News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ssijak on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:29PM (#40586959)
This is pure madness. So you have 48 hours after squatting started to report it and potentially get a fast eviction (why is it not an automatic criminal case for breaking into the property is beyond me). But after 48 hours it seems like it becomes a nightmare. So if you are on a business trip for 3 days or visiting parents in a different city or vacationing for a few days and somebody enters your home, you are out of luck and the squatters now have more rights than you?!
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by StevenHarlow on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:39PM (#40587089)
I live in Spain (Valencia) and see lots of okupas around the city. In reality they occupy buildings that aren't being occupied. Property taxes are incredibly low here and many people who own empty buildings are fine with letting them sit, fall apart, and eat the property tax than do anything with them. These are the buildings that are prone to Okupas. I've never seen nor heard of it happening to actively used buildings.

That said, I do think there are better solutions to allowing this to happen. It's a complicated issue here as housing is definitely viewed more as a right than in the USA, and honestly I'm really glad that the streets aren't full of homeless camps like they were when I lived in Oakland and SF.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by panarky on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:48PM (#40587252)
What's madness is the state allowing property owners to leave vacant, dilapidated buildings to blight the neighborhood. Owners should be required to maintain their structures and keep them occupied, or forfeit the property.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:09PM (#40587563)
The government should tell property owners that they are required to keep their property occupied otherwise the government should seize their property? This is an extremist view.

Who defines what “maintained” means? Beyond safety concerns about the structure (and even then, they shouldn’t be able to tell me anything as long as I post a danger unsafe structure keep out sign and lock the doors), why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tivert on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:54PM (#40588851)
>> What's madness is the state allowing property owners to leave vacant, dilapidated buildings to blight the neighborhood. Owners should be required to maintain their structures and keep them occupied, or forfeit the property.

> The government should tell property owners that they are required to keep their property occupied otherwise the government should seize their property? This is an extremist view.

It is not an extremist view. It's a public policy failure for land to sit vacant like that. Squatters rights can be a solution to that (e.g. in the US, squatters can actually get title to the land in cases of long-term abandonment).

> Who defines what “maintained” means? Beyond safety concerns about the structure (and even then, they shouldn’t be able to tell me anything as long as I post a danger unsafe structure keep out sign and lock the doors), why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?

This is actually the extremist view, private property rights do not trump all other considerations.

For a very clear example: if you're surrounded by starving people, and you own a warehouse full of food that you plan to let rot because you can't be bothered, the government absolutely does have the right to tell you what to do with that food.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:53PM (#40589723)
>> It's a public policy failure for land to sit vacant like that.

Then the government should buy the land.

>> For a very clear example: if you're surrounded by starving people, and you own a warehouse full of food that you plan to let rot because you can't be bothered, the government absolutely does have the right to tell you what to do with that food.

Let’s not use other examples and argumentation by analogy when we already have a very clear fact pattern. You own a building and the building is not currently occupied. The building is unsightly but structurally sound. Does/should the government have the right to make you surrender that building without compensation (because that’s what forfeit means) simply due to it being unoccupied? Why?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tivert on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:18PM (#40590038)
>> It's a public policy failure for land to sit vacant like that.

> Then the government should buy the land.

No, I don't think so.

> You own a building and the building is not currently occupied. The building is unsightly but structurally sound. Does/should the government have the right to make you surrender that building without compensation (because that’s what forfeit means) simply due to it being unoccupied? Why?

Yes. The legal principle has a long, long history across many different legal systems.

And I think you're thinking about it wrong: the government didn't "make you surrender that building," you chose to surrender it by leaving it unoccupied and unused to the point someone else could occupy and use it without a timely challenge.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:58PM (#40590534)
>> The legal principle has a long, long history across many different legal systems.

Cite them.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tivert on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:32PM (#40590877)
Adverse possession

Usucapio

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:43PM (#40591488)
In the US, adverse possession is a takings by a third party, not the government. And it’s not permitted when a land is unoccupied since one of the central tenets of adverse possession is open and notorious occupation. And, as you know based on your prior replies, adverse possession has a time component. The GP’s post is about merely leaving a property unoccupied. They don’t list a timeframe but we can pretty easily assume that if one exists in their mind it is less than the >5 years required for adverse possession based on the context.

I am not a commonwealth lawyer, but my understanding is that they have a similar modern rule in the UK and other commonwealth countries. I am not a continental lawyer, but my understanding is that civil law is similar with respect to government takings.

I will give you credit here because you may have interpreted the GP’s statement of “or forfeit the property” to mean generally lose possession of the property (including to a third party) rather than in the context of the prior sentence that references “the state allowing.” So, some backwards ancient legal principles that have been rejected or severely limited in modern times MIGHT support the contention that a third party can take someone’s land due to it being unoccupied and no modern legal principles support the contention that the government can make someone forfeit their land to the state merely for it being unoccupied.

The answer to my question (Does/should the government have the right to make you surrender that building without compensation (because that’s what forfeit means) simply due to it being unoccupied? Why?) is then “Maybe to someone that is occupying the unoccupied building (however that works) but not to the government.” Got it.

And it’s clear we both know that I have been talking about GOVERNMENT takings (“The government should tell property owners that they are required to keep their property occupied otherwise the government should seize their property?”).

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by littlestymaar on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:06AM (#40594025)
> Does/should the government have the right to make you surrender that building without compensation (because that’s what forfeit means) simply due to it being unoccupied? Why?

Because homelessness caused by artificial scarcity is violation of a basic human right, and a public order nightmare. Putting private property above other human rights is the root cause of so much problems in today's societies.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by quectophoton on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:57AM (#40594756)
(Disclaimer: I don't own a house, and I'm not even earning minimum wage with my freelance work.)

Question. If I owned a house, and went on a long vacation outside the country (e.g. because maybe I like travelling or something), how long would I be able to stay on vacation before the government yoinked my house due to it being empty?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by littlestymaar on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:02AM (#40594808)
If it's your main place of residence [1], I don't have issues with making it protected against the kind of mechanism we're talking about.

Because you know the problem doesn't come from people going for long vacations, but from landlords hoarding houses and holding in order to never let the price go down.

«Owning a house» can mean two very different things. It's either:

- I'm living in a place and I don't depend on anyone for hosting me.

- I hold some piece of paper that says that this particular place in the country belongs to me and if the people living there don't pay me I can call the police to get them evicted.

