Perhaps many small, poorly run hospitals have consolidated into a handful of large, poorly run hospitals. Still, that's no excuse to let Kaiser Permanente generate billions tax free.
MSOs are organized as LLCs, not 501c3 organizations.
The kinds of hospital networks that are run as 501c3s would be something like a CommonSpirit Health, Advent Health, UPMC, Mass Gen Brigham, etc.
> Perhaps many small, poorly run hospitals have consolidated into a handful of large, poorly run hospitals
Kinda. That's how CommonSpirit Health came to be, except backend management is basically centralized.
Focusing on profit is fundamentally sound unless you’re a monopoly, which tend to be when Gov sticks its beak into things it shouldn’t.
We’re talking about hospitals. Many areas are served by one local hospital. And where there are several, it’s typically the ambulance who decides where you go. It’s also pretty difficult to compare one hospital with another.
IMO hospitals resemble utilities where market forces aren’t enough to guarantee good service.
Don't necessarily disagree with most of your sentiment, however the vast majority of hospital patients do not arrive in an ambulance, or even through the ER.
A lot of hospital services are elective or planned (surgeries, pregnancies, etc) and for those I've found it very helpful to 'shop' for the best options.
Also, the one time I was in an ambulance, they asked which hospital I wanted my daughter transported to.
All that said, it isn't always possible or feasible to choose - but it's not because of an ambulance.
Ok, if "many areas have one hospital"... I don't think that's true at all. Most areas have multiple hospitals. Most people live in metropolitan or suburban areas.
Increasing taxes and removing alternatives is never a good deal.
"market forces aren't enough" government forces aren't enough either.
The VA is the penultimate example and I wouldn't wish that upon my worst enemy. That's where our veterans go to commit suicide in the parking lots waiting on help.
22 Veterans.
The people I know who use the VA are quite OK with it. It's not perfect but none of them would want to put up with the insanity the rest of us has to.
"it's not perfect" It's garbage and a prime example of government programs. Works for a few and fucks over the rest.
The ACA helps a few... and is built on lies - keep your plan? keep your doctor? save $2500 a year? Lies, lies, lies... a few million get help. The other 100m pay more, higher deductibles, lose their plans, lose their doctors.
But who cares about the 100m if the 1m get helped, eh?
the biggest problem is the wasted money, the lies and the people dying in the parking lots.
But who gives a f' about them eh?
The problem is the suggestion that government solutions will solve government created problems.
I have no problem admitting things can be fixed... but stuff like the unAffordable Care Act which is built on lies (Like your plan? Like your doctor? save $2500/year) is not going to solve the issues - nor is single payer, government ran solutions.
You'll never solve government created problems with government ran beauracracy.
The problem is that the conversation only focuses on the good parts of those systems and ignores the issues.
You can't have a real conversation and claim "have it better" when that may be true in parts but not in whole.
I don't claim the US system is better... or the best. But claiming that government ran or government overregulation leads to better is a lie. The VA is proof of that. the lies around the unACA is proof of that. The ever increasing prices and decreasing results due to government influence is proof of that.
Destroying what we have with something like the ACA isn't proof that government ran will be better... it's simply proof that people are willing to destroy what was working and claim that the destroyers will do a better job if only they have more money and more power.
That's like CA solving homelessness. "more money, more power and we'll solve homelessness" and there's never been more homelessness or less affordability in CA.
Paramedic here. It's typically, effectively, your insurance that dictates how we decide where you go.
If you're an acute, time-sensitive patient, then from a multitude of angles, "closest appropriate facility" makes sense.
Perhaps you dislike a hospital, or it's inconvenient, and you're not as acute or timely a patient, and your view is "I want to go to X hospital, and since I'm paying, why shouldn't I get to choose?"
As a paramedic, personally, I don't care.
However.
