If I recall Egypt partially did that after the military coup, and some Gulf countries. None of which are known for being kind to criticism. So this point is more validating of Aljazeera's position as relatively honest journalism in the a region full of dictatorships and corrupt governments.
Regardless, a news organizing funded by a monarchy not exactly known for its human and civilian rights mostly like has an agenda beyond "honest journalism".
BTW both have very high standards and make excellent journalism.
I'd like to see examples of bad Al Jazeera journalism instead of just attacks to Qatar monarchy.
With respect to everything except the middle east.
I won't deny that they have generally good coverage on many subjects, but the nuance is that they leverage / launder that credibility towards advancing the state aims of Qatar whenever needed.
And as OP mentioned, if you look up how AJ covers a topic in English and how they cover it in Arabic, it's wildly different.
And journalism can be technically right while still showing a very one sided view.
Not that I'm pro ban, just saying that there's a good reason to be vigilant when it comes to their news coverage and make sure it's not you're only source.
wahnfrieden is apparently an October 7 denier and is annoyed that the BBC does think it happened.
And there is plenty of reporting on the atrocity propaganda lies Zaka spread, but here is an Israeli publication's reporting: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-01-31/ty-article-ma...
NYT also repeated discredited lies: https://theintercept.com/2024/02/28/new-york-times-anat-schw...
Detractors say that discrediting Zaka propaganda is equivalent to Oct 7 denial full-stop, even though Israeli publications have also discredited their claims (I guess Haaretz must also be an Oct 7 denier) - you can be the judge of that
We have a constitution that protects our rights, and among them a right to make up our minds on the basis of an uncensored discourse. That's the other, implicit half of the first amendment: the right to listen to what others want to tell you.
And the E.U. banned Russia's RT media network, and has strict rules over foreign-owned media. This is all just the pot calling the kettle black to score points with anti-Israel domestic audiences. Literally every country complaining about it has some kind of similar restriction. Qatar doesn't recognize Israel as a state and has funded Hamas for years; Israel banning their state-owned media domestically is only controversial because some people find Israel to be controversial. Qatar complaining about it is especially ironic, since they hand out life sentences in prison for criticizing the Qatari government (e.g. Qatari poet Mohammed al-Ajami).
https://www.freedomforum.org/non-citizens-protected-first-am...
The US Constitution applies to any US Person - someone within the US’ international borders, regardless of citizenship status.
Banning a foreign news outlet who broadcasts outside the US isn’t violating anyone’s 1st amendment rights.
This is basically untrue. At times, the court has applied different standards to speech by residents, but this does not mean that they would allow the government to apply any kind of limit on their speech, or indeed, more than very narrow ones.
In addition, the first amendment also covers the right to receive information.
Foreign ownership rules are not the same thing as the EU banning RT through legal means, or Israel shutting down Al-Jazeera and instituting internet blocks. You will notice that RT is not blocked in the US, nor is any other foreign media company.
https://x.com/Esqueer_/status/1785637622582309038
https://x.com/Esqueer_/status/1783707046430319067
You can not. Inciting violence and calls for criminal action is a well establish limit of the First Amendment, but that is not what they are doing from what I gathered in this thread.
From the poster a few levels above:
> In the case of Israel, the Middle-Eastern unit were literally showing videos demanding further uprising against Israel across the region directly from Hamas. Also the entire point of Al Jazeera was for Qatar to provide political influence through media, not as an unbiased news agency.
Showing a video of an enemy of the country calling for genocide of that country is a newsworthy event that is part of journalistic practice. The American media showed Osama Bin Laden videos calling for the death of Americans, to report on him.
Please learn the difference of showing a video of a terrorist calling for genocide to report on him vs the news anchor/owner of that news company agreeing with that terrorist and joining that call for genocide.
America has other limits on free speech. Foreign control of media for example which I am not familiar with.
There is more to it than that. The Supreme Court has held that “advocacy of the use of force” is only unprotected when it is “directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action” and is “likely to incite or produce such action.”
Brandenburg v Ohio (the current standard for what constitutes incitement) literally says your free speech rights run up to and include advocacy for violent overthrow of the government. The limitation it establishes is "incitement to imminent lawless action", with heavy emphasis on "imminent".
I'd hope this only applies to the government though and not towards groups of people or ethnicity.
However, if you agree that Brandenburg set the correct limit, you can conditionalize aid on it. It’s just not a first principles approach.
Saying "ethnic group XXX should be exterminated" does not meet the standard for incitement. I don't know why the debate has become about US law but I'm even more puzzled about so many people confidently stating, wrongly, that the US bans hate speech. The US has frequently been criticized by Europeans for this exact reason -- in their view, the US stance permitting hate speech is irresponsible.
Had cops show up at the home of a child that was on a sports team of my daughter's. They were looking for her brother and took him in.
Afterwards we spoke more to her mother and found out that users in game forums had told him he could make these kinds of comments and it was free speech as long it wasn't a call to violence. Well I don't know the legalities, but I do know he was never welcome back at that school. (Nor even in the district for that matter.) Worse, the neighboring district got word, and they implemented their own machinations to ensure he was effectively banned from there as well. In the end, they sent him to live with relatives.
I wouldn't be so cavalier about telling people they can say things like this. It's like, well you can say anything. But if you say things that make oblique suggestions towards violence, expect to watched from that point on. And excluded from any activities that people believe would provide you opportunity to act on what they now suspect to be your intentions. You can't talk about indirect suggestions of violence against airliners, presidents, or students in high schools and still expect to be able to show up at the White House, or board an airliner, or go to the high school you attend. Society doesn't work like that these days.