The first one is basic human right and should be protected as such, the second one is just something enforced by the power of the state in favor of the upper class against the working class.

[1] which, in many countries you need to declare to the government already, so that they know where to get you should they send the police to arrest you.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by dukeyukey on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:38AM (#40595006)
Even if you're not in it, the house is full of your possessions. I'm not seeing how this is comparable to properties that have been actually empty for decades.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by quectophoton on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:17AM (#40595698)
If a property is fully decorated (photos of my family, toothbrush I've used, etc), is that still considered empty?

If the answer is "yes", then based on your post, the answer to my question of how long can I take a vacation for, is "decades".

But if that is indeed considered empty, then what if in addition to that, every month I email someone my travel expenses and tell them to print them and to put them in some drawer in that property (maybe locked with a key or something), and also mail some cheap souvenirs and tell them to put them as decoration somewhere, is that still considered empty? (Since it has my stuff, and is continuously storing more stuff I'm purchasing.)

If that is allowed, then the next question is what if my vacation is in the same country.

So yeah, what kind of activity, and with what frequency, does that property have to have in order for it to not be considered empty, without leaving some kind of loophole?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by littlestymaar on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:04AM (#40595994)
It's funny because most of your argument assumes setting some kind of threshold would be a problem, as if it was not exactly how fiscal rules worked already.

For instance, you are paying income taxes in your “country of residence” and not in your country of vacations (unless you are an American citizen living abroad, in which case you pay it to both your country of residence and to the US), and there is a threshold that makes one country qualify as “country of residence” versus your countries of vacations.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by quectophoton on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:14AM (#40596046)
Yeah I'm dumb when it comes to legal stuff, but my guess is that defining a threshold with a good balance while also not inconveniencing the common citizen wouldn't be as easy as it might first appear, at least without causing some unintended consequences that people might not think about when proposing "'just' do X".

But like I said, I'm dumb when it comes to this topic.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by labcomputer on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:39PM (#40599489)
> It's funny because most of your argument assumes setting some kind of threshold would be a problem, as if it was not exactly how fiscal rules worked already.

But it is the crux of the problem.

When establishing things like "country of residence" (or, here in the US, to which state(s) you owe taxes), the second order effects aren't the same. It's the difference between "you owe a few extra percent of your income for one year" versus "you lose your home permanently".

As public policy, it is important not to expropriate someone's home simply because they had to be away for extenuating life circumstances like caring for an ailing relative for a few months. Because otherwise, you will disincentivize that behavior (and create a greater burden for the state).

It's easy for you to come back with "Oh, well the competent bureaucrats in my government will simply write an exception for those who leave for a few months of eldercare because that is clearly a legitimate reason to leave your house vacant for a few months." But that is just a bandaid on an artery which creates an explosion of exceptions and exceptions to the exceptions.

What happens if I need to care for my grandmother, and then something else comes up? Do I get to have two exemptions to expropriation? Can they be consecutive? What sort of documentation do I need? What if the exemption allows n days, but I need n+3? What if I had planned an m-1 days vacation (for the m vacation days exception) right before I need n days to care for my grandmother?

Very quickly you will have 10,000 pages of rules that nobody understands. And you will get perverse outcomes when someone hits an edge case that wasn't quite accounted for.

Or maybe you will say "put the case in front of a judge and let them exercise discretion". But now we have the problem that it is no longer really rule of law, and people with connections will always get exceptions while people without don't. So that increases the class divide because people with connections are usually rich, and middle-class people usually don't have connections.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by littlestymaar on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:48PM (#40600969)
First of all, there's no need for a complete expropriation all at once. Having a significant property tax that scales with time would do the trick too. Start with 5%, next year the tax is 10% of its original price, then 15%, etc. After 4 years you lost half of your property, so I'm happy with that, and since it's all about percentage like other taxes you should be happy too.

And then, all this argument is basically a straw man, because there no need for the state to guess anything or to set threshold, at all: all you need to do is mandate people to declare their primary residence, and in fact it is the case in many fiscal system already! If it is your primary residence, then fine, you can leave it empty for as long you want, as long as you are not lying on the fact that this is in fact your primary residence (and if you're lying, then the state must gather the evidence and win against you in court, which is what the rule of law is).

Tada! Imaginary problems solved.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by asoneth on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:54PM (#40588117)
> tell property owners that they are required to keep their property occupied otherwise the government should seize their property?

I suspect it would make more sense to do so via tax policy, i.e. high property taxes (or LVT) with a deduction for each occupant.

> why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?

For one thing, governments have a vested interest in not being overthrown. If a sufficiently large percentage of the population believes that their living standards are declining (including not having a place to live) then an increasing number of people will arrive at the conclusion that revolution or terrorism has a positive risk/reward ratio.

I've worked in a country where the previous government had allowed this to occur; apparently it happened gradually and then suddenly. Beyond a certain point you can only consider something "my building" if you have the means to defend it against anyone who might wish to make it their building. In that case, the possession of a piece of paper which you once used to outsource the enforcement of your property rights to the previous government isn't very useful.

(Edit: To be clear, I think allowing squatting is a poor solution to the problem of reducing homelessness and better tax and housing policies are more sustainable and equitable, I'm just explaining why the government has a substantial interest in what private landowners do with their properties.)

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:45PM (#40589623)
>> I suspect it would make more sense to do so via tax policy, i.e. high property taxes (or LVT) with a deduction for each occupant.

Vacant land use taxes do make sense to me. That is not what GP advocated for: “Owners should be required to maintain their structures and keep them occupied, or forfeit the property.” Increased taxation is not forfeiture, and being forced to sell because taxes are prohibitive is different from the government taking your building.

>> governments have a vested interest in not being overthrown

This is a tortuous chain of logic to go from unoccupied buildings to overthrown government concerns.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by asoneth on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:05PM (#40589876)
> That is not what GP advocated for

Exactly, that's why before I responded to your question ("why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?") I tried to make it clear that I think there are better approaches than what the GP is advocating for i.e. seizing vacant properties.

> This is a tortuous chain of logic to get from building with squatters to government overthrown.

Can you be more specific about what part you disagree with?

To be clear, I'm not arguing that squatting results in overthrown governments, but that the acceptance of widespread squatting is sometimes a (shortsighted) policy response to a housing crisis. Squatting is a symptom, what can actually topple governments is sufficiently high levels of homelessness. Any government that allows a sufficiently large percentage of people (especially young people) to become homeless will eventually be replaced by anarchy or a new government that does.

