News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by willvarfar on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:26AM (#39917171)
The U in UTC stands for Universal.

If we can't use UTC for whole universe, or even for the nearby solar system, should we rename it Coordinated Global or Earth Time (GTC or ETC) instead?

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by andrewla on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:29PM (#39919493)
What you are describing is not just impractical, it is actually impossible. Someone linked to "falsehoods programmers believe about time" but I think maybe "falsehoods non-physicists believe about time" might be more apt.

There is no such thing as a universal frame of reference is the somewhat depressing outcome of Einstein's theories.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Out_of_Characte on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:24PM (#39920311)
I dont think the GP is asking for a universal reference frame in the same way physics describes it. I think he's asking for a universal programmatic reference frame to describe the offsets that sattelites and lunar stations have.

Even though time runs faster on sattelites, and the signal delay differs based on position. Because the vectors of sattelites and the moon is constant, as well as the moons gravity, you could calculate what those offsets should be and synchronise clocks anyway.

To put it another way, you normalise the clock drift and the delay, whats left over is the same clock drift you'll need to account for when you have a quartz clock in your computer and a time server that runs an atomic clock.

The point being, clock drift can become a huge issue unless you define a specification that allows any equipment to sync up with any other clock in Time And Relative Dimensions In Space.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by jzemeocala on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:23PM (#39923358)
Nice Dr. WHO reference
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by whimsicalism on Saturday April 06, 2024 @03:49AM (#39950770)
if the sequencing of events is not even consistent between the reference points, what offsets would possible make sense?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by 317070 on Saturday April 06, 2024 @10:28AM (#39952730)
You can always say, "I observed event A at time X from position Y"

Relativity doesn't make time-keeping impossible. It just requires more clarity. UTC was implemented after Einstein passed away.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Retric on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:12PM (#39920123)
You can select a rest frame based on the velocity of all observable galaxies adjusted for the expansion of the universe and the impact of local sources of gravity.

As far as we can tell any observer would come to similar conclusions about that reference frame would be. It’s just not a particularly useful reference.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nyrikki on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:53PM (#39920668)
There is no objective concept of 'now' even at distance scales of Alpha Centauri with reasonable curvature and speeds.

If you want to stick to special relativity, the Andromeda paradox will show the problem with simultaneity with distance, and Einstein's train thought experiment about trains will show the problem of simultaneity with high speed.

The order of events, timing of events, and even causal structure of events are not fixed.

Even the Conventional Celestial Reference System is only quasi-inertial, only inertial like over small periods of time.

The incredible smoothness of the earth approximating a co-rotating frame with a high error tolerance is the only reason we can treat time as absolute on the surface of the Earth.

But to derive the new definition of the Kilogram requires lots of corrections as do modern atomic clocks.

Don't confuse the ability to choose a reference frame with the Newtonian concept of universal reference frames.

When making measurements SR is a framework that allows you to pick any reference frame that is convenient, but the speed of causality(light) prevents the existence of a universal reference frame.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Retric on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:09PM (#39921666)
> The order of events, timing of events, and even causal structure of events are not fixed.

You can calculate observed order of events for any reference frame from any reference frame. Thus they are fixed once everyone agrees to using a given reference frame.

It’s not much more complicated than seismic detectors recording the seismic waves from an earthquake at different times based on their location. Sure detector X see earthquakes in order A, B, C and detector Y sees them in order C, B, A they would both agree that detector Z should see them in order A, C, B based on it’s location, the timing of the events, and wave propitiation speeds.

It only seems unintuitive because you aren’t used to accounting for such issues.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nyrikki on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:52PM (#39923708)
In SR, you have the spacetime interval, it is more complex in GR.

For constant velocity motion in flat spacetime:

Δτ^2Δs^2 = c^2Δt^2-Δx^2-Δy^2-Δz^2

The spacetime interval is invariant, but notice it is also a scaler that combines space and time, and note that time is multiplied by c^2.

Also note Δt is the time as observed but an inertial observer that is present at both events.

You have three types of intervals here represented by one scaler.