Your insurance does. And their perspective (sometimes rightly, and quite regularly wrongly) is that if you are well enough to bypass a hospital or multiple hospitals en route to a "chosen" facility, then did you need the ambulance? And if you didn't need it, why are "they" paying for it? And they can, and absolutely will, kick bills back to the ambulance company with a "please justify why an EMS transport was required versus advising POV (privately owned vehicle) transport or physician followup".
What they want to see happen, and what generally is actually the better option, as a provider is "we will go to the closest facility where they will assess and stabilize you as needed. if you then wish to be -transferred- to your facility of choice, they will organize that" (and, since the insurance criteria and questions are met, and a physician ordered the EMS transport, you should be covered). Though it is certainly less "convenient" for you.
Even beyond that, the area I'm in we have two hospitals. One is a Level 2 Trauma Center, one is a Level 3, but they're mostly comparable except for, well, acute trauma. We as providers will have a solid perspective of patient load in the ED of those hospitals, so I might ASK, not TELL you, hey, we might want to go to Hospital B, not A. And occasionally, though diversion is a convenience, not a concept under EMTALA (we can still absolutely show up at the ED with a patient even if they're "on divert"), some of the facilities here will round-robin to balance patient loads.
(Also, don't start me on Certificates of Need, where new hospitals essentially have to get the permission of existing hospitals in the area before they can open - essentially, "will you be okay if we take patients away from you"...)
The "non-profit" organizations are given tax-exempt status because they are centered around providing a public or social benefit, they explicitly should not be focused on providing a profit to their owners.
In my opinion the majority of people can't afford to choose their hospital. Often it's the one that is within their means to travel and provides the service they require, regardless of the quality of their services. And, of course, after a serious accident you end up wherever the ambulance brings you.
It's the idea that a comment that supports the basic foundation of the organization who run this board gets so severely downvoted.
I'm justing calling out how ironic it is.
The language you've chosen is baldly ideological and leaaves no room for good faith discussion.
If a sandwich shop produces bad sandwiches then eventually people stop buying them and shop around. This doesn't work with hospitals. In the worst case, dead people can't shop around.
This isn't a discretionary purchase, let's stop pretending one can go shopping for care.
Ironically when they get bought out by PE they lose their tax exempt status, so that's kinda solving the problem.
As a nonprofit, they cannot distribute those profits to shareholders. That's the whole point.
They're obligated to reinvest those profits back into the business, such as by developing new facilities, upgrading older facilities, and so on.
Ironically, if you forcefully revoked the nonprofit status you'd actually open the door for those profits to go to shareholders instead.
But can I buy a non-profit hospital and force them to start buying syringes from my for-profit syringe company at a 1000% markup?
The owners of the kindergarten hire the daily manager. They hire out the building itself to the kindergarten, as well as HR, accounting services etc. The prices are not 1000% market rate but certainly not competitive. By controlling the daily manager they make sure the kindergarten doesn't try to find better deals.
Thus the kindergartens make no profit, yet the owners can extract a decent profit regardless.
Pretty sure this idea was imported, and not something unique here.
You do not buy a syringe for a 1000x markup. You stand up a group purchasing organization (GPO) as a subsidiary and spin off your entire procurement department to it. You have your negotiating team accept nominal trade discounts off catalog prices, and instead prioritize lump-sum off invoice rebates at various spending thresholds. So while you previously got a $50 syringe discounted to $25 from a supplier, now your group purchasing subsidiary is paying nominally less than ~$50 per syringe but recieving a lump sum rebate against accounts payable from a supplier equivalent to $25 per syringe based on your primary client's expected spending volume (which is pretty predictable considering your former procurement department turned subsidiary has been working with this supplier for ages).