To reiterate, I'm just trying to answer your question of what right the government has to tell you what to do with your property -- I'm not specifically defending the GP's suggestion.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tivert on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:35PM (#40590264)
> Increased taxation is not forfeiture, and being forced to sell because taxes are prohibitive is different from the government taking your building.

That's a distinction without a difference, at least not a difference in the area we're talking about. Both mechanisms cause title to be lost if certain obligations are not met (in one case, an obligation to occupy, in the other, an obligation to pay taxes).

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:48PM (#40591537)
Well if we zoom out to the moon so that everything looks the same “in the area we are talking about” then I guess there are no distinctions between anything, are there? A person that gets robbed is the same as a person that forgets their wallet on a train, they both just failed to meet their obligations (in one case an obligation to not let someone have their wallet and in the other their obligation to remember where they put their wallet).
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by revert_to_test on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:22AM (#40594141)
Maybe government won't be overthrown, but you can easily loose the election.

European cities are dense, and there is limit to their growth, as they are often surrounded by tight circles of villages. Sure, you can build a few buildings there, but those villages are often fighting against high buildings, and residents often fight against urbanisation of the area. So you can't build suburbs like in USA and this makes the already problematic situation (high prices, big funds buying whole apartment complexes to rent them, many people buying apartments as assets and being afraid of renting due to protections towards tenants) even worse. So every building is worth it's weight in gold. And whole abandoned buying is going to be a daily reminder for many people that cannot afford to buy 1 room apartment about how unfair current situation is.

I don't want to argue about what to do with situation, just adding a perspective.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by skitout on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:25PM (#40588504)
Even if I am the owner of an apartment, I don't have the right to do a metal concert in my living room some Saturdays at 1 am... or don't have the right to paint my frontage the way I want... cause it creates negative consequences for other people.

Having vacant apartments and houses for long time in places where there is an housing shortage create much bigger negative consequences than few metal concerts...

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by abduhl on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:49PM (#40588779)
You do have a right to do a metal concert in your living room on Saturday at 1AM. You don’t have a right to violate the local noise ordinance or, because your example has you as an apartment owner and not a building owner, the condo association rules.

You do have the right to paint your frontage the way you want with respect to the GOVERNMENT.

But more importantly, the GP wanted the government to TAKE VIA FORFEITURE any building that is merely vacant. Your examples are limits on use, not relinquishment of property. They are not the same.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by vidarh on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:35AM (#40594235)
There isn't a government on the planet which doesn't place limits on how you can paint your property. Try painting a death threat against a government official on it for example.

The notion that property rights is unlimited is an extremist view that doesn't match the legal situation in any jurisdiction on the planet with a government.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by TulliusCicero on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:51AM (#40593944)
> The government should tell property owners that they are required to keep their property occupied otherwise the government should seize their property?

No, but they have to keep it in good condition, which includes keeping it secure.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by vidarh on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:16AM (#40594091)
Land is a scarce resource, and society agrees to enforce artificial restrictions on access and use because in many instances it is beneficial, but that does not mean society should automatically be required to extend unlimited support for property claims when an owner behaves in ways detrimental to society as a whole. No jurisdiction on earth grants property rights without limitations.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ekianjo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:55AM (#40593970)
with this kind of logic soon the government will tell you what to eat and wear
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Malcolmlisk on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:33AM (#40594573)
The government literally tells you what to eat and wear. And thank god... since without those laws we would eat the worst and toxic foods and wear toxic and low quality clothes.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by 4ggr0 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:13AM (#40594850)
> wear toxic and low quality clothes

uhm...that might be a bad example. winks towards shein, temu, fast fashion in general

and thinking for a bit longer - corn syrup/sugar in general is not toxic but it certainly is not that healthy either, and it's got big lobbies and large amounts of money behind it to influence the government.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by darkwater on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:39AM (#40595011)
Consider the worst case scenario and that, without regulations, it would be EVEN worse.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by 4ggr0 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:48AM (#40596290)
Yeah, that's a good point as well. We would certainly be much worse off in an Anarcho-Capitalist/Libertarian world.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ekianjo on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:25AM (#40622241)
you know that the whole food pyramid stuff thaught in school by the authorities for years was pure bullshit right?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by gryfft on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:11AM (#40594063)
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by KaiserPro on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:23AM (#40594504)
parts of the USA have much much higher property tax than elsewhere.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:25AM (#40594166)
In germany, if you see such a abandoned property, you cannot even ask the authority who owns it, if you have the plans to buy it (you would have to rely on local people knowing and telling you).

There are quite some neglected properties around here and the owners are away, do not care anymore and the authorities do not care as long as the low property taxes are paid. There was a case close by, where a buisness wanted to get rid of the old rotting building next to them, but could not. It went on for years. Only after the building burned down (no idea if someone helped with that), the space could be finally cleared.

So yeah, exproptiation should only ever be the last resort, but in some cases it really makes sense.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by terminalcommand on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:46AM (#40594297)
The solution is actually simpler, set a property tax that would hurt if the buildings became vacant. For example if you pay 1% of the buildings value as property tax each year, it would make enough incentive to rent it out or sell if you don't need it. The proceeds can be used for building public housing projects or helping the homeless. Property tax was invented for this very reason.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by pzo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:17AM (#40594475)
Its probsbly hard to reliably enforce it since hard to figure out if bulding is occupied or not. You can have someone registered at the residency but still not live there.

You could maybe try to figure out based on water usage but then someone could just leave water tap slightly leaking since water cost is not that expensive

Probsbly squatters are those cheap solution that can enforce it in the most efficient way

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by unaindz on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:48AM (#40594700)
You don't need to know if people live there, just raise tax enough so that the owner feels like renting or selling the building is better than paying the taxes out of pocket.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by account42 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:11AM (#40595662)
This also forcess poorer people (including retired people) to sell off the house they are actually living in. This is especially true if the tax is based on the current estimated value which may be much higher than what the house was bought for.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by terminalcommand on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:56AM (#40595927)
There are ways around this. For example set a property tax from second home on. Do not tax the primary residence. Or set income brackets. If poorer people live in their own homes they don't pay property tax.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by dukeyukey on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:35AM (#40594993)
Why does it matter if someone lives there or not? Slap a land value tax on it, high enough that if the owner doesn't make use of it they'll feel it.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by terminalcommand on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:55AM (#40595918)
You do not have to care if it is occupied. Tax the property tax. If the owner does not rent out the property, they'll pay out of pocket.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:51AM (#40594324)
Something like this yes. But the devil will be in the details.