Timelike: Δτ^2 > 0 Spacelike: Δτ^2 < 0 Lightlike: Δτ^2 = 0

In the case of Δτ^2 = 0, that is equivalent to an inertial observer that is present at both events at the same time. Which will seem to be simultaneous.

Δτ and Δt are practically the same in situations we commonly experience and an assumption of constant velocity motion in flat spacetime is usually accurate enough.

And will an assumption of constant velocity motion in flat spacetime, you can CHOOSE a Δτ that is 0.

There is no universal reference frame where Δτ =0.

More importantly your observations are of the past for distant observers, and don't have a universal concept of 'now' outside of the local case.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Retric on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:38PM (#39924208)
You just completely missed my point. GR and curved space time again isn’t an issue as long as everyone knows what space time looks like.

Mission Control on earth, a moon base, and mars would all experiencing time at a different rate and those rates would vary based on the orbits of each body. However assuming we needed extreme precision, such as telescope interferometry, people can pick one of them arbitrarily or perhaps due to politics some arbitrary 4th option. Whatever their choice everyone’s timelines based on that choice end up being absolutely identical.

The math simply works without any ambiguity. So because there’s an obvious choice based on the actual universe we live in, ie maximum amount of time since the Big Bang, then in theory trillions of civilizations across many different galaxies might all use the exact same reference even if no particle experienced it.

Edit: Well not exactly the same there’s uncertainty for such calculations but effectively the same.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by numpad0 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:15PM (#39920959)
I don’t get it, can’t you just set off neutron bomb every second on Earth and use it as a monotonic counter signal?

Isn’t that like, speed of light or wavefront of event propagation in the universe isn’t consistent but unavoidably potato shaped - but if so, wouldn’t it be at least difficult to have multiple potatoes intersecting, or potato being shaped like Klein bottle? Self intersecting potato shaped space-time would be cool, though.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nyrikki on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:49PM (#39921405)
The problem is that they aren't 'potato shaped' rotations, they are better thought of as hyperbolic rotations. Simultaneous distant events in Lorentz transformations will all lay on a shared hyperbola not a distorted circle.

Really this is beyond typical human intuition and requires math, but here is a quick minutephysics video that quickly demonstrates fairly well it without me typing out a bunch of math that no one wants anyway.

https://youtu.be/SrNVsfkGW-0

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by whimsicalism on Saturday April 06, 2024 @03:51AM (#39950785)
in short, no. not if you want hyperaccurate time keeping
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by tshaddox on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:59PM (#39920743)
This sort of clock wouldn't be very useful for, say, baking bread for the correct amount of time in an accelerating frame of reference, right?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by dpedu on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:39PM (#39921260)
Why can't Earth time be the universal frame of reference, and everywhere else use a factor of earth time? This article describes the rate difference already, why can't we use that?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by andrewla on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:59PM (#39921525)
For the moon that potentially works because we're close enough to the moon that the drift is dominated by local gravitation rather than relative motion. But for any other context, say Mars, the problem is that the clock drift will be non-uniform. An hour on Earth (as measured by a precise clock on Earth) vs an hour on Mars as measured by a precise clock on Mars) will not be a fixed ratio, but will depend on relative position and velocities at the time that you start measuring the hour.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by dpedu on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:30PM (#39923434)
Aren't those relative positions and velocities predictable enough? I believe NASA regularly makes predictions somewhat like this, such as when specific large asteroids are predicted to come near earth.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by ianburrell on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:45PM (#39924813)
Sure, just like the relativistic effects of GPS clocks on Earth are predictable. But it makes clock keeping on Mars much more complicated, always making corrections. The corrections are always changing and syncing time is hard because the motions are always changing. Simplest solution is to use local atomic clocks. And then calculate Earth time when needed.

All for zero benefit because the Earth is variable number of minutes from Mars so there will always be variation. Mars day is different from Earth have to calculate Earth time anyway.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Izkata on Thursday April 04, 2024 @01:08PM (#39933130)
> Simplest solution is to use local atomic clocks. And then calculate Earth time when needed.