Or https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/28/us/pastors-praise-anti-ga...
Yes. We see this with open chants of "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" and "Globalize the Intifada"
...as long as the call is not likely to produce "imminent lawless action". Brandenburg v. Ohio was a decision by the Supreme Court establishing the "imminent lawless action" test for determining when speech advocating illegal conduct is not protected by the First Amendment. The Court held that speech is protected unless it is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action.
I particularly object to taking worst possible interpretation, and labelling the slogan as a call for ethnic cleansing.
The phrase "will be free" would not normally be interpreted this was in in any other conflict.
Once again, we know that "free" in "Free Palestine" does not mean "freedom, sovereignty, self-rule" to Palestinians because every time Israel offers to facilitate a peace process ending in those things for Palestinians, it is rejected with violence by Palestinians (intifada). What "free" in "Free Palestine" means to Palestinians is "free of infidels". That is the bailey.
I don't know why we Westerners bend over backwards in an effort not to apply the most obvious, blatant, explicitly stated "interpretation" of Palestian behavior. I think we Westerners have largely forgotten the existence and real effect of implacable religious and ethnic hatred carried for centuries. We dismiss it as a motive because it is simply not in our direct, living experience. In fact, that may be a defining trait of Western.
Honestly not even sure what to say about the second paragraph, other than that “implacable religious and ethnic hatred” is definitely a deeply held Western value. We don’t have a monopoly on it, but the idea that we are the uniquely moral ones, while all those other people are just motivated by hatred… sheesh.
In 2005, the unilateral withdrawal from Gaza meant the IDF leaving and taking all Jews from the area with them. That's about as pro-peace as you can get. Israel saying in essence "Here you go, Palestinians. Take all of Gaza in peace. No strings attached. We will supply you with water and electricity too!"
Gazans elected Hamas and then fired so many rockets at Israelis that they had to invent a new technology to protect themselves. Gazans dug tunnels under the border with Israel for no other purpose than to kill Israelis.
Yeah, like most humans, we Westerners have experience of hate, but no, Westerners do not have living experience of that level of hate. Well, Jews do.
For someone who thinks the rest of us are so ignorant on this...
Gaza's (only) Airport, which had its radar station and control tower bombed in 2001, and its runways cut up by IDF bulldozers in 2002.
Gaza's port has been intermittently blockaded by the Israeli Navy since 2005, and permanently since 2007.
> Exit and entry into Gaza by sea or air is prohibited. There are only three crossings in and out of Gaza, two of them controlled by Israel and one by Egypt. Israel heavily regulates Palestinians' movement through Erez, with applications considered only for a small number of laborers (less than 5% of the number considered in 2000) and for limited medical and humanitarian reasons.[6] Israel's military cooperation with Egypt and its control of the population registry (through which it controls who can obtain the necessary travel documents) gives it influence over movement through Rafah.
Certainly sounds like "access to the rest of the world" is being prohibited.
Hamas was propped up by the hard right wing because they made a more visible enemy.
So, if Hamas is dedicated to "exterminating Jews" as you say, then why would Israel give them funding and support against the PLA?
Hamas is ~38,000 of 2.5M people. And thanks to those embargoes and blockades, they're the only ones who are really armed in Palestine.
2005, unilateral withdrawal from Gaza
2006, Gazans peacefully went about their lives, setting up - and minding their own - businesses, made trade contacts, geared up a booming tourist industry...? No. That's not what happened, is it. I'm sure you can find a way to blame Israel for Palestinian choices, but that helps no one.
2007, blockade, out of the blue with no rhyme or reason. Just to flex, and watch the world burn.
If you care about peace, you won't do these weird contortions to explain Israel's actions. As with Hamas, Israel explains the reasons for its actions very clearly but largely boils down to "leave us alone or FAFO".
The PLO had ordered its military/paramilitary to not antagonize Israel, and they weren't. That was one of the keys to sitting at the negotiation table. And there had been a few false starts. Israel, in response to those false starts, entirely reasonably, left the table. But then there was a period of reasonable calm.
Palestinians are not attacking Israel - this isn't a war.
Hamas continued to have a militant and extremist position, which included attacking Israel.
^ There, answering your question, acknowledging that Hamas had and continues to attack Israel.
Now answer mine:
Why did Israel fund and prop up Hamas rather than the PLO who was working towards a peaceable situation?
Like you said, Hamas are attacking Israel. But the Likud administration sent them money and supported them.
Why?
Seems contradictory. Which is it?
And I ask again: there were no reasonable security concerns behind the blockade according to you? Just for evil funsies?
> For years, the Qatari government had been sending millions of dollars a month into the Gaza Strip — money that helped prop up the Hamas government there. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel not only tolerated those payments, he had encouraged them.
> Mossad chief, David Barnea, was asked a question that had not been on the agenda: Did Israel want the payments to continue?
> Mr. Netanyahu’s government had recently decided to continue the policy, so Mr. Barnea said yes.
Source: "‘Buying Quiet’: Inside the Israeli Plan That Propped Up Hamas" - https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-q...
> The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from
> For years, the various governments led by Benjamin Netanyahu took an approach that divided power between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank — bringing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas to his knees while making moves that propped up the Hamas terror group.
> The idea was to prevent Abbas — or anyone else in the Palestinian Authority’s West Bank government — from advancing toward the establishment of a Palestinian state.
Source: "For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces" - https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up...