"pay 1% of the buildings value as property tax each year"

A old rotten building might be worth just 10000€. And 100 € a year ain't that much. One would have to tax the property - and who will set up the rates in a fair way in a process that is not vulnerable to corruption?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by amunozo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:03AM (#40594398)
And old rotten building sitting anywhere in a city is worth way more than 10.000€. Even if the building is not in good shape, the land is still valuable.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by p_l on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:09AM (#40594838)
Many property tax systems are based around value of the building, not the land.

I think Japan is one of the outliers where pretty much all property value is locked with the land itself, as buildings depreciate not appreciate.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ncruces on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:02AM (#40595607)
Right, and then the 80yo people living in a centenary house in a gentrified neighborhood suddenly get a 10x tax increase because the next door building got sold to be remodeled as a luxury condo, and drove property values through the roof.

That's good, because if they can't pay, their house is up for remodelling too. /sarcasm

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Peritract on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:50AM (#40595893)
If the 80yo people are living in the house, then it isn't vacant.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ncruces on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:16AM (#40596515)
That's not how property taxes work here.

Also, you need to figure out how you define vacant, and how to track it.

If I relocated for work, and use the house 3 months a year and every other month for a weekend, is it vacant? How do you tell?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by harimau777 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:01AM (#40597474)
It seems to me that we could start with a conservative approach and adjust from there. For example, define a property as vacant if it isn't occupied for 1 continuous month or a total of three months out of the year.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by emberfiend on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:20AM (#40597736)
Yes, we are discussing a hypothetical, from a few parents up: "set a property tax that would hurt if the buildings became vacant"

The definition of vacant is something that would have to be figured out, but it's not impossible. For example, you could do a generous 6-12 months of the year occupation without taxation, and then a sliding scale from there. (So you pay 0% of the new tax at 12 months yearly occupation, 0% at 6 months, 50% at 3 months, and 100% at 0 months.)

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by RyanHamilton on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:42AM (#40597310)
I'm open to being wrong but I believe the data shows, old people in the UK are living in houses that are too large and receiving pensions that rise with inflation whilst "young people" are paying huge rents, can't afford to buy and are stuck with huge student debt. Why shouldn't the old couple move to let 10x apartments be built? Or does the data show differently?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:07PM (#40600517)
"Why shouldn't the old couple move to let 10x apartments be built?"

Imagine you worked all your life and now you just want to enjoy your peace in your home for your last years. You really would not want to move and I am very against driving old people out of their homes, even though I am one of those young people with a small apartment also seeing empty and unused space everywhere.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by passwordle on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:23PM (#40603038)
I think not what parent comment said?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:38PM (#40603708)
What do you think parent said?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Manuel_D on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:17AM (#40597694)
If the property tax goes up by 10x, then that 80 year old couple has seen a 10x return on their real estate investment. They can easily take out a reverse mortgage to pay the property tax for the rest of their lives.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:01PM (#40600459)
"They can easily take out a reverse mortgage to pay the property tax for the rest of their lives."

Not everyone can do that easily. I would not know how that works and where are the downsides. I can learn it, sure, but for an 80 year old this would be real stress, having to figure unknown contracts out - and not getting cheated. Old people are a prime target for frauds for a reason.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Manuel_D on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:56PM (#40601067)
The reality is that the same thing, in effect, happens if you stop paying property taxes. The tax builds up and then when the house is sold after passing the government collects the tax before the descendants receive the sale proceeds.

This is why complaining about rising property taxes is almost never about the elderly people who actually live in the house. It's about their children that want to inherit the house without paying off their parents' property taxes.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by kgwgk on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:07AM (#40608381)
> The reality is that …

People in different countries experience different realities.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Manuel_D on Friday June 07, 2024 @01:15PM (#40610678)
Not really. By definition if your property value rises by 10x you have enough money to pay the property taxes by leveraging your home. Sure, it means you'll have to sell when you die and won't be able to pass on the house to your heirs. But the meme, "elderly homeowner becomes homeless because his home became super value" is just a fiction. It's not that the homeowner can't pay the property taxes - he's got plenty of value in his home. It's really the children that want to inherit a valuable home but don't want to cover the tax back payment.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by kgwgk on Friday June 07, 2024 @01:20PM (#40610729)
Just in case it was not clear, my comment was about

> The reality is that the same thing, in effect, happens if you stop paying property taxes. The tax builds up, etc.

and in many places worse things will happen to you if you stop paying property taxes.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:43AM (#40595847)
"Even if the building is not in good shape, the land is still valuable."

That was my point, not binding the value just to the building itself.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by resolutebat on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:40AM (#40595021)
That's why this scheme requires land tax, not property tax.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by terminalcommand on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:53AM (#40595912)
That is the very problem we are facing in Turkey :). The municipality determines the value of housing in a neighborhood each year. That is taken as a basis for property taxes and transaction taxes. The municipality assessed value is somewhere near 1/20th of the value of an average flat. So, almost no tax gets collected :(.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by UweSchmidt on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:59AM (#40595139)
Having a building vacant is already incredibly expensive; costs and interest add up and the building can get severely damaged (a building has to be heated in winter, ventilated properly and issues like broken pipes have to be found quickly by tenants etc.). Common reasons for vacancies are probate disputes, owners that are house rich but cash poor and can't handle maintenance, issues with building code and permits and similar. Apart from some truly dysfunct situations a scheme that involves vacancy doesn't make much sense. Why not take even a modest rent for a bit?

In general, everything you could propose that puts pressure on landlords leads to transfer of ownership from your (maybe friendly) landlord with 2-3 units, to larger, more professional companies who can handle the paperwork and regulations, with a tendency to tear down and rebuild something that is more expensive to rent or buy.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by terminalcommand on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:51AM (#40595899)
In countries with high inflation purchasing real-estate and keeping it vacant is an inflation hedge. Plus, you also benefit from low interest rates and get free money if your government allows it.

I live in Turkey. We had 80% p.a. inflation, where the government decided to lower the interest rates even further. Our president said Interest rates are the cause of inflation and if we lowered interest rates inflation would go down. State banks gave out house loans with 12% p.a. interest where the inflation rate was above 80% p.a.