Which is exactly what OP was suggesting, everyone else went off on a tangent.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by willvarfar on Thursday April 04, 2024 @02:59AM (#39927356)
(a bit late, but anyway, ...

I wasn't suggesting we should have a true universal time, I was suggesting that we rename the mislabelled universal coordinated time that we already have to something else... :) )

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Wissenschafter on Thursday April 04, 2024 @07:24AM (#39928927)
How is it depressing? Relativity of simultaneity implies the universe is basically a giant crystal, future and past both actually exist. They almost have to for relativity of simultaneity to be the way it is.

That means everything happening is happening forever, all at once.

I guess if you live a shitty existence, then its infinitely shittier, but if not, its infinitely meh.

Guess it depends on how you look at it.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by belter on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:55AM (#39917527)
You should not because on Earth, where gravity is relatively strong compared to the Moon, time runs slightly slower due to the gravitational time dilation effect. This means that clocks on Earth tick slightly slower compared to identical clocks in a region of weaker gravity, such as on the Moon's surface. So the UTC is from Earth perspective.

From rough calculations, the time experienced on the surface of the Moon is 0.99999999999848 times the experienced on Earth

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nerdjon on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:12AM (#39917780)
I have seen references to this but I am constantly confused by how this is actually a thing.

There was a video I watched that stated that in some situations 2 identical clocks that are in perfect working order, that if one of them was on a ship and doing certain things (that is purposefully vague since I don't remember) that if that ship came back to earth it would have a different time.

It is one of those things that really boggles my mind, even though it fascinates the hell out of me. If you have any resources to read or watch on this (the video I watched was space time I think) I would love it.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by ldargin on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:56PM (#39919877)
It's a bit easy to understand that in the context of gravity, because gravity bends light down. If you shine a flashlight on Earth, that light is in free-fall, bending down. Time follows the same path, because the speed of light is fixed.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by irobeth on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:14AM (#39918557)
The way I've understood it is that everything which can 'move' in spacetime has to have a momentum vector with constant magnitude C (when expressed in the right units, C = 1)

The faster you 'move' through space, the more you have to 'borrow' from the time component of the vector to maintain a magnitude of C

That means your 'position in time' moves slower; and so for people who aren't moving as fast through space as you are, they appear to 'experience more time'

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by bumby on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:40PM (#39919624)
Can you explain why the momentum vector must be constant in magnitude?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by notfish on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:53PM (#39919813)
There isn’t really a “why”, other than the need to match observed reality.

We know from observations that light moves at a constant speed, even when the observer is moving near the speed of light, and we know that this observation is true regardless of your frame of reference.

In order for physics to remain consistent while accounting for the constant speed of light, other things need to flex between the two reference frames: namely, time (time dilation) and length (Lorentz contraction).

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by bumby on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:54PM (#39922241)
In other words, "to make the math work out". That's kinda what I was poking at, trying to understand if that is some fundamental truth or if it is the result of some underlying mechanism that is more fundamental.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by adolph on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:45PM (#39920579)
> light moves at a constant speed

While in the same medium, right?

The speed of light is a universal constant in a vacuum, like the vacuum of space. However, light can* slow down slightly when it passes through an absorbing medium, like water (225,000 kilometers per second = 140,000 miles per second) or glass (200,000 kilometers per second = 124,000 miles per second).*

https://www.space.com/15830-light-speed.html#section-speed-o...

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by lxgr on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:28PM (#39921123)
Light propagation in a medium is a quite different thing from light in vacuum.

For example, the speed of light in a medium is not the "speed limit" of things in the same medium, and particles in it can actually move faster than light: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation

In other words, the speed of light in vacuum plays a special role in both a vacuum and a medium.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by idontpost on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:47PM (#39919728)
No, and if you could you would win a Nobel prize.

But a century of experimental and observational data proves that it is.