I suppose the Times of Israel is anti-semitic, too?
> And I ask again: there were no reasonable security concerns behind the blockade according to you? Just for evil funsies?
There's no room for conversation here. You doggedly hang on to issues even after they've been answered.
I literally said "Hamas was actively attacking Israel".
> "Yes, Hamas was financed by the government of Israel in an attempt to weaken the Palestinian Authority led by Fatah," Borrell said in a speech in the University of Valladolid in Spain without elaborating.
EU Foreign Policy Chief Josep Borrell.
> "Blowback: How Israel Went from Creating Hamas to Bombing It"
Source: https://theintercept.com/2018/02/19/hamas-israel-palestine-c...
This isn't anti-semitic conspiracy theory.
And what do you have? "Some guy on HN says Israel (and the US) supported the PLO against Hamas".
Huh. US involvement: "The US committed $59 million for training and non-lethal equipment for the Presidential Guard".
Fun fact, the amount that was sent to Hamas with Netanyahu's -specific and explicit- approval was around that much... every month... for near two decades.
But, as mentioned, I cannot see fruitful outcomes from further discussion here.
I regret the phrasing “U.S. and Israel backed coup”, since it makes them sound like equal participants and the discussion is now marginalizing the U.S.’s involvement. But like I said elsewhere, both the coup attempt and Israel’s support for Hamas at other points in time are well documented.
Parent keeps harping about Hamas coming to power in 2006 and that that is when the blockades started and that people should "figure out why those dates align", steadfastly refusing to acknowledge that the airport had been bombed in 1999 and runways dug up in 2001.
Oh, and any claim about Hamas being supported by Israel is apparently anti-semitic.
Who said that? Why did they say that?
You did? It was buried under lots of anti-Israel rhetoric that it was hard to see.
The blockade was introduced to the discussion as yet but one more example of Israel oppressing the poor Gazans, presented as if it were some kind of arbitrary evil simply to control Gazans with no other rhyme or reason. It turns out that there was a reason, actually. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40271323
So, without cruft:
2005: Israel withdrew from Gaza
2007: Israel blockades Gaza
we have "Hamas actively attacked Israel"
It seems a very straightforward cause and effect.
> Come on, you're actively avoiding anything that paints Israel as less than saintly.
Not at all. However, I do note with sadness that you and the other guy could not simply answer the question. Lots of diversion into how awful Israel is before at last a grudging admission that the blockade was in response to attacks.
Do you think it's at least possible that your firm and unwavering anti-Israel stance is informed itself by this kind of rhetoric? Just a thought.
Ok, now that that's established, I'll dig into this allegation of Netenyahu funding Hamas in order to deny Palestinians a state. And while I'm at it the other guy's allegation that at the same time Israel funded a coup against Hamas. Sounds suss out of the gate but who knows? Maybe this is the smoking gun that Israel is led by demons.
I find that most anti-Israel rhetoric is like that. Israel builds a wall in response to a wave of attacks: "Israel is building an open air prison". Israel blockades Gaza in response to tunnels: "Israel just wants to control Gazans lives" and so forth. Israel destroying an airport? Gee, I wonder why they did that? What possible reason could those monsters have for doing such a despicable act? Any ideas?
Did you know that Finland is building a wall on her border with Russia? In response to what, would you guess?
Is one of these walls ok but the other not? If not, why not? A wall is the most passive thing one can do to protect one's national borders, and yet, somehow you present it as yet another example of Israeli evil. Why Palestinians should have the right to stroll onto Israeli grounds anytime they please remains unexplained.
There certainly is a theme here of imputing malevolence even to Israel's most mild, passive response to actual violence by Palestinians. Are you infuriated by the Iron Dome as well?
While you’re looking at the last six months, perhaps also look at what Israeli government officials have been saying for years. Just last week Bezalel Smotrich called for the “complete destruction” of Gaza — far more explicitly genocidal than “from the river to the sea” — and for the annexation of the West Bank if the UN were to recognize a Palestinian state. That level of hate is, at the very least, heartily reciprocated.
I am Jewish, by the way. So inasmuch as this affects Jews as a whole — rather than Israelis specifically — it’s not abstract for me.
And you never answered the question. Why were those measures put in place?
Anyway, I’ll play ball. First of all, Israel controlled Palestinian movement into and out of the Gaza strip for years before Hamas came into power.
In 2000, during the Second Intifada, Israel closed Yasser Arafat International Airport — the only international airport in Gaza. The next year they destroyed it.
In 2005, Israel withdrew all settlements from Gaza out of concern that if the Palestinian population kept growing, it would threaten Israel’s ability to be a Jewish state.
In 2006, Hamas was elected in Gaza with a plurality of the vote. After the U.S. and Israel backed the previous incumbents Fatah in an attempted coup, Hamas seized full control of the Gaza strip. This is about when Israel imposed the full blockade.
about is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. Let's walk through more slowly.
Israel withdrew from Gaza when? Then imposed a blockade when and in response to what?
I'm hearing that Netanyahu supported Hamas, now I'm hearing from you Israel supported Fatah. Which is it? Either way, or both, it sounds pretty nefarious of these wiley, shifty Israelis. They do this simply because they are evil or is there a charitable interpretation that they are addressing a a specific concern?
Netanyahu was not the prime minister at the time of the blockade.
Anyway, if you want to read about the coup attempt: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2008/04/gaza200804
I also made another comment citing Netanyahu stating why he supports Hamas: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40274152
This is all well documented. But it seems like you are intent on finding charitable interpretations for Israel’s actions while not searching further than “they hate Jews” for Palestine’s. So unless that stance changes, I don’t really see any point in further discussion.