A lot of Turkish people got their free money from the bank and invested in real estate. In Turkey, everyone evades tax and property taxes are not really collected. This in turn fueled inflation even more, sky-rocketed inequality and caused the worst housing crisis.

That is why I am convinced that property taxes are a must.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by galangalalgol on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:27AM (#40596145)
I live somewhere with ~3% property taxes on properties, including the one you reside in. Not so long ago mortgages were cheaper than that, and mortgages at least end someday. At the same time, short term rentals like airbnb are illegal. Combined, this leads to most landlords either being companies large enough to keep extremely high occupancy rates, or families that flout the law to rent a second property owned due to marriage or inheritance and become vulnerable the whims of neighbors.

I think allowing short term rentals, and giving owners strong eviction rights for damage, illegal activity or non-payment (which we have) need to be paired with property taxes to prevent all landlords becoming large inhuman entities.

It should also be noted that if you tax everything at the value it could make, you distort the usage of valuable locations to exclude housing.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by wslwsl on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:11AM (#40595230)
don't you also have the "Grundbuch" (title register) in Germany, like we do here in Austria?

-- snip --

okay, I looked it up. you have, but it's not fully public like ours. Yeez that's messed up!

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:35AM (#40595804)
"Yeez that's messed up!"

Yes it is. You can request information, but I was told "wanting to buy" is explicitely excluded as a valid reason. (The usual solution is knowing someone inside the office, or paying someone who knows)

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by pineaux on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:33AM (#40596648)
This is not true. You can query the Grondbuch and it will give you all the necessary information of the owner.

Edit: sorry, havent been living in Germany for long. Thought it was the same as the Dutch kadaster. Turns out, it's not and my dealings with it have been unusually easy until now.

The reason why expropriation isn't used a lot is because it costs a lot of resources.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by amadeuspagel on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:43AM (#40597315)
Surely, before considering expropriation, we should tell people who owns a property so that they can offer to buy it. If that's too much a privacy concern, the government could simply relay the offer.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lukan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:12PM (#40600568)
Oh for sure. In the specific case I meant, the owner was known, but lived somewhere else around the globe and did not care, but it was his property. (where stones were falling off from the roof to the street)

Those are cases where I think expropriation would be warranted.

And if it would be easier to buy obviously unused land, less properties would end up in that rotten final state, so less need to even discuss forcing something.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by stevenwoo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:33AM (#40594220)
Heck, some streets in industrial areas in Silicon Valley and the street my local Costco in Mountain View down Rengstorff across 101 from Google HQ are lined with people living in cars and vans and RVs.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by salynchnew on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:11AM (#40594840)
Ah, so the real problem here is for people who are "squatting" on an a large number of empty investment properties and don't want the hassle of dealing with any actual tenants.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by vvillena on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:36PM (#40587052)
No. If someone enters your home, as in, you live there, the city has you registered into that address, and/or your ID card states that's your address, it's not squatting. That's trespassing, and the police will happily assist.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by AlunAlun on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:55AM (#40595557)
This reply is very true and should be higher up.

Squatting occurs almost exclusively in second residences, abandoned properties, and places reclaimed by the banks, etc.

If you can prove that the house is your primary residence, the police will oust the squatters promptly. As a result, squatters will not target a house that is clearly 'lived in'.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by diggan on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:33PM (#40587010)
As always, there are always multiple sides to any issue. Another commentator put it better than I could:

> The reasoning behind this is that some shady landlords might try to claim that genuine tenants are squatters in order to get rid of them. There are plenty of desperate people who'd accept a verbal contract and payment in cash, after all. Not that hard of a choice when the alternative is being homeless. Oh, but you paid your rent a day late? Sorry, you're now a "squatter", so we're cooking you alive until you leave.

> Making it too easy to get rid of squatters would expose the most vulnerable people in society to even more abuse, and making it trickier for absentee landlords to get rid of real squatters is considered a fair price to prevent this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40586929

It's not a black & white issue where one side is obviously right and the other one is obviously wrong.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by giantg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:38PM (#40587076)
"Making it too easy to get rid of squatters would expose the most vulnerable people in society to even more abuse, and making it trickier for absentee landlords to get rid of real squatters is considered a fair price to prevent this."

Except this is poorly thought out and not really true.

You can provide better protection for both sides by requiring written and recorded contracts for real property use/rental, just as we do for real property sales today.

"It's not a black & white issue where one side is obviously right and the other one is obviously wrong."

That's because the system is broke and allows abuses by both sides.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by bramblerose on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:53PM (#40587333)
So what happens when the law requires a contract yet the landlord doesn't offer a contract and simply collects the rent?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by giantg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:07PM (#40587530)
It's an illegal operation. Under that sort of restriction, any building occupied would either need to be occupied by the registered owner or have a registered lease. If those aren't found, the people are evicted. The point is to ensure that everyone knows that you need to have a registered document to stay somewhere so nobody takes those deals. Then on the landlord side, you need to enforce substantial fines for any that have offered unofficial leases and surveillance for property owners that have repeat offenses - both to protect the owner from repeated squating and also to catch any owner bypassing the law.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by bramblerose on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:14PM (#40589988)
I appreciate your response. I feel the same as the other commenter: the asymmetry between "a steep fine" and "losing your home" is enormous. But "what happens if the fine is enormous" (say, the landlord also stands to lose their home) is an interesting thought experiment - how big does the punishment need to be to "fix" the power imbalance?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by giantg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:59PM (#40590543)
That's not really a functional asymmetry. All you need is to pass a minimal threshold to disincentivize the behavior. A fine that outweighs potential illegal rent performs that task.

It also depends on what you mean by losing one's home. That's not an issue for people who would sign the written agreements. Afain, we want a disincentive to informal agreements, including from renters and squatters. I'm not sure how you can equate loss of ownership with loss of temporary use.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by skitout on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:17PM (#40588391)
I am volunteering in an housing rights organization in France, and I am and have been tenant in a city with high price and housing shortage.

There will always be many people taking "illegal deal" as sometime you have no other other solution, or other solution are even worse. And many many landlords are doing illegal things, including public housing.

Tenant don't have the same bargaining power / freedom / agency than landlord. Fighting illegal stuff that do landlord is long (usually longer than kicking out a squatter) and difficult. And you have little incentive to do it as a tenant : being in a fight with your landlord = being sure to have problem down the line

My feeling is that your comment ignores this asymmetry.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by giantg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:42PM (#40588715)
"My feeling is that your comment ignores this asymmetry."