At this point it's generally just taken as a fact that the speed of light is constant for all observers. The explanation given above falls out as a direct mathematical consequence.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by irobeth on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:40PM (#39924775)
to hear Lenny Susskind say it, "light moves at the speed of light"
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by user_7832 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:36AM (#39918841)
What is the frame of reference, or is there even one, in this case? If you have one spacecraft moving in one direction at 0.5c flying by Earth, is the craft at 0.5c and experiencing "slower" time, or is Earth experiencing slower time? Or do they both experience the same thing as they're not accelerating wrt each other?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:41AM (#39918907)
If they just pass by each other without changing speeds, each sees the other as experiencing slower time. For the case where one leaves and comes back, see the Twin paradox[1] which is resolved by the simple fact that to change speeds one must accelerate (or that the one who returns must have experienced at a minimum two different frames of references; one to leave and one to return).

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin_paradox

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by kijin on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:32PM (#39919535)
There is no independent frame of reference by which we can tell whose time is slower.

From the spacecraft's frame of reference, Earth's time is slower. From Earth's frame of reference, the spacecraft's time is slower. Both are right.

When we say that time is slower or faster on a spacecraft, the Moon, or an exoplanet of Christopher Nolan's, we are implicitly prefixing the statement with "From Earth's frame of reference..."

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by euroderf on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:39PM (#39921248)
> The faster you 'move' through space

Therein lies the rub. To "move" proves nothing about who is "faster" because there is no absolute frame of reference. You may think that I am moving at 0.8c, but maybe it is just me slowing down to a standstill while you are still receding at 0.8c. This might be a valid interpretation of your observation of me "moving at 0.8c" if... (and only if...) there were an absolute frame of reference. But there ain't.

AIUI it is the flavors of acceleration - including accelerating, decelerating, and gravity - that tinker with time. Which is why I still can't quite wrap my mind around the Twin Paradox, because it is usually explained in terms of speed, not periods of acceleration.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by lupire on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @08:55PM (#39925276)
You just explained it yourself. Time slows down for people who are accelerating (not in freefall).
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:37AM (#39918852)
All of those things fall out from the speed of light being independent of the speed you are moving at (i.e. regardless of how fast or slow or what direction you are going, you will always get the same answer when you measure the speed of light in a vacuum).

The easiest one to explain is probably the most mind-bending: wheter or not an event is "simultaneous" depends on the frame of reference.

You are sitting in a spaceship that has a large empty cargo bay. There is a lightbulb in the exact center of the cargo bay. If you turn the bulb on, it will hit the front and the rear of the cargo bay at the exact same time. This is true regardless of the speed the spaceship is traveling at (because the speed of light will always be measured as the same value).

Now think of what happens from the frame of reference of someone on a planet as the spaceship is passing by. Since the spaceship is moving forwards, and the light moves in both directions at the same speed, the light will hit the back of the cargo bay slightly before the light hits the front of the cargo bay. The faster the spaceship is moving, the bigger this difference.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by johnla on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:38AM (#39918107)
It will forever boggle me but the way I sort of rationalize it is that speed basically borrows energy from time. Something like that. So the faster you go, the slower the time goes. So if you go the speed of light, you're taking so much time away that when you make a roundtrip, you're like 50 years into the future.

That's a totally wrong explanation but it helps me sort out the effects and what to expect. If you fly quickly around the Earth, your watch is a tiny bit different than the stationary clock.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by andrewla on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:40PM (#39919623)
> speed basically borrows energy from time

This is close to the main intuitions of special relativity as a geometric theory. I would phrase is more as "speed borrows space from time". In general relativity (and special relativity if you look at it geometrically) every reference frame moves at 1 second / second in their own coordinates, but an observer in a different frame will see you move in their coordinates -- the 4-vector of your time / position keeps the same magnitude, so since you are moving faster in space, your time is moving slower.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by magicalhippo on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:09AM (#39918490)
AFAIK one can also consider the 4D velocity vector to have a constant lenght. Thus the faster you move in the spatial dimensions, the slower you move in the time dimension to maintain the constant length.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by bloopernova on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:21PM (#39919398)
That's a helpful explanation, thank you.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by bumby on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:41PM (#39919636)
Why must the velocity vector have a constant length?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by magicalhippo on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:24PM (#39921083)
As the sibling comment alludes to, it's otherwise they wouldn't behave according to what we measure.

