News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jadbox on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:10PM (#40742152)
Credit Unions are far more than just banks. That's like saying Apple iOS and Linux are pretty much the same. They both do have similar features, but the relationship towards the user/member is arguably different in practice. I.e. cooperative owner vs customer-to-extract.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:46PM (#40742531)
From my non-American perspective, any organization that exists to provide material benefits to its owners / members / employees / other affiliates is a for-profit organization. A non-profit should pursue public interests, and only its core activities should be tax exempt. If a non-profit operates a business, that business should pay taxes normally.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by nickff on Thursday June 20, 2024 @04:15PM (#40742861)
The problem is that there are no truly 'public' interests, there are only clusters of private interests. Going down this route would eliminate all non-profits (which I'm not entirely against).
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @04:43PM (#40743155)
And other people claim that the personal is political and that there are no truly private interests.

In practice, there is a shared understanding what acting in the public interest means in that particular society. Laws can also provide a non-exhaustive list of examples to clarify the meaning.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by lmm on Thursday June 20, 2024 @06:34PM (#40744180)
> In practice, there is a shared understanding what acting in the public interest means in that particular society

No there isn't lol. Half of society thinks promoting one political party is in the public interest, the other half thinks promoting the other one is. Same for religions, same for handling unwanted pregnancies, same for education...

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:18PM (#40744547)
Promoting a political position or a religious belief usually counts as a public interest, as that's at the core of freedom of speech and religious freedom. I've never heard anyone claiming seriously that their political party should be a tax-exempt non-profit, while the opposing party should be a for-profit corporation that has to pay taxes.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by nickff on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:23PM (#40744583)
Lots of 'Tea Party' organizations got "investigated" by the IRS, while their 'Occupy Movement' counterparts were given more leeway.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by nickff on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:56PM (#40743865)
I disagree that there is a 'shared understanding'; for instance, the latest Freakonomics podcast episode featured an interview where the subject stated that live theatre was a social good that was critical to a functioning society, and worthy of public subsidy. I like theatre, but think it's a luxury good. There are many similar 'interests'.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @06:06PM (#40743944)
It obviously depends on the society. Theatres run or subsidized by a state or a city are common. In many countries, supporting national culture is seen as one of the key functions of the government. Most people in those countries agree with that, and even those who don't generally understand that they are in the minority.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by nox101 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @08:09PM (#40744866)
Now we have to argue about "culture". I'd say, movies and net series are culture and well funded and popular with the public. No need for subsidies for unpopular "theater". Also, according to that same episode of freakonomics, average income for theater goes is $270k a year. Those fans can afford to pay for their preferred entertainment. The government does not need to subsides them.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:50PM (#40745398)
Public subsidies to movies are common, especially in countries that are not very popular in the international market. TV channels and streaming services are often required to have a certain amount of domestic content. Even video games get public subsidies.

What you say about the average income of theater audience sounds very foreign to me. I guess that elitist theater is the only form that remains viable when it has to rely on the market and charitable donations.

When I was a kid, theater was something you went to on a school excursion every year or so. It wasn't my thing, but some of my friends got interested in it. Later in the university, our student union had a semi-professional theater group that had become a national institution. Many student organizations had hobbyist theater groups. Even students of science started one shortly after I graduated. And before my time, socialist theater used to be a big thing. But that was when socialism meant actual socialism and primarily appealed to the working class.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by gopher_space on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:15PM (#40745528)
I mean I'd love to know that zero of my tax dollars support the military, which is problematic for my religion.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by _DeadFred_ on Friday June 21, 2024 @11:47AM (#40750774)
What's the median? The median excluding NYC, LA, and SF? Why is freakonomics using average? They know that's a 'manipulate public discourse' number not really a useful one, especially for something that can easily have 1 or 2 9 to 10 figure net wealth individuals in attendance.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday June 20, 2024 @04:56PM (#40743264)
"Profit" means income in excess of expenses, and in for-profit companies the profit is used either reinvested or paid to the owners as a dividend.

Credit unions (and other US 501c3 organizations) do not exist to make a profit, and any income they have in excess of expenses is reinvested. There are no dividends.

These are two utterly different sorts of things.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:10PM (#40743427)
As I said, that was my non-American perspective.

You gave a specific legal definition in a single jurisdiction. It does not match the definition in many other jurisdictions or the intuitive understanding many people have.

From my perspective, there is no fundamental difference between an ordinary company distributing its profits as dividends, an employee-owned company distributing profits as higher wages or bonuses, and a coop distributing its profits by providing better/cheaper services to its members. They are all for-profit businesses. Only the mechanisms of profit distribution are different.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:05AM (#40746036)
Then I consider your perspective flawed.

A company that exists to make money for its owners, who do not materially participate in the operations of the company, is (for me) substantively and qualitatively different from worked-owned coops, consumer-owned coops, credit unions etc.

I'd be interested in a jurisdiction that does not make this distinction.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jltsiren on Friday June 21, 2024 @02:03AM (#40746648)
My perspective was from Finland. Non-profit status there is tied to what the organization does rather than to the specific form of the organization. As a rule of thumb, if the organization competes against for-profit organizations, it's probably a for-profit organization for tax purposes. That covers most coops, including credit unions. There are of course specific rules for different types of organizations, but they don't change the big picture.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 21, 2024 @10:44AM (#40750161)
The US has a second form - the "benefit corporation" - that is based on what the organization does. It is possible to be a for-profit or not-for-profit benefit corporation, though sort of by definition almost all US not-for-profit organizations are inherently "benefit corporation" since otherwise they would likely lose their not-for-profit status.