Me: Why did Israel and Egypt blockade Gaza?
You: Did you know that Israel supported a coup against Fatah?
What would get me interested:
You: The blockade came in response to a serious of tunnel attacks and is an attempt to limit materials that could be used to attack Israel. But there is important context that's missing. Hamas came to power after an attempted coup, and...
I'll check into your 2 allegations and report back.
Regarding "the Israeli government supported Hamas", from the NYT:
For years, the Qatari government had been sending millions of dollars a month into the Gaza Strip — money that helped prop up the Hamas government there. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel not only tolerated those payments, he had encouraged them.
... Allowing the payments — billions of dollars over roughly a decade — was a gamble by Mr. Netanyahu that a steady flow of money would maintain peace in Gaza, the eventual launching point of the Oct. 7 attacks, and keep Hamas focused on governing, not fighting.
...Mr. Netanyahu’s critics disparage them as part of a strategy of “buying quiet,” and the policy is in the middle of a ruthless reassessment following the attacks.
Is that a fair excerpt?
Regarding "Israel and the US attempted a coup against Hamas" the gist appears to be that Bush the younger (really, as an aside, the worst President the US has had in my lifetime and I'm old enough to have been alive during the Nixon administration) supported a coup against Hamas in an incompetent attempt to create conditions for a the formation of a Palestinian state during his Presidency.
Is that fair? Probably not, because I don't have much patience for Bush shenanigans and it was hard to read.
> tightly controlled land border
for people who think border is there for security, you should be aware that Israel has, for years, blocked imports of essential sanitary products and food items into Gaza, i.e. toilet paper, soap, and humus. Many of the tunnels under gaza were built for smuggling in these items. United states has long protested this policy:
https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE52A5TA/
> Failure of the peace process
in 1995 Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, was assassinated by Israeli religious extremist to sabotage the peace process
> The perpetrator was Yigal Amir, a 25-year-old former Hesder student and far-right law student at Bar-Ilan University. Amir had strenuously opposed Rabin's peace initiative, particularly the signing of the Oslo Accords, because he felt that an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank would deny Jews their "biblical heritage which they had reclaimed by establishing settlements".
Netanyahu has been supporting and funding Hamas for years, specifically and explicitly to prevent recognition of a Palestinian state. Direct quote: “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas.”
https://archive.md/2024.04.07-081801/https://www.haaretz.com...
But yeah, I’m sure all those peace offers were totally legitimate and it’s Palestine’s fault for never being satisfied.
Oh, now I understand! This is but a simple misunderstanding! How silly, but easy to clear up.
You see, the tunnels came first - into Israel in order to kill Israelis. Only then did Israel and Egypt blockade Gaza. Had nothing to do with smuggling. Now that that is cleared up, you can distrust Hamas and trust Israel. Unless, of course, there's another misunderstanding in your way that I can clear up for us all?
https://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3267217,00.html (note the date, 2006 - after withdrawal in 2005 but before the blockade in 2007)
But also, that Ynet article is just stenography for the IDF! The only sources are IDF officers and the Israeli defense minister. Why would anyone believe this is not just manufacturing a pretext for escalation?
Why would anyone believe that?
For several decades, Israel's Likud party (currently in power) election manifesto was...
"From the river to the sea, there will be only Israeli sovereignty".
Perhaps that's where the Palestinians got it?
"Palestine will be free" is not "openly calling for murder".
Free as in judenfrei https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judenfrei
Concrete examples: “Jews will not replace us” is protected speech; “everyone go out and find a Jew” to an angry mob is probably not.
In terms of civil law you can generally sue anyone for anything at anytime unless there is existing law or contracts halting further civil actions.
Meanwhile Israeli citizens cannot read Al Jazeera legally now.
I think it would be a mistake to characterize the difference between Israeli media and pro Palestinian media as simply disagreeing about numbers. If we’ve learned anything about global conflict, numbers don’t mean anything to people. If all Al Jazeera were doing is putting a black text white background body count on screen, there would have been no issue.
The difference is the images that are being depicted. People are moved by images of suffering. And depending on whose side you’d like to benefit, there’s plenty of suffering to show. This is likely one of the reasons Israel is shooting journalists. They might show pictures that complicate their black and white depiction of the conflict.
It’s also a trap to say that showing one side diminishes the suffering of the other. Fundamentally, neither’s suffering is more important.
Haha. And we're going to let the government decide what is "correct" and "accurate"?
Letting whoever is currently in power control what information the electorate has access to is one of the single biggest threats to democracy.
> Al Jazeera making up causality figures in real-time isn’t how you make up your mind.
The correct response is pointing out that their numbers are made up. In a working democracy you get people to see truth through public discourse, not censorship.
Don't make a deal with the devil just to shut up the neighbor's annoying dog.
in an idealistic world, this is true.
Unfortunately, it is also empirically true that, at least in the USA, the majority of the voting population has become a bit dumb, and does not personally try to verify these things they see or hear on the news.
Civic duty in democracy includes this sort of scrutiny, but sadly this level of critical thinking has been in decline in recent decades.
Ok, so how did all this unchecked exposure to propaganda workout for Russia, China, North Korea, Iran, Palestine etc? Did it lead to some kind of "free thinking" utopia?
Free speech hasn't been banned in Israel. Access to information hasn't been banned. What has been banned is a platform for foreign agents to easily negative influence their populace and to broadcast nonsense en masse to their people.