For a deeper "why", see Feynman[1].

edit: it's related to how spacetime with a finite speed of light is represented mathematically. There's some discussion here[2] which might shed some light.

[1]: https://fs.blog/richard-feynman-on-why-questions/

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imaginary_time#In_cosmology

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:11PM (#39920113)
Now that's the billion dollar question, isn't it.

But it's true.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by numpad0 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:20PM (#39921025)
So to preoccupy your mind with simulation hypothesis and inter-node bandwidth estimation for the cluster we’re on.

edit: wait, if the Vector4.magnitude == 1, are dense objects actually just fast/hot?

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by anticensor on Thursday April 04, 2024 @02:37PM (#39934231)
With constant magnitude vectors, you can eliminate one of the numbers out of the motion simulation for each particle. Huge optimisation indeed.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Y_Y on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:59AM (#39919129)
> speed basically borrows energy from time

This sounds cool, but I don't think it has explanatory value. It's true that moving close to the speed of light will mess with your intuitions about the passage of time and give you things like the Twin Paradox. But there's nothing special about time there, it also makes things shorter by Fitzgerald contraction.

You can't be in the future, for example. The point of relativity is the equivalence of reference frames, it's not like the space traveller's clock is wrong and the stayhome's clock is correct, it's that humans who never travel at speeds close to the speed of light don't expect that two good clocks could ever disagree.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by everforward on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:45PM (#39922133)
The underlying reason is causality. Causality is the concept that an event can only be caused by another event in its past (not its future), and events can only impact their own future. Causality cannot propagate faster than the speed of light, ergo for a given event you can express the area of space that could have caused that event as a function of time (it's a circle with radius equal to the amount of time in the past you're looking times the speed of light; e.g. 10s before an event, that event could have been caused by another event anywhere within 10s*the speed of light).

If time is constant, objects moving at a significant fraction of the speed of light break causality. They're moving fast enough that causality propagating the opposite direction of their velocity (things happening in the future) reach them faster than they should, and causality propagating in the same direction as them reaches them slower than it should (because they're moving away from it at a significant portion of the speed causality is approaching them at).

E.g. lets say there are 2 massive celestial bodies A and B. A is not moving at all, B is moving at 50% the speed of light. Let's say they pass close enough to gravitationally interact, but are half a light-year away from each other. Once they pass each other, causality from B will propagate to A at the speed of light, like normal. Causality seems fine.

But causality will propagate from A to B much, much slower because of the relative velocity. If B is 1 light-year away, it would actually take something like 1.3 years for causality to reach it. In other words, A is within B's causality radius (B can cause effects on A), but B is not within A's causality radius (or rather, it is when the event happens, but it won't be there by the time causality gets there). That's a problem for something like gravity. B's gravity can influence A, but A's gravity can't be the cause of events on B, because of the speed of causality. Thus the only valid event is B's gravity on A, accelerating A without decelerating B, meaning we would have actually created energy (at least until causality catches up).

To maintain causality, and preservation of energy, something has to happen to B such that A interacts with B at the same time B interacts with A. The answer is to make movement through time and movement through space inversely correlated. If B is moving fast enough that light takes 30% longer to get there, B's time has to slow down by the same amount so that causality can be simultaneous and not create energy.

Causality essentially requires movement through space and movement through time to add up to some constant. As movement through space increases, movement through time decreases and vice versa. It's basically a formula like (current speed/speed of light) + rate of passage of time = 1.

That's the underpinnings of the idea that FTL travel will allow time travel. If (current speed/speed of light) is greater than 1, the passage of time has to be negative or flowing backwards to maintain causality. I.e. you are moving so quickly that you can catch up to and interact with causality propagating through the universe.

Somewhere out on the edges of the universe, the causality of the meteor that killed the dinos is still propagating outwards. Perhaps if we could move fast enough to reach that wave of causality, we would be able to interact with it somehow. It's all theoretical, and hand-wavy, and trippy, but interesting in concept.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by c54 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:00AM (#39918370)
FloatHeadPhysics does a really good job of explaining these kinds of things https://youtu.be/TJmgKdc7H34
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by trey-jones on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:10AM (#39918501)
This is actually the guy that finally helped me break through into understanding (at least a little what's going on). Specifically about how the movement through space lengthens distances between objects (including atoms) and causes information (including light) to travel further, along the hypotenuse of a triangle, "in order to do stuff".