The group purchasing subsidiary then adds a nominal markup of their supply catalog, say 20% or so. So that $50 syringe is sold to the hospital for $60. A 20% markup is considered fair and reasonable so your auditors give it their blessing. Suddenly the hosital is paying $35 more per syringe but the supplier is still getting the same $25 they always have. You also sign up another local hospital to join the GPO and negotiate even higher rebate thresholds. Both hospitals auditors and lawyers point to the industry wide practice of GPOs and their perceived benefits, making plausible enough defenses against both criminal and civil complaints. The executive team of the GPO that came over from their parent orgs and orchestrated this whole thing get generous (but fair market rate) employment contracts and benefits that just happen to absorb the maojrity of that $35 per syringe profit so very little ends up bubbling back up to the non-profit parent entities.
Do the same thing with selling your real estate to a real estate holding company, which leases it back to you at market rates (that just keep going up and up). Do the same with your nurses – spin up a nursing staffing company and contract all your nurse staffing through it. Same with physicians – spin off any directly employed physicians into a physician staffing company and conmtract with them for services.
As long as you follow the appropriate corporate formalities, you suddenly have a ton of knobs you can turn to engineer any particular operating margin you want your healthcare system to be perceived as having. This isn't limited to hospital systems, but with the prevalent level of inefficient middlemen entities that already exist in the US healthcare system and contribute to runaway costs, it's pretty damn easy to throw a few of your own into the mix in a manner that passes legal scrutinty around self-dealing. There are also plenty of liability-related reasons to justify such setups as well, so it's not purely a shift around profits from your tax-exempt non-profit entity.
And insurers don't actually care much at all about any of this. As they're required to pay out 80% of premiums as claims and only allowed 20% for administrative expenses and profits, the easiest way to increase profits is for claims to increase (and subsequently allowing the absolute value of that 20% piece to grow). If hospital charges go up across the board because of these sorts of shenanigans, that's as much a boon to the insurers paying out as it is to whatever lucky winners are siphoning off the profits from those related entity subsidiaries.
[1] https://www.aeaweb.org/research/regulating-health-insurers-a...
i mean look at sam altman, using openai funds for what was originally a NONPROFIT, to fund areas with conflicts of interests.
At least when it's for profit it's out in the open.
In practice, there is a shared understanding what acting in the public interest means in that particular society. Laws can also provide a non-exhaustive list of examples to clarify the meaning.
No there isn't lol. Half of society thinks promoting one political party is in the public interest, the other half thinks promoting the other one is. Same for religions, same for handling unwanted pregnancies, same for education...
What you say about the average income of theater audience sounds very foreign to me. I guess that elitist theater is the only form that remains viable when it has to rely on the market and charitable donations.
When I was a kid, theater was something you went to on a school excursion every year or so. It wasn't my thing, but some of my friends got interested in it. Later in the university, our student union had a semi-professional theater group that had become a national institution. Many student organizations had hobbyist theater groups. Even students of science started one shortly after I graduated. And before my time, socialist theater used to be a big thing. But that was when socialism meant actual socialism and primarily appealed to the working class.
Credit unions (and other US 501c3 organizations) do not exist to make a profit, and any income they have in excess of expenses is reinvested. There are no dividends.
These are two utterly different sorts of things.
You gave a specific legal definition in a single jurisdiction. It does not match the definition in many other jurisdictions or the intuitive understanding many people have.
From my perspective, there is no fundamental difference between an ordinary company distributing its profits as dividends, an employee-owned company distributing profits as higher wages or bonuses, and a coop distributing its profits by providing better/cheaper services to its members. They are all for-profit businesses. Only the mechanisms of profit distribution are different.
A company that exists to make money for its owners, who do not materially participate in the operations of the company, is (for me) substantively and qualitatively different from worked-owned coops, consumer-owned coops, credit unions etc.
I'd be interested in a jurisdiction that does not make this distinction.
But this reminds me ... I think that this conversation has not paid enough attention to the difference between the legal sense of a non-profit (in the USA, a 501c3 is the main classification, though there are others) and the colloquial sense (such as a credit union).
In the USA, you cannot be a 501c3 and also a credit union, for example. or a consumer owned cooperative. Nevertheless, people will sometimes refer to such organizations as "not for profit".