These are enforcement problems, not squatter problems. As you've said, the things the landlords are doing are already illegal. In the US we have Attorney General offices that will handle housing cases on behalf of tenants.

Both parties can benefit from better enforcement and written and recorded leases. Penalties for landlords leasing without recorded agreements may be more easily enforced that under the current system.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by skitout on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:02PM (#40590582)
This asymmetry makes enforcement easier when it profits the landlord, and make enforcement more difficult when it benefits the tenant... Your reflection seems based on the idea that there is a symmetry on the enforcement
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by giantg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:22PM (#40590780)
The enforcement is inconsistent or a drag on both sides already. I've seen both sides in the US. Enforcement benefiting the tenant is quite common.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by 8A51C on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:35AM (#40597253)
In England, if no contract exists but rent is being paid a tenant has quite alot of implied rights in law. Though enforcement of these rights would normally fall to larger organisations such as charities or councils rather than individual tenants. I remember a news story where a landlord was accepting casual rent for beds in sheds in the garden of a rented property who was brought to justice because the sheds were not habitable buildings.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by KaiserPro on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:30AM (#40594550)
> You can provide better protection for both sides by requiring written and recorded contracts for real property use/rental, just as we do for real property sales today.

In england there is the "Assured shorthold tenancy agreement" which basically provides a set of rights to tenants and landlords. On the one hand its great as it sets out a clear set of expectations for tenants (24 hours notice of landlord visiting, cant be evicted without notice, deposits must be in third party)

However there is still no fault evictions, which means you can be kicked out for no reason with only 1 months notice.

For the landlord it allows them to reclaim the property at the end of the contract.

However its still the most vulnerable that get evicted.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by 8A51C on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:13AM (#40596997)
Just to be clear, a tenant cannot be kicked out after a month. A section 21 notice requires a tenant to hand back possesion in 2 months, if a tenant does not the landlord may make an application to court for a possession order (which WILL be granted if all process followed correctly),the order is served and then if a tenant still doesn't relinquish possession a landlord may apply for an eviction warrant, this gives them the right to employ the bailiff to forcibly kick a tenant out. Depending on the courts and bailiff availability this process may take anywhere between 6 weeks and several months on top of the initial 2 months. The costs are often a loss for the landlord. 'Kicked out' was just a turn of phrase but I thought it should be clear in this context.

As for the most vulnerable, ime it is common for social tenants, that is councils and housing associations (who are compelled by law to offer affordable rents) to have assured tenancies, which do not allow no fault evictions. And if not then there is an extra notice period of 6 months plus 2 months for the section 21.

https://england.shelter.org.uk/professional_resources/legal/...

There is of course a crisis of availability of all rental properties so the most vulnerable overlap social and private sectors.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by KaiserPro on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:10PM (#40601213)
Sorry thank you for providing a much better and accurate overview of the law. It is most appreciated.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by hichamdoe on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:40PM (#40587110)
+1
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by prmoustache on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:42PM (#40587159)
In reality most cases of squatting are financial assets that property owners have no plan to rent to anyone. In an area where housing space that people can afford are very few and far between, nbuying properties for the sole purpose of speculation can be seen on a similar level of unethicality as occupying a space you don't own.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lottin on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:02AM (#40594004)
Absolute nonsense. Why would a "speculator" refuse to rent out their property and make a profit out of it?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by em500 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:04AM (#40594402)
Many countries especially in continental Europe have strong pro-tenant rights. Often the rent contract cannot be terminated by the landlord, only by the tenant, which can make it more profitable to leave property empty vs renting it out. (When a tenant-occupied property is sold, the new owner in some countries cannot terminate an existing rent contract, which makes the property less valuable on the market vs empty properties.)
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lottin on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:39PM (#40600219)
Yes, I understand that selling a rented property can be less profitable than selling a property without a rent contract. But holding on to a property that generates no income is even less profitable.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tomjakubowski on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:44PM (#40604513)
On an abandoned property, the land may appreciate faster than the improvements depreciate. As long as that pace exceeds the mortgage interest (if any) and property tax (ibid), it's profitable. There are other possible complications too which might swing it, like income tax deductions.

Sometimes seemingly abandoned buildings are used for one-off occasions which generate income: downtown LA is full of "historic" buildings which the owners allow to dilapidate outside of a few areas they can rent out once or twice a year to a film crew.

edit: another thing -- rich people procrastinate too, in fact many of them can afford to procrastinate on matters like this, and they may rather take a loss than confront the anxiety and work of selling or renting out the property

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lottin on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:25AM (#40617745)
Sorry, but I fail to see how owning an abandoned building is MORE profitable than having people living there and collecting rent on it, even if that means that you have to spend part of that income on maintenance costs.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by amunozo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:06AM (#40594419)
To be able to sell it in the future a higher price without worrying about people living there, or having to pay money to mantain a building that is not in condition to be rented.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lottin on Thursday June 06, 2024 @01:48PM (#40600317)
Right, because a run-down building sells for the same price as one in good shape.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by orthecreedence on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:20PM (#40600661)
You're just making the bet that real estate value increases faster than the building deteriorates with minimal maintenance. That's often a really good bet.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by lottin on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:21AM (#40617727)
I don't think that this is the bet. The bet is that the market will not discount the extra repair/maintenance costs that the buyer will have to incur, which is a ridiculous proposition. Speculators gain nothing from letting the property they own rot away.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by im_dario on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:17AM (#40595271)
Real estate is baby boomers and older millennials (as they inherited from their parents) "cryptocurrency" (as speculative asset). They HODL it to manufacture scarcity.

Just for reference, in a small city (40K people, 8 sq. km.) you can find 2K empty properties out of the market because it's more profitable to wait prices to raise.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:47PM (#40587239)
This problem will only grow because there's an increasingly large number of people in Spain unable to rent.

At this very moment the profile of squatters is diverse, but with such large pockets of spaniards staying just above of the poverty line, many people will be forced between squatting or just become homeless.

Just for reference, I live in a flat in a building from the 50s. Very poor insulation, 5º with no elevator, etc. I pay 475€ for it (small sized city), I've been living here for +5 years.

The guys in the 3rd floor came in recently. They pay 1100€ for basically the same flat.

The modal income in this city is 16k. I work on IT and I'm barely above 20k (well, was, as I'm now unemployed).