"Doing stuff" includes observing things because of the light travel distance, but also biological processes, which involve eg. electrons moving from one atom to another.

I didn't watched the linked video here (more relevant perhaps), but this was the one for me: https://youtu.be/Vitf8YaVXhc

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by akdev1l on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:18AM (#39917848)
this phenomenon is called “time dilation” you can search for it.

Not trying to be a dick, just not qualified to explain this myself

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nerdjon on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:20AM (#39917866)
Honestly that helps, just having a name to look for instead of somehow making a google search out of this will help.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by 7thaccount on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:33AM (#39918050)
There is also time dilation from motion through space (motion through space + motion through time is equal to the speed of light, so as you speed up, your motion through time slows down) as well as time dilation due to gravity (like when near a black hole I think).

I'm also not a physicist, but read some popsci books in my youth like "A brief history of time" from Stephen Hawking (it's written for normal people). That's probably the best book you'd want. He later wrote a more modernized version called "a briefer history of time" as well. They both cover time dilation from a high level iirc. Of course, to truly understand you'd need to learn the math. I'm looking forward to doing that during retirement in a few decades.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#39919560)
Highly recommend the best-selling book A Brief History of Time!
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by belter on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:19AM (#39917861)
Maybe this one:

"Does the Past Still Exist?" - https://youtu.be/GwzN5YwMzv0

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by nerdjon on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:20AM (#39917876)
I will watch that tonight, thank you.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by dmoy on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:26AM (#39917942)
> I have seen references to this but I am constantly confused by how this is actually a thing.

Shit, I studied this for a whole semster in physics back in the day, and even back then I was constantly confused by it.

It is some unnaturally (to humans) weird stuff.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by hoorayimhelping on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:35AM (#39918840)
A Brief History of Time deals with this subject very well. It's a very easy and quick read, meant for a wide audience, not a technical one. It's readable in an afternoon.

The concept that time is relative to the observer is where the theory of relativity gets its name from.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by corndoge on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:20AM (#39917880)
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by somenameforme on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:30AM (#39918756)
The concept of time dilation in general is actually pretty easy to explain, with the use of a relativistic starship! Imagine we create a ship that could constantly accelerate at 1g per second. What happens if you're on that ship, and start to approach the speed of light (relative to an observe back on Earth)? Well, some quite weird stuff - but you would not actually slow down! The speed of light is not a speed limit, like most people think of it. A human could easily travel billions of light years in a single lifetime.

But it is true that nothing can ever be perceived as traveling faster than the speed of light. So how you can you travel billions of light years in a few decades, yet never be perceived as going faster than the speed of light - one light year per year? Simple - the universe, like a simulation filled with spaghetti code, starts to cheat, and changes the rate at which things start to move through time. An observe back on Earth would see your ship start to accelerate towards the speed, but then hit an impossible asymptote just before it.

So if you traveled a million light years, they would see your trip taking a million years. But by contrast, only about 26 years would pass for you. So if you traveled a million light years out in our 1g accelerating ship, and then a million light years back, it would take you 52 years, but 2 million years would have passed on Earth. There's a calculator for this ship, called a relativistic starship, here. [1] This whole effect is called time dilation. Gravitational time dilation is just a special case of general time dilation, and is essentially the time dilation factor driven by the velocity needed to escape the gravitational well created by a body. So - more massive objects result in greater time dilation. It leads to interesting things like the core of the Earth actually being younger than its surface!

---

A clear way this can be seen in real life (and to also emphasize this is in no way whatsoever an optical illusion) is with particle accelerators. Many emergent or unstable particles tend to decay rapidly. Yet when we accelerate them to speeds near light, we end up being able to observe them for orders of magnitude longer than their decay when at rest. It's because of time dilation. From an at rest observer, time starts to move more slowly for something moving rapidly.