I think there's less difference between the USA and Finland than we've been suggesting.
A lot of non-profits funnel the "income they have in excess of expenses" to their execs or friends of the execs who provide business services. They don't reinvest or give to charity.
But it is not the same problem profits being distributed to owners who do not materially participate in the operations of the company.
Problem with this (in all kinds of contexts) is that it is trivially easy for any company to have zero profit.
Just give out all the profit as bonuses to execs and done, zero profit.
Or in cases where there is some oversight that makes it look bad, just hire a handful of consulting companies (just by random chance owned by friends and family of the execs) to do some highly overpriced work and get rid of the "profit" that way while still funneling the money back to them.
It gets taxed as personal income so where is the problem? Even if the execs are located in Georgia where dividends and stock appreciation count as foreign source income and remain untaxed, the bonus is considered to have been earned in Georgia and is taxed (at a low rate).
The thread was about non-profits. So it's a way to run a non-profit that meets the letter of the law but keeps raking in enourmous profits by shifting them elsewhere.
There are other scenarios as well where this is abused. For instance regulated corporations that are supposed to have a cap on profits in an attempt to control prices. But that fails, because they can raise prices infinitely and just shift the profits elsewhere.
> This is a policy aim of the government, both due to the economic impacts and because most residents being banked is core to orderly provision of benefits, taxation, and other government functions. A bank branch is a retail point-of-presence for the SSA getting funds to a pensioner, for the IRS collecting payroll taxes, and for the DEA interdicting fentanyl, staffed and funded by the private sector.
From the excellent blog [1] that everyone interested in how the financial system operates should read.
[1] https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/community-banking-and...
Both are entirely motivated by money; one just is overt about it.
Everyone is all about making the most money in the fastest way possible and few truly give a hoot about the people they use to achieve the goals.
Meanwhile, not-for-profit entities like credit unions don't need to justify not making an extra few billion dollars this year compared to last year, meaning they're less likely to make customer-hostile moves for their own sakes.
WETA (the public TV station) paid Sharon Percy Rockefeller $855,000 in 2022. The 12 highest paid employees all made more than $300,000. Maybe they are all "worth it" but how could you prove that WETA wouldn't function just as well at median salaries for everyone?
https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/530242992_202206_990_... (page 71)
Strange example to use.
I bought a 600$ fanless pc. It runs Linux. I run apps on it.
I bought a 600$ iPhone. It runs iOS. I run apps on it.
I haven’t paid a cent more than the original cost for each product. From an economical viewpoint they are the same.
I found this page that seems to agree- https://www.definitivehc.com/resources/healthcare-insights/h...
That shows a negative median operating margin for the last 5 years. How can an industry carry on losing money like this? This must be only part of the story, right?
The answer is hospitals target negative operating margins to meet various rules-- even though their "surplus" (ie profit) isn't taxed, it has to be near-0 to maintain non profit status. And, besides the normal games of revenue timing and amortization, they expense profitable activities to related parties.
Not all networks are for-profit.
By merging into larger networks, you allow hospital networks to consolidate the very expensive back-office processes like billing, insurance, IT, procurement, staffing, etc.
All the intermediate "glue" needed for medical care has grown expensive due to either compliance or general profiteering, which forced consolidation in order to leverage economies of scale.
This is why both for-profit and non-profit networks have been increasingly merging.
If these functions in society receive public funding, are of public interest, there should not be any way it’s main objective is to create finacial profit.
Economies of scale. When an industry faces headwinds, characterised by broad-based low or negative operating margins, the standard move is consolidation.
> More than half (55 percent) of all the income generated by 501(c)(3) organizations comes from tax-exempt hospitals and health-care plans.
They can carry on losing money because they are often charities. Isn't a 0% or less margin what most people would naively expect for a charity?