If any Al Jazeera staff who have a residency permit want to walk the streets and discuss things their passionate about to other people, it will be allowed. But it won't be allowed if it turns out their being paid to do so by a foreign government. It's no different.
Sorry to say this, but you have yet offered a sane alternative here.
We can't just have autocrats from foreign countries broadcasting nonsense, unabated to whoever wants to listen, else our society will look no different to those dystopias.
Domestic free speech within a democracy is one thing, foreign interference is another.
You did not think this argument through. None of the aforementioned countries have free press. They censor heavily.
In all of the above countries the government dictates what is "correct" and "accurate" information. News outlets saying anything else are shut down, banned, and journalists are sometimes jailed.
All of these non-democracies are afraid of free press. Is that the company Israel wants to keep in this matter?
> Access to information hasn't been banned [in Israel].
Al Jazeera is literally banned and blocked.
> We can't just have autocrats from foreign countries broadcasting nonsense, unabated to whoever wants to listen, else our society will look no different to those dystopias.
This defeatist argument leads to the conclusion that democracy cannot work. Democracy cannot work without free press, and according to you it cannot work if press is free from government interference.
Is that what we want to do? Give up?
You cannot let the legislative decide what constitutes an "enemy disinformation campaign" and what is "free press". It's an obvious weak spot in your democracy bad actors can exploit - far more dangerous than foreign propaganda that has to measure up against friendly outlets.
Anyway, I get your point but the difference here is this, you're allowed to ask questions like that in the very places where this nonsense is being fabricated.
That same toxic propaganda shouldn't be allowed to spread freely and unabated within our information space or we become those very dystopias we try to avoid.
I think this blind belief that "all information" is part of "free speech" is our Achilles heel, it might destroy our country.
BBC is known to have issues with factuality.
https://deadline.com/2023/10/bbc-wrong-to-speculate-on-gaza-...
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/21/bbc-reporter-nig...
But to address your point:
https://www.aljazeera.net/news/2024/5/3/%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B3%D...
"Russia is ready to discuss serious peace proposals, and Zelensky is rushing British weapons "
There is a spectrum of factuality, BBC News has problems with the govt threatening to shut it down if it doesn’t report what the govt wants it to report, but it’s no Russia Today, Daily Mail, or Fox News.
I am failing to see how an article about Russia's war correlates to OP's claim about Al Jazeera showing Hamas videos calling for an uprising. Can we get a direct link to the article that the OP mentioned?
> "Russia is ready to discuss serious peace proposals, and Zelensky is rushing British weapons "
Is that not correct? Or what's the problem with it? A basic translate + fact check seems it's basically correct?
"Russia is ready to discuss serious peace proposals, and Zelensky is rushing British weapons
"
Just a minute of searching directly.
https://www.memri.org/search-results?country_id_report%5B0%5...
There's nothing more shocking than the stuff Ben Gvir (security minister of Israel) does or says.
The second interview even references his calls to burn women and children as, yknow, a bad thing.
"memri" doesnt seem to consider that valid context, that is probably because it is a state propaganda outfit acting on behalf of that same Israeli minister who openly expressed a desire to burn women and children.
So you seem to be trying to hold Al Jazeera to a vastly higher standard than mainstream US media, at least in this particular regard.
Simply reporting without comment on what important/influential individuals and groups are saying, and adding basic objective context, is a large part of mainstream journalism.
Pushback is often limited to the opinion pages.
The mainstream US news media would fall foul of broadcasting standards laws in a lot of liberal Western democracies. Here in the UK, due impartiality is a legal duty of news broadcasters. The First Amendment is not the norm globally and the US is exceptionally laissez-faire when it comes to the regulation of broadcast news.
https://www.ofcom.org.uk/tv-radio-and-on-demand/broadcast-co...
This describes most interviews I've seen with Israeli government officials in the American press, although it's starting to change over the last few months.
The most-read newspaper in Israel, Israel Hayom, is owned by a friend of Bibi. Is it impartial? Should it be shut down?
In English:
Ceasefire negotiatios failed again
In Arabic, same news item:
Hamas spokesperson says they'll keep killing and raping Israeli's next time in Jerusalem and NEVER accept a ceasefire until all Jews are dead
Whether this is more or less dramatic/problematic than what some Israeli politicians say is not the point. I would also like to point out that you see the same on twitter, facebook, tiktok. Victimization in English, Threats, racism and claims of victory in Arabic.
It's hard for me to believe that your "Arabic" version is genuine. But if that's just me being naive, then I'd like to understand the truth, but I need actual evidence for that.
So if there are genuine headlines like that on Al Jazeera, it should be trivial for you to provide a couple of representative links that we can run through Google Translate to verify?
Really was not hard to find.
So, for instance:
"تواصلت الاشتباكات بين القوات الإسرائيلية ومقاومين فلسطينيين بمواقع داخل إسرائيل، وذلك مع دخول اليوم الثالث من عملية طوفان الأقصى التي أطلقتها كتائب عز الدين القسام التابعة لحركة المقاومة الإسلامية حماس ضد الاحتلال الإسرائيلي..."
"The clashes between the Israeli forces and Palestinian resistance fighters continued at locations inside Israel, as the third day of the Al-Aqsa Flood operation launched by the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades of the Islamic Resistance Movement Hamas against the Israeli occupation proceeds..."