All of this should also be taken with a general 'for illustrative purposes' asterisk. I'm leaving out lots of things, like how as you approached the speed of light you'd start to experience length contraction. It's essentially another way that the universe cheats to ensure that everybody always perceives the speed of light as a constant.

---

This has amusing and interesting social implications for Earth as well, if and when we become able of developing such technology - the rich and powerful, seeking immortality, will undoubtedly seek to thrust themselves into the future. Great setting for some sort of a sci-fi series, not only for those on Earth, but also for those setting out into a future that may not be exactly what they were hoping for.

[1] - https://spacetravel.simhub.online/

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by AnonHP on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:59PM (#39919917)
> A human could easily travel billions of light years in a single lifetime.

Serious questions follow. How and using what technology? Why are we still struggling to go to the moon or Mars by taking weeks or months?

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by somenameforme on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:10PM (#39920088)
Accelerating 1g constantly is much more difficult than it sounds. You'd need a practically infinite fuel source or some way to generate fuel while traveling. That's why the EM-drive was so tantalizing. If we could [near] perpetually generate even the smallest amount of thrust, the implications would be unimaginable. But for now this seems impossible.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by Traubenfuchs on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:48AM (#39918991)
It‘s pretty simple. In places with high gravity, time goes slower. In fast moving containers (car, plane, spaceship), mass+gravity are also increased. This is the reason why shining a light forward on a moving train doesn‘t make the photons the speed of light + the speed of the train. The speed of the light emitted from the flashlight is slowed down by the mass/gravitation increase through the movement of the train.

This way, travelling to the future is pretty easy by the way. Just travel in a vehicle almost at the speed of light and the outside worlds time will move faster (relatively), since you are slowed down.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by chgs on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:34AM (#39918062)
The length of a second varies at different points on earth too, and varies far more when in low earth orbit. UTC is still good enough though, even with the number of seconds in a year varying by a non-predictable amount.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by philistine on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:47PM (#39919730)
That's why if we ever make a Moon time, what should change is the length of the second, not the whole makeup of the calendar otherwise.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by lsllc on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:39PM (#39920512)
The definition of a second is as follows [0]:

  The second is defined by taking the fixed numerical value of the caesium frequency ∆ν, the unperturbed ground-state hyperfine transition frequency of the caesium 133 atom, to be 9 192 631 770 when expressed in the unit Hz, which is equal to s−1
But with the Moon's lower gravity, time flows very slightly faster (a moon-second is 0.99999999999848 of an earth second according to a sibling post). I'm no physicist, but my assumption is that the SI definition of a second would still be true on the moon (at least relative to the moon's reference frame). So it would make sense to me to leave a second defined as a SI second, regardless of your reference frame because that's how humans, science & technology measure time passing.

I think the bigger calendar problem with space travel is the differences in the length of a day (or sol), as we know it's 24hrs on earth, Mars is 24h 37m (not sure about the moon since it's tidally locked its ~27x24hrs). The drift of days between Mars and Earth is going to be far more noticeable than a tiny fraction of a second due to relativity.

[0] https://www.npl.co.uk/si-units/second

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by pavon on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:17PM (#39920196)
That might be convenient for the purpose of timekeeping, but then you would also have to redefine all sorts of physical constants, which could be problematic. Oops, our lander crashed because we were doing calculations using Moon seconds, but the gravitational constant G was in Earth seconds. Okay, the difference probably isn't enough to matter for that case, but still any physics calculations where that precision is needed (say interferometry?) you'd have to keep track of which measurement system you are using. In some ways it would be worse than US -> SI because they would be close enough that it wouldn't be immediately obvious you made a mistake.

I'd much rather have SI be universal than our calendar.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by philistine on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:40PM (#39921274)
The space shuttle had a four-second window to start its entry burn to reach the runway back on Earth. I don't think the discrepancy in a second on Earth versus the Moon is going to mean the difference between a crash or a success. No space-faring vessel had any tolerance as low as .0000001
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by vnchr on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:52PM (#39919794)
That’s great until we occupy a smaller moon and need to reduce the length of a second for that moon’s time dilation.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by dotancohen on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:59AM (#39919141)
Then, as GP implied, the U in UTC is a misnomer. Considering replacing it with a better name is logical considering the development of technology and our improving ability to go out and explore.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by torstenvl on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @04:42PM (#39922831)
> on Earth . . . time runs slightly slower due to the gravitational time dilation effect

When people say "time runs slower" in a location, that means that time spent there subjectively feels longer than it really is in the outside world. "Time runs slower at the cabin, a weekend there makes the city and office life seem like a long-ago time and place."