Am a paramedic. All of the ED physicians in the Level 2 Trauma Center I take most patients to are not employed by the hospital, but by a collective called "XYZ Emergency Medical Providers". The hospital then (I don't know these details) contracts with the collective. I also believe, very similar to a union, that if the hospital wishes to hire a new provider, they may handle all the interviewing, but ask for the collective to hire them.
Hospitals loose money on many procedures while making some money back on others.
There is also costs around staffing. For example, nursing schools aren't producing the growing number of nurses needed. Supply and demand kicks in.
That's just lazy and ignorant. This falls into the please read the relevant material on wikipedia category.
The only thing making them pay tax will do is create an accounting nuisance where they drive profits and thus taxes to zero.
(Although, separately, this is what IKEA does but they setup an extremely intricate multinational structure to achieve this, and this is what Amazon does, but that required heavy re-investment which only worked because the markets trusted the reinvestment would eventually be profitable and therefore invested in AMZN despite it not showing profits).
They’d have to do it by paying salaries or buying products, etc all of which are also taxed, and usually at rates higher than taxes on profits.
How does non profits spending money inefficiently to burn revenue help society?
"In each year from 2014 to 2018, about half of all large corporations had no federal income tax liability."
There are some technical for-profit companies that effectively drive profit to zero and the shareholders don't care, because that was the purpose.
https://www.stock-analysis-on.net/NASDAQ/Company/Amazoncom-I...
See Amazon v Walmart net profit margin 1999 to 2018 graph.
https://mgmresearch.com/amazon-vs-walmart-revenues-and-profi...
They are operating as non-profits, as defined by the IRS code and the law?
"Athletic associations" for example includes your all your local youth sports clubs. There's a lot of activities that can be done for a charitable purpose that may be organized under 501(c)(3) and similar regulations.
Yeah a Credit Union is like a bank, but it's not a bank. It's not operated for profit.
All but the smallest non-profits all have to file an annual Form 990 which is mostly public. You can go look them up, if you're wondering what they do and how they spend their money.
If they have income that is not directly related to their charitable purpose, they are supposed to pay tax on that. According to TFA that is weakly enforced, and while that may need fixing we need to be careful that we don't throw out the baby wth the bathwater.
Then they should not have to worry about paying income taxes regardless of their classification.
Well if they can't run themselves within a budget constraint and require outside subsidy/transfers to function, they should be public services rather than private firms, for-profit or nonprofit.
Maybe it's for the best.
One notable feature of the banking system in the US is that it's relatively unconcentrated. Only three major banks hold more than 10% of deposits in the US, at which point the feds actively block bank mergers barring something exceptional, like JPMorgan Chase absorbing SVB to save it.
These hospitals are spending immensely on expansion. Just think about how every (or the one) hospital around you seemingly has all manner of offices and facilities everywhere. Many even have gyms/"wellness centers".
You don't build a gym when you are borderline bankrupt. You build a gym when you need to spend money.
Physical or occupational therapists need most of the same equipment.
A benefit to the employees.
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. If people exercise, they are typically healthier.
You only pay taxes on Profits (not Losses).
So what's the argument you're trying to make?
It's not like paying taxes would cause you to become unprofitable.
It would also incentivize local governments to encourage the growth of non-profits. Currently Cambridge's tax revenue is negatively affected by Harvard's growth...
The phenomenon that a lot of American credit unions now advertise and compete with the capital markets (for where to get money from, or where to invest it) and with interstate banks, or that farm-credit nonprofits compete with nationwide programs, is an unanticipated and relatively recent legal development (and most interstate banking holding companies themselves are only 40-50 years old - before that, they couldn't coordinate across state lines).
The wider phenomenon that it sometimes seems like "everybody with the choice to do so" is merging into the fast lane due to red tape and other incentives is partially sampling bias, but even if it's true I don't consider it to provide proof that we should get rid of any remaining slow lanes. Probably we need more specific types of slow lanes, some of which will let you switch lanes later but cost you the back taxes.