But this reminds me ... I think that this conversation has not paid enough attention to the difference between the legal sense of a non-profit (in the USA, a 501c3 is the main classification, though there are others) and the colloquial sense (such as a credit union).

In the USA, you cannot be a 501c3 and also a credit union, for example. or a consumer owned cooperative. Nevertheless, people will sometimes refer to such organizations as "not for profit".

I think there's less difference between the USA and Finland than we've been suggesting.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by rqtwteye on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:16PM (#40743486)
"Credit unions (and other US 501c3 organizations) do not exist to make a profit, and any income they have in excess of expenses is reinvested. There are no dividends."

A lot of non-profits funnel the "income they have in excess of expenses" to their execs or friends of the execs who provide business services. They don't reinvest or give to charity.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:06AM (#40746038)
This is indeed a problem. A really big problem.

But it is not the same problem profits being distributed to owners who do not materially participate in the operations of the company.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by piperswe on Thursday June 20, 2024 @06:49PM (#40744304)
If there are no dividends, then why is my checking account called "Dividend-Bearing Checking"?
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:06AM (#40746044)
Because English is a language that allows homonyms.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by bongodongobob on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:56PM (#40743869)
I don't see the difference. Just increase what you pay your execs. Boom, you didn't make a profit.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jjav on Thursday June 20, 2024 @08:24PM (#40744933)
> "Profit" means income in excess of expenses

Problem with this (in all kinds of contexts) is that it is trivially easy for any company to have zero profit.

Just give out all the profit as bonuses to execs and done, zero profit.

Or in cases where there is some oversight that makes it look bad, just hire a handful of consulting companies (just by random chance owned by friends and family of the execs) to do some highly overpriced work and get rid of the "profit" that way while still funneling the money back to them.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by imtringued on Friday June 21, 2024 @06:48AM (#40748157)
>Just give out all the profit as bonuses to execs and done, zero profit.

It gets taxed as personal income so where is the problem? Even if the execs are located in Georgia where dividends and stock appreciation count as foreign source income and remain untaxed, the bonus is considered to have been earned in Georgia and is taxed (at a low rate).

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by jjav on Saturday June 22, 2024 @04:04PM (#40761731)
> It gets taxed as personal income so where is the problem?

The thread was about non-profits. So it's a way to run a non-profit that meets the letter of the law but keeps raking in enourmous profits by shifting them elsewhere.

There are other scenarios as well where this is abused. For instance regulated corporations that are supposed to have a cap on profits in an attempt to control prices. But that fails, because they can raise prices infinitely and just shift the profits elsewhere.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by abdullahkhalids on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:28PM (#40744620)
> Branches are not cheap to create or operate, and the large banks concentrate them in densely populated areas with relatively wealthy customers and businesses nearby. Community banks are willing to take worse economics to have branches in places where the large banks don’t; this keeps those places tied to the national financial system.

> This is a policy aim of the government, both due to the economic impacts and because most residents being banked is core to orderly provision of benefits, taxation, and other government functions. A bank branch is a retail point-of-presence for the SSA getting funds to a pensioner, for the IRS collecting payroll taxes, and for the DEA interdicting fentanyl, staffed and funded by the private sector.

From the excellent blog [1] that everyone interested in how the financial system operates should read.

[1] https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/community-banking-and...

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by snowpid on Friday June 21, 2024 @08:52AM (#40749089)
In Germany there are housing unions (providing cheap rent for the members) and union banks / membership banks / Genossenschaftsbank (?) quiet common and tax exempt.
Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by garciasn on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:25PM (#40742303)
That’s like comparing for-profit higher ed and not-for-profit higher ed.

Both are entirely motivated by money; one just is overt about it.

Everyone is all about making the most money in the fastest way possible and few truly give a hoot about the people they use to achieve the goals.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by danudey on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:35PM (#40742423)
Both are motivated by money, but only one is motivated by profit. The drive to increase profits over and over, year over year, indefinitely is to the detriment of society as a whole.

Meanwhile, not-for-profit entities like credit unions don't need to justify not making an extra few billion dollars this year compared to last year, meaning they're less likely to make customer-hostile moves for their own sakes.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by AlbertCory on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:06PM (#40743383)
What no one has stated so far is: jobs and salaries at non-profits have almost no discipline applied to them; market or otherwise. If they lose a little more money this year: ok, so what?

WETA (the public TV station) paid Sharon Percy Rockefeller $855,000 in 2022. The 12 highest paid employees all made more than $300,000. Maybe they are all "worth it" but how could you prove that WETA wouldn't function just as well at median salaries for everyone?

https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/530242992_202206_990_... (page 71)

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by BobaFloutist on Friday June 21, 2024 @02:44PM (#40752407)
That's funny, because for-profit higher ed is notoriously, almost comically inferior in its product, how it treats its customers, and its fundamental soundness to not-for-profit higher ed.

Strange example to use.

Re:Reining in America's $3.3T Tax-Exempt Economy by demondemidi on Friday June 21, 2024 @10:31AM (#40750021)
Not sure I follow.

I bought a 600$ fanless pc. It runs Linux. I run apps on it.

I bought a 600$ iPhone. It runs iOS. I run apps on it.

I haven’t paid a cent more than the original cost for each product. From an economical viewpoint they are the same.