I go for the listings and there's almost nothing listed and everything is > 800€/month. If I increase the range to 1h from any potential job location it goes down to ~500 for shitty places. Also, not precisely a lot to choose from, so probably wouldn't be able to rent neither.

Can anyone tell me how is exactly this going to work out? Not to mention all the "expats" and "digital nomads" that are willing to pay whatever the landlord says because they really really want to live here without thinking about the consequences, but that's another story.

Of course buying is totally out of the question with the current prices, and that's me that I got lucky, with the new prices no one will be able to save anymore.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by diggan on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:52PM (#40587323)
> Can anyone tell me how is exactly this going to work out? Not to mention all the "expats" and "digital nomads" that are willing to pay whatever the landlord says because they really really want to live here without thinking about the consequences, but that's another story.

Slowly, more regulation is added to get the problem somewhat under control. Rents capped by index, annual rent increases cap, introduction of "tense housing markets", new upkeep for vacant properties, bonuses for renting out to younger people and more are being introduced, at least here in Catalunya. Unsure exactly what of those things are on the national level but guessing something similar is being introduced elsewhere in the country if it isn't already.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:55PM (#40587357)
I don't think that helps honestly. What would help IMO is a lot of new housing close to jobs where foreigners can't apply. Because no matter how much you build, if someone from overseas is going to say "I pay double of whatever you've been offered" I can't compete.

And I know that's happening because my Gf has to work with this sort of people, sadly.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by diggan on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:58PM (#40587392)
> I don't think that helps honestly. What would help IMO is a lot of new housing close to jobs where foreigners can't apply. Because no matter how much you build, if someone from overseas is going to say "I pay double of whatever you've been offered" I can't compete.

But if the law blocks "I pay double of whatever you've been offered" from happening (which is true today, they cannot increase the rent to whatever they want), then you'd have a chance to compete because the competition is no longer about who can pay the most.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:01PM (#40587441)
No, because the landlord would either get the rest under the table or the competition would move onto risk profiles, where someone earning 4/5k month would beat any spaniard with our unstable and poorly paid jobs.

In the end, we either do it like in Vienna or Singapore, or we're not going to solve it.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:28AM (#40594534)
Singapore, I know about: A huge amount of decent public housing. Is Vienna similar? Is there no political pressure in Spain to build more decent public housing?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:15AM (#40595258)
Vienna has a massive public, universal, rent system. Like 50% of the total housing stock.

Everyone says they're going to make public housing here in Spain, nobody does anything.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by em-bee on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:27PM (#40600739)
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by misja111 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:31AM (#40594975)
You're correct, the competition wouldn't be on rent prices anymore. But since the shortage of houses is not solved, competition would just move to some other area.

E.g: which candidate does the landlord like the best, or who was on some waiting list for the most years, etc.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ricardobayes on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:25AM (#40595745)
Technically we have that, it's called VPO.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by misja111 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:04AM (#40594400)
Really that won't help. These kind of regulations have been tried in so many countries before and the result is always the same: cap the rents => landlords will take houses from the markets and sell them instead => there will be a shortage of properties for rent so finding them will be very hard, and the few landlords left will be extremely selective when choosing from the many candidates.

What does help: increase the supply. Make it easier to build or let houses by reducing bureaucracy, invest in housing projects etc.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:17AM (#40595273)
Increasing supply won't work with places where the demand is virtually infinite. You have to cut the demand somehow, and in the case of Spain it means preventing foreigners to access such stock. That means public housing, or some law that creates a lot of friction.

Cheaper housing in Spain will lead to induced demand, because there's just too many people willing to move here.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by misja111 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:46AM (#40595866)
Yes you're right, reducing demand will also work. Which is exactly what capping rents won't do, this will actually increase demand ..
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by account42 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:20AM (#40595720)
> Really that won't help. These kind of regulations have been tried in so many countries before and the result is always the same: cap the rents => landlords will take houses from the markets and sell them instead

Good. Too many people are forced into renting due to insane property prices as is.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by piaste on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:12AM (#40606426)
> cap the rents => landlords will take houses from the markets and sell them instead => there will be a shortage of properties for rent

Won't step 2 increase the supply of houses for sale, thus lowering the prices, thus decreasing the demand for rentals?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:26AM (#40594522)
You are in IT earning only 20K EUR per year? That is unbelievable! Why is the housing crisis happening? What changed? Did you have a population boom?

    > Not to mention all the "expats" and "digital nomads" that are willing to pay whatever the landlord says because they really really want to live here without thinking about the consequences, but that's another story.
Hmmm. Do you have any stats on this matter? It seems easy to lash out against this group because they are outsiders. The "expats" will pay tax, and plenty of it, because they are higher income. "Digital nomads" are another issue -- I am not a big fan because they usually pay no income, nor residence, tax.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by southerntofu on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:52AM (#40595100)
> You are in IT earning only 20K EUR per year?

Do you realize most people working in IT are paid minimum wage or close to that? Most sysadmins and developers i've met here in France are under 2000€/month and it's only on places like HN that i read about huge salaries in IT. (sorry i don't have stats this is just anecdata)

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Levitz on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:00AM (#40595962)
Spain has exceptionally low wages in the IT sector though, taking cost of living into account and all.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:37PM (#40604109)
Why don't people move to a place with higher wages? Spain a member of the EU.

And, why do people enter IT in Spain, if the wages are so terrible?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by southerntofu on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:44AM (#40606974)
Where would you move, and how? Wages are not better in surrounding countries, unless you work in specific companies it's not easy to get in. You also need the opportunity. Most people living paycheck-to-paycheck have little time and mental space to radically change their situation...
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Levitz on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:54AM (#40608738)
The Spanish population in general ain't that good when it comes to English and the quality of living in Spain is, in general, quite good. Weather and food are hard to replace.

Which begs the question: "Well why don't they work remotely from Spain then?" and the answer to that is that the Spanish IT sector does a whole lot of that to begin with, so a business in the market for it can just hire one of the many consulting business there.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by spaniard89277 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:05AM (#40595177)
It is a pretty normal salary here in Spain. The housing crisis is happening because of several factors, but mostly because there's a huge increase in demand due to immigration (millions of people coming) from all profiles (richer and poorer) so we're getting squeezed hard.

The regulations around housing are so bad that almost nothing is getting built. What's getting built is for wealthy people, and no public housing in sight.

And yes, of course rich foreigners play a role here. You maybe don't like to hear it because you're likely richer than the average spaniard, but they are plenty, and we can see what they do once they arrive here.

