
> Sometimes you are doing working everyone tells you is critical the day before they show you out the door.

I know this may appear so but the signs are there. We only want this to be true so we do not see it.

I've been in a similar situation where all we were seeing was high pressure to deliver something. This made it appear that is because the project is important. But the underlying reason was that if we didn't, the project would be dropped. Which they did.

A project may be critical but even more so is to be in a certain time frame and budget, otherwise the project doesn't have a reason to exist any more. But until that moment is still very important because, at the very least because there was a lot of investment into it.

Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by iknownthing on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:02AM (#42115518)
In my experience, most things in large companies are social constructs. Good things are good because they were decided to be good, bad things are bad because they were decided to be bad. Very rarely are they driven by actual metrics.
Re:How I ship projects at big tech companies by enugu on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:14AM (#42116780)
There is a tendency here to pattern match the advice in this article with frustrating experiences about office politics. But I dont see this as a post about politics.

Rather, what I got was that the spec is an incomplete description and there needs to be more inquiry into how the software is going to be used. This can require a little bit of 'going up the stack' to see how business need relates to the software requirement(single enterprise customer with a precise requirement, acquisition of new customer, software for some internal vision of CEO etc). Compare with a startup where one doesn't even have a spec and one is trying to find a product-market fit or when developers take sales calls and find new insights on how the software is actually being used.

A completely broken spec is indeed a failure in management process. But, in general, it helps a library developer to think beyond a library spec and see how it is being used.