1. "مقاومين فلسطينيين" (Palestinian resistance fighters): The term "resistance fighters" conveys a sense of legitimacy and heroism to the Palestinian combatants, compared to more neutral terms like "militants" or "combatants."
2. "الاحتلال الإسرائيلي" (the Israeli occupation): This phrase inherently carries a negative connotation and frames Israel as an occupying force, which is a viewpoint that aligns with Palestinian narratives and is contentious in international discussions.
3. "عملية طوفان الأقصى" (Al-Aqsa Flood operation): The operation's name itself, invoking the Al-Aqsa mosque—a highly symbolic and emotive site in the conflict—suggests a righteous or justified struggle, further aligning the narrative with Palestinian perspectives.
These choices in vocabulary serve to frame the conflict in a way that emphasizes Palestinian resistance against an unjust "occupation," aligning closely with the Palestinian viewpoint and potentially eliciting a sympathetic response from Arab audiences.
This framing influences how readers perceive the events, creating a less neutral, more partisan view of the conflict.
https://www.aljazeera.net/news/liveblog/2023/10/7/%D9%82%D8%...
This language makes it extremely difficult to have a conversation about the conflict. Everything Israel does is framed as nefarious and evil.
Your last point seems to be unawareness that the name given is Hamas’ official name for that operation. Using it in the quoted sentence seems very similar to, say, reporting that U.S forces attacked Houthi rebel positions in the sixth month of Operation Prosperity Guardian. Whether or not you like the term, it’s the official name and it’s reasonable to expect readers to be familiar with it.
That it's wrong doesn't matter to most people. "Occupied land" has a specific, legal definition that in no way applies to Israel or Gaza, and probably does not apply to the West Bank. And, see, already I'm losing this discussion: with just a single misused word "occupation" you - perhaps unintentionally - sewed misinformation that needs to be unwound even assuming you have a good faith interest in doing that. Most anti Zionists are simply not interested.
So, yes, words matter. If you repeat that Israel has "occupied" territory "illegally" long enough in the media, people like yourself will accept it as true without really understanding what it means.
> That’s a lot less incendiary than your first example.
I don't know what you're taking about. This is my first contribution to the thread.
First: no, you're wrong about international law.
Because obviously not under the original resolution, that would have allocated all of Israel + Jordan to Israel.
Not under the 1948 resolution. That would have allocated all of Israel (including Gaza and West Bank) to Israel.
Not under the 1967 resolution. That would leave the situation as is. Israel where it is, and Gaza and West Bank.
But let's not forget, now complain and complain how the territory "for the Palestinians" is shrinking ...
And this is in fact the latest resolution. NONE of these resolutions where accepted by ANY party they're about. Israel accepted them, of course. Arabs tried to massacre in response to every resolution. So what validity do they have, any of them? Which means the "let's just accept reality on the ground" proposal, which is close to, but not quite the 1967 resolution, is by far the most reasonable. And which one is more just? I don't know man. I don't care.
Second: definitely no.
Because Hamas is not after Gaza. Or even Gaza + West Bank. Hamas is after destroying Israel entirely. The whole reason Hamas was created is to destroy the Oslo accords, through massacres. This is the reason they exist in the first place. This is the reason they killed people, mostly Palestinians, for more than two decades.
To now go back to "international law" is ... completely absurd.
And if we're about "land should be returned to the original inhabitants". We're talking about muslims here. EVERY SQUARE CM they inhabit is conquered land. Islam "was spread through the sword". If we're going to give conquered land back, let's be consistent. Let's start with Nagorno-Kharabagh, which was conquered by muslims just 5 months ago. Of course, instead of "this injustice" satisfying the muslim side, they're already threatening the next piece of land.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68882269
Then, perhaps, let's talk about Palestinians occupying Lebanese land, because that's exactly what Hezbollah is doing. Nobody cares, because they're also creating civil war in Lebanon and attacking Israel in an attempt to create yet another war, and that's much worse than driving out South Lebanese, but it doesn't mean it's not happening.
(and we're even ignoring the fact that the two factions inside Hezbollah, Palestinians and Iranians/Syrians, HATE eachother. If they ever get what they want, that will immediately start YET ANOTHER Lebanese civil war. They regularly kill a few of one another even now. For PEOPLE inside Hezbollah, and all of Lebanon, it would be far better if Hezbollah lost, meaning both many more lives will be saved AND those lives will be better)
(in fact, if the whole alliance Hezbollah, Syria, Iran lost as a whole, through regime change in Iran, it would massively improve the lives of a great many people. Such an outcome is by far the best possible outcome)
The UN has a resolution SPECIFICALLY saying Hezbollah must leave South Lebanon, and has a military force deployed in South Lebanon that is to make them leave. Last time they tried anything Hezbollah killed two UN soldiers, and since then nothing has happened.
And yet, both of these are just okay, or at least not worthy of mention, to you.
And the list of recent conquests is long and keeps going. Cyprus. South Sudan. PNG. Kashmir. Goes on and on and on.
Second if UN resolutions are "international law", then clearly you don't care about international law either. The "Hezbollah" (and Palestinians, really) should leave Lebanon is a LOT more direct than any Israel resolution. It is totally ignored, and nobody seems to care.
No you're just not being fair at all. Every argument you make rings very hollow and double-standard. Clearly Arabs (the original name for "Palestinians") believe in military action. Well, let them accept military reality when they lose. Which is what's going to happen anyway. It is what happened every time before now. It is what will happen again.
Are you for real?