That's the opposite of what happens in gravitational time dilation. You spend a subjective two hours in Gargantua and decades pass on the outside.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by ta1243 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:56AM (#39917543)
You can't use any time for observers in different reference frames as the length of a second will be different. UTC is generally fine as far as normal time goes as we're all in roughly the same reference frame on Earth, and indeed anywhere in the Solar System. It would still drift by noticeable milliseconds per year, but we can cope with leap seconds just fine with UTC and that's a larger drift.

You'd probably want to avoid leap seconds and use TAI though, but we should avoid leap seconds anyway IMO.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by greggsy on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:34AM (#39917259)
GTC is easily confused with Galactic Time, which will likely cause mass havoc a rewrites in dead languages like Imperial C and Scala sometime after the year 48,000AD.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by kijin on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:42PM (#39919656)
A true visionary must plan for job security for millennia to come. Next on the todo list: code up a Kwisatz Haderach to do your all your data modeling work while you slack off.

On a more serious note, Galactic Time probably won't be useful because relativity introduces too much irreconcilable error at that scale. We'll be back in the early days of the railroad when every station had their own clock, adjusted to local noon.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by randomdata on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:35PM (#39921200)
Not to mention that universal, by definition, refers to earth already. Universal does not relate to universe any more than carpet relates to car.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by hbrav on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:24AM (#39918695)
I'm afraid it becomes even worse when you learn that the concept of 'simultaneous' is ambiguous.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by belter on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:01AM (#39917622)
"Falsehoods Programmers believe about Time" - https://hn.algolia.com/?q=Falsehoods+Programmers+believe+abo...
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by zokier on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:40AM (#39917336)
Terrestrial Time is a thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrestrial_Time

> TT is indirectly the basis of UTC, via International Atomic Time (TAI).

Nobody is going to bother renaming UTC at this point, misnomer or not. Besides, if they stop adding leap seconds to UTC (as is planned) the whole point of UTC goes away anyways.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by gadders on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:10PM (#39919262)
Go back to GMT. Embrace tradition.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by shawncampbell on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:20PM (#39919385)
ETC. Time, etcetera. I like that. There's something poetic about it.
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by GuB-42 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:41PM (#39920538)
We can use (Earth based) UTC on the moon, or on the whole universe for that matter.

The problem is that on the moon, due to relativistic effects, a UTC second is not really a second, it is slightly longer, and that makes it inconvenient for conducting experiments on the moon. So for moon-based operations, moon time will be used, it can then be converted to UTC for "universal" operations.

It is not the first time we use different clocks. In fact, we already have plenty: UT0, UT1, TAI, etc... That's because the Earth rotation is not that great at timekeeping, atomic clocks do better, but we still want our days to be aligned with the sun, so depending on whether you are more interested in the Earth rotation or in precisely counting seconds, you will use different clocks, with UTC being a compromise you can always convert to. GPS time is one such example, it is a few seconds off UTC because it doesn't account for leap seconds.

All that is not even accounting for local (earth) time zones.

Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by ant6n on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:03PM (#39920780)
Aren’t seconds different based on latitude, as well as elevation? Should we perhaps have many more time zones than the 30 or so we have now, all requiring occasional leap-ms to sync up to UTC?
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by foxyv on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:20PM (#39921019)
Re:White House wants Moon to have its own time zone, Coordin... by randomdata on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:27PM (#39921109)
> should we rename it Coordinated Global or Earth Time (GTC or ETC) instead?

No, why? Universal is already defined as referring to earth (the world). From the Oxford Languages dictionary:

u·ni·ver·sal – of, affecting, or done by all people or things in the world