This is no second-hand information. Because the housing situation is so bad they go on sprees trying to convince landlords to rent to them by offering more money.

Also, getting out of cities is problematic because we can't save money nor have disposable income, so owning and maintaining a car is quite an effort, and that in a city where I don't need a "B" stick to enter the city, in other cities it's worse because you're only allowed a subset of cars which are more expensive. There aren't cheap cars anymore, even shitty Dacias are +20k and anything under 10k second hand is close to junk.

We're fucked honestly. I'm willing to move, but I don't know where...

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ccozan on Thursday June 06, 2024 @05:13AM (#40595241)
I can suggest Romania. Depending on your IT skills, 2000 euro in IT is considered minimum and country is still very cheap to live in. There is a great shortage in IT there..

Climate also similar to Spain in sommer , you will get used to winters as well. Seaside and mountains are available.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by throwaway2037 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:38PM (#40604114)
Great suggestion. Plus, the language will be easy to learn for a native Spanish speaker.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by account42 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:18AM (#40595705)
> Did you have a population boom?

Unchecked (or even encouraged) mass migration, yes.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by stevenwoo on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:23AM (#40608477)
Anecdote but I visited Barcelona just pre-Covid, one of my California friends met another California friend who had bought a condo for the bargain price of 500,000 for a vacation home (and they spent time and money to renovate it) right next to the most popular touristy section of town and only lived there about a month a year, and airbnb'ed it the rest of the time. There were already things on the news that I could follow about hostility to short term rentals to tourists in the city.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ricardobayes on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:23AM (#40595735)
These sound like numbers from Seville or somewhere deep South. Just for reference I mention that in Munich you could also rent something for 475€ and your salary would probably triple overnight. https://www.immobilienscout24.de/Suche/radius/wohnung-mieten...
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by fasouto on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:37AM (#40594246)
Unless is your main residence, then you can just call the police and the squatters will be evicted, no need to go to court.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by rightbyte on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:46AM (#40594679)
The laws are written in such a way to protect tenants from landlords.

A shady landlord will just claim the tenants are squatters.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by tomjakubowski on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:36PM (#40604470)
tenants with a signed lease, a record of rent payments, correspondence with the shady landlord, etc. can simply show them in court and prove otherwise?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by rightbyte on Friday June 07, 2024 @07:42PM (#40614033)
Yes, but not if you are evicted by the police in 48h?
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by pnut on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:17AM (#40594874)
I don't get it.

You have keys to the place. There's no written contract, no money changing hands.

Show up with some muscle, chuck the losers out on the street and change the locks.

What are they going to do, take you to court?

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by southerntofu on Thursday June 06, 2024 @04:58AM (#40595128)
From a legal standpoint, assaulting people is illegal. Assaulting them in their residence (trespassing) could be even more illegal. They definitely could take you to court.

From a moral standpoint, do you realize you're advocating for the mafia here? That's exactly what private mafia companies have been doing for years. Rightful owners enjoying their property are already well protected by the law and the police (too much actually), at least in western Europe, as explained by other commenters.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Manuel_D on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:22AM (#40597761)
The okupas are the ones running the extortion racket. If anyone is acting like the Mafia, it's the people illegally occupying the house and demanding money to leave.

What happens in the US is that the land owner hires people to squat in the house. They don't lay a finger on the real squatters. They just take up all the rooms and generally make it annoying to live there until they leave. Then they get paid by the landowner and move out.

This has resulted in lots of funny videos where squatters get angry at other squatters for squatting. The hypocrisy is astounding.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by southerntofu on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:42AM (#40606959)
> If anyone is acting like the Mafia, it's the people illegally occupying the house and demanding money to leave.

People demand housing, not money. It's not a racket that people are homeless and need a place to live. It's funny how you go into conspirational thinking that quick. It's more concerning that you think it's better to pay the anti-squat mafia tons of cash, rather than give the same amount to the squatters to leave the place so they can find another home.

> This has resulted in lots of funny videos where squatters get angry at other squatters for squatting.

Just because you live in a squat doesn't mean anyone can come and live there. It's your residence, not a public space. There's enough empty dwellings to house everyone decently. That doesn't make it a moral obligation if you are struggling and squat a home to house every single homeless person that comes by. I mean, you don't have a greater moral obligation for that than someone who rents or owns their home.

It's not hypocrisy to get angry at assholes trying to ruin your life when you're already low on cash and living in precarious housing. It's cruel that you would find human misery "funny".

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by Manuel_D on Friday June 07, 2024 @01:12PM (#40610657)
> People demand housing, not money

Wrong. Okupas often demand money in exchange for leaving the house.

> But there is now a darker phenomenon too - squatters who demand a "ransom" before they will leave a property

https://www.bbc.com/news/stories-58310532

> Just because you live in a squat doesn't mean anyone can come and live there. It's your residence, not a public space

Do you really not see the hypocrisy of this statement?

"It doesn't mean anyone can come and live there. It's your residence, not a public space."

Then how on earth do you defend squatters moving into another person's residence illegally? This is the kind of laughable hypocrisy typically displayed when squatters come back to house they've illegally occupied and meet some new housemates. It's amazing how they can rationalize that it's acceptable for them to move into people's homes without permission, but not acceptable for other people to do the same.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ImJamal on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:07PM (#40602912)
It is not their residence. They broke in and just moved in.

Kicking out people who are trespassing is how you have a safe and lawful society. Allowing private citizens to do whatever they feel like to innocent people is mafia like behavior.

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by southerntofu on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:36AM (#40606920)
It is their residence. That's the semantic difference between residence and ownership. You may reside somewhere without owning it, and vice-versa.

Now, breaking into people's residence is a different matter, and is already highly criminalized. Laws about squatting and tenants rights don't exist in the void without a reason: they are supposed to be a balance between ownership rights and housing rights. Allowing the real estate mafia to make its own law is not exactly a balance...

Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by ricardobayes on Thursday June 06, 2024 @06:34AM (#40595797)
No, not for your primary residence. You can report that anytime and they will act immediately.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by dghughes on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:45AM (#40596742)
Madness is the story I just saw of a woman who bought land in Hawaii and someone else built a house on it. Then squatters arrived. Then the developer sued her. What a mess.
Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem by the_gipsy on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:33AM (#40608548)
Not your home. Never. 2nd apartment/house, yes.