There are many different nonprofit tax code section 501 types already, but I don't think that nonprofit status itself is a very well tailored conceptual solution to answer "what kind of slow lanes are useful nowadays?"
There are many commons and cooperative options that are hard to shoehorn into 501(c)(3). It would be nice to have some social benefit activities protected from taxation even in otherwise-taxable cooperatives. While some American state legislatures have enacted a "Low Profit Limited Liability Corporation" or L3C status available, the first thing you learn about it is that it is no different in tax status from any other LLC. HM Government in the UK offers a CIC or Community Interest Company business model, and this requires all profits to be reinvested for the benefit of a geographical area designated by the enterprise, and has an asset lock so that its possessions cannot be distributed to shareholders, although there can be shares traded -- all of which might be steps in a promising direction. But again there is no tax exemption (partial or total) for which these social enterprises are specifically eligible.
Require democratic voting among a broad membership, including customers and/or employees, not a tiny board passed down among a small group of insiders.
Of all of these, I support credit unions having this status. Their members have a democratic vote.
If they want to be a religion and do good works, fine.
If they want to even mention politics from the pulpit, whether working for a candidate, advocating for or endorsing a candidate, or even organizing voting like "Souls To The Polls" (i.e., this will be politically neutral and affect both sides), then your organization is fully taxable.
Insane amounts of money is in circulation in the religious sector. If it is for good works, that is wonderful. If it is being diverted to political activities, that is not something the entire set of taxpayers should be effectively subsidizing.
The rule I'd like to see is this: A religious organization's total assets may not exceed some reasonable amount for operating costs (private jets and mansions and multi billion dollar real estate and security holdings are out). Books are audited annually and publicly posted. Work out formula that say (for example) ministers pay may not exceed some multiple of average US salary, improvements to church facilities my not exceed some amount per congregant per decade etc. It could actually be very generous and allow nice churches and plenty of charitable work and well compensated ministry without the free for all grifting we have going on right now.
You can be a business, or you can be a religion and you have to chose.
I think this may actually improve churches many of which now are simply big scammy untaxed businesses selling not much of any use.
No it isn’t. You are treating as arms’ length salaries what are in economic substance partnership distributions to de facto owners.
Removing costs from the system will only increase profits, so why pretend that increasing costs will necessarily increase prices rather than decreasing profits?
(And before anyone plays the 'nonprofit' card, a nonprofit is only nonprofit in the sense that its net income must be zero. The owners and administrators of a nonprofit can most certainly profit by it.)
That so patently false it's almost comical.
Here's one source feel free to google. It's not hard to find evidence to the contrary.
> Nonprofit executives have embarked on an acquisition spree, assembling huge systems of hospitals and physician practices to raise prices and increase profits.
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/30/opinion/hospitals-nonprof...
I was a CSAA member before I moved to New York. Every year I received a dividend check. That was cool.
The tax savings allow the Credit Unions to offer better interest rates on savings accounts than any of the local or national banks.
Credit unions in my area also keep mortgages in-house, so my interest payments end up paying salaries of local staff who shop at the same local grocers and restaurants I do. The CUs all have a half dozen brick and mortar facilities which each require local IT contractors, janitorial, groundskeeping services, and utilities. A dollar spent with them stimulates the local economy a few more times than if you sent it directly to a wall street conglomerate.
I'm not sure if tax law is the enabler for both of these distinctions but I'd hate to lose a unique local financing option to the thought that 'it's just another bank."
The median operating margins for hospitals is around 0% or some times negative. Injecting more costs into the system is only going to push prices further upward.
> The majority of tax-exempt organizations today are business-like in form and function, including credit unions, hospitals, utilities, insurance companies, universities, professional athletic associations, golf clubs, and consulting firms, to name a few.
I'm completely on board with clamping down on tax exempt status for a lot of these other businesses, though. Credit Unions are nice, but they're still just banks. Insurance companies are obviously businesses. Athletic associations, golf clubs, consulting firms -- What is even going on that allowed these to be nonprofits?