Rashidun Caliphate (632–661)
Umayyad Caliphate (661–750)
Abbasid Caliphate (750–1258)
Fatimid Caliphate (909–1171)
Ayyubid Dynasty (1174–1260)
Mamluk Sultanate (1250–1517)
Ottoman Empire (1517–1918)
Where there is overlap, they ruled different parts of the area.
Personally, I think the idea of prior indigenous claim is counter productive, but since it has been introduced by Palestinians as a kind of volksgemeinschaft, blut und boden, Jews would have prior claim by that standard.
The folks who first brought up this "prior indigenous claim" business were the early Zionists of course. The pre-1897 inhabitants didn't have to "claim" any special rights because they were already there (give or take some forced migration within the Ottoman empire), and not trying to expand into any new territory they hadn't been occupying in living memory -- and so had nothing to justify or explain.
Anyway it's all moot because the earliest known inhabitants in the region were not Jews in any recognizable sense, but predominantly the Canaanites and other bronze age cultures. Whose presence predates any traces of the Israelite culture by 2000+ years. And who were likely the primary genetic reservoir for both Palestinians and Jews as they are currently known, via significant mixtures with other groups from outside the region.
The whole idea of attempting to adjudicate anything happening on the ground today on the basis of any of this history (or our current conception of it) is completely vacuous of course. As is this bizarre Blut und Boden reference that you're trying to asign to the Palestinians, of all people.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Edit: we've had to ask you this once before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33220658. Not cool. No more of this on HN, please.
Here, for example, note that use of the term occupied is established enough to be used in official UN documents:
https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/documents/hrbodies...
Similarly, the ICRC uses presence rather than trying to make complex judgements about the relative merits:
https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/resources/documents/misc/634kfc....
https://www-aljazeera-net.translate.goog/?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_t...
(yes, this strange URL is just Google translate translating the arabic frontpage of Al-Jazeera. Don't worry, they're not going to stop the double speak)
vs
Here's my take:
Arabic: https://www-aljazeera-net.translate.goog/news/2024/5/6/%d8%a...
Proudly declaring that Hezbollah attacks the Golan Heights of Israel with "booby-trapped drones". One might point out that booby trapping weapons is illegal under international law and a serious warcrime. A warcrime that even Russia, who see no problem with white phosphorous and poison gas, refuses to commit in Ukraine. Why? There's no telling who will be killed by booby trapped weapons (Booby trapped weapons legislation is about that will explode on impact, then explode again or otherwise injure people when it's getting cleaned up or examined. Because civilians might clean up weapons, or children might find them, this is a big no-no in international law)
The whole article is about using 10 different sources to brag how effective the attack was, and it just keeps and keeps going on about that. It mentions various sources, each more far fetched than the last, how "these types of rockets" cause enormous damage, death and injuries. It has no mention of this being a response to Israeli attacks, nor does it have any mention that Israel made a counterstrike.
It concludes by actually stating that the military campaign by Hezbollah is about to defeat the IDF.
English, same news event:
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/4/13/lebanons-hezbollah-...
In this, the "booby-trapped" part is gone, they are reporting it, pretending to be neutral about it (as opposed to in arabic, where they are anything but neutral) and the whole article starts trying to cause doubts about whether the attack happened at all.
Prominently featured in the article is that the Isreali military states no injuries where reported, and all the sources are suddenly gone. Instead, there is focus on that this is a "tit-for-tat" attack, that was really Israel's fault.
In other words, the article focuses on how this was a totally ineffective attack, that was justified because of Israeli killings in Lebanon, that absolutely does not merit any kind of counterattack.
In case you're wondering, Israeli press reported the same event:
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-05-06/ty-article-li...
https://www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-800017
https://www.ynetnews.com/article/s1joamlmc#autoplay
Summary:
1) 30 rockets (al Jazeera and Hezbollah reported many drones)
2) NO details, no statements from Hezbollah
3) it hit a town, Metulla, not a military base, either zero (Haaretz, Ynetnews) or two (Jerusalem Post) persons wounded, both civilians. The town, by the way, is in the foothills of the Golan heights at best, it is very much not actually in the Golan heights. But it's very close to Lebanon.
3) The IDF executed a military counterstrike, against military targets (which means Hezbollah launch sites)
https://www-aljazeera-net.translate.goog/where/arab/palestin...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al_Jazeera_controversies_and_c...
Have any citations?
Especially when you have, in your country, about 20% of muslim arabs, most of which being israelo-palestinians (i.e. palestinians with an israeli passport).
The last thing they'd want, in addition to fighting both Hamas and Hezbollah, would be an uprising of the israelo-palestinians who live in Israel.
It's of note that while there about 20% muslims in Israel, there's about zero jewish person in Gaza (there are some israelo-palestinian though) and zero jewish person in Iran. Or close to that.
The number of publication and jewish newspaper offices in both Gaza and Iran should also be food for thought.
You're talking about Israeli citizens. The way you keep them from uprising is by giving them political power. (I also see no evidence any uprising is imminent.)
Or they’re a diverse set of people whose views can’t be summarised based on their race and religion alone. I doubt, for example, many of them are in favour of a one-state solution.
Though I'm not a member of that group, so I don't want to misrepresent "their" views (and of course there is no such thing as "their" views, as you mentioned, they are a large and fairly diverse group).
> I doubt, for example, many of them are in favour of a one-state solution.
Why do you say that?
Israel is rich. Palestine is poor. It would be on par with a German or Korean reünification in terms of cost.
Also, Israel has a relatively-liberal voting population. Palestine does not. One could have reasonable concerns around losing valued freedoms if a single Palestinian state drifts towards regional norms.
