Re:Squatting in Spain: Understanding Spain's "okupas" problem
by asoneth on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:05PM
(#40589876)
> That is not what GP advocated for
Exactly, that's why before I responded to your question ("why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?") I tried to make it clear that I think there are better approaches than what the GP is advocating for i.e. seizing vacant properties.
> This is a tortuous chain of logic to get from building with squatters to government overthrown.
Can you be more specific about what part you disagree with?
To be clear, I'm not arguing that squatting results in overthrown governments, but that the acceptance of widespread squatting is sometimes a (shortsighted) policy response to a housing crisis. Squatting is a symptom, what can actually topple governments is sufficiently high levels of homelessness. Any government that allows a sufficiently large percentage of people (especially young people) to become homeless will eventually be replaced by anarchy or a new government that does.
To reiterate, I'm just trying to answer your question of what right the government has to tell you what to do with your property -- I'm not specifically defending the GP's suggestion.
Exactly, that's why before I responded to your question ("why would the government have any right to tell me what to do with my building?") I tried to make it clear that I think there are better approaches than what the GP is advocating for i.e. seizing vacant properties.
> This is a tortuous chain of logic to get from building with squatters to government overthrown.
Can you be more specific about what part you disagree with?
To be clear, I'm not arguing that squatting results in overthrown governments, but that the acceptance of widespread squatting is sometimes a (shortsighted) policy response to a housing crisis. Squatting is a symptom, what can actually topple governments is sufficiently high levels of homelessness. Any government that allows a sufficiently large percentage of people (especially young people) to become homeless will eventually be replaced by anarchy or a new government that does.
To reiterate, I'm just trying to answer your question of what right the government has to tell you what to do with your property -- I'm not specifically defending the GP's suggestion.