Of course. The original point was that they defy, as a community, summary.
Muslim Israelis have representation in the Knesset. Their community simply hasn’t aligned itself with the American pro-Palestinian movement. (There are absolutely racism issues in Israel. But it’s not Jim Crow.)
> It's of note that while there about 20% muslims in Israel, there's about zero jewish person in Gaza (there are some israelo-palestinian though) and zero jewish person in Iran. Or close to that.
Actually, while there are ~zero Jewish people in almost all Arab countries, Iran specifically has an actual Jewish population, though a very small one - I think the current estimate is around 8,000.
Not only are there Jews in Iran, they even have a seat permanently reserved in the Iranian parliament.
The ethnic cleansing isn't totally complete, but it's quite close. It's nice that the Ayatolla made a fatwa to protect them though. But if I were Jewish in Iran I would expect that protection to fall the second the Ayatolla dies.
Sure, there used to be more. Sure, there are obviously better places to be as a Jew.
But ... I replied to the comment that said "there are no Jews in Iran" . There are Jews living in Iran. That's it.
It's easy to just claim something, but it's crucial to back your point up front when it's particularly sensitive so as to not inadvertently spread misinformation. You may be correct, but that's why the citations are needed.
> According to a news bulletin on the Qatar-based channel, Mr al-Hamr said the ban was being imposed because the station was biased towards Israel and against Bahrain.
> Mr al-Hamr is said to have accused the station of being infiltrated by Zionists. "We believe (Al Jazeera) is suspect and represents the Zionist side in the region. We will not deal with this channel because we object to its coverage of current affairs. It is a channel penetrated by Zionists," he was quoted as saying.
This is perhaps making the opposite point I think you intended to.
https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/06/14/media-blocked-threatened...
Although VoA is the USA's state sponsored news outlet, they have reasonably good analysis on what led up to the 2013 ban. https://www.voanews.com/a/al-jazeera-iraq/3306460.html
Sorry, but I can't just take your words for it. It looks more like propaganda.
The more I read Al Jazeera, the more I respect their high journalism standards. I'm from a third world country and really envy the quality of the news.
This is the entire point of all mass media. There is no such thing as unbiased news.
Saudi Arabia is not exactly a bastion of free speech and murdered US journalist Jamal Khashoggi using the cover of an embassy. Not exactly a great endorsement of what Israel is doing here.
If you mean that they were covering such demands and showing clips in which they are made etc. - what's the problem with that?
> for being a security risk.
goes to show they were doing some decent journalistic work then. Not that Al-Jazeera is saintly, or unbiased, or treats all subjects fairly etc. (they are under the indirect control of the Qatari government after all) - but they certainly offer critically important coverage of what's happening in Palestine in general, and Gaza in particular, which is very hard to get elsewhere.
> Why would you allow that to continue in your country?
If by "you", you mean a semi-totalitarian state which wants to silence coverage of its crimes and hide the horrors of its actions from the world and from its residents, then - you're right, you definitely wouldn't want it to continue operating.
The second half contains emotion which makes clear where your heart is on this. So, that casts a shadow of doubt.
Could it be that there is credibility to your point but not to such an extreme extent where it’s like this deliberate conspiracy? I mean, as soon as everyone finds out, then this would actually be kind of a dumb plan on their part. The Arabic audience can inform the English audience of the discrepancy and vice versa. What if it’s not a conspiracy but a consequence of a large organization containing a blend of biased opinionated departments? Some more focused on journalism, and some on catering to local audiences’ tastes. That would make more sense to me, along with the typical biases of all news-media orgs everywhere in the world..
You should do some reading up on Qatar's agenda, extremist groups like the Muslim Brotherhood, and how Al Jazeera fits into all of that.
This is part of the reason why some Arab countries have banned them.
What did you Google?
There's quite a few countries on there, I didn't realise it was so widely mistrusted in the Arab world.
https://www.secularism.org.uk/news/2021/11/death-sentence-fo...
FWIW it's what Qatar does. They've also been caught the hand in the cookie jar bribing EU officials:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eva_Kaili
She's a MEP and yet went on to defend Qatar as a bastion of democracy (!). Close to a million EUR was found in cash at her apartment: which probably helped defend a country where the official law is the Sharia law as a bastion of democracy.
War is ugly but religious extremism is ugly too, especially when it's financed by a shitload of oil.
People would do well to wonder who's financing all these "grassroots" movements in the EU and the US defending people who voted in power a terrorist organization who swore by the death of Israel.
If you value liberty or democracy the only valid question is: why wouldn’t you?
The point is, in the US we forget that our speech didn’t used to be so unrestricted. What some countries call a security risk, in America we would call essential political speech.
Of course there remains the question of the extent to which we should support countries which do not share our values.
Isn't this the point of any news organization whatsoever?
This is a fact best appreciated in the context of the Sunni-Shi'a sectarian divide.
Anyway, you know which news outlets also have local and international versions with different content? BBC, CNN, ...
Also western democracies allowed "Letter to the American People" to be published in full. Also a messaging from an active terror group with significant impact at the time, more significant than Oct 7.
So yeah, countries allow that stuff.
In the case of Israel, the Middle-Eastern unit were literally showing videos demanding further uprising against Israel across the region directly from Hamas. Also the entire point of Al Jazeera was for Qatar to provide political influence through media, not as an unbiased news agency.
It's even banned in some Arab countries for being a security risk.
Why would you allow that to continue in your country?